Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “MHD simulation”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,135 records · Page 63

On FIRE mode in KSTAR

We report on the status of Fast Ion Regulated Enhancement (FIRE) mode experiments in the Korea Superconducting Tokamak Advanced Research. This regime is being developed for high-performance, steady-state operation which features a stationary ion internal transport barrier, enabling a central ion temperature approaching 10 keV to be sustained for up to 50 s, without the need for delicate profile control and with no significant impurity accumulation. As its key novelty lies in the significant contribution of fast ions that stabilize core turbulence, the regime has been named FIRE mode. To achieve this regime, neutral beam injection is applied at moderate power levels near the L–H power threshold, while maintaining low plasma density to avoid the L–H transition. The scenario is typically established in diverted magnetic configurations. The core features of FIRE mode were investigated through power balance analysis and fluctuation measurements, revealing a clear transport bifurcation in the ion channel. At the plasma edge, FIRE mode occasionally exhibits I-mode characteristics, particularly in unfavorable magnetic null configurations with q 95 ∼ 4, including the presence of weakly coherent modes. In terms of MHD activity, sawtooth oscillations are observed but appear to be stabilized during the high-performance phase. Fast ion-driven Alfvénic eigenmodes (AEs), indicated by strong frequency chirping near 200 kHz, are also observed. Additionally, lower-frequency MHD activities, distinct from the fast ion-driven AEs, are present and have some influence on plasma performance. The enhancement of core confinement is primarily attributed to fast ion effects, which were evaluated with respect to dilution, alpha stabilization, and resonant interactions with turbulence using gyrokinetic analyses. Among these, the dilution effect was found to be the most dominant. The characteristics of FIRE mode were compared with those of other hot ion plasma scenarios, such as supershot and hot ion mode. While they share many similarities, FIRE mode is distinguished by the accessibility to conditions with T i ≈ T e , presence of I-mode edge features, and its long-duration sustainment. Predictive simulations of FIRE mode were performed using integrated transport modeling with TRIASSIC, employing the TGLF anomalous transport model. These simulations confirmed the critical role of fast ions in achieving this regime. The future prospect of FIRE mode for application in fusion reactors is discussed, with an emphasis on possibly extending the regime to higher density operation.

FIRE mode↗

Fast ion stabilization of tilt in large radius FRCs

The field reversed configuration (FRC) has been a curious case in plasma physics research in that early MHD analysis suggested FRCs should be grossly unstable, while experimental results contradicted that prediction. Later, this theory was able to resolve this contradiction by understanding that finite Larmor radius effects largely negated the MHD predictions. Similarly, previous theoretical studies of beam driven FRCs predicted that such system would be unstable to beam driven modes while, again, experimental results indicated the contradiction. In this paper, we reconcile the theoretical understanding of beam driven modes with experimental observations of stability in these systems. By self-consistently capturing fast ion generation from neutral beam injection and its impact on the plasma equilibrium, we show that low amplitude perturbations in the magnetic field, driven by betatron particles, modify the precession frequencies of the betatron particles such that the drive for compressional Alfvén waves in the thermal plasma is reduced. Finally, we are able to demonstrate, for the first time, stable beam driven FRC evolution at high S*/E in 3D kinetic simulations.

Betatrons↗

Kelvin–Helmholtz instability under stabilizing parallel magnetic field in nonhomogeneous compressible MHD flows

We study the Kelvin–Helmholtz instability (KHI) for the general case of a compressible, nonhomogeneous, magnetized plasma flow. The study is limited to a vortex sheet interface with an imposed parallel magnetic field. We introduce a new formalism based on a convective Mach number M c , a convective Alfvénic Mach number M Ac , and a total convective Mach number that combines the two. We derive an analytic expression of the KHI growth rate for a homogeneous flow (i.e., zero Atwood number, A=0) that converges toward both the expression for unmagnetized compressible flow and Chandrasekhar's expression for magnetized incompressible flow. Otherwise, the dispersion relation is solved numerically and allows deriving general stability diagrams of magnetized KHI for the triplet (A, M c , β −plasma) parameters. We show these parameters uniquely define all configurations for a parallel magnetic field. We also construct diagrams with respect to the convective Alfvénic Mach number, the β − plasma parameter, or the magnetic field showing which magnetic field strength is required for stabilizing a given shear flow. The theoretical growth rates are compared with 18 simulations made with the GAMERA code, currently used for 3D magnetospheric simulations. Finally, we apply our results to the analysis of a past KHI experiment performed at the OMEGA laser facility, showing linear theory succeeds to provide accurate estimates of the growth rate at early times. We further discuss how our results can inform future experiments in the high-Mach magnetized regime at the National Ignition Facility. Possible limitations of the study due to resistive, mixing, or turbulence effects are discussed.

