Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Criticality”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,189 records · Page 66

Determination of critical experiment correlations for experiments involving arrays of low-enriched fuel rods

Quantifying correlations among critical experiments has become a topic of interest over the last 10-15 years. Correlations arise from the shared use of fissile material, non-fissile materials, fixtures, and procedures in multiple experiments or multiple experiment series. A Monte-Carlo sampling technique proposed as a viable technical method to evaluate these correlations has been implemented in the SCALE 6.2 Sampler sequence. This paper presents an investigation of the use of this new tool and technique for low-enriched uranium pin array experiments with a thermal neutron energy spectrum. The Nuclear Energy Agency's Expert Group on Uncertainty Analyses for Criticality Safety Assessments has been examining methods of calculating the correlation coefficients among experiments from the LCT-007 and LCT-039 series. Results for two scenarios are presented to demonstrate the impact of pin pitch uncertainty modeling on the correlation coefficients. The convergence of the correlation coefficients is also investigated. Additional studies examine the impact of the stochastic uncertainty and the use of continuous-energy Monte-Carlo for individual realizations on the correlation coefficients. Correlation coefficients are also determined for the LCT-042 experiment series. This experiment series differs from other experiments because unique poison panels and fuel array separation distances may reduce correlation of the individual experiments within the series. The effects of pin pitch uncertainty and stochastic uncertainty are also examined for this series. Comparing the results of the two sets of experiments shows potential conclusions that can be drawn regarding viability of the Monte-Carlo sampling technique for determining critical experiment correlations. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Determination of critical experiment correlations for experiments involving highly enriched uranium solutions

Quantifying the correlations among critical experiments has become a topic of interest over the last 10-15 years. The correlations arise from the shared use of fissile material, non-fissile materials, fixtures, and procedures in multiple experiments or multiple experiment series. A Monte Carlo sampling technique proposed as a viable technical method to evaluate these correlations has been implemented within the SCALE 6.2 Sampler sequence. This paper presents the investigation of the use of this new tool and technique for highly enriched uranium solution experiments. One of the first attempts to quantify the correlations among critical experiments examined a series of highly enriched solution experiments, including the HST-001 series. These correlations are included in the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project Handbook, and they form a basis for methodology comparisons. Results generated using the Sampler implementation are compared with these previously published results. Additional studies involving the HST-001 experiment series are also presented. A range of different assumptions of the independence of the geometry components, enrichments, and other material compositions are implemented to investigate the impact of these assumptions on the correlation coefficients. These effects are investigated with these experiments because the calculation time is shorter for the solution experiments than for the low-enriched lattice experiments discussed in a companion paper. The magnitude of the effects of different independence assumptions on the correlation coefficients is important to establish which parameters must be clearly identified as shared or unique for accurate correlation determinations. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Means and procedures for stopping a criticality accident in the MELOX homogeniser

The purpose of this paper is to describe the organizational and material changes as well as the intervention procedure in order to stop a hypothetical criticality accident in the MELOX homogenizer. By extension, this study will take into account a criticality accident in other workstations of the production chain. It establishes that stopping a criticality accident in the homogenizer requires that 20 kg of hafnium oxide will be injected into its tank. This admission will be carried out in two stages: initially operators have to pour 20 kg of hafnium oxide into a jar, then in a second step this jar will be brought, using a manual mode controlled by an automation technician, into the homogenizing workstation from a distant controller. Then, from this distant controller, the technician will blend the MOX with the hafnium in the homogenizer, and eventually stop the accident. These interventions involve the inhibition of safety PLC and the permanent radiation monitoring in the rooms where human presence is necessary. The foreseen radiation doses are studied and are encouraging. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Developing a streamlined approach to criticality safety analyst training/qualification

The Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) Criticality Safety Analyst (CSA) Qualification Standard was a multi-divisional effort forged in late 2012. The result of the effort is a well-documented and efficient approach to training, encompassing local and national Nuclear Criticality Safety (NCS) training courses for incoming criticality safety staff, as well as a model for professional development of qualified CSAs at LANL. Five years later, the approach to training and qualification for CSAs has evolved into a streamlined safety management function, integrated in all phases of employee recruitment, development, deployment, and management. (authors)

