Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Nuclear systems”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 73 records · Page 4

Development of Segregated Thermal-Hydraulics Solvers in MOOSE

The simulation of fluid flows is an essential part of the design and analysis of nuclear systems. Algorithms able to simulate flows at different fidelity levels are available in the Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment (MOOSE) and MOOSE-based applications such as Pronghorn \cite{novak2018pronghorn}, Pronghorn-Subchannel, RELAP-7, and SAM. Currently, significant effort is being invested in the development of coarse-mesh Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) capabilities within MOOSE and Pronghorn for the simulation of Generation IV nuclear reactors. Traditionally, the solution algorithms in MOOSE have relied on Newton or quasi-Newton methods (such as the preconditioned Jacobian-free Newton-Krylov method) where residuals and Jacobians (or approximations thereof) are constructed. Both Newton and quasi-Newton methods require the solution of a linear system at each nonlinear Newton iteration with the Jacobian as the system matrix. The Jacobian contains blocks originating from all variables in the problem (i.e., for thermal-hydraulics at least pressure, velocities, and temperature). Due to the formulation of the problem in a general multiphysics setting on unstructured mesh, creating a good preconditioner for the linear system can be challenging, thus many fluid applications have utilized direct solver-based methods such as LU factorization. However, with increasing system size and complexity in multi-dimensional problems, the direct solution of linear systems becomes computationally expensive both in execution time and and memory. For this reason, recent effort has focused on adapting segregated solution algorithms for CFD problems in MOOSE. These algorithms use fixed-point iteration between segregated systems whose assembly and preconditioning are easier those of the monolithic system. Initial results show that the segregated solution algorithm outperforms the monolithic approach in terms of memory usage and for large 3D problems in terms of CPU time as well.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Capsule Design and Preparation for YH x Specimen Irradiation in the High Flux Isotope Reactor

Advanced nuclear systems for terrestrial microreactors and space applications require moderator materials with high thermal stability, hydrogen retention, and efficient neutron moderation. Yttrium hydride (YH x ) is a promising candidate, but its irradiation performance and hydrogen stability remain insufficiently understood. To address this, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and Los Alamos National Laboratory, supported by the US Department of Energy’s Nuclear Science User Facilities program, have initiated an irradiation campaign in ORNL’s High Flux Isotope Reactor. The experiment employs six irradiation capsules containing YH x specimens (H/Y ≈ 1.9) designed for three target temperatures (300°C, 400°C, and 500°C) and two distinct neutron fast fluence levels. This report documents the irradiation test matrix, capsule design, specimen precharacterization, and experiment readiness for insertion. Planned postirradiation examinations will provide new insights into hydrogen retention and microstructural stability, advancing the understanding of YH x as a moderator for compact reactor applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Capsule Design and Preparation for YH x Specimen Irradiation in the High Flux Isotope Reactor

Advanced nuclear systems for terrestrial microreactors and space applications require moderator materials with high thermal stability, hydrogen retention, and efficient neutron moderation. Yttrium hydride (YH x ) is a promising candidate, but its irradiation performance and hydrogen stability remain insufficiently understood. To address this, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and Los Alamos National Laboratory, supported by the US Department of Energy’s Nuclear Science User Facilities program, have initiated an irradiation campaign in ORNL’s High Flux Isotope Reactor. The experiment employs six irradiation capsules containing YH x specimens (H/Y ≈ 1.9) designed for three target temperatures (300°C, 400°C, and 500°C) and two distinct neutron fast fluence levels. This report documents the irradiation test matrix, capsule design, specimen precharacterization, and experiment readiness for insertion. Planned postirradiation examinations will provide new insights into hydrogen retention and microstructural stability, advancing the understanding of YHx as a moderator for compact reactor applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Schiff Moment of 129 Xe and 199 Hg [Slides]

