Experiment with simulation studies of heavy ion radiolysis of aqueous systems
Abstract for invited presentation
11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Results for “Radiolysis”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Radiolytic evaluation of a new technetium redox control reagent for advanced used nuclear fuel separations
Technetium is a problematic radioisotope for used nuclear fuel (UNF) and subsequent waste management owing to its high environmental mobility and coextraction in reprocessing technologies as the pertechnetate anion (TcO 4 - ). Consequently, several strategies are under development to control the transport of this radioisotope. A proposed approach is to use diaminoguanidine (DAG) for TcO 4 - and transuranic ion redox control. Although the initial DAG molecule is ultimately consumed in the redox process, its susceptibility to radiolysis is currently unknown under envisioned UNF reprocessing conditions, which is a critical knowledge gap for evaluating its overall suitability for this role. To this end, we report the impacts of steady-state gamma irradiation on the rate of DAG radiolysis in water, aqueous 2.0 M nitric acid (HNO 3 ), and in a biphasic solvent system composed of aqueous 2.0 M HNO 3 in contact with 1.5 M N,N-di-(2-ethylhexyl)isobutyramide (DEHiBA) dissolved in n-dodecane. In addition, we report chemical kinetics for the reaction of DAG with key transients arising from electron pulse radiolysis, specifically the hydrated electron (e aq - ), hydrogen atom (H ˙ ), and hydroxyl ( ˙ OH) and nitrate (NO 3 ˙ ) radicals. The DAG molecule exhibited significant reactivity with the ˙ OH and NO 3 ˙ radicals, indicating that oxidation would be the predominant degradation pathway in radiation environments. This is consistent with its role as a reducing agent. Steady-state gamma irradiations demonstrated that DAG is readily degraded within a few hundred kilogray, the rate of which was found to increase upon going from water to HNO 3 containing solutions and solvents systems. This was attributed to a thermal reaction between DAG and the predominant HNO 3 radiolysis product, nitrous acid (HNO 2 ), k(DAG + HNO 2 ) = 5480 ± 85 M -1 s -1 . Although no evidence was found for the radiolysis of DAG altering the radiation chemistry of the contacted DEHiBA/n-dodecane phase in the investigated biphasic system, the utility of DAG as a redox control reagent will likely be limited by significant competition with its degradation by HNO 2 .
38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗
Radiation-Induced Effects on the Extraction Properties of Hexa-n-octylnitrilo-triacetamide (HONTA) Complexes of Americium and Europium
The candidate An(III)/Ln(III) separation ligand hexa-n-octylnitrilo-triacetamide (HONTA) was irradiated under envisioned SELECT (Solvent Extraction from Liquid waste using Extractants of CHON-type for Transmutation) process conditions (n-dodecane/0.1 M HNO 3 ) using a solvent test loop in conjunction with cobalt-60 gamma irradiation. The extent of HONTA radiolysis and complimentary degradation product formation was quantified by HPLC-ESI-MS/MS. Further, the impact of HONTA radiolysis on process performance was evaluated by measuring the change in 243 Am and 154 Eu distribution ratios as a function of absorbed gamma dose. HONTA was found to decay exponentially with increasing dose, affording a dose coefficient of d = (4.48 ± 0.19) × 10 –3 kGy –1 . Multiple degradation products were detected by HPLC-ESI-MS/MS with dioctylamine being the dominant quantifiable species. Both 243 Am and 154 Eu distribution ratios exhibited an induction period of ~70 kGy for extraction (0.1 M HNO 3 ) and back-extraction (4.0 M HNO 3 ) conditions, after which both values decreased with absorbed dose. The decrease in distribution ratios was attributed to a combination of the destruction of HONTA and ingrowth of dioctylamine, which is capable of interfering in metal ion complexation. Furthermore, the loss of HONTA with absorbed gamma dose was predominantly attributed to its reaction with the n-dodecane radical cation (R˙ + ). These R˙ + reaction kinetics were measured for HONTA and its 241 Am and 154 Eu complexes using picosecond pulsed electron radiolysis techniques. All three second-order rate coefficients (k) were essentially diffusion limited in n-dodecane indicating a significant reaction pathway: k(HONTA + R˙ + ) = (7.6 ± 0.8) × 10 9 M –1 s –1 , k(Am(HONTA) 2 + R˙ + ) = (7.1 ± 0.7) × 10 10 M –1 s –1 , and k(Eu(HONTA) 2 + R˙ + ) = (9.5 ± 0.5) × 10 10 M –1 s –1 . HONTA-metal ion complexation afforded an order-of-magnitude increase in rate coefficient. Additional nanosecond time-resolved measurements showed that both direct and indirect HONTA radiolysis yielded the short-lived (< 100 ns) HONTA radical cation and a second long-lived (µs) species identified as the HONTA triplet excited state. The latter was confirmed by a series of oxygen quenching picosecond pulsed electron measurements, affording a quenching rate coefficient of k( 3 [HONTA]* + O 2 ) = 2.2 × 10 8 M –1 s –1 . Overall, both the HONTA radical cation and triplet excited state are important precursors to the suite of measured HONTA degradation products.
