Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “STIRRING”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,153 records · Page 64

Environmental life cycle assessment of treatment and management strategies for food waste and sewage sludge

A consequential life cycle assessment (LCA) was utilized to compare the environmental impacts of food waste and sewage sludge management strategies. The strategies included a novel two-phase anaerobic digestion (AD) system and alternatives including landfill, waste-to-energy, composting, anaerobic membrane bioreactor, and conventional AD (wet continuous stirred-tank reactor [CSTR]). The co-management of food waste with sewage sludge was also considered for the two-phase AD system and for a conventional AD reactor. Further, a multidimensional LCA approach was taken, considering the five-midpoint impact categories of global warming, smog, human health particulate, acidification, and eutrophication estimated using the U.S. EPA Tool for the Reduction and Assessment of Chemical and Other Environmental Impacts. Co-management of food waste and sewage sludge using the novel two-phase AD system was shown to maximize energy recovery and had a net global warming benefit while reducing other environmental impacts compared with the alternative management strategies. It had similar relative environmental advantages across all categories as conventional AD, with the advantage of a smaller physical footprint. However, both approaches featured net environmental burdens when the background electric grid intensity fell below 0.25 kg CO 2 -eq kWh -1 , as could be expected in a decarbonized electric future. Upgrading the biogas produced from AD to renewable natural gas can displace the use of fossil natural gas for other non-electricity energy requirements that are difficult to decarbonize and may extend the time period of significant environmental benefits of utilizing AD for organic waste management. Treatment of the nutrient-rich supernatant generated by the novel two-phase AD system could be an obstacle for utilities with stringent nutrient discharge limits. Future research and full-scale implementation are needed to demonstrate the benefits of the two-phase AD system predicted through this analysis.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Enhancement of bronze alloy surface properties by FSP second-phase particle incorporation

This study presents results of an experimental study to evaluate friction stir processing (FSP) with and without hard second-phase particle incorporation as a means to enhance surface properties and wear performance of C86300 manganese bronze alloy. FSP of flat bronze alloy specimens was conducted with hardened H-13 tool steel to create a 3-mm-thick processed surface layer. The process was also used to incorporate B 4 C particles, thereby creating a metal-matrix composite layer on the alloy surface. FSP alone was observed to produce substantial reduction in grain size (from an initial value of 350 mu m to 1-5 μm). FSP without particle incorporation resulted in modest surface hardening due to grain refinement and dispersion hardening. Under lubricated contact in block-on-ring testing with a hardened steel counter face, FSP produced substantial reduction (about 3X) in bronze wear after polishing of processing surface roughening. FSP with hard B 4 C second-phase particle incorporation further reduced wear by up to 20X. The improvement in wear behavior is attributed to grain refinement and load shielding by second-phase particles, as determined by wear mechanism analysis.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Tribological behavior of hybrid Aluminum-TiB 2 metal matrix composites for brake rotor applications

Here, this research investigates the feasibility of hybrid aluminum metal matrix composites (MMC) incorporating TiB 2 particles for brake rotor applications. The composites were produced by incorporating both in-situ, submicron-sized TiB 2 particles and regular micron-sized TiB 2 powders via stir and squeeze casting techniques into A206 aluminum alloy matrix. Systematic adjustments in the fractions of in-situ and ex-situ TiB 2 particles were conducted to evaluate their impact on wear behavior and mechanisms. Combination of both particle types allowed composites with up to 10 vol% of reinforcements. Composites with higher proportions of ex-situ particles demonstrated increased wear resistance compared to those solely composed of in-situ particles, control specimens without TiB 2 , and conventional cast iron counterparts. The lowest wear rate for the hybrid composites sliding against phenolic brake pads was 1.1 × 10 -5 mm 3 /Nm, signifying a 3-fold reduction relative to cast iron sliding against the same pads. Wear analysis elucidated distinctive mechanisms within the hybrid composites, characterized by mild fragmented abrasive wear, adhesive wear, and plastic deformation, accompanied by the formation of an intermixed tribo-oxide layer.

