Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Discrete Element Modeling”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 631 records · Page 35

Regularized Finite Element Formulations for Shear Band Instabilities in Metals

In my research I have addressed several fundamental issues of dynamic fracture: 1. established the role of heat conduction as a natural regularizing mechanism in shearband problems (i.e. using the correct physics for this problem), 2. developed a unified model to incorporate fracture through a modified phase field formulation, 3. developed stability analysis tools to determine the onset of localization, 4. developed discretization methods and solvers to solve this problem (on parallel computers) that lead to mesh insensitive results and fast convergence. For such difficult problems, the physics and numerics are strongly coupled. To accurately model the physics, one must develop reliable numerics but reliable numerics depends on correct description of the physics. To this end, we have already made significant progress in the field showing that a fully-coupled implicit solution with heat conduction is the key to obtain reliable results for shear bands (see the next sections for more details). This research fits well within the mission of DOE ASCR program on all aspects: from governing equations to discretization to solvers to parallel computers to applications problems. It also relies on the computational tools developed through the SciDAC institutes FASTMath and SDAV, such as PETSc (and SLEPc), ParaView, Trilinos and Masquite.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

A general framework for substructuring-based domain decomposition methods for models having nonlocal interactions [including apppendix B]

A rigorous mathematical framework is provided for a substructuring-based domain-decomposition approach for nonlocal problems that feature interactions between points separated by a finite distance. Here, by substructuring it is meant that a traditional geometric configuration for local partial differential equation problems is used in which a computational domain is subdivided into non-overlapping subdomains. In the nonlocal setting, this approach is substructuring-based in the sense that those subdomains interact with neighboring domains over interface regions having finite volume, in contrast to the local PDE setting in which interfaces are lower dimensional manifolds separating abutting subdomains Key results include the equivalence between the global, single-domain nonlocal problem and its multi-domain reformulation, both at the continuous and discrete levels. These results provide the rigorous foundation necessary for the development of efficient solution strategies for nonlocal domain-decomposition methods.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Quantifying the Uncertainty in Deterministic Phonon Transport Calculations of Thermal Conductivity using Polynomial Chaos Expansions

The nature of computational simulations requires the inclusion of an uncertainty analysis, as we have limited knowledge of all physically determined input parameters for a computationally simulated problem. We rely on uncertainty quantification (UQ) to characterize our confidence in the outcomes. Quantifying uncertainty can provide a basis for certifications in high-consequence decisions, such as nuclear reactor design, and is a fundamental component of model validation. We employ a previously developed method of uncertainty quantification, polynomial chaos expansion with stochastic collocation (PCE-SC), applied to deterministic phonon transport simulations. In these simulations, we use the neutron transport code Rattlesnake, which solves the Self-Adjoint Angular Flux (SAAF) formulation of the transport equation with a continuous finite element (CFEM) spatial discretization and discrete ordinates, spherical harmonics angular discretizations. Rattlesnake was developed in the multi-physics object oriented simulation environment (MOOSE) framework. We have previously shown Rattlesnake to be effective in simulating phonon transport. We aim to provide a deterministic phonon transport framework for heterogeneous nuclear fuel with fission product defects to predict thermal conductivity (?). A first principles, physics-based calculation of thermal conductivity must involve factors such as the microstructure of nuclear fuel, which constantly changes during the fission process through the formation of isotopic decay products. Heat transport in oxide nuclear fuels is dominated by phonon transport. Impurities in the bulk material influence the transport of energy at the fundamental level, altering the scattering behavior of phonons and electrons. Conventionally, heat transport follows classical physics based on the heat equation derived from Fourier's law q = -k∇T, where q is heat flux, k is thermal conductivity and ∇T is a temperature gradient. However, Fourier's law is a macroscopic empirical law in which the thermal conductivity? does not have a mechanistic connection to the underpinning heat transport processes. Thermal conductivity of a material depends both on the material's intrinsic ability to transport heat and a variety of resistive effects caused by defects in the material. Thus ab initio prediction of the macroscopic conductivity - the property of interest for safe reactor operation - requires simulating detailed processes of heat transport, and then determining the effective thermal conductivity of the simulated material from the resulting heat flux under the imposed temperature difference. The thermal conductivity of a bulk, homogeneous, dielectric material can be well estimated by the mechanistically derived expression: k{sub bulk} = 1/3 C{sub ν}νgλ (2), where C{sub ν}, νg, and λ are the volumetric specific heat, phonon speed, and phonon mean free path, respectively. In these problems the relevant parameter is the material's acoustic thickness, its characteristic distance L relative to the phonon mean free path λ. In Eq. (2) the largest source of uncertainty is λ. While propagating uncertainty in λ to uncertainty in k through Eq. (2) is trivial, systems with extrinsic scattering require more sophisticated approaches. At the microscopic level, uncertainty in λ changes both a material's intrinsic thermal conductivity. Our goal is to propagate the uncertainty in λ through the deterministic transport computation of k. Because there are a small number of uncertain input quantities, we use the method of polynomial chaos expansion (PCE), which expresses solutions in the form of spectral expansions of an uncertain variable. This approach combines both intrusive and nonintrusive methods of uncertainty propagation techniques and results in a unique formulation which is very effective and efficient for problems with few uncertain parameters. Uncertainty Quantification and Sensitivity Analysis We use PCE-SC to measure propagation of uncertainty in a 3-D phonon transport problem of homogeneous silicon, to compute the mean and variance in temperature, heat flux and thermal conductivity. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Parallel, Multigrid Finite Element Simulator for Fractured/Faulted and Other Complex Reservoirs based on Common Component Architecture (CCA)

