Parametric Study of 239 Pu and 235 U Mass Equivalency in Spherical Geometries
In this technical document, parametric studies were performed to determine if a bounding mass equivalency can be used to simplify multi-material models in MCNP6 for criticality evaluations. The studies explored the simplification of MCNP6 models by substituting materials, particularly 239 Pu for 235 U. The initial hypothesis for the material simplification is based on the subcritical mass limits from the ANSI/ANS- 8.1 standard which states that for water reflected metal spheres the limits are 20.1 kg 235 U and 5.0 kg 239 Pu. Using those masses, it was hypothesized that a 20.1 kg sphere of 235 U and a 5.0 kg sphere of 239 Pu could be considered to have the same multiplication. Given that equivalency, 4kg 235 U could be modeled by 1kg 239 Pu (i.e., a mass ratio of 4:1). The parametric studies compare the materials 239 Pu and 235 U independently and in multi-material spherical models. Critical mass, critical thickness, critical mass ratio and critical thickness ratio values are presented as functions of inner radius. keff values are presented as a function of inner radius at different mass ratios and total masses. Results indicate that the conservative bounding mass equivalency is one. That is, if substituting 239 Pu for 235 U it should be done on a gram for gram basis.