SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “dislocation multiplication”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

SourceResearch connectionFrom yearThrough year

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 109 records · Page 6

All sources NASA NTRS DOE OSTI

DOE OSTI2024

Energy Efficiency Improvement Approaches in Ice Related Processes

Application and development of energy efficient techniques to separate ice from different surfaces and substrates is of significant value in the context of building equipment performance. A hybrid approach to help dislocate the ice layer using advanced materials and ultrasonic vibration to lower ice adhesion strength was investigated. Application of advanced polymer materials in lowering the adhesion strength of ice was confirmed where the measured strength was lowered by 50-70% depending on the material and geometry. Additionally, utilization of induced ultrasonic vibration in further lowering the ice harvesting energy was confirmed on multiple materials and geometries. Durability of the coating enhancement was also confirmed in a thermal cycling test under realistic operating conditions. Integration of these technical approaches was implemented and validated in commercial ice makers showing energy consumption reduction by ~ 15% to 30% depending on the technical enhancement.

Cheekatamarla, Praveen↗

DOE OSTI2021

Examining deformation localization of irradiated tungsten under uniaxial compression with crystal plasticity

In this work, the deformation behavior of irradiated tungsten at elevated service temperatures is examined using mechanism-based crystal plasticity finite element framework by considering multiple mechanisms, including thermal softening and irradiation hardening. The previously developed mechanism-based crystal plasticity model is first utilized to assess the yield stress of unirradiated and irradiated tungsten upon low-temperature irradiation. Additionally, the engineering stress-strain response under uniaxial compression is then predicted by considering the effect of irradiation-induced defect clusters on the motion of deformation-induced dislocations, and the predicted results agree well with the experimental measurements. More importantly, the formation and evolution of plastic strain localization zones in the form of shear bands are qualitatively captured, and the maximal principal strain distribution is quantitatively linked to the dose of irradiation damage. Finally, the deformation-induced shear band as a result of plastic instability in the compressed tungsten specimen is discussed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

NASA NTRS2019

GaN/AlGaN Avalanche Photodiode Detectors for High Performance Ultraviolet Sensing Applications

The shorter wavelengths of the ultraviolet (UV) band enable detectors to operate with increased spatial resolution, variable pixel sizes, and large format arrays, benefitting a variety of NASA, defense, and commercial applications. AlxGa1-xN semiconductor alloys, which have attracted much interest for detection in the UV spectral region, have been shown to enable high optical gains, high sensitivities with the potential for single photon detection, and low dark current performance in ultraviolet avalanche photodiodes (UV-APDs). We are developing GaN/AlGaN UV-APDs with large pixel sizes that demonstrate consistent and uniform device performance and operation. These UV-APDs are fabricated through high quality metal organic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD) growth on lattice-matched, low dislocation density GaN substrates with optimized material growth and doping parameters. The use of these low defect density substrates is a critical element to realizing highly sensitive UV-APDs and arrays with suppressed dark current under high electric fields.Optical gains greater than 5X10 (exp 6) with enhanced quantum efficiencies over the 350-400 nm spectral range have been demonstrated, enabled by a strong avalanche multiplication process. Furthermore, we are developing 6X6 arrays of devices to test high gain UV-APD array performance at ~355 nm. These variable-area GaN/AlGaN UV-APD detectors and arrays enable advanced sensing performance over UV bands of interest with high resolution detection for NASA Earth Science applications.

Sood, Ashok K.↗

DOE OSTI2025

Development and Evaluation of Embrittlement Resistant Alloys for Advanced LWR Cladding