38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗
Discerning the effect of various irradiation modes on the corrosion of Zircaloy-4
Using proton irradiation, this study investigates the individual influence of several factors on the corrosion kinetics of Zircaloy-4 in a hydrogenated water environment simulating a Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR). Using both simultaneous irradiation-corrosion and autoclave corrosion, we separately examine: (i) the effect of pre-irradiation on modifying the structure of the material, (ii) the impact of irradiation on creating defects in the growing oxide layer during corrosion, and (iii) the influence of irradiation on increasing the corrosion potential through radiolysis during corrosion. To replicate neutron-irradiated microstructure, two proton pre-irradiation schedules were employed: Schedule 1 (isothermal irradiation at 350 °C to 5 dpa) to simulate high-temperature PWR conditions, and Schedule 2 (two-step process: irradiation to 2.5 dpa at -10 °C followed by 2.5 dpa at 350 °C) to simulate lower temperature PWR and Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) conditions. Long-term autoclave corrosion testing over 360 days at 320 °C revealed no significant difference between unirradiated samples and those pre-irradiated according to either schedule, with all samples exhibiting sub-cubic kinetics within the pre-transition regime. Irradiated samples underwent Simultaneous Irradiation Corrosion (SIC) tests, corroding in 320 °C water while being irradiated with protons. Corrosion was found to accelerate in all SIC-tested samples relative to autoclave conditions, with the greatest increase observed in non-pre-irradiated samples. Pre-irradiation with either schedule resulted in a slower corrosion rate compared to non-pre-irradiated regions under SIC conditions. The degree of radiolysis observed in the SIC tests surpassed typical PWR conditions, approaching levels found in BWRs. Radiolysis products were identified as the primary contributors to accelerated corrosion, corroborated by radiolysis bar tests. Furthermore, these findings underscore the intricate interactions between irradiation, corrosion, and water chemistry in determining Zircaloy-4 corrosion kinetics within nuclear reactor environments.
Pressurized Water Reactor↗
Endogenic and Exogenic Contributions to Visible-wavelength Spectra of Europa’s Trailing Hemisphere
The composition of Europa’s trailing hemisphere reflects the combined influences of endogenous geologic resurfacing and exogenous sulfur radiolysis. Using spatially resolved visible-wavelength spectra of Europa obtained with the Hubble Space Telescope, we map multiple spectral features across the trailing hemisphere and compare their geographies with the distributions of large-scale geology, magnetospheric bombardment, and surface color. Based on such comparisons, we interpret some aspects of our spectra as indicative of purely exogenous sulfur radiolysis products and other aspects as indicative of radiolysis products formed from a mixture of endogenous material and magnetospheric sulfur. The spatial distributions of two of the absorptions seen in our spectra—a widespread downturn toward the near-UV and a distinct feature at 530 nm—appear consistent with sulfur allotropes previously suggested from ground-based spectrophotometry. However, the geographies of two additional features—an absorption feature at 360 nm and the spectral slope at red wavelengths—are more consistent with endogenous material that has been altered by sulfur radiolysis. We suggest irradiated sulfate salts as potential candidates for this material, but we are unable to identify particular species with the available data.
