Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Complexity theory”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,099 records · Page 61

An effective matrix model for dynamical end of the world branes in Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity

We study Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity with dynamical end of the world branes in asymptotically nearly AdS2 spacetimes. We quantize this theory in Lorentz signature, and compute the Euclidean path integral summing over topologies including dynamical branes. The latter will be seen to exactly match with a modification of the SSS matrix model. The resolution of UV divergences in the gravitational instantons involving the branes will lead us to understand the matrix model interpretation of the Wilsonian effective theory perspective on the gravitational theory. We complete this modified SSS matrix model nonperturbatively by extending the integration contour of eigenvalues into the complex plane. Furthermore, we give a new interpretation of other phases in such matrix models. We derive an effective W(Φ) dilaton gravity, which exhibits similar physics semiclassically. In the limit of a large number of flavors of branes, the effective extremal entropy S0,eff has the form of counting the states of these branes.

2D Gravity↗

Measurement of the polarisation of single top quarks and antiquarks produced in the $t$-channel at $ \sqrt{s} $ = 13 TeV and bounds on the $tWb$ dipole operator from the ATLAS experiment

A simultaneous measurement of the three components of the top-quark and top-antiquark polarisation vectors in t-channel single-top-quark production is presented. This analysis is based on data from proton–proton collisions at a centre-of-mass energy of 13 TeV corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 139 fb –1 , collected with the ATLAS detector at the LHC. Selected events contain exactly one isolated electron or muon, large missing transverse momentum and exactly two jets, one being b-tagged. Stringent selection requirements are applied to discriminate t-channel single-top-quark events from the background contributions. The top-quark and top-antiquark polarisation vectors are measured from the distributions of the direction cosines of the charged-lepton momentum in the top-quark rest frame. The three components of the polarisation vector for the selected top-quark event sample are P x' = 0.01 ± 0.18, P y' = –0.029 ± 0.027, P z' = 0.91 ± 0.10 and for the top-antiquark event sample they are P x' = –0.02 ± 0.20, P y' = –0.007 ± 0.051, P z' = 0.79 ± 0.16. Normalised differential cross-sections corrected to a fiducial region at the stable-particle level are presented as a function of the charged-lepton angles for top-quark and top-antiquark events inclusively and separately. These measurements are in agreement with Standard Model predictions. The angular differential cross-sections are used to derive bounds on the complex Wilson coefficient of the dimension-six O tW operator in the framework of an effective field theory. The obtained bounds are C tW ϵ [–0.9, 1.4] and C itW ϵ [–0.8, 0.2], both at 95% confidence level.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Competing Radical and Molecular Channels in the Unimolecular Dissociation of Methylformate

The thermal dissociation of methylformate has been characterized by numerous experimental and theoretical studies that all seem to agree that the lowest energetically accessible process is a 3-center H-atom transfer that leads to the molecular products CH3OH 3 OH + CO. However, these literature studies seem to be at odds with regards to the role of other competing molecular eliminations and bond-fission processes and therefore a complete and resolved mechanistic picture of methylformate thermal dissociation still eludes us. In this work, we have performed high-level electronic structure theory calculations to characterize the energetics of other overlooked molecular and radical processes that can originate on the complex CH3OCHO 3 OCHO potential energy surface (PES). The present calculations do indeed confirm that the lowest energy process accessible on this PES is molecular elimination to form CH3OH 3 OH + CO. However, unlike prior theoretical studies, the present calculations reveal that the second lowest energy process is a 5-center concerted elimination process that leads to the direct formation of H2 2 + CH2O 2 O + CO. We also note that HCO2 2 from the lowest-lying bond fission has two energetically comparable electronic states (of 2 B 2 and 2 A 1 symmetry). Furthermore, the barrier for H-atom migration of CH3OCHO 3 OCHO to form the carbene (CH3OCOH) 3 OCOH) is similar to that for the direct 4-center elimination process leading to CH2O 2 O + CH2O 2 O characterized in prior literature studies. Radical and molecular pathways to CH3 3 + HOCO and CH4 4 + CO2 2 can also be facilitated from this carbene. Master equation calculations were performed to characterize the competition between the various molecular and radical processes on this more elaborate CH3OCHO 3 OCHO PES. The results of the present theoretical analyses were used to resolve outstanding questions on the role of secondary radical- initiated reactions in characterizing prior literature experimental studies.

