Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Activity”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,225 records · Page 68

Assessment of antimicrobial activity of melittin encapsulated in bicontinuous microemulsions prepared using renewable oils

Abstract The objective of this study is to demonstrate that melittin, a well‐studied antimicrobial peptide (AMP), can be solubilized in an active form in bicontinuous microemulsions (BMEs) that employ biocompatible oils. The systems investigated consisted of Winsor‐III and ‐IV BME phases composed of Water/Aerosol‐OT (AOT)/Polysorbate 85/isopropyl myristate and a Winsor‐IV BME employing Polysorbate 80 and limonene. We found that melittin resided in an α‐helix‐rich configuration and was in an apolar environment for the AOT/Polysorbate 85 Winsor‐III system, suggesting that melittin interacted with the surfactant monolayer and was in an active conformation. An apolar environment was also detected for melittin in the two Winsor‐IV systems, but to a lesser extent than the Winsor‐III system. Small‐angle X‐ray scattering analysis indicated that melittin at a concentration of 1.0 g/L aq in the aqueous subphase of the Winsor‐IV systems led to the greatest impact on the BME structure (e.g., decrease of quasi‐periodic repeat distance and correlation length and induction of interfacial fluidity). The antimicrobial activity of the Polysorbate 80 Winsor‐IV system was evaluated against several bacteria prominent in chronic wounds and surgical site infections (SSIs). Melittin‐free BMEs inhibited the growth of all tested bacteria due to its oil, limonene, while the inclusion of 1.0 g/L aq of melittin in the BMEs enhanced the activity against several bacteria. A further increase of melittin concentration in the BMEs had no further enhancement. These results demonstrate the potential utility of BMEs as a delivery platform for AMPs and other hydrophilic and lipophilic drugs to inhibit antibiotic‐resistant microorganisms in chronic wounds and SSIs.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗

High-temperature active oxidation of nanocrystalline silicon-carbide: A reactive force-field molecular dynamics study

Flexible woven SiC ceramics are prone to accelerated fiber embrittlement under high temperature oxidation in dynamic oxygen environments. The nanocrystalline structure of the constituent fibers impacts the reaction kinetics and phase transformations during active oxidation. However, fundamental understanding and quantification of grain boundary effects on oxidation behavior in nanocrystalline SiC remain elusive when temperatures exceed 1500 K. This study deploys large-scale molecular dynamics simulations with a reactive force-field to elucidate the complex roles of atomic oxygen reservoir conditions and grain size on oxidation kinetics and the nature of oxides produced in both monocrystalline and nanocrystalline 3C-SiC between 1100 K and 2000 K. The simulations with dynamically replenished oxygen provide good agreement with oxidation kinetics and activation energies for the monocrystalline Si(100) and C(100) orientations published in the available literature. This study reveals that, by contrast, nanocrystalline SiC samples exhibit two distinct oxidation kinetics with a transition point at 1500 K due to surface melting, which is supported by experimental evidence. The introduction of a grain-boundary network produces a two-fold decrease in oxidation activation energies compared to monocrystalline SiC below 1500 K. Above 1500 K, however, the activation energies rise substantially due to the formation of a liquid Si phase at the SiC/Si oxide interface. Further, it is shown that the stability of the interfacial liquid phase is promoted by incoherent grain boundaries in the crystalline SiC. These findings are important for the deployment of nanocrystalline SiC fibers in advanced thermal protection systems for high-temperature applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Mushroom body input connections form independently of sensory activity in Drosophila melanogaster

