Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Membrane Carbonation”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 631 records · Page 35
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

Insights into determining pore size properties of ultrafiltration membranes

The selectivity of porous membranes is often characterized using solute rejection tests, where membranes are challenged with dilute aqueous solutions of neutral solutes at operating conditions that minimize concentration polarization and fouling. In single solute tests, a membrane is challenged with one molecular weight (MW) solute at a time from low to high MW. Since single solute methods are time-intensive, mixed solute tests have become more common, where a mixture of several MW solutes challenges a membrane at once. However, the presence of large solutes in a mixture increases the rejection of smaller solutes. Furthermore, there are no universally accepted operating conditions or standard methods used by membrane manufacturers or researchers for the experiments, leading to difficulty in pore size and pore characteristic comparisons. In this paper, commercial ultrafiltration membranes were challenged with single and mixed solute polyethylene glycol (PEG) and dextran aqueous solutions. First, rejection values determined using total organic carbon (TOC) and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) from single solute filtration experiments are compared. Differences in rejection curves obtained by the two techniques are attributed to solute polydispersity. Mixed solute filtration experiments with binary mixtures of solutes showcased co-solute interactions, which increase with both the size and weight percent of large solute in the mixture. Mixed solute filtration experiments at varying operating conditions (i.e., stir speed and flux) were conducted to determine operating conditions that mitigate co-solute interactions. Stir speed had a minimal effect on co-solute interactions. In contrast, low flux conditions can help minimize co-solute interactions, leading to pore size distributions that closely resemble results observed in single solute filtration using narrowly dispersed solutes. Additionally, at low flux conditions, the predicted membrane pore size distributions utilizing mixed solute experiments with PEG and dextran were similar.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Improvements in Ionic Liquid Technology for Carbon Dioxide Removal Applications

Carbon dioxide removal from cabin air continues to be of vital importance for future space missions. Current and proposed approaches have employed solid sorbents, hollow fiber membrane separators, and direct liquid sorbent contactors. Recent developments in ionic liquids have potential to improve performance in all three of these technologies. Efficient encapsulation of ionic liquids by polymeric shell can enable their use in a solid sorbent-like configuration without significant integration intervention to the current space technology. Poly(ionic liquid)-ionic liquid membranes have the potential to cross over the Robeson selectivity-permeability upper bound, and thereby outperform traditional membranes used in hollow fibers. Advances in ionic liquid chemistry enables performance improvements in liquid sorbent contactors owing to the tunable gravimetric CO2 capacity, reaction enthalpy and liquid viscosity. This paper will describe recent work in each of these areas.

Ionic Liquid,Carbon Dioxide,Air Revitalization↗
DOE OSTI2020

Lignin-derived electrochemical energy materials and systems

Electrochemical energy storage systems such as supercapacitors, rechargeable batteries and fuel cells have been proven the most effective technologies for energy conversion, storage, and management at different scales. Although a large number of electrochemical energy technologies have been developed in the past and they will continue to be optimized in terms of cost, lifetime, and performance, there is a substantial growing demand for advanced electrochemical energy systems. To deploy these advanced systems, the electrode and electrolyte materials with higher performance, longer life, and lower cost, must be developed. Lignin is the second most abundant natural polymer after cellulose, a byproduct from emerging cellulosic biorefineries, and a waste product from pulp and paper industries. Numerous researches have successfully demonstrated that lignin from different sources can be used as precursors or feedstocks for preparing high-performance electrochemical energy materials and components such as electrodes, electrolytes, membrane separators, and additives. Moreover, techno-economic analyses indicate that it is possible to prepare cost-effective carbons from lignin at engineering scales, compared to current carbon products. These facts suggest that scalable conversion of lignin into high-value energy materials will offer a promising pathway to not only promote the utilization and valorization of lignin but also boost the development of the advanced electrochemical energy systems. This review presents state of the arts of renewable energy materials derived from various lignin and their applications in electrochemical energy systems with emphasis on supercapacitors, rechargeable batteries, and fuel cells. Meanwhile, this article also aims to carve out the critical barriers for lignin-derived high-performance materials for energy applications, intending to identify viable approaches for synthesis of sustainable new energy materials.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗
DOE OSTI2021

