Can astrophysical abundances be taken seriously.
The essential feature underlying abundance analysis is the assumption that local thermodynamic equilibrium prevails in a stellar atmosphere - i.e., that all relevant distribution functions, except that for the photons themselves, are thermal and determined by the local temperature. It is pointed out that the blanket assumption of local thermodynamic equilibrium in stellar atmospheres is a fundamental weakness. The assumption can only be valid if collisional processes are dominant in bringing about transitions between the excitation states of an atom. It has, however, been shown that the density in a stellar atmosphere is so low that, on the contrary, radiative processes are predominant.