Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Fuel Performance Modeling”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 937 records · Page 52

Initial Demonstration of Peregrine in VERA-CS

This milestone demonstrates integration of the MOOSE-based Peregrine fuel performance code into the CASL Virtual Environment for Reactor Analysis (VERA). Specifically targeted at VERA’s core simulator functionality (VERA-CS), the existing VERA subchannel-neutronics capability based on COBRA-TF (CTF) and Insilico was extended to use the axisymmetric 2D R-Z fuel rod modeling functionality of PEREGINE to replace the simple fuel rod model in CTF. This three-way coupling involved defining and implementing data interfaces, software infrastructure development to support the requirements of each code, and numerical methods to implement the coupled physics. The result is a new VERA capability known as Tiamat. Development of Tiamat required extensions to the VERA build system to support a “meta build” that uses the MOOSE/libMesh/Peregrine native build system, development of a new driver layer designed to support long-term CASL code integration requirements, and implementation of data transfers for the coupled applications using the DataTransferKit (DTK). Peregrine is now compiled and tested under the VERA continuous integration server. Tiamat, a new advanced simulation tool consisting of three coupled codes - CTF for multiphase subchannel flow, Insilico for neutronics and Peregrine for fuels performance - has been developed. Tiamat was used to simulate a 17x17 assembly model for Watts Bar Unit 1 Cycle 1, which exceeds the goals of this milestone.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Modeling the Pore Formation Mechanism in UMo/AL Dispersion Fuel

In UMo/Al dispersion fuel meat, pores formed in the ILs or at IL-Al interfaces tend to increase in size with irradiation, potentially limiting performance of this fuel. There has been no universally accepted mechanism for the formation and growth of this type of pore. However, there is a consensus that the stress state determined by meat swelling and fission- induced creep is one of the determinants, and fission gas availability at the pore site is another. Five dispersion RERTR miniplates that have well defined irradiation conditions and PIE data were selected for examination. Meat swelling and pore volume were measured in each plate. ABAQUS finite element analysis (FEA) package was utilized to obtain the time-dependent evolution of mechanical states in the plates while matching the measured meat swelling and creep. Interpretation of these results give insights on how to model a failure function – a predictor for large pore formation – using variables such as meat swelling, interaction layer growth, stress, and creep. This model can be used for optimizing fuel design parameters to reach the desired goal: meeting high power and performance reactor demand.

Kim, Yeon Soo↗

Pellet cladding mechanical interaction as a potential failure mechanism during a control rod drop accident in a boiling water reactor

Boiling water reactors (BWRs) represent approximately one-third of the operating fleet in the United States, contributing significantly towards the global effort in reducing carbon emissions. Even though most of the operating fleet has been in operation for quite some time, continued advancements in new nuclear fuel (such as accident tolerant fuel) or operating regimes (such as power up-rates and higher burnup operation) necessitates similar advancements in modeling and simulation capabilities. Bison, a component of the Virtual Environment for Reactor Applications (VERA), is a high-fidelity fuel performance code able to explore the fuel performance of a wide variety of fuel types in one-, two-, and three-dimensions. Until recently, the code had not been used for analyses of BWRs. Modeling capabilities have been added for Gd-bearing UO{sub 2} and pure zirconium liners. New models have been added based upon the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) guide-lines for hydrogen pickup in Zircaloy-2 claddings and pellet-clad mechanical interaction (PCMI) failure during a reactivity insertion accident (RIA), known as a rod drop accident (CRDA) in BWRs. Implementing and/or improving Bison modeling capabilities extended its analytical reach to areas beyond its original intended purpose. This paper demonstrates one of these capabilities as a proof of concept. Recently developed models enable Bison to provide an alternate approach for cladding integrity determination in CRDA evaluations, which currently use bounding conservative estimates. As part of this demonstration, NRC guidance on hydrogen-pickup and PCMI failure models were utilized in this research. Even though more research is needed in establishing right inputs and process in this area, this paper demonstrates Bison's ability to determine cladding integrity in a CRDA evaluation. This first of a kind demonstration is a proof of concept in this area, which could potentially be extended to a number of other areas where a more accurate cladding integrity determination would be needed. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

