SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “experimental conditions”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

SourceResearch connectionFrom yearThrough year

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 919 records · Page 51

All sources NASA NTRS DOE OSTI

NASA NTRS2014

Characterization of the NASA Langley Arc Heated Scramjet Test Facility Using NO PLIF

The nitric oxide planar laser-induced fluorescence (NO PLIF) imaging was used to characterize the air flow of the NASA Langley Arc Heated Scramjet Test Facility (AHSTF) configured with a Mach 6 nozzle. The arc raises the enthalpy of the test gas in AHSTF, producing nitric oxide. Nitric oxide persists as the temperature drops through the nozzle into the test section. NO PLIF was used to qualitatively visualize the flowfield at different experimental conditions, measure the temperature of the gas flow exiting the facility nozzle, and visualize the wave structure downstream of the nozzle at different operating conditions. Uniformity and repeatability of the nozzle flow were assessed. Expansion and compression waves on the free-jet shear layer as the nozzle flow expands into the test section were visualized. The main purpose of these experiments was to assess the uniformity of the NO in the freestream gas for planned experiments, in which NO PLIF will be used for qualitative fuel-mole-fraction sensitive imaging. The shot-to-shot fluctuations in the PLIF signal, caused by variations in the overall laser intensity as well as NO concentration and temperature variations in the flow was 20-25% of the mean signal, as determined by taking the standard deviation of a set of images obtained at constant conditions and dividing by the mean. The fluctuations within individual images, caused by laser sheet spatial variations as well as NO concentration and temperature variations in the flow, were about 28% of the mean in images, determined by taking standard deviation within individual images, dividing by the mean in the same image and averaged over the set of images. Applying an averaged laser sheet intensity correction reduced the within-image intensity fluctuations to about 10% suggesting that the NO concentration is uniform to within 10%. There was no significant difference in flow uniformity between the low and high enthalpy settings. While not strictly quantitative, the temperature maps show qualitative agreement with the computations of the flow.

Kidd, F. Gray, III↗

NASA NTRS2015

The Growth of Small Corrosion Fatigue Cracks in Alloy 7075

The corrosion fatigue crack growth characteristics of small (greater than 35 micrometers) surface and corner cracks in aluminum alloy 7075 is established. The early stage of crack growth is studied by performing in situ long focal length microscope (500×) crack length measurements in laboratory air and 1% sodium chloride (NaCl) environments. To quantify the "small crack effect" in the corrosive environment, the corrosion fatigue crack propagation behavior of small cracks is compared to long through-the-thickness cracks grown under identical experimental conditions. In salt water, long crack constant K(sub max) growth rates are similar to small crack da/dN.

Piascik, Robert S.↗

NASA NTRS2015

Synthesis and Modification of Holey Graphene for Energy Storage

Porous graphene materials have recently drawn significant interest for energy storage applications due to the effective use of the graphitic surface area provided by the pores. Holey graphene is a type of porous graphene with pores in the form of physical through thickness holes. This type of porous graphene provides a unique morphology that allows for effective transport of molecular species through the graphene plane. Therefore, as we recently demonstrated, holey graphene could be advantageous in the preparation of electrodes in supercapacitors with high volumetric performance.1 We have developed methodologies to scalably prepare holey graphene materials with or without the use of catalysts (Figure 1).1,2 In this presentation, we will discuss the choice of synthetic strategies and experimental conditions on the morphology and physical properties of holey graphene (Figure 2) and the effect on their electrochemical properties. We will also present the results on the further modification of holey graphene to study their physical and chemical properties, especially with regard to the stability and chemical reactivity of carbons located around the edges of the holes.

Lin, Yi↗

NASA NTRS1973

Atmospheric Temperature from Raman Scattering

Raman scattering signatures are functions of the scattering-gas temperature, and are therefore of potential use for practical atmospheric temperature probes. The method described uses either ratios of pure rotational Raman scattering intensities for air utilizing various spectral bandpasses, or, alternatively, ratios of air-rotational to nitrogen-vibrational scattering intensities. Three aspects of work relating to the development of such probes are discussed in this presentation: (1) fundamental absolute Raman data, (2) construction of air spectra from these data, and (3) temperature-sensitivity of the signature. The fundamental data described are the absolute rotational and vibrational scattering cross sections. Recent measurements in this laboratory of rotational cross sections for N2, O2, and CO2 are emphasized, as are their use in predicting absolute magnitudes of Raman scattering signals. Next is described the computation of air rotational Raman spectra as a function of temperature calculated through use of the experimentally-measured cross sections. The spectra are based additively upon nitrogen and oxygen contributions, since pure rotational Raman scattering from water vapor is very weak. Finally, the sensitivity of the scattering intensity ratios to temperature is explored as a function of choice of spectral bandpass for the monitored rotational Raman scattering. Various compromises will be discussed which must be made in choosing bandpasses appropriate for specific purposes and experimental conditions.

