Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “REPROCESSING”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 577 records · Page 32

Decision Analysis Methods For the Analysis of Nuclear Terrorism Threats with Imperfect Information

Protection of commercial nuclear fuel cycles against adversary groups who may attempt to steal weapons-usable material is an issue of interest to the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Nuclear Energy. The wide array of potential nuclear fuel cycle configurations and the security measures that could be deployed to protect them pose a daunting system design problem. In general, there are billions of potential design configurations. Moreover, the design choices are not independent – the effectiveness of one design feature or security measure can affect the desirability of other design choices. To explore this issue, we develop a mixed-integer optimization problem that solves a complex decision tree to allocate security resources across a commercial nuclear fuel cycle configuration. A nominal UREX+ reprocessing facility is used to demonstrate how the model allocates resources across a particular fuel cycle facility and shows how the problem can be scaled up to include other facilities and design features in the fuel cycle. In our model, the defender first chooses a set of safeguards to implement in order to mitigate the risk of a terrorist theft from various unit operations in the reprocessing facility. The attacker observes the defender’s strategy choice and executes an attack to acquire material, including the possibility of declining to attack at all. The model considers the terrorist as an intelligent adversary with a set of attack strategies known to the defender. The strategic choices made by both the defender and attacker affect the probability of a successful attack by the terrorist and in turn affect the distribution of consequences to the defender. We use a decision tree to illustrate the interactions among costs, decisions, correlated uncertainties, and outcomes, and then show how to formulate the problem as a mixed-integer program with an equivalent solution. The novel features of our formulation include the following. First, as discussed above, we use a sequential game-theoretic formulation (a Stackelberg game). This formulation assumes the attacker can observe the defender’s actions before the attack is executed. Many previous game-theoretic studies have assumed attacker and defender act simultaneously without knowledge of the other’s strategy choice. We believe the sequential game formulation is more applicable for knowledgeable insider adversaries, the focus of this study. Second, we build on our previous work that has developed a methodology to reflect the correlation among probability distributions represented as discrete chance nodes in a decision tree. We illustrate how this methodology can be applied to two chance nodes in a decision tree that relate the quality of the materials that might be stolen or diverted by an adversary with the yield of a weapon that might be constructed from that material. In a decision tree, the dependence of the yield on the quality of the material could be modeled with conditional probabilities of the weapon yield given the quality of the materials obtained. For three outcome discretizations, this would require the assessment of nine conditional probabilities from domain experts as part of the model building effort. In contrast, our methodology will allow this same representation of the tree based on the assessment of the correlation between these two chance nodes by the experts, which we believe is a much easier and more reliable assessment task. The advantage of this approach increases as the number of dependent chance nodes grows in a decision tree representation of this problem. Third, we extend this approach to the approximation of the dependence between discrete binary events such as success or failure represented by binary chance nodes in a decision tree or in the special case of a probabilistic risk analysis (PRA) based on an event tree. This extension is a novel application in this domain, and uses Monte Carlo simulation to determine the appropriate conditional probabilities on the binary chance nodes when the number of correlated uncertainties is more than two. Fourth, we show how these decision trees or probability trees can be formulated and solved as equivalent integer programming (IP) problems. The advantages of the IP representation include the opportunity to use the computing power associated with powerful optimization solver algorithms available on high speed computers to solve very large versions of these trees, and the ability to include several such models of different facilities into a much larger IP with connecting constraints that represent budget restrictions, number of available inspection opportunities in a given time window, or other dependencies among these facilities. Policy makers can use the resulting model to inform their decisions about how to assess terrorism risk and to safeguard the commercial nuclear fuel cycle.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Phase 1 Methyl Iodide Deep-Bed Adsorption Tests