COUPLING OF RELAP5-SCDAP MOD4.0 AND NEUTRONIC CODES

High-fidelity and accurate nuclear system codes play a key role in the design and analysis of complex nuclear power plants, which consist of multiple subsystems, such as the reactor core (and its fuel, burnable poisons, control elements, etc.), the reactor internal structures, the vessel, and the energy conversion subsystem and beyond to grid demand. Most commonly the interplay between these various subsystems is modeled using coupled codes, each of which represents one of the subsystems. And the most common direct coupling is that of thermal-hydraulics and neutronics codes. The subject of this paper is the coupling of codes that model not only thermal-hydraulics and neutronics, but also structural components damage. Furthermore, the neutronic component is not limited to the sole core solver. The coupled code system encompasses thermal-hydraulics, material performance of the fuel, neutronic solver, and neutronic data preparation. Thus, this paper presents a framework for coupling RELAP5/SCDAPSIM/MOD4.0 with a suite of neutron kinetics codes that includes NESTLE, DRAGON and a version of the ENDF library. The version of the RELAP5/SCDAPSIM/MOD4.0 code used in this work is one developed by Innovate System Software (ISS) as part of the international SCDAP Development and Training Program (SDTP) for best-estimate analysis to model reactor transients including severe accident phenomena. This RELAP5/SCDAPSIM/MOD4.0 code version is also capable of predicting nuclear fuel performance. It uses nodal power distributions to calculate mechanical and thermal parameters such as heat-up, oxidation and meltdown of fuel rods and control rods, the ballooning and rupture of fuel rod cladding, the release of fission products from fuel rods, and the disintegration of fuel rods into porous debris and molten material. On the neutronics side, this work uses the NESTLE and DRAGON codes. NESTLE is a multi-dimensional static and kinetic neutronic code developed at North Carolina State University. It solves up to four energy groups neutron diffusion equations utilizing the Nodal Expansion Method (NEM) in Cartesian or hexagonal geometry. The DRAGON code, developed at Ecole Polytechnique de Montreal, performs lattice physics calculations based on the neutron transport equation and is capable of using very fine energy group structures. In this work, we have developed a coupling approach to exchange data among the various modules. In the coupling process, the generated nuclear data (in fine multigroup energy structure) are collapsed down into two- or four-group energy structures for use in NESTLE. The neutron kinetics and thermal-hydraulics modules are coupled at each time step by using the cross-section data. The power distribution results of the neutronic calculations are transmitted to the thermal-hydraulics code. The spatial distribution of coolant density and the fuel-moderator temperature, which result from the thermal-hydraulic calculations, are transmitted back to the neutron kinetics codes and then the loop is closed using new neutronics results. Details of the actual data transfers will be described in the full length paper.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Modeling and simulation challenges pursued by the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL)

The Consortium for the Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL), the first Energy Innovation Hub of the Department of Energy, was established in 2010 with the goal of providing modeling and simulation (M&S) capabilities that support and accelerate the improvement of nuclear energy's economic competitiveness and the reduction of spent nuclear fuel volume per unit energy, and all while assuring nuclear safety. To accomplish this requires advances in M&S capabilities in radiation transport, thermal-hydraulics, fuel performance and corrosion chemistry. To focus CASL's R&D, industry challenge problems have been defined, which equate with long standing issues of the nuclear power industry that M&S can assist in addressing. To date CASL has developed a multi-physics “core simulator” based upon pin-resolved radiation transport and subchannel (within fuel assembly) thermal-hydraulics, capitalizing on the capabilities of high performance computing. CASL's fuel performance M&S capability can also be optionally integrated into the core simulator, yielding a coupled multi-physics capability with untapped predictive potential. Material models have been developed to enhance predictive capabilities of fuel clad creep and growth, along with deeper understanding of zirconium alloy clad oxidation and hydrogen pickup. Understanding of corrosion chemistry (e.g., CRUD formation) has evolved at all scales: micro, meso and macro. CFD R&D has focused on improvement in closure models for subcooled boiling and bubbly flow, and the formulation of robust numerical solution algorithms. For multiphysics integration, several iterative acceleration methods have been assessed, illuminating areas where further research is needed. Finally, uncertainty quantification and data assimilation techniques, based upon sampling approaches, have been made more feasible for practicing nuclear engineers via R&D on dimensional reduction and biased sampling. Industry adoption of CASL's evolving M&S capabilities, which is in progress, will assist in addressing long-standing and future operational and safety challenges of the nuclear industry. - Highlights: • Complexity of physics based modeling of light water reactor cores being addressed. • Capability developed to help address problems that have challenged the nuclear power industry. • Simulation capabilities that take advantage of high performance computing developed.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