Lapp, M.↗

NASA NTRS2016

Human Health Countermeasures - Partial-Gravity Analogs Workshop

The experimental conditions that were deemed the most interesting by the HHC Element lead scientists are those permitting studies of the long-term effects of exposure to (a) chronic rotation when supine or in head down tilt (ground-based); and (b) long-radius centrifugation (space based). It is interesting to note that chronic ground based slow rotation room studies have not been performed since the 1960's, when the USA and USSR were investigating the potential use of AG for long-duration space missions. On the other hand, the other partial gravity analogs, i.e., parabolic flight, HUT, suspension, and short-radius centrifugation, have been regularly used in the last three decades (see review in Clément et al. 2015). Based on the workshop evaluations and the scores by the HHC scientific disciplines indicated in tables 3 and 4, simulation of partial G between 0 and 1 should be prioritized as follows: Priority 1. Chronic space-based partial-G analogs: a. Chronic space-based long-radius centrifugation. The ideal scenario would be chronic long-radius centrifugation of cells, animals and humans in a translational research approach - ideally beyond low earth orbit under deep space environmental effects and at various rotations - to obtain different G-effects. In this scenario, all physiological systems could be evaluated and the relationship between physiological response and G level established. This would be the most integrative way of defining, for the first time ever, G-thresholds for each physiological system. b. Chronic space-based centrifugation of animals. Chronic centrifugation of rodents at various G levels in space would allow for determination of AG thresholds of protection for each physiological system. In this case, all physiological systems will be of interest. Intermittent centrifugation will be of secondary interest. c. Chronic space-based centrifugation of cell cultures (RWV). Bioreactor studies of cells and cell cultures of various tissues at various G levels would allow for intracellular investigations of the effects of partial-G. Priority 2. Acute, intermittent space based partial-G analogs: a. Acute, intermittent space-based short radius human centrifugation. Intermittent centrifugation of humans would allow determination of thresholds of AG for protection of astronaut health in space. Priority 3. Chronic ground-based partial-G analogs: a. Chronic centrifugation of supine or head-down tilted humans. b. Chronic head-up tilt in humans. c. Chronic head-out graded dry immersion in humans. d. Chronic partial suspension of rodents e. Chronic rotating bioreactor cell culture studies (RWV) Priority 4. Acute ground based partial-G analogs. a. Parabolic flights. Very acute and short term effects of G levels between 0 and 1 in humans for fast responding systems like cardiovascular and sensorimotor as well as for acute responses in cell cultures and animals. b. Other acute models as indicated in table 3.

Barr, Yael↗

NASA NTRS2016

Tholins as Coloring Agents on Pluto and Other Icy Solar System Bodies

Tholins are refractory organic solids of complex structure and high molecular weight, with a wide range of color ranging from yellow and orange to dark red, and through tan to black. They are made in the laboratory by energy deposition (photons or charged particles) in gases and ices containing the simple molecules (e.g., N2, CH4, CO) found in planetary atmospheres or condensed on planetary surfaces. They are widely implicated in providing the colors and albedos, particularly in the region 0.3-1.0 microns, of several outer Solar System bodies, including Pluto, as well as aerosols in planetary atmospheres such as Titan. Recent color images of Pluto with the New Horizons spacecraft show concentrations of coloring agent(s) in some regions of the surface, and apparent near-absence in other regions. Tholins that may to some degree represent surface chemistry on Pluto have been synthesized in the laboratory by energetic processing of mixtures of the ices (N2, CH4, CO) known on Pluto's surface, or the same molecules in the gas phase. Details of the composition and yield vary with experimental conditions. Chemical analysis of Pluto ice tholins shows evidence of amides, carboxylic acids, urea, carbodiimides, and nitriles. Aromatic/olefinic, amide, and other functional groups are identified in XANES analysis. The ice tholins produced by e- irradiation have a higher concentration of N than UV ice tholins, with N/C approx. 0.9 (versus approx. 0.5 for UV tholins) and O/C approx.0.2. Raman spectra of the electron tholin show a high degree of structural disorder, while strong UV fluorescence indicates a large aromatic content. EUV photolysis of a Pluto gaseous atmosphere analog yields pale yellow solids relatively transparent in the visual, and with aliphatic CH bonds prominent in IR spectra. This or similar material may be responsible for Pluto's hazes.

