MRWFD Kr Capture Project
Progress report presentation to DOE program representatives.
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Progress report presentation to DOE program representatives.
A new daily as-run thermal analysis was performed at the Idaho National Laboratory on the Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR) test experiment number one at the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR). This thermal analysis incorporates gas gaps changing with time during the irradiation experiment. The purpose of this analysis was to calculate the daily average temperatures of each compact to compare with experimental results. Post irradiation examination (PIE) measurements of the graphite holder and fuel compacts showed the gas gaps changed from the beginning of life. The control temperature gas gap and the fuel compact - graphite holder gas gaps were modeled with a linear change from the original fabrication gap dimensions to the end of irradiation measurements. A steady-state thermal analysis was performed for each daily calculation with the commercial finite element heat transfer code ABAQUS. These new thermal predictions more closely match the experimental data taken during the experiment than previous analyses. Results are presented comparing normalized compact average temperatures to normalized log(R/B) Kr-85m. The R/B term is the measured release rate divided by the predicted birth rate for the isotope Kr-85m. Correlations between these two normalized values are presented. (authors)
The inverted geometry (fuel outside coolant tubes) has been previously investigated at MIT for application in gas-cooled fast reactors and pressurized water-cooled thermal reactors. Venting has also been studied for conventional fuel pins and was employed for those in the Dounreay Fast Reactor. In the present work the inverted fuel approach was adopted because it allows high fuel volume fraction, reduction of the coolant void reactivity, neutron leakage and enrichment, as well as lower pressure drop for the same channel length because grids and wire wraps are no longer necessary. Furthermore most results also apply to venting of conventional fuel pins. Physical and chemical behavior of volatile fission products in sodium was investigated to determine the maximum activity inventory which would eventually be released into the primary sodium. Results of this analysis show that the most troublesome radionuclides in terms of propensity to escape from the venting system are noble gases ({sup 85}Kr and {sup 133}Xe), and cesium ({sup 134}Cs and {sup 137}Cs). A final vented inverted fuel assembly design is proposed which meets all the design goals which have been set. Additionally purification systems were devised to reduce radionuclide activity of the coolant and the cover gas to tolerable levels. It is concluded that vented inverted (or vented conventional pin) fuel is a feasible concept and has sufficiently promising advantages - increasing fuel volume fraction to 50% and core outlet temperature by 20 deg. C, hence incrementing plant thermal efficiency by about 1% - to warrant serious consideration for future SFR designs. (authors)
Radiological Impact Assessment (RIA) following postulated accident i.e Loss of Coolant Accident (LOCA) with failed Emergency Core Cooling System (ECCS), performed as part of the reactor safety analysis of a typical 700 MWe Indian Pressurized Heavy Water Reactor(PHWR). The rationale behind the assessment is that the public needs to be protected in the event that the postulated accident results in radionuclide release outside containment. Radionuclides deliver dose to the human body through various pathways namely, plume submersion, exposure due to ground deposition, inhalation and ingestion. The total exposure dose measured in terms of total effective dose equivalent (TEDE) is the sum of doses to a hypothetical adult human at exclusion zone boundary by all the exposure pathways. The analysis provides the important inputs to decide upon the type of emergency counter measures to be adopted during the postulated accident. The importance of the various pathways in terms of contribution to the total effective dose equivalent(TEDE) is also assessed with respect to time of exposure. Inhalation and plume gamma dose are the major contributors towards TEDE during initial period of accident whereas ingestion and ground shine dose start dominating in TEDE in the extended period of exposure. Moreover, TEDE is initially dominated by I-131, Kr-88, Te-132, I-133 and Sr-89, whereas, as time progresses, Xe-133,I-131 and Te-132 become the main contributors. (authors)