79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗
Radiolytic and Thermolytic Bubble Gas Hydrogen Composition
The original version of this report described the development of a mathematical model for the estimation of the hydrogen composition of gas bubbles trapped in radioactive waste. The model described therein used a material balance approach to accurately incorporate the rates of hydrogen generation by several physical phenomena and scale the aforementioned rates in a manner that allows calculation of the final hydrogen composition. The proposed model accounted for the following physical phenomena: H 2 generation by primary radiolysis of water and salt solutions; H 2 generation by secondary radiolysis of formate and glycolate molecules in solution; Observation of negligible H 2 generation by thermolysis of formate at temperatures below 120 °C; H 2 generation by thermolysis of glycolate in caustic solutions; O 2 consumption by radiolysis and thermolysis of organic species. Additionally, the originally-proposed model conservatively excluded the following physical phenomena that are known to contribute slightly to the hydrogen composition in trapped gas bubbles: Equilibrium concentration of water vapor in trapped gas bubbles; Generation of N 2 O during radiolysis of nitrite solutions; Incomplete consumption of O 2 by organics. In this revision, the methodology for glycolate thermolysis has been improved to agree with recent findings published by Woodham and Martino. Furthermore, considerations for the thermolysis of organics other than glycolate have been made. In the case of non-glycolate organics, no evidence of non-flammable gas formation exists. Therefore, non-glycolate thermolysis is considered additive for conservatism.
12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗
Rapid Radiolytic Degradation of Amino Acids in the Martian Shallow Subsurface: Implications for the Search for Extinct Life
Amino acids are fundamental to life as we know them as the monomers of proteins and enzymes. They are also readily synthesized under a variety of plausible prebiotic conditions and are common in carbon-rich meteorites. Thus, they represent a reasonable class of organics to target in the search for prebiotic chemistry or chemical evidence of life on Mars. However, regardless of their origin, amino acids and other organic molecules present in near-surface regolith and rocks on Mars can be degraded by exposure to cosmic rays that can penetrate to a depth of a few meters. We exposed several pure amino acids in dry and hydrated silicate mixtures and in mixtures of silicates with perchlorate salts to gamma radiation at various temperatures and radiation doses representative of the martian near-subsurface. We found that irradiation of amino acids mixed with dry silica powder increased the rate of amino acid radiolysis, with the radiolysis constants of amino acids in silicate mixtures at least a factor of 10 larger compared with the radiolysis constants of amino acids alone. The addition of perchlorate salts to the silicate samples or hydration of silicate samples further accelerated the rate of amino acid destruction during irradiation and increased the radiolysis constants by a factor of *1.5. Our results suggest that even low-molecular-weight amino acids could degrade in just *20 million years in the top 10 cm of the martian surface regolith and rock, and even faster if the material contains elevated abundances of hydrated silicate minerals or perchlorates. We did not detect evidence of amino acid racemization after gamma radiation exposure of the samples, which indicates that the chirality of some surviving amino acids may still be preserved. Our experimental results suggest serious challenges for the search of ancient amino acids and other potential organic biosignatures in the top 2 m of the martian surface.
Alexander A. Pavlov↗
Solvated Electron in Acetonitrile: Radiation Yield, Absorption Spectrum, and Equilibrium between Cavity- and Solvent-Localized States
The equilibrium between a solvent cavity-localized electron, ecav-, and a dimeric solvent anion, (CH 3 CN)$_{2}^{•-}$, which are the two lowest energy states of the solvated electron in acetonitrile, has been investigated by pulse radiolysis at 233-353 K. The enthalpy and entropy for the e$_{cav}^{-}$ to (CH 3 CN)$_{2}^{•-}$ conversion amount to -11.2 ± 0.3 kcal/mol and -39.3 ± 1.2 cal/(mol K), corresponding to a 0.44 ± 0.35 equilibrium constant at 25 °C. The radiation yield of the solvated electron has been quantified using a Co(II) macrocycle that scavenges electrons with a 1.55 × 10 11 M -1 s -1 rate constant. The apparent yield increases without saturation over the attainable scavenger concentration range, reaching 2.8 per 100 eV; this value represents the lower limit for the acetonitrile ionization yield in pulse radiolysis. The apparent molar absorption coefficient of (20.8 ± 1.5) × 10 3 M -1 cm -1 at 1450 nm and 20 °C for the solvated electron and individual vis-near-infrared (NIR) absorption spectra of e$_{cav}^{-}$ and (CH 3 CN)$_{2}^{•-}$ are derived from the data. Variances with previous reports are thoroughly discussed. All together, these results resolve several controversies concerning the solvated electron properties in acetonitrile and furnish requisite data for quantitative pulse radiolysis investigations in this commonly used solvent.