Tholins↗

NASA NTRS2016

Charlotte - EDC Evaluation and Demonstration (CEED) Human-in-the-Loop Results Briefing to ATD-2 FAA Partners

The Charlotte EDC Evaluation and Demonstration (CEED) was the first Human-In-The-Loop experiment under the Air Traffic Management Technology Demonstration-2 (ATD-2) project. The purpose of the study was fourfold: 1) to establish a simulation environment (Charlotte) for airspace operations for ATD-2 technology, 2) to simulate current-day departures and arrival operations, 3) to assess the impact of current Traffic Management Initiatives (TMI) on Charlotte (CLT) departure flows and en route operations in Washington (ZDC) and Atlanta Centers (ZTL), and 4) to assess the impact of departure takeoff time compliance on airspace operations. The experimental design compared 3 TMIs and 2 compliance levels. Fourteen FAA retired controllers participated in the simulation. In addition, two Traffic Management Coordinators from ZTL and ZDC managed traffic flows. Surface and airborne delays, control efficiency, throughput, realism, workload, and acceptability were assessed and will be compared across the experimental conditions. Participants rated the simulation as very realistic. Results indicate that different TMIs have different impacts on surface and airspace delay. Departure compliance indicates partial benefits to sector complexity and controller workload. This simulation will provide an initial assessment of the tactical scheduling problems that the ATD-2 technology will address in the near term.

airspace technology demonstration 2↗

NASA NTRS2015

Laser Induced Fluorescence Spectroscopy of Neutral and Ionized Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons in the Cosmic Simulation Chamber

Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) molecules are considered the best carriers to account for the ubiquitous infrared emission bands. PAHs have also been proposed as candidates to explain the diffuse interstellar bands (DIBs), a series of absorption features seen on the interstellar extinction curve and are plausible carriers for the extended red emission (ERE), a photoluminescent process associated with a wide variety of interstellar environments. Extensive efforts have been devoted over the past two decades to characterize the physical and chemical properties of PAH molecules and ions in space. Absorption spectra of PAH molecules and ions trapped in solid matrices have been compared to the DIBs. Absorption spectra of several cold, isolated gas-phase PAHs have also been measured under experimental conditions that mimic the interstellar conditions. The purpose of this study is to provide a new dimension to the existing spectroscopic database of neutral and single ionized PAHs that is largely based on absorption spectra by adding emission spectroscopy data. The measurements are based on the laser induced fluorescence (LIF) technique and are performed with the Pulsed Discharge Nozzle (PDN) of the COSmIC laboratory facility at NASA Ames laboratory. The PDN generates a plasma in a free supersonic jet expansion to simulate the physical and the chemical conditions in interstellar environments. We focus, here, on the fluorescence spectra of large neutral PAHs and their cations where there is a lack of fluorescence spectroscopy data. The astronomical implications of the data (e.g., ERE) are examined.

Laboratory↗

NASA NTRS2017

The Formation of Nucleobases from the UV Irradiation of Astrophysical Ice Analogs

Nucleobases are the fundamental information bearing components of both RNA and DNA. They are central to all known terrestrial life and they are generally conserved between species. Biological nucleobases can be divided into two groups based on the N-heterocyclic molecules pyrimidine (uracil, cytosine, and thymine) and purine (adenine and guanine) respectively. Do date, no experimental conditions have been determined that could produce both pyrimidines and purines together, abiotically, in a ter-restrial environment or an early terrestrial analog. Organic materials produced in extraterrestrial envi-ronments may have been delivered to the primitive earth by comets and meteorites and may have contrib-uted to the emergence of life. To date, some, but not all nucleobases have been detected in meteorites and their isotopic signatures may be consistent with an extraterrestrial origin. Earlier work in our lab demonstrated that it is possible to produce all of the pyrimidine group nucleobases from the UV-irradiation of pyrimidine in astrophysically relevant ice analogs. Here we report our most recent work, which studied the formation of the purine group nucleobases under similar conditions.

