The low-stress and high-temperature creep in LiF single crystals: An explanation for the So-called Harper-Dorn creep
Not Available
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Not Available
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Abstract not provided.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Abstract not provided.
Alloy 709 is a high temperature austenitic steel with potential for replacing Type 316 stainless steel. Efforts have been underway to lay the groundwork for an ASME code case by first refine the processing conditions to manufacture Alloy 709 plate. This effort continued into this year, as well as work examining the range of allowable solution annealing temperatures, the ability to recover material that was solution annealed at a temperature that was found to produce poor mechanical properties, and to examine the effects of pre-aging the material prior to testing.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
This report provides an update on the materials performance criteria and methodology relevant to sodium-cooled fast reactors (SFRs). The report is the second deliverable (Level 2) in FY11 (M2A11AN040303) under the work package A-11AN040303 “Materials Performance Criteria and Methodology” as part of the Advanced Structural Materials Program for the Advanced Reactor Concepts. The overall objective of the Materials Performance Criteria and Methodology work project is to evaluate the key requirements for the ASME Code qualification and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) approval of advanced structural materials in support of the design and performance of sodium-cooled fast reactors. Advanced materials are a critical element in the development of fast reactor technologies. Enhanced materials performance not only improves safety margins and provides design flexibility, but also is essential for the economics of future advanced fast reactors. Qualification and licensing of advanced materials are prominent needs for the development and implementation of advanced fast reactor technologies. Nuclear structural component designs in the U.S. comply with the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel (B&PV) Code Section III (Rules for Construction of Nuclear Facility Components), and the NRC grants licensing. As the SFRs will operate at higher temperatures than the current light water reactors (LWRs), the design of elevated-temperature components must comply with ASME Section III Subsection NH (Class 1 Components in Elevated Temperature Service). A number of technical issues relevant to materials performance criteria and high temperature design methodology in the SFR were identified and presented in earlier reports. A viable approach to resolve these issues and the R&D priority were also recommended. The development of mechanistically based creep-fatigue interaction models for life prediction and reliable data extrapolation was chosen to be the central focus in near-term efforts. Our current focus is on the creep-fatigue damage issue in high-strength ferritic/martensitic steels such as mod.9Cr-1Mo (G91) and NF616 (G92) steels. The current ASME creep-fatigue design rule puts severe limits of fatigue and creep loads for G91 steel, the lead structural material for fast reactors. High-strength ferritic/martensitic steels behave fundamentally differently from austenitic stainless steels, for which the current ASME creep-fatigue design rules were developed. The unique deformation and damage characteristics in G91 steel, e.g. cyclic softening, degradation of creep and rupture strength during cyclic service, demands a new creep-fatigue design procedure that explicitly accounts for the material’s unique creep-fatigue behavior. G92 steel, a variant of G91 steel, is the lead candidate in the Advanced Alloy Development program. There is currently no creep-fatigue design rule available for this advanced alloy. To support the predictive model development and resolve the over-conservative issue with the ASME design rule for G91 steel, we recovered stress relaxation data from thirteen creep-fatigue tests conducted in the late 1980s and early 1990s at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, and conducted extensive data analysis in FY10. Based on this database and available literature data, we have developed a Cyclic Softening Model and a Stress Relaxation Model specifically applied to G91 steel. The Cyclic Softening Model describes the cyclic stress variation as a function of cycle number during creep-fatigue loading, and well captures the cyclic softening effect in G91 steel. The Stress Relaxation Model predicts the stress relaxation curve during the hold time of cyclic loading, and its dependence on the cyclic softening effect of G91 steel. Two creep-fatigue test systems have been set up to conduct model-oriented creep-fatigue experiments. Results from three creep-fatigue experiments on Heat 30176 of G91 steel are presented in the report: (1) a test performed at 550°C with total strain amplitude of 0.25% and a hold time of 60 s applied at peak strains in both tension and compression, (2) a test performed at 400°C with total strain amplitude of 0.5% and a tension and compression hold time of 60 s, and (3) a test performed at 20°C with total strain amplitude of 0.5% and a tension and compression hold time of 60 s. Three