Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Benchmarks”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 649 records · Page 36

Analysis of the pool critical assembly pressure vessel benchmark using pentran

The internationally circulated Pool Critical Assembly (PCA) Pressure Vessel Benchmark was analyzed using the PENTRAN Parallel Sn code system for the geometry, material, and source specifications as described in the PCA Benchmark documentation. This research focused on utilizing the BUGLE-96 cross section library and accompanying reaction rates, while examining both adaptive differencing on a coarse mesh basis as well as Directional Theta Weighted Sn differencing in order to compare the calculated PENTRAN results to measured data. The results show good comparison with the measured data as well as to the calculated results provided from TORT for the BUGLE-96 cross sections and reaction rates, which suggests PENTRAN is a viable and reliable code system for calculation of light water reactor neutron shielding and dosimetry calculations. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Comet solutions to a stylized BWR benchmark problem

In this paper, a stylized 3-D BWR benchmark problem was used to evaluate the performance of the coarse mesh radiation transport method COMET. The benchmark problem consists of 560 fuel bundles at 3 different burnups and 3 coolant void states. The COMET solution was compared with the corresponding Monte Carlo reference solution using the same 2-group material cross section library for three control blade (rod) configurations, namely, all rods out (ARO), all rods in (ARI) and some rods in (SRJ). The differences in the COMET and MCNP eigenvalues were 43 pcm, 66 pcm and 32 pcm for the ARO, ARI and SRI cases, respectively. These differences are all within 3 standard deviations of the COMET uncertainty. The average relative differences in the bundle averaged fission densities for these three cases were 0.89%, 1.24%, and 1.05%, respectively. The corresponding differences in the fuel pin averaged fission densities were 1.24%, 1.84% and 1.29%, respectively. It was found that COMET is 3,000 times faster than Monte Carlo, while its statistical uncertainty in the fuel pin fission density is much lower than that of Monte Carlo (i.e., {approx}40 times lower). (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

RELAP5-3D results for phase I (Exercise 2) of the OECD/NEA MHTGR-350 MW benchmark

The coupling of the PHISICS code suite to the thermal hydraulics system code RELAP5-3D has recently been initiated at the Idaho National Laboratory (INL) to provide a fully coupled prismatic Very High Temperature Reactor (VHTR) system modeling capability as part of the NGNP methods development program. The PHISICS code consists of three modules: INSTANT (performing 3D nodal transport core calculations), MRTAU (depletion and decay heat generation) and a perturbation/mixer module. As part of the verification and validation activities, steady state results have been obtained for Exercise 2 of Phase I of the newly-defined OECD/NEA MHTGR-350 MW Benchmark. This exercise requires participants to calculate a steady-state solution for an End of Equilibrium Cycle 350 MW Modular High Temperature Reactor (MHTGR), using the provided geometry, material, and coolant bypass flow description. The paper provides an overview of the MHTGR Benchmark and presents typical steady state results (e.g. solid and gas temperatures, thermal conductivities) for Phase I Exercise 2. Preliminary results are also provided for the early test phase of Exercise 3 using a two-group cross-section library and the Relap5-3D model developed for Exercise 2. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Benchmarking of calculation schemes in APOLLO2 and COBAYA3 for WER lattices

This paper presents solutions of the NURISP WER lattice benchmark using APOLLO2, TRIPOLI4 and COBAYA3 pin-by-pin. The main objective is to validate MOC based calculation schemes for pin-by-pin cross-section generation with APOLLO2 against TRIPOLI4 reference results. A specific objective is to test the APOLLO2 generated cross-sections and interface discontinuity factors in COBAYA3 pin-by-pin calculations with unstructured mesh. The VVER-1000 core consists of large hexagonal assemblies with 2 mm inter-assembly water gaps which require the use of unstructured meshes in the pin-by-pin core simulators. The considered 2D benchmark problems include 19-pin clusters, fuel assemblies and 7-assembly clusters. APOLLO2 calculation schemes with the step characteristic method (MOC) and the higher-order Linear Surface MOC have been tested. The comparison of APOLLO2 vs. TRIPOLI4 results shows a very close agreement. The 3D lattice solver in COBAYA3 uses transport corrected multi-group diffusion approximation with interface discontinuity factors of Generalized Equivalence Theory (GET) or Black Box Homogenization (BBH) type. The COBAYA3 pin-by-pin results in 2, 4 and 8 energy groups are close to the reference solutions when using side-dependent interface discontinuity factors. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Yankee Rowe isotopics benchmark using MCNP-XT

