Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “electrode processing”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 793 records · Page 44
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2022

Platinum Group Metal Catalysts: Supply Chain Deep Dive Assessment

The report “America’s Strategy to Secure the Supply Chain for a Robust Clean Energy Transition” lays out the challenges and opportunities faced by the United States in the energy supply chain as well as the federal government plans to address these challenges and opportunities. It is accompanied by several issue-specific deep dive assessments, including this one, in response to Executive Order 14017 “America’s Supply Chains,” which directs the Secretary of Energy to submit a report on supply chains for the energy sector industrial base. The Executive Order is helping the federal government to build more secure and diverse U.S. supply chains, including energy supply chains. This report focuses on the supply chain for catalysts, specifically platinum group metal (PGM) catalysts, used for decarbonizing energy technologies. Catalysts are substances that increase the rate, conversion, and selectivity of chemical reactions and are used in a variety of applications such as chemical manufacturing, petroleum refining, and catalytic converters. Catalysts containing PGMs (“PGM catalysts”) are particularly useful in widespread industrial applications, including the production of high-volume chemicals such as ammonia, acetic acid, nitric acid, and the refining of crude oil into petroleum products. The PGM metals possess extraordinary properties such as being active oxidation and hydrogenation catalysts; excellent electrical conductors and electrodes; and outstanding adsorbers of oxygen and hydrogen. Within the energy industrial base, PGM catalysts improve the energy and materials efficiency of petroleum refining and chemical industry processes and reduce energy consumption in manufacturing. In addition to their use in catalytic converters, PGM catalysts are important to maximizing the efficiency of emerging decarbonization technologies, specifically in proton exchange membrane (PEM) electrolyzers for green hydrogen production from water and PEM fuel cells for transportation and stationary energy storage. Green hydrogen is expected to play a significant role in decarbonization scenarios.

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗
DOE OSTI2022

KVOPO 4 cathode for sodium ion batteries

An electrode comprising: NaVOPO 4 having orthorhombic crystalline symmetry and space group Pna2 1 , as an active intercalation host material, wherein the electrode is capable of electrochemical insertion and release of greater than one sodium ion per vanadium, wherein the NaVOPO 4 is formed by a solid phase synthesis process from a heated powdered mixture of ammonium metavanadate, ammonium phosphate monobasic, and potassium carbonate, to yield NaVOPO 4 having corner-sharing VO 6 octahedra and PO 4 tetrahedra, defining two types of tunnels comprising a first type of tunnel formed of rings of two PO 4 tetrahedra and a second type of tunnel formed of rings of three PO 4 tetrahedra and three VO 6 octahedra, followed by substitution of the potassium ions with sodium ions.

Whittingham, M. Stanley↗
DOE OSTI2025

Scanning Electrochemical Microscopy: An Evolving Toolbox for Revealing the Chemistry within Electrochemical Processes

The parallel development of ultramicroelectrodes (UMEs) and groundbreaking scanning probe microscopy techniques in the late 1980s led to the development of the scanning electrochemical microscope. Scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM) was born from the idea of using a tiny electrode to measure the local electrochemical behavior at operating electrodes. From its foundations, the technique displayed an inherent versatility in measuring sample properties beyond topography. It allowed experimenters to measure and map chemical reactions occurring at diverse interfaces, from inspecting the reversibility of redox mediators at metal electrodes, to detecting the hallmarks of cellular respiration on living plant leaves. Related but distinct electrochemical scanning probe techniques, such as electrochemical atomic force microscopy (EC-AFM), scanning ion conductance microscopy (SICM), and scanning electrochemical cell microscopy (SECCM) have developed in parallel. These techniques have demonstrated exquisite spatial resolution down to the nanoscale regime. However, it is the proposition of this review that SECM remains unmatched at revealing the chemical aspects of electrochemistry. Furthermore, it is our intention to review and demonstrate that the versatile architecture of SECM continues to evolve and address fundamental and emerging challenges in the fields of energy storage and conversion, chemical biology, materials science, and environmental chemistry, among others.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2024