Chemical Kinetics↗

Hydrated Anions: From Clusters to Bulk Solution with Quasi-Chemical Theory

The interactions of hydrated ions with molecular and macromolecular solution and interface partners are strong on a chemical energy scale. Here we recount the foremost ab initio theory for the evaluation of the hydration free energies of ions, namely, quasi-chemical theory (QCT). We focus on anions, particularly halides but also the hydroxide anion, because they have been outstanding challenges for all theories. For example, this work supports understanding the high selectivity for F – over Cl – in fluoride-selective ion channels despite the identical charge and the size similarity of these ions. QCT is built by the identification of inner-shell clusters, separate treatment of those clusters, and then the integration of those results into the broader-scale solution environment. Recent work has focused on a close comparison with mass-spectrometric measurements of ion-hydration equilibria. We delineate how ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) calculations on ion-hydration clusters, elementary statistical thermodynamics, and electronic structure calculations on cluster structures sampled from the AIMD calculations obtain just the free energies extracted from the cluster experiments. That theory–experiment comparison has not been attempted before the work discussed here, but the agreement is excellent with moderate computational effort. This agreement reinforces both theory and experiment and provides a numerically accurate inner-shell contribution to QCT. The inner-shell complexes involving heavier halides display strikingly asymmetric hydration clusters. Asymmetric hydration structures can be problematic for the evaluation of the QCT outer-shell contribution with the polarizable continuum model (PCM). Nevertheless, QCT provides a favorable setting for the exploitation of PCM when the inner-shell material shields the ion from the outer solution environment. For the more asymmetrically hydrated, and thus less effectively shielded, heavier halide ions clustered with waters, the PCM is less satisfactory. We therefore investigate an inverse procedure in which the inner-shell structures are sampled from readily available AIMD calculations on the bulk solutions. This inverse procedure is a remarkable improvement; our final results are in close agreement with a standard tabulation of hydration free energies, and the final composite results are independent of the coordination number on the chemical energy scale of relevance, as they should be. Finally, a comparison of anion hydration structure in clusters and bulk solutions from AIMD simulations emphasize some differences: the asymmetries of bulk solution inner-shell structures are moderated compared with clusters but are still present, and inner hydration shells fill to slightly higher average coordination numbers in bulk solution than in clusters.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Guest-Host Interactions in Clathrate Hydrates: Benchmark MP2 and CCSD(T)/CBS Binding Energies of CH4, CO2 and H2S in (H2O)20 Cages

We present benchmark binding energies of naturally occurring gas molecules CH4, CO2, and H2S in the small cage, namely the pentagonal dodecahedron (512) (H2O)20, which is one of the constituent cages of the 3 major lattices (structures I, II and H) of clathrate hydrates. These weak interactions require higher levels of electron correlation and converge slowly with increasing basis set to the Complete Basis Set (CBS) limit, necessitating the use of large basis sets up to the augcc- pV5Z and subsequent correction for Basis Set Superposition Error (BSSE). For the host hollow (H2O)20 cages we have identified a most stable isomer with binding energy of -200.8 ± 2.1 kcal/mol at the CCSD(T)/CBS limit (-199.2 ± 0.5 kcal/mol at the MP2/CBS limit). Additionally, we report converged second order Moller-Plesset (MP2) CBS binding energies for the encapsulation of guests in the (H2O)20 cage of -4.3 ± 0.1 for CH4@(H2O)20, -6.6 ± 0.1 for CO2@(H2O)20 and -8.5 ± 0.1 kcal/mol for H2S@(H2O)20, respectively. For CH4@(H2O)20, exhibiting the weakest encapsulation affinity among the three, we report CCSD(T)/aug-cc-pVTZ binding energies and, based on them, a CCSD(T)/CBS estimate of -4.75 ± 0.1 kcal/mol. To the best of our knowledge, the CCSD(T)/aug-cc-pVTZ calculation for CH4@(H2O)20 is the largest one reported to date (168 valence electrons, 1978 basis functions and the correlation of 84 doubly occupied and 1873 virtual orbitals) and required a scalable implementation of the (T) module on 6144 nodes (350208 cores) of the “Cori” supercomputer at the National Energy Research Supercomputing Center (NERSC) for a total execution time of 195 minutes (for the (T) part). These efficient scalable implementations of highly correlated methods offer the capability to obtain long-lasting benchmarks of intermolecular interactions in complex systems. They also provide a path towards parametrizing classical potentials needed to study the dynamical and transport properties in these complex systems as well as assess the accuracy of lower scaling electronic structure methods such as Density Functional Theory (DFT) and MP2 including its spin-biased variants.

