Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “conclusion”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 937 records · Page 52

Characterization of Creep-Fatigue Crack Growth in Alloy 709 and Prediction of Service Lives in Nuclear Reactor Components (Final Report)

This final report summarizes the activities and results that were obtained by the research team working on the project “Characterization of Creep-Fatigue Crack Growth in Alloy 709 and Prediction of Service Lives in Nuclear Reactor Components”, DOE-NEUP Project 15-8623. This project was mainly concerned with the creep-fatigue crack growth characterization of austenitic stainless-steel Fe-20Cr-25Ni (Alloy 709). For this purpose, an array of experimental and computational activities was performed. The main goal of these activities was to describe and predict the crack growth behavior in Alloy 709 under different conditions of applied loading and temperature. Alloy 709 specimens were tested to describe both the uniaxial creep behavior and creep-fatigue crack growth rates at temperatures between 550°C and 700°C. Microstructure and fracture surface analysis was performed using several experimental techniques, and the defining features of crack growth propagation were identified and described. Thermodynamic and diffusion simulations were performed to understand the microstructure evolution of Alloy 709 at elevated temperatures, and to establish an aging schedule relevant for in-service conditions over extended periods. Experimental testing was performed on both as-received and aged Alloy 709 specimens. Two computational methods were developed to predict crack growth rates and remaining lives in specimens loaded under either fatigue of creep-fatigue. The first computational technique was the finite element method, while the second was strip-yield modeling. Both methods relied on the prediction of crack growth rates using the concept of plasticity-induced crack closure. Crack-tip opening loads were computed and used to perform crack growth rate predictions. The computational predictions matched well with the experimental results. The strip-yield model was shown to be an excellent predictive tool not only for crack growth in austenitic SS Alloy 709, but also in 316 SS, martensitic Cr-Mo steels, Ni-based alloys and Al-based alloys. The main conclusion of this study is that Alloy 709 exhibits excellent creep crack growth resistance at temperatures between 550°C and 700°C. In fact, the crack growth resistance of this alloy appears to be higher than that of 316 SS in similar testing conditions. Moreover, when creep loading with hold (dwell) times of 60s or 600s were intercalated every fatigue cycle, the crack growth rates did not change significantly. The conclusion is that the tests performed revealed that the crack growth is insignificant during the creep portion of a loading cycle, as compared with the crack growth during the fatigue portion of the cycle. In general, Alloy 709 shows excellent resistance to creep deformations and creep crack growth up to 700°C.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

SDAV Institute Final Report – February 2017

This report is organized into sections and subsections, each covering an area of development and deployment of technologies applied to scientific applications of interest to the Department of Energy. Each sub-section includes: 1) a summary description of the research, development, and deployment carried out, the results and the extent to which the stated project objectives were met; 2) significant results, including major findings, developments, or conclusions; 3) products, such as publications and presentations, software developed, project website(s), technologies or techniques, inventions, awards, etc., and 4) conclusions of the projects and future directions for research, development, and deployment in this technology area.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Shock-Induced Solid-State Reactions in Powders: An Experimentally-Based Reassessment

We have performed a series of ten planar impact experiments on six different materials, including certain reactive powders and two inert materials, using Sandia's 89 - mm powder gun at the STAR facility. Time - resolved particle - velocity histories were determined during each of the experiments from one or more VISAR measurements. We have analyzed the results of these measurements 1) by using jump conditions to determine shock and first reshock states and 2) by comparing measured particle velocity histories to synthetic histories predicted by one - dimensional computational analyses using the CTH shock physics code with various models for inert and reactive materials . These comparisons are consistent with the conclusion for these particular reactive powders, that for the duration of shock loading either 1) there is insignificant reaction or 2) the products of any reaction are indistinguishable from the reactants under the experimental conditions. Shock and reshock states were extracted for shock pressures between 5 and 40 GPa. Densities were at or greater than the theoretical maximum zero - pressure density of the starting mixture. This result would be expected if there were no reaction or negligible reaction for the first two shock states. Two experiments were performed on one reactive powder in a "ring - down " geometry to look for evidence of vapor production on pressure release. In both cases, the measured velocity continued to increase slowly over a period of microseconds for the du ration of the experiment. This observation suggests that vapor is produced along the release path, but information about the mechanism for vapor production cannot be extracted from these data. While it is possible that vapor is produced by a shock - induced reaction involving more than one of the original constituents, a simpler interpretation is that the vapor is made up of products of shock - induced decomposition reactions and/or simple vaporization of the constituents as would be expected to take place under the conditions of these experiments. Other sources of vapor could be water adsorbed on grain surfaces and air originally in the voids. Thus it is not necessary to invoke significant recombination reactions to explain the data. However, in the absence of ring - down control experiments, the possibility remains open. These conclusions are different from those of previous workers, but reassessment of a subset of the earlier data yields results consistent with the present work, i.e., the shock compression data do not provide evidence for strong exothermic reactions.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Validation of Wichner Predictive Model for Chronic Oxidation by Moisture of Nuclear Graphite

