A Computational Investigation of the Effect of Packing Structural Features on the Performance of Carbon Capture for Solvent-Based Post-Combustion Applications
Work presented at AIChE Annual Meeting, Orlando, FL, November 5-10, 2023.
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Work presented at AIChE Annual Meeting, Orlando, FL, November 5-10, 2023.
Techno-Economic Analysis (TEA) and Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) were performed on the Aqueous Lignin Purification with Hot Agents (ALPHA) process, which is being investigated for the fractionation and purification of raw, bulk lignins recovered from cellulosic ethanol biorefineries or Kraft pulp mills. Here, ALPHA is proposed for the isolation of lignin from a corn stover-to-ethanol plant into purified low, medium, and high molecular weight (MW) fractions for producing polyurethane foam, activated carbon, and carbon fiber, respectively. A scenario analysis was conducted to determine the effect of ALPHA solvent choice on process economics and environmental performance. Solvent choice was found to have a significant impact on ALPHA, with a minimum selling price of 838/tonne with use of acetic acid vs 463/tonne with ethanol. Conversion of the lignin, processed with ethanol solvent, to high-value products yields 151 million/year in profit, which over 30 years results in a total net present value of 533 million. A life cycle assessment was conducted to determine the “gate-to-gate” greenhouse gas emissions and energy consumption of the lignin-based products compared to fossil-based equivalents. In conclusion, a value allocation scenario was conducted and it was determined that products generated using the ALPHA process with ethanol have similar or lower greenhouse gas emissions than the same products from fossil feedstocks.
To achieve a truly closed-loop direct recycling process for lithium-ion batteries, all component materials must be recovered. To date, direct recycling method development has primarily focused on the high-value transition-metal cathode materials, while the inherently lower-value graphite has been challenging to recover in a cost-effective manner. However, end-of-life graphite contains a unique engineered value due to the presence of the solid electrolyte interphase (SEI). Growth of the SEI during the cell's active lifetime stabilizes the electronically reactive graphite surface through an irreversible consumption of Li, and thus necessitates both excess lithiation of the cathode and a costly and time-intensive formation procedure during manufacturing. An optimized pre-formed SEI that capitalizes on existing SEI components from end-of-life batteries has the potential to significantly reduce cathode lithiation requirements and eliminate the critical bottleneck of formation cycling during cell remanufacturing. Further, retaining Li at the anode obviates the need for a separate Li leaching and recovery step, improving the overall efficiency of the direct recycling line. In this work, we present a novel approach to "upcycling" spent graphite through use of tailored chemical treatment to remove adverse (i.e., highly resistive and/or poorly passivating) SEI species while retaining beneficially passivating components. We have explored a rational set of solvents spanning a range of polarity, proticity, and molecular size to evaluate structure-property-performance relationships between applied solvent(s), removed and remaining SEI species, and electrochemical response of the resulting graphite product. Further, we have developed and optimized a robust and holistic analysis procedure that couples symmetric-cell electrochemical testing, multi-modal materials characterization, and advanced electrochemical modeling. These analysis results inform a set of correlative metrics for graphite performance relative to both solvent properties and upcycled SEI composition. We demonstrate effective tunability in the residual SEI composition by varying solvent identity and concentration, and report on several promising solvent systems that achieve comparable or performance to pristine graphite.
This case study provides cost and performance estimates for a solvent-based direct air capture (DAC) system at varying scales. The performance of the DAC system is largely based upon vendor performance while the costs of the system were developed as independently as possible. This study is representative of an example DAC system configuration and is not an optimized design.
The INL radiolysis test loop system has been employed to evaluate the effects of gamma radiolysis the stability and performance of the GENIORS solvent extraction process. This report describes details and results of the experiments performed and documents completion of milestone M3FT-21IN030101024 “Testing of Radiolytic Stability of m-TDDGA Based Solvent at INL”. The purpose of the proposed dynamic irradiation tests to be performed is to evaluate the radiolytic stability of the GENIORS process solvent for An/Ln recovery under process-like conditions. Recent research efforts within the European Union GENIORS project have focused upon demonstrating additional process improvements. These improvements include simplification of the solvent composition, use of reagents composed of only C, H, O, and N atoms (the CHON principle), identification of a diglycolamide derivative with more favorable Pu loading behavior, and use of an aqueous soluble stripping reagent that is not sulfonated. As a result, a new solvent utilizing dimethyl-N,N,N’,N’-tetradecyl-diglycolamide (cis-mTDDGA) as the An/Ln extractant and the aqueous soluble 2,6-bis[1-(propan-1-ol)-1,2,3-triazol-4yl]-pyridine (PTD) as the An/Ln stripping reagent was proposed. The impact of gamma radiolysis upon the efficacy of the GENIORS process solvent was evaluated by determining the americium, europium, and cerium distribution ratios as a function of absorbed dose. The measured distribution ratios demonstrated that the GENIORS solvent did undergo radiolytic degradation. However, at absorbed doses corresponding to realistic process conditions, the extraction and stripping performance of the solvent remains acceptable. Compositional analysis of the irradiated solvent revealed a decrease in the concentration of cis-mTDDGA, which is consistent with the observed changes in metal distribution ratios as a function of absorbed dose.