Using Chicoma in 2025, we advanced DFT-based calculations needed to connect fundamental T violating interactions to measurable Schiff moments in heavy nuclei. We implemented DFT for polarized odd nuclear systems, a first step toward treating the time-reversal-breaking mean fields required for Schiff moment calculations. As a validation test, we computed polarizabilities using a perturbation with the dipole operator (see figure to the right) for the odd systems shown in Table 1; while no odd-system effect is expected for polarizabilities, this capability is essential for Schiff moments. Initial mean-field solutions for 129 Xe Schiff moment calculations were also generated.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Effect of Heat Treatment on Microstructure and Mechanical Property of 316L Stainless Steel Produced by Laser Powder Bed Fusion

The advanced non-light water reactor designs (Gen IV reactors), including molten salt/ very high temperature/ sodium-cooled and lead-cooled fast reactors, typically operate at higher temperatures and more extreme radiation conditions than light water reactors. An intrinsic part of the deployment and progress of Gen IV reactor designs is selecting the most suitable structural material for a specific application. Additive manufacturing (AM), a fairly new process of making physical, three-dimensional objects from a computer design file, is going to completely change the way of design, build and certify nuclear systems. It offers a range of opportunities to produce complex geometries from existing materials, offers new routes for processing of previously difficult to process materials, allows for design of new high-performance materials, and finally facilitates hybridization of dissimilar materials. This emerging technology has successfully produced cars, wind turbine blade molds and even live cells. It could also open up big opportunities for the nuclear industry to quickly deploy technologies at a fraction of the cost. So far, AM techniques have been preliminarily applied in the field of nuclear reactors, including the classical parts such as the pressure vessel of a small reactor with 508-III steel, the bottom nozzle of a fuel assembly with 304L steel, the fuel cladding with zirconium alloy and the integrated impeller of a pump and the multi-channel valve body with 316L steel [6,7]. The AM applications for operating nuclear reactors started in auxiliary plant components and have slowly migrated to metallic reactors and core components, but many of these are not safety critical components. Although many parts used for nuclear reactors have been fabricated by AM techniques, practical applications in engineering are still a long way off due to the uncertainty factors focused on the processing, material properties, analysis methods and application standards, which feeds the safety and life-cycle of the nuclear reactor. Due to rapid, repeated heating and cooling during production, a high dislocation density was present in the AM material. This microstructure feature is unstable at elevated temperature while high temperature is one of the typical operation environments for nuclear reactors. Thus, it is important to understand the thermal effect on the microstructure of AM material. The objectives of this study are to investigate the effect of heat treatment on the microstructure and mechanical properties of 316L stainless steel produced by laser powder bed fusion additive manufacturing, and to determine an appropriate heat treatment practice that will be applied to the lightweight AM lattice-structured material with the same chemistry. The heat treatment study consisted of annealing the samples at a temperature range of 800 to 1200 oC with a 50 oC increment for different times (1-24 hours), followed by vacuum or air cooling. Microstructural characterization was carried out by Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM). Grain size and crystallographic orientation were investigated by Electron Backscatter Diffraction (EBSD). Vickers hardness tests with a 0.5 kg load were employed to determine the hardness of samples after different heat treatments. After heat treatment, the random crystallographic orientation was preserved, and the volume fraction of high-angle grain boundaries (grain boundary misorientation =15 oC) remained the same. The dislocation density decreased with annealing temperature due to recovery. The fine subgrain structures in the as-printed specimen were quite stable up to 1200 oC. Minimal recrystallization was observed up to 1200 oC. Recrystallization initiated only after 8.5 hours at 1200 oC. The SEM images did not show obvious dependence of microstructure on cooling rate. The hardness of the specimens decreased with increasing annealing temperature as a result of the decrease in dislocation density. It is interesting to note that the AM material showed very similar hardness to the wrought material when annealing at similar temperature, although the microstructures are very different. Annealing at 1050 oC for 1 hour followed by air cooling was selected as the heat treatment procedure for the lattice designed lightweight AM 316L material.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Radiation-induced segregation in dilute Fe–Cr: A rate-theory framework for the Cr enrichment–depletion transition at the grain boundary