During the processing of used nuclear fuel (UNF), volatile radionuclides will be discharged from the facility stack if no recovery processes are in place to limit their release. The volatile radionuclides of concern are {sup 3}H, {sup 14}C, {sup 85}Kr, and {sup 129}I. There are three key regulations that address the release of these radionuclides to the environment- 40 CFR 61, 40 CFR 190, and 10 CFR 20. These regulations apply to the total radionuclide release and establish dose limits for the maximum exposed individual (MEI) in the public both in terms of whole body dose and dose to specific organs such as the thyroid. Each radionuclide released to the environment contributes to the total dose to some degree. In this paper we attempt to evaluate the efficiency requirements for the capture processes to limit the doses to the MEI to regulatory levels. Since the total amount of each volatile radionuclide present in the UNF changes with the age of the fuel, the respective capture requirements also change with time. Specifically, we are interested in the impact of the decreasing contribution of {sup 3}H and {sup 85}Kr, which have relatively short half-lives, 12.32 y and 10.76 y, respectively, with the increasing age of the fuel (i.e., time between when the UNF is removed from the reactor and the time it is processed) on the capture requirements. In this paper we examine the capture requirements for these four radionuclides for three fuel types (pressurized water reactor [PWR] with uranium oxide fuel [UOX], PWR with mixed oxide fuel [MOX], and an advanced high temperature gas-cooled reactor [AHTGR]), several burnup values, and time out of reactor extending to 200 y. We calculate doses to the MEI with the EPA code CAP-88 and look at two dose contribution cases. In the first case, we assume that the total allowable dose is attributed to only the four volatile radionuclides. This establishes the lowest capture efficiency value possible. Since this is unrealistic, because it assumes zero dose contribution from all other radionuclides, we also examine a second case, where only 10% of the allowable dose is assigned to the four volatile radionuclides. We calculate the required decontamination factors (DFs) for both of these cases for the three fuel types, multiple fuel burnups, and fuel ages and determine whether or not the dose to the whole body or to the thyroid that drives the capture requirements would require additional effluent controls for the shorter half-life volatile radionuclides based on dose considerations. This analysis indicates that the principal isotopes of concern are generally {sup 3}H and {sup 129}I, the latter requiring the highest DFs. The maximum DF value for {sup 129}I is 8000 for the evaluated cases and assumptions used. ∼60 for fresh fuels. The DF for {sup 14}C could be as high as 30 for certain fuels. These values are based on just meeting the regulatory limits, and additional engineering margins (perhaps 3x to 10x or higher) should be applied to provide a safety factor for compliance. However, by assuming less conservative dose allocations, taller stacks, different radionuclide speciation, fuel aging, and other reprocessing facility design and location parameters, the DF requirements could be significantly reduced. (authors)
Off-gas generated from the reprocessing of used nuclear fuel contains a mixture of several radioactive gases including {sup 129}I{sub 2}, {sup 85}Kr, HTO, and {sup 14}CO{sub 2}. Over the past few decades, various separation and recovery processes have been studied for capturing these gases. Adsorption data for gaseous mixtures of species can be difficult to determine experimentally. Therefore, procedures capable of predicting the adsorption behavior of mixtures need to be developed from the individual isotherms of each of the pure species. A particular isotherm model of interest for the pure species is the Generalized Statistical Thermodynamic Adsorption isotherm. This model contains an adjustable number of parameters and will therefore describe a wide range of adsorption isotherms for a variety of components. A code has been developed in C++ to perform the non-linear regression analysis necessary for the determination of the isotherm parameters, as well as the least number of parameters needed to describe an entire set of data. (authors)
Gamma emission tomography measurements have been performed at the Halden Reactor Project using a dedicated instrument, which utilizes a high-resolution gamma-ray detector allowing for spectroscopic analysis of the measurement data. Measurements have been performed on two fuel assemblies consisting of 9 and 13 rods, respectively, in order to characterize the rod-wise radioactive source distribution (i.e. fission and activation products) within the fuel. The 9-rod fuel assembly consisted of five fuel rods at 50 MWd/kgUO{sub 2} and four fuel rods at 26 MWd/kgUO{sub 2}, where all rods had cooled for approximately 22 years at the time of measurement. The rods in the 13-rod assembly all had a burnup of ∼4.5 MWd/kgUO{sub 2}, and cooled for approximately 1.5 years at the time of measurement. In this paper, the tomographic data was reconstructed using the Filtered Backprojection technique, where no consideration to gamma-ray attenuation in the fuel was given. Due to the varying burnup and cooling times between the assemblies, the spectroscopic data also varied between the respective sets of measurements. The high-resolution detector used in the measurements allowed for tomographic reconstruction of many gamma-ray peaks corresponding to various fission products and activation products present in the fuel and structural materials. For instance the gamma tomography technique has shown rod-wise variation in the contents of fission products between the high-burnup and low-burnup rods. The rod-internal distribution of fission products was also observed where the volatile fission product {sup 137}Cs is observed to have migrated to the outer pellet surface in fuel rods in the 9-rod assembly, and where the gaseous fission product {sup 85}Kr is observed to have a uniform distribution in each fuel rod's gas plenum.