Associative brain centers, such as the insect mushroom body, need to represent sensory information in an efficient manner. In Drosophila melanogaster, the Kenyon cells of the mushroom body integrate inputs from a random set of olfactory projection neurons, but some projection neurons—namely those activated by a few ethologically meaningful odors—connect to Kenyon cells more frequently than others. This biased and random connectivity pattern is conceivably advantageous, as it enables the mushroom body to represent a large number of odors as unique activity patterns while prioritizing the representation of a few specific odors. How this connectivity pattern is established remains largely unknown. Here, we test whether the mechanisms patterning the connections between Kenyon cells and projection neurons depend on sensory activity or whether they are hardwired. We mapped a large number of mushroom body input connections in partially anosmic flies—flies lacking the obligate odorant co-receptor Orco—and in wild-type flies. Statistical analyses of these datasets reveal that the random and biased connectivity pattern observed between Kenyon cells and projection neurons forms normally in the absence of most olfactory sensory activity. Finally, this finding supports the idea that even comparatively subtle, population-level patterns of neuronal connectivity can be encoded by fixed genetic programs and are likely to be the result of evolved prioritization of ecologically and ethologically salient stimuli.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗

Solute- and solvent-based electromotive force cells for activity measurements of electroactive species in molten salts

A novel combination of solute- and solvent-based electrodes was used to determine the activities of NdCl 3 and GdCl 3 in molten LiCI-KCI eutectic using electromotive force measurements across a broad concentration range of dissolved electroactive species. First, an electrochemical cell using solute-based electrodes was used to define the relative activity of each species as a function of concentration and the concentration region in which Henry's law was applicable. Next, the electromotive force between a solute-based electrode with a known NdCl 3 or GdCl 3 concentration and a solvent-based electrode with a known electromotive force was measured. The solvent-based electrode potential was converted to the Lithium Eutectic Electrode (LEE) potential, which allowed the activity of dissolved NdCl 3 and GdCl 3 to be calculated at the concentrations measured using the solute-based electrodes. The described two-cell method uses electromotive force measurements to accurately determine the activity of electroactive species over a wide concentration range and provides a simple approach to closing the knowledge gap of thermochemical properties of molten salts.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Enhancing the activity of Fe-N-C oxygen reduction reaction electrocatalysts by high-throughput exploration of synthesis parameters

Here, the most active class of platinum group metal-free (PGM-free) oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) electrocatalysts in acidic electrolytes are those synthesized by heat treatment of iron, carbon, nitrogen precursors (Fe-N-C). Due to the large number of possible precursor compounds, a small fraction of the synthesis variable space has been explored. Correlation of synthesis variables with Fe speciation and ORR activity has been limited. In this work, an automation platform and a multi-port ball-milling were utilized to evaluate the effects of synthesis variables, such as identity of iron precursor, iron loading, and carbon and nitrogen sources on the ORR activity of iron -nitrogen-carbon catalysts in acidic electrolyte. The ORR activity is correlated with catalyst Fe speciation determined using Fe K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAFS).

30 DIRECT ENERGY CONVERSION↗

Iron redox behavior and oxygen reduction activity of Fe-N-C electrocatalysts in different electrolytes

The iron redox behavior and oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) activity of Fe-N-C ORR electrocatalysts synthesized by a variety of techniques were investigated as a function of the identity of the electrolyte anion (bisulfate/sulfate or perchlorate) at a constant pH. In situ X-ray absorption spectroscopy data support the assignment of the redox peaks in the voltammograms to the Fe 3+ /Fe 2+ redox couple. It was found that for a given Fe-N-C catalyst, there is a correlation between the Fe redox couple peak potential and the ORR activity in perchloric acid electrolyte, but not in sulfuric acid electrolyte. While a higher Fe redox couple potential (≥ 110 mV higher) was observed in perchloric acid electrolyte, a higher ORR activity was obtained in sulfuric acid electrolyte. Here, the higher ORR activity observed in sulfuric acid than perchloric acid was correlated with the higher peak current and larger faradaic charge for the Fe redox couple. A study of the Fe redox behavior using a cavity microelectrode, eliminating the impact of ionomer, showed that the interaction of H 2 SO 4 with Fe-N-C is stronger than that of HClO 4 and that Fe redox in both electrolytes is a reversible surface electrochemical reaction.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Scattering by whistler-mode waves during a quiet period perturbed by substorm activity