This document reports the results of multi-year extensive research on chronic oxidation of nuclear graphite by traces of moisture that might be present in the helium coolant of high-temperature gas-cooled reactors (HTGRs). The research focuses on four grades of nuclear graphite that are considered potential candidates for component fabrication in advanced nuclear reactors. The four grades are (1) PCEA (medium-fine grain, extruded, manufactured by GrafTech Inc., USA); (2) NBG-17 (medium-fine grain, vibrationally molded, manufactured by SGL Carbon, Germany/France); (3) IG-110 (microfine grain, isostatically molded, manufactured by Toyo Tanso, Japan); and (4) 2114 (microfine grain, isostatically pressed, manufactured by Mersen, USA). The experimental part of this research comprised three objectives that were consistently pursued for each graphite material: (1) accelerated oxidation tests in well-controlled conditions (temperature, gas composition) and analysis of chemical kinetic models and of their parameters for each graphite grade; (2) measurements of water vapor transport rates from H 2 O/He mixtures through thin graphite slabs for estimation of the water effective diffusivity specific to each material; (3) controlled oxidation of graphite specimens in H 2 O/He mixtures and characterization of the effects of oxidation temperatures on the density profiles of oxidized layers. These three groups of experimental results were interpreted using the model developed by Wichner et al. for predicting the penetration depth of oxidants (moisture or oxygen) as a function of oxidation conditions. Basically, starting from the kinetic and transport properties of each graphite grade, the ultimate goal was predicting the stable density profile in the oxidized layer and its dependence on the oxidation temperature. The profiles obtained this way were then compared against direct observations of oxidized layers in specimens obtained in well-controlled oxidation conditions. The general agreement between predictions and observations validated the general applicability of the Wichner model. The results obtained in this project were presented at annual Department of Energy–Advanced Reactor Technologies program reviews and at specialist meetings and conferences and were published in Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) reports and in professional journals. The results published in 2018 had an immediate impact in 2019, when a group from three US universities used ORNL kinetic data as input information in a complex simulation of chronic oxidation by moisture using the same graphite grades during long-time operation in a modular high-temperature gas-cooled reactor. Their conclusion, in line with the conclusions obtained at the end of this project, was that chronic graphite oxidation by moisture during normal operation conditions of an HTGR will be limited to a thin surface layer of graphite blocks at the reactor bottom, where the highest temperatures are. That will not affect the integrity of graphite components and reactor safety, provided the impurity concentration in the helium coolant is rigorously controlled and maintained at the design specifications.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Energy Efficient Thermoplastic Composite Manufacturing

