Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “graphite electrode active material”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

71 records · Page 4
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

Operando FTIR investigation of salt dynamics in Li-ion batteries during fast charging

Li-ion batteries, when charged at fast-charging rates ($>$2C), suffer from reduced lifetimes and can undergo catastrophic failure. During high-rate charging, Li-ions are unable to rapidly transport through high-loading electrodes ($>$4 mAh cm −2 ). This results in unequal charge distributions, potentials, and utilization of the active material, which can lead to Li plating. Li-ion concentration polarization, in which Li-ions deplete in the anode and accumulate in the cathode during charging, precedes Li plating. An operando FTIR-ATR graphite/NMC cell developed in this research captured Li-ion concentration polarization in real-time. During fast charging, decreases in Li-ion concentration ($>$95%) were measured at the back of the anode. This is the first verification of complete Li-ion depletion within the anode at high C-rates. The measurements also showed graphite stage transition. A P2D model was developed for comparison to the operando measurements. The measurements agreed with the model in some cases, but disparities existed at high C-rates and loadings. In the experiment, the Li-ion concentration often failed to recover to 1.2 M until several hours after charging, whereas the model Li-ion concentration rapidly recovered. The contrast between the model and experiment results indicates that further investigation is required to improve understanding of Li-ion concentration dynamics during fast charging.

25 - ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Organic Solvent Free Process to Fabricate High Performance Silicon/Graphite Composite Anode

Cycling stability is a key challenge for application of silicon (Si)-based composite anodes as the severe volume fluctuation of Si readily leads to fast capacity fading. The binder is a crucial component of the composite electrodes. Although only occupying a small amount of the total composite mass, the binder has major impact on the long-term electrochemical performance of Si-based anodes. In recent years, water-based binders including styrene-butadiene rubber (SBR) and carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) have attracted wide research interest as eco-friendly and low-cost alternatives for the conventional poly(vinylidene difluoride) (PVDF) binder in Si anodes. In this study, Si-based composite anodes are fabricated by simple solid mixing of the active materials with subsequent addition of SBR and CMC binders. This approach bypasses the use of toxic and expansive organic solvents. The factors of binder, silicon, and graphite materials have been systematically investigated. It is found that the retained capacities of the anodes are more than 440 mAh/g after 400 cycles. These results indicate that organic solvent free process is a facile strategy for producing high performance silicon/graphite composite anodes.

Fang, Chen (ORCID:0000000321011991)↗
DOE OSTI2023

Pitch Carbon-coated Ultrasmall Si Nanoparticle Lithium-ion Battery Anodes Exhibiting Reduced Reactivity with Carbonate-based Electrolyte

Silicon anodes for lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) have the potential for higher energy density compared to conventionally used graphite-based LIB anodes. However, silicon anodes exhibit poor cycle and calendar lifetimes due to mechanical instabilities and high chemical and electrochemical reactivity with the carbonate-based electrolytes that are typically used in LIBs. In this work, we synthesize a pitch carbon-coated silicon nanoparticle composite active material for LIB anodes that exhibits reduced chemical reactivity with carbonate-based electrolytes compared to an uncoated silicon anode. Silicon primary particle sizes less than 10 nm diameter minimize micro-scale mechanical degradation of the anode composite, while conformal coatings of pitch carbon minimize the parasitic reactions between the silicon and the electrolyte. When matched with a high voltage NMC622 (LiNi 0.6 Mn 0.2 Co 0.2 O 2 ) cathode, the pitch carbon-coated silicon anode retains approximately 75% of its initial capacity at the end of 1000 cycles. Increasing the areal loading of the pitch carbon-coated silicon anodes to realize energy density improvements over graphite anodes results in severe mechanical degradation on the electrode level, highlighting a remaining challenge to be addressed in future work.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

