Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “reasoning”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,081 records · Page 60

Local Radiation Shielding Design Methodology

The NSLS-II accelerators are housed within a radiation enclosure of normal concrete (and in some places high density concrete) that has been designed to reduce the radiation generated from an assumed operational beam loss or bulk shielding current (BCS) from each accelerator. The beam loss model used to estimate the thickness of this bulk shielding, assumed a beam energy at the expected operating energy and a current loss based on reasonable assumptions for the fraction of the expected operating current. The thickness of the shield was determined to be the amount required to reduce the radiation outside the shield to a maximum dose rate of <0.5mrem/hr. for occupied areas for these normal operational losses. These assumed beam losses and the bulk shielding thicknesses required are given in reference [1]. Abnormal operating conditions generating higher than normal beam losses must also be considered, and additional engineering controls will be required depending on the magnitude of the radiation levels generated during the abnormal condition. Additional local shielding subject to configuration control may be utilized to reduce radiation levels associated with these abnormal loss conditions. Interlocked area radiation monitors are another means to prevent continued operation with higher than an acceptable level. The NSLS-II Shielding Policy requires that an engineered system be utilized to mitigate an abnormal condition producing radiation levels greater than 100 mR/h, and that two systems are required if the projected radiation levels during a fault condition are > 2000 mR/h. It is intended that shielding limits the dose rate to < 0.5 mR/h in occupied areas for normal operational losses, and the combination of administrative and engineered controls for abnormal losses will maintain radiation exposure to trained personnel working at the NSLS-II facility to as low as reasonably achievable. It is anticipated that all individual exposures will be well within the planned administrative control level of 100mrem/year. This technical note presents the method used to identify these potential high beam loss locations, evaluate the potential radiation risk these losses create outside the enclosure shield and the design process that specifies the required local radiation shielding needed to reduce this risk below the maximum dose rate of the bulk shield design, listed above. If shielding can’t be adequately provided or if other fault initiated losses could occur, then the necessary engineering controls will be indicated that will limit the energy, current or duration of the beam transport that constitute this high beam loss risk.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Sampling for Confidence: Guidance for Evaluating the Quality of Canister Sampling Plans

There is a need for an inspection frequency that demonstrates reasonable assurance that the confinement function of dual-purpose-canisters (DPCs) is maintained as these DPCs are returned to storage service following transportation. The DPCs contain spent fuel from shutdown reactor sites. The currently-proposed 100% DPC inspection frequency is overly conservative and unnecessary to demonstrate reasonable assurance that the confinement function of all DPCs is maintained for return to storage service. Testing all DPCs does not appropriately reflect the very low risk of leakage (i.e., low probability based on design and low consequences based on analysis). Currently, there are 1066 DPCs forecast to be loaded at reactor sites which either are shutdown or plan to cease operations by 2025. These DPCs may be transported by rail in sets of 3 to 5 DPCs per shipment. Assuming each rail consist originates at a single reactor site, an alternative proposal to test one canister/consist/site would result in 356 to 214 canisters, respectively, being tested given the population of 1,066 canisters This Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL) report outlines statistically-based, random sampling plans that provide guidance on the number of samples of these canisters that are needed to establish bounds on the quality of the outcome of such sampling. The quality of each proposed sampling plan is expressed in the form of a statement that the number of undetected, unacceptable canisters in the population is less than some number, call it D, at a high level of confidence. In addition, evaluations using a similar approach for random sampling at the proposed levels of 214 and 356 canisters are provided.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Sampling for Confidence: Guidance for Evaluating the Quality of Canister Sampling Plans

