SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Presentation at GSA 2023: National Energy Water Treatment & Speciation (NEWTS) : A Water & Critical Mineral Database and Dashboard
The general objectives of this project are to develop concepts for rare earth metal and critical mineral production from coal-based and related (minerals associated with coal) resources and incorporate them into a Technical Research Plan with an associated overall flow sheet. The project team has extensive expertise in market evaluation, mineral separation, leaching, chemical separations, alternative metallothermic reaction technology, electrowinning, and electrorefining that was critical to the success of the proposed project. The project included critical industrial partners needed for project success. The project team has extensive expertise in market evaluation, mineral separation, leaching, chemical separations, alternative reduction technology, electrowinning, and electrorefining as well as appropriate pilot-scale facilities to enable this project. The project encompassed broader opportunities for developing domestic resources of REE/CM materials for a more resilient, diverse, and secure supply chain for REE/CM materials with built-in redundancies and appropriate resource stockpiles. The production of REE/CM materials will help to revitalize and rebuild world-class American manufacturing capacity and the related workforce through new jobs and infrastructure. Furthermore, due to the nature and location of the production sites, economic growth in diverse communities of color and economically distressed areas will be cultivated. Finally, this technology can be applied to reuse and remediate coal waste tailings for REE/CM production.
Presentation at Produced Water Society Conference 2024. National Energy Water Treatment & Speciation (NEWTS): A Water & Critical Mineral Database and Dashboard.
Final Report; Illinois Basin - Carbon Ore, Rare Earth and Critical Mineral (IB-CORE-CM) project team has conducted a comprehensive basin-wide assessment of CORE-CM presence in coal, coal-based, and waste stream resources, as well as a thorough examination of mining practices, separation technologies, and the local infrastructure necessary for producing and providing the needed CORE-CM resources for U.S. industry. This final report details the research, methods, and results of the project.
Herein this study reports a novel approach of resource recovery from co-managing two geographically co-located and chemically complementary wastewaters using a pilot-scale treatment process. Designed to treat flue gas desulfurized (FGD) effluent from combustion powerplants and produced water (PW) from energy industries, the process consists of soda-ash softening, nanofiltration (NF), and reverse osmosis (RO). Recovered products are barite, calcite, and low-salinity water. Using field-collected waters, the results show that softening at pH 8.5 produces calcite (yield: 30 kg/m 3 treated water), a chemical used as SO ₂(g) scrubbers. NF treatment under an applied pressure of 3.5 MPa yields a permeate stream laden with monovalent ions (water recovery 60%) and a concentrate stream with a sulfate concentration 1.8 times of the feedwater concentration. Mixing the NF concentrate and PW at a volumetric ratio of 1.0 precipitates a high-density barite material (4.1 g/cm 3 , yield: ~7.5 kg/m 3 mixture) – a critical mineral commonly used as a weighting agent in drilling. The RO treatment recovers >64% water as the permeate, which can be readily used as cooling make-up water at the powerplants. The RO concentrate stream can be further processed in a thermal evaporative system for additional water recovery and brine production.
Demonstrate how to use project PARETO framework for screening different produced water networks and identify critical minerals recovery opportunities.
Abstract for the 2023 National Environmental Justice Conference and Training Program; Integrating Environmental Justice and Equity into the Development of Critical Mineral Industries
Oil and gas development activities require a significant amount of water. Given the environmental impacts associated with high consumption and subsequent disposal of this water, there is a need for strategies to support effective reuse of, treatment of, and/or resource recovery from this produced water. These streams can contain appreciable concentrations of rare earth elements (REE) and critical minerals (CM) (e.g., Lithium), which are critical for many important applications in electronics, technology, manufacturing, energy, and medicine [1]. Along with REE/CM present in produced water, other waste streams such as fly ash from coal-fired power plants and acid mine discharge present other potential sources for recovery of REE/CM [2-4]. And with increases in demand for REE/CM, the need for recovery from wastewater streams is becoming even more important. There is a need to develop effective decision-making tools to evaluate the economic and environmental potential for REE/CM recovery from produced water networks while supporting the needs of drilling and hydraulic fracturing activities. In this work, we present our progress in developing a decision-making framework to efficiently design and operate produced water networks for REE/CM recovery. Our approach considers REE/CM recovery from produced water streams alongside other potential wastewater sources. The models consider the location and capacity of storage and decentralized treatment processes as well as the design and operation of pipeline and transportation networks to connect different sources and effectively schedule inventories, reuse, and recovery opportunities. We focus on the evaluation of opportunities for REE/CM recovery with treatment constraints on composition and flow. We demonstrate this framework with an illustrative case study that features diverse production sites, storage facilities, transportation, and treatment sites. This proposed framework will be deployed in an open-source software package that is compatible with the PARETO framework to deliver analysis and decision-making tools that allow stakeholders to quantitatively evaluate potential opportunities for REE/CM recovery in produced water networks.
