Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Comparison”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,189 records · Page 66

Comparison of genetic algorithms with conjugate gradient methods

Genetic algorithms for mathematical function optimization are modeled on search strategies employed in natural adaptation. Comparisons of genetic algorithms with conjugate gradient methods, which were made on an IBM 1800 digital computer, show that genetic algorithms display superior performance over gradient methods for functions which are poorly behaved mathematically, for multimodal functions, and for functions obscured by additive random noise. Genetic methods offer performance comparable to gradient methods for many of the standard functions.

Bosworth, J. L.↗

A comparison of surface brightness measurements from OAO-2 and OSO-6

A comparison of surface brightness measurements of the night sky from the OAO-2 and OSO-6 satellites with ground observations shows good agreement between the space experiments but a systematic error in the zero point of the ground observations, indicating an additional atmospheric source of radiation.

Roach, F. E.↗

Transport of solar flare protons: Comparison of a new analytic model with spacecraft measurements

An analytic solution was obtained to the complete Fokker-Planck equation including the effects of convection, interplanetary deceleration and acceleration, corotation, and anisotropic diffusion. The solution yields a time to maximum for the particle flux of about 10 h and an exponential decay time of about 5 h. Several solar flare particle events were observed with the solar and galactic cosmic ray experiment on OGO-6. Comparisons of the calculated time dependence of the fluxes with these observations of 1 to 70 MeV protons show that the model adequately describes both the rise and decay times.

Lupton, J. E.↗

Comparison of NASTRAN and STARDYNE static analysis of a graphite fiber reinforced plastic truss structure

A static and buckling analysis of the ATS-F&G spacecraft reflector support truss (RST) and bridge truss assembly using NASTRAN was conducted. The RST is fabricated from a new material, graphite fiber reinforced plastic. A comparison is made with the NASTRAN results and the results of a similar analysis conducted using the stardyne program. The results of an actual static load test are also compared.

Honeycutt, G. H.↗

Comparison of heat transfer characteristics of three cooling configurations for air-cooled turbine vanes tested in a turbojet engine

A comparison was made of the heat transfer characteristics of three air cooled vanes. The vanes incorporated cooling schemes such as impingement cooling, film cooling, and convection cooling with and without extended surfaces. A redesign study was made for two vanes to improve the cooling effectiveness. An average impingement heat transfer coefficient was calculated on the bases of experimentally determined temperatures at the leading edge and a one dimensional heat transfer calculation. This heat transfer coefficient was compared with existing impingement heat transfer correlations.

Yeh, F. C.↗

In-flight comparisons of boundary-layer and wake measurement probes for incompressible flow

The results are presented of in-flight comparisons of a number of boundary-layer and wake measurement probes suitable for low-speed flight-test investigations. The tested boundary-layer probes included a traversing total-pressure probe and a hot-film probe mounted on an internally-mounted drive mechanism, a curved and a straight boundary-layer rake, and a traversing hot-film probe with an externally-mounted drive mechanism. The wake measuring devices included a traversing, self-aligning probe, a wake rake, and an integrating wake rate. The boundary-layer data are compared with a common reference velocity profile and comments given regarding the accuracy of the static-pressure and total-pressure measurements. Discussions on the various calibration presentations used with hot-wire and hot-film sensors and various aspects of improving the accuracy of hot-film sensor results are given in the appendix of this report.

Mertaugh, L. J., Jr.↗

Comparison of SLAR images and small-scale, low-sun aerial photographs.

A comparison of side-looking airborne radar (SLAR) images and black and white aerial photos of similar scale and illumination of an area in the Mojave Desert of California shows that aerial photos yield far more information about geology than do SLAR images because of greater resolution, tonal range, and geometric fidelity, and easier use in stereo. Nevertheless, radar can differentiate some materials or surfaces that aerial photos cannot; thus, they should be considered as complementary, rather than competing tools in geologic investigations. The most significant advantage of SLAR, however, is its freedom from the stringent conditions of weather, date, and time that are required by small-scale aerial photos taken with a specified direction and angle of illumination. Indeed, in low latitudes, SLAR is the only way to obtain small-scale images with low illumination from certain directions; moreover, in areas of nearly continuous cloudiness, radar may be the only practical source of small-scale images.

Clark, M. M.↗

Comparison of characteristics and shock capturing methods with application to the space shuttle vehicle.

A critical appraisal is presented of a method-of-characteristics (MOC) and a shock-capturing technique (SCT) for calculating three-dimensional supersonic flow. Detailed comparisons are made for pointed and blunt-nosed bodies with a thick delta wing at angles of attack from 5 to 15 deg. The results show excellent agreement between the methods and with experiment. It is established that the SCT code yields accurate shock locations and jump conditions. The SCT code typically requires about three times as many mesh points as the MOC code in order to resolve the bow shock, but the total computation time is about the same. On a point for point basis, the SCT code is about four times faster than the MOC code.

Rakich, J. V.↗

Comparison of characteristic schemes for three-dimensional, steady, isentropic flow.

The accuracy and order of three bicharacteristic schemes based on the numerical method of characteristics for three-dimensional, steady, isentropic, supersonic flow were compared based on numerical calculations. Comparisons were made for source flows and for flows in contoured axisymmetric nozzles. The first two methods were tetrahedral line networks, differing only in the manner in which the cross derivatives were evaluated. The third method was the pentahedral line network proposed by Butler. All three methods were numerically stable and produced efficient and accurate solutions. A discussion of the relative merits and disadvantages of each method is presented.

Cline, M. C.↗

Chemical composition of sawdust from lunar rock 12013 and comparison of a Java tektite with the rock.

