Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Additives”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 631 records · Page 35

Improved Creep and Tensile Properties of a Corrosion Resistant Ni-Based Superalloy Using High Temperature Aging and Nb/Ta Additions

Resistance to creep deformation is essential for cast and wrought Ni-based superalloys in next generation energy systems due to the considerable exposure times required at the operating temperature. Here the amount of precipitate strengthening was increased in variants to Inconel alloy 725 (IN725), a corrosion resistant alloy, to improve its elevated temperature mechanical strength. Additions of Nb or Ta coupled with a high temperature aging (HTA) heat treatment promoted the formation of γ" precipitates and grain boundary phases which led to significant increases in time to failure. The HTA increased the creep life of various alloy formulations as compared to the standard aging heat treatment with a maximum improvement of 371%. The Nb and Ta additions lowered the minimum creep rate (MCR) and had a similar effect on increasing creep life. The positive effect of the additions was more pronounced when coupled with the HTA which employed a higher temperature in the first step of the heat treatment to promote precipitate phase formation. The Ti/Al ratio was used to design alloys with preferential formation of ' or γ" precipitates. Compact morphology precipitates were formed in the alloys with a low Ti/Al ratio. While a low Ti/Al ratio was primarily associated with lower MCRs, the effect on the creep life was less evident than that of the HTA. By using additions of Nb or Ta and a HTA heat treatment, the creep life of IN725 for testing at 973 K (700 °C) and 483 MPa was improved by up to 256%.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Novel Approach to Studying Influences of Na{sub 2}O and K{sub 2}O Additions on Viscosity and Thermodynamic Properties of BF Slags

Abstract:: The present work calculated the heat capacity, enthalpy change, and slag temperature of CaO–MgO–Al{sub 2}O{sub 3}–SiO{sub 2} slags after adding Na{sub 2}O or K{sub 2}O, and investigated the influences of Na{sub 2}O and K{sub 2}O on the slag viscosity under given temperatures and heat quantities. It was found that the slag viscosity decreases with the addition of Na{sub 2}O and tends to increase with K{sub 2}O additions at the same temperature. The heat capacity of the slag increases, while the enthalpy change decreases obviously with the increasing addition of Na{sub 2}O or K{sub 2}O. Under the constant heat quantity, an increase in content of Na{sub 2}O or K{sub 2}O of the slag leads to an appreciable increase in slag temperature, whereas the viscosity decreases significantly. Besides, the Na{sub 2}O or K{sub 2}O additions also help to stabilize the slag fluidity and lower energy consumption of blast furnace.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Effect of Ni Addition to Sn0.7Cu Solder Alloy on Thermal Behavior, Microstructure, and Mechanical Properties

The addition of Ni on lead-free solder alloys Sn0.7Cu was tested in this study. A small amount of Ni was added to the solder alloys to evaluate the thermal behavior, microstructure, and mechanical properties of the composite solders after sintering and isothermal aging for 3 days and then compared with the results of the binary Sn0.7Cu solder. The results indicated that the ultimate tensile strength and yield tensile strength changed when adding 0.25 wt.% of Ni. The tested results of the differential scanning calorimeter showed that the addition of Ni (such as 0.5 and 1 wt.%) could obviously increase the solidification temperature of Sn0.7Cu alloys in the cooling process. When the Ni content was increased to 0.25 wt.% in the ternary condition, which includes the Sn0.7Cu-xNi (x = 0, 0.1, 0.25, 0.5, and 1 wt.%) solder alloys for the indentation creep test, the minimum creep rate reached the maximum; however, the trend was reversed as the Ni content was higher than this level. In addition, the microstructure of Sn-0.7Cu-xNi solder alloys was obviously different with the eutectic Sn-0.7Cu solder, such that the Ni gradually accumulated in the (Cu, Ni){sub 6}Sn{sub 5} IMCs within the Ni-containing solder alloys. Additionally, this process refined the microstructure of the Sn-0.7Cu solder. The fracture surface of the eutectic Sn-0.7Cu solder revealed ductile fracture modes; however, there was no mixed ductile–brittle fracture mode occurred when the Ni content was in the range of 0-1 wt.%.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Effect of Ca and Sm Combined Addition on the Microstructure and Elevated-Temperature Mechanical Properties of Mg-6Al Alloys