There is a need for an inspection frequency that demonstrates reasonable assurance that the confinement function of dual-purpose-canisters (DPCs) is maintained as these DPCs are returned to storage service following transportation. The DPCs contain spent fuel from shutdown reactor sites. The currently-proposed 100% DPC inspection frequency is overly conservative and unnecessary to demonstrate reasonable assurance that the confinement function of all DPCs is maintained for return to storage service. Testing all DPCs does not appropriately reflect the very low risk of leakage (i.e., low probability based on design and low consequences based on analysis). Currently, there are 1066 DPCs forecast to be loaded at reactor sites which either are shutdown or plan to cease operations by 2025. These DPCs may be transported by rail in sets of 3 to 5 DPCs per shipment. Assuming each rail consist originates at a single reactor site, an alternative proposal to test one canister/consist/site would result in 356 to 214 canisters, respectively, being tested given the population of 1,066 canisters This Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL) report outlines statistically-based, random sampling plans that provide guidance on the number of samples of these canisters that are needed to establish bounds on the quality of the outcome of such sampling. The quality of each proposed sampling plan is expressed in the form of a statement that the number of undetected, unacceptable canisters in the population is less than some number, call it D, at a high level of confidence. In addition, evaluations using a similar approach for random sampling at the proposed levels of 214 and 356 canisters are provided. This is a technical report that does not take into account the contractual limitations under the Standard Contract for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste (Standard Contract) (10 CFR Part 961). Under the provisions of the Standard Contract, DOE does not consider spent nuclear fuel in multi-assembly canisters to be an acceptable waste form, absent a mutually agreed upon contract amendment. To the extent discussions or recommendations in this report conflict with the provisions of the Standard Contract, the Standard Contract provisions prevail.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Rapid Crossing of a Resonance During Tune Modulation by Synchrotron Oscillations

It had become a standard practice to constrain the particle’s tune footprint while designing the ring lattice so that the particle tunes fit between harmful resonances that limit ring dynamic aperture (DA). This approach, known as “tune confinement”, puts tight limits on the magnitude of the tune shifts with amplitude and with momentum. The latter requires labor-intensive optimization of the off-energy dynamic aperture and control over the corresponding tune footprint for the large energy deviations and is a prerequisite to achieving reasonable lifetime if it is dominated by the Touschek scattering. As nonlinearities of the modern ring lattices are much enhanced as compared with the previous generation of synchrotron light sources, it is becoming more and more difficult to keep the off-momentum tune footprint confined. While one could reach reasonable on-energy DA suitable for injection into the machine, the off-energy DA optimization is much more complex and needs to satisfy more constraints so to reach large energy acceptance and secure decent lifetime at the high ring current. In certain cases when the lattice solution with the confined off-energy tune footprint cannot be found, one may ask whether crossing of a resonance stopband from off-momentum particle will lead to loss of this particle. Intuitively, if the particle crosses the stopband quickly, one may expect that the betatron oscillation amplitude will not increase substantially thereby keeping the particle within the machine acceptance. At the same time the tight tolerances of the modern lattice elements as designed and produced afford much narrower resonance stopbands being compared with the machines built decades ago. Under these circumstances the question above may be asked as what are the conditions for operating a ring with a large chromatic tune footprint, which crosses resonances, while not observing particle losses. In this paper we try to answer the questions above by studying the model of a particle with large initial momentum deviation (as, for example, driven by the Touschek scattering event), which crosses stopband of a half-integer resonance while executing synchrotron oscillations in the highly chromatic ring lattice.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Gamma Ray Spectrometry Assay Results of 242 Pu Samples at the Chemistry and Metallurgy Research Facility

Thirty individual items at the Chemistry and Metallurgy Research (CMR) facility with accountable amounts of 242 Pu required assay by gamma ray spectrometry in order to establish their masses with reasonable precision. There were two phases to this measurement campaign: 1) a preliminary screening phase in which each item was measured for a short 600 second count time to establish the relative masses between similar or like items, and 2) a second phase in which groups of items were counted for a considerably longer time in order to establish the group mass of 242 Pu in a reasonable time frame. The data from the two phases were assessed in a manner that allowed the project team to assign a 242 Pu mass to each individual item in the inventory, with the exception of three column tubes that could not be measured individually because of radiological contamination issues. The project team performed technical analyses with the SNAP™ analysis routine, PC-FRAM plutonium isotopic routine, and the NEN-2 PeakEasy routine. When total measurement uncertainties are factored in, the individual mass quantities calculated for all samples are statistically equivalent to the expected mass of 0.88 grams of total plutonium per sample.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Local Radiation Shielding Design Methodology

