Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “complementary”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 937 records · Page 52

Exploring Cs 2 AgIn x Bi 1− x Cl 6 double perovskites for optoelectronics: insights from theoretical and photophysical approaches

Lead-free halide double perovskites (HDPs) have become attractive materials for optoelectronic applications owing to their nontoxicity, structural stability, and germane photoelectric properties. In this work, we report the synthesis of high-quality In-alloyed Cs 2 AgIn x Bi (1−x) Cl 6 nanocrystals (NCs) using the antisolvent recrystallization method and comprehensively investigate the effects of In alloying on the structural, morphological, optoelectronic, and temperature-dependent photoluminescence (TDPL) properties using the state-of-the-art experimental and computational tools. Both XRD and Raman spectroscopy analyses confirmed the synthesis of highly crystalline Cs 2 AgIn x Bi (1−x) Cl 6 materials, which exhibited cubic morphology, as confirmed by TEM analysis. Room-temperature photoluminescence (PL) measurements revealed a drastic increase in the intensity above 75% In concentration with dual emission, whereas the time-resolved PL (TR-PL) results show an increase in the average lifetime values with an increase in In content, suggesting that the materials have excellent optical properties and hence are suitable candidates for optoelectronics. The TDPL measurements revealed the smallest Huang–Rhys factor (18.6) for the Cs 2 AgIn x Bi (1−x) Cl 6 (x = 0.9) sample, indicating weak exciton–phonon coupling in this composition. When deployed in the fabrication of a photodetector device, the Cs 2 AgIn x Bi (1−x) Cl 6 (x = 0.9) sample exhibited significantly enhanced photoresponsivity and a faster response time, confirming its potential for photodetector applications. Complementary DFT calculations showed that In alloying modifies the band structure of Cs 2 AgIn x Bi (1−x) Cl 6 . Our results provide valuable insights for designing multifunctional Cs 2 AgIn x Bi (1−x) Cl 6 -based materials for next-generation energy and optoelectronic devices.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

Direct measurements for the kinetics of C–C bond fission in the high temperature decomposition of isopropanol

The thermal decomposition of isopropanol was studied experimentally and theoretically with a view to isolate and directly measure rate coefficients for the dominant radical channel in this multi-channel process. Two complementary shock tube methods, laser schlieren densitomtery and H-atom atomic resonance absorption spectroscopy, were used to obtain rate coefficents for the C–C bond fission channel. The experimental ranges span temperatures from 1200–2100 K and pressures between 30–690 torr. These are the most direct measurements of this rate coefficent in the fall-off regime of relevance to high-temperature reacting systems. Theoretical studies also performed in this work confirm that the title reaction and a molecular elimination involving dehydration were the sole unimolecular processes at high temperatures. A master equation analysis yielded k ( T, P ) for the C–C fission and these are shown to be in good agreement with the present experimental measurements. Comparisons with prior experimental and theoretical studies in the literature indicate branching ratios as well as absolute k ( T, P ) for C–C bond-fission have been under-predicted for this decomposition reaction. Consequently, results from the present studies place an increased emphasis on radical-driven secondary processes in high-temperature pyrolysis of this simplest secondary alcohol.

Kim, John H. [Univ. of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI (Un↗

Libration of hydroxyl groups in layered aluminum (oxy)hydroxides and other material analogs: insights from inelastic neutron scattering and theory

We analyzed the hydroxyl librational signatures of five structurally related aluminum (oxy)hydroxides, using inelastic neutron scattering (INS) and plane-wave lattice dynamics simulations. A clear trend across these aluminum-containing phases illustrates the relationship between hydrogen bonding, local atomic structure, and the spectral location and profile of the librational bands. The INS spectra have been compared to previous optical spectroscopy and computational studies, highlighting the complementary nature of the INS technique. Taking into account other structurally or chemically related material analogs, we have identified a correlation between a blueshift (to higher energy) of the upper librational band edge and the geometry of the hydrogen bond interactions, mirroring (with opposite correlation) the well-known redshift in the intramolecular O–H stretching energy with increasing hydrogen bond strength. For hydroxyl groups that do not participate in hydrogen bonding effectively, the bending librations occur at lower energies and hybridize with metal–oxygen lattice modes. Standard density functional theory approximations, including dispersion corrections, struggle to correctly predict vibrational frequencies of motions dominated by H but perform well for metal–oxygen modes, allowing us to make detailed mode assignments in several cases, including a demonstration of how layer-to-layer disorder in boehmite hydrogen bond orientations is reflected in the sharp but minor low energy peaks (at ∼70–80 meV) of the INS spectrum.