The demand for Rare Earth Elements (REE) and other critical minerals (CM) required for consumer products, defense-related applications, and low-carbon energy technology is increasing rapidly. Unconventional sources of REE/CM, such as coal and associated sediments, could prove very important in building resilient and ethical energy supply chains. Utilization of existing infrastructure and the highly trained energy workforce in traditionally coal-producing regions in emerging REE/CM industries could provide an economic boost to coal communities. The Powder River Basin (PRB) of Wyoming and Montana, USA, is a prime candidate to investigate the feasibility of extracting REE/CM from coal and associated sediments. The PRB hosts thick (>50 ft) coal seams that are mined at the surface and more than 40% of the coal produced in the US comes from the PRB. Geochemical data from multiple locations in PRB coal systems show REE enrichments at the top and bottom margins and at internal partings in coal seams. This trend is exhibited in two cores drilled at Peabody’s North Antelope Rochelle mine in the east central PRB, the largest coal mine in the world. The two cores include the Wyodak Anderson coal zone as well as the over- and underlying shale units. The Wyodak Anderson coal zone is part of the Paleocene Tongue River Member of the Fort Union Formation in which most of the coal resources in the PRB reside. To understand REE/CM enrichment, a total of 188 samples were analyzed for their major and trace element chemistry from both cores, sampled at one foot or smaller intervals. The two cores show distinct REE enrichments in the uppermost and lowermost 3 to 12 feet of the Wyodak Anderson coal zone, as well as enrichments in bounding carbonaceous shale units. Total REE+Y (REY) concentrations as high as 2510 ppm (all concentrations reported on an ash basis), or 15 times average upper continental crust values (Taylor and McLennan, 1995), were identified in the coal. Partings within the coal zone also show relative REE enrichment, with concentrations up to 485 ppm REY. The remaining interior portions of the coal zone contain lower concentrations of REE, resulting in an average REY for all samples from both cores of 288 ppm. The proportion of high-value critical REE (Nd, Eu, Tb, Dy, Er, Y) compared to REY averages 36%, which is higher than the critical REE proportion in average upper continental crust of 33%. This finding highlights the relative enrichment of middle REE compared to light REE, in contrast to many conventional REE deposits. Other critical trace elements that show enrichments above average upper continental crust include Ga, Nb, and V. Within this sample suite, Ga concentrations range from 2.8 to 213 ppm, with an average of 29 ppm; Nb from 2.9 to 166 ppm with an average of 26 ppm; and V from 27 to 1695 ppm with an average of 188 ppm. None of these trace elements exhibit the same distinct pattern of enrichment as REE in the upper and lower bounding layers and internal partings of the coal zone. Major element chemistry indicates CaO concentrations averaging ~25% in the coal samples from both cores, which has important implications for the extractability of REE from coal. Calcium-rich PRB coal has been shown to be more amenable to REE extraction than lower calcium coals by some methods (Stuckman et al., 2019; Taggart et al., 2016), highlighting the importance of REE extractability in addition to REE concentration in assessing the value of potential feedstocks. The original coal resource in the PRB is estimated at 1.16 trillion short tons (Luppens et al., 2015). Thus, the PRB represents an important potential unconventional source for REE and other CM. Ongoing research to fully characterize the REE/CM resource, identify enrichment mechanisms, and further develop and scale extraction technologies is necessary to understand the full potential of this resource.
