TristructuralIsotropic (TRISO) Fuel Qualification in the US
TRISO development background and particle design US DOE AGR Program Fuel fabrication and quality control Irradiation testing Post-irradiation examination and high-temperature safety testing
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
TRISO development background and particle design US DOE AGR Program Fuel fabrication and quality control Irradiation testing Post-irradiation examination and high-temperature safety testing
Major Objectives in FY22 for AGR-5/6/7 PIE, and AGR 3/4
AGR Program Overview and Current Activities Fission Product Transport Data Short-Lived Fission Product Release Fuel Performance Margin Data Oxidation Testing Data
Previously, samples of coarse grained (CG, grain diameter > 1 µm), ultra-fine grained (UFG, 1 µm> grain diameter> 100 nm), and nanocrystalline (NC, 100 nm> grain diameter) grade 91 steel were neutron irradiated in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) at Idaho National Laboratory (INL). Grade 91 is a ferritic/martensitic steel alloy with a nominal composition of Fe-9%Cr-1%Mo by weight, and it is being studied for applications in advanced nuclear reactor designs including as a fuel cladding material in gas cooled reactors. To assess the viability of this alloy for nuclear applications, the role of grain boundary size has not been sufficiently explored as a mechanism for developing radiation-tolerant materials. To achieve an UFG microstructure the material was processed using equal channel angular pressing (ECAP), and the NC microstructure was achieved through high pressure torsion (HPT). Such samples of various geometries for different types of characterization were irradiated to a dose of 6 displacements per atom (DPA) at separate temperature conditions of 300 °C and 500 °C. Thus, there were a total of 6 experimental conditions, three grain sizes (CG, UFG, and NC), each irradiated at two different temperature conditions (300 °C and 500 °C).
The DOE Advanced Reactor Technology program has supported knowledge preservation efforts to recover and preserve fuel data from the US sodium cooled fast reactor (SFR) program. Efforts have focused on establishing databases of experimental data generated during the Integral Fast Reactor program (at EBR-II, FFTF, and TREAT) as well as during related out-of-pile examinations of the fuel irradiated at EBR-II. The information in these databases is essential to support further development and licensing activities for advanced fast reactor designs. OPTD, a newly-created database of out-of-pile furnace transient tests on metallic fuel, includes records of 62 tests on irradiated fuel pins conducted in furnace apparatuses constructed in the Alpha-Gamma Hot Cell Facility at ANL. Record discovery is ongoing, and at present, the database includes hundreds of documents describing these tests and related results. Access is currently available to Department of Energy researchers and can be extended to members of industry and the public as the content is approved for distribution. This report describes the out-of-pile furnace testing program, the content available in the database, and the structure of the web-accessible interface.
The Material Management and Minimization Program (formerly known as the Reduced Enrichment for Research and Test Reactor Program) is responsible for converting research reactors that use highly enriched uranium (HEU) fuels to ones that use low-enriched uranium (LEU) fuels. As part of the development of LEU fuels, a variety of irradiation experiments are being conducted using the Advanced Test Reactor. In addition to the reactor tests, there is interest in generating information about the transient behavior of irradiated fuel plates. For example, it is of interest to determine the temperature at which a blister will form on the surface of a fuel plate, due to fission gas release from the fuel meat, for a particular fuel plate design. Since in-pile testing to determine the 'blister threshold' (the temperature where a blister forms on the surface of a fuel plate) in plate-type fuel is very difficult and expensive and has historically been deemed impractical for fuel qualification testing, an out-of-pile 'blister test' has been developed and employed. This post-irradiation blister anneal test was developed as a conservative simulation of in-pile behavior and has been routinely used for many research reactor fuel designs currently in use. In this test, the irradiated fuel plate is inserted into a furnace at a given temperature, soaked for a period of time, and removed for inspection. If no visible blisters appear, the furnace temperature is increased, and the plate is soaked and inspected again. This process continues until blisters are observed. Recently, a section from an irradiated U-7Mo dispersion fuel plate with Al-4043 matrix, which has a nominal composition of 4.81Si-0.20Fe-0.14Ti-0.16Cu-0.01Cr 0.01Mn-bal Al, was tested in a furnace located in the Hot Fuel Examination Facility, located at the Idaho National Laboratory, up to 500 deg. C, at which point blisters were observed on the surface of the fuel plate section. A sample near the blistered region of the fuel plate section was then characterized using scanning electron (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). This paper discusses the results of this characterization and how they compare to those generated for a similar sample characterized after