Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Burn control”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 721 records · Page 40

In-flight rescue of stranded TDRS-1 spacecraft

On April 4, 1983, the first Tracking and Data Relay Satellite (TDRS-1), one of six to be built for SPACECOM and NASA, was launched by the Space Shuttle Challenger. During the ascent to geosynchronous orbit, the Inertial Upper Stage (IUS) booster malfunctioned, leaving TDRS stranded in a low, elliptical orbit. This report describes the amazing satellite recovery from a wild tumble and the dramatic three-month rescue effort to move TDRS into synchronous orbit. It took a total burn time of 44 hours from a pair of tiny one-pound thrusters, about 800 pounds of propellant, an adaptable, robust attitude control system and much resourcefulness from ground operators to accomplish this feat. TDRS-1 reached its proper earth orbit on June 29, 1983 and then began its ten-year mission as a data relay satellite.

Schmeichel, H.↗

Optical Detection Of Flameout In A Combustor

Fuel supply shut down in time to prevent explosion. Optical flameout detector designed to signal control system of facility to cut off supply of fuel into combustion chamber if flame goes out. Combustor which optical flameout detector designed burns methane in air to provide hot gases for 8-ft high-temperature test chamber. Acoustical flameout detector for same combustor described in "Acoustical Detection of Flameout in Combustor" (LAR-14900). Fiber optic probes mounted to fuel-spray bar upstream of flame. No focusing optics used, and probes aimed across flow of gases at spot on combustion chamber wall downstream from spray bar. Arrangement enables flameout detection system to respond quickly to potential loss of flame since it detects movement of flame front away from spray bar face. Overall response time of detection system under 10 milliseconds.

Borg, Stephen E.↗

Emissions Overview

The Emissions Reduction Project is working in close partnership with the U.S. aircraft engine manufacturers and academia to develop technologies to reduce NO, emissions by 70 percent over the LTO cycle from 1996 ICAO standards with no increase in other emission constituents (carbon monoxide, smoke, and unburned hydrocarbons) and with comparable NO, reduction during cruise operations. These technologies cannot impact the overall combustor and fuel delivery system operability, affordability or maintainability. These new combustion concepts and technologies will include lean burning combustors with higher operating gas temperatures and pressures, fuel staging, ceramic matrix composite material liners with reduced cooling air and possibly advanced controls. Improved physics-based analysis tool will be developed and validated and some longer term technologies that are more revolutionary will be assessed. These improved computational codes will provide improved design tools to increase design confidence and cut the development time to achieve major reductions in NO, emissions. Longer term, revolutionary technologies like active combustion controls, combustion from a large array of micro-injectors, electrostatic fuel injectors, fuel additives and others will be investigated and assessed through proof-of-concept testing.

Rohde, John↗

Fuel Cycle Performance of Thermal Spectrum Small Modular Reactors

Small modular reactors may offer potential benefits, such as enhanced operational flexibility. However, it is vital to understand the holistic impact of small modular reactors on the nuclear fuel cycle and fuel cycle performance. The focus of this paper is on the fuel cycle impacts of light water small modular reactors in a once-through fuel cycle with low-enriched uranium fuel. A key objective of this paper is to describe preliminary reactor core physics and fuel cycle analyses conducted in support of the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy Fuel Cycle Options Campaign. Challenges with small modular reactors include: increased neutron leakage, fewer assemblies in the core (and therefore fewer degrees of freedom in the core design), complex enrichment and burnable absorber loadings, full power operation with inserted control rods, the potential for frequent load-following operation, and shortened core height. Each of these will impact the achievable discharge burn-up in the reactor and the fuel cycle performance. This paper summarizes the results of an expert elicitation focused on developing a list of the factors relevant to small modular reactor fuel, core, and operation that will impact fuel cycle performance. Preliminary scoping analyses were performed using a regulatory-grade reactor core simulator. The hypothetical light water small modular reactor considered in these preliminary scoping studies is a cartridge type one-batch core with 4.9% enrichment. Some core parameters, such as the size of the reactor and general assembly layout, are similar to an example small modular reactor concept from industry. The high-level issues identified and preliminary scoping calculations in this paper are intended to inform on potential fuel cycle impacts of one-batch thermal spectrum SMRs. In particular, this paper highlights the impact of increased neutron leakage and reduced number of batches on the achievable burn-up of the reactor. Fuel cycle performance metrics for a small modular reactor are compared to a conventional three-batch light water reactor in the following areas: nuclear waste management, environmental impact, and resource utilization. Metrics performance for a small modular reactor are degraded for mass of spent nuclear fuel and high level waste disposed, mass of depleted uranium disposed, land use per energy generated, and carbon emission per energy generated