Black-oil, compositional and thermal simulators have been developed to address different physical processes in reservoir simulation. A number of different types of discretization methods have also been proposed to address issues related to representing the complex reservoir geometry. These methods are more significant for fractured reservoirs where the geometry can be particularly challenging. In this project, a general modular framework for reservoir simulation was developed, wherein the physical models were efficiently decoupled from the discretization methods. This made it possible to couple any discretization method with different physical models. Oil characterization methods are becoming increasingly sophisticated, and it is possible to construct geologically constrained models of faulted/fractured reservoirs. Discrete Fracture Network (DFN) simulation provides the option of performing multiphase calculations on spatially explicit, geologically feasible fracture sets. Multiphase DFN simulations of and sensitivity studies on a wide variety of fracture networks created using fracture creation/simulation programs was undertaken in the first part of this project. This involved creating interfaces to seamlessly convert the fracture characterization information into simulator input, grid the complex geometry, perform the simulations, and analyze and visualize results. Benchmarking and comparison with conventional simulators was also a component of this work. After demonstration of the fact that multiphase simulations can be carried out on complex fracture networks, quantitative effects of the heterogeneity of fracture properties were evaluated. Reservoirs are populated with fractures of several different scales and properties. A multiscale fracture modeling study was undertaken and the effects of heterogeneity and storage on water displacement dynamics in fractured basements were investigated. In gravity-dominated systems, more oil could be recovered at a given pore volume of injection at lower rates. However, if oil production can be continued at high water cuts, the discounted cumulative production usually favors higher production rates. The workflow developed during the project was also used to perform multiphase simulations in heterogeneous, fracture-matrix systems. Compositional and thermal-compositional simulators were developed for fractured reservoirs using the generalized framework. The thermal-compositional simulator was based on a novel 'equation-alignment' approach that helped choose the correct variables to solve depending on the number of phases present and the prescribed component partitioning. The simulators were used in steamflooding and in insitu combustion applications. The framework was constructed to be inherently parallel. The partitioning routines employed in the framework allowed generalized partitioning on highly complex fractured reservoirs and in instances when wells (incorporated in these models as line sources) were divided between two or more processors.

