Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Finite Element Modelling”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 955 records · Page 53

CTE Measurements for Loading Scenarios

The goals are to 1. understand full field thermal expansion of system parts by using strain gauges, DIC, and possibly ESPI. This is ultimately used to update a Finite Element Model relating to stockpile stewardship. 2. To verify the resolution of digital image correlation methods for thermal expansion measurements (CTE). A few conclusions: To this point, the DIC data shows more noise (less resolution) than we would like and Strain Gauge data is sound but it is more localized than full field.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Preparation and testing of corrosion and spallation-resistant coatings

The goal of this project was to take a recently developed method of bonding oxide dispersion-strengthened (ODS) FeCrAl plating to nickel superalloys closer to commercial use in syngas-fired turbines. The project was designed to better understand and develop the bonding process and to determine if plating APMT®, a specific highly oxidation-resistant ODS FeCrAl alloy made by Kanthal, onto nickel-based superalloy turbine parts is a viable method for substantially improving the lifetimes and maximum use temperatures of the parts. The superalloys investigated for protection were CM247LC and Rene® 80, both alumina scale-forming alloys. The method for bonding the APMT plate to the superalloys is called evaporative metal bonding, which involves placing a thin foil of zinc between the plate and the superalloy, clamping them together, and heating in an atmosphere-controlled furnace. Upon heating, the zinc melts and dissolves the oxide skins of the alloys at the bond line, allowing the two alloys to diffuse into each other. The zinc then diffuses through the alloys and evaporates from their surfaces, creating a bond between the APMT and the superalloy that is stronger than the APMT itself. Testing showed that the diffusivity of zinc in both APMT and CM247LC is quite similar at 700°C but 15 times higher in the APMT at 1214°C. Coefficients of thermal expansion were determined for each of the alloys as a function of temperature. This information was entered into a finite-element model using ANSYS, which was used to design a clamping jig for pressing the APMT to the superalloys at the bonding temperature. Scanning electron microscopy analyses of representative joints showed that no zinc remained in the alloys after bonding Unfortunately, the analyses also showed some small pieces of broken aluminum oxide scale near the bond lines, indicating that its scale was not sufficiently removed during prebonding cleaning. Samples from each of the bonded blocks were sent to Siemens for its standard oxidation, spallation, and corrosion testing, which was scheduled for completion in the spring of 2016. However, because of commercial demands, the tests were not completed by the time of this report except some initial spallation tests at 1150°C. In those tests, several of the APMT plates separated from the CM247LC, likely because of the remaining aluminum oxide scale on the surface of the CM247LC. This implies that surface preparation may need to include machining to remove the oxide scale before bonding rather than just sandblasting. In previous tensile testing at 950°C, the breaks in the tensile samples always occurred in the APMT and not at the joints. Gasifier sampling was completed to determine what types of trace contaminants may occur in cleaned and combusted syngas and that could lead to corrosion or deposition in turbines firing coal syngas. The sampling was done from a pressurized fluidized-bed gasifier and a pressurized entrained-flow gasifier. The particles captured on a filter from syngas were typically 0.2 to 0.5 μm in diameter, whereas those captured from the combusted syngas were slightly larger and more spherical. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy done at Oak Ridge National Laboratory showed that the particles do not contain any metals and have an atomic composition almost identical to that of the polycarbonate filter. This indicates that the particles are primarily soot-based and not formed from volatilization of metals in the gasifiers.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Shear dominated failure in the 'hat' specimen from the 2013 Sandia Fracture Challenge.

The objective of this memo is to present a brief report of the progress achieved during FY2016 on the investigation of ductile failure in the 2013 Sandia Fracture Challenge specimen. The experimental investigation was conducted with both the original steel A286 material used in the fracture challenge as well as with Al 7075-T651. The new results include further microscopy work for the steel A286 specimens, failure criterion verification for both materials and the implementation of a finite element model containing `material imperfections' to simulate the limit load in the response of the steel A286 specimens. Funding used to conduct the work presented here was provided by the ASC V&V program on validation of shear failure (Benjamin Reedlunn, PI) and from Sandia's LDRD program.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Thermal Safety Analyses for the Production of Plutonium-238 at the High Flux Isotope Reactor