96 KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT AND PRESERVATION↗

Fission Gases in Spent Fuel Pool Criticality Analysis

Historically all fission products, including fission gases have been included in the criticality analysis of many spent fuel pools (SFP). For transport casks ISG-8 Rev. 3 states, 'Credit for neutron absorbing isotopes other than those identified in Tables 1 and 2 should be accompanied by assurance that such isotopes are non-volatile, and non-gaseous,..' Recent questions from the NRC have challenged using fission gases in spent fuel pool criticality analyses, noting that the time the fuel is contained in the spent fuel pool can be long. This paper establishes a conservative approach for using some of the fission gases in the criticality analysis. Calculations have been performed for Indian Point Unit 2 to determine the impact of the fission gas release. The calculations have been run with the noble gases reduced by 32%, the halogens reduced by 10% and the Rb reduced by 44%. At 43 GWd/MTU, the impact of reducing the isotopes described here is only 0.0014 in k. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Incredibility of a Postulated Criticality Event for Enriched Uranyl Nitrate Storage

At the H-Canyon outside facilities, highly enriched uranyl nitrate solutions collected from leaks or during deliberate maintenance activities is collected into 5-gallon polyethylene bottles. The current criticality safety evaluation for the facility postulates that a criticality event is possible if the solutions are allowed to concentrate through evaporation, freezing, storing multiple bottles in a geometrically unfavorable array, or any combination of these conditions. Using chemical data on uranyl nitrate freezing from Savannah River National Laboratory, protected limits on concentration and enrichment, and normal operational restrictions, criticality was shown to be incredible under all normal and credible abnormal conditions. A bounding normal solution is analyzed under normal conditions and shown to be substantially subcritical. A bounding credible abnormal solution is defined as 9.2 g U{sup 235}/L and 73 wt. % enriched and 0 M excess nitric acid. The concentration and enrichment are limitations already protected by the facility for other processes. Because acidity is not specifically restricted, the most reactive lower bound is selected. The credible abnormal worst placement is in a concrete basin reflected on three sides. There the bottle(s) would be subject in the worst cases to flooding (full water reflection) and postulated concentration through evaporation or freezing. Computational modeling was performed using KENOVI in the SCALE 6.1 code package. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Criticality Consideration for Geologic Disposal of DOE-Owned Spent Nuclear Fuels - 20255

Decisions must be made relative to packaging spent nuclear fuel (SNF) for storage, transportation, and eventual disposal. This paper evaluates potential criticality-related loading and packaging considerations for Department of Energy (DOE)-owned SNF that could be impacted favorably or unfavorably by disposal uncertainties and proposes approaches to minimize such impacts. Using Al-Based SNF as an example and drawing on analyses performed in support of the Yucca Mountain Repository License Application (LA), this paper explores the role of natural barriers, engineered barriers, and waste form characteristics relative to reducing the potential for postclosure criticality. Several parameters important to postclosure criticality are considered in order to determine which are useful discriminators to support packaging decisions. Using these parameters, a qualitative assessment is performed relative to three options for managing DOE-owned SNFs. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

MCNP Progress for the Nuclear Criticality Safety Program

The DOE/NNSA Nuclear Criticality Safety Program (NCSP) supports research, development, maintenance, and verification and validation of the MCNP{sup R} Monte Carlo radiation transport software package for nuclear criticality safety (NCS) customers within DOE/NNSA. The MCNP Monte Carlo code has been used for high-fidelity analyses of criticality safety problems since the 1970's. This paper summarizes MCNP progress during FY 2015 and early FY 2016. Activities and accomplishments are summarized in five major areas: - MCNP6 status, - Whisper status, - Verification and validation testing, - User support and training, - Work in progress. (authors)

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Use of Criticality Eigenvalue Simulations for Subcritical Benchmark Evaluations

Subcritical multiplication experiments and simulations are important for a variety of applications including nonproliferation, safeguards, and criticality safety monitoring. Recently, subcritical experiments have been evaluated for inclusion in the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Process (ICSBEP). In addition, new subcritical experiments have recently been designed. In these experiments, list-mode data (a list of each absorption in the neutron detector) is recorded and neutron noise analysis is used to determine the leakage multiplication (ML) of each configuration. One downside to the simulation of these types of experiments is that they are computationally expensive. This is because analog Monte Carlo with no variance reduction must be performed in order to maintain the time accuracy required in the measurement analysis. This work demonstrates that criticality eigenvalue simulations can be used to estimate sensitivities and uncertainties for three parameters: singles count rate (R{sub 1}), doubles count rate (R{sub 2}), and leakage multiplication (M{sub L}). This will provide a useful aid both in the design and evaluation of new subcritical measurements. (authors)