Radiation-induced segregation (RIS) poses a significant challenge for ferritic Fe–Cr alloys under irradiation, as it can compromise mechanical integrity and increase susceptibility to intergranular corrosion. Yet, the mechanisms governing Cr segregation remain incompletely understood. Here, in this study, we present a physics-based rate-theory model parameterized using self-consistent mean field theory-based Onsager transport coefficients to investigate RIS at the grain boundary in dilute Fe-(0.1 at. %) Cr. Under equal production rates of vacancies and self-interstitial atoms (SIA), and their equal absorption rates by bulk dislocations, the model simulates the experimentally observed transition from Cr enrichment at low temperatures to depletion at higher temperatures. Under these unbiased conditions, systematic investigation reveals that while temperature-dependent transport properties dictate the segregation direction, dose rate, grain size, and dislocation density only influence the magnitude and spatial extent of Cr segregation. However, under more realistic conditions of preferential vacancy production within damage cascade and/or preferential SIA absorption by bulk dislocations, the enrichment-to-depletion transition shifts to lower temperatures. Our findings demonstrate that RIS predictions based solely on transport coefficients are valid only under symmetric point defect flux conditions, and that biases in defect production and absorption must be considered for accurate predictions. This work provides a mechanistic framework for understanding RIS in ferritic alloys and informs alloy design for advanced nuclear systems.

11 - NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Code Validation of SAM Using Forced and Natural Circulation Data from NACIE-UP Benchmark

Heavy liquid metals (HLMs) are promising candidates as coolants of Generation IV fast reactors due to their thermophysical properties. In the last decade, experimental work has been proposed as part of research and development efforts to develop such systems. In this context, researchers from the Brasimone Research Center have conducted many experiments using the Natural Circulation Experiment Upgrade (NACIE-UP) facility to study the thermofluid dynamic behavior of HLMs in rod bundle configurations with or without wire wrappers. This facility consists of a rectangular loop operated with lead-bismuth eutectic. Sensors across the loop monitor relevant parameters, i.e. temperatures, heat transfer, and flow conditions. Here, in the present work, we carefully select published data from NACIE-UP to validate the System Analysis Module (SAM), a modern system analysis code developed at Argonne National Laboratory. We developed one SAM model using specifications of the facility geometry and materials existing in relevant papers and reports. On top of that, these references provided the boundary conditions for simulating natural circulation and forced convection experiments in either steady or transient conditions. The SAM model simulates five test cases with diverse operating conditions. Ultimately, the code is proven to predict temperatures and mass flow rates that closely match the experiments. The discrepancies between numerical predictions and diverse transients are limited to a few degrees Celsius, showcasing that SAM is well suited for analyzing nuclear systems relying on HLM coolants.

advanced reactors↗

New helium recapture and reliquefier system for Dynamic Nuclear Polarization at UNH.

A new helium recapture and reliquefaction system, consisting of a gas bag, recapture manifold, cooling chiller, cryogenic purifier and, a gas storage cylinder banks, has been installed in the dynamic nuclear polarized target lab at the University of New Hampshire. This new system has the capability to improve the efficiency of our capacity to do target polarization runs by recycling our cryogenic helium which would otherwise be lost during polarization operations. Our helium liquefier is rated upto 40 L/Day under normal full-capacity operations, and is rated for a capacity of 500 liquid liters of helium. I explain the initial installation process followed by a discussion of the challenges with installation, including issues of impurities which appeared during the initial operation of the system. Then I discuss how we overcame these difficulties. Finally, I discuss the function of the system during normal operation and the present situation of the helium recapture and reliquefaction processing in the UNH Lab.