2022 Accomplishments Report Template

Chromium-doped UO 2 fuels is an industrially important Accident Tolerant Fuel (ATF) due to the ability to increase the average grain size relative to standard UO 2 . However, there is a lack of knowledge of the thermophysical properties of these doped fuels, which is necessary for accurately modeling the in-pile performance. The work accomplished this FY focused on developing large grain Cr-doped UO 2 pellets as a function of Cr content and subsequently measuring the thermophysical and mechanical properties. The microstructural variations were also investigated to evaluate chromium formation within the microstructure of the sintered pellets.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

An a priori Analysis of Mixture Fraction-Based Modeling of Coal Combustion

Due to the high computational cost associated with using detailed kinetic mechanisms, it is common practice to implement reaction models which rely on relatively small number of variables when simulating turbulent combustion systems. In this study, we perform an a priori assessment of the accuracy of three chemistry models: a Burke-Schumann chemistry model, an equilibrium chemistry model, and a steady laminar flamelet model. All chemistry modeling approaches considered include a mixture fraction for devolatilization products, and a normalized enthalpy deficit as parameters, with scalar dissipation rate as an additional input parameter for the flamelet model. Data used as a basis for the study is generated through One-Dimensional Turbulence (ODT) simulation of a coal combustion system in which high-fidelity models are used for gas phase chemistry and devolatilization. The flamelet model was found to be more accurate than both the equilibrium and Burke-Schumann models over a majority of parameter space. The performance of all models considered declined substantially for sufficiently fuel-rich conditions. Furthermore, the analysis in this work indicate that both differential diffusion and speciation of volatiles have a perceptible negative impact on flamelet reconstructions, though the effect of differential diffusion was more substantial.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Fuel relocation recovery implementation in Bison

During the initial rise to power in light water reactors (LWR), thermal gradients within a pellet cause radial and axial cracks to form in the fuel. The effect of these cracks is to reduce the pellet-cladding gap and accelerate the interaction between the fuel and cladding. This process is known as fuel relocation and may also include contributions from pellet eccentricity and cladding ovality. Since the cladding experiences both elevated temperatures and high external pressure due to the coolant, the cladding typically creeps inward further reducing the pellet-cladding gap. Once the gap is closed and pellet cladding mechanical interaction (PCMI) begins, both the thermal and mechanical behavior of the fuel is affected. The compressive forces exerted on the fuel due to contact with the cladding cause the fractured fuel sections to move back toward their original position which is termed relocation recovery. A model for this phenomenon is implemented in the BISON fuel performance code and applied to a set of validation test cases. In conclusion, the predicted fuel rod diameter is compared to experimental measurements to evaluate the influence of relocation recovery over a range of operating conditions.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Phase-field simulations of intragranular fission gas bubble evolution in UO2 under post-irradiation thermal annealing

Fission gas bubble is one of evolving microstructures, which affect thermal mechanical properties such as thermo-conductivity, gas release, volume swelling, and cracking, in operating nuclear fuels. Therefore, fundamental understanding of gas bubble evolution kinetics is essential to predict the thermodynamic property and performance changes of fuels. In this work, a generic phasefield model was developed to describe the evolution kinetics of intra-granular fission gas bubbles in UO2 fuels under post-irradiation thermal annealing conditions. Free energy functional and model parameters are evaluated from atomistic simulations and experiments. Critical nuclei size of the gas bubble and gas bubble evolution were simulated. A linear relationship between logarithmic bubble number density and logarithmic mean bubble diameter is predicted which is in a good agreement with experimental data.

