Experimental Measurements and CFD Predictions of NOx Emissions from a Water-Cooled Rotating Detonation Engine
Paper presented at Turbo Expo 2023, Boston, Massachusetts, June 26-30, 2023.
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Paper presented at Turbo Expo 2023, Boston, Massachusetts, June 26-30, 2023.
This work evaluates and compares various convolutional neural networks (CNNs) trained in previous NETL studies according to metrics effecting diagnostic feasibility, external applicability, and performance. Each CNN surveyed, including image classification, object detection, and time series classification, is used to develop total RDE diagnostics and evaluated alongside conventional techniques with respect to real-time capabilities. Real-time capable diagnostics are deployed and evaluated in the laboratory environment using an altered experimental setup, which is outlined herein for possible adaptations in external experimental facilities.
This work evaluates and compares various convolutional neural networks (CNNs) trained in previous NETL studies according to metrics effecting diagnostic feasibility, external applicability, and performance. Each CNN surveyed, including image classification, object detection, and time series classification, is used to develop total RDE diagnostics and evaluated alongside conventional techniques with respect to real-time capabilities. Real-time capable diagnostics are deployed and evaluated in the laboratory environment using an altered experimental setup, which is outlined herein for possible adaptations in external experimental facilities.
Within this study, the presence and proportion of ideal and non-ideal combustion regimes is compared across a variety of process conditions and wave modes. Large-scale data analysis seeks to summarize proportional heat release associated with commensal, parasitic, and detonative combustion averaged across individual traces of OH* chemiluminescent data acquired at the detonation plane. Means of regime partitioning based on the anatomy of the time-resolved OH* signal are proposed to ensure consistent analysis throughout the current and future studies concerning combustion regimes.
Rotating detonation rocket engines (RDREs) offer benefits over traditional deflagrative engines, including increased engine performance, compact combustion and negligible detrimental thermoacoustic instabilities due to mode-locking. Realizing the benefits of a detonation-based propulsion system will be accompanied by increased thermal loads due to a combination of heat release at elevated pressure and temperature, as well as compact heat release due to detonation. Managing these heat loads necessitates the development of thermal management strategies. As a first step towards establishing the requirements for detonation-based engine thermal management strategies, this work develops an additively manufactured (AM) water-based, axially resolved calorimeter for integration in an existing 76.8 mm outer diameter (OD) RDRE to measure average chamber heat flux. In particular, the calorimetry outer body provides average heat flux data via circumferential channels at nine axial stations to axially resolve the heat flux distribution on the chamber outer wall. The average heat flux is found to be 5 − 12 MW/m 2 for a straight annulus and 6 − 18 MW/m 2 for a constricted annular configuration which exhibited maximum heat flux at the throat. A difference in heat flux scaling is observed near the detonation region compared to the downstream flow expansion section in the constricted geometry. By quantifying the axial distribution of heat flux, this work seeks to support the development of thermal management systems for long duration firing of detonation-based devices.
Rotating detonation rocket engines (RDREs) offer benefits over traditional deflagrative engines, including increased engine performance, compact combustion and negligible detrimental thermoacoustic instabilities due to mode-locking. Realizing the benefits of a detonation-based propulsion system will be accompanied by increased thermal loads due to a combination of heat release at elevated pressure and temperature, as well as compact heat release due to detonation. Managing these heat loads necessitates the development of thermal management strategies. As a first step towards establishing the requirements for detonation-based engine thermal management strategies, this work develops an additively manufactured (AM) water-based, axially resolved calorimeter for integration in an existing 76.8 mm outer diameter (OD) RDRE to measure average chamber heat flux. In particular, the calorimetry outer body provides average heat flux data via circumferential channels at nine axial stations to axially resolve the heat flux distribution on the chamber outer wall. The average heat flux is found to be 5 − 12 MW/m 2 for a straight annulus and 6 − 18 MW/m 2 for a constricted annular configuration which exhibited maximum heat flux at the throat. A difference in heat flux scaling is observed near the detonation region compared to the downstream flow expansion section in the constricted geometry. By quantifying the axial distribution of heat flux, this work seeks to support the development of thermal management systems for long duration firing of detonation-based devices.