The Yankee Rowe spent fuel isotopic data provides a valuable source to benchmark the burnup calculations as part of verification and validation (V and V) efforts for the TerraPower's Monte Carlo depletion code, MCNP-XT. A total of 71 fuel rods were selected in the Yankee Rowe isotopic measurements covering a burnup range up to 44 MWd/kg ({approx}4.4%) under both the asymptotic spectrum and the non-asymptotic spectrum. The MCNP-XT pin cell depletion provides a comparison against the asymptotic spectrum measurement; and full assembly depletion with 322 depletion materials provides comparisons against various non-asymptotic depletion conditions. All calculations are performed based on the recent ENDF/B-VII.O data. Furthermore, the Monte Carlo depletion uncertainties and biases were examined showing their effect as insignificant. The set of burnup calculations cover the scattered experimental measurements demonstrating excellent agreement with the measured values. This benchmark exercise demonstrates the depletion analysis capability of the MCNP-XT code and validates the low burnup range. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Benchmarks for the point kinetics equations

A new numerical algorithm is presented for the solution to the point kinetics equations (PKEs), whose accurate solution has been sought for over 60 years. The method couples the simplest of finite difference methods, a backward Euler, with Richardsons extrapolation, also called an acceleration. From this coupling, a series of benchmarks have emerged. These include cases from the literature as well as several new ones. The novelty of this presentation lies in the breadth of reactivity insertions considered, covering both prescribed and feedback reactivities, and the extreme 8- to 9- digit accuracy achievable. The benchmarks presented are to provide guidance to those who wish to develop further numerical improvements. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Benchmark analysis of high temperature engineering test reactor core using McCARD code

A benchmark calculation has been performed for a startup core physics test of Japan's High Temperature Engineering Test Reactor (HTTR). The calculation is carried out by the McCARD code, which adopts the Monte Carlo method. The cross section library is ENDF-B/VII.0. The fuel cell is modeled by the reactivity-equivalent physical transform (RPT) method. Effective multiplication factors with different numbers of fuel columns have been analyzed. The calculation shows that the HTTR becomes critical with 19 fuel columns with an excess reactivity of 0.84% Δk/k. The discrepancies between the measurements and Monte Carlo calculations are 2.2 and 1.4 % Δk/k for 24 and 30 columns, respectively. The reasons for the discrepancy are thought to be the current version of cross section library and the impurity in the graphite which is represented by the boron concentration. In the future, the depletion results will be proposed for further benchmark calculations. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

International Developments on Uncertainties in NPP Decommissioning costs and planned work on Benchmarking at the OECD-NEA - 17074

The ability to decommission NPPs shut down after normal operation has been proven technically. Issues of current concern include the ability to accurately calculate and demonstrate the validity of decommissioning cost estimates, and to control costs during decommissioning. This paper describes recent international developments concerning addressing uncertainties in NPP decommissioning cost estimation, and work currently being planned relating to decommissioning cost benchmarking at the OECD Nuclear Energy Agency. The process of decommissioning cost estimation is evolving, with a general trend towards showing greater levels of detail in the estimate. The International Structure for Decommissioning Costing was published in 2012 and presents a common reporting format for decommissioning costing undertaken on a deterministic basis. However, this does not address probabilistic methods or associated presentation formats for the inclusion of uncertainties in decommissioning estimates. A consistent and comparable treatment of uncertainties in decommissioning cost estimation would further facilitate comparison between different cost estimates and enhance understanding of and confidence in the estimates themselves. There is growing interest in benchmarking decommissioning costs, reflecting a need to better understand the relationships between estimates and actual costs, to give greater confidence that funding will be sufficient, and as a useful tool in project management and enhancing project delivery. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Engaging Canadian Indigenous Communities and Public Stakeholders Through a US Site Benchmarking Trip - 19358

Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) is proposing a new approach to decommission the WR-1 reactor at its Whiteshell site near Pinawa, Manitoba Canada. To tackle WR-1 CNL is proposing in situ decommissioning, this new approach is subject to a Canadian federal environmental assessment. As part of this CNL is engaging with Indigenous communities and public stakeholders, both regionally and across the country. Nuclear in situ decommissioning is new to Canada but has been used numerous times in the United States. Throughout the environmental assessment process CNL has considered the feedback public and Indigenous groups have provided and has tried to enhance the way information is shared and respond where possible and reasonable. Feedback from some communities has been related to a greater understanding of what the in situ method looks like, how it is monitored, will it perform, and anxiety about having it in the community. CNL sought to respond to this feedback by coordinating a benchmarking trip to an in situ reactor in Hallam, Nebraska. The visit was coordinated around an annual inspection. Several regional stakeholder and Indigenous communities joined CNL on the benchmarking trip. The group witnessed and learned what a decommissioned in situ reactor looked like, how it was performing and the effect on the surrounding communities. The group learned important lessons during the visit, key among them that the entombment is working as designed and has had zero significant detectable effects to the surrounding community. All attendees are now better informed on what CNL's proposal for WR-1 represents and are in a position to better inform their communities and the process moving forward. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Subcritical Benchmark of the BeRP Ball Reflected by Tungsten

In September 2012, eight subcritical configurations were measured with the clad a-phase plutonium sphere known as the Beryllium-Reflected Plutonium (BeRP) ball at the National Criticality Experiments Research Center (NCERC). The configurations had varying tungsten thicknesses including: 0 (bare), 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 2.5, 2.75, and 3.0 inches. Measurements were conducted to provide subcritical benchmark data. This work includes measured and simulated results from the International Handbook of Evaluated Criticality Safety Benchmark Experiments (ICSBEP) evaluation. (authors)

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Benchmark Comparisons of Lattice Physics Calculations for Thorium-Based Fuels in Pressure-Tube Heavy Water Reactors

Thorium is a fertile nuclear fuel resource that is nearly three times as abundant as uranium in the earth's crust and that can be exploited and used to extend uranium resources. The pressure tube heavy water reactor (PTHWR) is an excellent existing technology for utilizing thorium-based fuels, due to its high neutron economy achieved by using heavy water as a moderator and coolant, the ability to perform online refueling, and its flexibility in fuel management. Reactor physics studies are underway at the Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) to evaluate several types of thorium-based fuels that could be implemented in PT-HWRs in the near-term and intermediate future, building upon past experience. For preliminary, conceptual studies, deterministic lattice physics and core physics codes such as WIMS-AECL and RFSP are used to provide quick and more approximate estimates of performance and safety characteristics. The objective of this study was to perform 2D lattice physics benchmark comparisons between WIMS-AECL and MCNP5 for several types of thorium-based fuel bundle lattices for potential use in PT-HWRs. Benchmark comparisons will help confirm the validity of deterministic calculation results, and provide estimates of the potential magnitude of calculation errors and uncertainties. Areas for potential improvements in the WIMS-AECL calculations may also be identified. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Uncertainty Quantification by Monte Carlo Analysis using CFD Simulations for GEMIX Benchmark Activities