NIOWAVE, Inc. is a domestic supplier of medical and industrial isotopes from uranium and radium. The Savannah River National laboratory (SRNL) is currently providing support to NIOWAVE, which plans to deploy a superconducting electron linear accelerator (LINAC) to fission uranium for Mo-99 production without the need for a nuclear reactor or HEU. The uranium from the Mo-99 production targets will be purified using a modified PUREX (Plutonium Uranium Reduction Extraction) solvent extraction process to recover the uranium in the product stream. The uranium will then be precipitated as an oxalate which is calcined to U 3 O 8 to fabricate pellets for new Mo-99 targets. In previous support provided to NIOWAVE, the SRNL demonstrated a solvent washing process to remove degradation products from the tributyl phosphate (TBP) solvent used in the modified PUREX process under development for uranium recovery. To supplement this technology demonstration, NIOWAVE requested the SRNL to provide summary information on the solvent recovery and management activities which are used at the Savannah River Site (SRS) H-Canyon facility. An existing reference document for the reprocessing of irradiated HEU fuels at the SRS was used as the primary reference for the solvent management activities; although, other reference documents were used to provide supplementary information. The information provided includes a brief summary of the solvent degradation issues which have been observed in the H-Canyon solvent extraction cycles and resulting process safety concerns. The solvent recovery processes for the three cycles of solvent extraction used in the H-Canyon were subsequently described including the process equipment which consists of the continuous and batch solvent washers, pumps, and tanks. A final section is provided on the monitoring and analysis of solvent quality based on the previous work performed at the SRNL for NIOWAVE and past research and development activities performed to support the solvent extraction processes in both the SRS F-Canyon and H-Canyon facilities.
Solvent-based post-combustion CO 2 capture (PCC) technology remains one of the leading methods to combat global CO 2 emissions produced from large-scale coal-fired power production. Advanced solventbased PCC technology has made significant improvements in design and performance that reduce capital and operating costs to enable its commercial use. Key to low cost, manageable logistics, and environmentally safe operation of solvent-based PCC technology are minimal solvent losses from the process through the treated gas stream exiting PCC plant absorbers. High flue gas aerosol particle concentrations (>10 5 particles/cm 3 ) for particles in the range of 70-200 nm have been shown to cause significant amine solvent losses for solvent-based PCC processes through several mechanisms including absorption of solvent and water into growing aerosol particles. Flue gas aerosol pretreatment technology is the only realistic and economically attractive method to reduce very high aerosol particle concentrations (>10 7 particles/cm 3 ) to enable solvent-based PCC for existing power plants lacking sufficient particle removal systems, such as baghouses. The overall goal of this project was to design, construct, independently test, and evaluate three flue gas aerosol pretreatment technologies identified to significantly reduce high aerosol particle concentrations (>10 7 particles/cm 3 ) in the 70-200 nm particle size range: (1) a novel, high-velocity water injection spray concept developed by RWE and tested by Linde, (2) an innovative electrostatic precipitator (ESP) device with optimized operating conditions developed by Washington University in St. Louis (WUSTL), and (3) a non-regenerative sorbent-based filter technology developed by InnoSepra for SO x and NO x removal from coal-fired power plant flue gas. Each technology has been validated with tests on 500-1000 scfm of actual coal-fired flue gas and evaluated in terms of particle removal efficiency (%), cost competitiveness, and environmental impact. Aerosol measurements were performed upstream and downstream of each aerosol reduction unit during independent testing of each technology using advanced instrumentation and analytical methods provided by WUSTL. To perform aerosol measurements, isokinetic probes were inserted into flanged pipes attached to the flue gas piping, and a small suction pump was used to sample gas containing aerosol particles. Aerosol particle number concentrations (# particles/cm 3 ) and size distributions were then measured using a scanning mobility particle sizer (SMPS, TSI Inc.) for very fine particles (<1,000 nm) and a particle counter manufactured by GRIMM for particles larger than 1,000 nm. This report summarizes the aerosol removal performance results from pilot scale testing of each technology. Performance results have been benchmarked against pre-defined targets and other flue gas aerosol pretreatment technologies with documented performance. Linde Gas North America LLC has been the prime contractor to DOE responsible for overall project management and provided the design for the high-velocity water spray-based aerosol removal technology based on a design concept developed by the German utility company RWE.