different test temperatures were chosen for two primary reasons: to determine the transition temperature of creep-fatigue interaction from a plasticity-dominated process to a creep-dominated process; to develop unified creep-fatigue models applicable for a wide range of temperatures. With the detailed information obtained in the creep-fatigue experiments, we have further refined the Cyclic Softening Model and Stress Relaxation Model. The Cyclic Softening Model and Stress Relaxation Model were incorporated into the Bilinear Creep-Fatigue Damage Model, forming a powerful framework for the life prediction by an improved creep-fatigue evaluation methodology. The cyclic softening and consecutive stress relaxation responses in G91 steel can be considered for each cycle of the entire cyclic process in the model calculation. The creep-fatigue damage in G91 steel was evaluated using the improved Bilinear Creep-Fatigue Damage Model without any safety margins. It was found that due to the significant cyclic softening in G91 steel, the unit creep damage in each cycle decreased continuously with increasing number of cycles. This continuous change in creep damage with cycling has significant implication in the evaluation of the total creep-fatigue damage. The total creep damage can be one order of magnitude lower when the unit creep damage at half-life was used in the evaluation in comparison with the calculations using the unit creep damage at cycle 10. An important conclusion was that the accurate assessment of the creep-fatigue damage in G91 steel must consider the history of cycling. This analysis provides a more realistic assessment of creep-fatigue damage and identifies critical factors that must be considered in the development of future advanced models for high-strength ferritic/martensitic alloys. An accelerated creep-fatigue testing methodology is proposed for the design of model-oriented experiments to guide and validate model developments. Future work will focus on creep-fatigue experiments of both G91 and G92 steels, and development of creep-fatigue models applicable to advanced ferritic/martensitic alloys. The Cyclic Softening Model and Stress Relaxation Model will be improved by incorporating microstructural parameters of dislocation density, subgrain structure, and second-phase particles. Collaborative modeling of combined Cyclic Softening Model, Stress Relaxation Model, and Interactive Damage Rate Model will be pursued for life prediction under creep-fatigue loading with extended hold time. Accelerated, well-controlled creep-fatigue tests will be conducted to provide high-quality experimental data to refine key material parameters and validate models.
This report provides an update on the materials performance criteria and methodology relevant to liquid metal reactors (LMRs), in particular, sodium cooled fast reactors. The report is the first deliverable (Level 3) in FY11 (M3A11AN04030303) under the work package A-11AN040303 “Materials Performance Criteria and Methodology” as part of Advanced Structural Materials Program for the Advanced Reactor Concepts. The overall objective of the Advanced Materials Performance Criteria and Methodology project is to evaluate the key requirements for the ASME Code qualification and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) approval of advanced structural materials in support of the design and licensing of the liquid metal fast reactors. Advanced materials are a critical element in the development of fast reactor technologies. Enhanced materials performance not only improves safety margins and provides design flexibility but also is essential for the economics of future advanced fast reactors. Qualification and licensing of advanced materials are prominent needs for the development and implementation of advanced fast reactor technologies. Nuclear structural component designs in the U.S. comply with the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel (B&PV) Code Section III (Rules for Construction of Nuclear Facility Components) and the NRC grants licensing. As the LMR will operate at higher temperatures than the current light water reactors (LWRs), the design of elevated-temperature components must comply with ASME Section III Subsection NH (Class 1 Components in Elevated Temperature Service). A number of technical issues relevant to materials performance criteria and high temperature design methodology in the LMR were identified and presented in earlier reports [Natesan et al. 2008, 2009]. A viable approach to resolve these issues and the R&D priority were also recommended. The development of mechanistically based creep-fatigue interaction models for life prediction and reliable data extrapolation was chosen to be the central focus in near-term efforts. Our current efforts focus on the creep-fatigue damage issue in high-strength ferritic-martensitic steels for two primary reasons. First, the current ASME design rule of bilinear damage summation puts severe limits of fatigue and creep loads for mod.9Cr-1Mo (G91) ferritic-martensitic steel, the lead structural material for fast reactors; secondly, the ferritic-martensitic steels behave fundamentally differently from austenitic stainless steels, for which the current ASME creep-fatigue design rules were developed. The unique deformation and damage characteristics in G91 steel, e.g. cyclic