Long Baseline Neutrino Experiment (LBNE) Target Material Radiation Damage from Energetic Protons of the Brookhaven Linear Isotope Production (BLIP) Facility
In search of a low-Z pion production target for the Long Baseline Neutrino Facility (LBNF) of the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE) various grades of graphite were irradiated with 140-180 MeV protons to fluence up to ~6 10 20 cm -2 and irradiation temperatures in the range of 100-200oC. The objective of the irradiation experiment was to assess the radiation induced changes in the graphite onset by its interaction with energetic protons and deduce some measure of performance and survivability under the design conditions of LBNF. A multi-faceted post-irradiation evaluation was conducted to both qualify and quantify the induced material property changes. These studies included dimensional stability and thermal expansion, damage annealing via thermal cycling, high temperature post-irradiation annealing to mimic irradiation at elevated temperatures, stress-strain behavior, oxidation contribution to the postirradiation analysis, potential influence of the argon atmosphere under which irradiation took place, and lattice evolution. Dilatometry-based techniques were coupled with ultrasound-based annealing methodologies as well as DSC and TGA analyses. X-ray diffraction experiments assessed the lattice parameter changes and SEM analyses were used to study the different graphite grade structures. The multi-faceted post-irradiation evaluation, in conjunction with off-beam analyses, revealed some important facts regarding the choice of a graphite grade. Specifically, it was observed that the microstructure of a grade plays an important role in its dimensional stability. X-ray diffraction data indicated variability in basal plane spacing prior to irradiation with POCO d 002 =3.3833 Å, IG-430 d 002 =3.36814 Å and R7650 d 002 =3.37944 Å. Isotropic graphite grades such as POCO and IG-430 are confirmed to undergo microstructural shrinking under irradiation. All four irradiated graphite grades experience irradiation-induced creep leading to increased Young’s modulus with changes as high as 50% that varies with microstructure. X-ray diffraction on irradiated graphite confirmed previously made observations where under both energetic protons as well as fast neutrons of fluence > 5 10 20 cm -2 and at temperatures around 200°C acceleration of the effects on both the micro-and macrostructure is observed. Amongst the irradiated grades POCO graphite showed tendency to increase crystallinity order but also shows turbostratic state resulting from the interaction of its lattice with protons. This report presents and discusses the details of the irradiation experiment and the results of the postirradiation evaluation with main objective the assessment of the applicability and survivability of the selected four graphite grades as high-power accelerators pion production targets where the structural integrity, density reduction, dimensional and physical property stability are of paramount importance.