Fossil fuel fired power plants are generally expected to remain one of the most significant global sources of electricity for decades to come. Consequently, carbon management technologies are needed to reduce or eliminate ongoing emissions from these sources. Amongst the many techniques for carbon capture, aqueous amine-based absorbents (monoethanolamine, MEA, in particular) are, presently, considered the leading technology for post-combustion CO 2 point-source capture. These technologies are nevertheless limited by their high capital and regeneration energy costs. Biphasic solvents have been identified as an attractive alternative to traditional MEA based absorbents due to their potential energy savings. Thus far, however, the research on biphasic solvents has largely focused on their performance in coal flue gas while more dilute natural gas flue gas applications have received relatively little attention. Here, this work examines the performances of two novel biphasic solvent blends, diethylenetriamine (DETA) and triethylenetetramine (TETA), in CO 2 capture from a natural gas flue gas simulant. Across several regeneration tests, both solvents achieved considerable energy savings over the benchmark MEA solution. Specifically, the energy consumption per mol CO 2 recovered for the DETA-based and TETA-based solvents was 46 % and 35 % less than that of the benchmark MEA solution, respectively. Molecular dynamics simulations were also performed to gain a deeper understanding of the phase separation phenomena that occur as a consequence of CO 2 absorption. These simulations indicated that phase change was driven by the strong interaction between the absorption products and water, while the degree of separation depended on the CO 2 loading.
Efficient carbon capture requires the design of new materials with high CO 2 selectivity and gas adsorption capacity that can be incorporated into existing industrial processes. Porous liquids (PLs) are promising candidate materials that consist of a nanoporous host and a solvent forming a liquid with permanent porosity based on exclusion of the solvent from the interior of the nanoporous host. Stable PLs are based on solvent-nanoporous host interactions, which can be evaluated through molecular simulations. Here, time- and temperature-dependent density functional theory simulations were performed between four solvents, 2-bromophenol, 4-methylphenol, 2,4-dimethylphenol, and cyclohexanone and the CC13 porous organic cage (POC) as a prototypical PL composition. Overall, minimal reactions occurred in the PL including no changes in the POC structure. Additionally, POC-solvent coordination occurred through interactions of neighboring functional groups such as methyl/bromide and hydroxyl on the solvent molecules with the POC surface. Therefore, the location rather than the number of functional groups on the solvent molecule controls the POC-solvent interactions. Additionally, the POC pore window contracted or expanded up to 8% during solvation, which correlates with the experimental solubility and static solvent-POC binding, where solvents that caused less contraction of the POC pore window increased POC solubility. Finally, these results allow for the design of optimized POC-based PL compositions based on solvent-nanoporous host binding and variation in the pore window during solvation.
Aqueous amines, as the most mature carbon capture technology, are subject to high energy and cost penalties due to the large water content in their formulations. Emerging technologies are in demand to enable a transition to a low-carbon global economy. However, rigorous process modeling and techno-economic analyses are limited for emerging carbon capture technologies. Here, four CO 2 -Binding Organic Liquids (CO 2 BOLs), all water-lean solvents were presented as promising options towards energy-effective and low-cost carbon capture from point sources. Rigorous solvent property and process models were developed in Aspen Plus for a coal-fired power plant with CO 2 BOL-based carbon capture unit. Techno-economic analyses were conducted in 2018 US pricing basis. The results suggest that water-lean formulations can minimize water condensation and vaporization, leading to a 36% energy saving compared with aqueous amines. Indeed, these CO 2 BOLs can capture up to 97–99% CO 2 from coal fired plant. The estimated carbon capture cost is about $40/tonne CO 2 at 90–97% carbon capture rate, about 12–23% less expensive than the conventional aqueous amine technology. The comparison between these CO 2 BOLs showed that in addition to vapor liquid equilibrium and kinetics (key properties for aqueous solvents), viscosity, volatility, and hydrophobicity, also have strong impacts on the performance of water-lean solvents. The methods presented in this work can be used to evaluate other emerging carbon capture technologies, while the results linking costs and performance of carbon capture solvents with their properties. Additionally, this work identifies research directions and targets for further reductions in total costs of capture from either cost or energy perspectives for these leading water-lean solvents.