The primary challenge preventing the deployment of reactor designs that leverage wrought FeCrAl as an advanced light-water reactor (LWR) cladding is irradiation hardening and embrittlement. Wrought FeCrAl alloys experience a loss of post-irradiation ductility and fracture toughness under low-temperature neutron irradiation (< 350°C) resulting from the combined effects of dislocation loop formation and the irradiation-enhanced precipitation of Cr-rich alpha-prime precipitates throughout the microstructure. Over the past decade, significant improvements in our understanding regarding the effect of Cr and Al content have been enabled through neutron irradiations, but even optimized wrought alloys such as C26M remain vulnerable to brittle failure during storage, transportation, and handling following irradiation. This report summarizes multiple irradiation campaigns initiated over the past 7 years and provides recent insights into the effect of (1) minor alloying composition, (2) alloy processing strategy, (3) crystal structure, and (4) the use of advanced oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) alloys. The first irradiation campaign irradiated body-centered cubic FeCrAl alloy C26M with and without elements such as Mo and Y. It also included face-centered cubic alumina-forming austenitic (AFA) alloys that have a steeper neutronic penalty but that have far superior high-temperature strength than wrought FeCrAl. Finally, this campaign compared conventional wrought C26M with the same material produced using modern powder metallurgical hotisostatic pressing (PM-HIP). The second irradiation campaign, initiated in 2018, irradiated wrought and FeCrAl-ODS materials up to 50 dpa to assess their irradiation resistance to high-doses. The results of this work indicate that wrought C26M suffers significant degradation following neutron irradiation at LWR-relevant temperatures regardless of Mo and Y content. The PM-HIP variant appears to be more resilient to irradiation-induced ductility loss in comparison with wrought variants but still loses almost all ductility by 8 dpa. Notably, the AFAs retained at least 5% total elongation after irradiation at the same dose and temperature condition, although additional deterioration may be expected at higher fluence levels. FeCrAl-ODS materials show the greatest promise as a transformative longer-term accident-tolerant fuel (LT-ATF) cladding material. The extruded 106ZY10C alloy retained 10% total elongation after 16 dpa irradiation and retained 8% total elongation after 50 dpa. Additional challenges with FeCrAl-ODS alloys also remain, including optimization of end cap joining methodologies, enhancement of fracture toughness, scaling production to prove economic viability, and optimizing post-pilger heat treatments to maximize ductility and irradiation resistance. This series of irradiations demonstrates the efficacy of the LWR testbed available within the United States for the rapid irradiation and down-selection of LT-ATF candidates. As the country rapidly accelerates its timeline for the deployment of advanced reactor concepts, the effective utilization of the High Flux Isotope Reactor for separate-effects style irradiations should continue to be prioritized to answer the final questions pertaining to LT-ATF candidates necessary for the deployment of advanced boiling water reactors and small modular reactors.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

DOE OSTI2025

Heterogeneous fatigue damage in a nickel-based single-crystal superalloy unraveled using correlative 3D X-ray technology

Nickel-based single-crystal (Ni-SX) superalloys under cyclic stress are susceptible to cracking at stress-concentration sites, eventually leading to low-cycle fatigue (LCF) failure. LCF cracks typically originate from intrinsic defects (e.g., voids and carbides) within solidified dendrites. However, systematic quantitative experimental analyses of defect-mediated local damage remain limited. To thoroughly understand the microscopic origins and evolution of LCF damage, correlated 3D mapping of dendrites across various regions is essential. Here, in this study, macroscale micro-computed tomography (μ-CT) was initially used to capture internal interdendritic secondary cracks within bulk DD413 superalloy after LCF testing at 760 °C. Subsequently, a multimodal methodology combining synchrotron 3D microdiffraction (3D-μXRD), high-resolution μ-CT, and electron microscopy was established. This approach allowed precise localization of internal damage zones near interdendritic secondary cracks and detailed mapping of the 3D correlated distributions of dendrites, defects, and residual stress/strain fields within these zones at submicron spatial resolution. Finally, the same approach was applied to specimens subjected to interrupted loading at approximately 40 % of the fatigue life to uncover the early damage states of dendrites. The dendrite cores (DCs) and interdendritic regions (IDs) exhibit microscale heterogeneous mechanical responses: nearly defect-free DCs accumulate local irreversible slip along specific slip systems to generate slip bands, while the IDs containing various defects accommodate local microplasticity through the activation of multiple slip systems around these defects. The local tensile stress near defects in the IDs exceeds that in the DC slip band regions by more than threefold, leading to the generation of local damage zones within the IDs. Chain-like defect distributions facilitate the interconnection of these local zones into a continuous damage region, further elevating the overall tensile stress in the IDs. Additionally, geometrically necessary dislocations alone are insufficient as indicators of LCF damage; both the internal stress state and its magnitude must be considered. These experimental results provide critical data and insights for the development of multi-physics fatigue models.