A Redox-Electrodialysis Model with Zero Fitting Parameters: Insights into Process Limitations, Design, and Material Interventions

Redox-Electrodialysis (r-ED) is an electrochemical desalination cell architecture that has recently received considerable interest, due to its low energy demand relative to electrochemical desalination technologies that rely on electrode-based ion removal. To further improve the energy efficiency of r-ED, we developed a lumped mathematical model with no adjustable parameters to investigate the various sources of overpotential within the cell. Existing models of electrodialysis and r-ED cells either do not accurately incorporate all phenomena contributing to the overpotential or utilize empirical fitting parameters. The model developed here indicates that ohmic overpotentials, especially in the diluate chamber, are the most significant contributors to energy losses. Based on this insight, we hypothesized that adding an ion exchange resin wafer in the diluate compartment would increase the ionic conductivity and decrease the energy demand. Experimental results showed an 18% reduction in specific energy use while achieving the same degree of salt removal (20 mM to 12 mM). Furthermore, the resin wafer enabled complete desalination to potable drinking levels at a current density previously unachievable within practical operating voltage limits (4.93 mA cm -2 ). We also expanded the model to explore differences in r-ED energy use between configurations using multiple cells and a single cell with increased area.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2023

Electrochemical Oxidation and Functionalization of Low‐Density Polyethylene

Abstract Plastic waste is a serious environmental issue, and polyethylene (PE) is a significant component. The chemically inert nature of PE makes its recycling/upcycling process challenging. Thus, a novel method was demonstrated that enables the selective electrochemical functionalization and deconstruction of low‐density polyethylene (LDPE) by using low‐cost transition metal electrocatalysts at room temperature (23±2 °C) and low cell voltage (±1 V). Three different electrode and electrolyte combinations were studied for the oxidation of LDPE: copper metal/copper (II) ions, nickel metal/nickel (II) ions, and stainless steel/iron (II) and (III) ions. The copper and nickel electrode/electrolyte pairs showed a promising capability for oxidation and chain‐scission of LDPE. In contrast, the stainless‐steel and iron electrode/electrolyte pair showed no activity towards LDPE oxidation or depolymerization. The electrolysis of LDPE offers a new vista for the depolymerization and upcycling of plastics, further understanding of the process is needed.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2020

Electrocatalytic Valorization into H2 and Hydrocarbons of an Aqueous Stream Derived from Hydrothermal Liquefaction

Electrocatalytic oxidation is an attractive process for valorizing the carbon and removal of nitrogen present in the aqueous waste streams at ambient conditions. Here, we evaluated the electrocatalytic oxidation as a function of applied potential over a commercial Pt electrode of aqueous waste stream generated via hydrothermal liquefaction. We validated the conversion of quantifiable carbon (e.g., carboxylic acids, alpha hydroxyacids, alcohols, ketones, amides) and unquantifiable carbon as well as nitrogen removal. The unquantifiable carbon was valorized to quantifiable short chain organic molecules (e.g., acetic). Model studies showed that carboxylic acids, alcohol and ketones converted following (non-) Kolbe chemistry. Amides and alpha hydroxyacids formed carboxylic acids that subsequently converted via (non-) Kolbe chemistry. Ammonia was oxidized into N2. The reaction rate varied for each molecule family with carboxylic acids and ammonia having the highest reaction rates. The main reaction products from the electrocatalytic oxidation at the anode were volatile, short chain hydrocarbons (i.e., olefins, paraffins) and CO generated via Kolbe chemistry, while H2 was generated at the cathode. The parallel denitrification, valorization of carbon, and H2 generation of the aqueous waste can replace and simplify the current unit operations used in a commercial hydrothermal liquefaction process. The high operation potential required to drive the electrocatalytic reaction is responsible for high operation costs; however, they can be either partially subsidized with sale of excess H2 at the current DOE goal of $2/kg H2. Thus, the present work shows how electrocatalytic oxidation can be used to valorize aqueous waste streams into volatile hydrocarbons and H2.