The U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE’s) Office of Fossil Energy awarded 13 Carbon Ore, Rare-Earth and Critical Minerals (CORE-CM) programs as part of the CORE-CM Initiative, designed to develop the technology and upstream and midstream supply chains to extract rare-earth elements (REEs) and CMs from the nation’s coal supplies. The intent is to catalyze regional economic growth and job creation while strengthening the use of domestic resources. The Williston Basin CORE-CM Program aims to drive the expansion and transformation of coal and coal-based resource usage within the Williston Basin to produce REEs, CMs, and nonfuel carbon-based products (CBPs). The work constitutes Phase 1 of a long-term program. The objectives of Phase 1 are to identify the existing knowledge base and gaps and to develop a series of assessments/plans, including an initial basinal assessment; a characterization and data acquisition plan; a waste stream reuse plan; a basinal strategies assessment for infrastructure, industries, and business; a technology assessment, development, and field-testing plan; a technology innovation center plan(s); and a stakeholder outreach and education plan. Originally, the CORE-CM programs were to do little if any sample collection as part of the Phase 1 program. As part of the ongoing interactions with DOE regarding the progress of the 13 CORE-CM programs, DOE has decided to extend Phase 1 with additional funding to allow all of the Phase 1 CORE-CM programs to collect and characterize more samples that have potential to be sources of REEs and CMs. The goal of this project is to initiate the development of a new industry in the resource-rich Williston Basin that will generate economic growth and job creation through a coalition team of private industry; university; and state, local, and federal government entities. A coalition team of nearly 30 private industry; university; and state, local, and federal government partners was formed for this program. Partners include the University of North Dakota Energy & Environmental Research Center, Institute for Energy Studies, and Nistler College; North Dakota State University; Montana Tech University; Pacific Northwest National Laboratory; Critical Materials Institute; North Dakota Geological Survey; South Dakota Geological Survey; U.S. Geological Survey; North American Coal Corporation; BNI Energy; Basin Electric Power Cooperative; Minnkota Power Cooperative; and many more.
Increasing demand for a more robust domestic supply of rare earth elements (REE) and critical minerals (CM) has led to significant investigation into unconventional sources. Coal and coal byproducts from the Powder River Basin (PRB) of Wyoming are potential sources of REE and CM. The association between strategic metals and their mineral hosts has important implications for extractability. Samples of overburden, underclays, and clay-rich partings were selected for analysis from core and bucket samples from three PRB coal mines. Quartz, illite, and kaolinite-group minerals are abundant in clay-rich portions of the PRB coal strata. We performed a five-step sequential extraction to constrain critical metal partitioning in samples of overburden and underclays (n=10). Unlike the occurrences of REE in other clay deposits, insignificant amounts of total REE + Y (TREY) were recovered in the ion-exchangeable fraction (< 0.5 ppm). A significant amount of TREY was leached from the acid-soluble fraction by 0.1M HCl, suggesting REE may be tied up within crystal lattices rather than sorbed to clay surfaces. The acid-soluble fraction contained between 3 and 250 ppm TREY, with an average TREY concentration of 60 ppm. Relative standard deviations for each extraction step were generally < ±10%. Whole-rock samples (n=72) contained greater TREY enrichment in overburden than in underclays and partings, however, the opposite is true for other CM, such as Ti and V. Other locations in the PRB show different enrichment trends. Our findings supplement a broader effort to couple REE and CM extraction with existing domestic coal production and contribute to the fundamental understanding of how these metals concentrate in low-temperature basin environments.
Increasing demand for a more robust domestic supply of rare earth elements (REE) and critical minerals (CM) has led to significant investigation into unconventional sources. Coal and coal byproducts from the Powder River Basin (PRB) of Wyoming are potential sources of REE but lack complete characterization of mineral hosts including ion-adsorption clays (IACs). IACs, which provide a substantial portion of the global REE supply, form when hydrated REE complexes are physiosorbed to negatively charged sites on clay surfaces. Typical IAC minerals include kaolinite, illite, and smectite. REE complexes are easily leached from IACs via ion exchange, making them economically attractive. However, research regarding the partitioning behaviors of strategic metals into PRB coal-hosted clays is limited. This project aims to quantify the modes of occurrence and distribution of REE and CM in clay minerals derived from PRB coals. Strategic metals investigated in this project have historic production or promising deposits within the PRB and/or high anticipated supply risk, and include: REE (lanthanides and Y), V, Ti, platinum group elements (PGE; Pt, Pd, Rh, Ru, Ir, Os), Al, Co, Ga, Zr, and W. Semi-quantitative compositional data from portable x-ray fluorescence spectroscopy (pXRF) on coal core from the PRB is consistent with the known correlation between REE and Al content, suggesting increased REE abundance will be found in clay-rich units. pXRF data also identifies elevated V, Ti, Co, and Zr correlated with Al. Preliminary x-ray diffraction (XRD) data indicates kaolinite, illite, and dickite are abundant minerals in overburden and clay-rich partings. Quantitative analysis via inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) provides insights into REE and CM fractionation in coals as we compare trace metal occurrence to variations in mineralogy. Additionally, we apply scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDS) data to correlate clay size and morphology to trace metal occurrence. Our findings supplement a broader effort to couple REE and CM extraction with existing domestic coal production and contribute to the fundamental understanding of adsorption processes that occur in low-temperature basin environments.