Intra-granular gas bubbles evolution↗

Evaluation of Radiolysis Data for Hydrogen Gas Generation During Gamma Irradiation of Pre-Corroded and Pristine Aluminum Samples - An Aluminum SNF Dry Storage Study Interim Report

Information and data from radiolysis testing to measure hydrogen (H₂) generated from hydrated oxides on aluminum exposed to ⁶⁰Co radiation were reviewed to evaluate hydrogen generation with radiation dose. Hydrogen generation rate is a primary input to the coupled thermal-chemical system model of the performance of aluminum-clad spent nuclear fuel in a dry storage canister (ASNF-in-canister) over its storage life. Hydrogen generation data and hydrogen generation rate (hydrogen generated per absorbed radiation dose, $\Delta$(H₂)/$\Delta$(dose)) were reported in two reports for radiolysis testing [1, 2]. The testing involved first-time data¹ for radiolytic yield of hydrogen from hydrated-oxides-on-aluminum substrates, and from pristine (non-corroded) aluminum substrates. The laboratory-grown hydrated-oxides-on-aluminum substrates contained a ~ 5 μm film consisting of the trihydroxide bayerite (Al(OH)₃) with amounts of the oxyhydroxide boehmite (AlOOH). These specimens were assumed to also contain physisorbed water (unquantified). The pristine substrates were flat coupons of aluminum that were ground to a 600-grit finish but were not immersed in water to grow a hydrated oxide. The pristine substrates were tested as companion specimens to provide information on hydrogen generation from material without chemisorbed water and were assumed to contain physisorbed water (unquantified).

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Impact of Isotope Fidelity on Fuel Cycle Calculations

The purpose of this study is to examine the importance of the isotopic composition of plutonium on PWR MOX fuel fabrication as part of a multi-tiered fuel cycle, and the effect of its evolution during a transition. Two main effects can modify the isotopic composition of the plutonium used to build the PWR-MOX fuel: decay and depletion. This analysis is based on a transition of the nuclear fuel cycle to a configuration identified as 'Evaluation Group 29' or 'EG29', in the recently-published Evaluation and Screening (E and S) report. The EG29 fuel cycle corresponds to a double strata fleet. The first stratum is composed of sodium-cooled fast reactors (SFRs) multi-recycling plutonium. Surplus plutonium is sent to the second stratum composed of pressurized water reactors with full mixed oxide (U/Pu)O{sub 2} cores (MOX-PWRs). The PWR stratum is also multi-recycling its plutonium. The target energy generation ratio for the final EG29 system is 70:30 (SFR:PWR), with a 1% annual growth in nuclear energy demand. All the calculation of this study have been performed using the Cyclus fuel cycle simulator framework. The facility models are from the Cycamore package, developed by the Cyclus team, and containing a Pu-equivalent fuel fabrication model as well as a simple fixed mixing ratio fuel fabrication model. A new neural network model has also been contributed to the Cyclus environment using the cyCLASS tool, allowing the use of the fuel fabrication and depletion models from the CLASS tool in Cyclus. (authors)

07 ISOTOPE AND RADIATION SOURCES↗

Nuclide inventory validation: radiochemical assay data quality and modeling challenges in benchmark models development

Oak Ridge National Laboratory is conducting radiochemical assay experiments, using high-precision analytical protocols validated with a comprehensive quality assurance plan, to expand the nuclide inventory validation basis for high burnup spent nuclear fuel. Preliminary measurement data for key actinides and fission products in two pressurized water reactor spent fuel samples are being used to investigate the impact of measurement data uncertainty on the sample burnup estimation. These measurement data are also being used to examine the impact of assumptions applied when developing best-estimate computational models to simulate fuel irradiation history. The simulations are being performed using depletion capabilities in the SCALE code system. Comparison of calculated and measured nuclide concentrations shows good agreement for the considered nuclides. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Modeling the Nuclear Fuel Cycle