Electrocatalytic oxidation, Aqueous waste valoriza↗
DOE OSTI2022

Solvent-Free Manufacturing of Lithium-Ion Battery Electrodes via Cold Plasma

Slurry casting has been used to fabricate lithium-ion battery electrodes for decades, which involves toxic and expensive organic solvents followed by high-cost vacuum drying and electrode calendering. This work presents a new manufacturing method using a nonthermal plasma to create inter-particle binding without using any polymeric binding materials, enabling solvent-free manufacturing electrodes with any electrochemistry of choice. The cold-plasma-coating technique enables fabricating electrodes with thickness (>200 μm), high mass loading (>30 mg cm -2 ), high peel strength, and the ability to print lithium-ion batteries in an arbitrary geometry. This crosscutting, chemistry agnostic, platform technology would increase energy density, eliminate the use of solvents, vacuum drying, and calendering processes during production, and reduce manufacturing cost for current and future cell designs. Here, lithium iron phosphate and lithium cobalt oxide were used as examples to demonstrate the efficacy of the cold-plasma-coating technique. It is found that the mechanical peel strength of cold-plasma-coating-manufactured lithium iron phosphate is over an order of magnitude higher than that of slurry-casted lithium iron phosphate electrodes. Full cells assembled with a graphite anode and the cold-plasma-coating-lithium iron phosphate cathode offer highly reversible cycling performance with a capacity retention of 81.6% over 500 cycles. For the highly conductive cathode material lithium cobalt oxide, an areal capacity of 4.2 mAh cm -2 at 0.2 C is attained. We anticipate that this new, highly scalable manufacturing technique will redefine global lithium-ion battery manufacturing providing significantly reduced plant footprints and material costs.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Mechanistic Insights into the Surface Instabilities of TiNb 2 O 7, a High‐Power Li‐Ion Anode

TiNb 2 O 7 (TNO) is a promising Li-ion battery anode for high-power applications, such as implantable medical devices and heavy-duty equipment. Hailed as being safe due to its elevated operating potential near 1.6 V, TNO has long been assumed to be highly stable in the carbonate-based electrolytes used in Li-ion batteries. Herein, all mechanisms occurring at the surface of both TNO and Nd-doped TNO are identified, and both materials in fact show significant gassing. CO 2 is even released at open circuit conditions, demonstrating the poor chemical stability of the material in the electrolyte even prior to battery operation. Such extreme instability is a critical safety concern. In addition, it was found that Ti dissolves from the surface of TNO particles at low voltage (below 1.4 V vs Li), and in fact deposits on the counter electrode. Ti further inside TNO particles then diffuses to the Ti-poor surface during discharge. Partial carbon-coating as a mitigating measure has also been tested and found to exacerbate these processes. The findings identify novel reactions occurring within TNO, and clearly highlight the need to stabilize the surfaces of TNO in order to prevent such aggressive deterioration at the surface of the particles.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Towards fast-charging high-energy lithium-ion batteries: From nano- to micro-structuring perspectives

Electric vehicles (EVs) have been playing an indispensable role in reducing greenhouse gas emissions for our modern society. However, current EVs are difficult to meet people’s diverse travel needs, especially in long endurance and fast-charging capacities. At the heart of this issue is the physicochemical limit of current lithium-ion batteries (LIBs), which are the core parts for powering the vehicles. Hence, LIBs with simultaneous high energy and power are critically required to further promote the development of EVs. Here, in this review, we first summarize the key electrochemical processes in electrochemical reactions which lead to the corresponding overpotentials in or between multiple battery components. Furthermore, numerical simulations are employed to quantitatively analyze the effects of versatile electrode parameters on electrochemical properties in high-energy NMC811//graphite systems. On the basis of the in-depth understandings from simulation, recent experimental efforts on designing electroactive materials and electrode architectures across multiple length scales are discussed. Among them, nano-structuring can promote local mass transport and stabilize the interfaces at the particle level, while micro-structuring can establish efficient pathways for charge carriers at the electrode level. Finally, we conclude that a tight feedback loop among structure engineering, characterization and simulation should be followed to speed up the understanding of the deficiencies existing in current electrode designs as well as point out the possible electrode optimization routes for next-generation fast-charging LIBs.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Observation of the surface layer of lithium metal using in situ spectroscopy