42 ENGINEERING↗

How we compute N matters to estimates of mixing in stratified flows

We know that most commonly used models for turbulent mixing in the ocean rely on a background stratification against which turbulence must work to stir the fluid. While this background stratification is typically well defined in idealized numerical models, it is more difficult to capture in observations. Here, a potential discrepancy in ocean mixing estimates due to the chosen calculation of the background stratification is explored using direct numerical simulation data of breaking internal waves on slopes. There are two different methods for computing the buoyancy frequency $N$ , one based on a three-dimensionally sorted density field (often used in numerical models) and the other based on locally sorted vertical density profiles (often used in the field), are used to quantify the effect of $N$ on turbulence quantities. It is shown that how $N$ is calculated changes not only the flux Richardson number $R_{f}$ , which is often used to parameterize turbulent mixing, but also the turbulence activity number or the Gibson number $Gi$ , leading to potential errors in estimates of the mixing efficiency using $Gi$ -based parameterizations.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Why fast magnetic reconnection is so prevalent

Evolving magnetic fields are shown to generically reach a state of fast magnetic reconnection in which magnetic field line connections change and magnetic energy is released at an Alfvénic rate. This occurs even in plasmas with zero resistivity; only the finiteness of the mass of the lightest charged particle, an electron, is required. The speed and prevalence of Alfvénic or fast magnetic reconnection imply that its cause must be contained within the ideal evolution equation for magnetic fields, $\unicode[STIX]{x2202}\boldsymbol{B}/\unicode[STIX]{x2202}t=\unicode[STIX]{x1D735}\times (\boldsymbol{u}\times \boldsymbol{B})$ , where $\boldsymbol{u}(\boldsymbol{x},t)$ is the velocity of the magnetic field lines. For a generic $\boldsymbol{u}(\boldsymbol{x},t)$ , neighbouring magnetic field lines develop a separation that increases exponentially, as $e^{\unicode[STIX]{x1D70E}(\ell ,t)}$ with $\ell$ the distance along a line. This exponentially enhances the sensitivity of the evolution to non-ideal effects. An analogous effect, the importance of stirring to produce a large-scale flow and enhance mixing, has been recognized by cooks through many millennia, but the importance of the large-scale flow $\boldsymbol{u}$ to reconnection is customarily ignored. In part this is due to the sixty-year focus of recognition theory on two-coordinate models, which eliminate the exponential enhancement that is generic with three coordinates. A simple three-coordinate model is developed, which could be used to address many unanswered questions.

Physics↗

Integration of pH Control into Chi.Bio Reactors and Demonstration with Small-Scale Enzymatic Poly(ethylene terephthalate) Hydrolysis

Small-scale bioreactors that are affordable and accessible would be of major benefit to the research community. In previous work, an open-source, automated bioreactor system was designed to operate up to the 30 mL scale with online optical monitoring, stirring, and temperature control, and this system, dubbed Chi.Bio, is now commercially available at a cost that is typically 1–2 orders of magnitude less than commercial bioreactors. In this work, we further expand the capabilities of the Chi.Bio system by enabling continuous pH monitoring and control through hardware and software modifications. For hardware modifications, we sourced low-cost, commercial pH circuits and made straightforward modifications to the Chi.Bio head plate to enable continuous pH monitoring. For software integration, we introduced closed-loop feedback control of the pH measured inside the Chi.Bio reactors and integrated a pH-control module into the existing Chi.Bio user interface. We demonstrated the utility of pH control through the small-scale depolymerization of the synthetic polyester, poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET), using a benchmark cutinase enzyme, and compared this to 250 mL bioreactor hydrolysis reactions. The results in terms of PET conversion and rate, measured both by base addition and product release profiles, are statistically equivalent, with the Chi.Bio system allowing for a 20-fold reduction of purified enzyme required relative to the 250 mL bioreactor setup. Through inexpensive modifications, the ability to conduct pH control in Chi.Bio reactors widens the potential slate of biochemical reactions and biological cultivations for study in this system, and may also be adapted for use in other bioreactor platforms.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Probing the Chemical Kinetics of Minimalist Functional Group Gasoline Surrogates