There has been a considerable effort over the previous few years to demonstrate and optimize the production of plutonium-238 ( 238 Pu) at the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR). This effort has involved resources from multiple divisions and facilities at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) to demonstrate the fabrication, irradiation, and chemical processing of targets containing neptunium-237 ( 237 Np) dioxide (NpO 2 )/aluminum (Al) cermet pellets. A critical preliminary step to irradiation at the HFIR is to demonstrate the safety of the target under irradiation via documented experiment safety analyses. The steady-state thermal safety analyses of the target are simulated in a finite element model with the COMSOL Multiphysics code that determines, among other crucial parameters, the limiting maximum temperature in the target. Safety analysis efforts for this model discussed in the present report include: (1) initial modeling of single and reduced-length pellet capsules in order to generate an experimental knowledge base that incorporate initial non-linear contact heat transfer and fission gas equations, (2) modeling efforts for prototypical designs of partially loaded and fully loaded targets using limited available knowledge of fabrication and irradiation characteristics, and (3) the most recent and comprehensive modeling effort of a fully coupled thermo-mechanical approach over the entire fully loaded target domain incorporating burn-up dependent irradiation behavior and measured target and pellet properties, hereafter referred to as the production model. These models are used to conservatively determine several important steady-state parameters including target stresses and temperatures, the limiting condition of which is the maximum temperature with respect to the melting point. The single pellet model results provide a basis for the safety of the irradiations, followed by parametric analyses in the initial prototypical designs that were necessary due to the limiting fabrication and irradiation data available. The calculated parameters in the final production target model are the most accurate and comprehensive, while still conservative. Over 210 permutations in irradiation time and position were evaluated, and are supported by the most recent inputs and highest fidelity methodology. The results of these analyses show that the models presented in this report provide a robust and reliable basis for previous, current and future experiment safety analyses. In addition, they reveal an evolving knowledge of the steady-state behavior of the NpO 2 /Al pellets under irradiation for a variety of target encapsulations and potential conditions.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Planetary Load Sharing in Three-Point Mounted Wind Turbine Gearboxes: A Design and Test Comparison

This work compares the planetary load-sharing characteristics of wind turbine gearboxes supported by cylindrical roller bearings (CRBs) and preloaded tapered roller bearings (TRBs) when subjected to rotor moments. Planetary bearing loads were measured in field-representative dynamometer tests and compared to loads predicted by finite-element models. Preloaded TRBs significantly improved load sharing. In pure torque conditions, the upwind planet bearing load in the gearbox with preloaded TRBs was only 14% more than the assumed load compared to 47% more for the gearbox with CRBs. Consequently, the predicted fatigue life of the complete set of planetary bearings for the gearbox with preloaded TRBs is 3.5 times greater than that of the gearbox with CRBs.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

Properties of Syntactic Foam for Simulation of Mechanical Insults.

Syntactic foam encapsulation protects sensitive components. The energy mitigated by the foam is calculated with numerical simulations. The properties of a syntactic foam consisting of a mixture of an epoxy-rubber adduct and glass microballoons are obtained from published literature and test results. The conditions and outcomes of the tests are discussed. The method for converting published properties and test results to input for finite element models is described. Simulations of the test conditions are performed to validate the inputs.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Brazing Dissimilar Metals with a Novel Composite Foil