softening, degradation of creep and rupture strength during cyclic service, demands a new creep-fatigue design procedure that explicitly accounts for the material’s unique creep-fatigue behavior. To support the development of predictive models and to resolve the over-conservative issue with the ASME design rule for G91 steel, we recovered stress relaxation data from thirteen creep-fatigue tests conducted at Oak Ridge National Laboratory in late 1980s and early 1990s, and conducted extensive data analysis. Based on this limited database and available literature data, we have developed a Cyclic Softening Model and a Stress Relaxation Model specifically applied to G91 steel. The Cyclic Softening Model incorporates strain hardening and creep deformation, and predicts the cyclic stress variation as a function of cycle number during creep-fatigue loading. The Stress Relaxation Model predicts the stress relaxation curve during the hold time of cyclic loading, based on the creep properties of the material. By incorporating the newly developed Cyclic Softening Model and Stress Relaxation Model with the Bilinear Damage Model, we have evaluated the creep-fatigue damage in G91 steel using experimental data without any safety margins. The analysis provided a more realistic assessment of creep-fatigue damage and identified critical factors that need to be considered in future advanced models. We have found that due to the significant cyclic softening in G91 steel, the unit creep damage in each cycle decreased continuously with increasing number of cycles. This continuous change in creep damage with cycling has significant implication in the evaluation of the total creep-fatigue damage. The total creep damage can be one order of magnitude lower when the unit creep damage at half-life was used in the evaluation in comparison with the calculations using the unit creep damage at cycle 10. An important conclusion is the accurate assessment of the creep-fatigue damage in G91 steel must consider the cycling history. Future work will refine the Cyclic Softening Model and Stress Relaxation Model and integrate these two models with the Damage Rate Model for life prediction under creep-fatigue loading. An accelerated creep-fatigue testing methodology is proposed for the design of model-oriented experiments to guide and validate model development. Key material parameters in the model will be determined by creep and fatigue data, obtained under symmetric continuous cycling (fast-fast and slow-slow) and asymmetric cycling (slow-fast and fast-slow) which often lead to accelerated creep-fatigue damage. The established model, based on creep and fatigue properties, will then be used to predict the life under creep-fatigue loading with hold-time in either tension or compression or combined tension and compression. With the success of this mechanistically based life prediction model for G91 steel, the model will be extended to advanced ferritic-martensitic steels, such as NF616.
Recently, the creep models in FRAPCON-3.4 were used to model the creep tests performed in IFA-699 up through cycle 4. IFA-699 is an instrumented test rig in the Halden Boiling Water Reactor that is being used to perform in-reactor creep experiments under changing stress conditions. The cladding creep tests in IFA-699 were on four fresh fuel segments with Zircaloy-4, E110, M-MDA, and M5™ cladding. These fuel segments were loaded in a test rig and placed in a PWR loop and operated under PWR conditions. Each of the test fuel rods were connected to gas lines in order to apply tensile and compressive stresses to the cladding. Diameters of the cladding were measured by diameter gages at several intervals to measure the creep behavior of the cladding as a function of time. The creep tests were performed at a temperature of around 360°C and fast neutron flux of 1.8 to 2.4×1017 n/m²-s (depends on specimen location). During the four cycles of operation, hoop stresses of -75, -50, +30, and +110 MPa were applied to the specimens. In addition to providing assessment of the FRAPCON-3.4 creep modeling, the creep model comparisons were also used to provide insight into the nature of primary creep following stress changes, whether creep behavior is symmetric under tensile and compressive loading, and the effect of fast fluence on creep rate. It was determined that creep strain should be calculated as a function of effective stress rather than hoop stress. This accounts for the observed difference between creep under compressive and tensile stress for the same hoop stress. It was also determined that the primary creep changes in proportion to the change in stress following stress change or stress reversal. Finally, it was observed that the irradiation creep rate decreases somewhat with increasing fluence. The creep model in FRAPCON-3.4 has already been developed to be a function of effective stress and includes a term that decreases the irradiation creep rate with increasing fluence. A new mathematical formulation has been developed that is suitable for a fuel performance code to calculate the primary creep strain under conditions of changing stress and stress reversal. The creep model in FRAPCON-3.4 and the formulation for calculating primary creep under changing stress conditions will be described in this paper. Comparisons to data will also be provided.