In the present study, the microstructure and elevated-temperature mechanical properties of Mg-6Al, Mg-6Al-4Ca, Mg-6Al-4Sm and Mg-6Al-2Ca-2Sm alloys were investigated. The experimental results showed that the microstructure and elevated-temperature mechanical property of Mg-6Al alloy changed obviously with the different elements addition. By analyzing the results of optical microscope, x-ray diffraction analysis, scanning electron microscope, and transmission electron microscope, it could be determined that there was only Mg{sub 17}Al{sub 12} phase in Mg-6Al alloy, there were Al{sub 2}Ca and (Mg, Al){sub 2}Ca phases in Mg-6Al-4Ca alloy, there were Al{sub 2}Sm and Mg{sub 17}Al{sub 12} phases in Mg-6Al-4Sm alloy, and there were (Mg, Al){sub 2}Ca, Al{sub 2}Ca and Al{sub 2}Sm phases in Mg-6Al-2Ca-2Sm alloy. In addition, the addition of alloying elements including Ca and Sm, especially the composite addition, could significantly improve the tensile properties of Mg-6Al alloy. Compared to Mg-6Al alloy, the tensile strengths of Mg-6Al-2Ca-2Sm alloy at 448, 473 and 498 K were enhanced by 50.32, 87.92, and 94.99%, respectively. Furthermore, when the stretching temperatures were 448 and 473 K, the fracture pattern of Mg-6Al-2Ca-2Sm alloy was the mixture of intergranular fracture and trans-crystalline fracture. However, when the stretching temperature was 498 K, the fracture pattern of Mg-6Al-2Ca-2Sm alloy was the intergranular fracture.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Characterization of Fe-6Si Soft Magnetic Alloy Produced by Laser-Directed Energy Deposition Additive Manufacturing

Abstract Commercial electrical steels, Fe-Si alloys with < 4 wt.% Si, are inexpensive and efficient materials for electrical power conversion. Further efficiency improvements require increasing the silicon concentration to 6 wt.%, at which point the material becomes brittle and difficult to form by conventional rolling and sheet fabrication methods. Additive manufacturing stands to overcome challenges with commercial manufacturing techniques by leveraging near-net-shape fabrication. The wide array of process conditions provides additive manufacturing with increased flexibility, enabling control over the microstructure and mechanical properties. This work explores the microstructures and magnetic properties of ring-shaped Fe-Si alloys produced using concentric and cross-hatch tool paths on a laser-directed energy deposition additive manufacturing system. Concentric-built samples exhibit elongated grain structures while cross-hatch-built samples comprise lower aspect ratio grain structures. Thermal finite element analysis simulations model the stress conditions produced by the different scan path geometries. Microhardness measurements probe the mechanical properties as a function of anneal temperature, providing a qualitative understanding of the intergranular defect density. Soft magnetic properties measured under quasistatic and AC conditions show frequency- and microstructure-dependent coercivity and permeability. Finally, analysis of the core loss quantifies how the build strategies and thermal treatments influence efficiency in electrical power conversion applications. Understanding the influences of scan path geometry and thermal treatment provides a pathway towards application of additively manufactured soft magnetic materials.

Adamczyk, Jesse M.↗

Improvement of Methane Production from Sugar Beet Wastes Using TiO{sub 2} and Fe{sub 3}O{sub 4} Nanoparticles and Chitosan Micropowder Additives

An experimental study was performed to measure biogas production from sugar beet waste, which is, in fact, the chopped parts of the sugar beet not going through the sugar extraction process, at different additive concentrations. Medium molecular weight chitosan in microsize and TiO{sub 2} and Fe{sub 3}O{sub 4} nanoparticles were added to ten experimental reactors to investigate their effect on the anaerobic digestion process. Three different concentrations of 0.01, 0.04, and 0.12% w/w were used for each additive. Biogas production and methane content were compared with a control sample containing no additive. Adding chitosan in powder form did not help the process nor improved methanogenic activities. The results showed no effect on anaerobic digestion by the addition of TiO{sub 2} nanoparticles in the mentioned concentrations, whereas adding Fe{sub 3}O{sub 4} nanoparticles led to a slight increase in methane production and in volatile solid and total solid reduction. The maximum enhancement in methane and biogas production in the sample containing 0.04% Fe{sub 3}O{sub 4}, as compared with the control sample, reached 19.77% and 15.09%, respectively.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

