Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “code comparisons”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 721 records · Page 40
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

NASA Langley FUN3D Analyses in Support of the 1st AIAA Stability and Control Prediction Workshop

This work summarizes the results of FUN3D analyses conducted for the 1st AIAA Stability and Control Workshop on behalf of participants from the NASA Langley Research Center. The workshop was created to establish best practices for the prediction of stability and control derivatives using computational fluid dynamics and assess the limitations of these methods when those best practices are applied. The inaugural workshop considered the ONERA version of the NASA/Boeing Common Research Model, which includes the wing, body, horizontal tail, and a vertical tail designed by ONERA. Wind tunnel data at small sideslip angles remain unpublished and served as ‘blind’ data for computational comparisons. The present research generated workshop test case data using the NASA FUN3D code, which is a parallelized, unstructured, node-based, finite-volume discretization, Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes flow solver. Steady- state numerical simulations were conducted for workshop test cases investigating the following: grid convergence, Mach number effect on static stability, wind tunnel sting increments, static stability-derivative calculations, and a sideslip angle sweep. Results were generated for two series of unstructured, mixed-element grids, one set provided by the workshop and another set created using the HeldenMesh grid generation software. The results provided include total- and component-level breakdowns of the force and moment coefficients, in addition to sectional pressure distributions for the wing and tail components for comparisons to wind tunnel data.

CFD↗
NASA NTRS2011

Rapid Calculation of Spacecraft Trajectories Using Efficient Taylor Series Integration

A variable-order, variable-step Taylor series integration algorithm was implemented in NASA Glenn's SNAP (Spacecraft N-body Analysis Program) code. SNAP is a high-fidelity trajectory propagation program that can propagate the trajectory of a spacecraft about virtually any body in the solar system. The Taylor series algorithm's very high order accuracy and excellent stability properties lead to large reductions in computer time relative to the code's existing 8th order Runge-Kutta scheme. Head-to-head comparison on near-Earth, lunar, Mars, and Europa missions showed that Taylor series integration is 15.8 times faster than Runge- Kutta on average, and is more accurate. These speedups were obtained for calculations involving central body, other body, thrust, and drag forces. Similar speedups have been obtained for calculations that include J2 spherical harmonic for central body gravitation. The algorithm includes a step size selection method that directly calculates the step size and never requires a repeat step. High-order Taylor series integration algorithms have been shown to provide major reductions in computer time over conventional integration methods in numerous scientific applications. The objective here was to directly implement Taylor series integration in an existing trajectory analysis code and demonstrate that large reductions in computer time (order of magnitude) could be achieved while simultaneously maintaining high accuracy. This software greatly accelerates the calculation of spacecraft trajectories. At each time level, the spacecraft position, velocity, and mass are expanded in a high-order Taylor series whose coefficients are obtained through efficient differentiation arithmetic. This makes it possible to take very large time steps at minimal cost, resulting in large savings in computer time. The Taylor series algorithm is implemented primarily through three subroutines: (1) a driver routine that automatically introduces auxiliary variables and sets up initial conditions and integrates; (2) a routine that calculates system reduced derivatives using recurrence relations for quotients and products; and (3) a routine that determines the step size and sums the series. The order of accuracy used in a trajectory calculation is arbitrary and can be set by the user. The algorithm directly calculates the motion of other planetary bodies and does not require ephemeris files (except to start the calculation). The code also runs with Taylor series and Runge-Kutta used interchangeably for different phases of a mission.

Scott, James R.↗
NASA NTRS1987

Comparison of two transonic noise prediction formulations using the aircraft noise prediction program

This paper addresses recently completed work on using Farassat's Formulation 3 noise prediction code with the Aircraft Noise Prediction Program (ANOPP). Software was written to link aerodynamic loading generated by the Propeller Loading (PLD) module within ANOPP with formulation 3. Included are results of comparisons between Formulation 3 with ANOPP's existing noise prediction modules, Subsonic Propeller Noise (SPN) and Transonic Propeller Noise (TPN). Four case studies are investigated. Results of the comparison studies show excellent agreement for the subsonic cases. Differences found in the comparisons made under transonic conditions are strictly numerical and can be explained by the way in which the time derivative is calculated in Formulation 3. Also included is a section on how to execute Formulation 3 with ANOPP.

