Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “metallic components”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 919 records · Page 51
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2022

High Nickel and No Cobalt - The Pursuit of Next-Generation Layered Oxide Cathodes

The prosperity of the electric vehicle industry is driving the research and development of lithium-ion batteries. As one of the core components in the entire battery system, cathode materials are currently facing major challenges in pushing higher capacity up to their theoretical limits and transitioning away from the unaffordable metals. To meet these requirements, the search for next-generation cathode materials has shifted to high-nickel and cobalt-free cathodes. In this review, we distinctly pointed out the shortcomings of cobalt in stabilizing layered structures, and systematically summarized the recent efforts to eliminate cobalt and achieve higher nickel content in layered cathode materials. Lastly, a reasonable prospect is put forward for further development of layered cathode materials and other promising candidates, which is likely to spur a wave of efforts toward developing high-performance and low-cost Li-ion batteries.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Tailored topotactic chemistry unlocks heterostructures of magnetic intercalation compounds

The construction of thin film heterostructures has been a widely successful archetype for fabricating materials with emergent physical properties. This strategy is of particular importance for the design of multilayer magnetic architectures in which direct interfacial spin-spin interactions between magnetic phases in dissimilar layers lead to emergent and controllable magnetic behavior. However, crystallographic incommensurability and atomic-scale interfacial disorder can severely limit the types of materials amenable to this strategy, as well as the performance of these systems. Here, we demonstrate a method for synthesizing heterostructures comprising magnetic intercalation compounds of transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs), through directed topotactic reaction of the TMD with a metal oxide. The mechanism of the intercalation reaction enables thermally initiated intercalation of the TMD from lithographically patterned oxide films, giving access to a family of multi-component magnetic architectures through the combination of deterministic van der Waals assembly and directed intercalation chemistry.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2026

Co-templating of polyoxoniobates and silicate/germanate trimer-rings in crystals and inorganic gels

Polyoxometalate (POM) supramolecular gels are a growing family of materials, both for understanding fundamental self-assembly and fabricating flexible monolithic materials that retain the function of metal oxides. Here, we exploited the pH-dependent speciation of polyoxoniobates (PONbs), targeting the formation of PONb-containing supramolecular gels that contain other low molecular weight components (silicate, germanate, phosphate, and carbonate). The introduction of gaseous CO 2 into aqueous hexaniobate solutions resulted in the formation of both new crystalline phases and highly transparent gels. The crystalline phases, formulated Cs 24 [Nb 7 O 22 (NbO(CO 3 ) 2 ) 9 (Si 3 O 9 )]·19.6H 2 O and Cs 21 Na 3 [Nb 7 O 22 (NbO(CO 3 ) 2 ) 9 (Ge 3 O 9 )]·33.6H 2 O are templated by a rare planar [X 3 O 9 ] 6− (X = Si, Ge) ring. Crystalline phases were not obtained with phosphate; instead, the gels contain a mixture of phosphate-centred PONbs and network-forming phosphate. POM speciation within the gels, physical properties, and assembly mechanisms were benchmarked by solution and solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, vibrational spectroscopies, small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), and thermogravimetry-mass spectroscopy. Optical analysis and dielectric behavior of the gels confirmed that they are highly transparent ionic and electronic conductors. The alkali and hydroxide concentration controls the formation of crystalline materials or supramolecular gels while maintaining the same network building blocks, providing a rare opportunity to describe the molecular-level structure of inorganic amorphous materials.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2026

Experimental investigation of a closed vapour box module for a divertor-like configuration in Magnum-PSI