Reactive brazing is a novel technique in the joining industry that uses reactive materials to produce substantial amounts of heat locally to join components. In this project, we created mechanically processed dilute thermite foils (Redox Foils) that upon ignition selfpropagate to produce molten metal capable of joining dissimilar metal combinations. Due to the transient nature of the reaction, there is limited thermal damage to the base materials. Also, novel component combinations, that cannot be joined via tradition furnace brazing (such as magnesium alloys to steel), can be produced. Redox Foils are produced by mechanically processing and consolidating constituent powders. By adjusting the fabrication pathway and chemistry, the reaction products can be tailored to join specific material combinations. In addition to producing mechanically processed foils, we produce vapor processed foils with controlled microstructures to understand some of the mechanisms of the reaction. Over the course of the program, we worked to identify and enhance the properties of the Redox Foils so that they could produce strong braze bonds of dissimilar metals (steel, Al, and Mg alloys). In a first step, the reactivity of the powders, from which the foils were made, was enhanced by ball milling Al and metal oxide powders before consolidation. In a second step, Redox Foils were made by physical vapor deposition to identify what level of dilution is needed to prevent the formation of Cu vapor during the reaction of the Redox Foils. In a third step, we incorporated diluent powders within the milling process to improve homogeneity within the final foils. In addition, finite element model simulations of heat transfer were also combined with detailed microstructure studies to identify what level of homogeneity is needed to avoid the generation of Cu vapor. Lastly, we include Ag powders as a diluent to form a lower melting temperature braze. Unfortunately, none of these steps led to Redox Foils that could produce bonds with shear strengths greater than 10 MPa. The generation of oxygen vapor appears to be generating porous bond lines that are still relatively week. To circumvent this vapor generation, we investigated Ti:2B reactive scaffolds that provide a heated framework to enhance braze flow and minimize porosity. However, BM Ti:2B powders suffered ~8% mass loss due to surface adsorbed water resulting in porous and weak bonds. As an alternative solution, we developed Ti-C-Cu based reactive braze foils that rely on TiC formation reactions to melt the Cu braze material. In this system, the foils did not produce gas or vapor upon reaction but did form the desired TiC product with molten Cu. Unfortunately, the reaction temperatures and the duration of Cu melting were insufficient to produce effective bonds. The goal of achieving bond strengths of 20 MPa or higher was not achieved.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Final Report on CFD and Thermal-Mechanical Stress Analysis of PWR Surge Line under Transient Condition Thermal Stratification and an Evolutionary Cyclic Plasticity Based Transformative Fatigue Evaluation Approach without Using S~N Curve: Rev. 1

This report presents an evolutionary cyclic plasticity based transformative approach for fatigue evaluation of safety critical components. This approach is generic which can be used not only for the present generation light water reactor components (which is our focus) but also for advanced reactor components. The approach is based on the fundamental concept of time-evolution of progressive fatigue damage rather than the end-of-life data based conventional S~N curve approaches. Series of fatigue tests on 316 stainless steel uniaxial specimens were conducted under strain-controlled and stress-controlled cyclic loading in two different environment such as in-air at 300 °C and PWR coolant water condition at 300 °C. Material models are developed to capture the uniaxial test data and are subsequently programmed into commercially available ABAQUS code to transform the uniaxial material behavior to multiaxial loading domain. The developed evolutionary cyclic-plasticity approach is verified by both analytical and 3D-FE modeling of uniaxial fatigue test specimens. Results show that the developed material models can capture the time-dependence of material hardening and softening with great accuracy. In addition, results show that the material models not only can capture the material behavior under constant amplitude loading but also can capture the load-sequence effect under variable and random amplitude loading. The ANL developed approach is one of its kind, which shows first in the fatigue research community that fatigue evaluation of a component (in our case verified for laboratory scale fatigue test specimens with great accuracy) can be performed for its entire fatigue life, including the hardening and softening behavior, without using a conventional S~N curve based approach. Additionally results are presented related to fatigue evaluation of real reactor components such as of a pressurized water reactor (PWR) surge line (SL), under upset transient conditions. SLs of PWR experience complex thermal stratification due to the mixing of differential temperature flow from hot leg and pressurizer. A detailed parametric study of thermal stratification in SL is performed through both standalone computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis and fluid-structure-interaction based coupled CFD and heat transfer analysis. Results show that the mass flow rate in SL substantially affects the extent of its thermal stratification. The resulting thermal boundaries conditioned are used as inputs for thermal-mechanical stress analysis and component level fatigue evaluation. Fatigue evaluation of SL pipe under example loading conditions was performed using the above-mentioned evolutionary-plasticity based approach and ASME code (for in-air life) and NUREG-6909 (for PWR environment life) based approaches. Results show that the evolutionary plasticity based approach estimate substantially different life compared to the conventional ASME based approach. To show the entirety of the proposed evolutionary fatigue-modeling framework, this report includes the results presented in semi-annual March report (ANL/LWRS-17/01). Sections 2-5 of March report are directly included as Sections 2-5 in this report, without any significant changes. However, Sections 6-9 of this report present the work performed during March-September of 2017. Whereas, Sections 1 and 10 present the organization of this report and the summary and future work, respectively. This report (ANL/LWRS-17/03 Rev. 1) is a slightly revised version of the earlier published report (ANL/LWRS-17/03). In this revised version, some of the results and associated discussion have been corrected/updated.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