Localized deformation↗

DOE OSTI2022

Damage Detection and Electrical Performance Impact of Flat-Flexible Circuits

Flat-flexible circuits or ‘flex circuits’ have varied applications in electronics and in explosive detonation systems. They pose advantages over conventional coaxial cables in their ability to fit into small mechanical envelopes and routings. A typical flex circuit is composed of a laminated assembly of multiple layers of conductor and dielectric materials. Copper, because of its high electrical conductivity, is one of the primary materials used in flex circuit conductors. The conductor must maintain structural integrity and electrical continuity when the flexible circuit is bent during processing or to fit an application envelope. Under some strain conditions a cable may have degraded electrical performance even though visible damage may not be evident. Dislocation density can increase by mechanisms such as dislocation forest hardening, where gliding dislocations in primary slip planes get pinned at obstacles and form Frank-Read sources. Dislocation density increases within the conductor layers may impact electrical resistivity but would not necessarily result in visible mechanical failure. In some detonation applications, such as for building implosion for demolition, the time for signal transmission and voltage used for firing detonators can be critical. If the resistance in a single flex cable within a building demolition array is too high, the resultant demolition shape may be asymmetric, leading to unplanned damage to nearby structures and potential hazards to public safety. This study will apply non-destructive evaluation techniques to evaluate the detectability of damage accumulation in flat, flexible copper-conductor cables and discuss potential implications to their practical use.

42 ENGINEERING↗

NASA NTRS2003

Modeling the Interactions Between Multiple Crack Closure Mechanisms at Threshold

A fatigue crack closure model is developed that includes interactions between the three closure mechanisms most likely to occur at threshold; plasticity, roughness, and oxide. This model, herein referred to as the CROP model (for Closure, Roughness, Oxide, and Plasticity), also includes the effects of out-of plane cracking and multi-axial loading. These features make the CROP closure model uniquely suited for, but not limited to, threshold applications. Rough cracks are idealized here as two-dimensional sawtooths, whose geometry induces mixed-mode crack- tip stresses. Continuum mechanics and crack-tip dislocation concepts are combined to relate crack face displacements to crack-tip loads. Geometric criteria are used to determine closure loads from crack-face displacements. Finite element results, used to verify model predictions, provide critical information about the locations where crack closure occurs.

Newman, John A.↗

DOE OSTI2022

Microstructural changes of proton irradiated Hastelloy-N and in situ micropillar compression testing of one single grain at different local damage levels

Here, in situ micropillar compression was used to study the deformation of proton-irradiated Hastelloy-N at different damage levels. Multiple pillars were prepared from a single domain along the cross-section of 2.5 MeV proton-irradiated Hastelloy-N. Depending on the location of micropillars, the critical resolved shear stress was obtained as a function of local damage levels. Such an approach eliminates the variation of yield stress due to the difference in the Schmid factor. Microstructural characterization showed that irradiation hardening is contributed by complicated defect structures, including (a) dislocation loops with many in corduroy-like alignments, (2) dislocations pile up, and (3) Cottrell atmosphere. Silicon atoms are found to segregate at dislocation lines and loops and form complicated Cottrell cloud patterns. The critical resolved shear stress, $t_{crss}$, and hardening exponents were both extracted as a function of displacements per atom values up to 2.3. There was a 60% increase in $t_{crss}$ at the highest damage level.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

DOE OSTI2022

Using machine-learning to understand complex microstructural effects on the mechanical behavior of Ti-6Al-4V alloys