fabrication but before irradiation and for a sample characterized after irradiation but before furnace testing. One goal of this work is to identify the changes in the microstructure during blister testing that contribute to the eventual release of fission gas that results in the development of blisters. SEM analysis of the furnace-tested sample showed that in some locations of the U-7Mo particles, Al-4043 matrix constituents (primarily Si) had penetrated the microstructure along grain boundaries. This provided potential pathways for increased fission gas migration in the fuel meat microstructure during the furnace heating process. Some attack of these boundaries was also observed in the as-fabricated U-7Mo/Al-4043 sample, but there appeared to be additional attack during the furnace annealing. Besides the changes observed in grain boundary features, the TEM analysis showed that the fission gas bubbles that are typically present in the intra-granular regions of the as-irradiated U-7Mo microstructure as a fission gas bubble superlattice had changed in size, morphology, and distribution. The result of this may be an increase in the mobility of the fission gas in intra-granular regions of the fuel. The complete implications of the changes in fission gas morphology and distribution in the fuel meat microstructure and their impact on blistering continues to be investigated. (authors)
This report contains the results of non-destructive examinations of Accident Tolerant Fuels 2 (ATF-2) rodlets irradiated in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) Loop 2A. The experiment is part of the U.S. Department of Energy Nuclear Technology Research and Development (NTRD) program’s Advanced Fuels Campaign (AFC). The rodlets were composed of UO2 pellets and Zr-4 cladding. The data have been collected to provide baseline PIE data to support future testing in TREAT and to have performance data against which the data of the ATF concepts can be compared directly. The analyses performed included: visual examinations, axial gamma scanning, neutron radiography and profilometry. All the data collected showed a performance consistent with expectations for this fuel system at low burnup.
VISION (VerifIable fuel cycle SImulatiON) is the Advanced Fuel Cycle Initiative’s and Global Nuclear Energy Partnership Program’s nuclear fuel cycle systems code designed to simulate the US commercial reactor fleet. The code is a dynamic stock and flow model that tracks the mass of materials at the isotopic level through the entire nuclear fuel cycle. As VISION is run, it calculates the decay of 70 isotopes including uranium, plutonium, minor actinides, and fission products. VISION.ECON is a sub-model of VISION that was developed to estimate fuel cycle and reactor costs. The sub-model uses the mass flows generated by VISION for each of the fuel cycle functions (referred to as modules) and calculates the annual cost based on cost distributions provided by the Advanced Fuel Cycle Cost Basis Report1. Costs are aggregated for each fuel cycle module, and the modules are aggregated into front end, back end, recycling, reactor, and total fuel cycle costs. The software also has the capability to perform system sensitivity analysis. This capability may be used to analyze the impacts on costs due to system uncertainty effects. This paper will provide a preliminary evaluation of the cost uncertainty affects attributable to 1) key reactor and fuel cycle system parameters and 2) scheduling variations. The evaluation will focus on the uncertainty on the total cost of electricity and fuel cycle costs. First, a single light water reactor (LWR) using mixed oxide fuel is examined to ascertain the effects of simple parameter changes. Three system parameters; burnup, capacity factor and reactor power are varied from nominal cost values and the affect on the total cost of electricity is measured. These simple parameter changes are measured in more complex scenarios 2-tier systems including LWRs with mixed fuel and fast recycling reactors using transuranic fuel. Other system parameters are evaluated and results will be presented in the paper. Secondly, the uncertainty due to variation in scheduling effects is evaluated. For example, economic impacts due to increased nuclear energy growth rates and speed-ups in deployment of fuel cycle facilities and fast reactors. Preliminary results show that significant variations in the costs of the scenarios can result from variations in burnup, capacity factor and reactor power. The paper will include new results from analysis of additional system variables and due to scheduling dynamics. Reference 1. Shropshire, D.E. et al, 2007, Advanced Fuel Cycle Cost Basis, INL/EXT-07-12107, April 2007.
The Department of Energy awarded Advanced Cooling Technologies, Inc. (ACT) an SBIR Phase II contract (#DE-SC0004729) to develop a high-temperature solar thermochemical reactor for syngas production using water and/or carbon dioxide as feedstocks. The technology aims to provide a renewable and sustainable alternative to fossil fuels, promote energy independence and mitigate adverse issues associated with climate change by essentially recycling carbon from carbon dioxide emitted by the combustion of hydrocarbon fuels. To commercialize the technology and drive down the cost of solar fuels, new advances are needed in materials development and reactor design, both of which are integral elements in this program.
The Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) Full-size Plate In Center Flux Trap Position (AFIP)-2 experiment was designed to evaluate the performance of monolithic fuels at a scale prototypic of research reactor fuel plates. Two qualified fueled plates were fabricated for the AFIP 2 experiment to be irradiated in the Idaho National Laboratory ATR. This report provides details of the fuel fabrication efforts, including material selection, fabrication processes, and fuel plate qualification.
To support the development of advanced low-enriched uranium for use in nuclear reactors, irradiation testing of U-Mo disk specimens was performed at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) to collect experimental irradiation data on this type of fuel at pressurized water reactor–relevant temperatures. U-Mo is a uranium alloy that has superior dimensional stability relative to alpha-phase uranium metal and has a substantially higher uranium density compared to UO 2 . U-Mo disks specimens were fabricated at Idaho National Laboratory and inserted into MiniFuel targets for HFIR irradiation. Three MiniFuel targets were successfully assembled, welded, tested, and delivered to HFIR, along with their quality assurance documentation. The targets were inserted into HFIR’s inner vertical experiment facility within the permanent beryllium reflector. Each target contains six disk specimens and will be irradiated in HFIR for three, four, and eight cycles, with target temperatures between 250 and 500°C. This report summarizes the experiment design, test matrix, pre-characterization of specimens, and experiment assembly.
This report describes the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL) work conducted for completion of the Thermal Hydraulics Methods (THM) Level 3 milestone THM.CLS.P15.10: BWR Full Fuel Assembly Testing and Validation. The extension of existing boiling closure designed for Pressurized Water Reactors (PWRs) to the high void fraction condition of Boiling Water Reactors (BWRs) is one of the challenges for Multiphase Computational Fluid Dynamics (M-CFD) applications. In the efforts aimed at developing the advanced boiling closure for BWRs, the baseline closure model, so-called ‘Zero’ closure, has been developed based on the GEN-I closure for PWRs which was used as a starting point. Since this simplest closure model is robust but does not contain any explicit description of the complex high void fraction mechanisms, the applicability of M-CFD needs to be evaluated before developing advanced closures for BWRs. To support this need, the high fidelity M-CFD simulation with Zero closure has been conducted for the BWR full fuel assembly. The capabilities of M-CFD with Zero closure were evaluated against the international OECD/NRC BFBT benchmark data. The scalability of the M-CFD application to the nuclear fuel assembly was demonstrated with the INL High Performance Computing (HPC) system. This report presents the recent view of the best practices on M-CFD for BWRs to provide a useful reference to identify and overcome common challenges in the M-CFD applications.
To obtain valuable data that will help in the design and commissioning of the Transformational Challenge Reactor, a series of graded, increasingly complex irradiation tests are planned that will demonstrate the feasibility of advanced manufactured reactor core components. In the first irradiation test, conventionally- fabricated uranium nitride tristructural isotropic (UN TRISO) fuel kernels will be embedded into compacts that are fabricated using advanced manufacturing methods. These compacts are to be irradiated at Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s Nuclear Reactor Laboratory and Idaho National Laboratory’s Transient Reactor Test Facility. This report presents the characteristics of the proposed samples and experiments.
One of the major research and development (R&D) areas under the Fuel Cycle Research and Development (FCRD) program is advanced fuels development. The Advanced Fuels Campaign (AFC) has the responsibility to develop advanced fuel technologies for the Department of Energy (DOE) using a science-based approach focusing on developing a microstructural understanding of nuclear fuels and materials. Accomplishments made during fiscal year (FY 20) 2011 are highlighted in this report, which focuses on completed work and results. The process details leading up to the results are not included; however, the technical contact is provided for each section. The order of the accomplishments in this report is consistent with the AFC work breakdown structure (WBS).
A novel dry treatment process for used nuclear fuel (UNF) using nitrogen dioxide is being developed to remove volatile and semi-volatile fission products and convert the monolithic fuel material to a fine powder suitable as a feed to many different separations processes. The process may be considered an advanced form of voloxidation, which was envisioned to remove tritium from the fuel prior to introduction of the fuel into the aqueous separations systems, where subsequent separation of tritium from the water would be difficult and expensive. The product from NO{sub 2} reaction can be selectively chosen to be U{sub 3}O{sub 8}, UO{sub 3}, or a nitrate by adjusting the processing conditions; all products are generated at temperatures lower than those used in standard voloxidation. All the fundamental tenants of the process have been successfully demonstrated as a proof of principle, and many aspects have been corroborated multiple times at laboratory scale. The goal of this roadmap is to define the activities required to develop the process to a technology-readiness level sufficient to an engineering-scale implementation. (authors)
NRIC is developing the Demonstration of Microreactor Experiments (DOME) test bed at the Idaho National Laboratory (INL) Materials and Fuels Complex (MFC): to allow for testing of advanced reactors in support of future licensing and commercial operations. One such need is a neutron and photon radiation shielding system to protect personnel and equipment from harsh neutron and photon fluxes during reactor operations and post shut down operations, disassembly, and decommissioning.