The acoustic sensor has been specially designed in order to provide a non-destructive technique to easily carry out the measurement of the internal gas pressure and gas composition of a LWR nuclear fuel rod. This sensor has been achieved in 2007 and is now covered by an international patent. In 2015, we presented a generation of acoustic sensors devoted to the characterization of fission gas. The gas composition can be defined with an uncertainty of about 1% and the pressure with an uncertainty of about 10 % (for around 50 bars and a gas mixture containing 20% Xe/Kr). This measurement is possible in hot laboratory facility using viscous liquid to couple the sensor with the rod. We develop a new acoustic sensor for an application in a spent fuel pool without viscous liquid to couple the sensor with the rod. This application consists in determining the default rod in a fuel assembly which has been declared 'no leak-proof' during the fuel discharging of the reactor. We develop a new method based on the detection of gas pressure drop into the fuel rod. This new method could replace the current one which is based on the detection of water into the fuel rod. The new generation of transducer and the associated methodology are now operational in laboratory for nondestructive measurement under water and enable to detect the gas pressure drop into the fuel rod. (authors)
A method is proposed to evaluate the extent of subcriticality of an accident-damaged nuclear reactor. In this method the radiation ratio of two FP rare gas nuclides, {sup 88}Kr and {sup 133}Xe, is measured. From the measured value, the value in the core is estimated by correcting for the time required by the gases to diffuse from the core to the measuring point. A simple expression for neutron multiplication factor has been derived, which uses the corrected {sup 88}Kr-to-{sup 133}Xe radiation ratio and the {sup 88}Kr-to-{sup 133}Xe fission yield ratios from {sup 244}Cm and {sup 235}U but no information on the amount or distribution of fissile materials, making the proposed method very simple. The method has the advantage that FP rare gases can easily leak from the reactor core through many openings and gaps, reaching germanium counters without reacting with other materials. (authors)
Nuclear fuel reprocessing is being considered in the United States as part of an effort to help meet US energy needs and as a means to improve waste management. During the chemical processing of UNF to recover the valuable components for reuse, a number of volatile radionuclides will be released into the off-gas streams of the reprocessing plant. These volatile radionuclides include H-3, C-14, Kr-85, and I-129. Off-gas abatement systems for the volatile radionuclides will be required to ensure that air emissions from a UNF reprocessing facility can meet or exceed emission requirements set forth by the US Environmental Protection Agency and the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission. An initial engineering evaluation of offgas abatement systems was completed recently. The evaluation addressed the designs of the head-end offgas treatment system, which typically includes both the shear off-gas and the dissolver off-gas and vessel off-gas treatment system. Based on this study, the waste volumes for each of the four primary volatile radionuclides (H-3, C-14, Kr-85, and I-129) were estimated. Included in these estimates were the nonradioactive isotopes and the 'tramp' elements found in air (e.g., Kr and C-12 as CO{sub 2}) and process chemicals (e.g., I and Cl). Because the final waste form for these radionuclides has not been selected, estimated volumes were calculated for various alternative waste forms as appropriate. The resulting waste volume for I was found to be highly dependent on the final waste form selected and increased by a factor of 2 to 4 by tramp halogens that would be released into the off-gas stream from the process chemicals. The volume of tritiated water from the fuel was quite small, but the estimated volume of the final waste form depended on the tritium management approach employed within the reprocessing plant. The Kr waste volume was calculated assuming pure Kr (i.e., assuming complete separation of Xe and Ar). For the case of no Xe separation, the estimated waste volume increased by factor of ∼10. Argon from the air, if not removed, increased the estimated volume by a factor of 425. The estimated volume of C-14 waste was dominated by the CO{sub 2} from the air leaking into the processing cell. (authors)