Spence, Peter L.↗
NASA NTRS1985

Measurement and prediction of model-rotor flow fields

This paper shows that a laser velocimeter can be used to measure accurately the three-component velocities induced by a model rotor at transonic tip speeds. The measurements, which were made at Mach numbers from 0.85 to 0.95 and at zero advance ratio, yielded high-resolution, orthogonal velocity values. The measured velocities were used to check the ability of the ROT22 full-potential rotor code to predict accurately the transonic flow field in the crucial region around and beyond the tip of a high-speed rotor blade. The good agreement between the calculated and measured velocities established the code's ability to predict the off-blade flow field at transonic tip speeds. This supplements previous comparisons in which surface pressures were shown to be well predicted on two different tips at advance ratios to 0.45, especially at the critical 90 deg azimuthal blade position. These results demonstrate that the ROT22 code can be used with confidence to predict the important tip-region flow field, including the occurrence, strength, and location of shock waves causing high drag and noise.

Owen, F. K.↗
NASA NTRS1988

A comparison of the various helicopter mathematical models used in the methodology assessment

Various features of the computer codes used in the helicopter industry and by government agencies for rotorcraft aeroelastic stability analysis are compared. Mathematical rigor in modeling rotorcraft is given primarily to the rotor-system dynamic behavior; the aerodynamic modeling is still limited to strip theory and to uneven application of corrections for stall, reversed flow, yawed flow, radial flow, and unsteady aerodynamic effects. The forward-flight regime analysis is included in five of the 11 codes surveyed. However, only two of these codes are capable of a Floquet analysis for aeroelastic stability. For the hover regime, nine of the 11 codes use eigen-analysis approach. The remaining codes perform a harmonic analysis of the transient response of system.

Stephens, Wendell B.↗
NASA NTRS1995

Comparison of spatial numerical operators for duct-nozzle acoustics

A production Navier-Stokes/Euler CFD code, NASTD, developed for aircraft flowfield analysis has been modified to analyze acoustic fields associated with propulsion exhaust systems. The modified code has been applied to the Category 5 nozzle problem using six different spatial discretization schemes combined with a third-order, compact storage Runge-Kutta time integration. NASTD was found capable of tracking pressure disturbances normalized by the freestream value of order 10(exp -6), even with lower-order schemes, for the benchmark problem.

Cain, A. B.↗
NASA NTRS1978

Analytical prediction of agricultural aircraft wakes

An analytical technique has been developed to understand the formation, interaction, and decay of lift-generated vortices. It is possible, by use of a computer code, to give a complete description of the viscous rollup of individual vortices from a wing. That the interaction of the vortex wake with the ground is a viscous interaction is demonstrated. Comparisons are given of experimental model data and predictions of vortex location for agricultural aircraft. The future of these codes in guiding wind-tunnel and flight research and in providing operational mission guidance is discussed.

Morris, D. J.↗
NASA NTRS1988

A computational study of heat transfer for laminar hypervelocity flows

Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) codes are routinely used to predict the flowfield and the heating environment around complex reentry configurations. At hypervelocities, where the velocity is greater than 3 km/sec, the AFWAL version of the blunt body code predicts the correct surface pressure distributions but underpredicts laminar wall heat fluxes. This study was performed to determine the reasons for the underprediction. The computer code chosen solves thin-layer Navier-Stokes equations in a time-asymptotic manner and assumes a constant isentropic exponent. Flowfields around a spherical configuration at various entry velocities are computed. The computed pressure distributions agree well with the tabulated, inviscid results of Lyubimov and Rusanov for entry velocities ranging from 0.6 to 5.92 km/sec. At hypervelocities, the calculated stagnation point heat transfer rates were lower by roughly fifty percent when compared to engineering correlations available in the literature. Good comparisons between heat transfer rates are obtained at hypervelocity entry conditions provided the CFD code is modified to include equilibrium air properties.