The NSLS-II accelerators are housed within a radiation enclosure of normal concrete (and in some places high density concrete) that has been designed to reduce the radiation generated from an assumed operational beam loss or bulk shielding current (BCS) from each accelerator. The beam loss model used to estimate the thickness of this bulk shielding, assumed a beam energy at the expected operating energy and a current loss based on reasonable assumptions for the fraction of the expected operating current. The thickness of the shield was determined to be the amount required to reduce the radiation outside the shield to a maximum dose rate of <0.5mrem/hr. for occupied areas for these normal operational losses. These assumed beam losses and the bulk shielding thicknesses required are given in reference. Abnormal operating conditions generating higher than normal beam losses must also be considered, and additional engineering controls will be required depending on the magnitude of the radiation levels generated during the abnormal condition. Additional local shielding subject to configuration control may be utilized to reduce radiation levels associated with these abnormal loss conditions. Interlocked area radiation monitors are another means to prevent continued operation with higher than an acceptable level. The NSLS-II Shielding Policy requires that an engineered system be utilized to mitigate an abnormal condition producing radiation levels greater than 100 mR/h, and that two systems are required if the projected radiation levels during a fault condition are > 2000 mR/h. It is intended that shielding limits the dose rate to < 0.5 mR/h in occupied areas for normal operational losses, and the combination of administrative and engineered controls for abnormal losses will maintain radiation exposure to trained personnel working at the NSLS-II facility to as low as reasonably achievable. It is anticipated that all individual exposures will be well within the planned administrative control level of 100mrem/year.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Increasing Compositions In NBSR Neutronics Model – Part 2

Calculations in support of the NIST research reactor (NBSR) use a Monte Carlo neutronics model in conjunction with a burnup capability. The representation of compositions within the fuel plates for the current reactor has assumed that with burnup there is a single uniform composition within all plates in each half fuel element. That model has been validated using operational data and leads to acceptable conservative results for safety analyses. However, for the conversion of the reactor to the use of low-enriched uranium (LEU) fuel, there has been an effort to change the modeling for several reasons. The use of large composition zones is inconsistent with the rigor in the rest of the neutronics model. There is also the possibility that the conservatism in maximum fission density may lead to excessive requirements for LEU fuel qualification. A new composition model has been proposed that would break each half fuel element into 15 composition zones improving the rigor while still allowing reasonable running time. This approach was tested, and results show that although it is an improvement over the previous model that had one composition zone (and an interim model with six zones) in each half fuel element, it falls short of being the ideal composition model. This report documents the objectives for the new model and the analysis of the resulting calculations.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Achieving Verifiable and High Integrity Instrumentation and Control Systems through Complexity Awareness and Constrained Design. Final Report

While most process control industries have been able to embrace digital Instrumentation and Control (I&C) technology to improve performance, reliability, maintainability, and efficiency of production, the nuclear industry has been relatively slow to adopt digital I&C for safety critical plant functions. There are a variety of reasons for this, but in general the nuclear industry takes a conservative stance that new technologies must mature before adoption. A deeper underlying reason for not fully realizing digital I&C and automation in nuclear power is associated with the complexity that can manifest in software-based systems that is different in nature from the complexity of their analog predecessors. Accordingly, this research pursued the development of innovative architectures and methods to “constrain complexity” to enhance verifiability of digital I&C devices. These constraints can positively impact the reduction of Software Common Cause Failures (SCCF) and other systematic errors. The architectural concept developed in this research effort is called SymPLe. SymPLe is specifically aimed at safety critical functions within Nuclear Power Plants and other critical infrastructure where constraining device complexity to support verifiability and safety case arguments is important. The SymPLe architecture is designed to promote “accessible verification” between OEM/utility engineers and the regulatory agencies who review and license nuclear power plant I&C systems. The major contributions of this work to the nuclear industry are: Demonstration of SymPLe as a viable approach to “complexity aware” I&C systems and Embedded Digital Devices.Comprehensive use of model-based design and engineering to produce verifiable I&C systems for the nuclear industry with clear findings on the usability of model-based engineering. Employ comprehensive use of model-based engineering, testing, and verification in an IEC 61508 workflow in support of design assurance. Gathered evidence of “difficult to find” design flaws found using model-based design and testing methods. Detailed the nature of these SCCFs including where they were introduced, the triggers, and how they were found. Gathered evidence on the synergistic use of practical formal methods and testing and how these methods can be used to significantly increase assurance of reduction and avoidance of design flaws.