Four radionuclides have been identified as being sufficiently volatile in reprocessing of nuclear fuel that their gaseous release needs to be controlled to meet U.S. regulatory requirements. These radionuclides are {sup 3}H, {sup 14}C, {sup 85}Kr, and {sup 129}I. Previous studies have discussed the need for treating off-gas streams to control {sup 3}H, {sup 14}C, {sup 85}Kr, and {sup 129}I from the reprocessing of used nuclear fuel (UNF) and the regulations that set the limits for releases from such a facility. These regulations ultimately prescribe the decontamination factor (DF) that must be met in the facility. Jubin et al. examined the role of off-gas pathways since the gaseous radionuclides can partition to different reprocessing off-gas streams. Based on this report and subsequent analysis, the required DF for {sup 129}I could be 1000 to 3000. The required DF for {sup 3}H could be as high as 200, depending on the age of the fuel processed. The DF for {sup 85}Kr could be up to ∼35, also depending on fuel age. The required DF for {sup 14}C is 1 in many cases (no treatment required) but could be higher in specific cases. While iodine has been the focus of a number of studies due to the high DF requirements on multiple escape pathways, it is clear from the studies noted above that the control of tritium will also be a significant issue for future reprocessing plants, especially if processing relatively short-cooled fuels (<10 yr post reactor discharge). Tritium contained in a UNF matrix will be released into the liquid and off-gas streams during fuel reprocessing. The amount released into the process streams is a function of the type and burnup of the fuel processed, and the chemical processes employed within the reprocessing plant. Previous studies have examined the tritium capture requirements for the reprocessing facility assuming that all of the tritium is volatilized in the head-end operations, i.e., tritium pretreatment is employed and tritium is completely released from the cladding. This is clearly a worst case scenario from the standpoint of the amount of tritium that could be released, but the scenario tends to limit the release pathway to the head-end off-gas stream. In this analysis, the volume of HTO and the HTO to H{sub 2}O ratio for each of the three plant-wide tritium DFs were determined. The overall amount of HTO that had to be captured from the off-gas streams was virtually the same for the three DF cases evaluated; 98%, 99% and 99.5% of the tritium in the fuel entering the plant needed to be recovered for overall plant DFs of 50, 100 and 200, respectively. The use of the 'tritium barrier' to limit the spread of HTO from the head-end systems to the balance of the plant results in an increase in tritiated waste concentration in the head-end recycle acid systems which results in a decrease in the total amount of HTO + H{sub 2}O that must recovered from the gaseous effluent from the plant. The use of the 'tritium barrier' decreases the waste volume due to the higher HTO:H{sub 2}O ratio in the treated off-gas stream. The results also show that increasing the acid recycle percentage increases the concentration of HTO within the UNF reprocessing plant. This is then manifested in less HTO + H{sub 2}O that must be recovered from the gaseous effluents. Finally, the application of tritium recovery on the recycle acid reduces the HTO concentration in the recycle acid stream and generates a separate HTO + H{sub 2}O stream that must be managed. However, the resulting volume of tritium-containing waste generated plant-wide is a function of the selectivity of the tritium recovery system and the ability of the tritium recovery system to limit the accumulation of HTO in the recycle acid such that the HTO + H{sub 2}O recovered from gaseous effluents does not contribute significantly to the overall tritium waste volume. (authors)
The need to control emissions of the gaseous radionuclides to the air during nuclear fuel recycling is widely recognized. Gaseous radionuclides can partition to off-gas streams emanating from the various individual processes used in the recycle plant, such as from the mechanical head end (shear), tritium pretreatment, fuel dissolver, vessel vents, cell ventilation, and conversion operations. In traditional recycle plants, the bulk of the four primary volatile fission products (i.e., {sup 3}H, {sup 14}C, {sup 85}Kr, and {sup 129}I) is released in the head-end processes, for example, the dissolution process. The usual off-gas treatment sequence of operations targets removal of tritium (as {sup 3}HHO), iodine, carbon (as {sup 14}CO{sub 2}), and the noble gases, in that order. Water and iodine are captured first because the other species are relatively unimpeded by the sorbents used for water and iodine, so they flow downstream to additional treatment processes. Water and iodine do react with one another, and many techniques used to collect one of these species also collect some fraction of the other. It is quite desirable to sequester the iodine and water