The objective of the project was to establish an effective and affordable method to lay-up and consolidate/join large thermoplastic composite aerospace structure with cycle times measured in minutes rather than hours. Composite airplane designs have proven efficient and effective however future potential product production rates are challenging what the current systems can efficiently produce due to material lay-down constraints and extended thermal cycle times. The ability to lay-up then rapidly heat, consolidate, and cool large complex composite structures plus very accurately tool them (i.e. matching CTE of composite materials) along with very precise thermal control is a difficult challenge. Current systems such as autoclave processing of thermoset materials require long cycle times due to method of heating and the large associated thermal masses. These extended cycle times inhibit the ability to meet higher rate production scenarios due to the need for multiple sets of equipment and tools. Thermoplastic composite materials were used to facilitate more rapid cycle times via the elimination of a need for a cure dwell at temperature. Also, utilized induction heating along with smart susceptors to enable the quick cycle times needed while providing precise intrinsic thermal control. The intrinsic control of the induction heating process via the smart susceptors along with the use of laser assisted fiber placement were the key innovations areas developed. The ability to rapidly heat and then precisely control the temperature of the consolidation component was paramount to the success of this project. It is this unique processing attribute coupled with the thermoplastic material characteristics along with rapid lay-up methods that are novel and advantageous. While many requirements and influencing factors decide the materials and processes utilized for future airplane construction, the forecast of accelerated production rates and the recent performance successes of composites in airplane construction provide an opportunity for this processing technology to have significant influence. During the course of this project a number of key accomplishments were completed. They are as follows: The needed laser assisted fiber placement capabilities have been developed and validated on a component of meaningful scale and complexity. Subsequently, a thermoplastic preform of the part scale-up part design was laser assisted fiber placed and made availalbe for consolidation. An induction consolidation system was sized, designed, and fabricated resulting in the full capability to consolidate the scale-up component. The tool for induction consolidating of the scale-up component was designed and fabricated. An aluminum pressure bladder was welded and formed for use as the pressurization membrane to perform the needed application of pressure on the part at temperature to achieve consolidation. The induction consolidation system consisting of the restraint, induction power supply, induction tool with integrated induction coils and smart susceptor liners, along with the aluminum bladder were successfully used to consolidate a large thermoplastic skin. The capability of accomplishing rapid heat-up rates and cool down rates for consolidation of large thermoplastic skins with precise thermal control and even pressure application at the consolidation temperature was validated. The general conclusion is that the use of induction consolidation with smart susceptors is an effective method to rapidly and efficiently consolidate large thermoplastic composite components and enable affordable high rate manufacturing of composites. More specific conclusions generated by this project are as follows: A restraint type induction consolidation system provides an affordable option over the standard press when using the induction consolidation processing method. Aluminum bladders can be formed to the complex shapes needed and supply uniform pressure for consolidation and co-consolidation of thermoplastic composite materials. Straightforward modifications can be made to existing fiber placement robotic systems to enable their use for thermoplastic lay-up applications.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Testing of an Iodine and Tritium Capture System for an NO₂-Based Tritium Pretreatment Process

The reprocessing of used nuclear fuel would release volatile radionuclides into the off-gas streams of a processing plant, including ³H, ¹⁴C, ⁸⁵Kr, and ¹²⁹I. One potential simplification to the management of the off-gas streams could be achieved through an efficient tritium pretreatment (TPT) step in which the UO₂ fuel is oxidized by either air or NO₂ before dissolution. The oxidation of the UO₂ fuel matrix will result in the release of tritium from the fuel. Upfront release of tritium from the fuel in a pretreatment step with subsequent tritium abatement can minimize or eliminate the distribution of tritium throughout a plant. This can decrease or eliminate the need for tritium capture on multiple off-gas streams and prevent distribution to the aqueous inventory. The use of NO₂ as the oxidant in an advanced tritium pretreatment (ATPT) allows for the oxidation to be performed at lower temperatures and may also result in the quantitative release of iodine from the fuel. The ATPT off-gas will contain up to 75 vol% NO₂ gas. Spencer et al. identified the most promising iodine sorbent as silver nitrate-impregnated alumina (AgA) and the most promising tritium sorbents as 3Å molecular sieve (3Å MS) and silica gel for radionuclide capture from ATPT off-gas streams. An initial series of tests were conducted in fiscal years 2017–2018 with the intent of demonstrating the recovery of iodine and tritium using these sorbents from a recirculating gas stream that simulated the NO₂ recycle loop envisioned for the ATPT system. These initial tests showed low tritium recoveries and significant variations in the iodine recovery on the AgA. Ultimately it was concluded, following disassembly of the system, that corrosion within the system was partially the cause of the poor recovery of both species. All components of that system were disposed of at the end of the analysis. One of the conclusions drawn from the initial tests pointed to the reconsideration of the materials of construction. Based on that recommendation a new test bed for the advanced TPT off-gas system, that addresses the issues identified in the fiscal years 2017 and 2018 scoping tests, was designed and constructed. The test bed used high nickel alloys wherever possible to address the previously observed corrosion issues, a redesigned surge tank to permit ease of purging, an improved feed injection system and a more modular system design that allowed testing of incremental increases in system complexity to allow the isolation of any element that results in changes to recovery of target species. Accompanying that design, a multifaceted test plan was completed. The overarching goals of this test series were two-fold. The first goal was to demonstrate the ability to recover both the iodine and tritium that would be released during TPT in a manner that the releases from the fuel can be quantified. The second goal was to demonstrate that the combined recovery system could operate in any of the three proposed TPT modes (once-through air or O₂, recirculating air or O₂, or recirculating NO x ). A total of 22 tests were completed. Ten tests examined tritium behavior under varying operating parameters, 8 tests examined iodine behavior under varying operating parameters, and 4 tests examined both tritium and iodine behavior. Silica gel was used for the tritium sorbent, and AgA or Ag-mordenite (AgZ) was used as the iodine sorbent. The following conclusions were drawn: Full recovery is achieved for both sorbates when no sorbent is in place indicating no accumulation within the test system. In even the simplest of the configurations (i.e., no sorbents in the columns), iodine is more difficult to transport and recover from the system than tritium. Analysis of the AgA iodine sorbent beds from the integrated tritium and iodine tests indicate quantitative iodine recovery can be achieved (within anticipated experimental errors). This system may provide a means for the quantification of the iodine released by the ATPT process within the experimental uncertainties. This would support 0.33 to 1.00 kg demonstrations of the ATPT process with actual used nuclear fuel. Iodine penetrated further into AgZ than into AgA when operated in gas recirculation mode. Tritium adsorbs to and cannot be fully recovered from the 10-cm column of silica gel at regeneration temperatures up to 140 °C.; Tritium adsorbs to and cannot be recovered from the 10-cm column of AgA at desorption temperatures up to 200 °C. Co-adsorbed tritium was recovered to a greater extent from AgZ than from AgA, but recovery was not complete. No visible corrosion was observed in the test system.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Hanging String Cuts in SPR Caverns: Modeling Investigation and Comparison with Sonar Data