Nuclear fission results in the production of fission products (FPs) and activation products including iodine-129, which could evolve into used fuel reprocessing facility off-gas systems, and could require off-gas control to limit air emissions to levels within acceptable emission limits. Research, demonstrations, and some reprocessing plant experience have indicated that diatomic iodine can be captured with efficiencies high enough to meet regulatory requirements. Research on the capture of organic iodides has also been performed, but to a lesser extent [Jubin 2012b]. Several questions remain open regarding the capture of iodine bound in organic compounds. Deep-bed methyl iodide adsorption testing has progressed according to a multi-laboratory methyl iodide adsorption test plan. This report summarizes the first phase of methyl iodide adsorption work performed according to this test plan using the deep-bed iodine adsorption test system at the Idaho National Laboratory (INL), performed during Fiscal Year (FY) 2013 and early FY-2014. Testing has been performed to address questions posed in the test plan, and followed the testing outline in the test plan. Tests established detection limits, developed procedures for sample analysis with minimal analytical interferences, and confirmed earlier results that show that the methyl iodide reacts when in contact with the AgZ sorbent, and not significantly in the gas flow upstream of the sorbent. The reaction(s) enable separation of the iodine from the organic moiety, so that the iodine can chemisorb onto the sorbent. The organic moiety can form other compounds, some of which are organic compounds that are detected and can be tentatively identified using GC-FID and GCMS. Test results also show that other gas constituents (NOx and/or H2O) can affect the methyl iodide reactions. With NOx and H2O present in the gas stream, the majority of uncaptured iodine exiting iodine-laden sorbent beds is in the form of I2 or HI, species that are soluble in NaOH scrubbing solution for iodine analysis. But when NOx and H2O are not present, then the majority of the uncaptured iodine exiting iodine-laden sorbent is in the form of methyl iodide. Methyl iodide adsorption efficiencies have been high enough so that initial DFs exceed 1,000 to 10,000. The methyl iodide mass transfer zone depths are estimated at 4-8 inches, possibly deeper than mass transfer zone depths estimated for I2 adsorption on AgZ. Additional deep-bed testing and analyses are recommended to (a) expand the data base for methyl iodide adsorption under various conditions specified in the methyl iodide test plan, and (b) provide more data for evaluating organic iodide reactions and reaction byproducts for different potential adsorption conditions.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Phase 2 Methyl Iodide Deep-Bed Adsorption Tests

Nuclear fission produces fission products (FPs) and activation products, including iodine-129, which could evolve into used fuel reprocessing facility off-gas systems, and could require off-gas control to limit air emissions to levels within acceptable emission limits. Research, demonstrations, and some reprocessing plant experience have indicated that diatomic iodine can be captured with efficiencies high enough to meet regulatory requirements. Research on the capture of organic iodides has also been performed, but to a lesser extent. Several questions remain open regarding the capture of iodine bound in organic compounds. Deep-bed methyl iodide adsorption testing has progressed according to a multi-laboratory methyl iodide adsorption test plan. This report summarizes the second phase of methyl iodide adsorption work performed according to this test plan using the deep-bed iodine adsorption test system at the Idaho National Laboratory (INL), performed during the second half of Fiscal Year (FY) 2014. Test results continue to show that methyl iodide adsorption using AgZ can achieve total iodine decontamination factors (DFs, ratios of uncontrolled and controlled total iodine levels) above 1,000, until breakthrough occurred. However, mass transfer zone depths are deeper for methyl iodide adsorption compared to diatomic iodine (I2) adsorption. Methyl iodide DFs for the Ag Aerogel test adsorption efficiencies were less than 1,000, and the methyl iodide mass transfer zone depth exceeded 8 inches. Additional deep-bed testing and analyses are recommended to (a) expand the data base for methyl iodide adsorption under various conditions specified in the methyl iodide test plan, and (b) provide more data for evaluating organic iodide reactions and reaction byproducts for different potential adsorption conditions.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Proliferation Persuasion. Coercive Bargaining with Nuclear Technology