compressible flows↗

Effect of insulator end cap thickness on time-dependent Hartmann flow in a rotating mirror

We present a framework for analysing plasma flow in a rotating mirror. By making a series of physical assumptions, we reduce the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) equations in a three-dimensional cylindrical system to a one-dimensional system in a shallow, cuboidal channel within a transverse magnetic field, similar to the Hartmann flow in ducts. We then solve the system both numerically and analytically for a range of values of the Hartmann number and calculate the dependence of the plasma flow speed on the thickness of the insulating end cap. We observe that the mean flow overshoots and decelerates before achieving a steady-state value, a phenomenon that the analytical model cannot capture. This overshoot is directly proportional to the thickness of the insulating end cap and the external electric field, with a weak dependence on the external magnetic field. Our simplified model can act as a benchmark for future simulations of the supersonic mirror device CMFX (centrifugal magnetic fusion experiment), which will employ more sophisticated physics and realistic magnetic field geometries.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Multidimensional Tests of a Finite-Volume Solver for MHD With a Real-Gas Equation of State

This work considers two algorithms of a finite-volume solver for the MHD equations with a real-gas equation of state (EOS). Both algorithms use a multistate form of Harten-Lax-Van Leer approximate Riemann solver as formulated for MHD discontinuities. This solver is modified to use the generalized sound speed from the real-gas EOS. Two methods are tested: EOS evaluation at cell centers and at flux interfaces where the former is more computationally efficient. A battery of 1D and 2D tests are employed: convergence of 1D and 2D linearized waves, shock tube Riemann problems, a 2D nonlinear circularly polarized Alfvén wave, and a 2D magneto-Rayleigh-Taylor instability test. The cell-centered EOS evaluation algorithm produces unresolvable thermodynamic inconsistencies in the intermediate states leading to spurious solutions while the flux-interface EOS evaluation algorithm robustly produces the correct solution. The linearized wave tests show this inconsistency is associated with the magnetosonic waves and the magneto-Rayleigh-Taylor instability test demonstrates simulation findings where the spurious solution leads to an unphysical simulation.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

PHELIX Shallow Cassette Liner Performance Tests 1 and 2 Post-Shot Simulation Report

PHELIX shallow cassette liner performance Tests 1 (PHELIX No. 151) and 2 (PHELIX No. 156) were conducted on August 07, 2020, and September 16, 2020, respectively. The primary purpose for these tests was to assess liner performance within the new shallow cassette PHELIX design configuration. Specific goals included: (1) an assessment of liner performance in terms of velocity and symmetry (both axial and azimuthal), and (2) an assessment of our ability to accurately predict liner performance. Test 1 was conducted with a driving potential of 70 kV. Test 2 was conducted with a driving potential of 75 kV.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Buoyancy-driven instabilities and the nonlinear breakup of a sheared magnetic layer

Motivated by problems concerning the storage and subsequent escape of the solar magnetic field, a study has been made of how a magnetic layer embedded in a convectively stable atmosphere evolves due to axisymmetric instabilities driven by magnetic buoyancy. The initial equilibrium consists of a toroidal field sheared by a weaker poloidal component. The linear stability problem is investigated for both ideal and resistive MHD, and the nonlinear evolution is followed by numerical integration of the equations of motion. In all cases, the instability is greatly affected by the distribution and strength of the poloidal field. In particular, both the horizontal and vertical scales of the motions are controlled by the location of the surface on which the poloidal field vanishes: the resonant surface. In the nonlinear regime, a resonant surface close to the interface between the magnetized and field-free fluid leads to the localization of the instability, so that only a fraction of the magnetic region is disrupted by the motions. By contrast, a deeply seated resonant surface leads to the complete disruption of the layer and to the formation of large, helical magnetic fragments whose identity is preserved for the entire simulation.