Harper-Dorn (H-D) creep is observed in metals and geological materials exposed to very low stresses at temperatures close to the melting point. It is one of several types of creep processes wherein the steady-state strain rate is proportional to the applied stress, Nabarro-Herring creep and Coble creep being two other important processes. H-D creep can be somewhat insidious because the creep rates are much larger than those expected for Nabarro-Herring or Coble creep. Since the working conditions of structural components of power plants and propulsion systems, as well as the motion of the earth’s mantle all involve very low stresses, an understanding of the factors controlling H-D creep is critical in preventing failures associated with those higher-than-expected creep rates. The purpose of this investigation was to obtain missing microstructural information on the evolution of the dislocation structures during static annealing of materials with fcc, bcc and hcp structure and use obtained results to test predictive capabilities of the dislocation network theory of H-D creep. In our view the evolutionary processes during static annealing and during Harper-Dorn creep are intimately related. The materials used in this study were fcc aluminum, hcp zinc and bcc tin. All characterizations of dislocation structures, densities and dislocation link length distributions were carried out using the etch pit method. To obtain quantitative information on the evolution of the dislocation networks during annealing the pure fcc aluminum samples were pre-deformed by creep at 913 and 620 K and then annealed. The higher deformation temperature was selected to generate starting dislocation networks similar to those forming during Harper-Dorn creep and the lower, to obtain higher dislocation densities suitable for reliable estimates of the parameters of the network growth law. The measured experimental link length distribution were, after scaling, (1) the same for all annealing temperatures, (2) time invariant and (3) identical to the distributions obtained previously for Harper-Dorn creep. This has never been shown before and confirms our theoretical expectations that evolution of the dislocation networks during annealing and H-D creep is governed by the same growth law. Obtained results were also used to predict H-D steady creep rates from annealing kinetics data using equations of the dislocation network theory. For the three considered stresses the theory predicts systematically smaller creep rates by the average factor of 4.5. Considering that the creep rates have been predicted from the annealing data alone and without any adjustable parameters, this results shout be considered as outstanding. In case of hcp zinc the samples were pre-deformed in compression at constant stress of 4 MPa at temperature of 573 K and subsequently annealed at the same temperature. During annealing samples readily recrystallized, but it was possible to obtain information on the link length distributions from several unrecrystallized grains. The results showed that the scaled link length distributions were time invariant and similar to those of the aluminum. The annealing studies on bcc tin were also curtailed by the concurrent recrystallization. It was only possible to obtain link length distribution for samples deformed in compression at constant load of 2 MPa at 423 K after unloading. The link length distribution was also in this case similar to that of the aluminum and zinc. These results suggest that the scaled link length distribution is universal and the same for the three considered crystal structures. This supports theoretical findings of these studies that appropriately scaled dislocation link length distribution should both universal and time invariant. We have also investigated the possibility of using alternative methods of estimating local dislocation densities from etch pits which could give more precise estimates of the dislocation link-lengths. The two most promising method are based on the use of Voronoi diagrams and uniform 3-connected nets. Both methods require further testing before they can be used in confidence in the analysis of the etch pit results.