Worrall, Andrew↗

Pre-conceptual design study of ASTRID core

In the framework of the ASTRID project at CEA, core design studies are performed at CEA with the AREVA and EDF support. At the stage of the project, pre-conceptual design studies are conducted in accordance with GEN IV reactors criteria, in particularly for safety improvements. An improved safety for a sodium cooled reactor requires revisiting many aspects of the design and is a rather lengthy process in current design approach. Two types of cores are under evaluation, one classical derived from the SFR V2B and one more challenging called CFV (low void effect core) with a large gain on the sodium void effect. The SFR V2b core have the following specifications: a very low burn-up reactivity swing (due to a small cycle reactivity loss) and a reduced sodium void effect with regard to past designs such as the EFR (around 2$ minus). Its performances are an average burn-up of 100 GWd/t, and an internal conversion ratio equal to one given a very good behavior of this core during a control rod withdrawal transient). The CFV with its specific design offers a negative sodium void worth while maintaining core performances. In accordance of ASTRID needs for demonstration those cores are 1500 MWth power (600 MWe). This paper will focus on the CFV pre-conceptual design of the core and S/A, and the performances in terms of safety will be evaluated on different transient scenario like ULOF, in order to assess its intrinsic behavior compared to a more classical design like V2B core. The gap in term of margin to a severe accident due to a loss of flow initiator underlines the potential capability of this type of core to enhance prevention of severe accident in accordance to safety demonstration. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Wide Area Security Region Final Report

This report develops innovative and efficient methodologies and practical procedures to determine the wide-area security region of a power system, which take into consideration all types of system constraints including thermal, voltage, voltage stability, transient and potentially oscillatory stability limits in the system. The approach expands the idea of transmission system nomograms to a multidimensional case, involving multiple system limits and parameters such as transmission path constraints, zonal generation or load, etc., considered concurrently. The security region boundary is represented using its piecewise approximation with the help of linear inequalities (so called hyperplanes) in a multi-dimensional space, consisting of system parameters that are critical for security analyses. The goal of this approximation is to find a minimum set of hyperplanes that describe the boundary with a given accuracy. Methodologies are also developed to use the security hyperplanes, pre-calculated offline, to determine system security margins in real-time system operations, to identify weak elements in the system, and to calculate key contributing factors and sensitivities to determine the best system controls in real time and to assist in developing remedial actions and transmission system enhancements offline . A prototype program that automates the simulation procedures used to build the set of security hyperplanes has also been developed. The program makes it convenient to update the set of security hyperplanes necessitated by changes in system configurations. A prototype operational tool that uses the security hyperplanes to assess security margins and to calculate optimal control directions in real time has been built to demonstrate the project success. Numerical simulations have been conducted using the full-size Western Electricity Coordinating Council (WECC) system model, and they clearly demonstrated the feasibility and the effectiveness of the developed technology. Recommendations for the future work have also been formulated.

24 POWER TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION↗

Additive Manufacturing of Research Reactor Control Elements and Subsequent Neutron Irradiation

