Testing Vpin on Big Data Response to Reflecting on the Vpin Dispute
The authors of this note are computer scientists and mathematicians from Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. Most of us are specialists in high-performance computing. In 2011, at the suggestion of a CFTC commissioner, we started examining the effectiveness of VPIN as a leading indicator of unusual market events such as the “Flash Crash” of 2010. The preliminary result of that work was published as a conference paper. Our work was the first to show that VPIN could generate strong signals based on trading records of individual stocks. On a number of stocks, VPIN generated strong signals more than an hour before the “Flash Crash.” This lead-time could be valuable for market makers, regulators and traders in general. To further test the effectiveness of VPIN, we recently expanded our tests to a much larger set of test data, including the trading records of the 94 most liquid futures contracts from beginning of 2007 to middle of 2012. We set out to verify the following hypothesis: the volatility of trading is higher than the average in a time window (we call the event horizon) after VPIN value crosses a threshold. Our work carefully examined the parameters controlling the computation of VPIN as well as the event horizon and the VPIN threshold. In this largest-ever study of a leading indicator based on market microstructure, we examined 16,000 combinations of these parameters, and found that the average false positive rate can be reduced to 7%.