Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Comparative Study”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 739 records · Page 41
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS1983

A comparative study of Soviet versus Western helicopters. Part 1: General comparison of designs

This document provides a general comparison of the state of the art of Soviet helicopter design vs. that of the West (U.S. in particular). It includes both commonalities and differences in conceptual design philosophies by addressing design parameters and design effectiveness according to accepted criteria. The baseline for comparison is by design gross weight which is presented in four categories: under 12,000 lb, 30-100,000 lb, and greater than 100,000 lb.

Stepniewski, W. Z.↗
NASA NTRS1982

A comparative study of real-time spaceborne synthetic aperture radar processing techniques

A review of various spaceborne synthetic aperture radar (SAR) processing algorithms and their associated real-time SAR processor architectures is given in this paper. The processing complexity for each real-time SAR processor is presented next. A complexity comparison is then given based on the Seasat SAR parameters. It is shown that the frequency/time domain hybrid fast correlation and the two-stage fast Fourier transform (FET) approaches are the two most cost-effective choices for real-time spaceborne SAR processing. Finally, a discussion on future development trends in real-time spaceborne SAR processing is given.

Liu, K. Y.↗
NASA NTRS1983

A comparative study of the fatty acid composition of prochloron lipids

The chemical analysis of lipids of Prochloron isolated from several hosts is discussed. The object was to determine whether differences in lipid composition could be used to characterize organisms from different sources. Major lipid components are given. An analysis of fatty acid composition of individual lipids slowed a distinctive disstribution of fatty acids. While present results do not justify the use of fatty acid content in the taxonomy of Prochlon, the variations found in the lipids of cells from the same host harvested from different areas, or at different times in the same area, suggest that a study of the effects of temperature and light intensity on lipid composition would be rewarding.

Kenrick, J. R.↗
NASA NTRS1983

A comparative study on synthetic aperture radar and optical imagery of ocean waves

The ocean imaging capability of synthetic aperture radar (SAR) is examined in terms of an intercomparison between simultaneous, spatially collocated images of a coastal ocean scene, as recorded by aerial photography and aircraft-borne SAR. Based on a detailed study of these images, this paper examines various local features of oceanographic interest as they are imaged by the two methods. This provides information not available in the usual comparisons of normalized SAR and single point buoy spectra. In addition, aspects of the intensity wavenumber spectra of the two images are examined and discussed. An interesting and surprising conclusion arising from the comparison study is the ability of the SAR to image accurately non-uniform (possibly nonlinear) wave features which are imaged by the aerial photography. This result should have important implications on the development of SAR imaging models and the interpretation of the effect of ocean surface motion on the SAR images.

Banner, M. L.↗
NASA NTRS1984

Radial gradient of cosmic ray intensity from a comparative study of data from Voyager 1 and 2 and IMP 8

The IMP 8 satellite and Voyager 1 and 2 space probes obtained cosmic ray measurements during the late 1977 to mid-1982 period. Comparisons of 27-day averages of the data show that a positive radial intensity gradient existed on the average during this period, and that the cosmic ray intensity decrease toward solar maximum in 1980-1981 proceeds in a stepwise fashion. The cosmic ray minimum reached in late 1980/early 1981 appears almost simultaneously at 1 AU and at 10 AU, with and without propagation time delay effects, between IMP 8 and the Voyager spacecraft. These data are generally consistent with a heliolatitudinal gradient of 0 + or - 1 percent/deg. Attention is given to the implications of these results in the overall context of cosmic ray modulation theory.

Venkatesan, D.↗
NASA NTRS1984

A comparative study of aerosol extinction measurements made by the SAM II and SAGE satellite experiments

SAM II and SAGE are two satellite experiments designed to measure stratospheric aerosol extinction using the technique of solar occultation or limb extinction. Although each sensor is mounted aboard a different satellite, there are occasions when their measurement locations are nearly coincident, thereby providing opportunities for a measurement comparison. In this paper, the aerosol extinction profiles and daily contour plots for some of these events in 1979 are reported. The comparisons shown in this paper demonstrate that SAM II and SAGE are producing similar aerosol extinction profiles within their measurement errors and that since SAM II has been previously validated, these results show the validity of the SAGE aerosol measurements.

Yue, G. K.↗
NASA NTRS1982

Rapid diagnostic methods for influenza virus in clinical specimens - A comparative study

A comparison of five rapid viral diagnostic techniques for identifying influenza virus in nasopharyngeal aspirates has been made on patients with influenza-like illnesses. Initial results with immune electron microscopy were positive in only one of 11 specimens from which virus was isolated and further work abandoned. Four other rapid tests were carried out on 39 specimens from which influenza virus had been isolated in tissue culture in 28. Of these 28 specimens yielding virus, 24 (85.7 percent) were positive by an indirect fluorescent antibody test (IFAT) on nasopharyngeal cells, 18 (64.3 percent) by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), 19 (67.8 percent) by enzyme-linked fluorescent assay (ELFA), and 26 (92.8 percent) by a rapid tissue culture amplification method (TCA) in a continuous Rhesus monkey kidney line (LLC-MK2) with identification of virus by fluorescent antibody. In terms of sensitivity, simplicity, and rapidity, a combination of the IFAT and TCA methods seems to be very useful.