Wang, Hsiu-Wen [Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORN↗

Size-dependent femtosecond proton transfer in protonated methanol clusters

Methanol clusters (CH 3 OH) n are prototypical hydrogen-bonded systems that bridge isolated molecules and bulk liquid methanol. Strong-field ionization of these clusters can trigger ultrafast charge migration, proton transfer, and isomerization; however, the onset timescales of these pathways remain largely unexplored despite extensive steady-state mass-spectrometric evidence for protonation and chemical rearrangement. Here we use femtosecond time-resolved strong-field ionization and disruptive probing to directly track the early-time dynamics of methanol clusters. Transient mass spectra yield size-dependent timescales for the formation of protonated clusters H + (CH 3 OH) n (n = 1–3) and an associated CHO˙ + radical cation. We find that both proton-transfer and subsequent stabilization become markedly faster with increasing cluster size. These measurements establish methanol clusters as a complementary benchmark to water for understanding ionization-initiated proton motion and chemical reorganization in hydrogen-bonded liquids.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

SLAB: simultaneous labeling and binding affinity prediction for protein–ligand structures

Machine learning models are often used as scoring functions to predict the binding affinity of a protein–ligand complex. These models are trained with limited amounts of data with experimentally measured binding affinity values. A large number of compounds are labeled inactive through single-concentration screens without measuring binding affinities. These inactive compounds, along with the active ones, can be used to train binary classification models, while regression models are trained using compounds with binding affinities only. However, the classification and regression tasks are often handled separately, without sharing the learned feature representations. In this paper, we propose a novel model architecture that jointly performs regression and classification objectives, aiming to maximize data utilization and improve predictive performance by leveraging two complementary tasks. In our setup, the regression yields the binding affinity, whereas the classification task yields the label as active or inactive. We demonstrate our method using PDBbind, the standard 3D structure database, as well as a dataset of flavivirus protease compounds with binding affinity data. Our experiments show that the new joint training strategy improves the accuracy of the model, increasing applicability in various practical drug screening scenarios.

Biological and medical sciences↗

Luminescent N-heterocyclic carbene Cu( I ) complexes with N^O chelating ligands exhibit microsecond lifetimes and photocatalytic activity

To replace precious noble metal-based photosensitizers in applications involving photoinduced charge separation, energy transfer, or photocatalysis, Cu(I) complexes are considered to be cost-effective, earth-abundant, and sustainable alternatives. An emerging and effective design principle in Cu(I) photosensitizers involves heteroleptic structures where the HOMO and LUMO are spatially separated over two different ligands. In the present work, we introduce a complementary class of heteroleptic, three-coordinate copper photosensitizers that pairs variable N^O chelating ligands (8-hydroxyquinoline and 10-hydroxybenzo[h]quinoline) with a bulky 2,6-diisopropylphenyl-substituted N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC). In this design, both frontier orbitals are localized on the same ligand, the N^O chelate, such that structural modulation of the electron-rich N^O-chelates can substantially tune the energy levels of the HOMO and LUMO, thereby controlling the photoluminescence properties. Detailed photophysical and electrochemical experiments as well as DFT calculations suggest charge-transfer transitions with intra-ligand charge transfer (ILCT) character, involving the N^O ligands. This strategy successfully produced long triplet excited-state lifetimes (up to 44 µs) in compounds that are strong photoreductants (E([Cu] + /*[Cu] as negative as −2.0 V vs. the ferrocenium/ferrocene couple). These properties allow these photosensitizers to be used as photocatalysts in various transformations of organic compounds, such as hydrogenation of substituted benzophenones, hydrodehalogenation of aryl/alkyl halides (including challenging C–Cl bond activation) and E/Z isomerization of (E)-stilbene (an example of triplet–triplet energy transfer).

