Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “ROLLING”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 883 records · Page 49

Manufacture of Alumina-Forming Austenitic Stainless Steel Alloys by Conventional Casting and Hot-Working Methods

Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and Carpenter Technology Corporation (CarTech) participated in an in-kind cost share cooperative research and development agreement (CRADA) effort under the auspices of the Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE) Technology Maturation program to explore the feasibility for scale up of developmental ORNL alumina-forming austenitic (AFA) stainless steels by conventional casting and rolling techniques. CarTech successfully vacuum melted 30lb heats of four AFA alloy compositions in the range of Fe-(20-25)Ni-(12-14)Cr-(3-4)Al-(1-2.5)Nb wt.% base. Conventional hot/cold rolling was used to produce 0.5-inch thick plate and 0.1-inch thick sheet product. ORNL subsequently successfully rolled the 0.1-inch sheet to 4 mil thick foil. Long-term oxidation studies of the plate form material were initiated at 650, 700, and 800 C in air with 10 volume percent water vapor. Preliminary results indicated that the alloys exhibit comparable (good) oxidation resistance to ORNL laboratory scale AFA alloy arc casting previously evaluated. The sheet and foil material will be used in ongoing evaluation efforts for oxidation and creep resistance under related CRADAs with two gas turbine engine manufacturers. This work will be directed to evaluation of AFA alloys for use in gas turbine recuperators to permit higher-temperature operating conditions for improved efficiencies and reduced environmental emissions.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Manufacture of Alumina-Forming Austenitic Steel Alloys by Conventional Casting and Hot-Working Methods

Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and Carpenter Technology Corporation (CarTech) participated in an in-kind cost share cooperative research and development agreement (CRADA) effort under the auspices of the Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE) Technology Maturation Program to explore the feasibility for scale up of developmental ORNL alumina-forming austenitic (AFA) stainless steels by conventional casting and rolling techniques. CarTech successfully vacuum melted 301b heats of four AFA alloy compositions in the range of Fe-(20-25)Ni-(12-14)Cr-(3-4)Al-(l-2.5)Nb wt.% base. Conventional hot/cold rolling was used to produce 0.5-inch thick plate and 0.1-inch thick sheet product. ORNL subsequently successfully rolled the 0.1-inch sheet to 4 mil thick foil. Long-term oxidation studies of the plate form material were initiated at 650, 700, and 800 C in air with 10 volume percent water vapor. Preliminary results indicated that the alloys exhibit comparable (good) oxidation resistance to ORNL laboratory scale AFA alloy arc casting previously evaluated. The sheet and foil material will be used in ongoing evaluation efforts for oxidation and creep resistance under related CRADAs with two gas turbine engine manufacturers. This work will be directed to evaluation of AFA alloys for use in gas turbine recuperators to permit higher-temperature operating conditions for improved efficiencies and reduced environmental emissions. AFA alloy properties to date have been obtained from small laboratory scale arc-castings made at ORNL. The goal of the ORNL-CarTech CRADA was to establish the viability for producing plate, sheet and foil of the AFA alloys by conventional casting and hot working approaches as a first step towards scale up and commercialization of the AFA alloys. The AFA alloy produced under this effort will then be evaluated in related CRADAs with two gas turbine engine manufacturers for gas turbine recuperator applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Interplay Between Plastic Deformations and Optical Properites of Metal Surfaces: A Multiscale Study