The Rotating Detonation Rocket Engine has maintained steady development at NASA with many staggering performance advantages demonstrated to date over the state-of-the-art (SOA). The implementation of additive manufacturing and specialized NASA developed alloys have enabled rapid maturation of the technology. Several hot fire test projects have been successfully conducted at Marshall Space Flight Center under an early career initiative project funded by NASA Space Technology Mission Directorate. In addition, a new start Technology Demonstration Mission (TDM) project has been funded to investigate challenges relating to integration of turbomachinery with an RDRE thrust chamber assembly. This engine system demonstration will leverage a methane/oxygen single shaft turbopump with fuel rich gas generator and a 10,000 lbf thrust chamber assembly. The configuration was down selected based on feedback from both US industry collaborators and power balance trades in combination with technical feasibility. To date, industry has identified several use cases for RDRE ranging from thruster to primary launch vehicle propulsion. A wide range of fuel and oxidizers were also identified including but not limited to Methane, Kerosene and other liquid hydrocarbon (LH) fuels, and hydrogen. Recent work at NASA and in partnership with NASA has investigated these major fuels of interest with oxygen, air, and hydrogen peroxide (HTP) for various applications. NASA Marshall has already investigated the use of hydrogen/oxygen, methane/oxygen, kerosene/oxygen, and has plans in partnership with industry and academia to investigate LH/air and LH/HTP. In addition to propellants, hardware geometry has been investigated with some critical lessons learned toward greater theoretical performance over the SOA. To this end, several experimental and computational activities are ongoing to further advance the RDRE towards flight missions. Given the rate of advancement, it is highly likely the technology will be flown in space mission in the coming decade. This work documents and overviews many of these investigations and overviews NASA’s future plans for the technology maturation.
This presentation contains notes for a 30 minute lecture that is part of an AIAA Special Session titled, Pressure Gain Combustion Overview: Principles, Operation, and Applications. The presentation covers an introduction to Pressure Gain Combustion (PGC) and the devices used to implement it. The concept of PGC is discussed on a thermodynamic basis, the performance benefits are demonstrated, and methods of implementation are described. These include devices such as Resonant Pulse Combustors, Internal Combustion Wave Rotors, Pulse Detonation Engines, and Rotating Detonation Engines.
This presentation describes experimental and computational approaches to measuring pressure gain in the various devices currently under investigation wherein the working fluid undergoes a pressure gain combustion (PGC) process. Pressure gain is essentially a measure of the fluid availability for work or thrust production. The devices covered are Resonant Pulse Combustors, Internal Combustion Wave Rotors, Pulse Detonation Engines, and Rotating Detonation Engines. The approaches to pressure gain measurement differ in each device. However, all of the approaches attempt to address the fundamental challenges of PGC system measurement: the extremely harsh environment which makes instrumentation difficult, and the temporal and spatial non-uniformity associated with the exhausting flow which makes assigning a single value to the total pressure difficult. As part of the two-day 2019 International Constant Volume and Detonative Combustion Workshop, held in conjunction with the 2019 AIAA Propulsion and Energy Forum, this presentation is intended to foster discussion and eventual consensus on acceptable measurement methods.
This presentation contains notes for a one-hour lecture that is part of a two-day AIAA Short Course titled, Hypersonic Air-Breathing Propulsion: Emerging Technologies and Cycles. The presentation covers an introduction to Pressure Gain Combustion (PGC) and its applicability to high speed airbreathing propulsion (HSABP). The concept of PGC is discussed on a thermodynamic basis, the performance benefits are demonstrated, and methods of implementation are described. These include devices such as Resonant Pulse Combustors, Internal Combustion Wave Rotors, Pulse Detonation Engines, and Rotating Detonation Engines.
A calorimeter-style rotating detonation rocket engine (RDRE) outer chamber body was designed, additively manufactured in GRCop-42, and hot-fire tested in test cell 105 at NASA Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC) in Huntsville, AL in August 2024. Steady-state, spatially resolved heat flux and chamber pressure were measured at 13 and 9 locations from the injector face, respectively, for a variety of test conditions and hardware configurations with gaseous methane and oxygen propellants. The 2-in. diameter highly instrumented design, enabled by metal additive manufacturing (AM), allowed for simultaneous measurement of heat flux and chamber pressure through 44 long duration hot-fire tests without failure. Of the 44 tests, only 3 of the tests featured chamber pressures below 100 psia and are discussed in this work. Heat flux trends for this subscale hardware are explored with respect to local propellant mass flux for several different injectors, chamber lengths, and chamber “subsonic” area ratios (contraction ratios). Results show that for increasing chamber pressure, a reduced amount of energy per kilogram of propellant is transferred to the wall. Switching injectors affects the near-face heat flux and chamber pressure profiles. Chamber length does not noticeably affect the heat flux profile but increases bulk heat load. A subsonic area ratio greater than 1 reduces heat losses to the wall compared to a straight annulus case. Equivalence ratio shift did not significantly affect heat flux. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and conjugate heat transfer (CHT) analyses were performed to delineate 3-D heat transfer and coolant mass flow maldistribution effects and create a calorimeter transfer function to transform heat flux data and mitigate the profile distortions. Additional CFD/CHT simulations were performed using experimental data as boundary conditions to assess local nucleate boiling propensity during testing and to assess projected hot wall temperatures for future fatigue assessment. Vapor fractions were observed locally for several cases. It is anticipated that this effort will provide a common framework for coolant system design/analysis in calorimeter systems for rocket-based and air-breathing combustors, ensuring greater repeatability in calorimetry measurements across the research community.