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Unbiased Ratio Estimator for k-Eigenvalue in Monte Carlo Criticality Calculations

In criticality calculations, the effective multiplication factor (k{sub eff}) is an important parameter for reactor analysis. It can be interpreted as the ratio of the neutron production rate to the loss rate in a reactor core. In Monte Carlo (MC) criticality calculations, k{sub eff} is obtained for each active cycle i as: k-i = P{sub i}/L{sub i} for I = 1 to I where P{sub i} and L{sub i} are the production rate and the loss rate at cycle i, respectively, and they are normalized by the nominal source size for cycle. Since all neutron particles in a cycle will be absorbed or leaks out at the end, the loss rate, L{sub i}, can be set as the source rate, which is the unity. Thus, in MCNP5, k{sub i} is simply calculated with P{sub i} by using three conventional estimators; collision, absorption, and track-length estimators. In domain decomposed MC criticality calculations based on the fission and surface source (FSS) iteration method, k{sub i} is calculated by a ratio of P{sub i} and L{sub i}, where both P{sub i} and L{sub i} are random variables, sampled by using the same particle histories. When the numerator and the denominator are correlated, the variance of the ratio can be smaller than that of the numerator. Then, the final estimate of k{sub eff} is provided as the sample mean of k{sub i}, which will be referred as 'simple' ratio estimator in this paper. In Ref., it is shown that this ratio estimator converges faster and fluctuates less than the conventional estimator. A similar ratio estimator is also used in Serpent 2, as an implicit estimate of k{sub eff}. However, this type of 'simple' ratio estimator is biased, which means that the expectation of the ratio is different from the ratio of the expectation of the numerator and that of the denominator. In this paper, an unbiased ratio estimator which was originally derived in the cytometry analysis is introduced to estimate k{sub eff} and is tested on a continuous-energy UO{sub 2} pin-cell problem. In this test problem, it is shown that the variance of the unbiased ratio estimator is smaller than those of the conventional estimators provided by MCNP5, while the simple ratio estimator can be significantly biased when the number of histories per cycle is too small. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Bounding the Chemistry Conditions in the HM Solvent Extraction Process Criticality Safety Analyses

An approach new to the H-Canyon facility criticality safety analysis has been performed using highly detailed models of the H-Modified (HM) process mixer settlers. The HM process uses tributyl phosphate (TBP) in organic n-paraffin to extract and purify uranium from used nuclear fuel. This occurs in two cycles of counter-current solvent extraction. The aqueous stream is a weak to moderate nitric acid and the feed stock is an aqueous stream. The first Cycle, consisting of two 16-stage banks (A and B-Banks) and one 12-stage bank (C-Bank), is a three step process that separates uranium from the fuel matrix, fission products, and most of the transuranic actinide content. The first Cycle aqueous product is concentrated, adjusted for acidity and fed to the second Cycle. The second Cycle, consisting of one 16-stage bank (D-Bank) and one 12-stage bank (E-Bank), is a two-step process that further purifies the uranium and removes to a great extent remaining actinides and fission products Each stage of the mixer settler banks is modeled as three unique compositions: the mixer as a combined composition of aqueous and organic components and the settler one aqueous and one organic component. This work addresses what is believed to be normal, credible abnormal, and beyond credible abnormal conditions for a particular postulated series of process parameter upsets. The level of detail and the source for the stage-wise compositions are both new and unique to criticality safety analyses of the HM process. Initial work was presented in Ref. 1 and has since been refined. A predictive chemistry model for flowsheet development has been used to solve the solvent extraction equations for the prescribed conditions and the output of that model was then transformed into compositions for each mixture in each stage. The remaining question upon which to achieve consensus is if the approach was appropriately conservative by concluding the chemistry is appropriately bounded. Computational modeling for criticality calculations was performed using KENO-VI in the SCALE 6.1 code package. Computational modeling of the chemistry was performed using the SEPHIS Modification 4 code.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