38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗
Examination of the Radiolytic Stability of the GENIORS Solvent
The INL radiolysis test loop system has been employed to evaluate the effects of gamma radiolysis the stability and performance of the GENIORS solvent extraction process. This report describes details and results of the experiments performed and documents completion of milestone M3FT-21IN030101024 “Testing of Radiolytic Stability of m-TDDGA Based Solvent at INL”. The purpose of the proposed dynamic irradiation tests to be performed is to evaluate the radiolytic stability of the GENIORS process solvent for An/Ln recovery under process-like conditions. Recent research efforts within the European Union GENIORS project have focused upon demonstrating additional process improvements. These improvements include simplification of the solvent composition, use of reagents composed of only C, H, O, and N atoms (the CHON principle), identification of a diglycolamide derivative with more favorable Pu loading behavior, and use of an aqueous soluble stripping reagent that is not sulfonated. As a result, a new solvent utilizing dimethyl-N,N,N’,N’-tetradecyl-diglycolamide (cis-mTDDGA) as the An/Ln extractant and the aqueous soluble 2,6-bis[1-(propan-1-ol)-1,2,3-triazol-4yl]-pyridine (PTD) as the An/Ln stripping reagent was proposed. The impact of gamma radiolysis upon the efficacy of the GENIORS process solvent was evaluated by determining the americium, europium, and cerium distribution ratios as a function of absorbed dose. The measured distribution ratios demonstrated that the GENIORS solvent did undergo radiolytic degradation. However, at absorbed doses corresponding to realistic process conditions, the extraction and stripping performance of the solvent remains acceptable. Compositional analysis of the irradiated solvent revealed a decrease in the concentration of cis-mTDDGA, which is consistent with the observed changes in metal distribution ratios as a function of absorbed dose.
38 - RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCL↗
Spent-fuel recycling molecule degradation product standards can be produced with preparative liquid chromatography
Solvent systems used for spent nuclear fuel separation schemes are subject to intense radiation fields from the spent fuel, resulting in a degradation of separation performance over time from both the radiolytic destruction of active compounds (extractants, holdback agents, etc.) and the production of degradation compounds (compounds produced from the destruction of the active compounds). Development of a quantitative understanding of the effects of radiolysis on separations is impeded by a near-complete lack of availability of degradation products from chemical manufacturers. Synthesis of these degradation products through traditional means is both cost and time prohibitive, inhibiting advancement of new fuel separation processes. We hypothesize that comprehensive sets of degradation products can be synthesized using preparative radiolysis, and purified using high performance liquid chromatography in quantities sufficient for unequivocal identification and subsequent use as quantitative analytical studies. Achieving this objective will facilitate development of a much more accurate understanding of radiolysis reactions and their effects on solvent extraction processes, positioning Idaho National Laboratory (INL) in a leadership role in the science of fuel cycle separations. We propose producing these degradation compounds by irradiating concentrated samples of solvent ligands in the INL gamma irradiator, separating the resulting mixture with preparative chromatography, and removing the mobile phase in the separated fractions with a vacuum concentrator. This will yield milligram to gram quantities of purified degradation products, sufficient for fundamental research, at a fraction of the time and cost of synthesis. Facile production of separation molecule degradation products at minimal cost will enable the fundamental research that will accelerate the development of fuel cycles that will ensure the competitiveness of nuclear energy.