A review of existing nuclear fuel cycle systems analysis codes was performed to determine if any existing codes meet technical and functional requirements defined for a U.S. national program supporting the global and domestic assessment, development and deployment of nuclear energy systems. The program would be implemented using an interconnected architecture of different codes ranging from the fuel cycle analysis code, which is the subject of the review, to fundamental physical and mechanistic codes. Four main functions are defined for the code: (1) the ability to characterize and deploy individual fuel cycle facilities and reactors in a simulation, while discretely tracking material movements, (2) the capability to perform an uncertainty analysis for each element of the fuel cycle and an aggregate uncertainty analysis, (3) the inclusion of an optimization engine able to optimize simultaneously across multiple objective functions, and (4) open and accessible code software and documentation to aid in collaboration between multiple entities and facilitate software updates. Existing codes, categorized as annualized or discrete fuel tracking codes, were assessed according to the four functions and associated requirements. These codes were developed by various government, education and industrial entities to fulfill particular needs. In some cases, decisions were made during code development to limit the level of detail included in a code to ease its use or to focus on certain aspects of a fuel cycle to address specific questions. The review revealed that while no two of the codes are identical, they all perform many of the same basic functions. No code was able to perform defined function 2 or several requirements of functions 1 and 3. Based on this review, it was concluded that the functions and requirements will be met only with development of a new code, referred to as GENIUS.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

BISON Validation to In-Situ Cladding Burst Test and High Burnup LOCA Experiments

The process to develop and qualify nuclear fuels for commercial nuclear application requires fundamental material development, characterization, and design; out-of-pile testing on unirradiated materials; integral fuel rod irradiations, testing, and post irradiation examinations (PIEs); and transient analyses. The historical approach depends on the generation of large empirical datasets and series of integral fuel rod irradiations, and this approach ultimately takes approximately 20 years—or sometimes longer—to acquire data through extensive sequential testing. Thus, the qualification and eventual deployment of new fuel systems constitute a long and drawn-out process. However, recent technological advancements have provided researchers the opportunity to perform out-of-cell, in-situ measurements to assess material performance for the duration of the experiment. One such example of this capability is the use of digital image coordination and thermal imaging to assess Zircaloy cladding performance under a simulated loss-of-coolant accident (LOCA) transient condition. In general, the in-situ measurements provide high-fidelity strain, strain rates, and temperature surface maps. This is critical for the United States nuclear industry, which is actively developing a technical basis to support extending the peak rod average burnup from 62 to ~75 GWd/tU and the deployment of accident-tolerant fuel. However, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, through their research information letter, outlined a number of technical issues for the industry to address before extending burnup. One topic of specific interest is understanding the cladding balloon and rupture geometry during the LOCA heatup phase. Leveraging these advanced in-situ capabilities, this work intends to use insitu data generated from a simulated LOCA in the Severe Accident Test Station at Oak Ridge National Laboratory to better understand high-temperature creep and its impact on Zircaloy balloon and rupture performance. This work used the BISON fuel performance code to compare BISON’s high-temperature creep model predictions to in-situ data and identify limitations and gaps within the model. Additionally, BISON will subsequently be used to simulate relevant high-burnup LOCA tests. The results will be analyzed and compared to the available post-test data in a manner consistent with the approach outlined in the Nuclear Regulatory Commission research information letter.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Mechanical modeling of porous oxide fuel pellet A Test Problem

A poro-elasto-plastic material model has been developed to capture the response of oxide fuels inside the nuclear reactors under operating conditions. Behavior of the oxide fuel and variation in void volume fraction under mechanical loading as predicted by the developed model has been reported in this article. The significant effect of void volume fraction on the overall stress distribution of the fuel pellet has also been described. An important oxide fuel issue that can have significant impact on the fuel performance is the mechanical response of oxide fuel pellet and clad system. Specifically, modeling the thermo-mechanical response of the fuel pellet in terms of its thermal expansion, mechanical deformation, swelling due to void formation and evolution, and the eventual contact of the fuel with the clad is of significant interest in understanding the fuel-clad mechanical interaction (FCMI). These phenomena are nonlinear and coupled since reduction in the fuel-clad gap affects thermal conductivity of the gap, which in turn affects temperature distribution within the fuel and the material properties of the fuel. Consequently, in order to accurately capture fuel-clad gap closure, we need to account for fuel swelling due to generation, retention, and evolution of fission gas in addition to the usual thermal expansion and mechanical deformation. Both fuel chemistry and microstructure also have a significant effect on the nucleation and growth of fission gas bubbles. Fuel-clad gap closure leading to eventual contact of the fuel with the clad introduces significant stresses in the clad, which makes thermo-mechanical response of the clad even more relevant. The overall aim of this test problem is to incorporate the above features in order to accurately capture fuel-clad mechanical interaction. Because of the complex nature of the problem, a series of test problems with increasing multi-physics coupling features, modeling accuracy, and complexity are defined with the objective of accurate simulation of fuel-clad mechanical interaction subjected to a wide-range of thermomechanical stimuli.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Developing Spent Fuel Assembly for Advanced NDA Instrument Calibration - NGSI Spent Fuel Project

