DOE OSTI2011
Takano et al. report the focusing of 10-keV X-rays to a size of 14.4 nm using a total-reflection zone plate (TRZP). This focal size is at the diffraction limit for the optic's aperture. This would be a noteworthy result, since the TRZP was fabricated using conventional lithography techniques. Alternative nanofocusing optics require more demanding fabrication methods. However, as I will discuss in this Comment, the intensity distribution presented by Takano et al. (Fig. 4 of ref. 1) is more consistent with the random speckle pattern produced by the scattering of a coherent incident beam by a distorted optic than with a diffraction-limited focus. When interpreted in this manner, the true focal spot size is {approx}70 nm: 5 times the diffraction limit. When a coherent photon beam illuminates an optic containing randomly distributed regions which introduce different phase shifts, the scattered diffraction pattern consists of a speckle pattern. Each speckle will be diffraction-limited: the peak width of a single speckle depends entirely on the source coherence and gives no information about the optic. The envelope of the speckle distribution corresponds to the focal spot which would be observed using incoherent illumination. The width of this envelope is due to the finite size of the coherently-diffracting domains produced by slope and position errors in the optic. The focal intensity distribution in Fig. 4 of ref. 1 indeed contains a diffraction-limited peak, but this peak contains only a fraction of the power in the focused, and forms part of a distribution of sharp peaks with an envelope {approx}70 nm in width, just as expected for a speckle pattern. At the 4mm focal distance, the 70 nm width corresponds to a slope error of 18 {micro}rad. To reach the 14 nm diffraction limit, the slope error must be reduced to 3 {micro}rad. Takano et al. have identified a likely source of this error: warping due to stress as a result of zone deposition. It will be interesting to see whether the use of a more rigid substrate gives improved results.
71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