We study the dynamics of radiation belt electrons during a 10-day quiet period perturbed by substorm activity and preceding a high-speed stream (HSS), aiming at a global description of the radiation belts in L-shell, L in [2, 6], and energy [0.1, 10] MeV. We combine Van Allen Probes observations and Fokker-Planck numerical simulations of pitch-angle diffusion. The Fokker-Planck model uses event-driven pitch angle diffusion coefficients from whistler-mode waves, built from the wave properties and the ambient plasma density measurements from the Van Allen Probes. We first find this event has some similar characteristics to regular quiet times previously studied; a widely extended plasmasphere within which we observe strong and varying whistler-mode waves. These ambient conditions lead to strong pitch-angle scattering, which contributes to the creation of a wide slot region as well as a significant decay of the outer radiation belts, which are observed and qualitatively well simulated. In addition, we find the substorm activity causes short duration (within ± 4h) decay of the plasma density and a lowering amplitude of the whistler-mode waves within the plasmasphere, both causing opposite effects in terms of pitch angle diffusion. This leads to a diminution of pitch-angle diffusion at the time of the main substorm activity. Conversely, whistler-mode waves become enhanced in the time periods between the substorm injections. All effects cumulated, we find an enhancement of pitch angle diffusion by whistler-mode waves above L~4.7 during the 10-day period. This directly relates to the combination of quietness and substorm activity which allows pitch angle diffusing of up to 1 MeV electrons in the outer belt. Relativistic electrons of 1–2 MeV remain trapped in the outer belt, from L~4.7 to L~5.2, forming, in both the observations and the simulations, a distinct pocket of remnant electrons.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

Synergistic Ru Co atomic pair with enhanced activity toward levulinic acid hydrogenation

Development of efficient metal-based catalysts is of great importance for levulinic acid (LA) hydrogenation to γ-valerolactone (GVL). The widely employed Ru-based catalysts are advantageous for H 2 dissociation, however, the steric hindrance for large Ru particles hampers their coordination to C=O moiety in LA, and thereby decreasing the activity. Herein, we report a Ru 1 Co 1 -N-C double single-atom catalyst (DSAC) with synergistic Ru and Co atomic pairs for LA hydrogenation into GVL. The Ru and Co doped zeolitic imidazole frameworks (RuCo-doped ZIF-8) precursor was rationally designed ((Ru+Co)/(Zn+Ru+Co) = 2 at.%), where the Zn node spatially isolates Ru and Co species, expanding the adjacent Ru-Co distance and facilitating the formation of the Ru-Co atomic pair upon pyrolysis, with each atom coordinated with three nitrogen atoms (N 3 -Ru 1 Co 1 -N 3 ). The Ru 1 Co 1 -N-C catalyst exhibits outstanding catalytic activity, with a turnover frequency (TOF) of 1980 h –1 , surpassing previously reported Ru-based catalysts. Experimental investigation and density functional theory (DFT) calculations reveal that the electron-rich Ru induced by less electronegative Co facilitates H 2 dissociation, while atomic Ru in dual-atomic pairs promotes C=O activation, Ru and Co atomic pairs synergistically enhancing LA conversion to GVL. In conclusion, this research will shed light on the precise control of active sites at atomic scale, and also provides a new concept for designing high-performance Ru-based catalysts towards LA hydrogenation to GVL.

Double single-atom catalysts↗

Deep Kronecker neural networks: A general framework for neural networks with adaptive activation functions

Here we propose a new type of neural networks, Kronecker neural networks (KNNs), that form a general framework for neural networks with adaptive activation functions. KNNs employ the Kronecker product, which provides an efficient way of constructing a very wide network while keeping the number of parameters low. Our theoretical analysis reveals that under suitable conditions, KNNs induce a faster decay of the loss than that by the feed-forward networks. This is also empirically verified through a set of computational examples. Furthermore, under certain technical assumptions, we establish global convergence of gradient descent for KNNs. As a specific case, we propose the Rowdy activation function that is designed to get rid of any saturation region by injecting sinusoidal fluctuations, which include trainable parameters. The proposed Rowdy activation function can be employed in any neural network architecture like feed-forward neural networks, Recurrent neural networks, Convolutional neural networks etc. The effectiveness of KNNs with Rowdy activation is demonstrated through various computational experiments including function approximation using feed-forward neural networks, solution inference of partial differential equations using the physics-informed neural networks, and standard deep learning benchmark problems using convolutional and fully-connected neural networks.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Low-dose high-resolution $\mathrm{TOF}$-$\mathrm{PET}$ using ionization-activated multi-state low-$\mathrm{Z}$ detector media