Testing↗

IAEA Coordinated Research Project on HTGR Physics, Thermal Hydraulics, and Depletion Uncertainty Analysis: PHISICS/RELAP5-3D Results for the Phase III Coupled Core Exercises

This report details the Parallel and Highly Innovative Simulation for INL Code System (PHISICS)/Reactor Excursions and Leak Analysis Program (RELAP5)-3D results obtained for the neutronics stand-alone core exercises defined for Phase II of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Coordinated Research Project (CRP) on high-temperature gas cooled reactor (HTGR) uncertainty analysis in modeling (UAM). The Phase II models and results are linked to the earlier Standardized Computer Analyses for Licensing Evaluation (SCALE)/Sampler/New ESC-based Weighting Transport (NEWT) data generated for the lattice physics (lattice) stage Phase I of the CRP. The focus of this report is the propagation of cross-section uncertainties from the lattice to the core calculation (core) phase of the prismatic 350 megawatt (MW) General Atomics (GA) Modular HTGR (MHTGR). The Phase II neutronics exercises consist of two sub-cases (II-2a and II-2b) specified for the fresh and mixed core loading of the MHTGR-350 prismatic high-temperature reactor design. Exercises II-2a and II-2b are performed without temperature feedback using isothermal temperature profiles. For the nominal lattice physics (i.e., best-estimate) model, a series of fresh and depleted single block and super cell SCALE/KENO and SCALE/NEWT models were developed at Idaho National Laboratory (INL) to assess the impact of spectral effects on the few-group cross sections. A combination of these lattice cells were used in a super cell calculation to construct 8-group cross-section libraries for use in the INL-developed PHISICS/RELAP5-3D code suite. The block-level homogenized libraries were assigned to the 220 fuel zones utilized in the MHTGR-350 PHISICS core model, according to the fresh and mixed fresh/depleted core loading pattern. In order to evaluate the effect of uncertainty propagation, several sets consisting of 1,000 perturbed NEWT lattice and PHISICS/RELAP5-3D core calculations were performed using the SCALE 6.2 ENDF/B-VII.1 cross-section co-variance data and the stochastic sampling module Sampler in SCALE 6.2.0. The Figures of Merit (FOM) investigated include the mean and standard deviation uncertainty values obtained for the eigenvalues, control rod worth values, block-averaged power profiles, power axial offsets, and isothermal temperature feedback coefficients. A sensitivity study on the main nuclide reaction contributors to the FOM uncertainties has not yet been performed since the SCALE/PHISICS/RAVEN coupling with ENDF/B-VII co-variance data is still being developed. It was found that uncertainties in the cross sections lead to uncertainties in the local power values of up to 1.5%. The variances between the fresh and mixed/depleted core models are not as large as the axial variations between the top and bottom within each core model. The core eigenvalue uncertainty is approximately 0.5%, which is significant in comparison to typical eigenvalue difference targets (less than ~0.1% for LWRs). The power peaking and axial offset uncertainties are smaller (0.10% – 0.15%) and probably below the level of significance in typical core design metrics. The use of an 8-group energy structure slightly under-estimates some of the uncertainties, but in absolute terms, the uncertainty results are reasonably close to the 26-group results. The 26- and 8-group mean and nominal results differ by a larger degree, and if it can be afforded in terms of calculation resources, the 26-group structure should be used for HTGR calculations. The 8-group structure can, however, still be useful for reasonably accurate uncertainty assessments of transient cases where computational time is important. It was furthermore found that the use of a super cell during the cross-section generation process for better representation of the spectral environment at the core periphery did not lead to significant changes in the core eigenvalues, axial offset, and power peaking uncertainties. The impact of the super cell cross sections on the nominal and mean eigenvalues is, however, important enough (0.6% – 1.1% lower) to justify the use of these super cells for HTGR core simulation to represent the softer spectral environment in the core peripheral regions for nominal best-estimate calculations. The use of super cells for HTGR uncertainty studies is, therefore, not strictly necessary, but the improvements in nominal results could justify their use.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Micro Reactor Simulation Using the PROTEUS Suite in FY19