02 PETROLEUM↗

AZTRAN and AZKIND verification with a BWR study case

The AZTLAN Platform project is a national initiative led by the National Institute of Nuclear Research which gather the main public institutions of higher education in Mexico: the National Polytechnic Institute, the National Autonomous University of Mexico and the Autonomous Metropolitan University. It consists in the development of a modeling platform for the analysis and design of nuclear reactors. This project aims to modernize, improve and integrate the neutronic, thermohydraulics and thermomechanical codes, developed in the national institutions, in a platform integrated and developed by Mexican experts. The development of AZTLAN Platform is divided technically into four working groups: neutronics, thermohydraulics, coupling and uncertainty analysis, and users group. The present work is the result of the activities of the Users Group focused on the follow-up, testing and use of the different codes (modules) being developed under the AZTLAN project; with the objective of providing feedback and to suggest development priorities to the team of developers, as well as to promote collaboration and synergy between the participating institutions. In particular, in this work, the AZTRAN and the AZKIND modules were verified and tested against the results of well-known codes of the nuclear industry for boiling water reactor (BWR) models. AZTRAN is a 3D transport code which solves numerically the multi-group time independent neutron transport equation in Cartesian geometry, based on the discrete ordinates (SN) method and the RTN-0 nodal scheme. AZKIND is a 3D diffusion code that solves numerically the time dependent neutron diffusion equations in Cartesian geometry, based on a Galerkin Finite Element Method using the RTN-0 polynomial nodal approximation.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Type II string theory on Calabi-Yau manifolds with torsion and non-Abelian discrete gauge symmetries

Here, we provide the first explicit example of Type IIB string theory compactication on a globally defined Calabi-Yau threefold with torsion which results in a fourdimensional effective theory with a non-Abelian discrete gauge symmetry. Our example is based on a particular Calabi-Yau manifold, the quotient of a product of three elliptic curves by a fixed point free action of Z 2 X Z 2 . Its cohomology contains torsion classes in various degrees. The main technical novelty is in determining the multiplicative structure of the (torsion part of) the cohomology ring, and in particular showing that the cup product of second cohomology torsion elements goes non-trivially to the fourth cohomology. This specifies a non-Abelian, Heisenberg-type discrete symmetry group of the four-dimensional theory.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Statistics of internal stress fluctuations in dislocated crystals and relevance to density-based dislocation dynamics models

A statistical analysis of internal stress fluctuations, defined as the difference between the local mean stress and stress on dislocations, is presented for deforming crystals with 3D discrete dislocation systems. Dislocation realizations are generated using dislocation dynamics simulations and the associated stress field is computed as a superposition of a regularized stress field of dislocation lines within the domain of the solution and a complementary stress field computed via a finite-element boundary value problem. The internal stress fluctuations of interest are defined by an ensemble of the difference between the stress on dislocation lines and the local mean field stress in the crystal. The latter is established in a piecewise fashion over small voxels in the crystal thus allowing the difference between the local average stress and stress on segments to be easily estimated. The results show that the Schmid stress (resolved shear stress) and Escaig stress fluctuations on various slip systems sampled over a random set of points follow a Cauchy (Lorentz) distribution at all strain levels, with the amplitude and width of the distribution being dependent on the strain. Finally, the implications of the Schmid and Escaig internal stress fluctuations are discussed from the points of view of dislocation cross-slip and the dislocation motion in continuum dislocation dynamics.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Assessment of Different Discrete Particle Methods Ability To Predict Gas-Particle Flow in a Small-Scale Fluidized Bed

Several discrete particle methods exist in the open literature to simulate fluidized bed systems, such as discrete element method (DEM), time driven hard sphere (TDHS), coarse-grained particle method (CGPM), coarse grained hard sphere (CGHS), and multi-phase particle-in-cell (MP-PIC). These different approaches usually solve the fluid phase in a Eulerian fixed frame of reference and the particle phase using the Lagrangian method. The first difference between these models lies in tracking either real particles or lumped parcels. The second difference is in the treatment of particle-particle interactions: by calculating collision forces (DEM and CGPM), using momentum conservation laws (TDHS and CGHS), or based on particle stress model (MP-PIC). These major model differences lead to a wide range of results accuracy and computation speed. However, these models have never been compared directly using the same experimental dataset. In this research, a small-scale fluidized bed is simulated with these methods using the same open-source code MFIX. The results indicate that modeling the particle-particle collision by TDHS increases the computation speed while maintaining good accuracy. Also, lumping few particles in a parcel increases the computation speed with little loss in accuracy. However, modeling particle-particle interactions with solids stress leads to a big loss in accuracy with a little increase in computation speed. The MP-PIC method predicts an unphysical particle-particle overlap, which results in incorrect voidage distribution and incorrect overall bed hydrodynamics. Based on this study, we recommend using the CGHS method for fluidized bed simulations due to its computational speed that rivals that of MPPIC while maintaining a much better accuracy.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