Lama, Chhetra [Univ. of New Hampshire, Durham, NH ↗

2025 Advances in NekRS: Supporting improved performance for nuclear applications

This report presents several 2025 advancements in NekRS, a high-fidelity spectral element CFD code developed at Argonne National Laboratory to support the NEAMS thermal-hydraulics program. The forthcoming v25 release consolidates several of these advances, adding new features for portability across heterogeneous GPU architectures, real-time in situ visualization, improved turbulence modeling, and conjugate heat transfer coupling. Over the past year, NekRS has demonstrated strong scalability and performance on DOE’s leading exascale platforms, including Aurora and Frontier, confirming its readiness for some of the largest and most complex simulations attempted to date. These achievements provide a powerful new platform for high-fidelity data generation, which in turn supports the development and validation of advanced closure models critical for reactor safety and design. Significant algorithmic innovations have also been introduced. A new global runtime h-refinement capability simplifies workflows by reducing mesh preparation burdens and enabling coarse-to-fine restarts. Building on this, a novel multigrid strategy was implemented to accelerate pressure and transport solves at scale, addressing long-standing bottlenecks in exascale CFD. Together, these developments improve both the efficiency and accessibility of high-fidelity simulations for reactor-relevant problems. Collectively, these enhancements represent a major step forward in simulation technology, positioning NekRS as a cornerstone of NEAMS efforts to enable accurate, efficient, and scalable high-fidelity analysis of advanced nuclear systems.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Multiphysics Modeling of Microreactors with NEAMS codes, and Validation Based on KRUSTY Reactivity Insertion

The NEAMS Multiphysics Applications team continues to assess code usability and functionality for microreactor design and safety analyses, while demonstrating that NEAMS tools capture both steady-state and transient behavior across distinct microreactor concepts. In FY2025, the team advanced full-core, high-fidelity, multiphysics models that solve more complex problems and strengthen verification/validation for several microreactor systems: heat-pipe microreactor (HPMR), gas-cooled microreactor (GCMR), and the KRUSTY experiment. These models employ the MOOSE MultiApp/Transfers architecture with Griffin for neutronics, BISON for heat conduction/thermomechanics, Sockeye for heat pipes, SAM/THM for coolant channels and loops, and SWIFT for hydride behavior, with meshes generated via the MOOSE Reactor Module. The graphite models available in the Grizzly code were also investigated for future analyses. For the HPMR, a Na-HPMR variant was constructed to align with recently validated heat-pipe experiments and Sockeye’s LCVF capability, enabling mechanistic heat-pipe transients and startup modeling. The Na-HPMR will serve as the primary model for HPMR investigations in upcoming tasks. The load-following and single heat-pipe failure scenarios (Griffin/BISON/Sockeye), which were previously modeled for the K-HPMR, were replicated for the Na-HPMR, showing strong negative temperature feedback and highly localized thermal effects, respectively, while the startup case captured vapor-front progression and heat-removal activation. Solid mechanics was added to the previously built K-HPMR full-core model in BISON, showing minimal impact on steady-state reactivity yet enabling stress-field predictions that prepare the path for full-core TRISO performance analyses. For the GCMR, automated steady-state and four transient scenarios were executed using Griffin/BISON/SAM/SWIFT. Results confirm robust inherent safety: power collapses promptly in loss-of-cooling events, the inlet-temperature drop settles to a new equilibrium, and a single-channel blockage yields only a ~30 K local fuel-temperature rise with <0.4% power decrease. SWIFT-predicted hydrogen redistribution affects reactivity during both steady-state and transient conditions, underscoring its importance. A Brayton-cycle balance of plant (BOP) model in SAM/THM demonstrated stable startup behavior, and xenon-driven reactivity during load following was analyzed. To improve TRISO-compact temperature fidelity, a fast multiscale Heat Source Decomposition (HSD) treatment was implemented. Against heterogeneous benchmarks, HSD reduces underprediction of kernel temperatures and lowers predicted peak powers in reactivity-insertion transients compared to previous homogenized models. KRUSTY warm-critical validation progressed from FY2024 baselines: the 15Ȼ insertion shows excellent agreement in peak power (~2% high) and temperature trends, and the 30Ȼ case was automated via a feedback controller that maintained power near 3 kW for ~150 s with close agreement to data. The successful modeling of the warm critical tests has laid a strong foundation for simulating more complex nuclear system tests in the years ahead. Throughout FY2025, developer feedback was provided (e.g., MOOSE batch mesh generation, distributed pre-split meshes, Griffin sweeper on displaced meshes), several new models were contributed to the Virtual Test Bed, and an OECD-NEA WPRS multiphysics benchmark based on the HPMR was initiated to enable broader cross-comparison and best-practice development with the nuclear community at large.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Physics-based hybrid machine learning for critical heat flux prediction with uncertainty quantification

