A GIS-Based Suitability Analysis of a Phytomanagment Strategy for TCE in Groundwater and Soil Niagara Falls Storage Site, New York - 19385
The large number of complexly contaminated sites throughout the nation has propagated the application of phytoremedial techniques in a wide array of environmental remediation strategies. The use and breeding of vegetation for the in-situ treatment of environmental media (soil, groundwater, sediment) contaminated with organic or inorganic contaminants has shown to provide a low-cost alternative to conventional means of remediating contaminated sites (e.g., groundwater extraction, chemical oxidation or reduction, bioremediation, excavation, etc.). One impediment to effective phytoremediation is the selection of proper plant-species, which is complicated due to the many variables that are required for plant-species viability (i.e. range of soil pH, annual precipitation values, depth to groundwater table, etc.). This study employed the use of a Geographic Information Systems (GIS) to first define the spatial extent of contaminated media (soil and groundwater) at a project site and then support an effective means to optimize phytoremediative techniques to manage these impacts prior to final remediation. Spatial analyses and analytical calculations were coupled to determine an optimal plant species and spacing to maximize the effectiveness of a phytomanagement plan. The incorporation of fuzzy membership functions and fuzzy overlay provide an innovative method to help select the optimal plant-species for phytomanagement planning. Fuzzy membership functions were used to represent the plant growth requirements and provided an intuitive method to represent the uncertainty associated with plant-growth requirements. The fuzzy overlay function then employed a raster-based suitability analysis that together provided decision makers with a scientific solution to optimally design a phytomanagement strategy for site-related volatile organic compound (VOC) impacts. The Niagara Falls Storage Site (NFSS) VOC-impacted groundwater is contained in clayey glacial sediments, which commonly are technically impractical to remediate. Prior on-site studies show that native poplar (cottonwood variants) preferentially translocate or phytoextract the VOCs from the site soils and thus provide a proven mechanism to manage the multi-media impacts. Consequently, the Army Corps of Engineers Buffalo District evaluated phytoremediative approaches as a passive tool to manage the VOCs during the project life cycle prior to final remediation. The fuzzy membership functions and fuzzy overlay modeling of candidate species narrowed the selection to an optimal species and subsequent transpiration modeling estimated the plant spacing for the overall phytomanagement plan. The method employed for this study is easy applied to other phytoremediative and phytomanagement actions derived from hazardous waste decision making. (authors)