Two micro reactor cores were simulated using the MOC solver of PROTEUS: MegaPower for a heat pipe micro reactor and Holos-Quad for a high-temperature gas-cooled micro reactor. Verification of PROTEUS standalone was performed by simulating 2D and 3D core benchmark problems developed based on MegaPower and Holos-Quad. Simulation results indicated that PROTEUS successfully modelled 2D and 3D cores of the MegaPower and Holos-Quad micro reactors and PROTEUS eigenvalues agreed well with the SERPENT Monte Carlo solutions. For a heat pipe cooled micro reactor, multiphysics simulations were performed using PROTEUS / FLUENT / ANLHTP. The coupling system of the three codes were developed using Python-based drivers, which exchange the data (power, temperature, and heat rate) required for the coupling and control the boundary conditions of FLUENT and ANLHTP. The coupled system was qualitatively verified using a 3D unit assembly problem composed of six fuel rods and seven heat pipes, which was developed based on the MegaPower compositions. The steady-state problem was solved using FLUENT / ANLHTP with given asymmetric fuel powers, demonstrating the reasonable convergence of temperatures of 7 heat pipes. Transient simulations were also performed by making one out of 7 heat pipes fail. For the transient, the coupled system of PROTEUS / FLUENT / ANLHTP demonstrated reasonable changes of total power and heat pipe temperatures with time, accounting for temperature feedback effects. In this simulation, no effect of structural change was accounted for, which will be performed using ANSYS-mechanical in future along with further verification with larger or whole-core 3D problems.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Extraction and Parametrization of Isobaric Trinucleon Elastic Cross Sections and Form Factors

By mining data from Jefferson Lab Hall A experiment E08-014 a new 3 He elastic cross section was extracted from a large quasielastic background. This measurement was taken with an initial beam energy of 3.356 GeV and an angle of 20.51°. The cross section was found to be 1.345 × 10 -6 µb/sr ± 0.086 × 10 -6 µb/sr at Q 2 = 34.19 fm -2 . This new data point falls approximately halfway between the first and second diffractive minima of the 3 He form factors. When combined with recent high Q 2 3 He elastic cross section measurements from Jefferson Lab and MIT-Bates this new data point improves our knowledge of the cross section and form factors at large momentum transfers. The new high Q 2 data motivate a reanalysis of the 3 He elastic cross section world data and provide an improved understanding of the magnetic form factor in particular. For this analysis the elastic cross section world data for 3 He, and its mirror nuclei 3 H, were collected. The world data spans a time frame from 1965 to 2016. The dataset contains electron energy ranges from tens of MeV to above 12 GeV for measurements performed at many different facilities. The world data were then fit using a sum of Gaussians parametrization which allowed for the extraction of both targets’ magnetic and electric form factors which were then used to calculate charge densities and radii. The new charge and magnetic form factors for 3 H and the charge form factor for 3 He are in good agreement with the 1994 fits from Amroun et al . However, the addition of the new high Q 2 data has caused the 3 He magnetic form factor’s first diffractive minimum to shift up in Q 2 by 1-3 fm -2 while also decreasing the magnitude of the magnetic form factor above Q2 ≈ 20 fm -2 . The first diffractive minima for 3H are located at Q2 ≈ 13 fm -2 and Q 2 ≈ 23-24 fm -2 for the charge and magnetic form factors respectively. The first diffractive minima for 3 He are located at Q 2 ≈ 11 fm -2 and Q 2 ≈ 17-20 fm -2 for the charge and magnetic form factors respectively. The charge radius for 3 He was found to be 1.90 fm ± 0.00144 fm in reasonable agreement with past measurements, and the charge radius for 3 H was found to be 2.02 fm ± 0.0133 fm which is much larger than past measurements. However, each of these charge radii has an additional uncertainty that must be applied to them due to allowing all parameters to float freely during the sum of Gaussians fitting procedure. This additional uncertainty should be small for 3 He, but it is likely quite significant for 3 H and would help bring this charge radius closer to agreement with past measurements that made different fitting choices. Unfortunately, this analysis was unable to quantify this additional uncertainty. The new form factor fits were compared to modern theoretical predictions from the 2016 paper of Marcucci et al . The ‘conventional’ theoretical approach applied in this paper modelled two and three-body nucleon interactions with relativistic corrections and was reasonably successful at predicting the charge form factors of 3 H and 3 He. χEFT predictions were also often successful. However, while the ‘conventional’ approach still performed best, theory failed to accurately predict the magnetic form factors of either 3 H or 3 He. The first diffractive minimum of the new 3 He magnetic form factor fits actually moved further away from theory. This disagreement between theory and experiment provides motivation for new asymmetry measurements using polarized 3 He and a polarized electron beam. When the beam is scanned in Q 2 on the target the sign of the asymmetry will flip at the form factor minima pinning down their true location.