Investigation of leaching for oil sales includes looking closely at cavern geometries. Anomalous cavern "features" have been observed near the foot of some caverns subsequent to partial drawdowns. One potential mitigation approach to reducing further growth of preexisting features is based on the hypothesis that reducing the brine string length via a "string cue' would serve to move the zone associated with additional leaching to a location higher up in the cavern and thus away from the preexisting feature. Cutting of the hanging string is expected to provide a control of leaching depth that could be used to "smooth" existing features and thus reduce geomechanical instability in that region of the cavern. The SANSMIC code has been used to predict cavern geometry changes (i.e., the extent of cavern growth with depth) based on variable input parameters for four caverns: West Hackberry 11 (WH11), West Hackberry 113 (WH113), Big Hill 104 (BH104), Big Hill 114 (BH114). By comparing the initial sonar geometry with resultant geometries calculated by the SANSMIC code, conclusions may be drawn about the potential impact of these variables on future cavern growth. Ultimately, these conclusions can be used to assess possible mitigation strategies such as the potential advantage of cutting versus not cutting a brine string. This work has resulted in a recommendation that a hanging string cut of 80 ft in WH11 would be beneficial to future cavern geometry, while there would be little to no benefit to string cuts in the other three caverns investigated here. The WH11 recommendation was followed in 2019, resulting in an operational string cut. A sonar performed after the string cut showed no adverse leaching in the area of the preexisting flare, as expected from the results of the preliminary SANSMIC runs described in this report. Additional SANSMIC modeling of the actual amount of injected raw water resulted in good agreement with the post-cut sonar.

02 PETROLEUM↗

Simulation Analysis of Geometry and Material Effects for Dropkinson Bar

The reported research is motivated by the need to address a key issue affecting the Dropkinson bar apparatus. This unresolved issue is the interference of the stress wave reflected from the bar-beam boundary with the measurement of the stress-strain response of a material tested in the apparatus. The purpose of the wave beam that is currently connected to the bar is to dissipate the stress wave, but the portion of the wave reflected from the bar-beam boundary is still significant. First, we focused on understanding which parameters affect the reflected wave's arrival time at a strain gauge. Specifically, we used finite-element numerical simulations with the Sierra/SM module to study the effects of various bar-beam connection fixities, alternative wave beam materials, and alternative geometries of the Dropkinson bar system based on a monolithic design. The conclusion of this study is that a partial reflection always occurs at the bar-beam boundary (or, for a monolithic design, at a point where the bar geometry changes). Therefore, given a fixed total length of the bar, it is impossible to increase the reflected wave's arrival time by any significant amount. After reaching this conclusion, we focused instead on trying to minimize the energy of the reflected stress wave circulating up and down through the bar over a relatively long period of time (10 ms). Once again, we used numerical simulations with the Sierra/SM module to investigate the effects of various bar-beam connection fixities, alternative wave beam materials, and parameters of an asymmetric monolithic design of the bar-and-beam system. This study demonstrated that various parameters can significantly affect the energy of the wave reflections, with the difference between best and worst configurations being about one order of magnitude in terms of energy. Based on the obtained results, we conclude with concrete takeaways for Dropkinson bar users and propose potential directions for future research and optimization.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Computational study of TATB