Cattaneo, Fausto↗

Exploring the transition from continuous turbulence fluctuations to bursting ELMs in high SOL density regimes

BOUT++ turbulence simulations of the DIII-D reveal that the density profile between the separatrix and pedestal plays a crucial role in the dynamics of edge localized modes (ELMs) and edge plasma turbulent transport. Nonlinear simulations demonstrate that small ELMs in the DIII-D hybrid scenario under high SOL density conditions are predominantly driven by local ballooning modes near the separatrix, stabilizing global instabilities while enhancing localized pressure fluctuations. A key control parameters for ELM dynamics is the separatrix-to-pedestal density ratio, n e,sep /n e,ped . A high ratio indicates a shallow gradient, favoring small ELMs, while a lower ratio signals a steep gradient, which increases the likelihood of large ELMs. Comprehensive parameter scans, including n e,sep /n e,ped , density gradient profiles near the separatrix, and resistivity, reveal the critical role of these parameters in shaping transitions between turbulence-driven transport and ELM bursting. The scans demonstrate that in high SOL density regimes, small ELMs can result from either global resistive MHD instabilities or local ballooning modes near the separatrix, depending on the steepness of the separatrix density gradient. These findings also highlight the transition from continuous turbulence to small ELMs. The post-crash peak in pressure fluctuations, δP rms serves as a critical metric for identifying transition from continuous turbulence fluctuations to ELM bursting. Larger δP rms values correlate with ELM bursts driven by local or global instabilities, whereas smaller values indicate turbulence-dominated transport. Drift-Alfvén and resistive ballooning turbulence enhance the entrainment of fluctuations from the pedestal to the SOL, contributing to the complex interplay of dynamics in this regime. These findings emphasize the importance of separatrix density shaping and pedestal gradient control for optimizing ELM behavior in ITER and future fusion devices.

Li, Nami [Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (↗

Quantifying the Ability of Magnetohydrodynamic Models to Reproduce Observed Birkeland Current and Auroral Electrojet Magnitudes

Although global magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) models have increased in sophistication and are now at the forefront of modeling Space Weather, there is still no clear understanding of how well these models replicate the observed ionospheric current systems. Without a full understanding and treatment of the ionospheric current systems, global models will have significant shortcomings that will limit their use. In this study we focus on reproducing observed seasonal interhemispheric asymmetry in ionospheric currents using the Space Weather Modeling Framework (SWMF). We find that SWMF does reproduce the linear relationship between the electrojets and the FACs, despite the underestimation of the currents’ magnitudes. Quantitatively, we find that at best SWMF is only capturing approximately 60% of the observed current. We also investigate how varying F10.7 effects the ionospheric potential and currents during the summer and winter. We find that simulations ran with higher F10.7 result in lower ionospheric potentials. Additionally, we find that the models do not always replicate the expected behavior of the currents with varying F10.7. This work points to a needed improvement in ionospheric conductance models.

Tre'Shunda James↗

Long-pulse high-performance H-mode plasmas achieved on EAST

A record duration of a 310 s H-mode plasma (H 98y2 ~ 1.3, n e /n GW ~ 0.7, f BS > 50%) has been recently achieved on experimental advanced superconducting tokamak (EAST) with metal walls, exploiting the device's improved long-pulse capabilities. The experiment demonstrates good control of tungsten concentration, core/edge MHD stability, and particle and heat exhaust with an ITER-like tungsten divertor and zero injected torque, establishing a milestone on the path to steady-state long-pulse high-performance scenarios in support of ITER and CFETR. Important synergistic effects are leveraged toward this result, which relies purely on radio frequency (RF) powers for heating and current drive (H&CD). On-axis electron cyclotron heating enhances the H&CD efficiency from lower hybrid wave injection, increasing confinement quality and enabling fully non-inductive operation at high density (n e /n GW ~ 70%) and high poloidal beta (β P ~ 2.5). A small-amplitude grassy edge localized mode regime facilitates the RF power coupling to the H-mode edge and reduces divertor sputtering/erosion. The high energy confinement quality (H 98y2 ~ 1.3) is achieved with the experimental and simulated results pointing to the strong effect of Shafranov shift on turbulence. Transport analysis suggests that trapped electron modes dominate in the core region during the record discharge. The detailed physics processes (RF synergy, core-edge integration, confinement properties, etc.) of the steady-state operation will be illustrated in the content. In the future, EAST will aim at accessing more relevant dimensionless parameters to develop long-pulse high-performance plasma toward ITER and CFETR steady-state advanced operation.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Inputs and Outputs for paper "The DESC stellarator code suite. Part 1. Quick and accurate equilibria computations"