Heindel, Joseph↗

Electrochemical Removal of Se(IV) from Wastewater Using RuO2‑Based Catalysts

The removal of selenite (SeO32-) from water is challenging due to the risk of secondary pollutants. To address this, we developed RuO2-based nanocatalysts on the titanium plate (RuO2/TP) for direct electrochemical reduction of Se(IV) to elemental selenium [Se(0)]. Optimizing Sn doping in RuO2 nanoparticles to induce charge redistribution enabled the Ru0.9Sn0.1Ox/TP catalyst to achieve ∼90% Se(IV) removal across concentrations of 0.1, 1, and 10 mM at -2 mA cm-2 over 8 h, outperforming undoped RuO2/TP. Furthermore, Ru0.9Sn0.1Ox/TP also maintained ∼90% removal efficiency in 1 mM of Se(IV) solutions containing competitive anions (0.5 M Cl-, 0.1 M SO42-, 0.01 M NO3-, and their mixtures), demonstrating suitability for complex wastewater treatment. Importantly, the catalysts were recyclable, with no observable contamination introduced into the solution. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations suggest that Sn doping effectively reduces the energy barrier for the reduction of Se(IV) to Se(0).

Hao, Shaoyun↗

Anion Association Strength as a Unifying Descriptor for the Reversibility of Divalent Metal Deposition in Nonaqueous Electrolytes

Developing next-generation battery chemistries that move beyond traditional Li-ion systems is critical to enabling transformative advances in electrified transportation and grid-level energy storage. Here, we provide the first evidence for common descriptors for improved reversibility of metal plating/stripping in nonaqueous electrolytes for multivalent ion batteries. Focusing first on the specific role of chloride (Cl – ) in promoting electrochemical reversibility in multivalent systems, rotating disk (RDE) and ring-disk electrode (RRDE) investigations were performed utilizing a variety of divalent cations (Mg 2+ , Zn 2+ , and Cu 2+ ) and the bis-(trifluoromethane sulfonyl) imide (TFSI – ) anion. By introducing varying concentrations of Cl – , a cooperative effect is observed between TFSI – and Cl – that yields the more reversible behavior of mixed electrolytes relative to electrolytes containing only TFSI – . This effect is shown to be general for Mg, Zn, and Cu electrodeposition, and mechanistic understanding of the role of Cl – in improving reversibility of TFSI-based electrolytes is obtained through the combination of R(R)DE experimental results and density functional theory (DFT) evaluation of the redox activity and thermodynamic stability of various TFSI- and Cl-based solution complexes of metal ions. The cooperative anion effect is further generalized to other mixed-anion systems, where systematic variations in anion association strength predicted from DFT (i.e., Cl – > OTf – ≈ TFSI – > BF 4 – > PF 6 – ) yield corresponding trends in redox potentials and improvements of ≥200 mV in the reversibility of metal deposition/dissolution. These results identify anion association strength as a common descriptor for the reversibility of divalent metal anodes and suggest a set of general design principles for developing new electrolytes with improved activity and stability.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Bridging the Gap in Carbon Free Iron Making: How Hydrogen Affects the Reduction of Iron Ore between 900 and 1590 °C