In this work, we have investigated the surface of lithium metal using x-ray photoemission spectroscopy and optical spectroscopic ellipsometry. Even if we prepare the surface of lithium metal rigorously by chemical cleaning and mechanical polishing inside a glovebox, both spectroscopic investigations show the existence of a few tens of nanometer-thick surface layers, consisting of lithium oxides and lithium carbonates. When lithium metal is exposed to room air (~50% moisture), in situ real-time monitoring of optical spectra indicates that the surface layer grows at a rate of approximately 24 nm/min, presumably driven by an interface-controlled process. Our results hint that surface-layer-free lithium metals are formidable to achieve by a simple cleaning/polishing method, suggesting that the initial interface between lithium metal electrodes and solid-state electrolytes in fabricated lithium metal batteries can differ from an ideal lithium/electrolyte contact.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Addressing Spacer Channel Resistances in MCDI Using Porous and Pliable Ionic Conductors

Membrane capacitive deionization (MCDI) is a unique electrochemical separations platform that allows for energy recovery during electrode regeneration. Similar to other electrochemical separation technologies producing deionized water (e.g. electrodialysis), ohmic resistances in the spacer channel significantly hampers the performance and energy efficiency of the process. This work devised a series of ionomer coated nylon mesh nets to address spacer channel resistances in MCDI. Under constant current operation, the ionomer coated nylon meshes displayed a 300 mV lower cell voltage rise during deionization while sustaining the same deionization rate. Furthermore, energy recovery was improved by 1.4x to 5.5x depending on the saline feed concentration. The lower cell voltage rise during deionization combined with the greater energy recovery with ionomer coated meshes resulted in energy normalized adsorbed salt (ENAS) values that were 2x to 3x greater. Addressing the spacer channel resistances in MCDI allowed for 8% to 19% increase in current density without the cell voltage exceeding 1.6 V—the upper bound set for mitigating parasitic reactions. Operating at higher current density leads to smaller MCDI units for a given deionization requirement and has implications for reducing the capital costs of the MCDI unit.

Palakkal, Varada Menon (ORCID:0000000317038323)↗
DOE OSTI2022

Electro–Oxidation of Nitroxide Radicals: Adsorption–Mediated Charge Transfer Probed Using SERS and Potentiometry

Organic compounds containing nitroxide radicals such as 4–hydroxy–2,2,6,6–tetramethylpiperidine–1–oxyl (4–hydroxy–TEMPO) are redox–active and are of interest for potential applications in redox flow batteries. The mechanisms governing charge–transfer reactions of such compounds are not well understood. Specifically, the anodic charge transfer coefficient (αa) corresponding to the electro–oxidation of 4–hydroxy–TEMPO in an aqueous medium is ~0.9, i.e., αa deviates considerably from the expected value (0.5) for a symmetric single–step one–electron transfer redox reaction. In a previous publication (J. Electrochem. Soc., 2020, 167, 143505), we have proposed a reaction mechanism to explain such asymmetric behavior by invoking adsorption–desorption processes. In the proposed mechanism, reversible oxidation of 4–hydroxy–TEMPO leads to the adsorption of the oxidation product, which then undergoes slow rate–limiting desorption from the electrode surface. In the present contribution, supporting evidence is provided for this mechanism. In situ surface–enhanced Raman spectroscopy combined with density functional theory simulations are employed to confirm the presence of surface–adsorbed species at a Au electrode during electro–oxidation of 4–hydroxy–TEMPO. Furthermore, we employ chronopotentiometry to track the gradual re–equilibration of the electrode–electrolyte interface following the electro–oxidation of 4–hydroxy–TEMPO. Analysis of the chronopotentiometry data further suggests the presence of adsorbed species, which were previously proposed and are now confirmed by direct spectroscopic evidence.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Li-Ion Battery Electrode Contact Resistance Estimation by Mechanical Peel Test