37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
Modeling the Fundamental Radiation Chemistry of the Organic Diluent, and the Effect of Metal Ion Complexation on the Radiochemical Behavior of Active Compounds
All used nuclear fuel (UNF) reprocessing technologies must operate efficiently in the presence of an intense, multi-component (predominantly alpha, beta, and gamma) radiation field. Consequently, radiation-induced degradation of reprocessing systems is of concern, as it negatively impacts process performance over time due to the destruction of both active compounds (ligands, phase modifiers, holdback agents, etc.) and the formation of degradation products. Reprocessing solvent system radiolysis has been linked to changes in separation efficiency and physical properties of solvent mixtures, solvent-recycle longevity, crud formation, and other unexpected outcomes that impact the efficient recovery of valuable materials (e.g., the actinides) and the volume of hazardous radioactive waste for final disposal, i.e., in a geological repository. Consequently, a fundamental understanding of radiolytic processes and their effects on reprocessing solvent system performance is critical for: (i) the cost-effective development and innovation of separation technologies; (ii) the design and implementation of predictive radiation chemical models for process monitoring and lifetimes; and (iii) potentially the ability to exploit radiolytic phenomenon to our benefit, e.g., strategic radiolysis of active molecules to liberate specific degradation products that aid subsequent process stages. Despite extensive investigation into the radiolytic behavior of active solvent system compounds, little attention has been given to understanding (i) the radiation chemical behavior and modification of the organic diluent and (ii) the effect of metal ion complexation on the radiochemical behavior of active compounds.
38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗
Radiolytic evaluation of select sulfur chlorides (S 2 Cl 2 and SOCl 2 ) for advanced low temperature chlorination of zirconium-based used nuclear fuel cladding
New sulfur chloride compounds—sulfur monochloride (S 2 Cl 2 ) and thionyl chloride (SOCl 2 )—have been proposed as alternative chlorinating agents for the chemical decladding of zirconium-based used nuclear fuel cladding materials. However, the radiation stability of these compounds has not been thoroughly evaluated, despite envisioned process conditions involving intense, multi-component radiation fields. Knowledge of the radiation chemistry of these sulfur chlorides is essential for the development and optimization of alternative chlorination technologies. To this end, we present preliminary findings on the gamma radiolysis of neat S 2 Cl 2 and SOCl 2 at ambient temperature up to ~ 34 MGy. In this study, Raman spectroscopy and density functional theory calculations were used to identify the Raman-active degradation products from S 2 Cl 2 and SOCl 2 radiolysis. Both sulfur chloride compounds exhibited significant radiation resistance, with respect to changes in the Raman signatures of the parent compounds and the ingrowth of Raman-active degradation products. For S 2 Cl 2 , molecular chlorine (Cl 2 ) was directly identified as the predominant degradation product, which was completely consumed at higher absorbed doses (> 9 MGy). Similarly, the main degradation product from SOCl 2 radiolysis was also Cl 2 , although in this system it continued to grow in with dose over the entire dose range. Further, an “S=O” containing degradation product(s) was also identified as a compliment to Cl 2 . Overall, the perceived radiation resistance of these sulfur chloride compounds makes them suitable for inclusion in a used nuclear fuel chemical decladding process, especially as radiolytically formed Cl 2 can be used to reform the parent compounds, thereby increasing the longevity of the solvents used.
38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗
Kinetics of Radiation-induced Cr( II ) and Cr( III ) Redox Chemistry in Molten LiCl-KCl Eutectic
Chromium (Cr) is a frequent constituent of the metal alloys proposed for molten salt nuclear reactor (MSR) applications, and is typically the least noble metal ion present. Consequently, chromium is preferentially corroded into molten salt solutions. Here, the redox poise and redox cycling of chromium ions in the salt can greatly influence its corrosivity towards structural alloys, ultimately impacting the longevity of MSR systems. Radiation-induced chemistry is expected to play a significant role in determining the chromium oxidation state distribution during MSR operations. In the present research, electron pulse radiolysis techniques were employed to characterize the reactivity of Cr(II) and Cr(III) ions with primary radiolysis products in molten lithium chloride–potassium chloride (LiCl–KCl) eutectic over a temperature range of 400–600 °C. Both chromium oxidation states were found to rapidly react with the primary products of molten chloride salt radiolysis, i.e., the solvated electron (e S - ) and the dichlorine radical anion (Cl 2 ˙ - ). For reactions with the e S - , second-order rate coefficients (k) of k = (4.1 ± 0.2) and (6.1 ± 0.3) × 10 10 M -1 s -1 at 400 °C for Cr(II) and Cr(III), respectively, were determined. Temperature-dependent measurements allowed for the derivation of activation parameters for electron capture by Cr(II) and Cr(III). Both chromium ions also react with Cl 2 ˙ - , k = (7.2 ± 0.3) and (1.4 ± 0.1) × 10 9 M -1 s -1 at 400 °C for Cr(II) and Cr(III), respectively.