Barcus, Scott↗

Comoparison of Slit Trench and Engineered Trench 3D Vadose Zone Conceptual Models

In the next revision of the E-Area Low-Level Waste Facility (ELLWF) Performance Assessment (PA), radionuclide groundwater transport from slit (ST) and engineered trenches (ET) will be simulated using 3-dimensional PORFLOW models representing the vadose zone. In total, the conceptual framework will aim to model 29 total trenches with a degree of conservatism that provides a high level of confidence in meeting performance objectives. The implementation of generic conceptual models allows for a reasonable number of simulation scenarios, thereby reducing the chances of errors and enabling a better one-to-one comparison between the results, while still capturing the most important features of each trench. The current investigation seeks to understand if a generic trench model based on the general ET footprint can justifiably be used for representing both STs and ETs while maintaining a reasonable degree of conservatism. In this process, the groundwater transport of several key radionuclides was simulated for both ET and ST geometries and the flux-to-the-water-table profiles were compared. For all radionuclides simulated, the ET geometry is shown to be conservative (i.e., produces the highest peak flux to the water table).

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Involute Working Group – Validation of CFD Turbulence Models for Steady-State Safety Analysis

There are three research reactors in the world having fuel plates curved as circle-involute (a spiral generated around a circle): The Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) located in Tennessee, U.S.A. [ORNL, 2018]; The Laue-Langevin Institute (ILL) High Flux Reactor (RHF) located in Grenoble, France [ILL, 2018]; and, The Technical University of Munich (TUM) Research Neutron Source Heinz Maier-Leibnitz (FRM II) located in Garching, Germany [TUM, 2018]. All three reactors are currently using Highly Enriched Uranium (HEU, 235U/U ≥ 20 wt. %) as fuel and all three are actively engaged in activities to convert to Low Enriched Uranium (LEU, 235U/U < 20 wt. %) fuel. More information on these reactors can be found in Section two. For various reasons, these reactors have expressed interest in using Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) tools to perform their Steady-State Thermal-Hydraulic (SSTH) safety calculations. Using CFD tools for SSTH analysis represents generally a significant departure from traditional methods and requires thorough verification and validation (V&V) to be accepted by regulators. This is why Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) and the involute reactors formed an informal group to help each other in this endeavor. This so-called Involute Working Group (IWG) aims at supporting the qualification of CFD tools for SSTH safety calculations. Activities include benchmarking, code-to-code comparison, Verification and Validation (V&V) as well as technical support. More information on the IWG and the reasons why involute-plate reactors are interested in CFD can be found in Section three. The present study aims at testing three turbulence models commonly implemented in commercial software (namely K-Epsilon, K-Omega and Reynolds-Stress) and assessing their relevance for involute-plate reactor application. An experiment performed by Gambill and Bundy in 1961 was performed to measure heat transfer coefficients in conditions prototypic of the HFIR reactor [Gambill, 1961]. More details on this experiment are provided in Section four. Based on the information available, CFD models of this experiment have been created and the experimental results have been compared to the ones obtained with these CFD models. CFD models and the results of this comparison are provided in Section five.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Glycolate Analysis in Tank 22: Developing and Testing Analytical Methods for the Savannah River Site Liquid Waste System