We report surrogate mixtures are routinely used for understanding gasoline fuel combustion in engine simulations. The general trend in surrogate formulation has been to increase the number of fuel components in a mixture to better emulate real fuel properties. Recently, a new surrogate design strategy based on functional group analysis of real gasolines was proposed using a minimal number of species [minimalist functional group (MFG)-approach]. MFG surrogates (having just one or two components) could experimentally capture the ignition delay time (IDT), threshold sooting index, and smoke point of different gasoline fuels with hundreds of components. However, other combustion characteristics were not explored, and kinetic modeling of MFG surrogates was not reported. These aspects are addressed in this paper, where the combustion behavior of MFG surrogates for various gasolines was assessed by simulating IDT, jet-stirred reactor oxidation, and premixed laminar flame speeds using chemical kinetic modeling. MFG simulations were compared with experimental data of the real gasolines as well as with the more complex multicomponent (five to nine species) surrogates. This study reveals that binary MFG surrogate mixtures are capable of accurately simulating the combustion behavior of more complex gasoline fuels with hundreds of components.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Experimental and Kinetic Modeling Study of 3-Methyl-2-butenol (Prenol) Oxidation

Longer chain alcohols with 4–5 carbon atoms are attractive alternative fuels as they can be derived from biological sources and since their combustion leads to lower exhaust gas levels of NO x and soot compared to commercial fossil fuels. The auto-ignition behavior of fuels that contain both a hydroxyl group and a C=C double bond in their molecular structure is not well established in the literature. Understanding the influence of these functional groups on the ignition behavior of fuels is critical in the development of tailor-made fuels for advanced combustion engines. In this study, ignition delay times of an unsaturated alcohol, 3-methyl-2-butenol (prenol), are measured using a high-pressure shock tube and a rapid compression machine at pressures of 15 and 30 bar at equivalence ratios of 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 in “air” in the temperature range 600–1400 K. Furthermore, a detailed kinetic model is developed and validated using the new experimental data in this study. In addition, speciation data in a jet-stirred reactor, ignition delay times, and laminar burning velocities available in the literature were also used to validate the new kinetic model. Fuel flux and sensitivity analyses are performed using this new model to determine the important fuel consumption pathways and critical reactions that affect the reactivity of prenol.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Non-Boltzmann Effects in Chain Branching and Pathway Branching for Diethyl Ether Oxidation

Low-temperature (LT) engine applications have several potential benefits, including reduced emissions and increased efficiency. Attaining these benefits requires accurate kinetic modeling of LT chain branching, which depends heavily on ketohydroperoxide (KHP) decomposition. For diethyl ether (DEE), a promising biofuel, current estimates of the KHP decomposition rate constant are largely based on empirical fits to data. In this study, we investigate the most important KHP isomer in DEE LT oxidation by applying variable reaction coordinate transition state theory to the main pathway for KHP decomposition: OO bond fission to produce •OH and a keto-alkoxy radical, •OQ'O. We also use ab initio kinetics methods to investigate the decomposition of •OQ'O, where we find dominant branching to acetic acid, with the remaining flux going to CH 3 C(O)OCHO. Additionally, new time-resolved measurements of DEE and acetic acid concentrations during LT (450–600 K) DEE oxidation are obtained in a laser photolysis flow reactor coupled with multiplexed photoionization mass spectrometry. These new experimental data, along with jet-stirred reactor data in the literature, are compared with the predictions of a recent DEE mechanism (Tran et al. Proc. Comb. Inst. 2019, 37, 511-519) that was modified with the newly calculated ab initio rate constants for KHP and •OQ'O decomposition. The predictions of the modified mechanism are quite poor when compared to the experimental data; this is primarily due to the new KHP ⇌ •OQ'O + •OH rate constant, which is 1–2 orders of magnitude slower than empirical values employed in recent mechanisms. To reconcile the new KHP rate constant and the experimental data, we explore and quantify the possible role of non-Boltzmann (nB) reaction sequences. The nB reactions have a substantial effect on both the overall mechanism reactivity and the •OQ'O branching to acetic acid. We also provide guidance on the proper implementation of nB reactions in kinetic mechanisms.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Perspectives on Polyolefin Catalysis in Microfluidics for High-Throughput Screening: A Minireview

