FITTING THE UNION2.1 SUPERNOVA SAMPLE WITH THE R{sub h} = ct UNIVERSE
The analysis of Type Ia supernova data over the past decade has been a notable success story in cosmology. These standard candles offer us an unparalleled opportunity to study the cosmological expansion out to a redshift of {approx}1.5. The consensus today appears to be that {Lambda}CDM offers the best explanation for the luminosity-distance relationship seen in these events. However, a significant incompatibility is now emerging between the standard model and other equally important observations, such as those of the cosmic microwave background. {Lambda}CDM does not provide an accurate representation of the cosmological expansion at high redshifts (z >> 2). It is therefore essential to re-analyze the Type Ia supernova data in light of the cosmology (the R{sub h} = ct universe) that best represents the universe's dynamical evolution at early times. In this paper, we directly compare the distance relationship in {Lambda}CDM with that predicted by R{sub h} = ct, and each with the Union2.1 sample, and show that the two theories produce virtually indistinguishable profiles, though the fit with R{sub h} = ct has not yet been optimized. This is because the data cannot be determined independently of the assumed cosmology-the supernova luminosities must be evaluated by optimizing four parameters simultaneously with those in the adopted model. This renders the data compliant to the underlying theory, so the model-dependent data reduction should not be ignored in any comparative analysis between competing cosmologies. In this paper, we use R{sub h} = ct to fit the data reduced with {Lambda}CDM, and though quite promising, the match is not perfect. An even better fit would result with an optimization of the data using R{sub h} = ct from the beginning.