Efficient management of extreme heat fluxes in the divertor region to extend the lifetime of the components remains a critical challenge for the realization of nuclear fusion-based power plants. Among the alternative concepts explored for the divertor region, the use of liquid metals, particularly lithium, is of interest due its ability to dissipate the incoming plasma heat flux through the vapour shielding effect (VS). In this work, we experimentally investigated a ‘closed’ configuration of a dedicated Vapour Box Module (VBM) in the linear plasma device Magnum-PSI. The goal of the experiments is to simulate the vapour box divertor environment conditions and assess its performance in terms of power mitigation and redistribution and lithium confinement. Initial testing without Li demonstrated the efficacy of a closed VBM structure in inducing detachment via neutral gas accumulation. Apertures which enabled non-condensing gas to be effectively pumped while ensuring lithium condensed on the inner surfaces were therefore added. With a lithium capillary porous structure target used, lithium is directly vaporized by the plasma, forming a dense lithium vapour cloud that interacts with the incoming plasma. This resulted in a significant reduction of the target temperature of at least 48%, together with a temperature locking effect, a phenomenon typically observed in the VS regime. Lithium vapour confinement within the VBM was strongly correlated with the wall temperature. Relatively cold walls promoted Li re-condensation and therefore improved Li confinement, although with the expected trade-off of increased hydrogenic retention on lithium-wetted surfaces. As the wall temperature increased, the confinement efficiency decreased, consistent with reduced Li re-condensation and thermally activated Li–H chemistry and remobilization at the walls. Diagnostic measurements through embedded thermocouples and calorimetry revealed that lithium vaporization and re-condensation processes also playedsignificant roles in plasma power dissipation. The results advance the case for a closed divertor chamber with direct lithium evaporation from the strike-points as a viable method to manage divertor heat fluxes in future fusion reactors.

Romano, Fabio [Dutch Institute for Fundamental Ene↗
DOE OSTI2024

Quantifying Trapped Powder in Electron Beam Powder Bed Fusion

Abstract Electron beam powder bed fusion (PBF-EB) shows great potential for manufacturing complex parts including those with internal cavities for heat exchanger, manifold systems, or energy absorption purposes. PBF-EB allows for the manufacture of channel geometries without the need for support structures. Due to the nature of the powder spreading process, powder feedstock is often trapped in intentionally manufactured cavities. This trapped powder can often be difficult to remove and can disturb the intended flow of fluid through the cavity or damage downstream components in its use case. These trapped powder particles present a risk of contamination and component failure if not completely evacuated. Ti6Al4V is a choice material for aerospace applications due to its high strength to weight ratio and its composition as a nonferrous metal; however, in weight sensitive applications excess entrapped powders or powders loosely attached to the surface could cause undesirable weight increases. The inherent spreading process of PBF-EB is different than laser powder bed fusion (PBF-LB) in its operational temperature, sintering. In addition, PBF-EB is less commonly studied in literature compared to its PBF-LB counterpart, and as a result the complexity of the semi-sintered powder and its spreading behavior are not well understood. Prior work has investigated the difficulty in removing trapped powder from PBF-EB, but these studies do not address how to quantify the amount of trapped powder in the cavity. Thus, an accurate method to measure the amount of trapped powder in the cavity must be investigated. In this work, Ti6Al4V coupons were manufactured with horizontal and vertical cavities of three different sizes. Archimedes testing allows for the determination of density differences caused by porosity and trapped powders by measuring mass and volumetric dispersion. Computed tomography (CT) is well suited for segmenting the internal structure and features of a part and has been studied for applications including voids, porosity, and dross. Thus, CT was explored as a method for evaluating trapped powder content in this work. The volumetric representation of the segmentation of the reconstructed CT volume can vary greatly depending on the input filter and thresholding methods. In this study, four different types of segmentation approaches were evaluated to determine the best approach for segmenting the volume as compared to an operator labeled ground truth. The percentage density results from the Archimedes testing were compared to the volumetric percent density from the computed tomography approach. Differences in packing density between two different internal channel features were investigated. Overall, this work sought to validate the use of computed tomography for the detection of trapped powders and present a framework for volumetric segmentation.