Contains the DESC and VMEC input and output files used in the paper, as well as the plotting scripts used to create the figures in the paper (Current with the arXiv Mar 31 2022 version, https://arxiv.org/abs/2203.17173v1): 3D equilibrium codes are vital for stellarator design and operation, and high-accuracy equilibria are also necessary for stability studies. This paper details comparisons of two 3D equilibrium codes, VMEC, which uses a steepest-descent algorithm to reach a minimum-energy plasma state, and DESC, which minimizes the MHD force error in real space directly. Accuracy as measured by final plasma energy and satisfaction of MHD force balance, as well as other metrics, will be presented for each code, along with the computation time. It is shown that DESC is able to achieve more accurate solutions, especially near-axis. DESC's global Fourier-Zernike basis also yields the solution everywhere in the plasma volume, not just on discrete flux surfaces. Further, DESC can compute the same accuracy solution as VMEC in an order of magnitude less time.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

On large-scale dynamos with stable stratification and the application to stellar radiative zones

Our understanding of large-scale magnetic fields in stellar radiative zones remains fragmented and incomplete. Such magnetic fields, which must be produced by some form of dynamo mechanism, are thought to dominate angular-momentum transport, making them crucial to stellar evolution. A major difficulty is the effect of stable stratification, which generally suppresses dynamo action. We explore the effects of stable stratification on mean-field dynamo theory with a particular focus on a non-helical large-scale dynamo (LSD) mechanism known as the magnetic shear-current effect. We find that the mechanism is robust to increasing stable stratification as long as the original requirements for its operation are met: a source of shear and non-helical magnetic fluctuations (e.g. from a small-scale dynamo). Both are plausibly sourced in the presence of differential rotation. Our idealized direct numerical simulations, supported by mean-field theory, demonstrate the generation of near equipartition large-scale toroidal fields. Additionally, a scan over magnetic Reynolds number shows no change in the growth or saturation of the LSD, providing good numerical evidence of a dynamo mechanism resilient to catastrophic quenching, which has been an issue for helical dynamos. These properties – the absence of catastrophic quenching and robustness to stable stratification – make the mechanism a plausible candidate for generating in situ large-scale magnetic fields in stellar radiative zones.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

Microphysically modified magnetosonic modes in collisionless, high-β plasmas

With the support of hybrid-kinetic simulations and analytic theory, we describe the nonlinear behaviour of long-wavelength non-propagating (NP) modes and fast magnetosonic waves in high-β collisionless plasmas, with particular attention to their excitation of and reaction to kinetic micro-instabilities. The perpendicularly pressure balanced polarization of NP modes produces an excess of perpendicular pressure over parallel pressure in regions where the plasma β is increased. For mode amplitudes |δB/B 0 |≳0.3, this excess excites the mirror instability. Particle scattering off these micro-scale mirrors frustrates the nonlinear saturation of transit-time damping, ensuring that large-amplitude NP modes continue their decay to small amplitudes. At asymptotically large wavelengths, we predict that the mirror-induced scattering will be large enough to interrupt transit-time damping entirely, isotropizing the pressure perturbations and morphing the collisionless NP mode into the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) entropy mode. In fast waves, a fluctuating pressure anisotropy drives both mirror and firehose instabilities when the wave amplitude satisfies |δB/B 0 |≳2β -1 . The induced particle scattering leads to delayed shock formation and MHD-like wave dynamics. Taken alongside prior work on self-interrupting Alfvén waves and self-sustaining ion-acoustic waves, our results establish a foundation for new theories of electromagnetic turbulence in low-collisionality, high-β plasmas such as the intracluster medium, radiatively inefficient accretion flows and the near-Earth solar wind.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Euler equations and the Sod shock tube problem