The design of metallic surfaces with required surface quality and visual appearance represents a significant challenge for scientists and engineers. For example, the surface of aluminum products such as reflector bright sheet, aerospace structural components, and architectural materials is always required to have an attractive appearance under different lighting conditions and to be free of defects and corrosion [ref. 1]. Industrial-scale modification processes of metal alloy products (heat treatment, rolling, stretching, extruding, etc.) are closely related to different plastic phenomena. Although plastic deformation takes place at the macroscopic level, it significantly changes the surface geometry at the meso- and microscopic scales which may result in spectacular modifications of visual appearance of the deformed surface. Here we use a combination of confocal optical microscopy, orientation imaging microscopy with electron back scattering diffraction (EBSD), original morphological image analysis approach developed by the authors, and finite element simulations, in order to investigate the interplay of different plastic instabilities emerging in the course of plastic deformation, and visual appearance. It is demonstrated that visual brightness of aluminum sheet products could be significantly suppressed by some widely used industrial processes such as uniaxial stretching of the sheet. On the other hand, a properly designed “texture rolling” (i.e., embossing additional controlled engineered features into the metal surface) makes it significantly brighter than a conventionally rolled surface because these features may serve as sinks for otherwise incompatible plastic deformations and enhance brightness due to the suppression of roughness. It is expected that such “imaging transitions” are of general nature and could be observed for different metals and alloys exhibiting plastic instabilities. In turn, these results provide guidelines for the control of metal surface morphology in order to achieve desirable visual appearance, such as visual brightness and omnidirectional coloration.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Fully R2R-Printed Carbon-Nanotube-Based Limitless Length of Flexible Active-Matrix for Electrophoretic Display Application

A limitless-length flexible active-matrix implies that virtually any surface can be rendered into an interactive medium when laminated with electrophoretic or organic light-emitting diode sheets. However, performance, cost, and size limitations of current fabrication technologies and semiconducting materials, typically utilized in thin film transistor (TFT) active matrices (TFT-AMs), have hindered progress, thus preventing the realization of fully printed TFT-AMs on a plastic roll. Here, a new high-purity semiconducting single-walled carbon nanotube (s-SWCNT) ink is prepared by first isolating 99.9% pure s-SWCNTs via conjugated polymer extraction, and then utilizing a ligand-exchange method to formulate a novel hydrophilic gravure-compatible semiconducting ink. Based on the s-SWCNT ink, a fully additive manufacturing process using roll-to-roll (R2R) gravure printing enables the fabrication of a flexible TFT-AM, overcoming performance, cost, and size limitations. TFT-AMs with 10 to 40 PPI resolution where average mobility of 0.23 ± 0.12 cm 2 V –1 s –1 , average on–off ratio of 10 4.1 , and threshold voltage variation of ±13% are attained. As a proof of concept, an inexpensive and flexible electrophoretic display is demonstrated by simply laminating an electrophoretic sheet onto the R2R gravure-printed s-SWCNT-based TFT-AM.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Research on Phase Reaction of Nb{sub 3}Al Precursor During Rapid Heating Process

Short samples of Nb{sub 3}Al precursor are heated by Ohm heating. The curves of temperature vs heating time are investigated to study the phase reaction of jelly-roll precursor and in situ powder-in-tube precursor during the rapid heating process. A short constant temperature process occurs at about 2000 {sup ∘}C. It is proved that the reaction that generates body-centered cubic (BCC) solid solution phase is reversible. For jelly-roll precursor, metallographic images show that no reaction occurs between Nb/Al roll and Nb matrix. Voids and cracks become larger as the precursor is processed for multiple times. For in situ powder-in-tube precursor, Nb and Al powder is not reacted completely. Using smaller original Nb powder and Al powder is good for the formation of BCC solid solution.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Characterization of Directional Elastoplastic Properties of Al/Cu Bimetallic Sheet

The paper presents the results of the study aimed at determining the elastoplastic properties of an Al/Cu bimetallic sheet consisting of aluminum and copper layers, which were joined by cold rolling. The values of elasticity coefficients in three orthotropic planes as well as the Kirchhoff modulus, and coefficient of internal friction in the perpendicular direction to the lamination were determined. The subjects of the analysis were also the values of limit stresses, uniform energy of elastic and plastic strain per unit volume, and coefficients of the hardening curve and normal anisotropy. The tests were carried out on bimetallic specimens with varying thicknesses of the copper layer, cut from the Al/Cu sheet in the direction of rolling and in the direction perpendicular to it. Two methods of determining the directional values of mechanical parameters were used in the tests, i.e., the uniaxial quasi-static tensile test and the dynamic acoustic resonance method. It was concluded that these methods made it possible to determine directional elastoplastic properties of the Al/Cu bimetallic sheet taking into account the variable share of components in the bimetal and the direction of cutting out specimens from cold-rolled sheet.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Effects of chemical segregation on ductility-anisotropy in high strength Fe-Mn-Al-C lightweight austenitic steels