Johnstone, Brian↗
DOE OSTI2020

(Invited) All-Solid-State Batteries Using Li 7 La 3 Zr 2 O 12 Garnet Electrolyte Framework

All-solid-state batteries (ASSB) using LLZO (variants of Li 7 La 3 Zr 2 O 12 ) garnet solid electrolyte with lithium metal anode potentially offer higher energy density and improved safety. Rational design of cell architecture as well as manufacturing scalability are key aspects to consider as the technology readiness level advances. A thick composite cathode layer attached to a thin solid electrolyte layer is desirable to obtain superior energy densities. Furthermore, the architecture within the composite cathode may be engineered to contain directional conduction paths of lithium ions or electrons for enhanced rate capabilities. Here, we demonstrate a functioning bulk-type LLZO based all-solid-state battery with a practical form factor incorporating the above described design concepts. Freeze-tape-casting (FTC), a scalable and environmentally friendly ceramic processing method, is used to construct 3D porous LLZO scaffolds composed of vertical arrays of LLZO walls. The thin solid-electrolyte layer is fabricated by tape-casting (TC). By sintering the stacks of FTC and TC green tapes, porous/dense bilayers and porous/dense/porous trilayers of LLZO frameworks are obtained. An ASSB was constructed using a porous/dense bilayer by infiltrating LiNi 0.6 Mn 0.2 Co 0.2 O 2 cathode powder and carbon black into the porous layer and adhering lithium metal foil to the dense side. We find it crucial to introduce a plastic crystal based soft solid electrolyte to the porous layer to electrochemically connect all cathode components, obviating the need for co-sintering to establish contact. The soft nature of the plastic crystal based solid-electrolyte may be able to accommodate the volume change of the cathode material as it cycles. In this device, which contained no liquid component, the initial discharge capacities were similar to those observed in a lithium ion battery configuration using the same cathode powder at C/10 rates.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Thermomechanical Modeling and Analysis of a High-Temperature Light Trapping Planar Cavity Receiver

Solar energy harnessed through concentrating solar power (CSP) systems offers a promising path to sustainable energy production, with the efficiency and longevity of these systems relying on key components like solar receivers. This study analyzes the thermomechanical behavior of an innovative enclosed light-trapping solar receiver optimized for particle heating applications. The receiver utilizes sheet metal alloys to form enclosed cavities that reflect and trap incoming solar flux, as well as enclosed channels that contain fluidized particle beds absorbing solar heat. Finite element analysis (FEA) is applied to predict the receiver's thermomechanical performance under extreme solar flux conditions. Temperature distributions from a thermal model simulating a multi-panel assembly at steady state are input into the FEA thermomechanical model for stress analysis. A key aspect of the analysis focuses on evaluating creep-fatigue damage, with a design target of achieving a 30- year service life. Various stress relief techniques are also proposed to extend the receiver's service life. The results highlight the significant impact of the particle-to-wall heat transfer coefficients (HTCs), ranging from 800 W/m2*K to 1400 W/m2*K. The 800 W/m2*K case shows a maximum von Mises stress of 164 MPa, while the 1400 W/m2*K case reduces it to 150 MPa. The creep life increases from 4,000 hrs in the 800 W/m2*K case to over 100,000 hrs in the 1400 W/m2*K case with Inconel 740H used, indicating that higher HTCs reduce stress and extend lifespan. This research advances the design of high-efficiency, low-stress solar receivers for particle-based thermal energy storage in CSP and industrial heating applications.

concentrating solar power↗
DOE OSTI2021

Identifying Limitations of ASME Section III Division 5 For Advanced SMR Designs

This report provides an overview of the ASME Boiler & Pressure Vessel Section III, Division 5 rules for the design and construction of high temperature nuclear reactor components. The overview focuses on the application of the rules to the design of Small Modular Reactors (SMRs). The discussion covers the general ASME Code rules for base metal design and construction, the rules for designing weldments, and provides an overview of environmental degradation mechanisms affecting reactor structural materials. The analysis includes historical context on the development of the ASME design approach and a description of what actions could be taken to mitigate the gaps identified in the report. The report concludes with a summary of the key gaps identified in the rules, as they apply to SMR, and a list of recommendations on how those gaps might be addressed.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗
DOE OSTI2023

Light-Induced Spin Trapping in Transition Metal Compounds (DOE-DE-SC0017889-Final-Report)