Why do states wait for prolonged periods of time with the technical capacity to produce nuclear weapons? Only a handful of countries have ever acquired the sensitive nuclear fuel cycle technology needed to produce fissile material for nuclear weapons. Yet the enduring trend over the last five decades is for these states to delay or forgo exercising the nuclear weapons option provided by uranium enrichment or plutonium reprocessing capabilities. I show that states pause at this threshold stage because they use nuclear technology to bargain for concessions from both allies and adversaries. But when does nuclear latency offer bargaining benefits? My central argument is that challengers must surmount a dilemma to make coercive diplomacy work: the more they threaten to proliferate, the harder it becomes to reassure others that compliance will be rewarded with nuclear restraint. I identify a range of mechanisms able to solve this credibility problem, from arms control over breakout capacity to third party mediation and confidence building measures. Since each step towards the bomb raises the costs of implementing these policies, a state hits a sweet spot when it first acquires enrichment and/or reprocessing (ENR) technology. Subsequent increases in proliferation capability generate diminishing returns at the bargaining table for two reasons: the state must go to greater lengths to make a credible nonproliferation promise, and nuclear programs exhibit considerable path dependency as they mature over time. Contrary to the conventional wisdom about power in world politics, less nuclear latency thereby yields more coercive threat advantages. I marshal new primary source evidence from archives and interviews to identify episodes in the historical record when states made clear decisions to use ENR technology as a bargaining chip, and employ this theory of proliferation persuasion to explain how Japan, North Korea, and Iran succeeded and failed to barter concessions from the United States. By clarifying when countries are able to leverage steps towards the bomb for international political gain, my work advances our understanding of proliferation and coercive diplomacy.

98 NUCLEAR DISARMAMENT, SAFEGUARDS, AND PHYSICAL P↗

A Brief User's Guide to the Excel ® -Based DF Calculator

To understand the importance of capturing penetrating forms of iodine as well as the other volatile radionuclides, a calculation tool was developed in the form of an Excel ® spreadsheet to estimate the overall plant decontamination factor (DF). The tool requires the user to estimate splits of the volatile radionuclides within the major portions of the reprocessing plant, speciation of iodine and individual DFs for each off-gas stream within the Used Nuclear Fuel reprocessing plant. The Impact to the overall plant DF for each volatile radionuclide is then calculated by the tool based on the specific user choices. The Excel ® spreadsheet tracks both elemental and penetrating forms of iodine separately and allows changes in the speciation of iodine at each processing step. It also tracks 3 H, 14 C and 85 Kr. This document provides a basic user's guide to the manipulation of this tool.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Preparation of NO 2 -Aged Silver-Functionalized Silica-Aerogel and Silver Mordenite Samples

Reprocessing used nuclear fuel can result in the volatilization of radioactive gaseous species, including 129 I, into the various process off-gas streams. In order to comply with US regulatory requirements, plant off-gas streams must be treated to remove the iodine prior to discharging the off-gas into the environment. The performance of available gas removal methods depends not only on the concentration of the volatile radioisotope of interest, but also on other constituents that could be present in the reprocessing off-gas streams. Some of the constituents, such as NOx produced during fuel dissolution, are known to have deleterious effects on the capture performance of silver-based sorbents used for iodine removal. Commercially available reduced silver mordenite (AgZ) has an iodine saturation concentration of 7.0-9.0 wt%, and its iodine sorption capacity is reduced by 20-50% as a result of NO2 aging. Silverfunctionalized silica aerogel (AgAerogel), an alternative for iodine capture, has an initial iodine saturation of 29.0 wt% and its iodine capacity is only reduced by 15% from NO2 aging. Understanding the differences in aging behavior between AgZ and AgAerogel is critical to determining the behavior of these sorbents under realistic off-gas conditions. To assist in future technical studies on this topic, samples of both AgZ and AgAerogel were aged with NO2. In the experiment, 10.2190 g of AgZ and 10.1771 g of AgAerogel were exposed to a static 0.75% NO 2 /dry air blend for a period of 28 days. The samples were then removed and stored under argon until needed for future experiments.=

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Sorption Modeling and Verification for Off-Gas Treatment