We have performed a computational study of TATB. The study is composed of two parts, one where we perform static T = 0 K calculations with several different DFT functionals, to investigate structural properties and obtain a cold curve. Even though the functionals used in this study give poor results at ambient pressure, they perform much better at compression, when the dominance of the van der Waals’ forces in the binding is replaced by more normal interactions. In particular AM05 gives good results, mainly because it doesn’t include any “faulty” van der Waals’. Indeed the van der Waals’ corrected functional (PBE+D2) results shows the worst performance on structural properties. For the cold curve the PBE+D2 functional gives the best results compared to experiments (room temperature) but since the structural properties were bad with this functional we cannot for sure say that this is in any way a validation. It is shown that scaling the AM05 results with a common factor reproduces the experimental data. We leave the question on why to a follow up study but speculate that maybe the experiment and our calculations do not represent the same system set-up. From the structural properties we identify a site in the TATB lattice that contains a high concentration of oxygen and hydrogen. The consequences of this finding, if any, are left to a future project. In the second part of the study we perform extensive high-quality DFT-MD (molecular dynamics with DFT forces) calculations to obtain points on the Hugoniot. This part of the study did not get finished within this project and a more extensive summary of this part will be given in a follow up report at a future date. However, we show that obtaining calculated data is essential for equations of state development since the existing experimental Hugoniot data barely deviates from room temperature isotherm data and thus give no information of the high temperature dependency of materials properties. Our conclusion so far in the project is that being able to calculate materials properties is essential for high explosives since experiments are unable to give information in the high temperature part of phase space. While blind use of DFT cannot (yet) give unambiguous answers, we can still explore qualitatively and use such information to guide us in EOS development. However, the main conclusion is that we need better functionals in DFT to easily extract needed properties from calculations.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Effect of Air Oxidation on Pore Structure Development and Mechanical Properties of Nuclear Graphite

This document reports on continuation of R&D activities at ORNL directed at investigating the effect of air oxidation of nuclear graphite on development and structure of porosity in the oxidized layer, and on the effect on mechanical properties of oxidized graphite. The material investigated was nuclear-grade graphite (purified PCEA graphite, from GrafTech International). Based on conclusions of previous work (ORNL/TM-2009/192), the method of analysis of the porosity in the oxidized layer based on optical microscopy coupled with automated image analysis was further improved and standardized. In addition, characterization of oxidized specimens by optical microscopy was complemented with measurements of mechanical properties (compressive strength) on a statistically significant number of specimens. A series of cylindrical shape specimens were machined and oxidized in air at two temperatures (600 and 700 o C) and at three levels of burn-off at each temperature (5-6 %; 10-12 % and 15-17%). The procedure used for specimen preparation and oxidation, and the oxidation equipment, were those recommended in ASTM D-7542-09. However, in order to comply with the aspect ratio requirements for specimens employed in compressive strength measurements (ASTM C-695-91) all specimens were machined with a length to diameter ratio of 2 (i.e. 25.4 mm height vs. 12.7 mm diameter) instead of 25.4 mm length and 25.4 mm diameter recommended by ASTM D-7542-09. After oxidation, mechanical properties (compressive strength) were measured on at least three samples obtained at equal oxidation conditions, while another specimen from the same lot was sectioned, mounted in resin and surface polished for optical microscopy analysis. In the latter procedure, mosaic pictures were collected of a rectangular stripe across the diameter of each specimen. These images were analyzed in order to derive the penetration depth and the pore structure in the oxidized layer as a function of oxidation temperature and weight loss level. Automated image analysis was performed using the commercial software Image Pro Plus. The results led to the conclusion that the depth of the oxidation layer is more dependent on the oxidation temperature than on the level of weight-loss. The penetration depth of the oxidized layer is about 6 mm at 600 o C and about 1.5 mm at 700 o C. Consequently, the 12.5 mm diameter specimens oxidized at 600 o C were completely penetrated by oxidation, while those oxidized at 700 o C had the oxidation layer restricted in a narrower band near the exposed surface. This difference was reflected by mechanical properties. A closer analysis of high magnification images in the oxidized layer revealed that oxidation attacks preferentially the binder phase in graphite, where development of fine new pores was observed. The density of new pores was higher near large pores pre-existing in graphite structure. Acute oxidation at low temperatures (e.g. 600 o C) causes more damage on mechanical strength than high temperature oxidation (700 o C). Although the latter is much faster, the oxidized layer is limited to a narrow zone next to the external surface, so that the core is not visibly affected. In contrast, oxidation at lower temperature, although slower, is more damaging because it penetrates deeply beyond the exposed surface.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