Chakraborty, Soumi [University of Houston, TX (Uni↗

Reassessment of caustic scrubbing for radioiodine capture during UNF processing

The effective removal of iodine-129 from gaseous emissions during used nuclear fuel processing is critical for minimizing environmental contamination and ensuring environmental regulatory compliance. Recent research has focused on optimizing process air, scrubber conditions, and integrating complementary techniques, such as solid sorbents as a polishing step, to improve iodine capture efficiency. The efficiency of a caustic scrubber is influenced by several factors, such as pH, temperature, gas–liquid contact time, and the presence of oxidants, yet the existing literature tends not to consider how these factors might interact or change in importance with process scaling. This perspective advocates for reconsidering how to mitigate many of these factors, especially in view of the transition from laboratory bench to pilot scale and beyond. This paper reviews the principles, operational parameters, and advancements in caustic aqueous scrubbing for radioiodine mitigation, aims to direct the next scientific pursuit of this technology, and inform environmental decision-making.

Ngelale, Randy [Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORN↗

Assembly of small silica nanoparticles using lipid-tethered DNA ‘bonds’

Single-stranded DNA molecules modified with cholesterol functional groups are physically tethered to silica nanoparticles (diameter 25 nm) that are encapsulated in a lipid bilayer. Such tethering increases the azimuthal mobility of the DNA molecules across the nanoparticle surface and enables nonspecific bonding, eliminating the need for specialized surface chemistries (such as silane or thiol ligands). To induce assembly, double-stranded DNA ‘bridge’ molecules are then added with complementary nucleotides to the DNA ‘anchor’ molecules that are physically tethered to the lipids on the surface of the particles. Assembly is observed to occur at room temperature and without the need for temperature annealing. Using automated liquid handling tools, assemblies are created in high throughput and rapidly characterized using SAXS. It is determined that the relative concentration of DNA-to-silica and the ionic strength of the solution are important parameters that affect the resulting assembly. Analysis of SAXS data is performed using coarse-grained particle dynamics simulations. The results support the spontaneous formation of semi-crystalline particle assemblies by particle condensation, where the interparticle distance is tuned by the sequence of the DNA ‘bridge’ used to link the particles. Crystallinity analysis performed on the resulting simulations, optimized to match SAXS observations, suggest that particle clusters display increased crystallinity in the center of the clusters, but their maximum size remains relatively small (sub-micron) before settling occurs, which limits the extent of crystallization.

Chiang, Huat Thart [Univ. of Washington, Seattle, ↗

Measuring the buried interphase between solid electrolytes and lithium metal using neutrons

Interfaces are the key to next-generation high-energy batteries including solid-state Li metal batteries. In solid-state batteries, the buried nature of solid–solid electrolyte–electrode interfaces makes studying them difficult. Neutrons have significant potential to non-destructively probe these buried solid–solid interfaces. This work presents a comparative study using both neutron depth profiling (NDP) and neutron reflectometry (NR) to study a model lithium metal–lithium phosphorus oxynitride (LiPON) solid electrolyte system. In the NDP data, no distinct interphase is observed at the interface. NR shows a difference between electrodeposited, and vapor deposited LiPON–Li interfaces but finds both are gradient interphases that are less than 30 nm thick. Additional simulations of the LiPON–Li 2 O–Li system demonstrate that NDP has an excellent resolution in the 50 nm–1 μm regime while NR has an ideal resolution from 0.1–200 nm with different sample requirements. Together NDP and NR can provide a complementary understanding of interfaces between Li metal and solid electrolytes across relevant length scales.

Westover, Andrew S. [Oak Ridge National Laboratory↗

Water-stable direct air capture of CO 2 with microcapsules of task-specific ionic liquid and their electrothermal regeneration