The Quest for Stable Potassium‐Ion Battery Chemistry

Abstract Potassium‐ion batteries (KIBs) have attracted wide interest for energy storage because of the abundance of the electrode materials involved; however, their electrochemical performances are far behind what can be achieved from lithium‐ion batteries (LIBs) or sodium‐ion batteries (SIBs). Herein, key promising electrode and electrolyte materials for potassium‐ion batteries are identified, the coupled electrochemical reactions in the cell are investigated, and the compatibility between different materials is demonstrated to play the most important role. K 2 Mn[Fe(CN) 6 ] cathode can deliver a high capacity of ≈125 mAh g −1 and exceptional cycling stability over 61 000 cycles (≈9 months) if the side reactions from the anode can be prevented. Graphite is a good anode material but is subjected to degradation in traditional carbonate electrolytes. New concentrated electrolytes are developed and evaluated. A stable KIB system is demonstrated by coupling a stable K 2 Mn[Fe(CN) 6 ] cathode, a prepotassiated graphite anode with a concentrated electrolyte to achieve a high energy density of ≈260 Wh kg −1 (based on the active mass of cathode and anode) and good cycling of over 1000 cycles.

Wu, Xianyong↗
DOE OSTI2020

Boosting the sodium storage behaviors of carbon materials in ether-based electrolyte through the artificial manipulation of microstructure

The porous carbon blacks rationally designed by a facile yet efficient NH 3 thermal etching route have been investigated as anode materials in an ether-based electrolyte for sodium-ion batteries. The as-synthesized CBN35 carbon black with a 35% weight loss after NH3 thermal etching exhibited a large specific charge capacity of 352 mAh g -1 at 50 mA g -1 and a superior rate capability of 101 mAh g -1 at 16000 mA g -1 , due to its highest microporosity, an appropriate surface area, a desirable microstructure, and a promising hybrid intercalation mechanism. Impressively, even cycled at 1600 mA g -1 over 3200 cycles, an outstanding reversible capacity of 103 mAh g -1 with a negligible 0.0162% capacity loss per cycle can still be achieved. Based on the multimodal characterizations including the structural probes of phase evolution for carbon materials, the electrochemical techniques, and the surface-sensitive XAS measurements, the exceptional electrochemical properties should stem from several merits of modified carbon black system. While the particular microporous structure provides relatively more accessible sodium storage sites, a novel hybrid intercalation mechanism in ether-based electrolyte would incorporate the sodium ion insertion into the disordered structure with the solvated sodium ion species co-intercalation into the graphitic phase. In addition to the diffusion-controlled redox reactions, the noticeable surface-induced pseudocapacitive reactions also significantly contribute to the charge storage upon sodiation and guarantee the rapid migrations of sodium ions/solvated compounds. In conclusion, this system further features a controlled emergence of a robust but thin solid electrolyte interphase layer, which could suppress the side reactions of active electrode with reactive electrolyte, maintain the fragile porous structure upon cycling, and facilitate the migrations of sodium ions and solvated sodium ion compounds.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Old Woman Creek Wetland Sediment and Electrochemical Sensor Microbial Community, 2023

We are developing a technique to monitor microbiological activities referred to as zero resistance ammetry, which entails the deployment of graphite electrodes in sediments. Measurement of current between electrodes of contrasting redox regimes and/or predominant terminal electron accepting processes can be used as an indicator of the extents of microbiological activity. We deployed an electrode array at depths of 2 mm, 4 mm, 76 mm, 78 mm, 152 mm, 154 mm, 227 mm, and 229 mm below the wetland sediment water interface in the Old Woman Creek National Estuarine Research Center, Huron, OH, USA (Lat. = 41.380833, Long. = -82.508889). A core was collected from adjacent sediment and subsamples were collected from depth intervals of 0 – 25 mm, 25 – 127 mm, 127 – 128 mm, and below 178 mm. To determine if the microbial communities attached to the electrodes were reflective of the adjacent sediment-associated microbial community, we conducted a 16S rRNA gene-based (V4 region) survey of these respective materials. This data package contains the results of these surveys, including metadata on the depths from which samples were collected (samples.csv), DNA extraction and sequencing information (OWC_DEPTH_AMPLICON_SEQUENCING_METADATA), sequence processing information (OWC_DEPTH_BIOINFORMATIC_METADATA.csv), an operational taxonomic unit (OTU) table (OWC_DEPTH_97OTUS_TABLE.csv), and nucleotide sequences of OTUs (OWC_DEPTH_97OTUS_SEQS.fasta). All files can be opened using a text-editing application. The fasta file is compatible with bioinformatics applications.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2023