This report summarizes the work by Oak Ridge National Laboratory to investigate the application of modeling and simulation to support the performance assessment and calibration of the advanced nondestructive assay (NDA) instruments developed under the Next Generation Safeguards Initiative Spent Fuel (NGSI-SF) Project. Advanced NDA instrument calibration will likely require reference spent fuel assemblies with well-characterized nuclide compositions that can serve as working standards. Because no reference spent fuel standard currently exists, and the practical ability to obtain direct measurement of nuclide compositions using destructive assay (DA) measurements of an entire fuel assembly is prohibitive in the near term due to the complexity and cost of spent fuel experiments, modeling and simulation will be required to construct such reference fuel assemblies. These calculations will be used to support instrument field tests at the Swedish Interim Storage Facility (Clab) for Spent Nuclear Fuel.

Hu, Jianwei↗

Graphite Moderation in Fast Reactors

With the renewed interest in designing and building a fast test reactor in the U.S., several new reactor concepts have been emerging. Although the main mission of a fast test reactor would be to enable high fast flux irradiation capability, there could be added value for such a fast test reactor to also offer thermal neutron irradiation capabilities. As such, several of these concepts considered the use of a moderator material in a Sodium-cooled Fast Reactor (SFR), which is claimed to also offer benefits with respect of mass of fuel required. The work discussed in this paper focuses on exploring and assessing the benefits and challenges resulting from making use of thermalized neutrons to reduce the critical fuel mass. The analyses are performed for a graphite moderating material, using a simple core model to easily identify the phenomena observed. It is found that it is necessary to reduce the fuel enrichment near the moderated regions in order to avoid unacceptable power peaking. In the end, use of moderating materials outside a SFR core does not provide significant benefit in term of fuel volume reduction, but allows for a noticeable reduction of the mass of fissile material needed. However, it also implies a number of additional challenges which are highlighted in this paper.

core optimization↗

Economic viability of multiple algal biorefining pathways and the impact of public policies

This study presents an extensive systems-level multi-pathway sustainability assessment of algae biofuel production that demonstrates the necessity of high-value co-products, examines the impact of public policy scenarios, and identifies improvements and pathway directions required for economic viability. Engineering process models for several fuel and co-product pathways were leveraged to perform high fidelity techno-economic analysis. These pathways included: baseline hydrothermal liquefaction; protein extraction followed by hydro-thermal liquefaction; fractionation into high-value chemicals with fermentation followed by hydrothermal liquefaction for fuels; and a small-scale first-of-a-kind plant coupled with a wastewater treatment facility. From these models, it was shown that hydrothermal liquefaction as a fuel-only pathway is not economically viable. Likewise, the benefits of coupling with wastewater water treatment are insignificant compared to the impact ofreduced facility size resulting in increased capital costs. These models were also used to examine public policy scenarios, uniquely presenting their impact on the breakeven cost of fuel production and sensitivity to scenario assumptions. Specifically, depreciation type was shown to be irrelevant for write offs faster than 10 years. Due to discounting, short-term subsidies were found to capture 50% of the subsidy value in 6 years with an additional24 years required for full subsidy valuation. Integration of a carbon economy was shown to decrease biofuel production costs, particularly for the protein pathway due to the co-product accounting. Finally, a metric of normalized costs was used to compare algal biorefineries to corn and cellulosic ethanol production, showing that algal systems are uniquely different due to significantly higher capital costs, though operational costs are comparable. Overall, this work demonstrates that, to reach economic viability, algal biofuel production must either utilize higher value non-fuel co-products or achieve drastic reductions in capital costs.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