Building blocks for a digital twin of additive manufacturing

Properties and serviceability of additively manufactured components are affected by their geometry, microstructure and defects. These important attributes are now optimized by trial and error because the essential process variables cannot currently be selected from scientific principles. A recourse is to build and rigorously validate a digital twin of the additive manufacturing process that can provide accurate predictions of the spatial and temporal variations of metallurgical parameters that affect the structure and properties of components. Key building blocks of a computationally efficient first-generation digital twin of laser-based directed energy deposition additive manufacturing utilize a transient, three-dimensional model that calculates temperature and velocity fields, cooling rates, solidification parameters and deposit geometry. The measured profiles of stainless steel 316L and Alloy 800H deposits as well as the secondary dendrite arm spacing (SDAS) and Vickers hardness measurements are used to validate the proposed digital twin. The predicted cooling rates, temperature gradients, solidification rates, SDAS and micro-hardness values are shown to be more accurate than those obtained from a commonly used heat conduction calculation. Finally, these metallurgical building blocks serve as a phenomenological framework for the development of a digital twin that will make the expanding knowledge base of additive manufacturing usable in a practical way for all scientists and engineers.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Structural integrity of additively manufactured stainless steel with cold sprayed barrier coating under combined cyclic loading

Integration of metal additive manufacturing (AM) and cold spray (CS) technologies provide an unprecedented opportunity to manufacture coated material systems with complex geometrical features. The application of these material systems in functionally critical components requires adequate structural integrity, particularly in the presence of cyclic loading. This article researches the multiaxial fatigue (axial-torsional cyclic loading) behavior of a coated material system consisting of 15Cr-5Ni precipitation-hardening stainless steel (15-5 PH SS) substrate additively manufactured by direct metal laser sintering with a layer of chromium carbide nickel (CrC-Ni) barrier coating deposited by CS. The influence of AM and CS-induced residual stresses on fatigue performance of test specimens was thoroughly studied. Additionally, the effect of surface roughness and processes induced defects were considered to explain the crack growth mechanism. Stresses assessed by synchrotron X-ray diffraction indicated a substantial accumulation of residual stresses, particularly in the outer surface of the as-fabricated 155 PH SS specimens. The state of residual stress was changed notably following the deposition of CrC-Ni coating in the axial, hoop, and radial directions of the fatigue test specimen. Also, CS deposition of CrC-Ni coating caused significant improvement in the surface quality of the additively manufactured components. Fatigue test results indicated, CS deposition of CrC-Ni substantially enhances the fatigue life of the AM-produced 15-5 PH SS substrate in all loading conditions, particularly in the high cycle fatigue regime. The improvement in the fatigue life of the specimens with coating was associated with a reduction in equivalent residual stress at the substrate surface and improvement in the specimens' surface condition (i.e., reduced surface roughness). The fractographic analysis of the specimen indicated the cracks tend to initiate in the surface of both as-fabricated and cold-sprayed specimens. However, the mechanism of crack growth changed notably following the deposition of CrC-Ni coating. The cracks tended to propagate in the planes parallel or with a small deviation from the build layers of the AM-produced specimens. On the other hand, deposition of CrC-Ni coating increased the deviation of crack growth plane from the build layers of the substrate.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Structural stability of thin overhanging walls during material extrusion additive manufacturing of thermoset-based ink

Recent developments have enabled material extrusion additive manufacturing of thermoset-based composite inks on the large scale. In addition, printing out-of-plane components is of broad interest to the polymer material extrusion community. Here, we address some of the challenges associated with both large-scale and out-of-plane thermoset material extrusion additive manufacturing by studying the height at which thin overhanging walls collapse. Walls at a range of overhang angles were printed until they collapsed. An optical camera captured the profile of each wall throughout the print, allowing the collapse height to be identified and the geometric fidelity to the programmed angle to be evaluated. Using previously measured rheological properties, predictive models were generated to approximate the collapse height and profile of the deflected walls. First, an analytical model was created to predict the height at which the walls would yield. The analytical model assumes the walls exhibit a perfectly linear profile; however, experiments proved this assumption to be false. Therefore, a finite element simulation was developed to account for the elastic deflection that occurs during printing. The finite element simulation predicts both the yield height and the deflected profile after the deposition of each layer. For the properties of the thermoset ink used here, the yield height predicted by the analytical model and finite element simulation are virtually identical. These predictions match experimental data reasonably well, but minor errors are observed. Accounting for the fully plastic moment appears to explain the small mismatch between experimental data and predictions. Additionally, the finite element simulation provides an excellent prediction of the deflected profile before the wall begins to collapse. Finally, by demonstrating that the collapse height and deflected profile of thin overhanging walls can be predicted, this work illustrates how the soft viscoelastic properties of thermoset-based composite inks limit the scale of a key feature required to print some nonplanar components. It also provides a basis to tailor in-process curing systems to suppress deflection and collapse of thin overhanging walls.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