A Study on the Effects of a Viscous Fluid Surrounding a Small Electrical Assembly

Currently there are limitations in computing chatter behavior of small electrical contacts embedded in components using finite element models. Reduced order models (ROM) have been developed of such electrical contact sub-assemblies to assess the chatter behavior of the contacts during vibration and shock environments. The current ROM method requires experimental validation. This ROM also neglects the frequency and damping effects of the viscous fluid that typically surrounds such sub-assemblies. Dynamic ring-down testing of the electrical contacts in air will be performed and will provide a validation data set for the current ROM. Additionally, dynamic ring-down testing of the electrical contact will be performed in fluids of varying viscosities that will help characterize the effect of the fluid on the contact for an improved ROM.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

High-current density CORC® wires for use in accelerator magnets

Next generation accelerator magnets capable of generating magnetic fields in excess of 16 T require high-temperature superconductors (HTS) such as Conductor on Round Core (CORC®) cables and wires, wound from RE-Ba 2 Ca 3 O 7-δ (ReBCO, Re = rare earth) coated conductor tapes.1 The severe operating requirements of an engineering current density (J e ) of at least 400 Amm -2 at 4.2 K and 20 T, high operating currents of 5-20 kA, tolerance to Lorentz stresses in excess of 150 MPa, and in many cases cable bending diameters as small as 30 mm, make accelerator magnets one of the most challenging applications for any HTS material. Advanced Conductor Technologies (ACT) has been developing CORC® cables and wires wound from ReBCO tapes containing substrates of 30-50 µm thickness to meet these requirements. Although these requirements could each be met separately with current CORC® technology, meeting the requirements at the same time requires thinner, more powerful CORC® wires wound from tapes with even thinner substrates. The purpose of this Phase I SBIR program was to determine the feasibility to develop ReBCO tapes containing 25 µm thick substrates on an industrial scale and wind thinner CORC® wires from these tapes that could eventually meet the stringent performance specifications for accelerator magnets. The results of the Phase I program clearly demonstrated the feasibility of developing thinner, more powerful CORC® wires using ReBCO tapes with 25 µm substrate that would likely meet the stringent requirements for use in accelerator magnet by the end of the potential Phase II program. SuperPower Inc., as the subcontractor on the Phase I program, was successful in developing tapes with 25 µm substrate at minimum piece lengths of 30-40 m with a clear path towards industrial production. A total length exceeding 350 meters of 2 mm wide ReBCO tape with critical current (I c ) of between 45 and 65 A at 77 K was delivered to ACT during the Phase I program. The thinner tapes allowed us to reduce the CORC® core (former) from 2.5 mm to 2.0 mm, resulting in a higher current density conductor with enhanced flexibility. Several CORC® wires were manufactured to reach the Phase I goal of a Je of at least 300-400 Amm -2 at 20 T at a minimum bending diameter to less than 50 mm. Several CORC® wires were wound and analyzed after bending by identifying the location of peak stresses and causes of tape damage. Data was compared to 3D finite element models that included parametric studies to identify key parameters leading to the observed tape failure modes. The models suggest that flexibility is heavily dependent on the friction coefficient between tapes in a CORC® wire and the width of the tapes used. These studies provide a clear and straightforward path to improve conductor flexibility within the proposed Phase II program to reach our goal of minimum bending diameters below 30 mm with minimal I c reduction. We were successful in developing a flexible, 3.3 mm thick, high-J e CORC® wire containing 30 ReBCO tapes that carried > 80 % of its original I c after bending to diameters down to 44 mm. The CORC® wires showed no cyclic degradation due to in-field testing up to 57 stress cycles at 12 T. Another CORC® wire of 3.4 mm thickness had a J e as high as 451 Amm -2 when extrapolated to 20 T at a bending diameter of 63 mm, which is a new high-field performance record. We were also able to design a CORC® wire with increased tensile strength of 240 MPa at 76 K. The results of the Phase I program allow us to propose a very strong Phase II program with a high likelihood of reaching the ultimate goal of CORC® accelerator magnets wires with I c exceeding 8-10 kA and J e exceeding 600 Amm -2 at 20 T while bent to a 30 mm diameter.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