Balakrishnan, A.↗
NASA NTRS1976

Weight comparisons of optimized stiffened, unstiffened, and sandwich cylindrical shells made from composite or aluminum materials

This work presents optimum designs for unstiffened, hat stringer-stiffened and honeycomb sandwich cylinders under axial compression. Optimization results for graphite-epoxy cylinders show about a 50 percent weight savings over corresponding optimized aluminum cylinders for a wide loading range. The inclusion of minimum gage considerations results in a significant weight penalty, especially for a lightly loaded cylinder. Effects of employing a smeared stiffener buckling theory in the optimization program are investigated through comparison of results obtained from a more accurate branched shell buckling computer code. It was found that the stiffener cross-sectional deformations, which are usually ignored in smeared stiffener theory, result in about a 30 percent lower buckling load for the graphite-epoxy hat stiffened cylinder.

Agarwal, B. L.↗
NASA NTRS1977

Bolivian satellite technology program on ERTS natural resources

The author has identified the following significant results. Application of digital classification for mapping land use permitted the separation of units at more specific levels in less time. A correct classification of data in the computer has a positive effect on the accuracy of the final products. Land use unit comparison with types of soils as represented by the colors of the coded map showed a class relation. Soil types in relation to land cover and land use demonstrated that vegetation was a positive factor in soils classification. Groupings of image resolution elements (pixels) permit studies of land use at different levels, thereby forming parameters for the classification of soils.

Brockmann, H. C.↗
NASA NTRS1981

The NASA-LeRC wind turbine sound prediction code

Development of the wind turbine sound prediction code began as part of an effort understand and reduce the noise generated by Mod-1. Tone sound levels predicted with this code are in good agreement with measured data taken in the vicinity Mod-1 wind turbine (less than 2 rotor diameters). Comparison in the far field indicates that propagation effects due to terrain and atmospheric conditions may amplify the actual sound levels by 6 dB. Parametric analysis using the code shows that the predominant contributors to Mod-1 rotor noise are (1) the velocity deficit in the wake of the support tower, (2) the high rotor speed, and (3) off-optimum operation.

Viterna, L. A.↗
NASA NTRS1986

Software Comparison

Software Comparison Package (SCP) compares similar files. Normally, these are 90-character files produced by CDC UPDATE utility from program libraries that contain FORTRAN source code plus identifier. SCP also used to compare load maps, cross-reference outputs, and UPDATE corrections sets. Helps wherever line-by-line comparison of similarly structured files required.

Blanchard, D. C.↗
NASA NTRS1985

Assessment of preliminary prediction techniques for wing leading-edge vortex flows at supersonic speeds

A theoretical investigation of the aerodynamics of sharp leading-edge delta wings at supersonic speeds has been conducted. The primary objective of this was to determine the applicability of existing theoretical methods to predict wing leading-edge separated-flow characteristics at conditions conductive to high-lift supersonic flight. Predicted results from two modified linear-theory methods (LTSTAR and VORCAM) are compared with experimental data. Comparison of the two methods for uncambered wings revealed that the LTSTAR code is in much better agreement with experimentally measured vortex strength, vortex position, and total lifting characteristics than the VORCAM code. Selected analysis was also performed with an Euler code, SWINT. The results of this study indicated that the SWINT code was not well suited to the analysis of wings with separated flow at high lift and low supersonic speeds.

Wood, R. M.↗
NASA NTRS1988

Determination of in-flight AVIRIS spectral, radiometric, spatial and signal-to-noise characteristics using atmospheric and surface measurements from the vicinity of the rare-earth-bearing carbonatite at Mountain Pass, California

An assessment of the Airborne Visible/Infrared Imaging Spectrometer (AVIRIS) performance was made for a flight over Mountain Pass, California, July 30, 1987. The flight data were reduced to reflectance using an empirical algorithm which compensates for solar, atmospheric and instrument factors. AVIRIS data in conjunction with surface and atmospheric measurements acquired concurrently were used to develop an improved spectral calibration. An accurate in-flight radiometric calibration was also performed using the LOWTRAN 7 radiative transfer code together with measured surface reflectance and atmospheric optical depths. A direct comparison with coincident Thematic Mapper imagery of Mountain Pass was used to demonstrate the high spatial resolution and good geometric performance of AVIRIS. The in-flight instrument noise was independently determined with two methods which showed good agreement. A signal-to-noise ratio was calculated using data from a uniform playa. This ratio was scaled to the AVIRIS reference radiance model, which provided a basis for comparison with laboratory and other in-flight signal-to-noise determinations.