Ductile Fe-Mn-Al-C lightweight steels offer great potential as high specific strength materials for weight critical applications. In the present work, very high yield (~1 GPa) and ultimate tensile strength levels (~1.5 GPa) were obtained along the rolling and transverse directions of Fe-30Mn-8.5Al-0.9Si-0.9C-0.5Mo (wt.%), with high tensile elongation to failure of ~35%. This excellent mechanical behavior was attributed to the nanoscale, ordered κ-carbide precipitates formed during aging after rolling. However, tensile ductility was not isotropic through all directions of the rolled plate. In particular, the ductility was consistently lower than 5% true strain along the normal direction. Upon detailed microstructural investigations, micro-scale lamellar chemical micro-segregation bands were detected, which caused the observed anisotropic embrittlement along certain plate directions. These bands resulted in low failure strains along the normal direction since it is oriented perpendicular to these chemical segregation bands, resulting in a failure type reminiscent of delamination-induced cleavage fracture. Chemical segregation causes an inhomogeneous κ-carbide precipitate distribution upon aging, producing more pronounced mechanical anisotropy after peak-aging as compared to the solution heat treated samples. Surprisingly, deformation twinning was observed after tensile deformation of solution-heat treated specimens via electron-backscatter diffraction experiments, which is anomalous for a high stacking faulty energy (SFE) material. Further, it was proposed that chemical micro-segregation promotes locally different SFE regions, leading to deformation twinning in this nominally high SFE material. Overall, this work demonstrates the effects of chemical segregation on mechanical properties and microstructural evolution in a high performance, lightweight Fe-Mn-Al-C steel.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Quantum dice

In a letter to Born, Einstein wrote [42]: “Quantum mechanics is certainly imposing. But an inner voice tells me that it is not yet the real thing. The theory says a lot, but does not really bring us any closer to the secret of the ‘old one.’ I, at any rate, am convinced that He does not throw dice.” In this paper we take seriously Einstein’s famous metaphor, and show that we can gain considerable insight into quantum mechanics by doing something as simple as rolling dice. More precisely, we show how to perform measurements on a single die, to create typical quantum interference effects, and how to connect (entangle) two identical dice, to maximally violate Bell’s inequality. -- Highlights: •Rolling a die is a quantum process admitting a Hilbert space representation. •Rolling experiments with a single die can produce interference effects. •Two connected dice can violate Bell’s inequality. •Correlations need to be created by the measurement, to violate Bell’s inequality.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Modeling of deformation behavior and texture evolution in magnesium alloy using the intermediate $\phi$-model

The viscoplastic intermediate phi-model was applied in this work to predict the deformation behavior and texture evolution in a magnesium alloy, an HCP material. We simulated the deformation behavior with different intergranular interaction strengths and compared the predicted results with available experimental results. In this approach, elasticity is neglected and the plastic deformation mechanisms are assumed as a combination of crystallographic slip and twinning systems. Tests are performed for rolling (plane strain compression) of random textured Mg polycrystal as well as for tensile and compressive tests on rolled Mg sheets. Simulated texture evolutions agree well with experimental data. Activities of twinning and slip, predicted by the intermediate $\phi$-model, reveal the strong anisotropic behavior during tension and compression of rolled sheets.

$\phi$-Model↗

A Comprehensive Assessment by Tumor Site of Patient Setup Using Daily MVCT Imaging From More Than 3,800 Helical Tomotherapy Treatments