This project was successfully executed to provide valuable adsorption data and improve a comprehensive model developed in previous work by the authors. Data obtained were used in an integrated computer program to predict the behavior of adsorption columns. The model is supported by experimental data and has been shown to predict capture of off gas similar to that evolving during the reprocessing of nuclear waste. The computer program structure contains (a) equilibrium models of off-gases with the adsorbate; (b) mass-transfer models to describe off-gas mass transfer to a particle, diffusion through the pores of the particle, and adsorption on the active sites of the particle; and (c) incorporation of these models into fixed bed adsorption modeling, which includes advection through the bed. These models are being connected with the MOOSE (Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment) software developed at the Idaho National Laboratory through DGOSPREY (Discontinuous Galerkin Off-gas SeParation and REcoverY) computer codes developed in this project. Experiments for iodine and water adsorption have been conducted on reduced silver mordenite (Ag0Z) for single layered particles. Adsorption apparatuses have been constructed to execute these experiments over a useful range of conditions for temperatures ranging from ambient to 250°C and water dew points ranging from -69 to 19°C. Experimental results were analyzed to determine mass transfer and diffusion of these gases into the particles and to determine which models best describe the single and binary component mass transfer and diffusion processes. The experimental results were also used to demonstrate the capabilities of the comprehensive models developed to predict single-particle adsorption and transients of the adsorption-desorption processes in fixed beds. Models for adsorption and mass transfer have been developed to mathematically describe adsorption kinetics and transport via diffusion and advection processes. These models were built on a numerical framework for solving conservation law problems in one-dimensional geometries such as spheres, cylinders, and lines. Coupled with the framework are specific models for adsorption in commercial adsorbents, such as zeolites and mordenites. Utilizing this modeling approach, the authors were able to accurately describe and predict adsorption kinetic data obtained from experiments at a variety of different temperatures and gas phase concentrations. A demonstration of how these models, and framework, can be used to simulate adsorption in fixed- bed columns is provided. The CO 2 absorption work involved modeling with supportive experimental information. A dynamic model was developed to simulate CO 2 absorption using high alkaline content water solutions. The model is based upon transient mass and energy balances for chemical species commonly present in CO 2 absorption. A computer code was developed to implement CO 2 absorption with a chemical reaction model. Experiments were conducted in a laboratory scale column to determine the model parameters. The influence of geometric parameters and operating variables on CO 2 absorption was studied over a wide range of conditions. Continuing work could employ the model to control column operation and predict the absorption behavior under various input conditions and other prescribed experimental perturbations. The value of the validated models and numerical frameworks developed in this project is that they can be used to predict the sorption behavior of off-gas evolved during the reprocessing of nuclear waste and thus reduce the cost of the experiments. They can also be used to design sorption processes based on concentration limits and flow-rates determined at the plant level.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Prototype Demonstration of Gamma- Blind Tensioned Metastable Fluid Neutron/Multiplicity/Alpha Detector – Real Time Methods for Advanced Fuel Cycle Applications

The content of this report summarizes a multi-year effort to develop prototype detection equipment using the Tensioned Metastable Fluid Detector (TMFD) technology developed by Taleyarkhan [1]. The context of this development effort was to create new methods for evaluating and developing advanced methods for safeguarding nuclear materials along with instrumentation in various stages of the fuel cycle, especially in material balance areas (MBAs) and during reprocessing of used nuclear fuel. One of the challenges related to the implementation of any type of MBA and/or reprocessing technology (e.g., PUREX or UREX) is the real-time quantification and control of the transuranic (TRU) isotopes as they move through the process. Monitoring of higher actinides from their neutron emission (including multiplicity) and alpha signatures during transit in MBAs and in aqueous separations is a critical research area. By providing on-line real-time materials accountability, diversion of the materials becomes much more difficult. The Tensioned Metastable Fluid Detector (TMFD) is a transformational technology that is uniquely capable of both alpha and neutron spectroscopy while being “blind” to the intense gamma field that typically accompanies used fuel – simultaneously with the ability to provide multiplicity information as well [1-3]. The TMFD technology was proven (lab-scale) as part of a 2008 NERI-C program [1-7]. The bulk of this report describes the advancements and demonstrations made in TMFD technology. One final point to present before turning to the TMFD demonstrations is the context for discussing real-time monitoring of SNM. It is useful to review the spectrum of isotopes generated within nuclear fuel during reactor operations. Used nuclear fuel (UNF) from a light water reactor (LWR) contains fission products as well as TRU elements formed through neutron absorption/decay chains. The majority of the fission products are gamma and beta emitters and they represent the more significant hazards from a radiation protection standpoint. However, alpha and neutron emitting uranium and TRU elements represent the more significant safeguards and security concerns. Table 1.1 presents a representative PWR inventory of the uranium and actinide isotopes present in a used fuel assembly. The uranium and actinide isotopes (chiefly the Pu, Am and Cm elements) are all emitters of alpha particles and some of them release significant quantities of neutrons through spontaneous fissions