Current status of biogas upgrading for direct biomethane use: A review

Anaerobic digestion produces biogas, a mixture of CH 4 and CO 2 , where CH 4 is a low cost, environmentally friendly, and renewable energy source. The application of biogas production is increasing rapidly as a means of reducing the pollution impact of organic biomasses. However, biogas contains unwanted elements such as hydrogen sulfide, carbon monoxide, siloxanes, and carbon dioxide. To remove these elements, several biogas upgrading technologies like water scrubbing, amine scrubbing, pressure swing adsorption, and membrane separation have been developed and are being used at various commercial scales. Problems with these methods are high energy consumption, the use of expensive chemicals, and high operating cost. Therefore, a major effort is currently underway to improve the design of existing methods as well as developing innovative new upgrading technologies such as cryogenic separation and biological upgrading. Here, this review intends to provide a comprehensive overview of the limitations with the existing upgrading technologies along with recent advances in physical, chemical, and biological biogas upgrading technologies (e.g., pressure swing adsorption, membrane separation, biochar adsorption and CO 2 conversion by biological organisms) and further into possible future solutions, such as hybrid systems. Comparative studies of process complexities and associated economic concerns are also provided, and future perspectives that may facilitate research into sustainable biogas upgrading technologies are discussed, focusing in particular on cryogenic separation, novel biological techniques, biochar based upgrading and hybrid technologies incorporating two or more different methods seamlessly integrated.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗
DOE OSTI2024

Intensification and Integration of Hydrogen and Ammonia Production

In this project the Colorado School of Mines developed a more efficient method for on-site and on-demand generation of high purity hydrogen from ammonia for hydrogen fueling stations. Used primarily as a fertilizer, ammonia is the world’s highest volume commodity chemical. Having 17.6% hydrogen by mass, it also shows potential as a hydrogen carrier and carbon-free fuel. The team developed new technology to generate fuel cell quality hydrogen from ammonia using a catalytic membrane reactor (CMR). In addition, during the project we pivoted to use this CMR technology for the production of NH3/H2 mixtures for use in clean combustion applications. We demonstrated that these mixtures may serve as a drop-in replacement for conventional hydrocarbons such as natural gas. This project entails development of new catalysts, new membranes, and their innovative integration. This project helped generate >$4M in follow on funding at Mines, and resulted in the formation of a clean tech startup, Blaze Energy Technologies, which has licensed IP developed in this project and is working to commercialize this technology.

08 HYDROGEN↗
DOE OSTI2022

Operating Strategies for Dispatchable PEM Electrolyzers that Enable Low-Cost Hydrogen Production

Hydrogen is a pathway to enabling decarbonization across multiple economic sectors that cannot be directly decarbonized with electricity including heat for industrial operations, medium- and heavy-duty transportation applications, long-duration energy storage, and as a feedstock for chemical synthesis. Producing hydrogen at low costs and carbon footprint is likely essential to economically decarbonize these otherwise "hard to decarbonize" sectors. Low-temperature polymer electrolyte membrane (PEM) electrolysis produces hydrogen from water and electricity and is a rapidly developing pathway towards making hydrogen at the scales required for decarbonization applications. The levelized cost of electrolytic hydrogen is dependent on the capital cost, efficiency, and durability of the electrolyzer system as well as the price of electricity supplied to the electrolyzer and the annual utilization of the electrolyzer (capacity factor). Electricity price and capacity factor depend on the source of energy that the system uses and impact other economic factors. Electricity price and capacity factor and the connections between other aspects of hydrogen production via PEM electrolyzers are the focus of this work. PEM electrolyzers have conventionally been operated at high capacity factors using electricity purchased from utilities with a constant price throughout the year. To achieve lower effective electricity prices, recent work has investigated opportunities for electrolyzers to purchase electricity in wholesale markets, where the cost of electricity varies hourly. This option can lead to lower electricity costs when the electrolyzer is a controllable load that ramps up and down rapidly and turns on and off frequently. This configuration and operating strategy capitalizes on times of low wholesale electricity prices and results in lower hydrogen levelized costs than constant operation due to reduced electricity costs even though the reduced capacity factor increases the cost of recovering the capital investment. Cycling on and off frequently also has implications for electrolyzer durability. An electrolyzer configuration where it is directly connected to renewable generation such as wind or solar, only running when the generator is producing energy, has similar implications on operating strategy, hydrogen levelized cost, capacity factor, and durability. This work provides insight into the relationships between dispatchable electrolyzer operating strategies and the cost of producing hydrogen from these systems, outlining strategies and opportunities to minimize production costs while minimizing operations that are likely to negatively impact system durability and efficiency. We find strategies that minimize electrolyzer cycling and the resulting durability impacts while increasing the hydrogen levelized cost only slightly above the minimum. We also find opportunities for batteries to minimize the number of cycles in systems directly connected to renewable generation. These findings outline key opportunities for future electrolyzer deployments and the synergistic benefits between electrolyzers and increased deployment of renewable energy generation like wind and solar. They also inform research and development that is reducing electrolyzer capital cost while managing durability impacts.