Structural materials properties are highly dependent on their microstructure. Their microstructure is in turn affected by multiple fabrication and thermo-mechanical treatment parameters, all of which conform a highly-dimensional parametric space with often hidden correlations that are difficult to extract by experimentation alone. This is particularly true for alloys of the dual-phase Ti-6Al-4V family, with their greatly complex and rich microstructures, which combine several intrinsic length scales associated with multiple grain and subgrain structures, grains with different crystal lattices (α and β phases), and complex chemistry. In this paper we use a comprehensive set of machine learning techniques to develop predictive tools relating the yield strength and hardening rate of these alloys to a set of input parameters covering extensive ranges. The data generator is a finite-element crystal plasticity model for polycrystal deformation that takes into account slip anisotropy and employs standard dislocation evolution models for the α and β phases of Ti-based alloys. Our dataset includes over two thousand independent simulations and is used to train the machine learning models, which are then used to establish correlations between microstructural parameters and the alloys’ mechanical response. Our results point to the most influential parameters affecting yield strength and hardening rate, information that can then be used to guide experimental synthesis and characterization efforts to save time and resources.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

NASA NTRS1988

The effect of hydrogen on deformation substructure, flow and fracture in a nickel-base single crystal superalloy

The room temperature flow and fracture of a nickel-base single crystal gamma/gamma-/prime superalloy in the presence and absence of hydrogen is explored. The procedure of hydrogen-charging employed in this study provides a very high and uniform hydrogen concentration of the order of 5000 at.-ppm in the material. It is shown that the most compelling hydrogen-induced changes in deformation behavior are enhanced dislocation accumulation in the gamma matrix and extensive cross-slip of super-dislocations. The explanation of these changes is proposed. Both effects contribute to the increase of flow stress and the notable work hardening that occurs prior to fracture. Hydrogen enhanced strain localization in the gamma matrix leads to the dramatic loss of ductility and premature cracking, which manifests as failure macroscopically parallel to the 100-plane-oriented faces of gamma-prime precipitates. On the microscale, cracking, while limited to the gamma matrix, occurs parallel to multiple 111-plane-oriented slip systems.

Dollar, M.↗

DOE OSTI2020

Electron tomography imaging methods with diffraction contrast for materials research

Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) enable the visualization of three-dimensional (3D) microstructures ranging from atomic to micrometer scales using 3D reconstruction techniques based on computed tomography algorithms. This 3D microscopy method is called electron tomography (ET) and has been utilized in the fields of materials science and engineering for more than two decades. Although atomic resolution is one of the current topics in ET research, the development and deployment of intermediate-resolution (non-atomic-resolution) ET imaging methods have garnered considerable attention from researchers. This research trend is probably not irrelevant due to the fact that the spatial resolution and functionality of 3D imaging methods of scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and X-ray microscopy have come to overlap with those of ET. In other words, there may be multiple ways to carry out 3D visualization using different microscopy methods for nanometer-scale objects in materials. From the above standpoint, this review paper aims to (i) describe the current status and issues of intermediate-resolution ET with regard to enhancing the effectiveness of TEM/STEM imaging and (ii) discuss promising applications of state-of-the-art intermediate-resolution ET for materials research with a particular focus on diffraction contrast ET for crystalline microstructures (superlattice domains and dislocations) including a demonstration of in situ dislocation tomography.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2021

Twinning pathways enabled by precipitates in $\mathrm{AZ91}$

While precipitates have been shown to substantially strengthen magnesium alloys by blocking the glide of dislocations inside the grain, the interactions between these precipitates and deformation twins, which commonly occur in these alloys, are much less understood. Here, in this work, an elasto-viscoplastic fast-Fourier-transform (EVP-FFT) model is used to study the interactions between plate-shaped basal precipitates and propagating $10\bar{1}2$ tensile twins in AZ91 Mg alloy. The results suggest that while precipitates may impede the propagation and thickening of twins, they can also cause stress localizations that can promote the formation of multiple new twins of the same or different crystallographic variants. We show that the location of the twin-precipitate interaction site, whether precipitate-central or precipitate-edge impingement, and the thickness of the precipitate can influence the propensity for twins to expand around the precipitate or nucleate a new twin on the other side of it. Depending on the twin-precipitate impingement site, we propose multiple twinning pathways that can help explain how twins can proliferate in the magnesium alloys in the presence of precipitates.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2024

Fracture behavior of irradiation induced nanocrystalline UO 2 studied by in-situ mechanical testing in transmission electron microscopy