In solar cells, devices that convert the energy of light directly into electricity, dye sensitized solar cells (DSSC) are some of the most capable devices for energy conversion. Ruthenium is a key component for these high-power conversion efficiencies in DSSC. Ruthenium, unfortunately, is among one of the rarest elements, and, thus, more earth-abundant replacements are needed. Though the properties of ruthenium are unique, these properties may be possible to mimic with other elements. To do this, the ability to control how other more earth-abundant elements like iron behave is essential. In this work, a method was developed to enable better control over iron species, for example, and their interaction with light.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2021

Metal-organic frameworks for the adsorption and catalytic transformations of carbon dioxide

Novel crystalline porous materials known as metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) and methods for their synthesis are provided herein. The MOFs include a M6(μ3-OH)8(OH)8(μ2,η2-(O2C)2cyclam)8 cluster, and a metal atom coordinated to the one or more cyclam of the cluster, wherein M is Zr or Hf, and the metal atom is any one of Cu, Ni, Cr, Ru, Co, and Gd. The MOFs can be used as an adsorbent, alone or in a medium with other components, of CO2. The MOFs can also be used as a catalyst for the transformation of CO2 and epoxides to cyclic carbonates. The MOFs can also be used in the electrochemical catalytic reduction of CO2. The MOFs can also be used for photocatalytic CO2 reduction for the production of carbon-based fossil fuels. The MOFs can also be used for light-induced nitric oxide (NO) release. The MOFs can also be used as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) agents.

Morris, Amanda Jean↗
DOE OSTI2020

3D Hybrid Plasmonic Framework with Au Nanopillars Embedded in Nitride Multilayers Integrated on Si

Integration of nanoscale photonic and plasmonic components on Si substrates is a critical step toward Si-based integrated nanophotonic devices. Herein, a set of unique complex 3D metamaterials with intercalated nanolayered and nanopillar structures with tunable plasmonic and optical properties on Si substrates is designed. More specifically, the 3D metamaterials combine metal (Au) nanopillars and alternating metal-nitride (Au-TiN and Au-TaN) nanolayers, epitaxially grown on Si substrates. The ultrafine Au nanopillars ( d ≈ 3 nm) continuously grow throughout all the nanolayers with high epitaxial quality. Novel optical properties, such as highly anisotropic optical property, high absorbance covering the entire visible spectrum regime, and hyperbolic property in the visible regime, are demonstrated. Furthermore, a waveguide based on a silicon nitride (Si 3 N 4 ) ridge with a multilayer structure is successfully fabricated. The demonstration of 3D nanoscale metamaterial design integrated on Si opens up a new route toward tunable metamaterials nanostructure designs with versatile material selection for various optical components in Si integrated photonics.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2019

High-throughput investigation of crystal-to-glass transformation of Ti–Ni–Cu ternary alloy

A high-throughput investigation of metallic glass formation via solid-state reaction was reported in this paper. Combinatorial multilayered thin-film chips covering the entire Ti-Ni-Cu ternary system were prepared using ion beam sputtering technique. Microbeam synchrotron X-ray diffraction (XRD) and X-ray fluorescence (XRF) measurements were conducted, with 1,325 data points collected from each chip, to map out the composition and the phase constitution before and after annealing at 373 K for 110 hours. The composition dependence of the crystal-to-glass transition by solid-state reaction was surveyed using this approach. The resulting composition-phase map is consistent with previously reported results. Time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectroscopy (ToF-SIMS) was performed on the representative compositions to determine the inter-diffusion between layers, the result shows that the diffusion of Ti is the key factor for the crystal-to-glass transition. In addition, both layer thickness and layer sequence play important roles as well. This work demonstrates that combinatorial chip technique is an efficient way for systematic and rapid study of crystal-to-glass transition for multi-component alloy systems.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Lithium degradation in lithium–sulfur batteries: insights into inventory depletion and interphasial evolution with cycling