Astrophysical Ice↗

NASA NTRS2017

Metastable Phase Relations in the System Ca(sub O)-Al2(sub O)3-MgO-TiO(sub 2): Applications to Ca- And Al-Rich Inclusions

Introduction: High temperature phases such as corundum, hibonite, grossite, and perovskite are among the earliest phases that condensed in the early solar nebula. Recent work has shown that defect-structured phases occur in some ultrarefractory inclusions as metastable, possibly more kinetically-favored alternatives to the thermodynamically predicted stable phase assemblages [1-4]. For example, Han et al. have shown that non-stoichiometry in hibonite is accommodated by extra "spinel" blocks in the structure instead of the equilibrium assemblages hibonite+corundum or hibonite+spinel. To explore these relations, we have conducted a series of experiments in the system CaO-Al2O3- MgO-TiO2. Here we discuss the compositions and mineralogy of the experimental samples and how they relate to phases in refractory inclusions with a focus on perovskite and spinel. Methods: For the series of annealing studies, a CaO-Al2O3 eutectic melt is allowed to react with a pure alumina crucible at 1,530degC for either 4 hours or 5 days, followed by quenching in air. Later experiments were similar except that additions of 5 wt% MgO, and CaTiO(sub 3) were used to explore the effect of minor elements on the phase assemblages. The experimental conditions resulted in reaction zones approximately 100-300 m wide consisting of a hibonite layer immediately adjacent to the corundum, followed by a grossite layer, and finally krotite with residual quenched melt. For the experiments with Mg, spinel is distributed in all layers but is mainly concentrated in the krotite layer. In the Ti-bearing experiments, perovskite precipitated in association with the krotite and residual melt. In addition to the experiments, we also analyzed perovskite grains in the FUN inclusion SHAL [5] and a large compact type A CAI from Allende. The experiments and refractory inclusions were analyzed using a JEOL 7600F SEM and quantitative analyses were obtained using the JEOL 8530F field-emission electron microprobe.

Keller, L. P.↗

NASA NTRS2018

Observing Ice Sublimation From Water-Doped Lunar Simulant at Cryogenic Temperatures

NASA's Resource Prospector (RP) mission is intended to characterize the three-dimensional nature of volatiles in lunar polar and permanently shadowed regions. The Near-Infrared Volatile Spectrometer System (NIRVSS) observes while a drill penetrates to a maximum depth of 1 m. Any 10 cm increment of soil identified as containing water ice can be delivered to a heating crucible with the evolved gas delivered to a gas chromatograph / mass spectrometer. NIRVSS consists of two components; a spectrometer box (SB) and bracket assembly (BA), connected by two fiber optic cables. The SB contains separate short- and long-wavelength spectrometers, SW and LW respectively, that collectively span the 1600-3400 nm range. The BA contains an IR emitter (lamp), drill observation camera (DOC, 2048 x 2048 CMOS detector), 8 different wavelength LEDs, and a longwave calibration sensor (LCS) measuring the surface emissivity at four IR wavelengths. Tests of various RP sub-systems have been under-taken in a large cryo-vacuum chamber at Glenn Re-search Center. The chamber accommodates a tube (1.2 m high x 25.4 cm diameter) filled with lunar simulant, NU-LHT-3M, prepared with known abundances of water. Thermocouples are embedded at different depths, and also across the surface of the soil tube. In the chamber the tube is cooled with LN2 as the pressure is reduced to approx. 5-6x10(exp -6) Torr. For the May 2016 tests two soil tubes were prepared with initially 2.5 Wt.% water. The shroud surrounding the soil tube was held at different temperatures for each tube to simulate a warm and cold lunar environment. Table 1 provides a summary of experimental conditions and Figure 1 shows the nominal view of the NIRVSS components, the drill foot, and the top of the soil tube. Once the average soil temperature reached approx. 178 K, drilling commenced. During drilling activities NIRVSS was alternating between obtaining spectra and obtaining images. Here we discuss NIRVSS spectral data obtained during controlled drill percussions.