In situ laser profilometry for material segmentation and digital reconstruction of a multicomponent additively manufactured part

In addition to its ability to produce geometrically complex parts, additive manufacturing offers a unique opportunity to collect data about a component while it is being fabricated. However, there has only been limited effort to characterize parts morphologically and compositionally in situ. In this article, we present a layer-by-layer, laser profilometry-based in situ characterization technique as a method to digitally reconstruct a multi-material part. Data collected by the laser profilometer yields height maps and grayscale images which are voxelized using purpose-built software to volumetrically reconstruct the part. Additionally, the same part was also analyzed using X-ray computed tomography (CT) which was not able to resolve the different compositional regions within the part, but captured the filament morphology. The part was then bisected to compare the digital reconstruction to the actual part morphology and composition. Overall, the digital reconstruction was in good agreement with both the CT and bisected images. Deviations between the digital reconstruction and the CT/bisected images are likely the result of image segmentation settings or material shifts after data was collected. The in situ characterization method demonstrated here sets the stage for real time process monitoring and paves the way for additively manufactured parts that are “born qualified.”

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Janthinobacter additions reduce rotifer grazing of microalga Microchloropsis salina in biotically complex communities

Grazing and parasitism in algal production systems are significant causes of crop loss. Biological control of algal ponds, such as application of protective bacteria, represents a promising alternative to current mitigation strategies. The major barriers to probiotic methods are the lack of identified protective bacteria and uncertainty of scale-up effects, including potential negative interactions with the resident algal microbiome. Here, we report that application of Janthinobacter lividum affords robust protection against rotifer (Brachionus plicatilis) grazing on Microchloropsis salina. Protection was observed at laboratory scale from live bacteria and solvent extract additions as well as in biologically complex communities from bacterial additions to outdoor mesocosms. J. lividum persisted in outdoor communities for at least 3 days following addition, and did not lead to selective exclusion of specific taxa in the resident microbiome. These results demonstrate that J. lividum can provide protection against grazers in these diverse communities, without severe effects on the resident microbiome. Our results suggest that J. lividum is a promising treatment to mitigate algal crop losses due to pests. Additionally, the study highlights the importance of an ecologically-informed approach to algal crop management that will aid future applications in the biological control of algal ponds.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Sub-additivity in combining infiltration with mechanical ventilation for single zone buildings

We report that in determining ventilation rates, it is often necessary to combine naturally-driven infiltration, with air flows from mechanical systems. When there are balanced mechanical systems, the solution is simple additivity, because a balanced system does not impact the internal pressure of the space or the air flows through the building envelope. Unbalanced systems, however, change internal pressures and therefore can impact natural ventilation non-linearly in such a way as to make it sub-additive. Several sub-additive approaches are found in the literature, but they are not robust across the full spectrum from tight to leaky buildings and ranges of mechanical ventilation air flow rates. There are two approaches for combining natural infiltration with mechanical ventilation that require different solutions. The forward problem is to find the total air flow when adding mechanical ventilation to natural infiltration, and this application has been investigated in previous studies. The inverse problem finds the required mechanical ventilation in order to meet a total ventilation rate given a known amount of natural infiltration. This article presents the results of millions of hours of simulations of the physically correct solution, which span a broad range of climates, air leakage and structural conditions. This large dataset allows for the comparison with three literature models and the development of new robust sub-additivity models. These improved models are for use with unbalanced systems appropriate for consensus standards and guidelines for both the forward and inverse problem. Finally, they reduce errors to 1% or less and work across the air tightness spectrum.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Effects of organic additives on calcium hydroxide crystallisation during lime slaking