We propose PET scanners using low atomic number media that undergo a persistent local change of state along the paths of the Compton recoil electrons. Measurement of the individual scattering locations and angles, deposited energies, and recoil electron directions allows using the kinematical constraints of the 2-body Compton scattering process to perform a statistical time-ordering of the scatterings, with a high probability of precisely identifying where the gamma first interacted in the detector. In these cases the Line-of-Response is measured with high resolution, determined by the underlying physics processes and not the detector segmentation. There are multiple such media that act through different mechanisms. As an example in which the change of state is quantum-mechanical through a change in molecular configuration, rather than thermodynamic, as in a bubble chamber, we present simulations of a two-state photoswitchable organic dye, a ‘Switchillator’, that is activated to a fluorescent-capable state by the ionization of the recoil electrons. The activated state is persistent, and can be optically excited multiple times to image individual activated molecules. Energy resolution is provided by counting the activated molecules. Location along the LOR is implemented by large-area time-of-flight MCP-PMT photodetectors with single photon time resolution in the tens of ps and sub-mm spatial resolution. Simulations indicate a large reduction of dose.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

The corrosion effects of neutron activation of 2LiF-BeF 2 (FLiBe)

The redox effect of activation reactions in molten salts has been previously qualitatively defined but never quantified. Here, we quantify the corrosion effects of neutron activation of FLiBe. Rates of change of activation products are computed for FHR and ARC. The impact of activation reactions on salt chemistry is quantitatively compared to other environmental effects of similar consequences on the salt. The results are applied to a redox control case-study and an irradiation-corrosion experiment. The results are presented in a manner useful to the reactor chemist and designer concerned with corrosion and chemistry control and tritium management in irradiated FLiBe, and design of salt-irradiation experiments.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Pristane promotes anaerobic glycolysis to facilitate proinflammatory activation of macrophages and development of arthritis

Highlights: • Pristane-induced arthritis is dependent on macrophages with M1 phenotype. • Pristane causes mitochondrial dysfunction and metabolic abnormalities in macrophages. • Macrophages treated by pristane show increased glycolysis flux and enzyme activity. • Metabolic reprogramming of macrophages controls M1 polarization and arthritis. Pristane-induced arthritis (PIA) could be adoptively transferred by splenic T cells in rats, and innate immunity should play critical roles in T cell activation. However, in pre-clinical stage, the activation mechanism of innate cells like macrophages remains unclear. Here we found that PIA was dependent on macrophages since cell depletion alleviated disease severity. Splenic macrophages of PIA rats showed M1 phenotypic shifting. The quantitative proteomics analysis suggested that macrophages initiated metabolic reprogramming with the conversion of aerobic oxidation to glycolysis in response to pristane in vivo. Notably, macrophages treated with pristane showed mitochondrial dysregulation and increased glycolysis flux and enzyme activity. Additionally, TNFα production, strongly associating with the glycolysis enzyme Ldha/Ldhb, could be reduced as glycolysis was inhibited or be enhanced as citrate cycle was blocked. This work provides detailed insights into the molecular mechanisms of pristane-mediated metabolic reprogramming in macrophages and suggests a new therapeutic strategy for arthritic disorders.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

Mechanisms of Enhanced Antibacterial Activity by Reduced Chitosan-Intercalated Nontronite

