DOE OSTI2019
For ~15 years and perhaps longer, Pantex Plant has used a spherical platen in their compression load train when performing compression tests for Core Surveillance and HE Qualification. As our mechanical testing team at Los Alamos National Laboratory has always worked closely with our Pantex colleagues, and has maintained very similar practices in terms of calibration and testing, the author of this report has documented discussions with Pantex personnel (Robert Spence, et al.) dating back to ~2003, discussing the pros and cons of spherical platen use. LANL used spherical platens for a year or two, but determined issues and discontinued the practice. Based on multiple Engineering Evaluations (EE), LANL opportunities to watch Pantex procedures, it is our understanding that Pantex continued to use spherical platens from circa 2003 (or earlier) through summer 2019, despite the discontinued practice at LANL and the strong encouragement from LANL that spherical platens introduced error and should not be used. The short study reported here was intended to provide quantitative argument as to why spherical platens should not be used. As of a mechanical testing EE in August 2019, and after the testing of this LANL study was complete, LANL was informed by Pantex personnel that the practice of using spherical platens had recently been discontinued with no obvious problems or changes to the quality of the data. Although the urgency is gone for reporting our results, this is a brief quick summary of the data we collected.