Additive manufacturing techniques have made major strides in recent years and are now capable of creating complex components in near-final form. The nuclear industry has many applications with complicated and even unique components that are time consuming, expensive, and more difficult to make using traditional fabrication routes. Modern fabrication techniques possess the potential to reduce fabrication lead-time and costs while increasing quality and efficiency. However, these methods have not been adopted due to the need for strict validation for nuclear applications. Unlike structural components that largely consist of a uniform material, for nuclear reactor core components incorporation of fissile or neutron poison materials inside a cladding becomes necessary. This in turn requires a more complex and flexible manufacturing method to produce these hybrid components. In this study, demonstration of ultrasonic additive manufacturing (UAM) process to produce components resembling research reactor control elements was carried out]. Specifically, the control elements for ORNL's High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) were targeted. These control elements (consisting of an inner cylinder and four outer plates) are placed on the periphery of the circular HFIR core. The control elements consist of Al6061-T6 alloy with a 13-cm-long grey and a 56-cm-long black region, corresponding to 40 wt% of Ta and 30 wt% Eu{sub 2}O{sub 3} (europia) are incorporated along their length. In this study various fabrication parameters for production of aluminum blocks with and without embedded Eu{sub 2}O{sub 3} and Ta bearing compacts were explored. Select optimized specimens we then irradiated inside HFIR for one reactor cycle. The UAM process exploits ultrasonic energy to facilitate solid-state welding of metal foils in contact under pressure. This additive process is carried out in successive layers to build up the material and when coupled with CNC milling, it yields complex 3D components. The milling and subsequent additive steps may be used to embed foreign material into the material undergoing buildup. In this manner fissile or neutron poison elements may be incorporated into the complex structure, though in an inhomogeneous fashion. Multiple Al-6061 blocks were produced by UAM using 25 mm wide by 0.15 mm thick Al-6061-H18 tapes. The mechanical properties of these blocks in the as-fabricated condition was characterized in detail and it was shown that a great degree of anisotropy in the mechanical behavior exists between the direction in the tape plane and the direction perpendicular to the tapes (buildup direction) The latter exhibited reduced modulus and significantly smaller strength. Post production heat treatment appeared to greatly enhance the strength in the buildup direction. Multiple tensile specimens machined per SS-J3 geometry were prepared for irradiation testing. The tensile specimen matrix was set up to enable post irradiation examination of mechanical properties in various directions as well as after heat treatment. A small block with embedded Ta- and Eu{sub 2}O{sub 3}-bearing compacts, three of each kind, was also produced, as demonstrated previously. These compacts were 5.7 mm in diameter and 1.6 mm in height and contained 60 vol Ta or Eu{sub 2}O{sub 3}. The poison-bearing Al-6061 block alongside the tensile bars was loaded into a perforated rabbit (irradiation capsule) for irradiation in HFTK. The perforated rabbit allows penetration of HFIR water coolant into the Interior of the capsule in direct contact with the test specimens. The rabbit was loaded into the flux trap region at the uppermost position in the core. Irradiation temperature was 68 deg. C and fast neutron (E>0.1 MeV) fluence was 10{sup 25} neutrons/m{sup 2}. Currently PIE activities are ongoing that are focused on mechanical testing of irradiated tensile bars and metallographic examination of neutron poison bearing block.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Use of spectral shift to greatly improve uranium utilisation in FHR designs

Fluoride-salt-cooled high-temperature reactors (FHRs) are thermal-spectrum nuclear reactors defined by their use of liquid-fluoride-salt coolants, together with tri-isotropic (TRISO)-coated particle fuels and graphite moderator materials (Forsberg, 2004). FHRs are also characterized by their improved thermodynamic efficiency relative to gas-cooled reactors. The liquid salt coolant is designed to operate with high core outlet temperature and nearly atmosphere pressure. These features allow the FHR to possess higher core power density compared to gas-cooled TRISO-based systems. However, industry fabrication limitations result in a low volumetric fraction of fuel kernel in TRISO particles. In order to obtain reasonable operation periods, the enrichment needs to be in the high LEU (low enriched uranium) range as was proposed in the original design (Greene, 2010). Recent studies (Ilas, 2014) presented newly repurposed SmAHTR-CTC reactor concept that relies on prior experience obtained from the 2010 initial SmAHTR design (Greene, 2010). This design consists of 19 hexagonal fuel assemblies arranged in a 3-ring hexagonal geometry with 18 fuel plates each. The active length of fuel plates in each fuel assembly is 4 meters. The proposed SmAHTR-CTC achieves substantial improvements from the neutronic performance standpoint over the original concept. The results indicate that a fuel cycle length of over two years with discharged fuel burnup of 40 gigawatt-day per metric ton of initial heavy metal (HM) is possible with an 8% fuel enrichment in a once-through fuel cycle. However, the lower uranium enrichment loading requires a more frequent refueling strategy and hence considerably reduces the cycle length. It is necessary to achieve reasonable cycle length values but at the same time to extend the residence time of the fuel, especially since the costs associated with TRISO-fuel are substantially higher (Shropshire et al., 2008) than traditional UO{sub 2} fuel ($10,000/kg for TRISO vs $200/kg for UO{sub 2}). This paper presents an approach to extend the operational time and improve fuel utilization of FHR by means of spectral shift control. This is achieved by incorporating movable graphite structures into the design, instead of the static graphite blocks presently envisaged. At beginning of life (BOL), the graphite structures are withdrawn. The reactor is under-moderated, with excess neutrons being primarily captured in {sup 238}U, breeding {sup 239}Pu. Towards the end of life (EOL), the graphite structures are inserted, thermalizing the neutron spectrum and increasing reactivity. The extra {sup 239}Pu bred during the cycle is then burned, allowing the cycle and discharge burnup to be extended. Such movable structures regime should be feasible from an engineering point of view, given that it is broadly equivalent to inserting and withdrawing control rods. The preliminary results indicate that such a design may considerably improve the fuel utilization.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