Uncertainty quantification (UQ) methods can be applied to computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations for determining the uncertainty bands of the simulations results. In order to determine the applicability of these different methods, simple benchmark activities have been conducted by various group for comparison. The GEMIX (Generic Mixing experiment) test facility was used to develop benchmark data for this purpose by the Paul Scherrer Institute (PSI). The facility involves the mixing of two fluids that are initially separated. One of the two fluids is water with sugar dissolved in it to create a fluid with similar fluid properties to water, except for density. The other fluid was distilled water to reduce the uncertainty in the fluid's properties. During the experiments, velocity fields and concentration measurements were acquired at several planes of interest. The velocity fields were acquired using particle image velocimetry (PIV) and concentrations of each fluid were acquired using laser induced fluorescence (LIF). The inlet velocity profiles were acquired using laser Doppler velocimetry (LDV). The activity provided the opportunity to vary turbulence models, meshing methodologies, and numerical schemes for creation of uncertainty estimates. The present study investigates the usage of a simple Monte Carlo (MC) technique for varying the inlet boundary conditions of each inlet. The velocity profiles and densities of each inlet were specifically varied based on experiment measurement uncertainty. The intent was to isolate the uncertainty due to inlet quantities and not related to meshing, numerical scheme, or turbulence models. The comparisons of experimental and simulation results were found to be reasonably accurate. Though deficiencies were identified in the modeling approach to be corrected in future works by the authors. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Evaluation of Rapid for a UNF cask benchmark problem

To ensure criticality safety and maintain a high level of security of Used Nuclear Fuel (UNF), it is necessary to perform detailed Particle Transport simulations. The commonly used technique is the 3-D, continuous energy Monte Carlo method that is time-consuming and, for eigenvalue calculations, may have difficulties with the source convergence. Wenner and Haghighat and Dufek demonstrated that in criticality problems with high dominance ratio and/or under-sampling possibilities, the fission matrix (FM) methodology should be used in order to be able to obtain unbiased solution. The RAPID (Real-time Analysis for Particle transport and In-situ Detection) code system is based on the Multi-stage Response-function Transport (MRT) methodology, and uses the FM formulation to determine eigenvalue, subcritical multiplication and fission density distribution of nuclear systems. This paper uses a benchmark problem similar to the GBC-32 Cask to evaluate the accuracy and performance of RAPID against the results of a reference MCNP solution. We performed a detailed sensitivity analysis on a single-assembly model in order to determine the MCNP eigenvalue parameters necessary to obtain a reliable reference solution. These results provided a guide for the selection of an appropriate set of parameters for the eigenvalue calculation for the whole cask. The paper is organized as follows: initially, the RAPID code system is briefly discussed; then, the benchmark problem is introduced. The methodology used to analyze results is proposed and some of the results of different cases are analyzed to identify the best set of eigenvalue parameters for a reference MCNP calculation. The selected case is then compared with the RAPID calculation for both a single assembly and a full cask model. In the end some conclusions and future work perspectives are drawn.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Application of the Hybrid Diffusion-Transport Spatial Homogenization Method to a Pressurized Water Reactor Benchmark Problem - Paper 70

The recently developed Hybrid Diffusion-Transport Spatial Homogenization (DTH) method was previously tested on a benchmark problem typical of a boiling water reactor. In this summary, the DTH method is tested in a 1-D benchmark problem typical of a pressurized water reactor. The method recreates the heterogeneous flux to within 1% average flux error and 34 pcm eigenvalue error in half the time as a heterogeneous transport calculation. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Evaluation of the concrete shield compositions from the 2010 criticality accident alarm system Benchmark experiments at the CEA VALDUC silene facility - 14454

In October 2010, a series of benchmark experiments were conducted at the French Commissariat a l'energie Atomique et aux energies Alternatives (CEA) Valduc SILENE facility. These experiments were a joint effort between the United States Department of Energy Nuclear Criticality Safety Program and the CEA. The purpose of these experiments was to create three benchmarks for the verification and validation of radiation transport codes and evaluated nuclear data used in the analysis of criticality accident alarm systems. This series of experiments consisted of three single-pulsed experiments with the SILENE reactor. For the first experiment, the reactor was bare (unshielded), whereas in the second and third experiments, it was shielded by lead and polyethylene, respectively. The polyethylene shield of the third experiment had a cadmium liner on its internal and external surfaces, which vertically was located near the fuel region of SILENE. During each experiment, several neutron activation foils and thermoluminescent dosimeters (TLDs) were placed around the reactor. Nearly half of the foils and TLDs had additional high-density magnetite concrete, high-density barite concrete, standard concrete, and/or BoroBond shields. CEA Saclay provided all the concrete, and the US Y-12 National Security Complex provided the BoroBond. Measurement data from the experiments were published at the 2011 International Conference on Nuclear Criticality (ICNC 2011) and the 2013 Nuclear Criticality Safety Division (NCSD 2013) topical meeting. Preliminary computational results for the first experiment were presented in the ICNC 2011 paper, which showed poor agreement between the computational results and the measured values of the foils shielded by concrete. Recently the hydrogen content, boron content, and density of these concrete shields were further investigated within the constraints of the previously available data. New computational results for the first experiment are now available that show much better agreement with the measured values. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Benchmark Models and experimental data for a U(20)-Polyethylene-moderated critical system - 14650