MELCOR 2.2 Benchmarks of Peach Bottom NUREG/CR 7155 Uncertainty Analysis

The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) performed a first-of-a-kind uncertainty analysis (UA) of the accident progression, radiological releases, and offsite consequences for the State-of- the-Art Reactor Consequence Analyses (SOARCA) of an unmitigated long-term station blackout (LTSBO) severe accident scenario at the Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station. The objective of the UA was to evaluate the robustness of the SOARCA deterministic "best estimate results and conclusions documented in NUREG-1935, and to develop insight into the overall sensitivity of the SOARCA results to uncertainty in key modeling inputs. The study was completed in 2015 and documented in NUREG/CR-7155. Since 2015, two other SOARCA UAs were completed for two pressurized water reactor (PWR) plants. The PWR UAs incrementally updated the approach and methodology, including using the latest release of the MELCOR 2.2 computer code. There were also advances made in the state-of-the-art modeling related to NRC efforts using the Peach Bottom model in NUREG-2206, which provided the technical basis for the containment protection and release reduction rulemaking for boiling water reactors with Mark I and Mark II containments. This report documents the input model changes from the NUREG/CR-7155 study and performs a small number of reference calculations to assess the changes of the new computer code and the model input updates. The objective of the work is to verify whether the updated Peach Bottom MELCOR model and updated version of MELCOR support the conclusions formed in the Peach Bottom SOARCA UA by performing these representative calculations.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Detection and Perception of Sound by Eagles and Surrogate Raptors

One overarching objective of this program of study was the accumulation of objective, scientifically valid information relating to auditory performance of bald and golden eagles that may be used to guide the development of acoustic alerting/deterrence technologies intended to discourage encroachment into wind energy air spaces. To that end, analyses aimed at the characterization of sensitivity to sound in bald and golden eagles, along with findings in the supra-threshold, dynamic frequency spaces related to response latencies and amplitudes, leads us to conclude that bald, and golden eagles navigate the same basic working auditory space, as in other known and thus far characterized members of the diurnal raptor family. Specifically, bald and golden eagles, along with other raptor species within the group, operate in an auditory space characterized by a frequency band at least four octaves wide and centered on 2 kHz, with an upper frequency limit between 6 and 10 kHz at 80 dB SPL and a lower frequency limit that almost certainly extends below 0.2 kHz. Consequently, we recommend that signal designers use these data as a guideline in efforts to design effective and efficient acoustic alerting/deterrent systems. It is important to note that signal energy broadcast outside of this frequency band at moderate levels will not contribute to the efficacy of a deterrent but will add an unnecessary fraction to the overall acoustic pollution budget. The importance of this consideration is heightened by contemporaneous concerns related to the transmission of noise broadcast by wind energy farms. In addition, based on analyses of data acquired from red-tailed hawks using the same experimental paradigm and data acquisition system, we conclude that auditory function in the red-tailed hawk is sufficiently like that observed in bald and golden eagles to permit its use as a surrogate species. Response waveforms, threshold-frequency curves, and input-output characteristics match those of eagles closely. It should be noted however, that differences in sensitivity and slightly extended high-frequency limits of hearing should be taken into account when extrapolating findings from one species to the others. Although the inclusion of behavioral tests of red-tailed hawks to acoustic stimuli was beyond the scope of this investigation, future efforts to assess response parameters like signal-type preference and habituation rate will further elucidate their suitability to serve as eagle surrogates in behavioral studies; nonetheless, the species in question are well matched with respect to basic auditory performance. A second essential objective of this program of study was the acoustic characterization of a subset of calls comprising the vocal repertoires of bald and golden eagles that may be used to supplement auditory performance findings in the effort to guide the development of acoustic alerting signals. With regard to that objective, the vocal repertoires of both bald and golden eagle species are rich and varied. While similar in spectrographic structure, distinctive differences are also clear. Generally, golden eagles produce some calls with shorter durations, and similar “sounding” calls exhibit distinctively different spectrographic patterns than those of bald eagles. Both species produce calls that contain a wide variety of nonlinear elements that operate to enhance the rich and varied nature of commonly observed vocal products. Comparison of the average power spectra of commonly observed bald and golden eagle calls with threshold-frequency curves leads to the conclusion that call energies fall within the frequency bounds of hearing. Further, the acoustic energy of calls considered in this report tend to fall into overlapping, but different frequency ranges of the acoustic sensitivity curve. This condition may encourage signal designers to vary the frequency content of acoustic deterrence signals in the field. Finally, preliminary observations relating to the tendencies and proclivities of bald eagles to attend to the acoustic landscape lead to the conclusion that eagles monitor their immediate sound environment assiduously. Individuals respond to a variety of natural and synthetic sound signals reliably and, perhaps most relevant in the context of the engineering of acoustic alerting/deterrence technologies, habituation to most sounds considered in this effort was minimal. These preliminary results, while calling for extended behavioral testing, are promising and set the stage for the exportation of behavioral studies into real world scenarios.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