Li-ion battery electrode electronic properties, including bulk conductivity and contact resistance, are critical parameters affecting cell performance and fast-charge capability. Contact resistance between the coating and current collector is often the largest electronic resistance in an electrode and is affected by chemical, microstructural, and interfacial variations. Direct measurements of contact resistance and bulk conductivity have proven to be challenging. In their absence, a mechanical electrode peel test is often used to compare adhesion and electrical contact resistance. However, using a micro-flexible-surface probe, contact resistance can be directly determined. Here, this work compares contact resistance and mechanical peel strength of multiple commercial-grade HE5050 and NCM523 cathodes and graphite and silicon anodes. It was found that peel strength correlates well with contact resistance in a carefully curated data set (p < 0.05) and in some situations may be a good metric to estimate electrical properties. However, there were distinct outliers in the data set, indicating that peel strength may not accurately reflect electrical properties when there is significant variation in electrode composition. These results illustrate the value of the micro-flexible-surface probe in quantifying contact resistance and bulk conductivity to better understand how battery composition and processing steps affect microstructure and resulting cell performance.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Revealing meso-structure dynamics in additive manufacturing of energy storage via operando coherent X-ray scattering

3D printing is an emerging technology for the fabrication of energy storage devices, offering advantages over traditional manufacturing methods. However, optimization and design of such devices requires an understanding of the meso-structure formation during the 3D printing process. This study utilizes operando coherent X-ray scattering, X-ray Photon Correlation Spectroscopy (XPCS), to study the spatiotemporally-resolved far-from-equilibrium dynamics during direct ink writing 3D printing. Here, Lithium Titanate (LTO) based ink is prepared and rheologically tested for its shear-thinning properties. Two-time intensity-intensity functions are calculated to be used in subsequent quantitative analysis, which allows for an overall characterization of the dynamics, description of an initial fast decorrelation and identification of sudden rearrangements of subdomains of the sample. The results show the dynamics to be anisotropic, spatiotemporally heterogenous and marked by distinct rearrangement events, all of which impact the electrochemical performance of energy storage devices. The studied 3D printing ink is used to fabricate electrodes which are then electrochemically tested, showing good performance in cycling and retaining structural integrity. This work furthers the understanding of the far-from-equilibrium material dynamics during 3D printing, giving quantitative characterization of this process, and highlights aspects of structure formation relevant to the electrochemical performance of the resultant energy storage device.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Anion-Exchange-Membrane Electrolysis with Alkali-Free Water Feed

Hydrogen is a green and sustainable energy vector that can facilitate the large-scale integration of intermittent renewable energy, renewable fuels for heavy transport, and deep decarbonization of hard-to-abate industries. Anion-exchange-membrane water electrolyzers (AEM-WEs) have several achieved or expected competitive advantages over other electrolysis technologies, including the use of precious metal-free electrocatalysts at both electrodes, fluorine-free hydrocarbon-based ionomeric membranes and bipolar plates based on inexpensive materials. Contrasting the analogous proton-exchange-membrane system (PEM-WE), where pure water is circulated (no support electrolyte), the current generation of AEM-WEs necessitates the circulation of a dilute aqueous alkaline electrolyte for reaching high energy efficiency and durability. For several reasons, including but not limited to lower cost of balance-of-plant, lower operating cost and improved device's lifetime, achieving high cell efficiency and performance using an alkali-free water feed is highly desirable. In this review, we develop and build a foundational understanding of AEM-WEs operating with pure water, as well as discuss the effects of operating with natural water feeds like seawater. After a discussion of the possible advantages of pure-water-fed AEM-WEs, we cover the thermodynamic and kinetic processes involved in AEM-WE, followed by a detailed review of materials and components and their integration in the device. We highlight the influence of electrolyte composition and alkali/electrolyte-free feed on the membrane-electrode assembly, ionomers, electrocatalysts, porous transport layer, bipolar plates and operating configuration. We provide evidence for how the pure water feed engenders several issues related to the degradation of device components and propose mitigation strategies.