Previous studies have documented the antibacterial activity of certain iron-containing clays. However, the repulsion between negatively charged bacteria and the clay surface makes this process inefficient. The objective of this study is to improve the bactericidal efficiency of clays by reversing their surface charge from negative to positive. To achieve this objective, here positively charged chitosan, a nontoxic and biodegradable polymer, was intercalated into nontronite NAu-2. Chitosan-intercalated NAu-2 (C-NAu-2) was chemically reduced to obtain reduced C-NAu-2 (rC-NAu-2). Relative to reduced nontronite (rNAu-2), the antibacterial activity of rC-NAu-2 is higher and more persistent over a pH range of 6–8. The close spatial association between positively charged rC-NAu-2 and negatively charged bacteria increases the chances of cell membrane attack by extracellular ROS, the influx of soluble Fe 2+ into the bacterial cell, and the yield of intracellular ROS. All these factors contribute to the enhanced antibacterial activity of rC-NAu-2. In contrast to rNAu-2 treated E. coli cells, where membrane damage and intracellular ROS/Fe accumulation are restricted to the polar regions, the close bacteria–clay association in rC-NAu-2 results in nonselective membrane damage and more uniform intracellular ROS/Fe distribution across whole bacterial cells. These results advance the antibacterial model by highlighting the importance of bacteria–clay interactions to the antibacterial activity of Fe-bearing clays.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗

Decoding Active Sites for Highly Efficient Semihydrogenation of Acetylene in Palladium–Copper Nanoalloys

Accurately decoding the three-dimensional atomic structure of surface active sites is essential yet challenging for a rational catalyst design. Here, we used comprehensive techniques combining the pair distribution function and reverse Monte Carlo simulation to reveal the surficial distribution of Pd active sites and adjacent coordination environment in palladium-copper nanoalloys. After the fine-tuning of the atomic arrangement, excellent catalytic performance with 98% ethylene selectivity at complete acetylene conversion was obtained in the Pd 34 Cu 66 nanocatalysts, outperforming most of the reported advanced catalysts. Further, t he quantitative deciphering shows a large number of active sites with a Pd-Pd coordination number of 3 distributed on the surface of Pd 34 Cu 66 nanoalloys, which play a decisive role in highly efficient semihydrogenation. This finding not only opens the way for guiding the precise design of bimetal nanocatalysts from atomic-level insight but also provides a method to resolve the spatial structure of active sites.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Identification of In Situ Generated High-Spin Fe(II)-N 4 Active Sites for Acidic Oxygen Reduction Reaction via Operando 57 Fe Mössbauer Spectroscopy

Iron-nitrogen-carbon (FeNC) catalysts are considered among the most promising alternative to Pt catalysts in acidic oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), yet the geometric and electronic structures of the true active site under reaction conditions have not been clearly elucidated. Herein, we synthesized a representative FeNC catalyst by pyrolyzing Fe 3+ absorbed on ZIF-8-derived N-doped carbon at a mild temperature under the H 2 /Ar atmosphere, where a formation mechanism of FeN 4 sites through a Zn-mediated Fe nanoparticle atomization process was proposed. The resulting FeNC-750 catalyst shows high acidic ORR activity with a half-wave potential of 0.838 V and a peak power density of 1 W cm -2 in proton-exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC). By using operando 57 Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy on FeNC-750, it was revealed that the pyrrolic N-coordinated high-spin Fe 2+ N 4 sites, which are in situ generated from high-spin Fe 3+ N 4 during ORR, are identified as catalytic active states. Density functional theory calculations further verified that, compared to the pyridinic N-coordinated low-spin Fe 2+ N 4 , the pyrrolic N-coordinated high-spin Fe 2+ exhibits optimized adsorption energy for reaction intermediates, thereby lowering the energy barrier of the rate-determining step (RDS) and facilitating OH* desorption. In conclusion, this work provides both experimental and theoretical evidence of the true active site in the FeNC during acidic ORR, offering significant insights for the rational design of high-performance materials for acidic fuel cells.