Uranium Dioxide (UO 2 ) is widely used as a fuel in current light water reactors (LWRs). Upon accumulation of radiation damage, LWR UO 2 fuel pellets start to develop a different microstructure at the pellet periphery when fuel burnup exceeds 45–50 GWd/tHM. The resulting porous, nanocrystalline microstructure is one of the most prominent microstructural changes occurring in such fuel. Its fracture mechanisms, which causes fuel fine fragmentation, could impact safety limits when the cladding breaches. Direct measurements of these properties are challenging, therefore a surrogate obtained via ion irradiation can be used. In this study, multiple microcantilevers were fabricated by focused ion beam from both fresh UO 2 and UO 2 irradiated with 84 MeV Xe 26+ ions to a peak dose of 1357 displacements per atom (dpa). Further, the irradiation produced a pseudo high burnup structure approximately 2 µm below the surface. In-situ nano-mechanical bending tests were conducted to investigate the fracture behavior and the effect of the surrogate UO 2 high burnup structure on local fracture properties. Fresh UO 2 fuel was observed to fracture in transgranular mode without nucleation or movement of dislocations. However, the Xe-irradiated nanocrystalline microcantilevers fractured along the grain boundaries, with no influence from the pre-existing micro-cracks in the microcantilever. Fracture toughness for this type of surrogate high burnup UO 2 structure is reported for the first time in literature. Both the fracture stress and toughness show degradation for UO 2 as a result of Xe-irradiation.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

DOE OSTI2022

Role of chemical disorder on radiation-induced defect production and damage evolution in NiFeCoCr

Understanding chemical disorder in many concentrated solid solution alloys (CSAs) at the levels of electrons and atoms has attracted increasing attention as a path forward to reveal and identify underlying mechanisms for extraordinary mechanical properties and improved radiation tolerance. Single-phase NiFeCoCr CSA is a common base for many high-entropy alloys (HEAs) that have shown improved mechanical strength and radiation tolerance. In this study, defect production and damage evolution in NiFeCoCr under ion irradiation at room temperature to dose over 20 dpa are determined using ion channeling technique along both <100> and <110> directions utilizing multiple probing beam energies. The results obtained from the multi-axial and multi-energy channeling analysis are compared with those previously obtained for Ni crystals irradiated under similar conditions. The influence of chemical complexity on defect production and clustering at early-stage under room temperature irradiation up to dose of 1 dpa is discussed based on positron annihilation spectroscopy results. Defect structure evaluation in Ni and NiFeCoCr is also discussed based on transmission electron microscopy results over a prolonged irradiation at both room and elevated temperatures. Compared with chemically complex NiFeCoCr, larger dislocation loops thus less lattice strain are expected to form in pure Ni. Moreover, the role of chemical disorder in this CSA is also investigated based on ab initio calculations using large supercells. Finally, to understand the impact of chemical complexity effect on defect structure evolution, this integrated research effort attempts to link the relatively large charge redistribution due to difference in valence electron counts resulting from alloying different 3d transition metal elements, moderate lattice distortion arising from similar adaptable atomic size, and notable suppressed or delayed damage evolution in NiFeCoCr.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2020

Six-junction III–V solar cells with 47.1% conversion efficiency under 143 Suns concentration

Single-junction flat-plate terrestrial solar cells are fundamentally limited to about 30% solar-to-electricity conversion efficiency, but multiple junctions and concentrated light make much higher efficiencies practically achievable. Until now, four-junction III–V concentrator solar cells have demonstrated the highest solar conversion efficiencies. Here, we demonstrate 47.1% solar conversion efficiency using a monolithic, series-connected, six-junction inverted metamorphic structure operated under the direct spectrum at 143 Suns concentration. Furthermore, when tuned to the global spectrum, a variation of this structure achieves a 1-Sun global efficiency of 39.2%. Nearly optimal bandgaps for six junctions were fabricated using alloys of III–V semiconductors. To develop these junctions, it was necessary to minimize threading dislocations in lattice-mismatched III–V alloys, prevent phase segregation in metastable quaternary III–V alloys and understand dopant diffusion in complex structures. Further reduction of the series resistance within this structure could realistically enable efficiencies over 50%.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