A hybrid incremental projection method for thermal-hydraulics applications

In this paper, a new second-order accurate, hybrid, incremental projection method for time-dependent incompressible viscous flow is introduced in this paper. The hybrid finite-element/finite-volume discretization circumvents the well-known Ladyzhenskaya–Babuška–Brezzi conditions for stability, and does not require special treatment to filter pressure modes by either Rhie–Chow interpolation or by using a Petrov–Galerkin finite element formulation. The use of a co-velocity with a high-resolution advection method and a linearly consistent edge-based treatment of viscous/diffusive terms yields a robust algorithm for a broad spectrum of incompressible flows. The high-resolution advection method is shown to deliver second-order spatial convergence on mixed element topology meshes, and the implicit advective treatment significantly increases the stable time-step size. The algorithm is robust and extensible, permitting the incorporation of features such as porous media flow, RANS and LES turbulence models, and semi-/fully-implicit time stepping. A series of verification and validation problems are used to illustrate the convergence properties of the algorithm. The temporal stability properties are demonstrated on a range of problems with 2 ≤ CFL ≤ 100. The new flow solver is built using the Hydra multiphysics toolkit. The Hydra toolkit is written in C++ and provides a rich suite of extensible and fully-parallel components that permit rapid application development, supports multiple discretization techniques, provides I/O interfaces, dynamic run-time load balancing and data migration, and interfaces to scalable popular linear solvers, e.g., in open-source packages such as HYPRE, PETSc, and Trilinos.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Estimation of full-field dynamic strains from digital video measurements of output-only beam structures by video motion processing and modal superposition

Strain is an necessary quantity to characterize local structural behaviors and directly correlates with structural damage initiation and development that is within local regions. Strain measurement at high spatial resolution (density) locations is thus required to characterize local structural behaviors and detect potential local damage. Traditional contact-type strain gauges are mostly discrete point-wise sensors that can only be placed in a limited number of positions. Distributed optical fiber sensing techniques can measure strains at spatially dense measurement points, but their instrumentation is a time- and labor-intensive process associated with the issue of the fragility of fibers. Noncontact optical measurement techniques, such as a family of interferometry techniques using laser beams (e.g., laser Doppler vibrometers), can provide vibration measurement at high density spatial points without the need to install sensors on the structure. Yet, these measurement devices are active sensing methods that are relatively expensive and vulnerable to ambient motion. Photogrammetry is an alternative noncontact optical measurement method using (passive) white-light imaging of digital video cameras that are relatively low-cost, agile, and provides simultaneous measurements at high spatial density locations where every pixel becomes a measurement point. Among others, digital image correlation can achieve full-field deformation measurements and subsequently estimate the full-field strains. However, it is computationally extensive. This research develops a new efficient approach to estimate the full-field (as many measurement points as the pixel number of the video frame on the structure) dynamic strains at high-spatial (pixel)-resolution/density location points from the digital video measurement of output-only vibrating structures. The developed approach is based on phase-based video motion estimation and modal superposition of structural dynamic response. Moreover, the method is augmented by a high-fidelity finite element model, which is updated with the full-field experimental modal parameters “blindly” identified from the video measurement of the output-only structure. Laboratory experiments are conducted to validate the method on a bench-scale cantilever beam structure. Results demonstrate that the full-field dynamic strain estimated by the developed approach from the video measurement of the output-only vibrating beam match very well those directly measured by the strain gauges (at discrete measurement points). Some factors associated with the effectiveness of the method are experimentally studied and discussed.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

Validation of the SCEPTRE Boltzmann-CSD Solver

A new Boltzmann-CSD solver has been developed within the SCEPTRE radiation-transport code, based on the 1st-order form of the transport equation, using discontinuous finite elements in space and energy and discrete ordinates in angle. The Boltzmann-CSD solver has been validated against experimental data for electron energy deposition distributions and for electron emission spectra. Comparison of the calculated results with experimental data shows excellent agreement for many of the test configurations and reasonable agreement for other test configurations. The tests have also been modeled with the ITS Monte Carlo code, which also shows excellent to reasonable agreement with the SCEPTRE results and experimental data. The SCEPTRE Boltzmann-CSD solver relies on electron cross sections generated by the legacy CEPXS code, which currently is limited to electron-only Boltzmann-CSD cross sections. Performing full electron-photon radiation transport with the Boltzmann-CSD solver will require further development in the cross section generating code. For the energy- deposition calculations, neglecting photon transport results in at most about 5% overprediction of the energy deposition for high-energy electrons on high-Z targets, and relatively insignificant difference for the other test configurations.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