The U.S. DOE Criticality Safety Enterprise - Next Generation - 00001

Star Trek has been a popular cultural icon worldwide since the mid-1960's. It spans roughly through the cold-war era just after World War II until now. The original cast and crew have mostly retired or passed away and the mission of space exploration has been handed off to a new starship and a new crew, the next generation. There was a transition movie in the series, Star Trek Generations, in which Captain Kirk and Captain Picard meet and the torch is passed. I am going to use this familiar movie franchise as a framework for my remarks on the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Criticality Safety Enterprise because I see us at such a crossroads. Many new frontiers have been explored by the old crew but new challenges await a younger captain and crew. Many old challenges have been solved but new ones are appearing. My remarks are formed from within the vantage-point of the U.S. DOE and the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA). I would venture to say that the situation is similar in the realm of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission and its Licensees, but I do not pretend to speak authoritatively for that community. I'm going to review what has been accomplished by the U.S. DOE Nuclear Criticality Safety Program (NCSP) and cover broadly what is the state of criticality safety in the U.S. DOE and NNSA. Then I will look at the transition taking place now and identify what I believe to be new challenges for the next crew. Finally, I will suggest some recommendations that I hope the next generation crew, which will be a multi-national crew, will find helpful as they navigate uncharted regions going forward. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Beyond 5% enrichment limit for PWR 17x17 and VVER-440 fuel - Criticality problems - 14207

The fuel suppliers improve permanently fuel for commercial energetic nuclear reactors. One way is to increase initial enrichment of U{sup 235}. Higher initial enrichment of U{sup 235} allows to increase burnup of assembly, to prolong stay in assembly in reactor and therefore decrease number of fresh assemblies loaded into reactor and decrease number of spent fuel assemblies for storage and disposal. In this article are some criticality analyses for fresh fuel PWR 17x17 and VVER-440 for enrichment up to 6% of U{sup 235} without burnable absorber: - Criticality of fresh assembly (PWR 17x17 and VVER-440) in cold state in reactor - Critical number of fresh assemblies (PWR 17x17 and VVER-440) in water - Possible storage and transport of fresh fuel VVER-440 in existing facilities and transport cask The SCALE 6.1.2 system was used for all calculation. The KENO VI module was used with library v7-238 (continuous energy). (author)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

International organization for standardization on the topic of nuclear criticality safety (ISO TC85/SC5/WG8) - 14244

This paper is a four-year update (i.e. 2011 - 2015) about the progress and activities of the International Organization for Standardization (ISO), Technical Committee 85 (TC85) on Nuclear energy, Subcommittee 5 (SC5) on Nuclear fuel cycle, Working Group 8 (WG8) on Nuclear criticality safety. The update provides a brief summary of historic standards developed by ISO TC85/SC5/WG8 and descriptions about evolving standards for nuclear criticality safety. The update describes the potential value and relevance of indigenous standards and technological developments by OECD regarding nuclear criticality safety standards. Elements of the published WG8 ISO standards that have been incorporated into International Atomic Energy Agency non-consensus guides and standards are provided. A review of international participation and needed participation is also addressed along with the benefits to ISO participating member countries. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Sensitivities and correlations of critical experiments due to uncertainties of system parameters and nuclear data - 14416

With increasing demand on accuracy of criticality calculations, correlations between benchmark experiments due to system parameter uncertainties become of interest in bias determination. The impact of different interpretations of system parameter uncertainties on the calculation of covariances and correlations of k{sub eff} is discussed in this article. Following the suggestion of the OECD/NEA EGUACSA Benchmark phase IV [1], 21 experiments from the ICSBEP international Handbook of Evaluated Criticality Safety Benchmarks [2] are used for this analysis (LEU-COMP-THERM series 07, exp. 01-04 and 39, exp. 01-17). The experiments share certain assembly and fuel features and were carried out in the same lab. Therefore, correlations in the calculation of k{sub eff} appear. Correlation coefficients between experiments due to nuclear data uncertainties are calculated with TSUNAMI [3] and show high values for most experiments. For the correlation analysis due to system parameter uncertainties mainly two scenarios are considered: In scenario A all uncertain parameters are varied mutually for all fuel rods, representing a systematic deviation of the actual experimental setup from the design value. This analysis is performed for all experiments listed above. In scenario E certain parameters like the outer cladding diameter are varied for each fuel rod individually, representing a random scattering of the varied parameter. Scenarios B, C and D represent intermediate scenarios between A and E, which are discussed shortly. Uncertainty and sensitivity calculations of k{sub eff} on the uncertain experimental parameters based on Monte Carlo sampling are presented and discussed. The calculations were performed with SUnCISTT (Sensitivities and Uncertainties in Criticality Inventory and Source Term Tool [4]) and SCALE 6.1.2 [3]. For the 21 EGUACSA proposed experiments the outer cladding diameter is the leading effect for the uncertainty of k{sub eff} for scenario A. In contrast, for scenario E the impact of the cladding diameter on k{sub eff} cancels out due to rod wise variations leaving the fuel diameter as the leading effect. The correlation analysis based on system parameter uncertainties indicates a significant dependence of the correlation coefficients on the interpretation of the uncertainties. It shows high values for scenario A, if the neutronic features are similar (EALF, H/U). For scenario E the overall correlations are significantly smaller and variations between experiments decrease. The impact of the determined correlations on bias calculations of application cases will be discussed by the authors in the accompanying paper 'Impact of correlated data in validation procedures'. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Towards application of a neutron cross-section uncertainty propagation capability in the criticality safety methodology - 14434

