The impact of sodium on the sub-bandgap states in CZTSe and CZTS
We compare the optically active sub-bandgap states in polycrystalline Cu{sub 2}ZnSnSe{sub 4} (CZTSe) and Cu{sub 2}ZnSnS{sub 4} (CZTS) thin films as a function of sodium content. In all samples studied, we find that CZTSe has a lower concentration of radiative defect-derived states compared to CZTS and that the states are also shallower in CZTSe compared to CZTS. Further, we find that sodium impacts the relative ratios of two sub-bandgap peaks in the 4 K photoluminescence (PL) spectra of CZTSe (one at ∼0.85 eV and another at ∼0.92 eV). We propose that both of these sub-bandgap peaks stem from intrinsic point defects in CZTSe rather than from electronic states introduced by sodium; this is supported by a measurement on a sodium-free single-crystal of CZTSe. We also show that films with stronger emission through the shallower sub-bandgap states at 4 K display room-temperature PL closer to the bandgap energy. For all sodium quantities studied, one broad PL peak is observed in the 4 K PL spectrum of CZTS which also shifts towards the band edge with increasing sodium. A reduced overall defect density and the fact that the states that are present are shallower together may help account for the lower V{sub OC} deficits in CZTSe and the empirical observations that sodium improves device performance.