Researchers developed and tested a range of techniques to support a low mg/L Limit of Quantitation (LOQ) of glycolate in radioactive Tank 22 waste solution by Ion Chromatography (IC) and by proton NMR. For the IC method, Dionex OnGuard II cartridges were tested as a means of removing alkali earth and transition metals that can interfere during ion chromatography applications especially when analyzing for low-concentration, chelating analytes. Additionally, concentrations of nitrate in the raw Tank 22 sample (5,000 to 10,000 mg/L) were managed by using reasonable levels of sample dilution. The resulting IC performance quality was enhanced by improving the baseline, increasing sensitivity [Limit of Quantitation (LOQ) of 12 mg/L and Limit of Detection (LOD) of 4.0 mg/L], and resolving analytes into well-defined Gaussian peaks when using the Dionex OnGuard II H⁺ cartridges to remove matrix interferences. High concentrations of nitrate limited the performance of the IC method. To achieve an acceptable baseline, samples with high nitrate content require more dilution, resulting in higher detection limits. Tests on samples with higher concentrations of nitrate (Tank 30 and 32 supernate with approximately 150000 mg/L nitrate) suggested that IC detection limits for glycolate in these samples would be > 500 mg/L. Thus, an LOQ of 12 mg/L is not feasible by this IC method on evaporator feed samples. An alternative method of glycolate analysis, using proton nuclear magnetic resonance (H NMR), was developed by the research team. In initial tests, the H NMR technique provided reasonable quantitation of glycolate in Tank 22 conditions by direct observation of the liquid. The H NMR method may provide improved detection limits for solutions with higher nitrate concentrations. We recommend further development of this analysis for high nitrate LWS samples such as evaporator feed and evaporator drop tank content. A method for pretreatment of samples using crystalline silicotitanate (CST) was developed and tested. The objective of the pretreatment was to facilitate analysis of samples with higher levels of radioactivity. The pretreatment did not influence the glycolate concentration in solution, and the pretreatment is projected to reduce Cs 137 activity in a sample by a factor of 16,200. The double strike CST pretreatment was demonstrated and would allow milliliters of higher activity samples to be transferred from the Shielded Cells and handled in a containment unit for glycolate analysis. The various studies validated IC and H NMR methods for glycolate analysis, defined the range of applicability, and demonstrated key supporting analytical protocols. Based on the results, high quality glycolate analysis of Tank 22 is feasible down to approximately 12 mg/L, with the potential for broader applicability of the methods to other conditions in the Savannah River Site Liquid Waste System (LWS).

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

A Brief Introduction to Gamma and Neutron Radiation [Slides]

Objectives: Describe gamma rays in plain English; Give 3 reasons we measure gamma rays; Describe shielding effect vs gamma energy; List 4 components of the natural background; Detail the main reason we care about neutrons; and List three good neutron moderators.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Evaluation of the 2018 Version of the Integrated Surveillance Program Database Pressure Equation