Hydrogen-based reduction of iron ore for iron and steel production has emerged as a promising alternative to coal and natural gas. Unlike other hydrogen-based iron ore reduction studies, this research focuses on a wide temperature range across 900–1590 °C, encompassing reduction in solid, mixed, and liquid (slag) phases. For a 20 min exposure to hydrogen, the reduction degree increased monotonically from ∼35% at 900 °C to >90% at 1550 °C, except between 1100 °C and 1400 °C, where it stagnated ∼60%. This experimental work challenges the widely accepted notion that higher temperatures enhance the reduction process. Instead, it reveals an overlooked kinetic bottleneck, suggesting complex thermodynamic and mass transfer limitations influenced by phase transformations, diffusion barriers, and microstructural changes. Density functional theory-based molecular dynamics simulations indicate that oxygen diffusivity in BCC iron is 3.88 × 10 –5 cm 2 /s which is ∼5–10 times higher than that in FCC iron. This study reports that this stagnant reduction degree in the mixed solid–liquid phase is due to competition of multiple mechanisms, such as surface- and bulk-diffusion, pore collapse mechanisms, and crystallographic transitions.

08 HYDROGEN↗

Towards complete assignment of the infrared spectrum of the protonated water cluster H + (H 2 O) 21

The spectroscopic features of protonated water species in dilute acid solutions have been long sought after for understanding the microscopic behavior of the proton in water with gas-phase water clusters H + (H 2 O) n extensively studied as bottom-up model systems. We present a new protocol for the calculation of the infrared (IR) spectra of complex systems, which combines the fragment-based Coupled Cluster method and anharmonic vibrational quasi-degenerate perturbation theory, and demonstrate its accuracy towards the complete and accurate assignment of the IR spectrum of the H + (H 2 O) 21 cluster. The site-specific IR spectral signatures reveal two distinct structures for the internal and surface four-coordinated water molecules, which are ice-like and liquid-like, respectively. The effect of inter-molecular interaction between water molecules is addressed, and the vibrational resonance is found between the O-H stretching fundamental and the bending overtone of the nearest neighboring water molecule. The revelation of the spectral signature of the excess proton offers deeper insight into the nature of charge accommodation in the extended hydrogen-bonding network underpinning this aqueous cluster.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Atomic scale crystal field mapping of polar vortices in oxide superlattices

Polar vortices in oxide superlattices exhibit complex polarization topologies. Using a combination of electron energy loss near-edge structure analysis, crystal field multiplet theory, and first-principles calculations, we probe the electronic structure within such polar vortices in [(PbTiO 3 ) 16 /(SrTiO 3 ) 16 ] superlattices at the atomic scale. The peaks in Ti L-edge spectra shift systematically depending on the position of the Ti 4+ cations within the vortices i.e., the direction and magnitude of the local dipole. First-principles computation of the local projected density of states on the Ti 3d orbitals, together with the simulated crystal field multiplet spectra derived from first principles are in good agreement with the experiments.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Stochastic density functional theory: Real- and energy-space fragmentation for noise reduction

Stochastic density functional theory (sDFT) is becoming a valuable tool for studying ground-state properties of extended materials. The computational complexity of describing the Kohn-Sham orbitals is replaced by introducing a set of random (stochastic) orbitals leading to linear and often sub-linear scaling of certain ground-state observables at the account of introducing a statistical error. Schemes to reduce the noise are essential, for example, for determining the structure using the forces obtained from sDFT. Recently, we have introduced two embedding schemes to mitigate the statistical fluctuations in the electron density and resultant forces on the nuclei. Both techniques were based on fragmenting the system either in real space or slicing the occupied space into energy windows, allowing for a significant reduction in the statistical fluctuations. For chemical accuracy, further reduction of the noise is required, which could be achieved by increasing the number of stochastic orbitals. However, the convergence is relatively slow as the statistical error scales as 1 / N χ according to the central limit theorem, where N χ is the number of random orbitals. In this paper, we combined the embedding schemes mentioned above and introduced a new approach that builds on overlapped fragments and energy windows. The new approach significantly lowers the noise for ground-state properties, such as the electron density, total energy, and forces on the nuclei, as demonstrated for a G-center in bulk silicon.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Nonadiabatic Molecular Dynamics Simulations Based on Time-Dependent Density Functional Tight-Binding Method