Electrodes↗
DOE OSTI2023

A Coacervate-Based Mixed-Conducting Binder for High-Power, High-Energy Batteries

Polymer binders add crucial structural integrity to lithium ion battery composite cathodes, but industry standard binders, such as polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF), are insulating to ions and electrons, detrimentally adding resistance to the overall system. In this work, we use electrostatics to stabilize a blend of a charged conjugated polymer with an oppositely charged polyelectrolyte, providing a processable, stable binder with high ionic and electronic conduction. Using LiFePO4 cathodes as a model system, we show significant improvement in rate capability and stability, with the conducting binder enabling a 39% utilization at 6C compared to 1.6% when PVDF is the binder. Additionally, the conducting binder affords a 63% capacity retention over 400 C/2 cycles, compared to only a 6% retention over 400 cycles when PVDF is the binder. These results show that electrostatically stabilized complexation is a promising strategy to integrate both electronic and ionic conductivity into a binder, while simultaneously maintaining stability and processability.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Wake-up and fatigue mechanisms in ferroelectric Hf 0.5 Zr 0.5 O 2 films with symmetric RuO 2 electrodes

In this work, the mechanisms leading to wake-up and fatigue in ferroelectric hafnium zirconium oxide thin film devices with symmetric RuO 2 electrodes are investigated via polarization, relative permittivity, dielectric nonlinearity, pyroelectric coefficient, and microfocus X-ray diffraction (XRD) measurements. The devices are observed to wake-up for up to 10 3 bipolar pulsed field cycles, after which fatigue occurs with the polarization approaching zero following 10 8 cycles. Wake-up is accompanied by a decrease in both high-field permittivity and hysteresis loop pinching and an increase in pyroelectric coefficient, indicating that the wake-up process involves a combination of transformations from the tetragonal to the orthorhombic phase and domain depinning from defect redistribution. Fatigue is observed to coincide with an increase in irreversible domain wall motion and a decrease in pyroelectric coefficient. Finite pyroelectric coefficients are measured on fully fatigued devices, indicating that domain pinning is a strong contributor to fatigue and that fatigued devices contain domain structures that are unable to switch under the fields applied for measurement. Microfocus XRD patterns measured on each device reveal that the phase constitution is qualitatively unaffected by the field cycling and resultant polarization fatigue. This data indicates that the wake-up process has contributions from both phase transformations and domain depinning, whereas the fatigue process is driven primarily by domain pinning, and the near-zero measured switchable polarization is actually a poled device with immobile domains. These observations provide insight into the physical changes occurring during field cycling of HfO 2 -based ferroelectrics while examining a possible oxide electrode material for silicon CMOS device implementation.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2024

Ketjenblack-Supported and Unsupported ZrO 2 –ZrN Nanoparticle Systems for Enabling Efficient Electrochemical Nitrogen Reduction to Ammonia

Artificial N 2 fixation via the electrocatalytic nitrogen (N 2 ) reduction reaction (NRR) has been recently promoted as a rational route toward reducing energy consumption and CO 2 emission as compared with the traditional Haber–Bosch process. Nevertheless, optimizing NRR relies on developing highly efficient electrocatalysts. Herein, we report on the reliable and reproducible synthesis of two promising electrocatalysts in either the presence or absence of Ketjenblack (KB), namely, ZrO 2 –ZrN@KB and ZrO 2 –ZrN systems, synthesized through the nitriding of Zr. Both materials had never previously been considered for NRR, to the best of our knowledge. Nevertheless, both of these electrocatalysts incorporated a combination of tetragonal ZrO 2 , ZrON, and cubic ZrN and showed excellent activity and durability toward NH 3 formation. Moreover, the maximum NH3 production rate of 84.1 μg h –1 mg –1 at -0.7 V vs a reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE) was achieved with the ZrO 2 –ZrN electrocatalyst with an impressive Faradaic efficiency of 21.2% at -0.6 V vs RHE, indicating a high selectivity associated with the NRR. Additionally, the catalysts demonstrated excellent stability during the electrolysis process and recycling tests. Here we postulate that the combination of exposed active sites of ZrN and ZrO 2 likely contributes to the enhanced NRR performance attributed to ZrO 2 –ZrN.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