Highlights: • Sucrose and lignosulfonate reduce the crystallite size of Ca(OH){sub 2}. • Lime slaking in sucrose solutions leads to Ca(OH)2 with irregular shape. • Lime slaking in presence of lignosulfonate leads to plate-like Ca(OH){sub 2} crystals. • Effects of additives are enhanced when introduced before slaking. • Additives stabilise the unstable edge faces of Ca(OH){sub 2} during ageing. Organic compounds, often used in cement systems as admixtures, may affect the crystallisation and carbonation kinetics of Ca(OH){sub 2}, an important phase of hydrated cement. Here, we investigated changes in Ca(OH){sub 2} morphology in the presence of 3 organic compounds, commonly encountered in cement and lime-based materials: sucrose, pectin and calcium lignosulfonate. The additives were introduced either before or after lime slaking to determine the influence of temperature. Ca(OH){sub 2} crystals and supernatant solutions were characterised at time of slaking and after 6 months of ageing using scanning electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction and optical emission spectroscopy. Our results indicate that the morphology of Ca(OH){sub 2} crystals is modified by the characteristics of the organic molecules which promote formation of Ca(OH){sub 2} with habits that can result in faster carbonation, an effect that is detrimental to cement used in reinforced concrete. These effects are enhanced when the additives are introduced before slaking, likely as a result of thermal degradation.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Effect of hydromagnesite addition on the properties and water resistance of magnesium oxysulfate (MOS) cement

Magnesium oxysulfate (MOS) cement exhibits excessive cracking when exposed to water because of the reaction of residual MgO that forms extensive Mg(OH){sub 2}, which significantly limits the application breadth of MOS cement. This study investigates the effects of the addition of hydromagnesite ((MgCO{sub 3}){sub 4}·Mg(OH){sub 2}·4H{sub 2}O) on the hydration products of MOS cement and the microstructure and physical properties of MOS paste samples. It was found that the addition of hydromagnesite increased the compressive strength and water resistance of MOS cement. This effect is mainly due to the reaction between hydromagnesite and free MgO present in the cement that forms magnesium carbonate (MgCO{sub 3}·Mg(OH){sub 2}·3H{sub 2}O) and acts as an additional binding phase. The use of hydromagnesite as an additive for improving the water resistance of MOS cement leads to a decrease in the residual MgO content and improves the water stability of amorphous materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Effects of roasting additives and leaching parameters on the extraction of rare earth elements from coal fly ash

Coal fly ash is a promising alternative source for rare earth elements (REE), which are critical materials in many technologies. REEs are entrained in the aluminosilicate glass of the fly ash particles, hindering their ability to solubilize during acid leaching. The purpose of this research was to test the effectiveness of roasting techniques to improve extraction of REEs from fly ash, determine key parameters controlling REE extraction, and understand trade-offs in reagent use. Representative coal ash samples from major U.S. coal basins (Appalachian, Illinois, and Powder River basins) were roasted using a variety of chemical additives (Na 2 O 2 , NaOH, CaO, Na 2 CO 3 , CaSO 4 , (NH 4 ) 2 SO 4 ). Further experiments investigated the effects of additive:ash ratio, roasting temperature, and leachate pH on REE extraction. We found here that NaOH roasting often recovered >90% of total REE content, equivalent to the USGS-recommended method (Na 2 O 2 sintering). Other additives tested recovered <50% of total REE content; the 450 °C sinter temperature, which was well below the melting points of these agents, may have been a contributing factor. Decreasing the NaOH-ash ratio did not significantly inhibit in REE recoveries, while increasing the leachate pH led to a sharp decline. There was a strong positive correlation between REE extraction and leachate H + molarity. Recoveries of ~100% were observed for the Powder River Basin ash sample regardless of the roasting agent and additive:ash ratio used. This suggests that acid leaching alone is sufficient for recovering REEs from more soluble Powder River Basin ashes. For Appalachian and Illinois Basin ashes, the recommended roasting conditions for >70% REE extraction are a 1:1 NaOH-ash ratio and leaching with 1–2 mol/L HNO 3 .