Abundances of 11 major and minor elements and 11 trace elements have been determined by instrumental neutron activation analysis of two Apollo 12013 rock fragments, a sample of rock 12013,17 sawdust, and a Java tektite (J2). Although the abundances of major elements in tektite J2 are similar to those of rock 12013, comparison of the minor and trace elements shows that no fragment of sawdust or rock 12013 that has been analyzed to date is chemically similar to tektite glass. Rock sawdust is representative of ?whole rock' composition only if the amount of contamination from the sawing process is known. After appropriate correction for saw wire contamination, analyses of sawdust yield fairly accurate averaged elemental compositions of complex clastic lunar and other rocks.

Showalter, D. L.↗

A comparison of orthogonal transformations for digital speech processing.

Discrete forms of the Fourier, Hadamard, and Karhunen-Loeve transforms are examined for their capacity to reduce the bit rate necessary to transmit speech signals. To rate their effectiveness in accomplishing this goal the quantizing error (or noise) resulting for each transformation method at various bit rates is computed and compared with that for conventional companded PCM processing. Based on this comparison, it is found that Karhunen-Loeve provides a reduction in bit rate of 13.5 kbits/s, Fourier 10 kbits/s, and Hadamard 7.5 kbits/s as compared with the bit rate required for companded PCM. These bit-rate reductions are shown to be somewhat independent of the transmission bit rate.

Campanella, S. J.↗

Tests and comparisons of gravity models.

Optical observations of the GEOS satellites were used to obtain orbital solutions with different sets of geopotential coefficients. The solutions were compared before and after modification to high order terms (necessary because of resonance) and were then analyzed by comparing subsequent observations with predicted trajectories. The most important source of error in orbit determination and prediction for the GEOS satellites is the effect of resonance found in most published sets of geopotential coefficients. Modifications to the sets yield greatly improved orbits in most cases. The results of these comparisons suggest that with the best optical tracking systems and gravity models, satellite position error due to gravity model uncertainty can reach 50-100 m during a heavily observed 5-6 day orbital arc. If resonant coefficients are estimated, the uncertainty is reduced considerably.

Marsh, J. G.↗

International comparison of radiometers - Techniques and results.

Description of an international comparison of radiometers made on May 10 through 14, 1971, with 24 instruments, each one representing the calibration standard of a different country or a major laboratory. All were pyranometers, viewing the sun and sky, thus bypassing the conventional method of transferring the standard from Angstrom pyrheliometers. This is the first time that pyranometers from all around the globe have been brought together in order to verify the scale on which to report solar radiation data. A highly accurate data collection system measured simultaneously the output of each instrument and that of a reference standard at 20-sec intervals. Over 300,000 radiometric signals were recorded under varying atmospheric conditions, as well as data on turbidity, temperature, and other relevant parameters. Computer programs were developed for overnight analysis of the data and distribution to participants on the following day. Among major findings are that instruments of different types and independent calibration such as those of Eppley, U. S. A., World Radiation Center, Switzerland, and Melbourne, Australia, show better agreement than anticipated, that certain national standards have to be revised by as much as 16% and that the cosine factor is highly dependent on the type of instrument.

Thekaekara, M. P.↗

Further comparison of theory and experiment for decay of homogeneous turbulence.

An analysis of the decay of homogeneous turbulence from a given initial state is compared with the experiment of Lin and Huang (1970). Comparisons were made for decay of turbulent energy, decay of energy-transfer spectra, decay of three-dimensional turbulent-energy spectra, and decay of higher-order spectral quantities V, R, and S, where these respectively represent functionals of three-, four-, and five-point spectral quantities. Good agreement between theory and experiment is noted.

Deissler, R. G.↗

Comparison of the Effectiveness of Flares With That of Fins for Stabilizing Low Fineness Ratio Bodies at Mach Numbers From 0.6 to 5.8

An experimental and analytical investigation has been made of the effectiveness of flares and of fins for providing aerodynamic stability of low-fineness-ratio bodies near zero angle of attack. Wind-tunnel tests were performed at Mach numbers from 0.6 to 3.8 to measure the normal force, center of pressure, and drag of bodies consisting of conical noses in combination with cylindrical midsections and finned or flared aftersections. This study included an investigation of the effects of nose bluntness, midbody length, flare angle (from 0° to 20°), and fin leading-edge bluntness. The results showed that for the same plan-form area, flares were more effective than fins, but for the same drag, fins were more effective than flares. Flow separation, which occurred ahead of a flare at certain Mach numbers, resulted in an increase in the stabilizing effectiveness of the flare and a decrease in the drag. However, flow separation led to large undesirable shifts in the center of pressure. Blunt fins were found to be more effective than sharp fins, with the vertical as well as the horizontal fins contributing to the effectiveness. Comparisons of the analytical with the experimental results indicated that the analytical method employed gave good estimates of the stabilizing effectiveness of both fins and flares throughout the supersonic Mach number range.

Leland H Jorgensen↗

Comparison of neutron spectra measured with three sizes of organic liquid scintillators using differentiation analysis

Proton recoil distributions were obtained by using organic liquid scintillators of different size. The measured distributions are converted to neutron spectra by differentiation analysis for comparison to the unfolded spectra of the largest scintillator. The approximations involved in the differentiation analysis are indicated to have small effects on the precision of neutron spectra measured with the smaller scintillators but introduce significant error for the largest scintillator. In the case of the smallest cylindrical scintillator, nominally 1.2 by 1.3 cm, the efficiency is shown to be insensitive to multiple scattering and to the angular distribution to the incident flux. These characteristics of the smaller scintillator make possible its use to measure scalar flux spectra within media high efficiency is not required.

Shook, D. F.↗