Roush, T. L.↗

NASA NTRS2013

Photo-Induced Deuterium Enrichment in Residues Produced from the UV Irradiation of Pyrimidine in H2O and H2O+NH3 Ices

Organic compounds found in meteorites often show isotopic signatures of their interstellar/protosolar heritage as enrichments in D and 15N. Meteoritic organics found to be enriched in D include amino acids, hydroxy and dicarboxylic acids, as well as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). Processes that can produce isotopic enrichments in presolar/protosolar materials include gas-phase ion-molecule reactions, gas-grain surface reactions, and unimolecular photo-dissociation reactions involving PAHs. Because many molecules in interstellar clouds are enriched in D, the presence of D anomalies in meteorites is thought to originate from preserved or slightly altered interstellar/protostellar materials. However, the link between isotopic enrichments seen in space and those in meteoritic compounds and their relationship remain unclear. In this work, we present results of hydrogen isotopic fractionation for compounds in organic residues produced from the UV irradiation using an H2- discharge UV lamp of H2O:pyrimidine = 20:1 and H2O:NH3:pyrimidine = 20:2:1 ice mixtures at low temperature (is less than 20 K). After irradiation, the resulting residues are dissolved in H2O and analyzed with gas chromatography-mass spectrometry coupled with isotope ratio mass spectrometry (GC-MS/IRMS) [1], following a protocol similar to that used for previous analyses of comparable samples [2,3]. We used this technique to measure compound-specific D/H isotopic ratios for the initial pyrimidine and for two photo-products present in the residues, namely, 2,2'-bipyrimidine and an unidentified bipyrimidine isomer [2-4]. Measuring D enrichments in bipyrimidines has the advantage that the H atoms on these molecules are not easily exchangeable with other compounds, in particular the H2O and NH3 present in the ices or the solvents used to extract the samples for GC-MS/IRMS measurements. The δD value for the initial pyrimidine, measured with a high-temperature conversion elemental analyzer connected to the IRMS, was found to be -30% per mille. Preliminary measurements made on a residue produced from the UV irradiation of an H2O:NH3:pyrimidine = 20:2:1 ice mixture indicate δD values of +118% per mille for 2,2'- bipyrimidine and +92% per mille for the other bipyrimidine isomer, and therefore show a significant D enrichment during the photo-processing and warm-up that lead to their formation [5]. New measurements are currently being performed on a number of residues produced from simpler H2O:pyrimidine = 20:1 ice mixtures under different experimental conditions and will be presented here.

Laboratory Astrochemistry↗

NASA NTRS2016

The Past and Future of AstroPAH Research and the Diffuse Interstellar Bands

Here, we present a critical assessment of the PAHs as DIB Carriers and discuss the progress and the advances that have been achieved so far through a series of complementary studies involving astronomical observations of DIBs, laboratory simulation of interstellar analogs for PAHs (neutrals and ions), space exposure experiments of PAHs, theoretical calculations of PAH spectra and the modeling of diffuse and translucent interstellar clouds. We will discuss what we have learned from these complementary studies, the constraints that can be derived from these studies for the PAHs as DIB carriers and the future studies that are required to address the open questions. These involve extending the laboratory and astronomical PAH-DIB studies from the NUV-Visible range into the NIR and MIR domains where DIBs have also been observed and developing tools in the laboratory to help generate more complex, PAH-related species for comparison with astronomical data. For the laboratory part, we will present the COSmIC facility at NASA-Ames that provides experimental conditions that closely mimic the interstellar conditions and helps address these issues. The comparison of astronomical data with laboratory data measured under realistic conditions is the only way to derive clear and unambiguous conclusions regarding the expected abundances for PAHs of various sizes and charge states in interstellar environments. From the observational aspect we will explore the new opportunities offered by JWST to connect the DIBs to MIR PAH emission and to search for NIR DIBs that may trace the presence of PAHs.

Salama, Farid↗

NASA NTRS2018

Interstellar PAHs: From Ground to Space, Expanding Spectroscopic Frontiers

Recent progress in astrochemistry and in our understanding of the Molecular Universe has been driven by new detector technologies and advances in ground-, airborne- and space astronomy coupled to new, innovative approaches in molecular spectroscopy. The search for the complex carbon-based molecules (PAHs, Fullerenes, nanoparticles) thought to be responsible for the ubiquitous infrared emission bands (UIBs) and optical absorption bands (DIBs) that are observed in various regions of the interstellar medium of local- and extragalactic environments illustrates the progress in spectroscopy techniques that has been driven by astronomy. Recent progresses reached in this domain will be discussed together with the laboratory techniques that have been developed to measure the spectra of laboratory analogs of cosmic molecules in the UV Visible-NIR range under experimental conditions that attempt to reproduce the interstellar conditions.