electricity markets↗
NASA NTRS2003

NASA Tech Briefs, March 2003

Topics covered include: Tool for Bending a Metal Tube Precisely in a Confined Space; Multiple-Use Mechanisms for Attachment to Seat Tracks; Force-Measuring Clamps; Cellular Pressure-Actuated Joint; Block QCA Fault-Tolerant Logic Gates; Hybrid VLSI/QCA Architecture for Computing FFTs; Arrays of Carbon Nanotubes as RF Filters in Waveguides; Carbon Nanotubes as Resonators for RF Spectrum Analyzers; Software for Viewing Landsat Mosaic Images; Updated Integrated Mission Program; Software for Sharing and Management of Information; Update on Integrated Optical Design Analyzer; Optical-Quality Thin Polymer Membranes; Rollable Thin Shell Composite-Material Paraboloidal Mirrors; Folded Resonant Horns for Power Ultrasonic Applications; Touchdown Ball-Bearing System for Magnetic Bearings; Flux-Based Deadbeat Control of Induction-Motor Torque; Block Copolymers as Templates for Arrays of Carbon Nanotubes; Throttling Cryogen Boiloff To Control Cryostat Temperature; Collaborative Software Development Approach Used to Deliver the New Shuttle Telemetry Ground Station; Turbulence in Supercritical O2/H2 and C7H16/N2 Mixing Layers; and Time-Resolved Measurements in Optoelectronic Microbioanal.

Source record↗
DOE OSTI2026

Enhancing Acidic Oxygen Evolution Activity by Supporting Iridium Electrocatalysts on Tantalum Carbide

For a high-performance proton exchange membrane water electrolyzer (PEMWE), acidic oxygen evolution reaction (OER) electrocatalysts require highly dispersed iridium oxide (IrO x ) nanoparticles. Although carbon-based materials have been explored as promising supports for IrO x nanoparticles, their limited stability under harsh oxidative and acidic PEMWE conditions remains a significant challenge. Here, in this study, we report the synthesis and in situ characterization of active and durable IrOx electrocatalysts supported on electrochemically stable and electrically conducting tantalum carbide (TaC). When applied in a PEMWE, the IrO x /TaC electrocatalyst achieves a cell voltage of 1.71 V at 1.0 A cm –2 , outperforming the commercial IrO 2 catalyst (1.82 V at 1.0 A cm –2 ). Furthermore, the IrO x /TaC catalyst maintains a stable operation for 200 h at 0.5 A cm –2 with a low degradation rate of 36 μV h –1 . Density functional theory calculations further confirm that Ir–O–Ta bond formation at the IrO x /TaC interface reduces the overpotential of the OER compared to IrO 2 . This study underscores the pivotal role of supporting IrO x over stable and conducting metal carbides, providing guidance for the design of advanced acidic OER catalysts.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2020

Influence of Coating Method on the Performance of Roll-to-Roll Coated PEM Fuel Cell Catalyst Layers

