DOE OSTI2017
Costs for environmental analysis and monitoring are increasing at a rapid rate and represent a significant percentage of the total and future remedial expenses at many U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) contaminated sites. It has been reported that about 30 to 40% of the remediation budget is usually spent on long-term monitoring (LTM), of which a large percentage represents laboratory analytical costs. Energetics such as perchlorate (ClO 4 - ) are among the most frequently detected contaminants in groundwater and surface water at or near military installations due to their persistence and mobility. Currently, the standard protocol entails collecting samples in the field, packaging them, and shipping them overnight to a designated laboratory for analysis. This process requires significant sample preparation and handling, and analytical results may not be available for several days to weeks. In this project, we developed and demonstrated a portable Raman sensor based on surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) technology to detect ClO 4 - in contaminated water. We summarize major accomplishments as follows: • A SERS sensor based on elevated gold (Au) nano-ellipse dimer architectures was designed and developed for ClO 4 - with a detection limit of ~10 -6 M (or 100 μg/L); The performance of these sensors was evaluated and optimized through variation of their geometric characteristics (i.e., dimer aspect ratio, dimer separation, etc.). • Large-scale commercial production of SERS substrate sensors via nanoimprinting by Nanova Inc. and Nanoimprint lithography (NIL) technology was successfully demonstrated. This is a substantial step forward toward the commercialization of the SERS sensors and may potentially lead to significantly reduced fabrication costs of SERS substrates. • Commercially produced SERS sensors were demonstrated to detect ClO 4 - at levels above 10 -6 M using a portable Raman analyzer. The performance of the commercial SERS sensors for ClO 4 - detection in the presence and absence of interferences was determined for a series of standard solutions. Sulfate (SO 4 2- ) was found to exhibit the greatest interference for the anions tested, which included Cl-, NO 3 - , and SO 4 2- . • Field demonstration of the portable Raman sensor with commercially produced SERS substrates was completed at two Department of Defense (DoD) sites; twice at the Indian Head Naval Surface Warfare Center, Indian Head, MD, and once at Redstone Arsenal, Huntsville, AL. Multiple wells were sampled at both DoD sites, where a standard addition method was employed using the sensor to determine the ClO 4 - 4 - and possibly other energetics that are both important for environmental monitoring and of interest for national security. However, we point out that SERS technology is also prone to interferences due to its sensitivity and responses to other ionic species, such as NO 3 - , SO 4 2- , and dissolved organics or co-contaminants present in the groundwater, which could potentially mask the SERS signal of the target analyte (i.e., ClO 4 - ). As such, SERS analysis was subject to significant variations (e.g., ±20% or more), and its detection limit for ClO 4 - -8 M) and was substantially higher than what we anticipated from laboratory studies. However, despite these complications, the portable Raman sensor developed in this project could be used as a rapid screening tool for ClO 4 - at concentrations above 10 -6 M. Future studies are warranted to further develop the technology and to optimize its performance, and eventually to bring the technology to the market. With additional development and demonstration, the sensor has the potential to reduce analytical costs by eliminating shipping and typical costs associated with laboratory analysis. A cost savings of 30–45% may be realized during a typical sampling event and, more importantly, the technology could allow rapid turn-around of information to decision makers for site characterization and remediation.
47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