The Global Threat Reduction initiative (GTRI) was established by the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) in 2004. One of the highlights of the program is to convert research and test reactors at home and abroad from Highly Enriched Uranium (HEU) to Low Enriched Uranium (LEU) fuels. By switching directly from HEU to LEU, an LEU reactor produces fewer neutrons than an HEU reactor and in some cases; a direct switch from HEU to LEU results in the reactor being unable to achieve criticality. Under certain circumstances, criticality is achieved and the original neutron fluxes are restored with LEU fuel by adding more fuel elements to the core. Not all reactors, exemplified by the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) at the Idaho National Lab (INL), have the luxury of simply adding more fuel to the core. In such cases, entirely new designs must be created and tested. The ATR utilizes plate type fuel. During the design and testing of the ATR fuel, vortex shedding was identified as potential source for experiment and fuel failure. For fuel conversion, elements must be tested in pile prior to the qualification of the new fuel design. For some test elements, the primary test plate is followed by a secondary handling plate. It is known that objects downstream influence the vortex shedding. While vortex shedding is an important and well-studied phenomenon, not only in the context of nuclear engineering, but in fields as diverse as aeronautical engineering and biology, there is a significant gap in the understanding of vortex shedding in regards to two bluff bodies in line direct line with one another. The study provides a scaling analysis of the frequency of vortex shedding for plates in line. The scaling analysis is then compared to numerical simulation of two in line plates. The study provided a scaling analysis and suggested parameter for determining the expected trends in the Strouhal number for a plate with some object downstream. The analysis made the consideration of differing length scales as the cause for a reduction in vortex shedding frequency as well as looked at the potential impact of boundary layer growth on vortex shedding for a flat plate. The comparison between the expected scaling and numerical data was less than ideal, but there are several potential causes. One of the biggest issues with the comparison is the uncertainty associated with the defect velocity. The frequency was well established in several cases, but the velocity was not always well established resulting in a larger uncertainty. In the cases where the velocity was near zero (i.e. b/d = 0.5), the uncertainty dominated since the corrected Strouhal number is divided by the defect velocity. The Reynolds numbers were not incredibly large, ranging from 350-1600. The low Reynolds numbers potentially undermine the principle assumption made in the scaling analysis, i.e. Reynolds number is negligibly small. Additionally, the exact definition of the 'reduced velocity' was never explicitly defined, merely inferred from the assumption that the x length scale and y length scale were in fact different. Another potential problem is the defect velocities in the lower Reynolds number cases were not much smaller than the free stream velocity. Further work needs to be done at higher Reynolds numbers and with more data points to ensure the assumptions made are valid as well as confirm the accuracy of the scaled relationship. (authors)
The Global Threat Reduction initiative (GTRI) was established by the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) in 2004. One of the highlights of the program is to convert research and test reactors at home and abroad from Highly Enriched Uranium (HEU) to Low Enriched Uranium (LEU) fuels. By switching directly from HEU to LEU, an LEU reactor produces fewer neutrons than an HEU reactor, and in some cases, a direct switch from HEU to LEU results in the reactor being unable to achieve criticality. Under certain circumstances, criticality is achieved and the original neutron fluxes are restored with LEU fuel by adding more fuel elements to the core. Not all reactors, exemplified by the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) at the Idaho National Lab (INL), have the luxury of simply adding more fuel to the core. In such cases, entirely new designs must be created and tested. The ATR utilizes plate type fuel. During the design and testing of the ATR fuel, flow induced vibrations were identified as potential source for experiment and fuel failure. Flow induced vibrations are problematic to solve because both the frequency of excitation and the modal frequencies of the object need to be determined. For the frequency of the object the frequency is often determined, either theoretically or experimentally without any influence of fluid. When a fluid is introduced, the fundamental frequency of an object can be greatly reduced allowing for resonance between the excitation frequency and the fundamental frequency of the plate. The consequence of such resonance is often failure of the component. Current methods for determining the frequency of a body immersed in a fluid requires the use of multi-physics software in order to determine (if at all possible) the frequency of the object. The work herein provides an alternative means of calculating the frequency of a plate by combining plate frequency theory to determine the added mass on the plate when in the presence of narrow channels. (authors)