As production of fuel cell vehicles and power systems increases there is a need to understand the process science of fuel cell manufacturing. Industrial production of polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) electrodes will rely on continuous roll-to-roll (R2R) coating methods to meet the rates needed for mass production. There are a variety of coating methods that could be used to coat catalyst layers. The different physics of each method may result in different morphologies and performance. Here we present the results of a study comparing fuel cell catalyst layers coated using two R2R coating methods: slot-die and gravure. These two methods were selected because the physics of applying the liquid to the substrate is very different between the two cases. Pt/C catalysts layers were coated directly onto carbon-fiber gas diffusion media to create gas diffusion electrodes (GDEs), without the use of a decal transfer process. These GDEs were assembled into membrane electrode assemblies (MEAs) by hot pressing to Nafion membranes. In situ performance and other electrochemical diagnostics were used to determine the influence of coating method on catalyst layer electrochemical properties. Electron microscopy was utilized to understand the influence of coating method on electrode morphology and its influence on electrochemical properties. We also explored the influence of solvent ratio to understand the potential coupling between ink formulation and coating methodology.

DIRECT ENERGY CONVERSION,MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Spatially resolved performance and degradation in a perfluorinated anion exchange membrane fuel cell

Anion exchange membrane fuel cells may enable future operation with non-precious metal-based catalysts. These systems have a delicate sensitivity to operating conditions such as humidification levels and the presence of CO2 in the air oxidant stream. We present spatially resolved in-situ performance results that shed light on phenomena that are unique to anion exchange membrane fuel cells. For cell construction, a highly conductive perfluorinated anion exchange polymer was used as the membrane and the material in powder form as the ionomer. Experiments were conducted to investigate the effects of humidification, fuel/oxidant concentration, and carbonation effects on the performance and its distribution in the cell. The results indicated that (i) dry conditions at the cathode have a stronger effect than at the anode on overall cell performance, (ii) performance significantly suffered when humidification was below 90%, (iii) fuel and oxidant dilution effects lead mass-transport losses and were stronger than flow rate effects, (iv) CO2 in the cathode feed stream creates an equilibration disparity between the inlet and outlet sections and CO2 purging is affected by flooding conditions, and (v) after >500 h of operation, performance deteriorates predominantly at the inlet.

2+1D fuel cell model↗
DOE OSTI2020

Decoupling copolymer, lipid and carbon nanotube interactions in hybrid, biomimetic vesicles

Bilayer vesicles that mimic a real biological cell can be tailored to carry out a specific function by manipulating the molecular composition of the amphiphiles. These bio-inspired and bio-mimetic structures are increasingly being employed for a number of applications from drug delivery to water purification and beyond. Complex hybrid bilayers are the key building blocks for fully synthetic vesicles that can mimic biological cell membranes, which often contain a wide variety of molecular species. While the assembly and morpholgy of pure phospholid bilayer vesicles is well understood, the functionality and structure dramaticlly changes when copolymer and/or carbon nanotube porins (CNTP) are added. The aim of this study is to understand how the collective molecular interactions within hybrid vesicles affect their nanoscale structure and properties. In situ small and wide angle X-ray scattering (SAXS/WAXS) and molecular dynamics simulations (MD) are used to investigate the morphological effect of molecular interactions between polybutadiene polyethylene oxide, lipids and carbon nanotubes (CNT) within the hybrid vesicle bilayer. Within the lipid/copolymer system, the hybrid bilayer morphology transitions from phase separated lipid and compressed copolymer at low copolymer loadings to a mixed bilayer where opposing lipids are mostly separated from the inner region. This transition begins between 60 wt% and 70 wt%, with full homogenization observed by 80 wt% copolymer. The incorporation of CNT into the hybrid vesicles increases the bilayer thickness and enhances the bilayer symmetry. Analysis of the WAXS and MD indicate that the CNT–dioleoyl interactions are much stronger than the CNT–polybutadiene.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2025

A Business Case Evaluation of Gas Switching Reforming (GSR) Technology: A Promising Technology for Natural Gas Reforming with Integrated CO2 Capture