Experimental and numerical evaluations of the energy savings potential of thermally anisotropic composites

Previous numerical studies conducted in FY 17 showed that the application of thermally anisotropic composites (TACs) coupled with a heat sink/source can re-direct and reduce unwanted heat flows through exterior building walls, with associated reductions in envelope-generated heating and cooling loads in buildings. The numerical analyses included two-dimensional finite element models (FEM) of wall assemblies and whole-building modeling to estimate the annual reductions in wall-generated heating and cooling loads, and associated energy consumption. The FY17 study used combined FEM and EnergyPlus (E+) simulations of a typical two-story, single-family DOE prototype residential building model.1 We studied performance of several configurations of walls containing exterior continuous insulation and thermally anisotropic composites on the wall exterior. The study showed that annual energy cost savings of up to $270 are possible under Phoenix and Baltimore weather conditions, by retrofitting a baseline wall with an anisotropic composite. In the cases considered, the TAC consisted of three layers of aluminum foil-faced foam boards. In general, it was found that the anisotropic composites were effective in reducing cooling loads; more investigation on heating loads is needed. During FY 18, ORNL performed a series of laboratory tests of anisotropic composites and appropriate heat sink/source, validated the FEMs used for the FY17 numerical study using experimental data, and revisited the whole-building modeling. Wall prototypes were created and tested in ORNL’s large scale climate simulator (LSCS) under variable conditions approximating summer and winter time periods.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Methodology for Irradiation Creep Testing of SiC / SiC Composite Cladding

Irradiation creep compliance is a critical parameter for evaluating the stress evolution of silicon carbide (SiC) components during operation in various reactor concepts. Recent instrumented irradiation creep testing of SiC, performed at low dose in the Halden reactor, showed a creep compliance that is orders of magnitude higher than previous un-instrumented bend relaxation experiments performed in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR). This discrepancy illustrates the need for additional irradiation creep data for SiC. To this end, a novel irradiation capsule design has been developed to test miniature SiC tensile specimens under loading during irradiation in the HFIR. The experiment design uses the coolant pressure of the HFIR to compress a bellows, which applies the loading on the specimen. Preliminary thermal finite element models were developed to estimate the temperature distribution within the specimen and surrounding capsule components. Similar structural models were developed to evaluate the stress distribution within the specimen. The thermal analyses show that within the gauge section, the specimen temperatures remain within ~10°C of the nominal 300°C design temperature. Similarly, the structural analysis predicts axial stresses within ~10 MPa of the target stress of 100 MPa. These initial analyses show that irradiation creep testing of SiC in the HFIR is feasible and could provide a low-cost, high-throughput vehicle for gathering needed irradiation creep data.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Fracture Mechanics Analysis of Isotope Fuel Impact Tester, Milli-Watt, Multi-Hundred Watt and GPHS Outer Catch-Tube Subassembly Design

The Isotope Fuel Impact Tester (IFIT) at PF-4 is a specialized set of equipment designed for simulating high-speed impact of experimental parts. The IFIT is an inert gas launcher designed to impact 238 PuO 2 heat source assemblies, fuel encapsulation materials, structural materials, and subassemblies of radioisotope thermoelectric generators (RTGs). TA-55 management desires to re-use outer catch tube (OCT) of the milli-watt (MW), multi-hundred watt (MHW) and general purpose heat source (GPHS) designs and thus requires a technical evaluation of potential life cycles to failure. This report provides a fitness-for-service (FFS) assessment using fracture mechanics techniques based on the state-of-stress developed with the aid of a computational finite element model (FEM) of the IFIT. Importantly, the report describes the different material options for the OCT; H-11 vacuum-arc re-melted (VAR) and H-13 VAR for a given heat treatment resulting in a Rockwell-C hardness of 42, and an additional option of 4340 alloy steel with a range of heat treatment resulting in Rockwell-C hardness of 40 to 44.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Proposed Methodology for Assessing Available Drawdowns for Each Oil Storage Cavern in the Strategic Petroleum Reserve