At the Paul Scherrer Institute (PSI) the methodology for criticality safety evaluations (CSE) used for Swiss applications is focused, following common practice, on establishing an upper subcriticality limit (USL) for the effective neutron multiplication factor (k{sub eff}), based on a statistical evaluation of the obtained validation results in terms of the calculated-to-benchmark k{sub eff} values. Recently, a new computational tool referred to as NUSS (Nuclear data Uncertainty Stochastic Sampling) was developed in order to propagate neutron-nuclear data (ND) uncertainties in calculations with Monte Carlo transport codes in combination with general-purpose ND libraries in ACE format. Thereby, this tool should now allow for a quantification of ND data uncertainties in CSE and to introduce these into the CSE criteria definition. This paper concerns an application of the NUSS methodology for criticality validation studies. Calculated k{sub eff} uncertainty estimations were obtained for the current PSI validation suite including in total 149 critical benchmark configurations for which in-house MCNP(X) models were developed, covering both uranium and mixed uranium-plutonium oxide fuels. The MCNPX-2.7.0 code was used together with the ENDF/B-VII.1 ND library while the ND variance-covariance matrixes (VCM) were taken from both SCALE-6.0 44-group libraries and also from ENDF/B-VII.1 files. Based on the newly obtained information on the uncertainties, a re-assessment of the lower tolerance bound (LTB) for k{sub eff} using the total uncertainties as weighting factors is proposed as means for the present PSI CSE methodology upgrade and some possible directions of further methodology enhancements are discussed next. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Impact of modeling choices on inventory and in-cask criticality calculations for FORSMARK 3 BWR spent fuel - 14441

Simulation of boiling water reactor (BWR) fuel depletion poses a challenge for nuclide inventory validation and nuclear criticality safety analyses. This challenge is due to the complex operating conditions and assembly design heterogeneities that characterize these nuclear systems. Fuel depletion simulations and in-cask criticality calculations are affected by (1) completeness of design information, (2) variability of operating conditions needed for modeling purposes, and (3) possible modeling choices. These effects must be identified, quantified, and ranked according to their significance. This paper presents an investigation of BWR fuel depletion using a complete set of actual design specifications and detailed operational data available for five operating cycles of the Swedish BWR Forsmark 3 reactor. The data includes detailed axial profiles of power, burnup, and void fraction in a very fine temporal mesh for a GE14 (10x10) fuel assembly. The specifications of this case can be used to assess the impacts of different modeling choices on inventory prediction and in-cask criticality, specifically regarding the key parameters that drive inventory and reactivity throughout fuel burnup. This study focused on the effects of the fidelity with which power history and void fraction distributions are modeled. The corresponding sensitivity of the reactivity in storage configurations is assessed, and the impacts of modeling choices on decay heat and inventory are addressed. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Means for stopping a criticality accident in the MELOX homogenizer - 14447

The purpose of this paper is, starting from the criticality event scenario in the homogenizing workstation, to define the impact of different neutronic absorbers and determine the most effective one to stop the chain reaction. At least 14 litres of water are necessary for a chain reaction to occur in the MELOX homogenizer if the fissile medium and the water are heterogeneously distributed. However, if all the matter is homogeneously distributed, the accident cannot last if there is less than 59 litres of water. The first way to stop a criticality accident in the homogenizer is thus to homogenize the content of the tank. If more than 59 liters have been poured in the homogenizer, then the use of neutronic absorbers like boron or gadolinium is necessary. The absorbers can be either liquid or solid. The study shows that liquid absorbers aren't efficient enough because of their strong moderator effect. Then a study has been performed with a solid absorber: the gadolinium oxide. It is shown that less than 250 g of Gd is enough to stop a criticality accident in the homogenizer. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