Hydrogen is essential in the transition to sustainable energy, and developing low-carbon production methods is a key research focus. Traditional steam methane reforming (SMR) dominates the hydrogen industry but contributes substantially to CO2 emissions. In response, Gas Switching Reforming (GSR) has emerged as a novel process that integrates carbon capture and utilizes process heat more efficiently. Unlike other reforming methods, GSR consolidates oxidation and reduction reactions within a single reactor, which minimizes external energy inputs and simplifies scaling. Like conventional steam methane reforming (SMR), GSR can be integrated with water-gas shift and pressure swing adsorption units for pure hydrogen production. This work presents a comprehensive business case analysis of GSR technology based on experimental results in Technology Readiness Level 3, Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and Techno-Economic (TEA) evaluation incorporating ASPEN Plus process modeling considering different configurations and energy scenarios. The TEA incorporates data from kinetic experiments from various catalysts to evaluate the GSR process under various conditions. The goal of this work is to evaluate GSR’s potential to serve as a low-carbon alternative to SMR, focusing on global warming potential and additional impact categories to evaluate a wide spectrum of environmental impacts. Comparative assessments were conducted with SMR, chemical loop reforming (CLR), and proton exchange membrane (PEM) electrolysis to explore trade-offs across environmental metrics. The environmental impact assessment of this work encompasses the entire hydrogen production lifecycle from raw material extraction to plant decommissioning, using a cradle-to-gate boundary. Preliminary findings highlight that GSR, when integrated with low-carbon energy sources, could significantly reduce environmental impacts, making it a promising candidate for low-carbon hydrogen infrastructure. The insights from this business case evaluation aim to guide industry in scale-up and commercialization of this promising clean energy technology.

03 NATURAL GAS↗
DOE OSTI2022

Simulation of methanol synthesis in a membrane-contactor reactor

In a recent paper we investigated experimentally in the laboratory the methanol synthesis (MeS) reaction in a novel high-pressure membrane reactor (MR) using tetraethylene glycol dimethyl ether (TGDE) and an ionic liquid (IL) as the sweep liquids. We reported significantly higher carbon conversion (per single-pass) compared to a traditional packed-bed reactor (PBR), as a result of the in-situ removal of methanol by the sweep liquid. Here, in this paper, a steady-state model is developed to simulate the MR behavior during MeS and is validated by the experimental data. The model is then used to study the reactor behavior for a broader range of operating conditions beyond those that can be accessed and studied experimentally in the laboratory-scale reactor. Converting the model equations into their dimensionless form helps to identify the key dimensionless groups determining reactor performance, enables one to better evaluate the efficacy of the MR system, and guides further process design and scale-up.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Nafion Inhibits Polysulfide Crossover in Hybrid Nonaqueous Redox Flow Batteries

Here, we report on the effectiveness of sodium-exchanged Nafion membranes for inhibiting polysulfide crossover during redox flow battery operation. The solubility of polysulfides allows them to be used as a high-capacity catholyte for nonaqueous redox flow batteries (NARFB). The NARFB cathode capacity is controlled by the total tank catholyte volume and polysulfide concentration and, as such, is independent of polysulfide adsorption sites on carbon fibers or nanotubes as found within traditional Na or Li–S batteries. However, one of the major barriers to the realization of polysulfide NARFBs is associated with developing a robust membrane that has minimal polysulfide crossover under the operating conditions. We found that sodium-exchanged Nafion membrane separators effectively inhibit polysulfide crossover within a Na–sulfur NARFB. These membranes significantly improve both capacity retention (70%) and Coulombic efficiencies (99%) after 50 cycles. Commercial porous membranes showed a large crossover as detected by UV–vis spectroscopy and resulted in low capacity retention (20%) and Coulombic efficiency (74%) after 45 cycles. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) measurements highlighted the trade-off between innate reactivity and ionic conduction of the membranes. The results show that dense, single ion conducting Nafion enables a long cycle life; however, it reacts with Na metal to form a resistive passivation layer and increases the cell resistance. On the contrary, the open pore structure of Celgard allows for higher current charge/discharge, and its chemical nature is compatible with Na; however, it has a high degree of polysulfide crossover.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Favorable morphology and electronic conductivity of functional sublayers for highly efficient water splitting electrodes