Coal and associated sediments are potential sources of Rare Earth Elements (REE) and other critical minerals necessary for many consumer and defense-related products and development of energy technologies. For this study, 15 samples were sourced from Dry Fork Mine within the Powder River Basin near Gillette, Wyoming, to determine REE content along with select transition metals (t-metals) of interest in non-combusted coals and associated sediments. An excavator collected samples along a mine highwall, within benched intervals representing a foot to a few feet of coal strata. Homogenized sample subsets were crushed in an aluminum-ceramic vial, then passed through a 106-micron sieve. Sieved samples were pyrolyzed by a LECO TGA-108, which concurrently measured sample moisture, volatile, and ash content. Residual ash was then fused into a glass bead with lithium metaborate at a 6:1 Li-metaborate to sample ratio and then dissolved in 20% nitric acid. The nitric acid solutions containing digested beads were then diluted and passed through a 0.45 micron syringe filter. Filtered samples were analyzed by ICP-MS for REE and select t-metals. Reagent blanks were analyzed to assess for any potential contamination. Total REE plus Y (REE+Y) concentrations across the 15 samples range from 52 ppm to 1015 ppm with an average of 477 ppm on a dry ash basis. When normalized to upper continental crust (UCC; Taylor and McLennan, 1985) values, 13 of the 15 samples show average enrichment factors (EF) for REE+Y greater than 1. EF values indicate M-type enrichment (Sm through Er), as opposed to distinct preferential enrichment of light or heavy REE. T-metals with the highest average concentrations are V, Cu, Ni, and Zr at 215, 243, 123, and 118 ppm, respectively. Multiple t-metals had EF>1; however, Cu, Ge, and Sb have the highest average EF relative to UCC for t-metals, at 9.7, 8.0, and 17.0, respectively.
Identification of sources for domestic critical minerals and rare earth elements (CM/REE) has been deemed essential for the energy transition by the United States Department of Energy (DOE). The U.S. DOE’s National Energy Technology Laboratory’s (NETL) Geomaterials Characterization Laboratory has performed non-destructive core characterizations on energy-relevant rock cores for the past decade. During this time, NETL has published over 36 technical reports and made the associated data publicly available. Much of this work focuses on unconventional shale gas, subsurface carbon storage systems, and carbon-ore. These efforts provide cm-scale petrophysical and elemental data, photographic documentation, detailed core descriptions, and computed tomography (CT) data for each well. This provides a first phase prospecting resource for CM/REE resources and can provide a map for pin-pointing intervals and lithologies for further development. Using historical core characterization data from 12 Marcellus wells from the western portion of the Appalachian Basin, this study builds an improved understanding of the chemostratigraphy of the basin. X-ray fluorescence (XRF) and CT images were used to determine lithologic intervals and potential ore bodies for further analysis, including benchtop digestion and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) to better understand the CM/REE enrichments.