System Study: Technology Assessment and Prioritizing Update

For the Intelligent Engine System (Propulsion 21) study, each technology was evaluated to determine the impact to fuel burn, acoustics, and NOx emissions. The optimum combination of technologies and their overall benefits to the system were also evaluated, resulting in noise improvement potential of 1.89 EPNdB cumulative margin,-1.34 percent fuel burn, and 50 percent NOx reduction from the 2015 UEET-QAT baseline. All the technology evaluations, except T18-20D, were based on newengines, where the engine was resized to obtain the maximum system benefit while maintaining the same cycle parameters as the 2015 UEET-QAT baseline. The impact of turbine clearance control on deteriorated engines, T18-20D, was also evaluated. Recommendations for future system study work include, but were not limited to, validation of a university-developed engine deterioration model and customer value analysis as figures of merit beside fuel burn, emissions, and acoustics.

Source record↗

Applied & Computational MathematicsChallenges for the Design and Control of Dynamic Energy Systems

The Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 (EISA) was passed with the goal 'to move the United States toward greater energy independence and security.' Energy security and independence cannot be achieved unless the United States addresses the issue of energy consumption in the building sector and significantly reduces energy consumption in buildings. Commercial and residential buildings account for approximately 40% of the U.S. energy consumption and emit 50% of CO{sub 2} emissions in the U.S. which is more than twice the total energy consumption of the entire U.S. automobile and light truck fleet. A 50%-80% improvement in building energy efficiency in both new construction and in retrofitting existing buildings could significantly reduce U.S. energy consumption and mitigate climate change. Reaching these aggressive building efficiency goals will not happen without significant Federal investments in areas of computational and mathematical sciences. Applied and computational mathematics are required to enable the development of algorithms and tools to design, control and optimize energy efficient buildings. The challenge has been issued by the U.S. Secretary of Energy, Dr. Steven Chu (emphasis added): 'We need to do more transformational research at DOE including computer design tools for commercial and residential buildings that enable reductions in energy consumption of up to 80 percent with investments that will pay for themselves in less than 10 years.' On July 8-9, 2010 a team of technical experts from industry, government and academia were assembled in Arlington, Virginia to identify the challenges associated with developing and deploying newcomputational methodologies and tools thatwill address building energy efficiency. These experts concluded that investments in fundamental applied and computational mathematics will be required to build enabling technology that can be used to realize the target of 80% reductions in energy consumption. In addition the finding was that there are tools and technologies that can be assembled and deployed in the short term - the next 3-5 years - that can be used to significantly reduce the cost and time effective delivery of moderate energy savings in the U.S. building stock. Simulation tools, which are a core strength of current DOE computational research programs, provide only a part of the answer by providing a basis for simulation enabled design. New investments will be required within a broad dynamics and control research agenda which must focus on dynamics, control, optimization and simulation of multi-scale energy systems during design and operation. U.S. investments in high performance and high productivity computing (HP2C) should be leveraged and coupled with advances in dynamics and control to impact both the existing building stock through retrofits and also new construction. The essential R&D areas requiring investment are: (1) Characterizing the Dynamics of Multi-scale Energy Systems; (2) Control and Optimization Methodologies of Multi-scale Energy Systems Under Uncertainty; and (3) Multiscale Modeling and Simulation Enabled Design and Operation. The concept of using design and control specific computational tools is a new idea for the building industry. The potential payoffs in terms of accelerated design cycle times, performance optimization and optimal supervisory control to obtain and maintain energy savings are huge. Recent advances in computational power, computer science, and mathematical algorithms offer the foundations to address the control problems presented by the complex dynamics of whole building systems. The key areas for focus and associated metrics with targets for establishing competitiveness in energy efficient building design and operation are: (1) Scalability - Current methodology and tools can provide design guidance for very low energy buildings in weeks to months; what is needed is hours to days. A 50X improvement is needed. (2) Installation and commissioning - Current methodology and tools can target a three month window for commissioning of building subsystems; what is needed is one week. A 10X improvement is needed. (3) Quality - Current design tools can achieve 30% accuracy; what is needed to make design decisions is 5% with quantification of uncertainty. A 5X improvement is needed. These challenges cannot be overcome by raw computational power alone and require the development of new algorithms. Here algorithms mean much more than simulating the building physics but need to be inclusive of a much better understanding of the building and the control systems associated with the building and to capture the entire set of dynamics. The algorithmsmust represent computationally new mathematical approaches to modeling, simulation, optimization and control of large multi-scale dynamic systems and bringing these elements to bear on industry in simulation enabled design approaches.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Propulsion system tests on a full scale Centaur vehicle to investigate 3-burn mission capability of the D-lT configuration