Evans, A. S.↗
NASA NTRS1985

A comparative study of the nonuniqueness problem of the potential equation

The nonuniqueness problem occurring at transonic speeds with the conservative potential equation is investigated numerically. The study indicates that the problem is not an inviscid phenomenon, but results from approximate treatment of shock waves inherent in the conservative potential model. A new bound on the limit of validity of the conservative potential model is proposed.

Salas, M. D.↗
NASA NTRS1984

A comparative study of distant magnetotail structure at Venus and earth

Spacecraft data on the magnetotails of earth and Venus are discussed with regards to interactions between the two planets and the solar wind. Consideration is given to Pioneer Venus Orbiter plasma analyzer, magnetometer and plasma wave observations around Venus and equivalent ISEE-3 data from the terrestrial region. The discussion is constrained to clear lobe and plasmasheet intervals greater than 5 and 30 min for Venus and earth, respectively. The orientation of the Venusian plasma sheet was normal to that of earth's, while both regions displayed distinct mantle, lobe, plasmasheet boundary layer, and plasmasheet regions. Additionally, the plasmasheet magnetic field distributions in distant regions of the tails exhibited characteristics of disconnection from the planets and a return to the solar wind. The lobe field magnitudes were consistent with the interaction of the planets with the solar wind. It is noted that the Venus plasmasheet is hotter and/or denser than the terrestrial magnetosheath.

Slavin, J. A.↗
NASA NTRS1985

Comparative study of Suits and SAIL canopy reflectance models

A detailed understanding of the relationships between the canopy reflectance and the characteristics of canopy elements is an important factor for the full exploitation of the potential of remote sensing from aircraft and spacecraft altitudes to map vegetation and estimate key agronomic parameters such as the leaf area index (LAI) and biomass (BM). Suits (1972) idealized the canopy geometry by replacing each plant component with three orthogonal projections of that component. Verhoeff and Bunnik (1981) extended the Suits model, henceforth called the SAIL (Scattering from Arbitrarily Inclined Leaves) model, by removing certain constraints. The present investigation is concerned with an evaluation of the performance of the Suits and SAIL models, taking into account two data sets on soybean and corn. It was found that the tested models have significant deficiencies. However, the performance of the SAIL model is better than that of the Suits model because it provides a more realistic description of the canopy architecture.

Badhwar, G. D.↗
NASA NTRS1984

A comparative study of linear and nonlinear MIMO feedback configurations

In this paper, a comparison is conducted of several feedback configurations which have appeared in the literature (e.g. unity-feedback, model-reference, etc.). The linear time-invariant multi-input multi-output case is considered. For each configuration, the stability conditions are specified, the relation between achievable I/O maps and the achievable disturbance-to-output maps is examined, and the effect of various subsystem perturbations on the system performance is studied. In terms of these considerations, it is demonstrated that one of the configurations considered is better than all the others. The results are then extended to the nonlinear multi-input multi-output case.

Desoer, C. A.↗
NASA NTRS1985

A comparative study of tail rotor noise mechanisms

A study was made of helicopter tail rotor noise, particularly that due to interactions with the wakes of the main rotor, hub, and fuselage, and with the engine exhaust. Both harmonic and broadband noise were analyzed. The disturbed flow into the tail rotor was modeled using combinations of aerodynamic and acoustic flow codes along with some necessary estimates of turbulence properties. Representative calculations show that the main rotor wake is the strongest contributor to both harmonic and broadband tail rotor noise. The fuselage separation wake and the engine exhaust flow are also very important to both harmonic and broadband noise. The hub and hub-shaft wakes are important contributors to the broadband noise only. The tip vortices do not seem to be important to broadband noise, but their effects on harmonic noise were not modeled accurately enough to draw any conclusions from this study.

George, A. R.↗
NASA NTRS1987

Comparative study of high-resolution shock-capturing schemes for a real gas

Recently developed second-order explicit shock-capturing methods, in conjunction with generalized flux-vector splittings, and a generalized approximate Riemann solver for a real gas are studied. The comparisons are made on different one-dimensional Riemann (shock-tube) problems for equilibrium air with various ranges of Mach numbers, densities and pressures. Six different Riemann problems are considered. These tests provide a check on the validity of the generalized formulas, since theoretical prediction of their properties appears to be difficult because of the non-analytical form of the state equation. The numerical results in the supersonic and low-hypersonic regimes indicate that these produce good shock-capturing capability and that the shock resolution is only slightly affected by the state equation of equilibrium air. The difference in shock resolution between the various methods varies slightly from one Riemann problem to the other, but the overall accuracy is very similar. For the one-dimensional case, the relative efficiency in terms of operation count for the different methods is within 30%. The main difference between the methods lies in their versatility in being extended to multidimensional problems with efficient implicit solution procedures.

Montagne, J.-L.↗