Graphitized Mesoporous Engineered Carbon Support for Fuel Cell Applications

As proton exchange membrane fuel cells mature into commercial devices capable of powering a wide range of stationary and automotive applications, they need materials with tunable properties to improve their performance and durability. Carbon supports used for platinum (Pt) nanoparticle dispersion is typically based on a furnace black-type material with a random structure, thereby hindering progress in catalyst development. To address this challenge, engineered carbons with a tunable mesoporous structure offer an opportunity to maximize catalyst performance and durability. In this article, we report on the development of a graphitized, mesoporous carbon support with a high degree of ordering, labeled here as ECS4005, for the dispersion of Pt nanoparticles. Pt/ECS4005 shows significantly improved kinetic activity due to its mesoporous structure that mitigates Pt poisoning by sulfonate functional groups in the ionomer while simultaneously enabling favorable accessibility to reactants.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Quantifying Volume Change in Porous Electrodes via the Multi-Species, Multi-Reaction Model

Automotive manufacturers are working to improve individual cell and overall pack design by increasing their performance, durability, and range, while reducing cost; and active material volume change is one of the more complex aspects that needs to be considered during this process. As the time from initial design to manufacture of electric vehicles is decreased, design work that used to rely solely on testing needs to be supplemented or replaced by virtual methods. As electrochemical engineers drive battery and system design using model-based methods, the need for coupled electrochemical/mechanical models that take into account the active material change utilizing physics based or semi-empirical approaches is necessary. In this study, we illustrated the applicability of a mechano-electrochemical coupled modeling method considering the multi-species, multi-reaction model as popularized by Verbrugge and Baker. To do this, validation tests were conducted using a computer-controlled press apparatus that can control the press displacement and press force with precision. The coupled MSMR volume change model was developed and its applicability to graphite and NMC cells was illustrated. The increased accuracy of the model considering the coupled MSMR volume change approach shows in the importance of accounting for individual gallery volume change behavior on cell level predictions.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

A Cobalt– and Manganese–Free High–Nickel Layered Oxide Cathode for Long–Life, Safer Lithium–Ion Batteries

High-nickel LiNi 1–x–y Mn x Co y O 2 and LiNi 1–x–y Co x Al y O 2 cathodes are receiving growing attention due to the burgeoning demands on high-energy-density lithium-ion batteries. The presence of both cobalt and manganese in them, however, triggers multiple issues, including high cost, high toxicity, rapid surface deterioration, and severe transition-metal dissolution. Herein, a Co- and Mn-free ultrahigh-nickel LiNi 0.93 Al 0.05 Ti 0.01 Mg 0.01 O 2 (NATM) cathode that exhibits 82% capacity retention over 800 deep cycles in full cells, outperforming two representative high-Ni cathodes LiNi 0.94 Co 0.06 O 2 (NC, 52%) and LiNi 0.90 Mn 0.05 Co 0.05 O 2 (NMC, 60%) is presented. It is demonstrated that a titanium-enriched surface along with aluminum and magnesium as the stabilizing ions in NATM not only ameliorates unwanted side reactions with the electrolyte and structural disintegrity, but also mitigates transition-metal dissolution and active lithium loss on the graphite anode. As a result, the graphite anode paired with NATM displays an ultrathin (≈8 nm), monolayer anode-electrolyte interphase architecture after extensive cycling. Furthermore, NATM displays considerably enhanced thermal stability with an elevated exothermic temperature (213 °C for NATM vs 180 and 190 °C for NC and NMC, respectively) and remarkably reduced heat release. This work sheds light on rational compositional design to adopt ultrahigh-Ni cathodes in lithium-based batteries with low cost, long service life, and improved thermal stability.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Boosting the Low-Temperature Performance of Graphite Anodes by Creating an Electrochemically Active Interface