Critical heat flux (CHF) is a key quantity in nuclear system modeling due to its impact on heat transfer, safety margins, and reactor performance. This study develops and validates an uncertainty-aware hybrid modeling approach that combines machine learning with physics-based models to predict CHF in cases of dryout. The Biasi and Bowring empirical correlations were paired with three ML uncertainty quantification (UQ) techniques: deep neural network (DNN) ensembles, Bayesian neural networks (BNNs), and deep Gaussian processes (DGPs). A pure ML model without a base model was evaluated for comparison. Model performance was assessed under plentiful (7,350 points) and limited (9 points) training data scenarios using parity, uncertainty distributions, and calibration curves. Results show that the Biasi hybrid DNN ensemble achieved the best overall performance, with a mean absolute relative error of 1.846%, and well-calibrated uncertainty estimates. The BNN-based hybrids showed slightly higher error (2.14%) but superior uncertainty calibration. DGP models underperformed, with over 6% error and poor uncertainty calibration. All hybrid models outperformed pure machine learning configurations, demonstrating resistance against data scarcity. These findings indicate that hybrid modeling significantly improves predictive accuracy, interpretability, and resilience to data scarcity. The integration of uncertainty awareness provides actionable confidence in CHF predictions, which is vital for safety-critical decisions in nuclear applications. This hybrid approach offers a viable pathway for deploying ML models in reactor analysis tools while preserving domain knowledge and physical consistency.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

A full-scope, high-fidelity simulator-based hardware-in-the-loop testbed for comprehensive nuclear power plant cybersecurity research

Nuclear power plant (NPP) cybersecurity research often relies on hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) testbeds that integrate real hardware components into simulated environments. These testbeds allow researchers to identify vulnerabilities, evaluate attack impacts, and test security measures in a controlled setting. Furthermore, previous HIL testbeds lacked fidelity to accurately represent real nuclear systems, limiting the scope of cybersecurity analysis. This study presents the creation of a HIL testbed, devised upon a full-scope, high-fidelity NPP simulator, to facilitate realistic and comprehensive cybersecurity research. To demonstrate its capabilities, the control logic for the steam generator water level was migrated from the simulator to an external programmable logic controller. As a practical application of the developed testbed, supply chain attack scenarios were simulated by injecting malicious code into the controller logic, and the effects of manipulating sensor inputs and control commands were observed. While this HIL testbed provides more detailed simulations, enhanced realism, and wider applicability compared to other options utilizing a less complex simulator, it is also more intricate and costly. For this reason, we include a detailed comparison with some alternative architectures to aid fellow researchers and practitioners in the selection of a suitable HIL architecture based on specific research objectives.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

4.0 MOOSE: Enabling massively parallel Multiphysics simulation

Approaching 18 years of existence, MOOSE—the Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment—is being developed at a higher pace than ever before. With significant support from four research institutions across the globe, and dozens of new contributors, the capabilities of the framework are being expanded to meet modeling challenges in a wide variety of fields from nuclear system design, to geomechanics, to material science. This includes new development in equation discretization techniques, solver methods, meshing capabilities, application deployment, and user interface improvements. Applications built on MOOSE benefit from all these improvements.

22 - GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Multi-material additive manufacturing of aluminum 6061-T6 alloy with stainless steel 304: Suppression of intermetallic compounds and interface growth mechanism

Fabricating integrated aluminum-steel structures is difficult because of metallurgical incompatibilities that promote intermetallic compound (IMC) formation at their interfaces. This work introduces a practical route for additively manufacturing 6061-T6 aluminum alloy (AA6061-T6) directly onto 304 stainless steel (SS304) using a high shear strain rate-assisted interfacial bonding mechanism. Through the friction extrusion deposition-based additive manufacturing method, both single- and multi-layer deposits of AA6061-T6 were successfully fabricated on SS304, yielding a robust hybrid multi-material structure. Comprehensive analyses of deposition quality, interface porosity, and bonding performance showed that the interface achieved a tensile strength exceeding 154 MPa under quasi-static loading. Microstructural observations revealed that the deposited aluminum layers experienced severe plastic deformation, resulting in pronounced grain refinement. Importantly, the interfacial zone was found to be free of brittle IMCs, instead containing a thin amorphous layer that evolved through a non-linear reaction-zone growth law. This solid-state additive strategy establishes a promising pathway for lightweight structural systems, nuclear energy component cladding, and multifunctional engineering components, redefining how dissimilar metals can be integrated for advanced applications.