NASA has developed a subscale rotating detonation rocket engine platform, enabling rapid parameterization of components and their associated performances. A major performance metric of interest for RDREs is the total heat absorbed at a given operating condition and wave mode operation. To investigate this, several sets of hardware were produced to have variation of the contraction ratio, injector geometry, and length. A wide range of total mass flow rates and mixture ratios were also explored using gaseous methane/oxygen. All hardware was produced using laser powder bed fusion GRCop-42, GRX-810, or C-103 alloys depending on the component cooling requirements. Outer and inner body hardware were made from GRCop-42 where heat fluxes were expected to be high and were water cooled through integrated coolant channels. Nozzles were made from C-103 which are radiatively cooled. Finally, the injectors were produced using GRCop-42 or GRX-810 as passive cooling via propellant injection has previously found to be sufficient given the small gap width of exposed injection surface. Total heat load and bulk heat flux measurements to the hot walls are reported. Trends in heat load and heat flux are shown with relation to parameters such as chamber pressure, area ratio, and wave mode. Heat loads between the inner and outer bodies and the chamber and shroud section are compared.
NASA has developed a subscale rotating detonation rocket engine platform, enabling rapid parameterization of components and their associated performances. A major performance metric of interest for RDREs is the total heat absorbed at a given operating condition and wave mode operation. To investigate this, several sets of hardware were produced to have variation of the contraction ratio, injector geometry, and length. A wide range of total mass flow rates and mixture ratios were also explored using gaseous methane/oxygen. All hardware was produced using laser powder bed fusion GRCop-42, GRX-810, or C-103 alloys depending on the component cooling requirements. Outer and inner body hardware were made from GRCop-42 where heat fluxes were expected to be high and were water cooled through integrated coolant channels. Nozzles were made from C-103 which are radiatively cooled. Finally, the injectors were produced using GRCop-42 or GRX-810 as passive cooling via propellant injection has previously found to be sufficient given the small gap width of exposed injection surface. Total heat load and bulk heat flux measurements to the hot walls are reported. Trends in heat load and heat flux are shown with relation to parameters such as chamber pressure, area ratio, and wave mode. Heat loads between the inner and outer bodies and the chamber and shroud section are compared.
A Rotating Detonation Rocket Engine (RDRE) model is described which characterizes the device as an essentially infinite number of circumferentially arranged, sequentially firing pulse detonation engine (PDE) tubes. The PDE tubes are in turn treated as lumped-parameter chambers, each of which executes a dynamic (i.e. time dependent) Atkinson cycle with an allowance for a finite Mach number during the refill portion of the cycle. The formulation results in several free parameters which are used to essentially tune the model such that it closely matches higher fidelity computational fluid dynamic RDRE simulations in terms of performance, flow rates, etc. The simplicity of the model allows for straightforward combination with component models (e.g. turbopumps, cooling jackets, etc.) as well as implementation within larger vehicle simulations. Such capability allows for realistic mission analyses and benefits studies which will help to determine the best application for the RDRE concept.
A Rotating Detonation Rocket Engine (RDRE) model is described which characterizes the device as an essentially infinite number of circumferentially arranged, sequentially firing pulse detonation engine (PDE) tubes. The PDE tubes are in turn treated as lumped-parameter chambers, each of which executes a dynamic (i.e. time dependent) Atkinson cycle with an allowance for a finite Mach number during the refill portion of the cycle. The formulation results in several free parameters which are used to essentially tune the model such that it closely matches higher fidelity computational fluid dynamic RDRE simulations in terms of performance, flow rates, etc. The simplicity of the model allows for straightforward combination with component models (e.g. turbopumps, cooling jackets, etc.) as well as implementation within larger vehicle simulations. Such capability allows for realistic mission analyses and benefits studies which will help to determine the best application for the RDRE concept.
Programmatic overview of rotating detonation rocket engine (RDRE) research at NASA GRC for Scientific American for reference for Scientific American article. This is a compilation of previously released slides. This material will NOT be published as part of the article, but are being provided for background information.
This poster is a general description of Rotating Detonation Rocket Engine task under the GCD project. It includes a brief summary of accomplishments for FY20. The scope of this work is to develop computational tools and design rules for RDRE’s.
Annual review presentation for the Rotating Detonation Rocket Engine project under the Game Changing Development program.