Graphite is the major anode material used in commercial lithium-ion batteries (LIBs). However, the sluggish ion-transfer kinetics associated with graphite anodes significantly restrict the operation of LIBs over a wide temperature. This is primarily due to their low reversible capacity and the substantial overpotential exhibited under low-temperature conditions. To address this limitation, we demonstrate herein an approach that involves grafting an electrochemically active lithium benzenesulfonate layer onto a graphite surface through a typical reduction reaction of diazonium cations, followed by ion exchange process. This surface modification reduces the charge transfer resistance of graphite anodes, leading to an excellent reversible capacity of ~150 mAh g –1 at low-temperatures (-20 °C, 0.1C). Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy indicates that both desolvation of the lithium ions outside the graphite, and lithium diffusion within the solid electrolyte interphase and graphite lattice are two crucial rate-limiting steps during the Li (de)lithiation, with the latter dominating during the low-temperature operation. In conclusion, these findings demonstrate a facile method for enhancing the low-temperature performance of graphite through surface modification and provide valuable insights into fundamental understandings that can guide the future design of better -low-temperature graphite anodes.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Ultra-Low Amounts of Transition Metals in Carbon-Based Catalysts Improve Their Alkaline OER Performance: A Systematic Study

The pursuit of green hydrogen production highlights a persistent gap in electrocatalyst research: while academic efforts prioritize cost-efficiency via activity enhancement, industrial viability demands greater emphasis on electrochemical stability. Carbon-based electrocatalysts, particularly those incorporating transition metals, have shown promise in alkaline oxygen evolution (OER) due to their high activity, cost-efficiency, and resource-efficiency. However, these catalysts suffer from insufficient stability under oxidizing conditions compared to pure transition metal catalysts due to erosion of the carbon support resulting from carbon corrosion, among other degradation mechanisms. In this systematic study, the influence of ultra-low amounts (<1 wt %) of iron, cobalt, nickel, and their most common combinations on the stability of a hydrothermally derived, N-doped carbon support and the overall catalyst performance during alkaline OER is systematically explored. By identifying critical stability descriptors and correlating them with synthesis conditions and catalyst properties, primary and secondary corrosion pathways are unraveled. Subsequently, through careful adjustment of carbonization temperature and composition of incorporated transition metals, overall catalyst corrosion can be suppressed immensely. Especially, the inclusion of Ni and Fe is paramount for the formation of stable catalyst materials under laboratory conditions (10 mA/cm 2 in 0.1 M KOH), which is surprisingly unconstrained by the degree of graphitization of the carbon support. Mixing this electrochemically stable material with a graphitic carbon powder results in an excellent stability of over 400 h at 100 mA/cm 2 in 1 M KOH, implying great potential for the future improvement of carbon-based electrodes under oxidizing conditions toward industrial application.

N-doped carbon↗
DOE OSTI2026

Reducing Internal Resistance in Activated Carbon Supercapacitors via Exfoliated Coal-Derived Graphene Additive

Low equivalent series resistance (ESR) is critical for high-rate energy storage devices (e.g., supercapacitors), and graphene is a promising additive for reducing ESR in carbon-based supercapacitor electrodes. However, graphene can be costly and difficult to produce at scale. This study investigates the addition of graphene, produced through electrochemical exfoliation of domestic coal-derived graphite, in activated carbon-based supercapacitors. The coal-derived graphene was incorporated at varying weight loadings and tested in symmetric supercapacitors with aqueous electrolytes. ESR was evaluated using both direct current internal resistance (DCIR) and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) measurements. DCIR measurements revealed ESR reductions of ∼34%, ∼18%, and ∼21% at 3, 5, and 10 wt % loadings, respectively, compared to the baseline (0 wt %) of ∼0.54 Ω. These results were further confirmed by EIS measurements. Correspondingly, power density increased by ∼52%, ∼27%, and ∼35% at 3, 5, and 10 wt % loadings relative to the baseline (∼29 kW/kg). Additionally, the electrodes exhibited moderate increases in specific capacitance and energy density, along with stable cycling performance (capacitance retention above 85% after 100,000 cycles) and capacitive behavior (α = 0.95−0.97), suggesting favorable charge transfer kinetics. These findings highlight the potential of exfoliated coal-derived graphene as an effective additive for supercapacitor electrodes.