Novel electrolyte designs to further enhance the lithium (Li) metal battery cyclability are highly desirable. Here, fluorinated 1,6-dimethoxyhexane (FDMH) is designed and synthesized as the solvent molecule to promote electrolyte stability with its prolonged –CF 2 – backbone. Meanwhile, 1,2-dimethoxyethane is used as a co-solvent to enable higher ionic conductivity and much reduced interfacial resistance. Combining the dual-solvent system with 1 m lithium bis(fluorosulfonyl)imide (LiFSI), high Li-metal Coulombic efficiency (99.5%) and oxidative stability (6 V) are achieved. Using this electrolyte, 20 µm Li||NMC batteries are able to retain ≈80% capacity after 250 cycles and Cu||NMC anode-free pouch cells last 120 cycles with 75% capacity retention under ≈2.1 µL mAh -1 lean electrolyte conditions. Such high performances are attributed to the anion-derived solid-electrolyte interphase, originating from the coordination of Li-ions to the highly stable FDMH and multiple anions in their solvation environments. This work demonstrates a new electrolyte design strategy that enables high-performance Li-metal batteries with multisolvent Li-ion solvation with rationally optimized molecular structure and ratio.
An advanced Amine Promoted Buffer Solution (APBS), APBS-CDRMax® (CDRMax), developed by Carbon Clean Solutions Limited (CCSL), was tested at the 0.7 MWe CO 2 capture facility at Kentucky Utilities E.W. Brown Generation Station using a heat-integrated two-staged stripping CO 2 capture process. The performance of the solvent was evaluated to determine operating conditions that maximized the cyclic capacity of the solvent and results in energy savings. The regeneration energy ranged from 2.9 to 3.3 GJ/ton CO 2 with 14 vol % (dry) CO 2 inlet and approximately 90 % capture. The difference in the reboiler specific heat duty at stripper pressures of 1.7 and 2.1 bar was minimal as similar amounts of water vapor were observed in the CO 2 product stream at stripper outlet. Recycling of product CO 2 increased the inlet CO 2 concentration to the absorber from 14 to 16 vol% which enhanced mass transfer from the gas to the solvent resulting in about 5 % reduction in the energy of regeneration at the lower stripper pressure. The solvent circulation rate was reduced by about 30 % relative to previous 30 wt% MEA campaign for the CO 2 target capture of 90 %. Finally, the reduced solvent make-up rate of CDRMax shows promise for capital and operating cost savings for post-combustion CO 2 capture.
The development of semiconducting polymers with good processability in green solvents and competitive electrical performance is essential for realizing sustainable large-scale manufacturing and commercialization of organic electronics. A major obstacle is the processability-performance dichotomy that is dictated by the lack of ideal building blocks with balanced polarity, solubility, electronic structures, and molecular conformation. Herein, through the integration of donor, quinoid and acceptor units, an unprecedented building block, namely TQBT, is introduced for constructing a serial of conjugated polymers. The TQBT, distinct in non-symmetric structure and high dipole moment, imparts enhanced solubility in anisole—a green solvent—to the polymer TQBT-T. Furthermore, PTQBT-T possess a highly rigid and planar backbone owing to the nearly coplanar geometry and quinoidal nature of TQBT, resulting in strong aggregation in solution and localized aggregates in film. Remarkably, PTQBT-T films spuncast from anisole exhibit a hole mobility of 2.30 cm 2 V -1 s -1 , which is record high for green solvent-processable semiconducting polymers via spin-coating, together with commendable operational and storage stability. The hybrid building block emerges as a pioneering electroactive unit, shedding light on future design strategies in high-performance semiconducting polymers compatible with green processing and marking a significant stride towards ecofriendly organic electronics.