Green, Robert O.↗
NASA NTRS1991

Addition of equilibrium air to an upwind Navier-Stokes code and other first steps toward a more generalized flow solver

An upwind three-dimensional volume Navier-Stokes code is modified to facilitate modeling of complex geometries and flow fields represented by proposed National Aerospace Plane concepts. Code enhancements include an equilibrium air model, a generalized equilibrium gas model and several schemes to simplify treatment of complex geometric configurations. The code is also restructured for inclusion of an arbitrary number of independent and dependent variables. This latter capability is intended for eventual use to incorporate nonequilibrium/chemistry gas models, more sophisticated turbulence and transition models, or other physical phenomena which will require inclusion of additional variables and/or governing equations. Comparisons of computed results with experimental data and results obtained using other methods are presented for code validation purposes. Good correlation is obtained for all of the test cases considered, indicating the success of the current effort.

Rosen, Bruce S.↗
NASA NTRS1993

Numerical Modeling of Anti-icing Systems and Comparison to Test Results on a NACA 0012 Airfoil

A series of experimental tests were conducted in the NASA Lewis IRT on an electro-thermally heated NACA 0012 airfoil. Quantitative comparisons between the experimental results and those predicted by a computer simulation code were made to assess the validity of a recently developed anti-icing model. An infrared camera was utilized to scan the instantaneous temperature contours of the skin surface. Despite some experimental difficulties, good agreement between the numerical predictions and the experiment results were generally obtained for the surface temperature and the possibility for each runback to freeze. Some recommendations were given for an efficient operation of a thermal anti-icing system.

Al-Khalil, Kamel M.↗
NASA NTRS1993

Navier-Stokes analysis of airfoils with leading edge ice accretions

A numerical analysis of the flowfield characteristics and the performance degradation of an airfoil with leading edge ice accretions was performed. The important fluid dynamic processes were identified and calculated. Among these were the leading edge separation bubble at low angles of attack, complete separation on the low pressure surface resulting in premature shell, drag rise due to the ice shape, and the effects of angle of attack on the separated flow field. Comparisons to experimental results were conducted to confirm these calculations. A computer code which solves the Navier-Stokes equations in two dimensions, ARC2D, was used to perform the calculations. A Modified Mixing Length turbulence model was developed to produce grids for several ice shape and airfoil combinations. Results indicate that the ability to predict overall performance characteristics, such as lift and drag, at low angles of attack is excellent. Transition location is important for accurately determining separation bubble shape. Details of the flowfield in and downstream of the separated regions requires some modifications. Calculations for the stalled airfoil indicate periodic shedding of vorticity that was generated aft of the ice accretion. Time averaged pressure values produce results which compare favorably with experimental information. A turbulence model which accounts for the history effects in the flow may be justified.

Potapczuk, Mark G.↗
NASA NTRS1993

Numerical modeling of anti-icing systems and comparison to test results on a NACA 0012 airfoil

A series of experimental tests were conducted in the NASA Lewis IRT on an electro-thermally heated NACA 0012 airfoil. Quantitative comparisons between the experimental results and those predicted by a computer simulation code were made to assess the validity of a recently developed anti-icing model. An infrared camera was utilized to scan the instantaneous temperature contours of the skin surface. Despite some experimental difficulties, good agreement between the numerical predictions and the experimental results were generally obtained for the surface temperature and the possibility for the runback to freeze. Some recommendations were given for an efficient operation of a thermal anti-icing system.

Al-Khalil, Kamel M.↗