Low electronic conductivities and improper morphologies of anode electrodes greatly limit the reaction area, catalyst utilization and efficiency in proton exchange membrane water electrolyzers. In this study, conductive sublayers with different conductivities and morphologies were introduced into anode electrodes in membrane-based water electrolyzers. In-situ and ex-situ investigation results showed that conductive sublayers (Au mesh and carbon nanotube (CNT) film) augmented the sheet conductivity of anode electrodes by up to 4000 times (from 2000 to 0.5 ohm square -1 ), and the ohmic resistance of water electrolyzers was reduced to 1/3 when inserting conductive sublayers. In addition, CNT film provided a higher electrochemical active area than Au mesh, because of favorable morphologies (large porosity and surface area) of CNT fibers on CNT films. Therefore, the current density of water splitting was increased by 3 times (from 4.55 mA cm -2 to 14.83 mA cm -2 ) at 2.5 V compared to a conventional anode electrode. Visualizations on bubble dynamics showed improved performances with conductive sublayers; this was mainly due to greatly increased number of reaction sites, highly spread reaction area (from 50 to 1000 um), and reduced activation overpotential. Therefore, a balance between high electronic conductivity and nanoporous morphology is essential to the anode electrode for larger reaction sites and areas in highly efficient water electrolyzers.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Separation of isoprene from biologically-derived gas streams

Renewable organic precursors, including olefinic compounds such as isoprene, have attracted interest from the polymer and pharmaceutical industries. Biologically-derived processes can generate these target compounds; however, their gaseous product streams are complex mixtures of condensable organic vapors (COVs), water vapor, carbon dioxide (CO 2 ), and/or nitrogen (N 2 ). Because COVs, CO 2 and water vapor are known to alter polymer membranes, mixed gas separations data at ambient and elevated temperatures are limited. Here, this study focused on two classes of polymer membranes, glassy [polyetherimide (Ultem®)] and a rubbery [polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS)] with results indicating that isoprene separation is possible in humidified gas environment (2–4 vol% water). Gas permeabilities of these membranes did not noticeably change in the presence of humidity; however, the selectivity of these membranes was significantly lower compared to their performance under dry conditions. The role of water vapor in gas transport was derived from the energy of activation of permeation (E p ) for PDMS and Ultem® from 30–80°C in humidified mixed gas streams. For both polymers, E p data shows a slight decrease in selectivity with the other gases (hydrogen, N 2 , CO 2 , and methane) at elevated temperatures in the presence of water vapor. Thus, these COVs separations are feasible with polymer membranes in the presence of humidified gas streams, even in the case of glassy and rubbery membranes in series.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2024

Photocatalytic Generation of Singlet Oxygen by Graphitic Carbon Nitride for Antibacterial Applications

Carbon-based functional nanocomposites have emerged as potent antimicrobial agents and can be exploited as a viable option to overcome antibiotic resistance of bacterial strains. In the present study, graphitic carbon nitride nanosheets are prepared by controlled calcination of urea. Spectroscopic measurements show that the nanosheets consist of abundant carbonyl groups and exhibit apparent photocatalytic activity under UV photoirradiation towards the selective production of singlet oxygen. Therefore, the nanosheets can effectively damage the bacterial cell membranes and inhibit the growth of bacterial cells, such as Gram-negative Escherichia coli, as confirmed in photodynamic, fluorescence microscopy, and scanning electron microscopy measurements. The results from this research highlight the unique potential of carbon nitride derivatives as potent antimicrobial agents.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

U.S. Indirect and Direct Potable Water Reuse Systems (2020)

Collection of proposed, operating, demonstration, and pilot study potable reuse systems across the U.S. as of 2020. Information includes project name, location, augmentation type, capacity, year operational, treatment train, and source water type. References are included in this submission. As potable reuse facilities undergo expansions or upgrades, treatment trains and capacities are subject to change. Operational status may also change. Treatment trains listed are reported to the detail that the source provides. Type and doses of chemical post-treatment or chlorination is often not specified. Please see README section in spreadsheet for definitions of acronyms used.

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