The promise of high energy density lithium–sulfur batteries with long cycle life is currently tempered by the rapid degradation of lithium-metal anodes with cycling. An in-depth understanding of the dynamical behavior in liquid electrolytes, including the mechanisms underlying depletion of lithium inventory and evolution of lithium interphases, is crucial to make Li–S batteries a reality. We use here an anode-free full cell configuration, pairing a Li 2 S cathode with a bare nickel current collector with no lithium metal on it, to quantitatively estimate the lithium inventory loss per cycle. Lithium inventory loss is shown to be the main factor limiting the overall cyclability of Li–S batteries. Time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry measurements on the deposited lithium reveal the presence of substantial metallic lithium even after most of the active lithium inventory has been depleted. The trapped metallic lithium is rendered electrochemically inactive by the growth of a resistive electrolyte decomposition interphase on the lithium surface. The bulk of the deposited lithium is shown to be composed of various fully reduced interphasial components, including several hydrogen-containing species that show a substantial reduction in intensity with cycling. This indicates considerable gas evolution and is also correlated with the loss of lithium inventory. The use of an anode-free full cell configuration provides a framework for accurate assessment of the dynamics of lithium inventory depletion and characterization of the accompanying interphasial evolution with cycling. The insights gained will prove invaluable to the development of strategies for extending the cycle life of energy-dense Li–S batteries.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Halide Perovskite Solar Photovoltaics

Technological progress in photovoltaic (PV) technologies provides hope that a comprehensive and desperately needed decarbonization of the energy sector is possible. Commercially successful PV technologies based predominantly on silicon wafer technology are reliable and cost-effective, but remain capital- and carbon-intensive. In this context, emerging PV technologies, such as metal-halide perovskites (MHPs), could further catalyze the energy transition by providing technological opportunities for even lower-cost, mass-producible, high-efficiency solar cells with a significantly reduced "carbon footprint." This themed issue of MRS Bulletin on "Halide perovskite solar photovoltaics summarizes the current state of the art, challenges, and opportunities of perovskite photovoltaics with contributions and perspectives from six expert teams worldwide. The topics covered provide a status update on perovskite PV, remaining hurdles to their deployment, and challenges to realizing the potential of this technology to impact climate goals. Articles in this collection address scalability of perovskite PV and prospects for industrial manufacturing; perovskite PV as an add-on technology on top of commercial silicon PV; environmental and sustainability considerations; and durability and reliability considerations. Further considerations include prospects of automation, coupled to artificial intelligence and machine learning, for accelerating material-based solutions to these outstanding challenges including the possibilities of discovering new absorber and device component materials to enable success and ultimately deployment of these next-generation PVs.

metal-halide perovskites↗
DOE OSTI2021

Mixed matrix membranes for post-combustion carbon capture: From materials design to membrane engineering

Mixed matrix materials (MMMs) containing nanofillers dispersed in continuous polymer matrices have emerged as an exciting and versatile platform to develop membranes with superior CO 2 /N 2 separation performance for post-combustion carbon capture. Both polymers and nanofillers can be vertically designed and engineered to combine the advantages of excellent processability (derived from polymers) and strong size-sieving ability or/and significant permanent porosity (originated from nanofillers). However, the MMMs face major challenges, such as interfacial incompatibility, particle agglomeration, and poor thin-film formability. This report provides a comprehensive yet critical review of various polymers and nanofillers (such as metal-organic frameworks, covalent organic frameworks, and two-dimensional materials) with promising CO 2 /N 2 separation properties. We exhaustively describe strategies to improve interfacial compatibility, such as in situ syntheses of polymers and nanofillers and functionalization of both components to improve adhesion. Moreover, we highlight various approaches to engineer the MMMs into thin-film composite (TFC) membranes. The review reveals the structure/property relationship in these MMMs and outlines the challenges and opportunities to realize their potential for practical applications.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2022