Microcapsules of the task specific ionic liquid (TSIL) 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium 2-cyanopyrrolide [EMIM][2CNpyr] with composite polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) shells were fabricated for use in CO 2 direct air capture (DAC) conditions. The TSIL was encapsulated using an oil-in-oil emulsion as a templating procedure through two different approaches. In the first approach, a PDMS-polyurea (PU) shell was constructed by interfacial polymerization, while in the second approach, a graphene oxide (GO)-PDMS shell was constructed by cross-linking GO sheets. The composition and structure of both capsule types were fully characterized, and their CO 2 DAC performance was evaluated by gravimetric and breakthrough analysis. Both capsules exhibited competitive capacities, with the PDMS-PU capsules and the GO-PDMS capsules reaching 0.75 mol kg −1 and 0.66 mol kg −1 , respectively. We further demonstrate that both capsule systems can be regenerated with complementary electrothermal methods. Microwave (MW) regeneration was used for the PDMS-PU capsules, effectively releasing absorbed CO 2 in less than an hour. Owing to the electrical conductivity of GO, GO-PDMS capsules were regenerated via radio frequency heating (RF). This work highlights the importance and opportunity of tuning solid–liquid composite performance for advanced applications, including direct air capture of carbon dioxide.

Al-Mahbobi, Luma [Texas A&M University, College St↗

Quantum effects on the dynamics and properties of soft materials

The quantum effects of nuclear and electronic motion play an important role in the structure, dynamics, and function of soft materials, yet they are difficult to capture with conventional classical simulations or static electronic–structure methods. In this work several complementary approaches for treating quantum effects in polymeric and soft–matter systems are demonstrated, with a focus being on the hydrogen-bonded networks, ion and charge transport, and photoactive chromophores. The proton transfer, tunneling, and isotope effects are captured within the reduced-dimensionality models by implementing grid-based nuclear quantum dynamics in terms of the discrete variable and Fourier bases. The nuclear quantum dynamics is extended to larger systems by employing the quantum trajectories and quantum–thermal bath schemes combined with on-the-fly electronic structure, enabling the description of high-dimensional polymeric environments at feasible cost. The dynamics in the electronic degrees of freedom, simulating the optical response in large chromophores such as chlorophylls, is performed using the real-time time-dependent density functional theory implemented in the real-space multigrid (RMG) code. These approaches are demonstrated on case studies of the proton and hydroxide transport in hydrated polymer membranes, charge transfer in conjugated polymers, and the optical spectra of chlorophyll chromophores relevant to polymerized chlorophyll materials and chlorophyll–polymer hybrids. The reviewed methods and applications highlight practical routes of including quantum effects in simulations of soft functional materials.

Garashchuk, Sophya [Univ. of South Carolina, Colum↗

Solubilization of PET in binary mixtures of HFIP and DCM

The dissolution of polyethylene terephthalate (PET) is a critical step for a solvent-based process, yet it typically requires highly corrosive or toxic solvents. Here, we investigate the solubilization and conformational behavior of PET in binary mixtures of hexafluoro-2-propanol (HFIP) and dichloromethane (DCM) as a strategy to reduce HFIP usage while maintaining effective dissolution. Small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) measurements reveal that PET remains molecularly dissolved in HFIP/DCM mixtures up to 50 vol% DCM. Analysis of PET chain conformations shows a transition from Gaussian behavior at low HFIP fractions to more swollen chains at intermediate compositions, accompanied by a counter-intuitive minimum in the radius of gyration at 50% HFIP. Complementary SANS measurements of the binary solvents demonstrate that compositional heterogeneity is maximized at this same solvent composition, suggesting a direct coupling between solvent microstructure and polymer dimensions. Molecular dynamics simulations corroborate the experimental findings, revealing solvent domain formation, preferential solvation of PET by HFIP, and a “caging” effect arising from solvent heterogeneity that leads to polymer coil compaction. Together, these results provide molecular-level insight into polymer behavior in mixed solvent systems and establish HFIP/DCM mixtures as a promising, more sustainable solvent platform for the PET post-process.