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Milestone Report - M4FT-17OR030107025 - Design of a tritium and iodine removal system for use with advanced TPOG

US regulations will require the removal of iodine and tritium, along with other volatile and semi-volatile radionuclides, from the off-gas streams of nuclear fuel reprocessing plants. Advanced tritium pretreatment (TPT) is an additional head-end operation that could be incorporated within nuclear fuel reprocessing plants. It utilizes nitrogen dioxide (NOR2R) as an oxidant to convert UOR2R to UR3ROR8R prior to traditional aqueous dissolution. Advanced TPT can result in the quantitative volatilization of both tritium and iodine. Up-front removal of iodine is of significant advantage because otherwise it distributes to several unit operations and the associated off-gas streams. The off-gas streams will then require treatment to comply with US regulations. Advanced TPT is currently under development at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, and a kilogram-scale hot cell demonstration with used nuclear fuel (UNF) is planned for fiscal year (FY) 2018.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Reducing Actinide Production Using Inert Matrix Fuels

The environmental and geopolitical problems that surround nuclear power stem largely from the longlived transuranic isotopes of Am, Cm, Np and Pu that are contained in spent nuclear fuel. New methods for transmuting these elements into more benign forms are needed. Current research efforts focus largely on the development of fast burner reactors, because it has been shown that they could dramatically reduce the accumulation of transuranics. However, despite five decades of effort, fast reactors have yet to achieve industrial viability. A critical limitation to this, and other such strategies, is that they require a type of spent fuel reprocessing that can efficiently separate all of the transuranics from the fission products with which they are mixed. Unfortunately, the technology for doing this on an industrial scale is still in development. In this project, we explore a strategy for transmutation that can be deployed using existing, current generation reactors and reprocessing systems. We show that use of an inert matrix fuel to recycle transuranics in a conventional pressurized water reactor could reduce overall production of these materials by an amount that is similar to what is achievable using proposed fast reactor cycles. Furthermore, we show that these transuranic reductions can be achieved even if the fission products are carried into the inert matrix fuel along with the transuranics, bypassing the critical separations hurdle described above. The implications of these findings are significant, because they imply that inert matrix fuel could be made directly from the material streams produced by the commercially available PUREX process. Zirconium dioxide would be an ideal choice of inert matrix in this context because it is known to form a stable solid solution with both fission products and transuranics.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Fundamental Aspects of Zeolite Waste Form Production by Hot Isostatic Pressing

The direct conversion of iodine-bearing sorbents into a stable waste form is a research topic of interest to the US Department of Energy. The removal of volatile radioactive 129I from the off-gas of a nuclear fuel reprocessing facility will be necessary in order to comply with the regulatory requirements that apply to facilities sited within the United States (Jubin et al., 2012a), and any iodine-containing media or solid sorbents generated by this process would contain 129 I and would be destined for eventual geological disposal. While recovery of iodine from some sorbents is possible, a method to directly convert iodineloaded sorbents to a durable waste form with little or no additional waste materials being formed and a potentially reduced volume would be beneficial. To this end, recent studies have investigated the conversion of iodine-loaded silver mordenite (I-AgZ) directly to a waste form by hot isostatic pressing (HIPing) (Bruffey and Jubin, 2015). Silver mordenite (AgZ), of the zeolite class of minerals, is under consideration for use in adsorbing iodine from nuclear reprocessing off-gas streams. Direct conversion of I-AgZ by HIPing may provide the following benefits: (1) a waste form of high density that is tolerant to high temperatures, (2) a waste form that is not significantly chemically hazardous, and (3) a robust conversion process that requires no pretreatment.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Hot Isostatic Pressing of Engineered Forms of I-AgZ

