DOE OSTI2008
Accurate model representation of the long-term response of forested ecosystems to elevated atmospheric CO2 concentrations (eCO2) is important for predictions of future concentrations of CO2. For biogeochemical models that predict the response of net primary productivity (NPP) to eCO2, free-air CO2 enrichment (FACE) experiments provide the only source of data for comparison. A synthesis of forest FACE experiments reported a 23% increase in NPP in eCO2, and this result has been used as a model benchmark. Here, we provide new evidence from a FACE experiment in a deciduous forest in Tennessee that N limitation has significantly reduced the stimulation of NPP by eCO2, consistent with predictions from ecosystem and global models that incorporate N feedbacks. The Liquidambar styraciflua stand has been exposed to current ambient atmospheric CO2 or air enriched with CO2 to 550 ppm since 1998. Results from the first 6 years of the experiment indicated that NPP was significantly enhanced by eCO2 and that this was a consistent and sustained response. Now, with 10 years of data, our analysis must be revised. The response of NPP to eCO2 has declined from 24% in 2001-2003 to 9% in 2007. The diminishing response to eCO2 since 2004 coincides with declining NPP in ambient CO2 plots. Productivity of this forest stand is limited by N availability, and the steady decline in forest NPP is closely related to changes in the N economy, as evidenced by declining foliar N concentrations. There is a strong linear relationship between foliar [N] and NPP, and the steeper slope in eCO2 indicates that the NPP response to eCO2 should diminish as foliar N declines. Increased fine-root production and root proliferation deeper in the soil have sustained N uptake, but not to an extent sufficient to benefit aboveground production. The mechanistic basis of the N effect on NPP resides in the photosynthetic machinery. The linear relationships between Jmax and Vcmax with foliar [N] did not change from 1998 to 2008 or in response to eCO2; hence, lower foliar [N] resulted in significant reductions in Jmax, Vcmax, and photosynthesis over time and in eCO2. It is not yet clear whether foliar [N] and NPP will continue to decline or have reached a new steady state indicative of long-term forest response to eCO2. These results are consistent with ecosystem models, which suggest that the NPP response to eCO2 will include a transient increase in NPP followed by a decline to a lower level when fast C and N pools reach quasi-equilibrium at eCO2. Our results also are consistent with optimization models of carbon-water-nitrogen economy, which suggest eCO2 leads to increased fine-root production, declining foliar [N], and diminishing enhancement of aboveground production. At a larger scale, a model incorporating N feedbacks (CLM3-CN) predicts a much smaller enhancement of NPP in eCO2 than the CLM3-CASA model without such a feedback. When applied across the terrestrial biosphere, the smaller CO2 fertilization effect has important implications for the pace of climate change.
54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