Arifuzzaman, Arif [ORNL]↗

Opportunities and challenges for the expansion of LFP battery supply chains

Global markets for energy storage are growing rapidly, with some applications transitioning from traditional LiNi x Mn y Co 1−x−y O 2 (NMC) toward LiFePO 4 (LFP) due to cost, safety, and performance advantages. Battery growth has seeded interest in critical material supplies such as high-purity lithium precursors. In contrast, challenges in securing high-purity iron and phosphorus, historically not considered critical materials, are often overlooked. Precursors must remain inexpensive to maintain LFP's current cost advantage, which leverages the low-cost (∼$\$100$ per t) FeSO 4 byproduct from titanium dioxide manufacturing and will not be available as LFP manufacturing expands. As an alternative, iron is mined primarily for steel manufacturing, for which the existing supply chain and beneficiation process is optimized. LFP batteries require small iron volumes compared to steel (0.11%), but profit margins associated with existing low-cost iron ores and high costs (∼$27 000 per t) associated with low volume high-purity iron oxides may limit interest in manufacturing small volumes of high-purity, specialized iron battery precursors. The complementary LFP precursor, phosphoric acid (H 3 PO 4 ), is primarily utilized in fertilizers. Of the current phosphate ore demand for fertilizers, 4–22.8% would be required to meet projected 2045 LFP H 3 PO 4 demand, suggesting significant supply chain planning is needed to achieve projected demand. If only higher-grade material is considered, demand jumps to 15–77% of current world production. While lithium precursor purity requirements have been evaluated (Li 2 CO 3 is commonly defined as ≥99.5%), “battery grade” iron and phosphorus precursors remain poorly defined, with no internationally accessible and widely adopted standard, further challenging expanding industry by creating manufacturing uncertainty and increasing potential costs.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Upcycling plastic waste into polyhydroxyalkanoates with high carbon conversion via CO 2 plasma-enabled deconstruction

Plastic deconstruction into fermentable intermediates is a key step for microbial bio-upcycling into value-added products. In this study, CO 2 plasma deconstruction was used as an electrified route to convert polyethylene into oxygenated intermediates and liquid (OIL). The resulting OIL was rich in fatty acids, fatty alcohols, and hydrocarbons, making it a suitable feedstock for medium-chain-length polyhydroxyalkanoate (mcl-PHA) production by Pseudomonas putida NRRL B-14688 and Pseudomonas resinovorans NRRL B-2649. Compared with batch fermentation and monocultures, fed-batch co-cultivation markedly improved biomass formation and PHA accumulation, likely due to complementary substrate utilization, particularly hydrocarbon conversion by P. resinovorans. Using virgin polyethylene-derived OIL (Vir-OIL), the co-culture achieved 40.11% mcl-PHA content and about 18% PHA yield based on total OIL fed. More importantly, OIL produced from post-consumer single-use plastic films (PCR-OIL) was directly fermented and well supported the cell growth and PHA accumulation, achieving 38.11% PHA content and about 14.7% PHA yield. Based on emulsified OIL fractions, PHA yields for Vir-OIL and PCR-OIL were comparable (∼28%). PHA granules were extracted from PCR-OIL-grown cells with high recovery (88.25%) and purity (94.8%). Five monomers were identified in the polymer, including 3-hydroxyhexanoate (3HHx), 3-hydroxyoctanoate (3HO), 3-hydroxydecanoate (3HD), 3-hydroxydodecanoate (3HDD), and 3-hydroxytetradecanoate (3HTD), with 3HO (44.28%) and 3HD (40.60%) as the dominant units. The polymer exhibited moderate molecular weight and narrow dispersity (M n = 65.4 kDa, M w = 92.1 kDa, Đ = 1.40) and low crystallinity (T m ≈ 76.6 °C, X c ≈ 15.5%). These characteristics indicate elastomer-like behavior, making the material suitable for flexible applications such as films, coatings, adhesives, and blend modifiers. Overall, this study establishes a CO 2 plasma-assisted route for generating fermentable polyethylene-derived intermediates and demonstrates that fed-batch co-culture fermentation can effectively funnel plastic-derived carbon into mcl-PHA.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Hierarchical microstructure of Yb-filled skutterudites through ultrasonically atomized spherical powders for enhanced thermoelectric performance