This work involves the analysis of recent experiments performed on the Aerojet General Nucleonics (AGN)-201M (AGN) polyethylene-moderated research reactor at the University of New Mexico (UNM). The experiments include 36 delayed critical (DC) configurations and 11 positive-period and rod-drop measurements (transient sequences). The Even Parity Neutron Transport (EVENT) radiation transport code was chosen to analyze these steady state and time-dependent experimental configurations. The UNM AGN specifications provided in a benchmark calculation report (2007) were used to initiate AGN EVENT model development and to test the EVENT AGN calculation methodology. The results of the EVENT DC experimental analyses compared well with the experimental data; the average AGN EVENT calculation bias in the k{sub eff} is -0.0048% for the Legendre Flux Expansion Order of 11 (P{sub 11}) cases and +0.0119% for the P{sub 13} cases. The EVENT transient analysis also compared well with the AGN experimental data with respect to predicting the reactor period and control rod worth values. This paper discusses the benchmark models used, the recent experimental configurations, and the EVENT experimental analysis. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

RELAP5-3D Solutions to Exercise 1 of the OECD-NEA HTTF Benchmark

The high-temperature gas-cooled reactor (HTGR) is an advanced reactor concept that has received considerable attention over the last 60 years. HTGRs boast high coolant outlet temperatures, passive safety, and large margins to fuel failure. Recent years have seen increasing interest in HTGRs, whether large-scale HTGRs for electricity or process heat applications or as microreactors serving remote communities. HTGRs have considerable potential to fulfill these applications, but modeling and simulation tools typically used for reactor safety analysis have not been validated for HTGR modeling. The High-Temperature Test Facility (HTTF) was constructed at Oregon State University (OSU) to provide validation data for HTGR modeling. Recently, Idaho National Laboratory (INL), OSU, Argonne National Laboratory, Canadian Nuclear Laboratories, and the University of Tennessee Knoxville have collaborated to develop an HTGR thermal hydraulics benchmark based on HTTF experiments. This summary presents results from a portion of that benchmark using RELAP5-3D

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Whole core analysis of OECD/NEA TVA-WB1 benchmark exercise 1 using continuous-energy Monte Carlo code MVP with JENDL-4.0u and ENDF/B-VII.0

The TVA WB1 benchmark problem was precisely modeled in accordance with the geometry and material specifications, and benchmark exercise 1 was solved with the MVP code and the nuclear data libraries based on JENDL-4.0u (JENDL-4.0 updated file) and ENDF/B-VII.0. The criticality, the control rod bank worth, the isothermal temperature coefficient (ITC), the integral rod worth of bank D, and differential soluble boron worth (DBW) were obtained. The criticality and the control rod bank worth were compared with the measured data and published calculation results with other codes, Serpent and KENO. The criticality and the control rod bank worth calculated by MVP and the libraries agree with the measured and the published calculation results within the criteria specified in the ANSI/ANS standard. From these results, the calculation model for the MVP and the libraries was verified. The other parameters such as ITC, the integral rod worth, and DBW were also compared between JENDL-4.0u and ENDF/B-VII.0. The comparison of the results shows JENDL-4.0u and ENDF/B-VII.0 give comparable results within the standard deviation, the difference between libraries is small. (author)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