Purpose: To assess patient setup corrections based on daily megavoltage CT (MVCT) imaging for four anatomic treatment sites treated on tomotherapy. Method and Materials: Translational and rotational setup corrections, based on registration of daily MVCT to planning CT images, were analyzed for 1,179 brain and head and neck (H and N), 1,414 lung, and 1,274 prostate treatment fractions. Frequencies of three-dimensional vector lengths, overall distributions of setup corrections, and patient-specific distributions of random and systematic setup errors were analyzed. Results: Brain and H and N had lower magnitude positioning corrections and smaller variations in translational setup errors but were comparable in roll rotations. Three-dimensional vector translational shifts of larger magnitudes occurred more frequently for lung and prostate than for brain and H and N treatments, yet this was not observed for roll rotations. The global systematic error for prostate was 4.7 mm in the vertical direction, most likely due to couch sag caused by large couch extension distances. Variations in systematic errors and magnitudes of random translational errors ranged from 1.6 to 2.6 mm for brain and H and N and 3.2 to 7.2 mm for lung and prostate, whereas roll rotational errors ranged from 0.8{sup o} to 1.2{sup o} for brain and H and N and 0.5{sup o} to 1.0{sup o} for lung and prostate. Conclusions: Differences in setup were observed between brain, H and N, lung, and prostate treatments. Patient setup can be improved if daily imaging is performed. This analysis can assess the utilization of daily image guidance and allows for further investigation into improved anatomic site-specific and patient-specific treatments.

62 RADIOLOGY AND NUCLEAR MEDICINE↗

Evaluation of Rotational Errors in Treatment Setup of Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy of Liver Cancer

Purpose: To evaluate the dosimetric impact of rotational setup errors in stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT) treatment of liver tumors and to investigate whether translational shifts can compensate for rotation. Methods and Materials: The positioning accuracy in 20 patients with liver malignancies treated with SBRT was reevaluated offline by matching the patients' cone-beam computed tomography (CT) scans (n=75) to the planning CT scans and adjusting the 3 rotational angles (pitch, roll, and yaw). Systematic and random setup errors were calculated. The dosimetric changes caused by rotational setup errors were quantified for both simulated and observed patient rotations. Dose distributions recalculated on the rotated CT scans were compared with the original planned doses. Translational corrections were simulated based on manual translational registration of the rotated images to the original CT scans. The correction efficacy was evaluated by comparing the recalculated plans with the original plans. Results: The systematic rotational setup errors were -0.06 Degree-Sign {+-} 0.68 Degree-Sign , -0.29 Degree-Sign {+-} 0.62 Degree-Sign , and -0.24 Degree-Sign {+-} 0.61 Degree-Sign ; the random setup errors were 0.80 Degree-Sign , 1.05 Degree-Sign , and 0.61 Degree-Sign for pitch, roll, and yaw, respectively. Analysis of CBCT images showed that 56.0%, 14.7%, and 1.3% of treated fractions had rotational errors of >1 Degree-Sign , >2 Degree-Sign , and >3 Degree-Sign , respectively, in any one of the rotational axes. Rotational simulations demonstrated that the reduction of gross tumor volume (GTV) coverage was <2% when rotation was <3 Degree-Sign . Recalculated plans using actual patient roll motions showed similar reduction (<2%) in GTV coverage. Translational corrections improved the GTV coverage to within 3% of the original values. For organs at risk (OAR), the dosimetric impact varied case by case. Conclusion: Actual rotational setup errors in SBRT for liver tumors are relatively small in magnitude and are unlikely to affect GTV coverage significantly. Translational corrections can be optimized to compensate for rotational setup errors. However, caution regarding possible dose increases to OAR needs to be exercised.

62 RADIOLOGY AND NUCLEAR MEDICINE↗

Distance-to-Agreement Investigation of Tomotherapy's Bony Anatomy-Based Autoregistration and Planning Target Volume Contour-Based Optimization