The Euler equations are a subset of the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) equations in the infinitely collisional, unmagnetized limit. MHD modeling is central to many areas of plasma physics, ranging from low-temperature glow discharges to inertial confinement fusion. An important aspect of the Euler equations is their ability to describe states with discontinuities, such as shock waves. A standard benchmark test for numerical implementation of the Euler equations is the Sod shock tube. In this test, the system is initialized at rest with a pressure and density discontinuity, which results in a shock wave traveling into the low-pressure region and a rarefaction wave traveling into the high-pressure region. Starting with the presentation of the Euler equations, a numerical algorithm is presented here to solve these equations in one dimension. This is followed by an overview of the Sod shock tube problem that includes the precise initial setup and the analytic solution. Finally, the analytic solution is compared with results from numerical simulations.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Modeling Magnetic Disk Wind State Transitions in Black Hole X-Ray Binaries

We analyze three prototypical black hole X-ray binaries, 4U 1630–472, GRO J1655–40, and H1743–322, in an effort to systematically understand the intrinsic state transition of the observed accretion disk winds between wind-on and wind-off states by utilizing state-of-the-art Chandra/HETGS archival data from multi-epoch observations. We apply our magnetically driven wind models in the context of magnetohydrodynamic(MHD)calculations to constrain(1)their global density slope(p),(2)their density (n17) at the foot point of the inner most launching radius, and(3)the abundances of heavier elements(AFe,S,Si). Incorporating the MHD winds into xstar photoionization calculations in a self-consistent manner, we create a library of synthetic absorption spectra given the observed X-ray continua. Our analysis clearly indicates a characteristic bimodal transition of multi-ion X-ray winds; i.e., the wind density gradient is found to steepen(fro mp∼1.2–1.4 to∼1.4–1.5)while its density normalization declines as the source transitions from the wind-onto the wind-off state. The model implies that the ionized wind remains physically present even in the wind-off state, despite its apparent absence in the observed spectra. Super solar abundances for heavier elements are also favored. Our global multi-ion wind models, taking into account soft X-ray ions as well as Fe K absorbers, show that the internal wind condition plays an important role in wind transitions besides photoionization changes. Simulated XRISM/Resolve and Athena/X-IFU spectra are presented to demonstrate a high fidelity of the multi-ion wind model for a better understanding of these powerful ionized winds in the coming decades

Keigo Fukumura↗

Taking control of compressible modes: bulk viscosity and the turbulent dynamo

Many polyatomic astrophysical plasmas are compressible and out of chemical and thermal equilibrium, introducing a bulk viscosity into the plasma via the internal degrees of freedom of the molecular composition, directly impacting the decay of compressible modes, $\mathrm{{\boldsymbol {\mathit {v}}}}_{\parallel }(\boldsymbol {k})$. This is especially important for small-scale, turbulent dynamo processes in the interstellar medium (ISM), which are known to be sensitive to the effects of compression. To control the viscous properties of $\mathrm{{\boldsymbol {\mathit {v}}}}_{\parallel }(\boldsymbol {k})$, we perform trans-sonic, visco-resistive dynamo simulations with additional bulk viscosity $\nu _{\text{bulk}}$, deriving a new $\nu _{\text{bulk}}$ Reynolds number $\text{Re}_{\text{bulk}}$, and viscous Prandtl number $\text{P}\nu \equiv \text{Re}_{\text{bulk}}/ \text{Re}_{\text{shear}}$, where $\text{Re}_{\text{shear}}$ is the shear viscosity Reynolds number. We derive a framework for decomposing $E_{\rm mag}$ growth rates into incompressible and compressible terms via orthogonal tensor decompositions of $\boldsymbol {\nabla }\otimes \mathrm{{\boldsymbol {\mathit {v}}}}$, where $\mathrm{{\boldsymbol {\mathit {v}}}}$ is the fluid velocity. We find that $\mathrm{{\boldsymbol {\mathit {v}}}}_{\parallel }(\boldsymbol {k})$ play a dual role, growing and decaying $E_{\rm mag}$, and that field-line stretching is the main driver of growth, even in compressible dynamos. In the absence of $\nu _{\text{bulk}}$ ($\text{P}\nu \rightarrow \infty$), $\mathrm{{\boldsymbol {\mathit {v}}}}_{\parallel }(\boldsymbol {k})$ pile up on small-scales, creating a spectral bottleneck, which disappears for $\text{P}\nu \approx 1$. As $\text{P}\nu$ decreases, $\mathrm{{\boldsymbol {\mathit {v}}}}_{\parallel }(\boldsymbol {k})$ are dissipated at increasingly larger scales, in turn suppressing incompressible modes through a coupling between high-k modes. We emphasize the importance of further understanding the role of $\nu _{\text{bulk}}$ in compressible astrophysical plasmas, which we estimate could be as strong as the shear viscosity in the cold ISM, and highlight that compressible direct numerical simulations without bulk viscosity have unresolved compressible mode dissipation scales.