FY2020 Savannah River Site Composite Analysis Annual Summary Review

This document provides the Department of Energy (DOE) Order 435.1 and its manual, Radioactive Waste Management (DOE 2021a, 2021b) required Annual Review for the Savannah River Site (SRS) Composite Analysis (CA). Progress made to-date toward addressing the secondary issue from the LFRG review of the 2010 SRS CA has focused primarily upon inventory estimate improvements. Inventory impacts dose in a linear fashion and reduces the uncertainty with the CA conclusions. Maintenance items are addressed, as funding allows, based on the relative risk associated with meeting the performance objectives. Currently, there is minimal risk in exceeding the DOE 100 mrem/yr CA primary dose limit or the DOE 30 mrem/yr dose constraint (administrative limit). Proposed activities, discoveries, new information and changes potentially affecting the 2010 SRS CA are documented in this and earlier Annual Summary reports, and a consolidated list of changes since the 2010 CA is documented in this report. The impact to the CA of changes arising from updated performance assessment (PA) baselines [i.e., Saltstone Disposal Facility (SDF), E-Area Low-Level Waste Facility (ELLWF), and F & H Tank Farm (FTF & HTF) closures] is expected to be minor for the following reasons: The primary contributors to the SRS CA dose impact at the Upper Three Runs (UTR) point of assessment (POA) are the H-Canyon and Mixed Waste Management Facility (MWMF), contributing 68% and 9%, respectively, to the dose impact at that POA. The combined contribution to the UTR dose impact from all PA’s (SDF, ELLWF, FTF and HTF) is ~2% of this total. The 2010 SRS CA model validation performed indicates that the CA projected dose, while generally conservative, provides a reasonable representation of the maximum annual doses. Doses evaluated are well below the SRS established 15 mrem/yr administrative limit (Crapse et al. 2011). Based on the assessment presented within this annual review and collective engineering judgement, the conclusions of the 2010 SRS CA remain valid and there is reasonable assurance that SRS will meet the performance objectives delineated in DOE Manual 435.1-1. The 2010 SRS CA should be updated to incorporate PA changes, proposed changes to inventories and sources and model improvements accumulated since the 2010 CA. The timing will be dependent on the completion of the ongoing E-Area PA revision.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Blast furnace slag reactions in various solutions (Interim Report)

Blast furnace slag (BPS) is a critical component of grout formulations for the remediation of low activity nuclear waste. This interim report describes the initial results of a study designed to investigate the fundamental mechanisms of BPS dissolution. The goal of the work is to delineate the physicochemical aspects of the slag that impart beneficial properties to grout formulations to enable the consistent production of a slag-replacement material (“designer slag”) that performs better than what is commercially available. This report documents the dissolution experiments that were conducted using nine different initial solution compositions. Solution measurements for each solution, including pH and solution composition, are given for 1, 7, 14, 28, and 56 day intervals samples. Scanning electron microscopy images are presented for the 56 day samples from each of the solutions. Inferences about reaction mechanisms and 56-day mineralogy are made based on the information collected to date. Some conclusions are made based on the work performed for this interim report, and a path forward including the strategy for making stronger conclusions based on X-ray diffraction (XRD) analyses is presented.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Enhancing the Useability of the IAEA's Physical Model: An Analysis of User Feedback

This study presents the results of Physical Model user interviews conducted with 12 people who have International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) safeguards experience. The goal of this report is to provide additional context for policy makers when prioritizing the needs of the IAEA regarding support for enhancements to the Physical Model. The interviews covered the general usability of the Physical Model, its effectiveness as a technical reference, and the scope and utility of the Physical Model's indicators and content. The key conclusions from these interviews are as follows: 1) The Physical Model is difficult to find and not well advertised. 2) The Physical Model can be difficult to use due to its format, which makes searching for information difficult, and lack of visual content. Therefore, the Physical Model should be supported in multiple formats (print, PDF, web) to maximize its usability for different stakeholders. 3) The scope of the Physical Model's content and indicators is likely sufficient, and translating indicators into other languages is unlikely to be worth the effort. 4) Despite its inefficiencies and other issues, the Physical Model in its current form is a vital (albeit under-utilized) resource for key stakeholders. 5) Despite its broad use case the Physical Model is not a catch-all tool and force-fitting the Physical Model into functions for which it has not been designed for would likely diminish its value. 6) It can be difficult to disentangle challenges related to the Physical Model and its usability from broader challenges at the Agency, such as general issues with communication and coordination. Based on these conclusions and considering the results of past studies on the Physical Model funded by NA-241, the analysis team developed a list of recommendations and associated actions for IAEA consideration. These recommendations are prioritized based on the assessed level of difficulty for the IAEA to implement a recommendation, emphasizing low hanging fruit then building to more ambitious changes to the Physical Model's format and content.