Polyolefins are the largest produced plastics in the world which traditionally employ continuous stirred tank reactors and fluidized bed reactors for commercial production. The operating condition, reaction kinetics, and molecular interactions inside the reactor strongly affect the polyolefin properties, which require stringent process control in conventional procedures. Understanding the catalytic pathway, behavior of polymer particles and effect of reactor conditions are essential for designing specific polymer properties, namely the molecular weight, chain length, polydispersity, etc. Microfluidics can play a significant role in designing polymers tailored to the user needs. Smaller channel dimensions help obtain uniform reaction conditions over the length of the microfluidic reactor in a controlled environment. With real-time monitoring techniques in microfluidics, even single particle growth of polymer can be studied to understand the parameters affecting the polymer properties. High throughput microfluidics can help catalyst screening in a short duration with less consumption of reagents generating less waste. When supplemented with efficient machine learning algorithms, automated high throughput microfluidics has the potential to rapidly optimize the process and develop new knowledge even with a limited data set. When trained on data sets generated using microfluidic experiments that are designed efficiently with working knowledge of the process, machine learning algorithms can provide the relationship between the multivariable parameters space and polymer properties, which is not possible with the traditional statistical methods and interpolation techniques. Here, the rise in the utilization of microfluidics, with the advancement of machine learning algorithms, for polyolefin catalysis, highlights the importance of microfluidics for catalyst discovery, parameter optimization, and understanding reaction pathway for producing polymers with specific properties for specialized applications.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Insights into Constraining Rate Coefficients in Fuel Oxidation Mechanisms Using Genetic Algorithm Optimization

Accurate fuel oxidation mechanisms can enable predictive capabilities that aid in advancing combustion technologies. High-level computational kinetics can yield reasonable rate coefficients with uncertainties, in some cases, below a factor of 2. Computed rate coefficients can be constrained further by optimizing against experimental data. Here, we explore the application of genetic algorithm (GA) optimization to constrain computed rate coefficients in complex fuel oxidation mechanisms in conjunction with temperature-dependent species mole fractions from jet-stirred reactor (JSR) measurements. Cyclohexane is a model candidate for understanding the reactivity of cyclic fuels. In this work, we optimize the rate coefficients of the most recent literature cyclohexane mechanism, which incorporates theoretically computed rate coefficients for the reaction networks stemming from the first and second O 2 addition pathways, against the experimental results of two separate literature JSR studies. Optimization consistency is evaluated by carrying out three GA optimizations: fitting to the temperature-dependent species mole fractions in each JSR experiment separately and simultaneously fitting the species mole fractions in both experiments. Local sensitivity analyses are used to identify five influential low-temperature oxidation reactions for optimization. Although the three optimizations do not yield identical rate coefficients, the direction of change in all five rate coefficients is consistent among the three optimizations. Performance of the models from the three optimizations is assessed against literature ignition delay times with differences in the level of agreement observed among the different optimizations. In conclusion, comparisons are made with our recent optimization work of a cyclopentane oxidation master-equation model against time-resolved species concentrations, and insights and improvements of the strategy for constraining rate coefficients using GA optimization are discussed.

33 ADVANCED PROPULSION SYSTEMS↗

Constraining the Low-Temperature Oxidation Mechanism of n -Hexanol through the Detection and Identification of C 6 Elusive Intermediates