Aluminum alloy↗

Microstructural stability of irradiated yttrium hydride under thermal cycles

Hydrides that retain their hydrogen in service are critical for advanced microreactor and space nuclear systems. Hydrogen retention is affected by evolving microstructure under temperature and irradiation extremes. This study investigated microstructural features in neutron-irradiated yttrium hydride and the stability of these features under thermal cycles. Differential scanning calorimetry was used to determine hydrogen desorption and temperatures at which significant phase changes are occurring, and transmission electron microscopy was used for microstructural analysis after each thermal cycle. Cyclic heating led to crystallization and epitaxial growth of surface oxidation and dehydriding of the matrix. Other features such as the bulk matrix crystal structure, irradiation-induced cavities, and matrix precipitation remained constant after thermal cycling. Results allow us to design better hydride alloys through microstructure tailoring and potential irradiation conditioning treatments.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

An investigation on machine learning predictive accuracy improvement and uncertainty reduction using VAE-based data augmentation

The confluence of ultrafast computers with large memory, rapid progress in Machine Learning (ML) algorithms, and the availability of large datasets place multiple engineering fields at the threshold of dramatic progress. However, a unique challenge in nuclear engineering is data scarcity because experimentation on nuclear systems is usually more expensive and time-consuming than most other disciplines. One potential way to resolve the data scarcity issue is deep generative learning, which uses certain ML models to learn the underlying distribution of existing data and generate synthetic samples that resemble the real data. In this way, one can significantly expand the dataset to train more accurate predictive ML models. In this study, our objective is to evaluate the effectiveness of data augmentation using variational autoencoder (VAE)-based deep generative models. We investigated whether the data augmentation leads to improved accuracy in the predictions of a deep neural network (DNN) model trained using the augmented data. Additionally, the DNN prediction uncertainties are quantified using Bayesian Neural Networks (BNN) and conformal prediction (CP) to assess the impact on predictive uncertainty reduction. To test the proposed methodology, we used TRACE simulations of steady-state void fraction data based on the NUPEC Boiling Water Reactor Full-size Fine-mesh Bundle Test (BFBT) benchmark. Here, we found that augmenting the training dataset using VAEs has improved the DNN model’s predictive accuracy, improved the prediction confidence intervals, and reduced the prediction uncertainties.

Bayesian neural network↗

A Monte Carlo Laplace Transform Estimator for Radiation Transport

This work formulates and implements a Laplace transform estimator in a simple Monte Carlo radiation transport code. The estimator maps flux-based quantities of interest, like reaction rates, from a desired phase-space dimension to the complex Laplace domain. This on-the-fly Monte Carlo integration technique enables the spectral analysis of arbitrary nuclear systems via the Laplace transform. A simple code tests the estimator in neutron slowing-down problems across various infinite media, and the results compare well with Ganapol’s uninverted analytical solution of the neutron slowing-down equation.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

On two nucleons near unitarity with perturbative pions

We explore the impact of perturbative pions on the Unitarity Expansion in the two-nucleon S-waves of Chiral Effective Field Theory at next-to-next-to leading order (N 2 LO). Pion exchange explicitly breaks the nontrivial fixed point’s universality, i.e. invariance of S waves under both conformal and Wigner’s combined SU(4) spin–isospin transformations. On the other hand, Unitarity explicitly breaks chiral symmetry. The two seem incompatible in their respective exact-symmetry limits. χEFT with Perturbative Pions in the Unitarity Expansion resolves the apparent conflict in the Unitarity Window (phase shifts 45° ≲ δ(k) ≲ 135°), i.e. around momenta most relevant for low-energy nuclear systems. Its only LO scale is the scattering momentum; NLO adds only scattering length, effective range and non-iterated one-pion exchange (OPE); and N 2 LO only once-iterated OPE. Agreement in the 1 S 0 channel is very good.

Chiral symmetry↗