Cast Components for High Temperature Concentrated Solar Power Thermal Systems

Concentrating Solar-Thermal Power (CSP) components such as piping, valves fittings are required for use at temperatures up to 800°C. These are anticipated to be made using Nickel-based alloys such as Haynes ® 230 ® , Haynes ® 282 ® , or IN ® 740H ® and can contribute significantly to the cost of a CSP Gen 3 plant. Thus, there is a significant motivation to lower the cost of materials and components so that the capital costs can be minimized. In all these cases, the cost of the component has two contributions: 1. Materials cost, and 2. Manufacturing cost. Both materials cost and manufacturing costs must be kept low to attain the lowest possible cost. Materials cost can be lowered by using materials that have the ideal combination of properties at the lowest cost. Another avenue to lower cost is chose a manufacturing process that has the potential to lower the cost. Traditionally tubes are made from billets through a wrought process and can be expensive. An alternative process to consider is the centrifugal casting process where the tube is directly fabricated from molten metal. In this case, the molten metal is poured inside a cylindrical metallic mold with an insulating layer and is spun rapidly. A wide range of sizes (diameter, wall thickness, and length) can be cast using this process. The objective of this project was to develop the process for fabricating pipes and related components using a centrifugal casting process and to measure the properties of alloys fabricated using this process.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2022

Closo ‐Borate Gel Polymer Electrolyte with Remarkable Electrochemical Stability and a Wide Operating Temperature Window

Abstract A major challenge in the pursuit of higher‐energy‐density lithium batteries for carbon‐neutral‐mobility is electrolyte compatibility with a lithium metal electrode. This study demonstrates the robust and stable nature of a closo ‐borate based gel polymer electrolyte (GPE), which enables outstanding electrochemical stability and capacity retention upon extensive cycling. The GPE developed herein has an ionic conductivity of 7.3 × 10 −4 S cm −2 at room temperature and stability over a wide temperature range from −35 to 80 °C with a high lithium transference number ( = 0.51). Multinuclear nuclear magnetic resonance and Fourier transform infrared are used to understand the solvation environment and interaction between the GPE components. Density functional theory calculations are leveraged to gain additional insight into the coordination environment and support spectroscopic interpretations. The GPE is also established to be a suitable electrolyte for extended cycling with four different active electrode materials when paired with a lithium metal electrode. The GPE can also be incorporated into a flexible battery that is capable of being cut and still functional. The incorporation of a closo ‐borate into a gel polymer matrix represents a new direction for enhancing the electrochemical and physical properties of this class of materials.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2021

Performance Validation of Pulsed Thermal Imaging System for In-Service Applications

Additive manufacturing (AM) is an emerging method for cost-efficient fabrication of complex topology nuclear reactor parts from high-strength corrosion resistance alloys, such as stainless steel and Inconel. AM of metallic structures for nuclear energy applications is currently based on laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) process, which has the capability of melting metallic powder and net shaping the structures with relatively high precision. Some of the challenges with using LPBF method for nuclear manufacturing include the possibility of introducing pores into metallic structures. Integrity of AM structures needs to be evaluated nondestructively because material flaws could lead to premature failures in high temperature nuclear reactor environment. Currently, there exist limited capabilities to evaluate actual AM structures non-destructively. Pulsed Thermography Imaging (PTI) provides a capability for non-destructive evaluation (NDE) of subsurface defects in arbitrary size structures. The PTI method is based on recording material surface temperature transients with infrared (IR) camera following thermal pulse delivered on material surface with flash light. The PTI method has advantages for NDE of actual AM structures because the method involves one-sided non-contact measurements and fast processing of large sample areas captured in one image. Following initial qualification of an AM component for deployment in a nuclear reactor, a PTI system can also be used for in-service nondestructive evaluation (NDE) applications. In this report, we describe recent progress in enhancing PTI capabilities in detecting microscopic defects in metallic specimens. SS316 and IN718 specimens were developed with a pattern of subsurface calibrated flat bottom hole (FBH) defects with diameters from 500µm to 200µm. FBH’s were created with EDM (electron discharge machining) drill. PTI imaging data was processed Spatial Temporal Denoised Thermal Source Separation (STDTSS) unsupervised machine learning (ML) algorithm. We show that defects as small as 200µm in SS316 and IN718 can be detected with STDTSS algorithm. To the best of our knowledge, these are the smallest detected defects which are reported in literature.

42 ENGINEERING↗