separately because the tritiated water may be disposed of as a low level waste. If not cleanly separated, contamination of the low-level waste by iodine may elevate its classification to high-level waste and result in greater costs for disposal. The proposed sorption sequence was tested in the laboratory. Use of a second column of AgZ permits the detection of breakthrough from the primary AgZ column while protecting the downstream 3AMS column from collecting iodine. (This arrangement is equivalent to enabling intra-column sampling of the primary column.) Neutron activation analysis of the 3AMS revealed that iodine was below, or at, the level of detection. The results successfully demonstrated that iodine can be sequestered in the AgZ while the water is collected free of iodine in the 3AMS column. (authors)
Virtually all the elements in the periodic chart are generated as a result of atomic fission in nuclear fuel. Several of the elements are volatile or can readily react with other chemicals to form volatile molecules that can be released during the processing of used nuclear fuel for the recovery of the valuable products. Among the volatile fission products, {sup 129}I, {sup 14}C, {sup 3}H, {sup 85}Kr, and {sup 79}Se constitute the main environmental concern for uncontrolled release. Storage of used fuel allows the short-lived isotopes to decay significantly (e.g., {sup 3}H decays in half every 12.32 years and {sup 85}Kr every 10.76 years). However, depending on regulatory limits they may remain an environmental concern up to about 50-100 years of fuel storage. In contrast, the concern for environmental release of the highly mobile {sup 129}I and {sup 14}C remains for geological times (half-lives of 15.7 million years for {sup 129}I and 5730 years for {sup 14}C). Processing of used commercial nuclear fuel requires significant head-end operations to remove the fuel from the protective coverings (e.g., assemblies). The current industrial process includes cropping the end caps of the fuel assemblies, chopping of the fuel pins and/or bundles into short segments, and prolonged leaching of the segments using concentrated nitric acid (HNO{sub 3}). The infrastructure, processes, and waste treatment systems in the head-end operations, including the associated off-gas system, are some of the larger and more costly components of the entire plant. The bulk of the volatile fission products are released to the off-gas during the leaching and dissolution. However, a small but significant amount will transfer to the following steps of processing such as solvent extraction and will show up in many different waste streams. The effective capture of {sup 3}H and iodine throughout the different processes and disposition of associated waste streams is costly and complicated. Up-front removal and capture is highly desirable. Currently, at the U.S. Department of Energy national laboratories and internationally, several dry pretreatment technologies are being studied and developed with the potential to simplify and increase the safety of subsequent storage or chemical recycling processes. These studies include (1) alternative decladding methods, (2) oxidation of exposed fuel following either conventional shearing or chemical decladding, and (3) the collection and stabilization of released volatile radionuclides. Several dry processes are being developed for the up-front removal of tritium and other fission products. They can be combined with different decladding alternatives and, in general, produce a fine powder that can be fed to aqueous or pyrochemical separations processes. (authors)
In recent years, the surge in the number of isotope production facilities under design has increased the need to analyze isotope migration in facility Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning (HVAC) during normal operations and accident scenarios. These facilities are used to produce isotopes for medical, security, and industrial applications and as such are subject to license and regulatory requirements 10CFR20, 10CFR30, 10CFR50, and 10CFR70. GOTHIC, a general-purpose thermal-hydraulics software package, includes the ability to model isotopic tracers, radioactive decay and isotope migration as well as HEPA and charcoal filters for isotope retention. A GOTHIC model was developed by Zachry Nuclear Engineering (ZNE) to examine the effect of negative room pressure, HEPA filtration, and HVAC fluctuations on radiation areas, hot cells and gloveboxes. Radioactive tracers were used to simulate the concentration of spills within contaminated areas, track the migration of isotopes of interest, and determine the isotopic retention and buildup on facility HEPA filters. A variety of isotopes with concern to dose (e.g., Kr-85, Sr-90, I-131, etc.), including their