37 - INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL AND ANALYTICAL C↗
Mapping Electron Beam-Induced Radiolytic Damage in Molecular Crystals
Every electron crystallography experiment is fundamentally constrained by radiation damage [1]. Despite its crucial importance, little is understood about the onset and progression of radiolysis in beam-sensitive molecular crystals [2]. Since the typical metric used for monitoring the degradation induced by radiolysis is the attenuation of Bragg reflections in electron diffraction patterns [3], the scope of previous analyses [2-6] has mostly been limited to indirect observation via the back focal plane. Here, a simultaneous visualization of the effects of electron beam-induced radiolysis—in both real space and reciprocal space—remains elusive.
74 ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS↗
Transient Coupled Chemical-Thermal-Fluid Field Simulation for Sealed Aluminum-clad Spent Nuclear Fuel Storage Canister
As the first step toward developing three-dimensional (3D) multi-physics computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model for unsealed and vented canister storage system, a 3D CFD model coupled with bulk gas radiolysis reactions was developed first for sealed DOE standard canisters filled with inert gas and trace amount of air and water. The workflow for constructing canister-scale 3D CFD models and coupling with gas phase radiolysis reactions were established, which can be readily extended to unsealed, vented canister storage system. This interim milestone report documents the theory of the model, workflow to establish radiolysis reaction network, and initial simulations of the evolutions of thermal fields and hydrogen gas concentrations within sealed DOE standard canisters over long period of time. In addition, a mesh refinement test was done to show that increasing the models mesh refinement had negligible impact upon the temperature profiles.
12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗
The radioracemization of isovaline - Cosmochemical implications
The optically pure D- and L-enantiomers of isovaline, which cannot be racemized by ordinary chemical mechanisms involving alpha-hydrogen removal and which has been isolated in apparently racemic form from the Murchison meteorite, have been subjected to partial radiolysis by the ionizing radiation from a 3000-Ci Co-60 gamma-ray source. Both in the anhydrous and hydrated solid states and as solid sodium or hydrochloride salts each enantiomer suffered significant radioracemization of the undestroyed residue during its partial radiolysis. The sodium salt of isovaline in 0.1-M aqueous solution suffered extensive radiolysis with relatively small radiation doses, but showed no detectable radioracemization. The significance of these observations with respect to the primordial enantiomeric composition of the isovaline (and other amino acids) indigenous to meteorites is discussed.
Bonner, W. A.↗
Beta-decay, Bremsstrahlen, and the origin of molecular chirality
A brief review is presented of the Vester-Ulbricht beta-decay Bremsstrahlen hypothesis for the origin of optical activity, and of subsequent experiments designed to test it. Certain experiments along these lines, begun in 1974 and involving the irradiation of racemic and optically active amino acids in a 61.7 KCi Sr-90-Y-90 Bremsstrahlen source, have now been completed and are described. After 10.89 years of irradiation with a total Bremsstrahlen dose of 2.5 x 10 to the 9th rads, crystalline DL-leucine, norleucine, and norvaline suffered 47.2, 33.6, and 27.4 percent radiolysis, respectively, but showed no evidence whatsoever of asymmetric degradation. Dand L-Leucine underwent about 48 percent radiolysis and showed 2.4-2.9 percent radioracemization. Other samples in solution were too severely degraded to analyze. Probable intrinsic reasons for the failure of the Vester-Ulbricht mechanism to afford asymmetric radiolysis in the present and related experiments involving beta-decay Bremsstrahlen are enumerated.
Bonner, W. A.↗
New estimates of asymmetric decomposition of racemic mixtures by natural beta-radiation sources
Some recent calculations that appeared to invalidate the Vester-Ulbricht hypothesis, which suggests that the chirality of biological molecules originates from the beta-radiolysis of prebiotic racemic mixtures, are reexamined. These calculations apparently showed that the radiolysis-induced chiral polarization can never exceed the chiral polarization produced by statistical fluctuations. It is here shown that several overly restrictive conditions were imposed on these calculations which, when relaxed, allow the radiolysis-induced polarization to exceed that produced by statistical fluctuations, in accordance with the Vester-Ulbricht hypothesis.
Hegstrom, R. A.↗