Liquid electrolyte engineering plays a critical role in modern lithium-ion batteries. However, the existing electrolytes fall short when used with some trending battery chemistries such as high-voltage and high-energy-density electrodes. Fluorination of electrolyte solvents has been identified as an effective approach for improved cyclability, but few works systematically studied the effects of fluorination extent of carbonate solvents on battery performance. Here we design and synthesize a family of fluorinated ethyl methyl carbonates. Different numbers of F atoms are finely tuned to yield monofluoroethyl methyl carbonate (F1EMC), difluoroethyl methyl carbonate (F2EMC) and trifluoroethyl methyl carbonate (F3EMC). The cycling behavior of several types of lithium-ion pouch cells, including graphite (Gr)/single-crystalline LiNi 0.8 Mn 0.1 Co 0.1 O 2 (SC-NMC811), Gr-SiO x /LiNi 0.6 Mn 0.2 Co 0.2 O 2 (NMC622), high-voltage Gr/LiNi 0.5 Mn 1.5 O 4 (LNMO), Gr/layered Li-rich Mn-based oxide (LLMO) and fast-charging Gr/NMC622, were systematically investigated to understand the impact of fluorination degree. Compared to the commercially available F3EMC, we found that the partially-fluorinated F1EMC and F2EMC in some cases showed improved cycling stability, which we attribute to their locally-polar –CH 2 F and –CHF 2 groups and thus fast ion conduction than –CF 3 . This work suggests that highly or fully fluorinated solvents are not necessarily desirable; instead, fluorination degree needs to be rationally and finely tuned for optimized lithium-ion cell performance.
Abstract Efficient direct air capture (DAC) of CO 2 will require strategies to deal with the relatively low concentration in the atmosphere. One such strategy is to employ the combination of a CO 2 ‐selective membrane coupled with a CO 2 capture solvent acting as a draw solution. Here, the interactions between a leading water‐lean carbon‐capture solvent, a polyether ether ketone (PEEK)‐ionene membrane, CO 2 , and combinations were probed using advanced NMR techniques coupled with advanced simulations. We identify the speciation and dynamics of the solvent, membrane, and CO 2 , presenting spectroscopic evidence of CO 2 diffusion through benzylic regions within the PEEK‐ionene membrane, not spaces in the ionic lattice as expected. Our results demonstrate that water‐lean capture solvents provide a thermodynamic and kinetic funnel to draw CO 2 from the air through the membrane and into the bulk solvent, thus enhancing the performance of the membrane. The reaction between the carbon‐capture solvent and CO 2 produces carbamic acid, disrupting interactions between the imidazolium (Im + ) cations and the bistriflimide anions within the PEEK‐ionene membrane, thereby creating structural changes through which CO 2 can diffuse more readily. Consequently, this restructuring results in CO 2 diffusion at the interface that is faster than CO 2 diffusion in the bulk carbon‐capture solvent.
Solvent extraction desalination (SED) is a promising technique for efficiently treating high salinity brines. However, only a few studies in the literature have investigated the influence of the molecular characteristics of the organic solvents on the emergent performance of the separation process. Thus, in this work we investigate the influence of the molecular structure of four different secondary amines on the desalination process of a concentrated aqueous solution of NaCl. Molecular dynamics simulations and free energy calculations are used to obtain the thermodynamic and structural properties of the pure solvent bulk phase, as well as a homogeneous solvent-water bulk mixture. Furthermore, solvent-water and solvent-brine interfacial systems are used to explicitly analyze the water partitioning behavior in the relevant temperature range for SED. The water solubilization in these secondary amines is found to be an exothermic process. Additionally, although the hydrogen-bonding interaction between the water and solvent molecules are beneficial, this interaction is not necessarily the dominant factor for ranking the water solubility performance of the different solvents. Finally, the excess volume of mixing of the bulk solvent-water mixture, as well as the electrostatic surface features of the solvents are also found to provide important clues for screening solvent behavior.
Non-aqueous redox flow batteries have shown promise for applications in grid energy storage. Increasing the efficiency of these batteries by developing the electrolyte chemistries is needed. Herein, we investigate the correlation between solvent properties and the electrochemical parameters of vanadium acetylacetonate V(acac) 3 . Using cyclic voltammetry (CV) and rotating disk electrode experiments (RDE), we show that trends in the performance of the V(acac) 3 kinetics are directly related to solvent properties. In this study, we found strong relationships between the solvents polarity, viscosity, and donor number with the electrochemical behavior of V(acac) 3 in terms of the electrochemical working widow, electron kinetics and stability towards cycling. Based on these finding, we also demonstrate how solvent selection can be improved with limited a priori knowledge.
Evaluating six economic and two environmental performance metrics for recycling of waste PET via solvent-based dissolution–precipitation processes.