capacitors↗
DOE OSTI2023

Nanoscale electrostatic control in ultraclean van der Waals heterostructures by local anodic oxidation of graphite gates

In an all-van der Waals heterostructure, the active layer, gate dielectrics and gate electrodes are assembled from two-dimensional crystals that have a low density of atomic defects. This design allows two-dimensional electron systems with very low disorder to be created, particularly in heterostructures where the active layer also has intrinsically low disorder, such as crystalline graphene layers or metal dichalcogenide heterobilayers. A key missing ingredient has been nanoscale electrostatic control, with existing methods for fabricated local gates typically introducing unwanted contamination. Here we describe a resist-free local anodic oxidation process for patterning sub-100 nm features in graphite gates, and their subsequent integration into an all-van der Waals heterostructure. We define a quantum point contact in the fractional quantum Hall regime as a benchmark device and observe signatures of chiral Luttinger liquid behaviour, indicating an absence of extrinsic scattering centres in the vicinity of the point contact. In the integer quantum Hall regime, we demonstrate in situ control of the edge confinement potential, a key requirement for the precision control of chiral edge states. In conclusion, this technique may enable the fabrication of devices capable of single anyon control and coherent edge-state interferometry in the fractional quantum Hall regime.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Time-Resolved X-ray Operando Observations of Lithiation Gradients across the Cathode Matrix and Individual Oxide Particles during Fast Cycling of a Li-Ion Cell

Lithiated transition metal oxides serve as active materials in the positive electrode (cathode) of lithium-ion cells. During electrochemical cycling, lithium ions intercalate and deintercalate into these oxide particles. This behavior causes two types of lithiation gradients to emerge: (i) a bulk gradient across the depth of the cathode matrix (averaged over individual oxide particles) and (ii) a microscopic gradient across the particles themselves, which also depends on their location in the electrode. Here we show how both gradients can be studied using operando X-ray diffraction during 4C charge and 4C discharge. The oxide (de)lithiation is estimated from the unit cell parameters by indexing the X-ray diffraction spectra. By fitting the lithiation profiles with orthogonal polynomials, the bulk gradients across the electrode thickness are quantified. These gradients develop as the current flows through the cell and dissipate during open-circuit and potentiostatic-hold periods. Further details of lithiation dynamics can be obtained through shape analysis of the Bragg peaks. In particular, from electrochemical model simulations, we show that the width and skewness of the (003) peak track (de)lithiation fronts moving across the individual oxide particles.

(003) peak↗
DOE OSTI2025

Highly Active Hydrogen Evolution Reaction (HER) Catalysts Formed by Energetic Pt n Cluster Deposition: Deposition Dynamics and the HER Mechanism

Mass-selected Pt n + (n ≤ 7) were deposited at variable energies on highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG), creating highly active hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) electrocatalysts. HER mass activities were ~2 to >10 times higher than those for the surface atoms in bulk Pt and for Pt n deposited on several other supports. Thus, high activity reflects the Pt-C structures formed by energetic Pt n -HOPG impacts, in addition to high Pt surface availability. The Pt n /HOPG electrodes were probed by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, low energy ion scattering, and electron microscopy. Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics (BOMD) was used to simulate Pt n - HOPG impacts, revealing the types of structures formed at different energies, then DFT was used to probe their most important HER pathways. For low deposition energies, the Pt n deposit onto the HOPG surface with sub-unit sticking probability, aggregating at defects. With increasing deposition energy, the sticking probability initially decreases, then rises to unity as subplantation and defect creation allow formation of strongly bonded platinum-carbon structures. Barriers for HER on these structures were found to be low and weakly dependent on Pt n size, consistent with experiment. The activities were highest for small covalently-bonded Pt-C structures created at high deposition energies. The larger aggregated structures formed at low energies were less active, but still substantially better than the bulk Pt surface monolayer. The catalysts were stable in repeated potential cycling at reducing potentials, but electrodes containing subplanted Pt became more active when scanned to oxidizing potentials, due to emergence of subplanted Pt onto the surface.