DOE OSTI2024

Grand canonically optimized grain boundary phases in hexagonal close-packed titanium

Grain boundaries (GBs) profoundly influence the properties and performance of materials, emphasizing the importance of understanding the GB structure and phase behavior. As recent computational studies have demonstrated the existence of multiple GB phases associated with varying the atomic density at the interface, we introduce a validated, open-source GRand canonical Interface Predictor (GRIP) tool that automates high-throughput, grand canonical optimization of GB structures. While previous studies of GB phases have almost exclusively focused on cubic systems, we demonstrate the utility of GRIP in an application to hexagonal close-packed titanium. We perform a systematic high-throughput exploration of tilt GBs in titanium and discover previously unreported structures and phase transitions. In low-angle boundaries, we demonstrate a coupling between point defect absorption and the change in the GB dislocation network topology due to GB phase transformations, which has important implications for the accommodation of radiation-induced defects.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

NASA NTRS2024

Wear and Neutron Shielding Resilience of Titanium-Hexagonal Boron Nitride Coatings Against Extreme Lunar Radiation and Thermal Cycles

Ti6Al4V and Al6061 are aerospace alloys used in lunar structural components and rovers owing to their high specific strength. However, they deteriorate rapidly when subjected to demanding conditions of the lunar environment, such as extreme thermal cycles, solar particle radiation, and abrasive regolith. Cryo-milled powders were employed to deposit hBN-reinforced protective titanium coatings through plasma spray (atmospheric APS and vacuum-VPS) with 2 and 10 vol% of hBN on Ti6Al4V and Al6061 substrates. These coatings were evaluated for durability under extreme lunar-like conditions, including thermal cycling, electron radiation, and synergistic (electron radiation-thermal cycle) exposure. The coatings exhibited radiation-induced hardening, resulting in a substantial increase in their microhardness ~20–40% compared to virgin condition. Bright-field transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analysis reveals the presence of high dislocation densities, black dot defects, and dislocation clusters, providing evidence of the severe impact of synergistic environmental stresses. Ball-on-disk tribological tests were conducted in the presence of JSC-1 A lunar regolith simulant to evaluate the wear performance of coatings. Compared to conventional Ti6Al4V substrate, 50%, 90%, and 70% reductions in wear volume were observed in the Ti/2 vol% hBN coatings in thermal-only, radiation-only, and synergistic environments. Neutron shielding tests indicate that the synergistic coatings offer higher neutron shielding performance by up to 28% compared to virgin coatings, attributed to improved neutron capture by 10B isotopes. Upon a comprehensive assessment and ranking of multiple coatings under varying conditions, the VPS Ti/2 vol% hBN coating emerges as the top choice for protection against extreme radiation and thermal cycles for future lunar explorations.

Boron nitride↗

DOE OSTI2023

Microstructure characterization and elastic-plastic self-consistent simulation studies of anisotropic deformation of β -tin

Uniaxial compression tests of 99.9% pure polycrystalline $β$-tin (Sn) were conducted at various strain rates (10 -3 /s, 10 -1 /s and 1/s) and temperatures (294 K and 193 K) to understand the effects of these variables on the stress–strain response, microstructure evolution, and stress relaxation behavior. Multiple Sn specimens were subjected to complex compressive loading/unloading/reloading paths at different strain rates. Specimens initially compressed at higher strain rates showed strain rate-dependent texture evolution and more pronounced relaxation upon reloading, as compared to those pre-strained at lower rates at room temperature (RT). Compression tests conducted at low temperature (193 K) revealed increased strength, similar to the enhanced strength observed when the strain rate was increased at RT. Neutron diffraction was employed to characterize the initial and final bulk textures of the RT specimens. Electron backscatter diffraction was utilized to examine the crystallographic grain orientation and morphology, thereby identifying the signatures of dislocation-mediated deformation, grain refinement, recrystallization, and twinning behaviors. Elastic-plastic self-consistent simulations were performed to investigate the deformation modes responsible for the strain rate-dependent macroscopic stress–strain response and texture evolution. Effects of crystallographic orientation on stress relaxation behavior was also examined. In conclusion, the model predictions are in reasonable agreement with experimental observations.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