FeNC catalyst↗

MX Anti-MXenes from Non-van der Waals Bulks for Electrochemical Applications: The Merit of Metallicity and Active Basal Plane

Two-dimensional transition-metal compounds (2DTMCs) are promising materials for electrochemical applications, but 2DTMCs with metallicity and active basal planes are rare. In this work, we proposed a simple and effective strategy to extract 2DTMCs from non-van der Waals bulk materials and established a material library of 79 2DTMCs, which we named as anti-MXenes since they are composed of one M atomic layer sandwiched by two X atomic layers. By means of density functional theory computations, 24 anti-MXenes were confirmed to be thermodynamically, dynamically, mechanically, and thermally stable. The metallicity and active basal plane endow these anti-MXenes with potential as excellent electrode materials, for example, as electrocatalysts for hydrogen evolution reactions (HER). Among the noble-metal free anti-MXenes with favorable H-binding, CuS can boost HER at the whole range of H coverages, while CoSi, FeB, CoB, and CoP show promise for HER at some specific H coverages. The active sites are the tetra-coordinating nonmetal atoms at the basal planes, thus rendering a very high density of active sites for these materials. CoB is also a promising anode material for lithium-ion batteries, showing low Li diffusion energy barriers, a very high capacity, and a suitable open circuit voltage. Overall, this work promotes the “computational exfoliation” of 2D materials from non-van der Waals bulks and exemplifies the applications of anti-MXenes in various electrochemical processes.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

An Activity-Based Oxaziridine Platform for Identifying and Developing Covalent Ligands for Functional Allosteric Methionine Sites: Redox-Dependent Inhibition of Cyclin-Dependent Kinase 4

Activity-based protein profiling (ABPP) is a versatile strategy for identifying and characterizing functional protein sites and compounds for therapeutic development. However, the vast majority of ABPP methods for covalent drug discovery target highly nucleophilic amino acids such as cysteine or lysine. Here, we report a methionine-directed ABPP platform using Redox-Activated Chemical Tagging (ReACT), which leverages a biomimetic oxidative ligation strategy for selective methionine modification. Application of ReACT to oncoprotein cyclin-dependent kinase 4 (CDK4) as a representative high-value drug target identified three new ligandable methionine sites. We then synthesized a methionine-targeting covalent ligand library bearing a diverse array of heterocyclic, heteroatom, and stereochemically rich substituents. ABPP screening of this focused library identified 1oxF11 as a covalent modifier of CDK4 at an allosteric M169 site. This compound inhibited kinase activity in a dose-dependent manner on purified protein and in breast cancer cells. Further investigation of 1oxF11 found prominent cation-π and H-bonding interactions stabilizing the binding of this fragment at the M169 site. Quantitative mass-spectrometry studies validated 1oxF11 ligation of CDK4 in breast cancer cell lysates. Further biochemical analyses revealed cross-talk between M169 oxidation and T172 phosphorylation, where M169 oxidation prevented phosphorylation of the activating T172 site on CDK4 and blocked cell cycle progression. Finally, by identifying a new mechanism for allosteric methionine redox regulation on CDK4 and developing a unique modality for its therapeutic intervention, this work showcases a generalizable platform that provides a starting point for engaging in broader chemoproteomics and protein ligand discovery efforts to find and target previously undruggable methionine sites.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Di- and Tetrameric Molybdenum Sulfide Clusters Activate and Stabilize Dihydrogen as Hydrides

NaY zeolite-encapsulated dimeric (Mo 2 S 4 ) and tetrameric (Mo 4 S 4 ) molybdenum sulfide clusters stabilize hydrogen as hydride binding to Mo atoms. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations and adsorption measurements suggest that stabilization of hydrogen as sulfhydryl (SH) groups, as typical for layered MoS 2 , is thermodynamically disfavored. Competitive adsorption of H 2 and ethene on Mo was probed by quantifying adsorbed CO on partly hydrogen and/or ethene covered samples with IR spectroscopy. During hydrogenation, experiment and theory suggest that Mo is covered predominately with ethene and sparsely with hydride. DFT calculations further predict that under reaction conditions, each Mo x S y cluster can activate only one H 2 , suggesting that the entire cluster (irrespective of its nuclearity) acts as one active site for hydrogenation. The nearly identical turnover frequencies (24.7 ± 3.3 mol ethane ·h -1 ·mol cluster -1 ), apparent activation energies (31-32 kJ·mol -1 ), and reaction orders (~0.5 in ethene and ~1.0 in H 2 ) show that the active sites in both clusters are catalytically indistinguishable.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