08 HYDROGEN↗
DOE OSTI2020

Directly Embedded Ni3S2/Co9S8@S-Doped Carbon Nanofiber Networks as a Free-Standing Anode for Lithium-Ion Batteries

Transition metal sulfides as electrode materials for lithium-ion batteries have attracted significant research attention due to their high theoretical capacity, excellent redox reversibility, and earth abundance. However, this material family still suffers from poor conductivity and experiences huge volume changes. Here, we demonstrate a facile and scalable electrospinning method to prepare Ni3S2 and Co9S8 nanoparticles embedded in sulfur doped carbon nanofiber networks as a free-standing anode material for lithium ion batteries. Similar to literature findings, the coupling of two different metal sulfides indeed synergistically promoted the electrochemical performance. Embedding them within individual carbon nanofibers not only enhances the intrinsic conductivity, but also provides a highly stable structure, which results in excellent battery performance. Furthermore, the individual carbon nanofibers intertwine with each other to form a free-standing 3D nanofiber network which acts as a freeway network for fast electron transfer and the pores between fibers allow easy penetration of the electrolyte, namely easy lithium ion access to active nanoparticles. When directly applied as the anode in lithium ion batteries, the free-standing nanofiber mat bypassed all slurry making steps and showed excellent cycling stability with a high specific capacity of 528 mA h g-1 after 200 cycles at a current density of 300 mA g-1. Good rate capability was also obtained. Additionally, the charge storage process analysis indicated that the pseudocapacitive behavior of the material is attributed to its good performance. This work introduces a facile strategy to simultaneously and in situ generate Co9S8 and Ni3S2 nanoparticles within a S-doped carbon fiber matrix via facile electrospinning followed by a one-step heating procedure. It is demonstrated that the free-standing transition bimetallic sulfide nanofibers prepared are very promising for light and small battery applications.

ADVANCED PROPULSION SYSTEMS,ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Fabrication of Advanced Nanocarbon-Metal Composites for Improved Energy Efficiency

We fabricated nanocarbon metal composites (NCMC) of Al alloys with a process called “electrocharging assisted process” (EAP). This method consists of the application of a high current to a mixture of liquid metal and carbon particles. We investigated aluminum alloys (6061 and 1350) and used activated carbon and graphite powder as the source of carbon. The high current induces the formation of carbon chains and ribbons in the liquid metal. Upon solidification of the metal an epitaxial relation between the carbon nanostructures and the metal lattice is produced. The purpose of the project was to find the parameters during the reaction that would give rise to a high density of nanoribbons extending throughout the metal such that the electrical conductivity and the mechanical strength of the composite increased and that the method could be extended to large scale manufacturing. For this purpose, we designed two reactors for the incorporation of nanocarbon ribbons in aluminum metal. The first reactor was designed to have more control of the region with the high current density. However, there were problems with getting good mixing of the carbon in small volumes. A second reactor was designed with a stirrer that allowed for better mixing of the carbon by the introduction of argon gas through the shaft of the stirrer. NCMC were fabricated with a series of parameters to understand the role of current, time of applied current, type and shape of the cathode electrode and stirring speed of the mixture. We analyzed the composites by Raman scattering to gain information on the crystallite size of the nanocarbon, XRD to obtain the crystal structure of the composite, SEM and TEM to characterize the grain size of the aluminum grains and the quality of the crystal structure. We also measured the electrical conductivity and mechanical properties of selected samples. The nanocomposites showed increase in crystallite size of the nanocarbon with a linear dependence of the crystallite size on the duration of the applied current. There is a minimum current density necessary for the crystallite size to increase compared to the ~ 10 nm size of the activated carbon source used in the fabrication. The electrical conductivity of the nanocomposites increased with crystallite size of the nanocarbon and with the concentration of converted carbon. The maximum increase in electrical conductivity was 5.7% above the baseline for samples with ~ 4 wt % nanocarbon with crystallite size larger than 30 nm. These samples presented a hardness ~ 8% higher than the baseline samples with no carbon.

24 POWER TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION↗