The tensile and compressive creep behavior of an extruded Mg–10Gd–3Y–0.5Zr (wt.%) alloy was investigated at temperatures ranging from 200 °C to 300 °C and under stresses ranging from 30 MPa to 120 MPa. There existed an asymmetry in the tensile and compressive creep properties. The minimum creep rate of the alloy was slightly greater in tension than in compression. The measured values of the transient strain and initial creep rate in compression were greater than those in tension. The creep stress exponent was approximately 2.5 at low temperatures (T < 250 °C) and 3.4 at higher temperatures both in tension and in compression. The compression creep activation energy at low temperatures and high temperatures was 83.4 and 184.3 kJ/mol respectively, while one activation energy (184 kJ/mol) represented the tensile–creep behavior over the temperature range examined. Dislocation creep was suggested to be the main mechanism in tensile creep and in the high-temperature regime in compressive creep, while grain boundary sliding was suggested to dominate in the low-temperature regime in compressive creep. Precipitate free zones were observed near grain boundaries perpendicular to the loading direction in tension and parallel to the loading direction in compression. Electron backscattered diffraction analysis revealed that the texture changed slightly during creep. Non-basal slip was suggested to contribute to the deformation after basal slip was introduced. In the tensile–creep ruptured specimens, intergranular cracks were mainly observed at general high-angle boundaries. - Highlights: • Creep behavior of an extruded Mg–RE alloy was characterized by EBSD. • T5 aging treatment enhanced the tension–compression creep asymmetry. • The grains grew slightly during tensile creep, but not for compressive creep. • Precipitate free zones (PFZs) were observed at specific grain boundaries. • Intergranular fracture was dominant and cracks mainly originated at GHABs.
Highlights: • The true creep deformation mechanism has been found by an evaluation of threshold stresses. • The analysed creep data suggest that the rate-controlling mechanism of creep is dislocation climb. • Coarsening of the M{sub 23}C{sub 6} carbides has been observed at 650 °C and 700 °C during creep. In this study, creep tests were conducted on a set of specimens made from the same tube of T91 steel at different temperatures (600 °C, 650 °C and 700 °C) with the applied stresses ranging from 30 MPa to 180 MPa and rupture times from 28.7 to 7957 h for understanding the creep mechanism. The stress dependence of minimum creep rates exhibits a power law with different exponents were found to be 14.3, 11 and 4.6 at 600 °C, 650 °C and 700 °C, respectively. Activation energy of creep was determined to be ~573 kJ/mol, which is ~53% higher than that of the lattice self-diffusion in α-iron. Based on the stress exponents, the modified Bird-Murkherjee-Dorn (BMD) equation was used to find the threshold stresses which has shown the strongly dependent on the test temperature. After incorporating the threshold stress, true activation energy of creep was found to be decreased ~271 kJ/mol, which is equivalent to that of lattice-self diffusion in α-iron. This subsequently led to evaluation of true stress exponent ~4. The results of creep data suggest that the rate-controlling mechanism of creep is dislocation climb for T91 steel. Microstructural observation of T91 steel is mainly consisting of lath martensite structure with fine MX carbonitrides and M{sub 23}C{sub 6} carbides were characterized using the scanning and transmission electron microscopes. The stress dependence of creep rupture life has shown that the operating mechanism of creep is similar. Furthermore, creep data was analysed for validity of the Monkman-Grant relationship and creep damage tolerance parameter. The qualitative microstructure of the crept samples show that less number of MX carbonitrides within grains is responsible for creep cavity formation and decreasing the rupture life. Thus, microstructural degradation is attributed to M{sub 23}C{sub 6} carbides coarsened and dislocation sub-structure boundaries are mainly responsible for creep damage. The fracture morphology of the samples has revealed with dimples is a typical transgranular ductile failure.