Laboratory astrophysics and astrochemistry↗

NASA NTRS2019

Permeation Rate Equations for Hydrogen and Deuterium in a Palladium-Silver Alloy

Mass transfer of a gas through a selective, solid membrane is an effective method for separation of desired species. This selective permeability is evident in the flow of hydrogen and the isotope deuterium through palladium-silver metal alloy media. In this study, based upon Sieverts’s law and the Arrhenius diffusion equation, an empirical correlation was developed to determine the steady-state permeation rate R, dependence on media temperature T, gas supply pressure p(sub S), and gas backpressure p(sub B) on the lower pressure side. Because of an extensive range of experimental conditions and complete reporting of raw data, the research by Ackerman and Koskinas was used as a source for data allowing empirical equation fitting. Unfortunately, those authors reported best-fit equations that poorly represented their own results. To improve the modeling of the original data and demonstrate the quality of the measurements, the current study develops improved hydrogen and deuterium permeation rate equations: P = 4.22×10(exp −6) A[exp(−704/T)](sq. root p(sub S) − sq. root p(sub B))/t for hydrogen P = 2.12×10(exp −6) A[exp(−468/T )](sq. root p(sub S) − sq. root p(sub B))/t for deuterium for values of cross-sectional area A (sq.cm), medium thickness t (cm), pressure p (psia), and temperature T (Kelvin), giving a permeation rate in mole/minute. These equations model permeation rate data more closely than do several other existing literature sources.

Smith, Phillip J.↗

NASA NTRS2018

Analysis of the Two-Level NO PLIF Model for Low-Temperature High-Speed Flow Applications

The current work compares experimentally obtained nitric oxide (NO) laser-induced fluorescence (LIF) spectra with the equivalent spectra obtained analytically. The experimental spectra are computed from captured images of fluorescence in a gas cell and from a laser sheet passing through the fuel-air mixing flowfield produced by a high-speed fuel injector. The fuel injector is a slender strut that is currently being studied as a part of the Enhanced Injection and Mixing Project (EIMP) at the NASA Langley Research Center. This injector is placed downstream of a Mach 6 facility nozzle, which simulates the high Mach number airflow at the entrance of a scramjet combustor, and injects helium, which is used as an inert substitute for hydrogen fuel. Experimental planar (P) LIF is obtained by using a UV laser to excite fluorescence from the NO molecules that are present in either a gas cell or the facility air used for the EIMP experiments. The experimental data are obtained for several segments of the NO fluorescence spectrum. The selected segments encompass LIF lines with rotational quantum numbers appropriate for low-to-moderate temperature flows similar to those corresponding to the nominal experimental flow conditions. The experimental LIF spectra are then evaluated from the data and compared with those obtained from the theoretical models. The theoretical spectra are obtained from LIFBASE and LINUS software, and from a simplified version of the two-level fluorescence model. The equivalent analytic PLIF images are also obtained by applying only the simplified model to the results of the Reynolds-averaged simulations (RAS) of the mixing flowfield. Good agreement between the experimental and theoretical results provides increased confidence in both the simplified LIF modeling and CFD simulations for further investigations of high-speed injector performance using this approach.

Drozda, Tomasz G.↗

NASA NTRS2018

Analysis of the Two-Level NO PLIF Model for Low-Temperature High-Speed Flow Applications

Tomasz G Drozda↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Linear Mixed-Effects Models for Human-in-the-Loop Tracking Experiment Data

Linear mixed-effects models provide several benefits over more traditional statistical inference tests that are particularly useful for most human-in-the-loop tracking experiment data. However, surprisingly, mixed models are virtually not used for the analysis of tracking experiment data. This paper uses of linear mixed-effects models to analyze combined tracking data from two previous human-in-the-loop roll tracking experiments that compared control behavior metrics collected in both a research aircraft and a motion-base simulator. In the experiments, pilots' behavior under 10 different motion configurations with varying motion filter gains and break frequencies was evaluated and compared to that in the real aircraft. The linear mixed-effects model analysis on the combined dataset confirmed the main statistical outcomes of the individual experiments. The main benefits of mixed models for this type of data were demonstrated by successfully combining data from two experiments that used different experimental conditions and of which one had an additional apparatus and the other a missing participant. Finally, the mixed-model analysis was able to explicitly test for scientifically relevant statistical differences in the dependent measures between the aircraft and simulator, as well as both experiments.

manual control↗