Propulsion system tests were conducted on a full scale Centaur vehicle to investigate system capability of the proposed D-lT configuration for a three-burn mission. This particular mission profile requires that the engines be capable of restarting and firing for a final maneuver after a 5-1/2-hour coast to synchronous orbit. The thermal conditioning requirements of the engine and propellant feed system components for engine start under these conditions were investigated. Performance data were also obtained on the D-lT type computer controlled propellant tank pressurization system. The test results demonstrated that the RL-10 engines on the Centaur vehicle could be started and run reliably after being thermally conditioned to predicted engine start conditions for a one, two and three burn mission. Investigation of the thermal margins also indicated that engine starts could be accomplished at the maximum predicted component temperature conditions with prestart durations less than planned for flight.

Groesbeck, W. A.↗

On the Red Antenna States of Photosystem I Mutants from Cyanobacteria Synechocystis PCC 6803

To identify the molecular composition of the low-energy states in cyanobacterial Photosystem I (PSI) of Synechocystis PCC6803, we focus on high resolution (low-temperature) absorption, emission, resonant, and nonresonant hole burned spectra obtained for wild-type (WT) PSI and three PSI mutants. In the Red_a mutant, the B33 chlorophyll (Chl) is added to the B31-B32 dimer; in Red_b, histidine 95 (His95) on PsaB (which coordinates Mg in the B7 Chl within the His95-B7-A31-A32- cluster) is replaced with glutamine (Gln), while in the Red_ab mutant, both mutations are made. We show that the C706 state (B31-B32) changes to the C710 state (B31-B32-B33) in both Red_a and Red_ab mutants, while the C707 state in WT Synechocystis (localized on the His95-B7-A31-A32 cluster) is modified to C716 in both Red_b and Red_ab. Excitation energy transfer from C706 to the C714 trap in the WT PSI and Red_b mutant is hampered as reflected by a weak emission at 712 nm. Large electron-phonon coupling strength (exposed via resonant hole-burned spectra) is consistent with a strong mixing of excited states with intermolecular charge transfer states leading to significantly red-shifted emission spectra. We conclude that excitation energy transfer in PSI is controlled by fine-tuning the electronic states of a small number of highly conserved red states. Finally, we show that mutations modify the protein potential energy landscape as revealed by different shapes and shifts of the blue- and red-shifted antiholes.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

JSC Materials Laboratory Reproduction and Failure Analysis of Cracked Orbiter Reaction Control System Niobium Thruster Injectors