Purpose: To compare Tomotherapy's megavoltage computed tomography bony anatomy autoregistration with the best achievable registration, assuming no deformation and perfect knowledge of planning target volume (PTV) location. Methods and Materials: Distance-to-agreement (DTA) of the PTV was determined by applying a rigid-body shift to the PTV region of interest of the prostate from its reference position, assuming no deformations. Planning target volume region of interest of the prostate was extracted from the patient archives. The reference position was set by the 6 degrees of freedom (dof)—x, y, z, roll, pitch, and yaw—optimization results from the previous study at this institution. The DTA and the compensating parameters were calculated by the shift of the PTV from the reference 6-dof to the 4-dof—x, y, z, and roll—optimization. In this study, the effectiveness of Tomotherapy's 4-dof bony anatomy–based autoregistration was compared with the idealized 4-dof PTV contour-based optimization. Results: The maximum DTA (maxDTA) of the bony anatomy-based autoregistration was 3.2 ± 1.9 mm, with the maximum value of 8.0 mm. The maxDTA of the contour-based optimization was 1.8 ± 1.3 mm, with the maximum value of 5.7 mm. Comparison of Pearson correlation of the compensating parameters between the 2 4-dof optimization algorithms shows that there is a small but statistically significant correlation in y and z (0.236 and 0.300, respectively), whereas there is very weak correlation in x and roll (0.062 and 0.025, respectively). Conclusions: We find that there is an average improvement of approximately 1 mm in terms of maxDTA on the PTV going from 4-dof bony anatomy-based autoregistration to the 4-dof contour-based optimization. Pearson correlation analysis of the 2 4-dof optimizations suggests that uncertainties due to deformation and inadequate resolution account for much of the compensating parameters, but pitch variation also makes a statistically significant contribution.

62 RADIOLOGY AND NUCLEAR MEDICINE↗

Enhancing workability in sheet production of high silicon content electrical steel through large shear deformation

Enhanced workability, as characterized by the magnitude and heterogeneity of accommodated plastic strains during sheet processing, is demonstrated in high Si content Fe-Si alloys containing 4 and 6.5 wt% Si using two single-step, simple-shear deformation techniques – peeling and large strain extrusion machining (LSEM). The model Fe-Si material system was selected for its intrinsically poor material workability, and well-known applications potential in next-generation electric machines. In a comparative study of the deformation characteristics of the shear processes with conventional rolling, two distinct manifestations of workability are observed. For rolling, the relatively diffuse and unconfined deformation zone geometry leads to cracking at low strains, with sheet structures characterized by extensive deformation twinning and banding. Workpiece pre-heating is required to improve the workability in rolling. In contrast, peeling and LSEM produce continuous sheet at large plastic strains without cracking, the result of more confined deformation geometries that enhances the workability. Peeling, however, results in heterogeneous, shear-banded microstructures, pointing to a second type of workability issue – flow localization – that limits sheet processing. This shear banding is to a large extent facilitated by unrestricted flow at the sheet surface, unavoidable in peeling. With additional confinement of this free surface deformation and appropriately designed deformation zone geometry, LSEM is shown to suppress shear banding, resulting in continuous sheet with homogeneous microstructure. Thus LSEM is shown to produce the greatest enhancement in process workability for producing sheet. In conclusion, these workability findings are explained and discussed based on differences in process mechanics and deformation zone geometry.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Effects of Zn and Ca on the deformation texture evolution of Mg–Zn–Ca alloys at elevated temperatures

This work utilized crystal plasticity simulations and experimental thermo-mechanical processing to examine how Zn and Ca content affects texture evolution in Mg–Zn–Ca alloys during simulated hot rolling. Four different compositions were studied: unalloyed Mg and three Mg alloys of ZX0p50 (Mg- 0.5 wt% Zn- 0.1 wt% Ca), ZX30 (Mg-3 wt% Zn- 0.1 wt% Ca), and ZX31 (Mg-3 wt% Zn- 0.3 wt% Ca). Multi-pass Gleeble experiments simulated hot rolling using plane strain conditions. Unalloyed Mg developed a strong basal texture, while the addition of Zn and Ca significantly weakened the texture in ZX30 and ZX31; this reduction was not seen in ZX0p50. Notably, ZX31 exhibited a split basal texture aligned with the rolling direction. Crystal plasticity simulations revealed that the weaker basal texture in ZX30 and ZX31 resulted from reduced activation of basal and twinning modes compared to unalloyed Mg and Zx0p50. Increased Zn and Ca content raised the ratios of basal to pyramidal critical resolved sheer stress (CRSS) and twin to pyramidal CRSS, enhancing pyramidal slip activity and weakening the basal texture. Extension twinning played a critical role in texture development during the first deformation pass. In unalloyed Mg and ZX0p50, twinning led to a strong basal texture, while ZX30 and ZX31 had weak basal textures that increased only slightly with further deformation. The split basal poles simulated in ZX31 were consistent with the experimental findings, highlighting the interplay between alloy composition and texture evolution.