CFD-DEM and PR-DNS studies of low-temperature densely packed beds

Over the past few decades, granular media is gaining attention as a viable option for heat transfer fluids (HTFs). Several research efforts are studying the use of particle-based heat transfer fluids in a wide variety of applications. With this motivation, the current work focusses on analyzing the different heat transfer mechanisms in low-temperature mono-sized densely packed granular media. To study the heat transfer behavior of granular media at different scales, the current work employs a two-way coupled computational strategy. The motion of particles is solved using the Discrete Element Method (DEM) and the interstitial air is solved using a Finite-Volume (CFD) approach. The Open-Source library CFDEM Coupling® is used in the current study to join the Finite Volume PISO solver of OpenFOAM® and the DEM solver of LIGGGHTS®. Typically, particle-particle contact conduction and particle-air convection are the most popular closure models. But recent research identified a different heat transfer phenomenon in packed beds that cannot be identified by conduction or convection models. While closure models were developed to implement this on a CFD-DEM framework, they did not capture the effect of intra-particulate thermal gradients on this phenomenon. Hence the current work also employs Particle-Resolved Direct Numerical Simulations (PR-DNS) to gain valuable insights allowing for the modification of existing models. A new closure model is then proposed here and is implemented in the CFD-DEM framework. This model provides key insights into the different heat transfer mechanism of packed beds.

42 ENGINEERING↗

A point-centered arbitrary Lagrangian Eulerian hydrodynamic approach for tetrahedral meshes

We present a three dimensional (3D) arbitrary Lagrangian Eulerian (ALE) hydrodynamic scheme suitable for modeling complex compressible flows on tetrahedral meshes. The new approach stores the conserved variables (mass, momentum, and total energy) at the nodes of the mesh and solves the conservation equations on a control volume surrounding the point. This type of an approach is termed a point-centered hydrodynamic (PCH) method. The conservation equations are discretized using an edge-based finite element (FE) approach with linear basis functions. All fluxes in the new approach are calculated at the center of each tetrahedron. A multidirectional Riemann-like problem is solved at the center of the tetrahedron. The advective fluxes are calculated by solving a 1D Riemann problem on each face of the nodal control volume. A 2-stage Runge–Kutta method is used to evolve the solution forward in time, where the advective fluxes are part of the temporal integration. The mesh velocity is smoothed by solving a Laplacian equation. The details of the new ALE hydrodynamic scheme are discussed. Results from a range of numerical test problems are presented.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Extended spin symmetry and the standard model

We review unification ideas and explain the spin-extended model in this context. Its consideration is also motivated by the standard-model puzzles. With the aim of constructing a common description of discrete degrees of freedom, as spin and gauge quantum numbers, the model departs from q-bits and generalized Hilbert spaces. Physical requirements reduce the space to one that is represented by matrices. The classification of the representations is performed through Clifford algebras, with its generators associated with Lorentz and scalar symmetries. We study a reduced space with up to two spinor elements within a matrix direct product. At given dimension, the demand that Lorentz symmetry be maintained, determines the scalar symmetries, which connect to vector-and-chiral gauge-interacting fields; we review the standard-model information in each dimension. We obtain fermions and bosons, with matter fields in the fundamental representation, radiation fields in the adjoint, and scalar particles with the Higgs quantum numbers. We relate the fields' representation in such spaces to the quantum-field-theory one, and the Lagrangian. The model provides a coupling-constant definition.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Is tokenization needed for masked particle modeling?