MHD↗

Linear stability analysis via simulated annealing and accelerated relaxation

Simulated annealing (SA) is a kind of relaxation method for finding equilibria of Hamiltonian systems. A set of evolution equations is solved with SA, which is derived from the original Hamiltonian system so that the energy of the system changes monotonically while preserving Casimir invariants inherent to noncanonical Hamiltonian systems. The energy extremum reached by SA is an equilibrium. Since SA searches for an energy extremum, it can also be used for stability analysis when initiated from a state where a perturbation is added to an equilibrium. The procedure of the stability analysis is explained, and some examples are shown. Because the time evolution is computationally time consuming, efficient relaxation is necessary for SA to be practically useful. An acceleration method is developed by introducing time dependence in the symmetric kernel used in the double bracket, which is part of the SA formulation described here. An explicit formulation for low-beta reduced magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) in cylindrical geometry is presented. In conclusion, since SA for low-beta reduced MHD has two advection fields that relax, it is important to balance the orders of magnitude of these advection fields.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Integrated Pulse Detonation Propulsion and Magnetohydrodynamic Power

The prospects for realizing an integrated pulse detonation propulsion and magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) power system are examined. First, energy requirements for direct detonation initiation of various fuel-oxygen and fuel-air mixtures are deduced from available experimental data and theoretical models. Second, the pumping power requirements for effective chamber scavenging are examined through the introduction of a scavenging ratio parameter and a scavenging efficiency parameter. A series of laboratory experiments were carried out to investigate the basic engineering performance characteristics of a pulse detonation-driven MHD electric power generator. In these experiments, stoichiometric oxy-acetylene mixtures seeded with a cesium hydroxide/methanol spray were detonated at atmospheric pressure in a 1-m-long tube having an i.d. of 2.54 cm. Experiments with a plasma diagnostic channel attached to the end of the tube confirmed the attainment of detonation conditions (p2/p1 approximately 34 and D approximately 2,400 m/sec) and enabled the direct measurement of current density and electrical conductivity (approximately = 6 S/m) behind the detonation wave front, In a second set of experiments, a 30-cm-long continuous electrode Faraday channel, having a height of 2.54 cm and a width of 2 cm, was attached to the end of the tube using an area transition duct. The Faraday channel was inserted in applied magnetic fields of 0.6 and 0.95 T, and the electrodes were connected to an active loading circuit to characterize power extraction dependence on load impedance while also simulating higher effective magnetic induction. The experiments indicated peak power extraction at a load impedance between 5 and 10 Omega. The measured power density was in reasonable agreement with a simple electrodynamic model incorporating a correction for near-electrode potential losses. The time-resolved thrust characteristics of the system were also measured, and it was found that the NM interaction exerted a negligible influence on system thrust and that the measured I(sub sp) of the system (200 see) exceeded that computed for an equivalent nozzleless rocket (120 see).

Litchford, Ron J.↗