Crystal plasticity finite element↗

Simulations of post-recrystallization grain growth in monolithic U–10Mo fuel processing

In this study, the Potts Model was used to simulate the post-recrystallization grain growth behavior of U-10 wt.% Mo (U-10Mo). The fabrication process for monolithic U-10Mo fuels involves multiple stages of rolling, during which spatially heterogeneous distributions of second phase particles form in the alloy microstructure. These particles can strongly affect the post-recrystallization grain growth process. Absent particle dissolution effects, U-10Mo grain growth has been observed stagnating at increasing grain size with increasing annealing temperature. In this work, we simulate this effect in the Potts Model by making adjustments to the non-physical Monte Carlo temperature. This modification was used to account for the weakening pinning effect of the second phases with elevated annealing temperature. Simulated average grain sizes and grain size distributions were compared with experimentally obtained results for 700 °C, 800 °C, and 900 °C anneals of duration up to 240 hours. These simulations achieved reasonable agreement with experimentally observed grain growth behavior, but showed narrower grain size distributions. It is believed that this disagreement originates from the formation of bands of second-phase particles during rolling. Finally, these results demonstrate the capability to evaluate the post-recrystallization grain growth behavior for U-10Mo as a function of previous homogenization, rolling, and annealing treatments.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Impacts of annealing treatment on the microstructure of U-Mo monolithic fuel plates

The objective of this paper is to analyze the effect of different heat treatments on the fuel microstructure and texture in laboratory scale monolithic U-Mo fuel plates. Such analyses are relevant as they could possibly inform future fabrication methods for the optimization of microstructure and of material properties to ultimately improve fuel performance during irradiation. For this reason, detail characterization including Energy x-ray dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) and electron backscattered diffraction (EBSD) techniques were applied on U-Mo plates fabricated with different heat treatments to understand the influence of fabrication on fuel microstructure. Here, U-Mo fresh fuel specimens with or without annealing treatments (homogenization and stress release annealing) after rolling were analyzed in this work. In this study for the first time EBSD was systematically used to analyze the heat treatments influence on texture present in fresh fuel monolithic U-Mo fuel plates. Such changes were connected to other known microstructural and chemical changes. In this work minimization of molybdenum concentration variation and gamma phase decomposition of the U-Mo fuel core after homogenization was observed. Also, an increase in the interaction layer of the U-Mo fuel core with the Zr interlayer diffusion barrier was observed with the UZr 2 growing up to 1 µm in thickness. Such microstructural changes were aligned to the changes in texture and grain structure. Indeed, common texture observed in body-centered cubic (BCC) metal after cold rolling (e.g., α, ξ, γ fibers) were minimized by the annealing/homogenization process. Moreover, grain structure was influenced by the fabrication route with elongated grains formed in the rolled sample and equiaxed grains found after annealing. Such features are relevant since the formation of microstructural features formed during fuel fabrication can impact fuel performance in reactor.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Annealing induced interfacial layers in niobium-clad stainless steel developed as a bipolar plate material for polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell stacks

Niobium (Nb)-clad 304L stainless steel (SS) manufactured by cold rolling is currently under consideration for use as a bipolar plate material in polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) stacks. To make the fabrication of bipolar plates using the Nb-clad SS feasible, annealing may be necessary for the Nb-clad SS to reduce the springback induced by cold rolling. However, the annealing can develop an interfacial layer between the Nb cladding and the SS core and the interfacial layer plays a key role in the failure of the Nb-clad SS as reported earlier [JPS our work]. In this investigation, the Nb-clad SS specimens in as-rolled condition were annealed at different combinations of temperature and time. Based on the results of scanning electron microscope (SEM) analysis, an annealing process map for the Nb-clad SS was obtained. The results of SEM analysis and Transmission Electron Microscope (TEM) analysis also suggest that different interfacial layers occurred based on the given annealing conditions.

annealing↗