The Integrated Surveillance Program (ISP) Database Pressure Equation was developed to determine with reasonable certainty the total maximum pressure of hydrogen and other gases in packaged 3013 containers stored at Savannah River Site (SRS) in support of the destructive evaluation (DE) process. The pressure equation in the Department of Energy (DOE) 3013 Standard, “Standard for Stabilization, Packaging and Storage of Plutonium- Bearing Materials” (DOE-STD-3013-2004) used a bounding assumption that all the water is decomposed to form hydrogen. However, the results of Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) shelf-life experiments showed that hydrogen is consumed, and that the maximum pressures would not approach the design pressure of the 3013 container. Therefore, the ISP Database Pressure Equation was revised in 2008 to include terms for the generation of helium and hydrogen as a function of time, as well as the consumption of water and destruction of hydrogen based on shelf-life results. The 2008 ISP Database Pressure Equation provided a more reasonable estimate of the total maximum pressure in packaged 3013 containers than the pressure equation in versions of the 3013 Standard issued prior to 2018.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Understanding Materials Characteristics of Palladium Lanthanide Cermet Wires as a Mimic of Californium Wire Production

Californium-252 (Cf-252) has been synthesized on a large scale (mg) since the 1970s for use as a portable neutron source. With a half-life of 2.645 years and a spontaneous fission fraction of 3.09%, Cf-252 emits 2.31 × 10 12 neutrons/gram second. Today most of the Cf-252 produced in the world is made at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) using the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) and the Radiochemical Engineering Development Center (REDC). Because of its highly radioactive nature, all manipulations of Cf-252 need to be performed in hot cell facilities by highly trained personnel. The Cf-252 produced at ORNL is done at the REDC, which is conveniently located next to the HFIR. Cf-252 is sold as bulk wire, which has been described as palladium (Pd) metal incasing californium oxide (Cf 2 O 3 ). The process was developed by Mosley et al. at Savannah River Laboratory (SRL) where it was modeled after the thorium work done by Fuschillo et al. This process has been used since the 1970s to synthesize this unique wire, but its fundamental chemistry and materials characteristics were never openly reported. Here we aim to better understand the chemistry and the materials characteristics of Cf-252 wire production for process improvements and to better our fundamental understanding of the mid-late actinides. Though there are many challenges in working with radioactive elements such as Cf, the isotope Cf-252 is even more complicated due to its neutron emission. One challenge with neutron emission is the ability of neutrons to penetrate much deeper through materials, causing radiation damage. This makes using instrumentation to characterize the chemistry and materials properties of this process difficult. For this reason, this study will first focus on terbium (Tb) as a surrogate for Cf. Currently Tb is used as a carrier or filler in Cf production when small amounts of Cf are being processed. This, along with their similar size and charge, makes Tb a reasonable surrogate for this study.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

RAMSeS: Rapid Analysis of Mission Software Systems

Over the past few decades, software has become ubiquitous as it has been integrated into nearly every aspect of society, including household appliances, consumer electronics, industrial control systems, public utilities, government operations, and military systems. Consequently, many critical national security questions can no longer be answered convincingly without understanding software, including its purpose, its capabilities, its flaws, its communication, or how it processes and stores data. As software continues to become larger, more complex, and more widespread, our ability to answer important mission questions and reason about software in a timely way is falling behind. Today, to achieve such understanding of third-party software, we rely predominantly on the ability of reverse engineering experts to manually answer each particular mission question for every software system of interest. This approach often requires heroic human effort that nevertheless fails to meet current mission needs and will never scale to meet future needs. The result is an emerging crisis: a massive and expanding gap between the national security need to answer mission questions about software and our ability to do so. Sandia National Laboratories has established the Rapid Analysis of Mission Software Systems (RAMSeS) effort, a collaborative long-term effort aimed at dramatically improving our nation’s ability to answer mission questions about third-party software by growing an ecosystem of tools that augment the human reverse engineer through automation, interoperability, and reuse. Focusing on static analysis of binary programs, we are attempting to identify reusable software analysis components that advance our ability to reason about software, to automate useful aspects of the software analysis process, and to integrate new methodologies and capabilities into a working ecosystem of tools and experts. We aim to integrate existing tools where possible, adapt tools when modest modifications will enable them to interoperate, and implement missing capability when necessary. Although we do hope to automate a growing set of analysis tasks, we will approach this goal incrementally by assisting the human in an ever-widening range of tasks.

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