Alcohol-based fuels are currently considered to be viable energy carriers for the transportation sector. Consequently, a comprehensive mechanistic understanding of the low-temperature oxidation of alcohols is essential for application in advanced low-temperature compression engines. Here, in this work, a multidimensional approach involving experimental investigations, kinetic modeling, and theoretical calculations was used to provide new insights into the low-temperature oxidation mechanism of a C 6 alcohol, n -hexanol (CH 3 (CH 2 ) 5 OH), through the detection and identification of elusive C 6 intermediates. The oxidation of n-hexanol was investigated in a jet-stirred reactor under stoichiometric conditions (ϕ = 1.0), an initial fuel concentration of 2%, a residence time of 2 s, a temperature range between 500 and 660 K, and a pressure of 700 Torr. The reactants, intermediates, and final products were detected and identified by means of molecular-beam mass spectrometry coupled with single-photon ionization employing tunable synchrotron-generated vacuum ultraviolet radiation. Chemical kinetic simulations were performed using a previously published kinetic model (Togbé et al., Energy Fuels 2010, 11, 5859−5875) to predict the reactivity of n-hexanol and elucidate the predominant formation pathways of the observed low-temperature species. Experimental photoionization efficiency curves in conjunction with ab initio calculations, enabled the identification of important low-temperature species, such as C 6 unsaturated alcohols, C 6 olefinic hydroperoxides, C 6 cyclic ethers, C 6 diones, and C 6 ketohydroperoxides. The results of this study provide valuable insight into the mechanism of the low-temperature oxidation chemistry of n -hexanol, contributing to the development of kinetic models for the low-temperature oxidation of n-hexanol and other long-chain linear alcohols.

alcohols↗

Reduced Chemistry for Butanol Isomers at Engine-Relevant Conditions

Butanol has received significant research attention as a second-generation biofuel in the past few years. In the present study, skeletal mechanisms for four butanol isomers were generated from two widely accepted, well-validated detailed chemical kinetic models for the butanol isomers. The detailed models were reduced using a two-stage approach consisting of the directed relation graph with error propagation and sensitivity analysis. During the reduction process, issues were encountered with pressure-dependent reactions formulated using the logarithmic pressure interpolation approach; these issues are discussed and recommendations are made to avoid ambiguity in its future implementation in mechanism development. The performance of the skeletal mechanisms generated here was compared with that of detailed mechanisms in simulations of autoignition delay times, laminar flame speeds, and perfectly stirred reactor temperature response curves and extinction residence times, over a wide range of pressures, temperatures, and equivalence ratios. Good agreement was observed between the detailed and skeletal mechanisms, demonstrating the adequacy of the resulting reduced chemistry for all the butanol isomers in predicting global combustion phenomena. In addition, the skeletal mechanisms closely predicted the time-histories of fuel mass fractions in homogeneous compression-ignition engine simulations. The performance of each butanol isomer was additionally compared with that of a gasoline surrogate with an antiknock index of 87 in a homogeneous compression-ignition engine simulation. The gasoline surrogate was consumed faster than any of the butanol isomers, with tert -butanol exhibiting the slowest fuel consumption rate. As a result, while n -butanol and isobutanol displayed the most similar consumption profiles relative to the gasoline surrogate, the two literature chemical kinetic models predicted different orderings.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Harnessing Fermentation May Enhance the Performance of Biological Sulfate-Reducing Bioreactors

Biological sulfate reduction (BSR) represents a promising strategy for bioremediation of sulfate-rich waste streams, yet the impact of metabolic interactions on performance is largely unexplored. Here, genome-resolved metagenomics was used to characterize 17 microbial communities in reactors treating synthetic sulfate-contaminated solutions. Reactors were supplemented with lactate or acetate and a small amount of fermentable substrate. Of the 163 genomes representing all the abundant bacteria, 130 encode 321 NiFe and FeFe hydrogenases and all genomes of the 22 sulfate-reducing microorganisms (SRM) encode genes for H 2 uptake. We observed lactate oxidation solely in the first packed bed reactor zone, with propionate and acetate oxidation in the middle and predominantly acetate oxidation in the effluent zone. The energetics of these reactions are very different, yet sulfate reduction kinetics were unaffected by the type of electron donor available. We hypothesize that the comparable rates, despite the typically slow growth of SRM on acetate, are a result of the consumption of H 2 generated by fermentation. This is supported by the sustained performance of a predominantly acetate-supplemented stirred tank reactor dominated by diverse fermentative bacteria encoding FeFe hydrogenase genes and SRM capable of acetate and hydrogen consumption and CO 2 assimilation. Thus, addition of fermentable substrates to stimulate syntrophic relationships may improve the performance of BSR reactors supplemented with inexpensive acetate.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗

Kinetics of Cation and Oxyanion Adsorption and Desorption on Ferrihydrite: Roles of Ferrihydrite Binding Sites and a Unified Model

Understanding the kinetics of toxic ion reactions with ferrihydrite is crucial for predicting the dynamic behavior of contaminants in soil environments. In this study, the kinetics of As(V), Cr(VI), Cu, and Pb adsorption and desorption on ferrihydrite were investigated with a combination of laboratory macroscopic experiments, microscopic investigation and mechanistic modeling. The rates of As(V), Cr(VI), Cu, and Pb adsorption and desorption on ferrihydrite, as systematically studied using a stirred-flow method, was highly dependent on the reaction pH and metal concentrations and varied significantly among four metals. Spherical aberration-corrected scanning transmission electron microscopy (Cs-STEM) showed, at sub-nano scales, all four metals were distributed within the ferrihydrite particle aggregates homogeneously after adsorption reactions, with no evidence of surface diffusion-controlled processes. Based on experimental results, we developed a unifying kinetics model for both cation and oxyanion adsorption/desorption on ferrihydrite based on the mechanistic-based equilibrium model CD-MUSIC. Overall, the model described the kinetic results well, and we quantitatively demonstrated how the equilibrium properties of the cation and oxyanion binding to various ferrihydrite sites affected the adsorption and desorption rates. Our results provided a unifying quantitative modeling method for the kinetics of both cation and oxyanion adsorption/desorption on iron minerals.

Environmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory↗

Predicting Aerosol Reactivity Across Scales: from the Laboratory to the Atmosphere

To fully utilize the results of laboratory-based studies of the chemistry of model atmospheric aerosol reactions, it is important to understand how to relate them to the conditions found in nature. In this study, we have taken a validated reaction-diffusion mechanism for oxidation of C 30 H 62 aerosol by OH under flow tube conditions and examined its predictions for another experimental regime (continuous flow stirred tank reactor) and for the atmosphere, spanning alkane aerosol viscosities from liquid to semisolid. The results show that under OH-concentration-limited and aerosol-mixing-limited conditions, it should be possible to select laboratory experimental conditions where many aspects of the particle phase and volatile product chemistry under atmospheric conditions can be revealed. If the OH collision and organic diffusion rates are comparable, however, reactivity is highly sensitive to the details of both OH concentration and internal mixing. Furthermore the characteristics of the transition between limiting conditions provide key insights into which parts of the reaction mechanism dominate in the various kinetic regimes.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Toward an Envelope of Design Solutions for Combined/Intensified Reaction/Separation Systems

In this work, we develop an envelope of design solutions for combined intensified reaction/separation systems. The attainable region-based continuous flow stirred tank reactor equivalence principle is applied to characterize design boundaries for a given chemistry independent of process design. The thermodynamic-based Generalized Modular Representation Framework is then employed to generate candidate process alternatives along the design boundaries. The proposed approach is showcased via a case study on olefin metathesis. As a result, we also highlight the need to incorporate the attainable region-based constraints into synthesis strategies to assist effective bounding of design/intensification space.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Kinetics and Mechanism of Ce(IV) Phase Transfer by the Neutral Extractants Tributyl Phosphate and N,N -Di(2-ethylhexyl)isobutyramide

Tributyl phosphate and N,N-di(2-ethylhexyl)isobutyramide (DEHiBA) are uranium-selective extractants that could be used to recover low-enriched uranium from commercial used nuclear fuel. The economic viability of liquid-liquid extraction processes for chemical separations depends on both thermodynamic and kinetic considerations. Here we used microfluidic droplet extraction to measure interfacial phase transfer rate constants for the extraction and stripping of Ce(IV), a non-radioactive actinide surrogate. The Damkohler numbers for each system were calculated and the phase transfer processes were determined to be diffusion-limited under all conditions, contrary to prior studies using constant interface stirred cells and single drop methods. A well-extracted 2:1 DEHiBA/Ce(IV) complex in the organic phase was determined from batch distribution studies, suggesting a different extraction mechanism for Ce(IV) compared with poorly extracted Pu(IV). Finally, phase disengagement rates were found to be rapid in both systems, in agreement with other studies.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