The Department of Energy maintains an up-to-date documentation of the number of available full drawdowns of each of the caverns owned by the Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR). This information is important for assessing the SPR's ability to deliver oil to domestic oil companies expeditiously if national or world events dictate a rapid sale and deployment of the oil reserves. What factors go into assessing available drawdowns? Determining the number of drawdowns requires the consideration of several factors regarding cavern and wellbore integrity and stability, including stress states caused by cavern geometry and operations, salt damage caused by dilatant and tensile stresses, the effect of enhanced creep on wellbore integrity, and the sympathetic stress effect of operations on neighboring caverns. A consensus has now been built regarding the assessment of drawdown capabilities and risks for the SPR caverns. The process involves an initial assessment of the pillar-to-diameter (P/D) ratio for each cavern with respect to neighboring caverns. Ideally, it is desired to keep this value greater than 1.0, which is in line with most industry design standards and should ensure cavern integrity and prevent loss of fluids to the surrounding rock mass. However, many of the SPR caverns currently have a P/D less than 1.0, or will likely have a low P/D after one or two full drawdowns. For these caverns, it is important to examine the structural integrity with more detail using geomechanical models. Finite-element geomechanical models have been used to determine the stress states in the pillars following successive drawdowns. By computing the tensile and dilatant stresses in the salt, areas of potential structural instability can be identified that may represent "red flags" for additional drawdowns. These analyses have found that many caverns will maintain structural integrity even when grown via drawdowns to dimensions resulting in a P/D of less than 1.0. The analyses have also confirmed that certain caverns should only be completely drawn down one time. As the SPR caverns are utilized and partial drawdowns are performed to remove oil from the caverns (e.g., for occasional oil sales authorized by the Congress or the President), the changes to the cavern volumes casused by these procedures must be tracked and accounted for so that an ongoing assessment of the cavern's drawdown capacity may be continued. A proposed methodology for assessing and tracking the available drawdowns for each cavern is presented in this report.

02 PETROLEUM↗

Potting Adhesion Investigation Using Double Cantilever Beam Tests

The adhesive properties of an elastomeric potting material were investigated experimentally using double cantilever beam (DCB) specimens. In these tests, the applied load and opening displacement were measured, with the goal of quantitatively characterizing the adhesive strength of the thin layer of potting material. The DCB tests were also simulated using a finite element model that incorporated an adhesive traction-separation model to represent the compliance of the potting layer and evolving (weakening) strength of the potting-to-metal adhesive interfaces. The test and simulation results were used to determine a range of traction-separation model parameters, expressed in the form of correlated probability distributions, that constitute a good calibration of the model over the range of variability exhibited in the test series.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Multi-layer Printing of Complex Antennas Using Aerosol Jet Technology (CRADA NFE-18-07315 Final Report)

This project demonstrated the feasibility of producing multilayer radio-frequency (RF) and microwave-frequency components using aerosol jet additive manufacturing technology. Funded by the U.S. Department of energy, Advanced Manufacturing Office, this effort focused on novel stacked component designs for devices such as antennas, electronic filters, resistive/inductive/capacitive (RLC) components, and transmission lines. Our approach to RF/microwave component fabrication by aerosol jet printing has the potential to reduce component size, improve performance characteristics, and allow devices to be fabricated on non-planar surfaces. Specifically, folded micro-patch antenna designs were fabricated by stacking layers of conductors and dielectrics printed in sequence using Optomec’s aerosol jet technology. ORNL supported the effort by providing design input on printing parameters and characterizing the performance of printed structures. ORNL identified suitable stacked antenna designs, produced finite element models (FEM) in high-frequency simulation software (HFSS), and provided the designs to Optomec for printing. After printing, the devices were tested and characterized at ORNL to determine the frequency response and material characteristics of the printed components. These proof-of-principle devices will provide feedback on printing parameters, optimizations for the FEM models, and a path for more complex multilayer device designs.