decay and progeny, are included in the analysis. Negative pressures are maintained in the regions of interest by a representative central HVAC system equipped with a volumetric fan that exhausts to the environment after a series of isolation valves and HEPA filters. GOTHIC is an industry trusted tool for providing engineering solutions for a variety of applications, including fission product tracking, aerosol and particulate transport and ventilation assessments. The software provides an integrated analysis environment that includes a graphical user interface (GUI) for constructing analysis models, a numerical solver that includes parallel processing capabilities and a post-processor for evaluating simulation results. It solves the conservation equations for mass, momentum and energy for multicomponent, multi-phase flow in lumped parameter and multi-dimensional geometries (1, 2, or full 3D), including the effects of turbulence, diffusion and buoyancy. It has been developed and maintained under a Quality Assurance program in compliance with the requirements of 10CFR50 Appendix B and applicable portions of ASME NQA-1 since 1995. GOTHIC has been used for assessing both forced and natural convection conditions for a wide range of applications, including: - Tracking concentration of hazardous gases and chemicals for habitability and safety assessments - Determining ventilation and filtration requirements and optimizing location and arrangement of these systems - Room heat-up, including diverse and Flexible coping strategies for Extended Loss of AC Power (FLEX/ELAP) - Equipment Qualification (EQ) A distinctive feature of GOTHIC is the ability to track many different fields/substances in a simulation, including user defined tracer elements, in the liquid, vapor and droplet fields as well as surfaces and filters. This capability allows GOTHIC to model fission product transport and release or the removal of particulates or harmful toxins from exhaust gases using a spray scrubber or other types of filtration systems. GOTHIC also includes models for engineered equipment, such as fans, filters, charcoal filters, dryers/demisters, dampers, etc. The aerosols and other filtered material are removed or accumulated in these components. The range of aerosol and radiological applications that GOTHIC has been used for includes: - Source Term: Primary Coolant (Equilibrium) Activity; Non-Water Coolant Source/Leakage. - Conditions for Iodine Re-evolution: Sump/Suppression Pool Conditions and pH; - RWST Conditions and pH. - Isotope Removal Mechanisms: Containment Sprayed and Unsprayed Region Mixing; Charcoal Filter Heating due to Iodine decay. - Radionuclide Transport and Decay: Post-LOCA Release in containment; Transport between connected Compartments and vent systems; Groundwater transport of radionuclides. - Non-Newtonian Fluid modeling for sludge, waste tanks, etc. ADAMS ML071581053 (titled 'Best Practice Guidelines for the use of CFD in Nuclear Reactor Safety Applications') poses guidelines for applying single phase CFD codes in nuclear reactor safety problems and GOTHIC is listed as a 'tool for 3D flows' and 'dispersal and deposition of radionuclides.' The Nuclear Quality Assurance (NQA) pedigree of GOTHIC is an important aspect for applications in the nuclear industry. The fundamental tracer models (convective transport, molecular and turbulent diffusion, removal mechanisms, etc.) have been verified using analytical solutions and validated against applicable separate effects tests. Also, GOTHIC has been benchmarked to many integrated effects tests, including Phebus FP (Fission Product). GOTHIC gives good agreement for the buildup and decay of fission products in Phebus Test 3. The model developed by ZNE demonstrates GOTHIC's applicability and acceptability for use in analyzing the migration and retention of radioactive isotopes and their progeny in normal operation and accident scenario analyses for isotope production facilities, hot cells, and gloveboxes. The tracer activities calculated by GOTHIC can then be used in downstream radiation transport and shielding codes like RADTRAD-NAI{sup C}, MCNP{sup R}, and MicroShield{sup R} to determine on-site and of-site doses. (authors)
Presentation detailing the status of Kr and Xe separation and capture research at INL
Off-gas research within the Material Recovery and Waste Form Development (MRWFD) team is dispersed among four national laboratories and multiple universities and small businesses. Ensuring research is conducted consistently and in a manner conducive to direct comparison is a nontrivial task. The team assembled to realign goals and expectations by identifying distinct R&D phases, prioritizing crucial metrics, and outlining standardized tests specifically associated with Kr, Xe, and I capture.