In this work, we significantly enhance masked particle modeling (MPM), a self-supervised learning scheme for constructing highly expressive representations of unordered sets relevant to developing foundation models for high-energy physics. In MPM, a model is trained to recover the missing elements of a set, a learning objective that requires no labels and can be applied directly to experimental data. We achieve significant performance improvements over previous work on MPM by addressing inefficiencies in the implementation and incorporating a more powerful decoder. We compare several pre-training tasks and introduce new reconstruction methods that utilize conditional generative models without data tokenization or discretization. We show that these new methods outperform the tokenized learning objective from the original MPM on a new test bed for foundation models for jets, which includes using a wide variety of downstream tasks relevant to jet physics, such as classification, secondary vertex finding, and track identification.

conditional generative models↗

Guidelines for the formulation of Lagrangian stochastic models for particle simulations of single-phase and dispersed two-phase turbulent flows

In this paper, we establish a set of criteria which are applied to discuss various formulations under which Lagrangian stochastic models can be found. These models are used for the simulation of fluid particles in single-phase turbulence as well as for the fluid seen by discrete particles in dispersed turbulent two-phase flows. The purpose of the present work is to provide guidelines, useful for experts and non-experts alike, which are shown to be helpful to clarify issues related to the form of Lagrangian stochastic models. A central issue is to put forward reliable requirements which must be met by Lagrangian stochastic models and a new element brought by the present analysis is to address the single- and two-phase flow situations from a unified point of view. For that purpose, we consider first the single-phase flow case and check whether models are fully consistent with the structure of the Reynolds-stress models. In the two-phase flow situation, coming up with clear-cut criteria is more difficult and the present choice is to require that the single-phase situation be well-retrieved in the fluid-limit case, elementary predictive abilities be respected and that some simple statistical features of homogeneous fluid turbulence be correctly reproduced. This analysis does not address the question of the relative predictive capacities of different models but concentrates on their formulation since advantages and disadvantages of different formulations are not always clear. Indeed, hidden in the changes from one structure to another are some possible pitfalls which can lead to flaws in the construction of practical models and to physically unsound numerical calculations. A first interest of the present approach is illustrated by considering some models proposed in the literature and by showing that these criteria help to assess whether these Lagrangian stochastic models can be regarded as acceptable descriptions. A second interest is to indicate how future developments can be safely built, which is also relevant for stochastic subgrid models for particle-laden flows in the context of Large Eddy Simulations.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Next-Generation Performance-Based Regulation. Volume 1: Introduction - Global Lessons for Success; Volume 2: Primer - Essential Elements of Design and Implementation; Volume 3: Innovative Examples from Around the World

Performance-based regulations (PBRs) provide a regulatory framework to connect goals, targets, and measures to utility performance or executive compensation. Well-designed PBRs provide incentives for utility performance, benefiting consumers and utility owners alike. This report considers the role of both PBRs and more discrete performance incentive mechanisms (PIMs) in 21st century power sector transformation. Innovative technologies are transforming the way electricity is generated, delivered, and consumed. PBRs have the potential to realign utility, investor, and consumer incentives and mitigate emerging challenges to the utility business model, renewable integration, and even cyber security.The goals of PBRs in the form of multi-year rate plans are in many respects the same in terms of providing reasonably priced and reliable service to customers. However, today's technologies have changed, and there is more emphasis on clean energy. Thus, the pathways and the potential outcomes are different than they were in the 20th century when centralized generator stations and large infrastructure additions dominated the utility landscape. Given unprecedented changes underway in the electricity sector, PBRs - by specifying expectations of utility performance and outcomes for consumers, while staying agnostic to the exact means of delivery - constitute a form of prescient regulation that harnesses disruption. PBRs are one tool in a broader toolbox in the transition toward flexible regulatory and market structures that rewards utilities that adapt or evolve in reaction to market and technology change. PBRs and PIMs have great value for the electric industry when designed well and can be applied to many different situations. How exactly PBR mechanisms are most effectively enacted will vary based on the utility ownership model, institutional arrangements, and a variety of other local factors. PBRs should be tailored to the needs and goals of each jurisdiction, and perhaps each utility, to most effectively achieve the needs of a 21st century power grid in that jurisdiction. Presented in three volumes, this report highlights the lessons learned from their evolving history, explores essential elements of their design and implementation as well as considerations for how they may be best applied, and examines leading examples of PBRs from the United Kingdom, New York, Denmark, Mexico, and South Africa. The full report, 'Next-Generation Performance Based Regulation - Emphasizing Utility Performance to Unleash Power Sector Innovation,' published in September 2017, can be accessed at https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy17osti/68512.pdf.

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