Hierarchical microstructures are widely explored as a strategy to reduce lattice thermal conductivity in thermoelectric materials while preserving favorable electronic transport. Here we demonstrate that ultrasonic atomization of precursor powders provides an intrinsic pathway to generate such architectures in n-type Yb0.3Co4Sb12 skutterudites. Materials were synthesized by both conventional sealed-ampoule and ultrasonic atomization routes, each yielding essentially single-phase skutterudite after densification. However, the atomized spherical powders undergo a distinct reaction-driven microstructural evolution during thermal treatment prior to densification. Electron microscopy reveals that the skutterudite phase within the particles induces swelling, cracking, and fragmentation of the droplets before consolidation. Multimodal structural and microstructural characterizations show that densification of these fragmented powders produces a hierarchical microstructure consisting of submicron grains, micrometer-scale faceted crystallites, and powder-derived domains separated by oxide-decorated boundaries. Comprehensive thermoelectric transport measurements evidence that this multiscale architecture lowers the lattice thermal conductivity while maintaining favorable electronic transport, leading to an average ~10% enhancement in the thermoelectric figure of merit. Complementary 121Sb Mössbauer spectroscopy further indicates lattice softening in the atomized material. These results demonstrate that ultrasonic atomization provides an effective route to engineer hierarchical microstructures in skutterudite thermoelectrics and offers a promising strategy for tailoring thermal transport in energy-conversion materials.

Bouteiller, Hugo [ORNL] (ORCID:0009000421322962)↗

Carbon doping in GeTe drives differences in local structure and properties

Advances in low-power, energy-efficient information storage and computing require understanding and controlling the atomic and nanoscale structures of functional materials, such as phase-change materials. Phase-change memory technology enables nonvolatile, low-power memory in devices by storing information through reversible changes in a phase-change material's atomic structure (i.e., transformations between amorphous and crystalline phases) that have corresponding changes in properties, including electronic resistivity and optical reflectivity. Here, we apply complementary X-ray absorption spectroscopy and X-ray pair distribution function analyses to experimentally identify the local- and medium-range atomic structure differences of GeTe and C-doped GeTe thin films. Upon controlled heating, composition- and temperature-dependent atomic structure evolution in GeTe and C-doped GeTe films shows differences in bonding behavior and local structure that directly influence crystallization onset temperature. We find that the introduction of C interrupts Ge–Ge bonds in amorphous GeTe, altering the as-deposited structure to be more similar to the distorted rocksalt structure of crystalline α–GeTe. The change alters the response of the amorphous atomic structure to heating and also lowers the crystallization onset temperature, from 230 °C in GeTe to 220 °C in the C-doped film. The combined insights from both X-ray techniques provide understanding of structural transformations that enables the development and optimization of next-generation memory and computing materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Chapter 13: Time-of-Flight Secondary-Ion Mass Spectrometry and Atom Probe Tomography

Time-of-flight secondary-ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) and atom probe tomography (APT) have many similarities. Both detect the chemical makeup of a solid material at ppm or better sensitivity, while retaining the spatial location information from the signal. Both use a similar principle to measure a signal associated with a given charged secondary ion—the flight time it takes a secondary ion to reach the detector after it is generated. Both are destructive techniques—albeit destructive of very small volumes—because the signal measured is generated by the removal of material from the sample itself. Importantly, both techniques require ultra-high vacuum (UHV) to ensure that the secondary ions, once generated, can reach the detector without collision with other atoms in the gas phase. In the case of TOF-SIMS, the samples can vary from several mm to several inches in size, whereas for APT, the samples are cones several hundred microns in size that are prepared in a special manner (covered in detail later in the chapter). We will discuss the basic fundamentals of each technique and cover several examples of the technique applied to photovoltaic materials, which should give a good idea of the types of information one can gain from TOF-SIMS and APT and how they are complementary as they both operate at different length scales: at the hundreds of microns to hundreds of nanometer scale for TOF-SIMS and at the nanometer to a few angstroms scale for APT.

41 EE - Solar Energy Technologies Office (EE-4S)↗

Chapter 8: Time-Resolved Photoluminescence Characterization of Polycrystalline Thin-Film Solar Cells

This chapter describes some photoluminescence (PL) approaches to characterize thin film solar cells with emphasis on time-resolved methods. Spectral PL analysis is complementary and was recently reviewed. Since TRPL is not very commonly used in PV characterization, we consider interface and bulk recombination in the test structures and in devices, briefly describe charge-carrier transport and recombination microscopy, and finally, summarize and compare some CdTe, CdSeTe, CIGS, kesterite, and perovskite EO characteristics.

bulk recombination↗