Nonadiabatic excited-state molecular dynamics underpin many photophysical and photochemical phenomena, such as exciton dynamics, charge separation and transport. In this work, we present an efficient nonadiabatic molecular dynamic (NAMD) simulation method based on time-dependent density functional tight-binding (TDDFTB) theory. Specifically, the adiabatic electronic structure, an essential NAMD input, is described at the TDDFTB level. Here, the nonadiabatic effects originating from the coupled motions of electrons and nuclei are treated by the trajectory surface hopping algorithm. To improve the computational efficiency, nonadiabatic couplings between excited states within the TDDFTB method are derived and implemented using an analytical approach. Further, the time-dependent nonadiabatic coupling scalars are calculated based on the overlap between molecular orbitals rather than the Slater determinants to speed up the simulations. In addition, the electronic decoherence scheme and a state reassigned unavoided crossings algorithm, which has been implemented in the NEXMD software, are used to improve the accuracy of the simulated dynamics and handle trivial unavoided crossings. Finally, the photoinduced nonadiabatic dynamics of a benzene molecule are simulated to demonstrate our implementation. The results for excited state NAMD simulations of benzene molecule based on TDDFTB method compare well that obtained with numerically expensive time-dependent density functional theory. The proposed methodology provides an attractive theoretical simulation tool for predicting the photophysical and photochemical properties of complex materials.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Origin of the “odd” behavior in the ultraviolet photochemistry of ozone

Significance This study solves a 30-y mystery about the origin of dramatic oscillations in the quantum product states of 16 O 3 upon photodissociation. Ozone is a key component of the atmosphere and undergoes complex cycles of formation and destruction by photodissociation and reaction. These dynamics are a rich proving ground for theories of quantum reaction dynamics as well as subtleties such as nuclear spin-statistics and symmetry. A previous theory constructed to explain the observed oscillations, although plausible, was not fully consistent with experimental measurements. Our quantum model and calculations show conclusively the origin of the effect, and match new more detailed experiments.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Stochastic density functional theory combined with Langevin dynamics for warm dense matter

Here, this study overviews and extends a recently developed stochastic finite-temperature Kohn-Sham density functional theory to study warm dense matter using Langevin dynamics, specifically under periodic boundary conditions. The method's algorithmic complexity exhibits nearly linear scaling with system size and is inversely proportional to the temperature. Additionally, a linear-scaling stochastic approach is introduced to assess the Kubo-Greenwood conductivity, demonstrating exceptional stability for dc conductivity. Utilizing the developed tools, we investigate the equation of state, radial distribution, and electronic conductivity of hydrogen at a temperature of 30 000 K. As for the radial distribution functions, we reveal a transition of hydrogen from gaslike to liquidlike behavior as its density exceeds 4 g/cm 3 . As for the electronic conductivity as a function of the density, we identified a remarkable isosbestic point at frequencies around 7 eV, which may be an additional signature of a gas-liquid transition in hydrogen at 30 000 K.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Materials genome innovation for computational software (magics) center