42 ENGINEERING↗

2020 Annual Report of Available Drawdowns for Each Oil Storage Cavern in the Strategic Petroleum Reserve

The Department of Energy maintains an up-to-date documentation of the number of available full drawdowns of each of the caverns owned by the Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR). This information is important for assessing the SPR's ability to deliver oil to domestic oil companies expeditiously if national or world events dictate a rapid sale and deployment of the oil reserves. Sandia was directed to develop and implement a process to continuously assess and report the evolution of drawdown capacity, the subject of this report. A cavern has an available drawdown if after that drawdown, the long-term stability of the cavern, the cavern field, or the oil quality are not compromised. Thus, determining the number of available drawdowns requires the consideration of several factors regarding cavern and wellbore integrity and stability, including stress states caused by cavern geometry and operations, salt damage caused by dilatant and tensile stresses, the effect of enhanced creep on wellbore integrity, and the sympathetic stress effect of operations on neighboring caverns. A consensus has now been built regarding the assessment of drawdown capabilities and risks for the SPR caverns. The process involves an initial assessment of the pillar-to-diameter (P/D) ratio for each cavern with respect to neighboring caverns. A large pillar thickness between adjacent caverns should be strong enough to withstand the stresses induced by closure of the caverns due to salt creep. The first evaluation of P/D includes a calculation of the evolution of P/D after a number of full cavern drawdowns. The most common storage industry standard is to keep this value greater than 1.0, which should ensure a pillar thick enough to prevent loss of fluids to the surrounding rock mass. However, many of the SPR caverns currently have a P/D less than 1.0 or will likely have a low P/D after one or two full drawdowns. For these caverns, it is important to examine the structural integrity with more detail using geomechanical models. Finite-element geomechanical models have been used to determine the stress states in the pillars following successive drawdowns. By computing the tensile and dilatant stresses in the salt, areas of potential structural instability can be identified that may represent "red flags" for additional drawdowns. These analyses have found that many caverns will maintain structural integrity even when grown via drawdowns to dimensions resulting in a P/D of less than 1.0. The analyses have also confirmed that certain caverns should only be completely drawn down one time. As the SPR caverns are utilized and partial drawdowns are performed to remove oil from the caverns (e.g., for occasional oil sales authorized by the Congress or the President), the changes to the cavern caused by these procedures must be tracked and accounted for so that an ongoing assessment of the cavern's drawdown capacity may be continued. A proposed methodology for assessing and tracking the available drawdowns for each cavern was presented in Sobolik et al. (2018). This report includes an update to the baseline drawdowns for each cavern, and provides an initial assessment of the evolution of drawdown expenditure for several caverns

02 PETROLEUM↗

Validation and Verification of Multi-Material Split Rings

Process induced residual stresses commonly occur in composite structures composed of dissimilar materials. These residual stresses form due to differences in the composite materials coefficients of thermal expansion as well as the shrinkage upon cure exhibited by most thermoset polymer matrix materials. Depending upon the specific geometric details of the composite structure and the materials curing parameters, it is possible that these residual stresses can result in interlaminar delamination and fracture within the composite as well as plastic deformation in the structures metallic materials. It is important to consider potential residual stresses when designing composite parts and their manufacturing processes. However, the experimental determination of residual stresses in prototype parts can be prohibitive, both in terms of financial and temporal costs. As an alternative to physical measurement, it is possible for computational tools to be used to quantify potential residual stresses in composite prototype parts. A simplified method for simulating residual stresses was previously validated with two simple bi-material structures. Continuing on, the objective of this study is to further validate the simplified method for simulating residual stresses for bi-material split rings of different composites and layup variations. The validation process uses uncertainty quantification to develop a distribution of possible simulated residual stress states that are compared to experimentally measured residual stress states of fabricated structures similar to those simulated. The results of the comparisons indicate that the proposed finite element modeling approach is capable of accurately simulating the formation of residual stresses in composite structures and a temperature independent material model is adequate within the composites glassy region.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