In April 2004 a Space Shuttle Orbiter Reaction Control System (RCS) thruster was found to be cracked while undergoing a nozzle (niobium/C103 alloy) retrofit. As a failure resulting from an in-flight RCS thruster burn-through (initiated from a crack) could be catastrophic, an official Space Shuttle Program flight constraint was issued until flight safety could be adequately demonstrated. This paper describes the laboratory test program which was undertaken to reproduce the cracking in order to fully understand and bound the driving environments. The associated rationale developed to justify continued safe flight of the Orbiter RCS system is also described. The laboratory testing successfully reproduced the niobium cracking, and established specific bounding conditions necessary to cause cracking in the C103 thruster injectors. Each of the following conditions is necessary in combination together: 1) a mechanically disturbed / cold-worked free surface, 2) an externally applied sustained tensile stress near yield strength, 3) presence of fluorine-containing fluids on exposed tensile / cold-worked free surfaces, and 4) sustained exposure to temperatures greater than 400 F. As a result of this work, it was concluded that fluorine-containing materials (e.g. HF acid, Krytox , Brayco etc.) should be carefully controlled or altogether eliminated during processing of niobium and its alloys.

Castner, Willard L.↗

Narrow-band erbium-doped fibre linear–ring laser

We have demonstrated a narrow-band linear – ring fibre laser with an output power of 15 mW at a wavelength of 1.55 μm and an emission bandwidth less than 5 kHz. The laser frequency is stabilised by an unpumped active fibre section and fibre Bragg grating. The fibre laser operates in a travelling wave mode, which allows the spatial hole burning effect to be avoided. At a certain pump power level, the laser switches from continuous mode to repetitivepulse operation, corresponding to relaxation oscillations. (control of laser radiation parameters)

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Auxiliary engine digital interface unit (DIU)

This auxiliary propulsion engine digital unit controls both the valving of the fuel and oxidizer to the engine combustion chamber and the ignition spark required for timely and efficient engine burns. In addition to this basic function, the unit is designed to manage it's own redundancy such that it is still operational after two hard circuit failures. It communicates to the data bus system several selected information points relating to the operational status of the electronics as well as the engine fuel and burning processes.

Source record↗

The hydrogen sulfide emissions abatement program at the Geysers Geothermal Power Plant

The scope of the hydrogen sulfide (H2S) abatement program at The Geysers Geothermal Power Plant and the measures currently under way to reduce these emissions are discussed. The Geysers steam averages 223 ppm H2S by weight and after passing through the turbines leaves the plant both through the gas ejector system and by air-stripping in the cooling towers. The sulfide dissolved in the cooling water is controlled by the use of an oxidation catalyst such as an iron salt. The H2S in the low Btu ejector off gases may be burned to sulfur dioxide and scrubbed directly into the circulating water and reinjected into the steam field with the excess condensate. Details are included concerning the disposal of the impure sulfur, design requirements for retrofitting existing plants and modified plant operating procedures. Discussion of future research aimed at improving the H2S abatement system is also included.

Allen, G. W.↗

A state-trajectory control law for dc-to-dc converters

Mathematical representations of a state-plane switching boundary employed in a state-trajectory control law for dc-to-dc converters are derived. Several levels of approximation to the switching boundary equations are presented, together with an evaluation of the effects of nonideal operating characteristics of converter power stage components on the shape and location of the boundary and the behavior of a system controlled by it. Digital computer simulations of dc-to-dc converters operating in conjunction with each of these levels of control are presented and evaluated with respect to changes in transient and steady-state performance.

Burns, W. W., III↗

Analytic derivation and evaluation of a state-trajectory control law for dc-to-dc converters

Mathematical representations of a state-plane switching boundary employed in a state-trajectory control law for dc-to-dc converters are derived. Several levels of approximation to the switching boundary equations are presented, together with an evaluation of the effects of nonideal operating characteristics of converter power stage components on the shape and location of the boundary and the behavior of a system controlled by it. Digital computer simulations of dc-to-dc converters operating in conjunction with each of these levels of control are presented and evaluated with respect to changes in transient and steady-state performance.

Burns, W. W., III↗