In recent years, acid mine drainage (AMD) has emerged as a promising unconventional source of rare earth elements (REEs) and other critical minerals (CMs) such as cobalt and manganese. In this regard, AMD provides a natural heap leaching effect that extracts and concentrates REE/CM from the host strata creating a partially enriched feedstock suitable for downstream extraction, separation, and recovery. While several prior studies have described processes and approaches for the valorization of AMD, very few have described the supply chain and infrastructure requirements as well as the associated economic assessment. To that end, this paper provides a fundamental economic assessment of REE/CM recovery from AMD using a network sourcing strategy in addition to a robust, flexible feedstock separations and refining facility. The methodology of this paper follows that of a typical techno-economic analysis with capital and operating costs estimated using AACE Class IV (FEL-2) guidelines. To demonstrate the range of possible outcomes, four pricing scenarios were modeled including contemporary prices (September, 2021) as well as the minimum and maximum prices over the last decade. In addition, five production scenarios were considered reflecting variations in the product suite, ranging from full elemental separation to magnet REE and CM production only (i.e., Pr, Nd, Tb, Dy, Y, Sc, Co, and Mn). The results of this analysis show that, with the exception of the minimum price scenario, all operational configurations have positive economic indicators with rates of return varying from 25% to 32% for the contemporary price scenario. The optimal configuration was determined to be production of Co, Mn, and all REEs except for mischmetal, which is not recovered. Sensitivity analysis and Monte Carlo simulation show that capital cost and HCl consumption are the two major factors influencing rate of return, thus indicating opportunities for future technology development and cost optimization. Implications of the study and a cooperative profit-sharing model for sourcing are also described.
The global transition toward low-carbon energy not only means an increase in demand for clean electricity and renewable resources, but also an increase in demand for the critical minerals (CMs) and rare earth elements (REEs) that these technologies rely upon. Indeed, low-carbon energy technologies, such as those used for wind turbines and electric vehicle motors, require significantly more lithium, nickel, cobalt, manganese, graphite, and other CMs than fossil-based energy technologies. The growing demand for new forms of low- carbon energy will necessitate a proportional scale-up of CM and REE extraction and processing. Presently, the majority of extraction and processing activities for CMs and REEs are concentrated in very few countries, primarily in China and the Global South. CM and REE supply chain activities conducted in or controlled by these countries are commonly associated with widespread and well- documented human rights abuses and environmental degradation. As a result of concerns related to supply chain security, worker welfare, and the overall need for additional sources of CMs and REEs, governments worldwide have begun to explore policy pathways for the development of new supply chains. The development of new supply chains for CMs and REEs re s a multifold opportunity to accelerate the global deployment of low-carbon energy fleets, reduce global carbon emissions, build political resilience—and also to enhance policy objectives of environmental justice and equity in the clean energy transition. Fulfilling these policy objectives requires energy producers to navigate a maze of global supply chain policies designed to shape and accelerate the growth of new markets. In the United States, for instance, President Biden recently implemented fiscal and trade policies that incentivize both domestic and global reliance on U.S.-produced CMs and REEs, leveraging key relationships in Asia and Europe to ensure the accelerated buildout of the U.S. supply chain. The Biden Administration’s framework also emphasizes that new supply chains for CMs, REEs, and other low-carbon energy pathways must generate benefits for marginalized and disadvantaged communities, build energy equity, and contribute to the Biden Administration’s vision of environmental justice. present CM and REE supply chains include several stages, including mining, processing, transport, utilization, and disposal, each of which involves different environmental justice considerations and potential injustices. This study explores how technical innovation, paired with responsible community engagement and empowerment, can help inform the development of energy equity and environmental justice at all stages of new supply chains. The study highlights these opportunities on a broad scale. We also lend a specific focus to research at the University of Wyoming School of Energy Resources that aims to guide the development of CM and REE industries in communities with high economic dependence on coal and other fossil fuel industries, identifying pathways to grow a U.S. domestic supply chain by producing CMs from coal, coal by-products, and coal waste streams. These production pathways represent a potential new supply for CMs across the U.S. and elsewhere, thereby enhancing national security and accelerating the widespread deployment of low-carbon energy technologies, while also generating alternative applications for remaining coal reserves and aiding in a just transition for rural energy-producing communities.
Poster for the 2024 NETL Resource Sustainability Meeting. The poster presents a new project award by the Office of Technology Transitions to accelerate application and commercial utilization of an NETL-developed technology to rapidly characterize critical mineral occurrences within secondary and/or unconventional feedstocks, such as coal refuse or waste impoundments.
The presentation summarizes research updates from our university subcontractors on the topic of updates within the PARETO optimization framework to enable evaluation, design, and operation of produced water networks considering opportunities for critical mineral recovery.