96 KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT AND PRESERVATION↗

Global Ethanol-Blended-Fuel Vehicle Compatibility Study

The objective of this study is to understand the impact of ethanol-blended fuel at various blending levels (10%, 15%, and 20% vol.) on "in-operation" vehicles built to differing emissions and manufacturing standards around the world. The study focuses on vehicles used in Canada, China, India, Indonesia, Japan, South Korea, and Mexico. Historical experience in the United States and Brazil informs the analysis. The primary study question is: Are vehicles in targeted countries physically and operationally compatible with ethanol blended fuel? For a fuel to be compatible with a vehicle, the fuel must perform its function as part of the integrated fuel-vehicle system, meaning: the car should start easily and drive normally, the fuel should not cause catastrophic fuel system leaks, the fuel should not cause corrosion or degradation of any engine or fuel system components (including emissions control components). The history of E10 use in the United States, beginning in 1978, was evaluated and shows no reliability or operability issues for cars dating back to pre-emissions-control times -- and likely included many cars manufactured in the 1960s. This strongly supports the contention that fuel chemistry and property differences between E0 and E10 are so small that any car made to international standards in the last 50 years will have a very high probability of being fully compatible with E10. This conclusion is supported by the experience in Brazil in the 1970s, where E10 was also introduced, and ethanol blending for conventional cars rapidly ramped up to even higher blend levels. A limited number of fuel system and component manufacturers supply the global market, including Bosch, Continental, Denso, Delphi, and Visteon. To reduce complexity, ethanol-compatible materials began to be integrated in fuel system designs globally. Fuel systems evolved over the following decades to incorporate ethanol-compatible materials with core subsystem families, such as in-tank fuel pumps used across several global vehicle original equipment manufacturers (OEMs). A similarly compelling case can be made that all cars at the Tier 1 (or equivalent) emissions-control technology level or higher are fully compatible with E15 blends, based on the data evaluated by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Ricardo in 2010. For cars at this technology level, the minor differences in fuel chemistry and properties between E10 and E15 are not significant. For E20, studies are not as extensive but are still highly significant. A long-term durability study conducted on mileage accumulation dynamometers presents convincing evidence that Tier 2 technology level cars have materials of construction and engine control authority for compatibility with E20, although this conclusion is not as strong as those drawn for E10 and E15, which are also partly based on real-world experience.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Technical Basis for Extended Dry Storage of Aluminum-Clad Spent Nuclear Fuel

This report addresses previously identified technical knowledge and technology gaps and presents the key findings of the multiyear, EMTD-funded research efforts with the goal of evaluating whether ASNF can be safely stored dry for many decades and whether changes to existing ASNF management practices are appropriate. The findings formulate the technical basis for the extended dry storage of ASNF, leading to the main conclusion: All completed work to close the identified knowledge gaps on extended (>50 years) ASNF dry storage supports the conclusion that extended ASNF dry storage is both safe and viable.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Report on Thermal Cycling Testing and Bimaterial Weld Development for a Passively Actuated Materials Surveillance Test Article

This report describes the continuation and conclusion of a thermal cycling test program designed to evaluate a family of passively actuated material surveillance test articles. Additionally, the report details a preliminary study of bimetallic welding between 316 stainless steel and TZM (tungsten-zirconium-molybdenum) alloy. The test program was ultimately successful in demonstrating the basic viability of the passively actuated test article concept as well as specifically validating the procedures developed to size specimens to mimic the mechanical response of operating components. The report discusses and summarizes the results of the complete test program which tested samples for more than 1,000 controlled thermal cycles. The weld development program included both stir friction and electron beam joining. The stir friction welding was ultimately successful, while the electron beam welding would require additional development. Ultimately, these test programs pave the way for implementing a materials surveillance program in future molten salt reactors (MSRs). The report conclusions outline a plan for transforming the research and developed described here into a definite set of practices and procedures for a surveillance program at a future operating reactor.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