Functional layered material (LM) architectures will dominate nanomaterials science in this century. We have developed theory, modeling, simulation, and software and data tools that enhance understanding and AI guide synthesis, enable characterization of complex structures, and improve capabilities in the predictive design and growth of LMs. Research at the Center has focused on: Computational synthesis and characterization: AI guided synthesis and experimental synthesis of stacked LMs with tailored properties via optimized chemical vapor deposition (CVD) growth and liquid-phase exfoliation; study defects, edges, grain boundaries, wrinkling of atomic layers and their effects on chemical, mechanical, electrical, and optical properties. Far-from-equilibrium processes: Joint experimental and simulation based probe of electronic processes with NAQMD and ultrafast X-ray free-electron laser (XFEL) and ultrafast electron diffraction (UED) facilities at Stanford. Experimentally validate NAQMD by ultrafast electron diffraction and X-ray spectroscopy studies of structural and excited state dynamics, shape fluctuations, and phonon dynamics. Scalable software: Simulation engines for desktop-to-exascale platforms using low-overhead, linear-scaling QMD algorithms; divide-conquer-recombine NAQMD with electronic excitations; extended-Lagrangian reactive molecular dynamics (RMD), machine learning (ML) based neural-network quantum molecular dynamics (NNQMD), and super-state accelerated molecular dynamics (AMD) and kinetic Monte Carlo codes; thermal and electrical transport software; and design 3D architectures of LMs with desired functionality using scalable software. Distribution of software and data, and training: Software and simulation-experimental data generated within the Center are distributed to the materials science community via Berkeley Materials Project (MP) framework. We have also organized three workshops for software distribution and training at USC (Nov. 2017, Mar. 2018) and Gaithersburg, MD (Nov. 2018) to train researchers, with the last one in focused on underrepresented groups, in collaboration with Howard University which is one of the largest HBCUs. The Center supported a total of 46 personnel and 6 undergraduate students. These include 14 faculty, 11 postdoctoral research associates, 20 graduate research assistants, and mentored 6 undergraduate students. This resulted in the publications of 63 research papers that include 46 publications on Reactive and Quantum Dynamics Simulations, 13 publications on Machine Learning for Quantum Materials, and 4 publications on Quantum Computing.

2D Materials↗

Implications of Microstructure in Helium-Implanted Nanocrystalline Metals

Helium bubbles are known to form in nuclear reactor structural components when displacement damage occurs in conjunction with helium exposure and/or transmutation. If left unchecked, bubble production can cause swelling, blistering, and embrittlement, all of which substantially degrade materials and—moreover—diminish mechanical properties. On the mission to produce more robust materials, nanocrystalline (NC) metals show great potential and are postulated to exhibit superior radiation resistance due to their high defect and particle sink densities; however, much is still unknown about the mechanisms of defect evolution in these systems under extreme conditions. Here, the performances of NC nickel (Ni) and iron (Fe) are investigated under helium bombardment via transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Bubble density statistics are measured as a function of grain size in specimens implanted under similar conditions. While the overall trends revealed an increase in bubble density up to saturation in both samples, bubble density in Fe was over 300% greater than in Ni. To interrogate the kinetics of helium diffusion and trapping, a rate theory model is developed that substantiates that helium is more readily captured within grains in helium-vacancy complexes in NC Fe, whereas helium is more prone to traversing the grain matrices and migrating to GBs in NC Ni. Our results suggest that (1) grain boundaries can affect bubble swelling in grain matrices significantly and can have a dominant effect over crystal structure, and (2) an NC-Ni-based material can yield superior resistance to irradiation-induced bubble growth compared to an NC-Fe-based material and exhibits high potential for use in extreme environments where swelling due to He bubble formation is of significant concern.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Shield weight optimization using Monte Carlo transport calculations

Outlines are given of the theory used in FASTER-3 Monte Carlo computer program for the transport of neutrons and gamma rays in complex geometries. The code has the additional capability of calculating the minimum weight layered unit shield configuration which will meet a specified dose rate constraint. It includes the treatment of geometric regions bounded by quadratic and quardric surfaces with multiple radiation sources which have a specified space, angle, and energy dependence. The program calculates, using importance sampling, the resulting number and energy fluxes at specified point, surface, and volume detectors. Results are presented for sample problems involving primary neutron and both primary and secondary photon transport in a spherical reactor shield configuration. These results include the optimization of the shield configuration.

Jordan, T. M.↗

Scattering by spheres with nonisotropic refractive indices

Experimental scattering results using a microwave analog technique are described. Artificially constructed axially symmetric spheres with a graphite-like fine-layered composite structure and anisotropic refractive indices were employed to aid high-precision measurements of forward scattering under stable conditions (temperature, physical dimensions, electronic conditions) and to facilitate studies of the extinction and polarization of light by graphite particles in interstellar space. A theoretical approximation utilizing Mie theory for spheres with suitable orientation-dependent refractive indices is applied to account for changes in the complex forward-scattering amplitudes and phase in response to target orientation. The methods are extended to the full range of scattering angles, from the forward direction continuously to about 165 deg and at 180 deg. Agreement between experiment and prediction is close when the symmetry axis is parallel to the polarization.

Wang, R. T.↗