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

A computational study of the effects of graphene additions on electrical properties of polycrystalline copper

The addition of graphene has recently shown promise as a route for the significant improvement of the bulk electrical properties of metallic materials. Here, we explore the effects these additions have on the net electrical conductivity of fabricated copper-graphene (Cu-Gr) nanocomposites as a function of grain structure and grain boundary properties. Synthetic 3D microstructures were generated to represent polycrystalline copper with different average grain diameters and twinned grain boundary fractions. Then, the Poisson equation of electrical transport was solved using a finite difference method in order to predict the net electrical conductivity of each microstructure. In this context, the potential effect of graphene on the conductivity of the composite was evaluated as a function of the number of affected grain boundaries. The results of these calculations indicate that 1.) as supported by literature, net electrical conductivity decreases with decreasing grain size, 2.) the presence of twinned grain boundaries results in smaller loss of conductivity than would otherwise be expected, and 3.) the presence of graphene on the grain boundaries can be expected to lead to improvements in net electrical conductivity. However, we also find that 4.) when the Cu grain structure becomes sufficiently refined, the addition of graphene could conceivably result in significant improvements in electrical conductivity over and above coarse-grained Cu. It is estimated from our calculations that, assuming microstructures with average grain sizes between 100 nm and 100 μm and graphene conductivity 1000 to 10,000 that of a typical Cu grain boundary, an improvement in electrical conductivity of approximately 17% over that of bulk Cu may be attainable. Therefore, by performing this study we suggest a possible route for the improvement of Cu electrical properties through the addition of graphene.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

The biological effects of subacute inhalation of diesel exhaust following addition of cerium oxide nanoparticles in atherosclerosis-prone mice

Background: Cerium oxide (CeO{sub 2}) nanoparticles improve the burning efficiency of fuel, however, little is known about health impacts of altered emissions from the vehicles. Methods: Atherosclerosis-prone apolipoprotein E knockout (ApoE{sup -/-}) mice were exposed by inhalation to diluted exhaust (1.7 mg/m{sup 3}, 20, 60 or 180 min, 5 day/week, for 4 weeks), from an engine using standard diesel fuel (DE) or the same diesel fuel containing 9 ppm cerium oxide nanoparticles (DCeE). Changes in hematological indices, clinical chemistry, atherosclerotic burden, tissue levels of inflammatory cytokines and pathology of the major organs were assessed. Results: Addition of CeO{sub 2} to fuel resulted in a reduction of the number (30%) and surface area (10%) of the particles in the exhaust, whereas the gaseous co-pollutants were increased (6-8%). There was, however, a trend towards an increased size and complexity of the atherosclerotic plaques following DE exposure, which was not evident in the DCeE group. There were no clear signs of altered hematological or pathological changes induced by either treatment. However, levels of proinflammatory cytokines were modulated in a brain region and liver following DCeE exposure. Conclusions: These results imply that addition of CeO{sub 2} nanoparticles to fuel decreases the number of particles in exhaust and may reduce atherosclerotic burden associated with exposure to standard diesel fuel. From the extensive assessment of biological parameters performed, the only concerning effect of cerium addition was a slightly raised level of cytokines in a region of the central nervous system. Overall, the use of cerium as a fuel additive may be a potentially useful way to limit the health effects of vehicle exhaust. However, further testing is required to ensure that such an approach is not associated with a chronic inflammatory response which may eventually cause long-term health effects.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

The additive to background assumption in cancer risk assessment: A reappraisal

The assumption that chemical and radiation induced cancers act in a manner that is additive to background was proposed in the mid-1970s. It was adopted by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in 1986 and then subsequently by other regulatory agencies worldwide for cancer risk assessment. It ensured that cancer risks at low doses act in a linear fashion. The additive to background process assumes that the mechanism(s) resulting in induced (i.e., treatment related) and spontaneous (i.e., control group) cancers are identical. This assumption could not be properly evaluated due to inadequate mechanistic data when it was proposed in the 1970s. Using the findings of modern molecular toxicology, including oncogene activation/mutation, gene regulation, and molecular pathway analyses, the additive to background assumption was evaluated in the present paper. Based on published studies with 45 carcinogens over 13 diverse mammalian models and for a broad range of tumor types compelling evidence indicates that carcinogen-induced tumors are mediated in general via mechanisms that are not identical to those affecting the occurrence of the same type of spontaneous tumors in appropriate control groups. These findings, which challenge a fundamental assumption of the additive to background concept, have significant implications for cancer risk assessment policy, regulatory agency practices, as well as fundamental concepts of cancer biology.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