Hot isostatic pressing (HIP) is being considered for direct conversion of 129 I-bearing materials to a radiological waste form. The removal of volatile radioactive 129 I from the off-gas of a nuclear fuel reprocessing facility will be necessary to comply with regulatory requirements regarding reprocessing facilities sited within the United States, and any iodine-containing media or solid sorbents generated by offgas abatement will require disposal. Zeolite minerals such as silver-exchanged mordenite (AgZ) have been studied as potential iodine sorbents and will contain 129 I as chemisorbed AgI. Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) has conducted several recent studies on the HIP of both iodine-loaded AgZ (I-AgZ) and other iodine-bearing zeolite minerals. The goal of these research efforts is to achieve a stable, highly leach resistant material that is reduced in volume as compared to bulk iodine-loaded I-AgZ. Through the use of HIP, it may be possible to achieve this with the addition of little or no additional materials (waste formers). Other goals for the process include that the waste form will be tolerant to high temperatures and pressures, not chemically hazardous, and that the process will result in minimal secondary waste generation. This document describes the preparation of 27 samples that are distinct from previous efforts in that they are prepared exclusively with an engineered form of AgZ that is manufactured using a binder. Iodine was incorporated solely by chemisorption. This base material is expected to be more representative of an operational system than were samples prepared previously with pure minerals.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Design and Test Plan for an Integrated Iodine Scrubber and Polishing Bed System

The capture and subsequent immobilization of four regulated volatile radionuclides ( 3 H, 14 C, 85 Kr, and 129 I) and relevant semivolatile species from the off-gas streams of a used nuclear fuel (UNF) reprocessing facility has been a topic of significant research interest on the part of the US Department of Energy and other international organizations. Significant research and development has been conducted over the past decade. In 2016 an initial engineering evaluation and design of the off-gas abatement systems required for a hypothetical 1000 t/yr UNF reprocessing facility treating 5 yr–cooled, 60 GWd/tIHM UNF was completed. One of the key findings of that report was that the consumption rate of silver-based iodine sorbents in the dissolver off-gas primary iodine capture bed is very high and may warrant the evaluation of alternative methods to capture the bulk of the iodine that could significantly reduce the associated frequent remote handing of the iodine filter beds. This report is intended to describe the design of an experimental system that can be used to examine the use of aqueous scrubbing to remove the bulk of the iodine from the dissolver off-gas stream prior to a silver-based solid sorbent that would be used to provide the final iodine capture or polishing step. This report also provides a description of the initial series of tests that are proposed for this system.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Testing of an Iodine and Tritium Removal System for Advanced Tritium Pretreatment Off-Gas

The reprocessing of used nuclear fuel would release volatile radionuclides into the off-gas of a processing plant, including 3 H, 14 C, 85 Kr, and 129 I. For a reprocessing plant sited within the United States and governed by US regulations, the abatement of some or all of these radionuclides from the plant off-gas would be required before discharge of that gas to the environment. A potential simplification of the off-gas management system can be achieved through an efficient advanced tritium pretreatment (ATPT) step in which the UO 2 fuel is oxidized by NO 2 prior to dissolution. Oxidation of the UO 2 fuel matrix results in the release of tritium contained within. Up-front removal of tritium from the fuel in a pretreatment step, followed by the abatement of tritium from the advanced tritium pretreatment off-gas (ATPTOG) stream, can minimize or eliminate the distribution of tritium throughout the plant, also decreasing or eliminating the need for tritium capture on multiple off-gas streams. The use of NO 2 as the oxidant allows tritium pretreatment to be performed at lower temperatures and may result in the quantitative release of iodine from the fuel. A total of five tests examined AgA as a potential iodine sorbent at an operating temperature of 150°C and both 3A MS and silica gel as potential tritium sorbents with an operating temperature of 40°C. 3A MS and silica gel are intended for use as regenerative sorbents, in which the adsorbed tritium (as tritiated water or tritiated nitric acid) is loaded onto the sorbent at operating temperature and then subsequently desorbed at high temperature into a small-volume gas stream for recovery and conversion to a waste form. This testing leaves many fundamental questions regarding the ATPTOG iodine and tritium abatement systems unanswered. These include questions regarding sorbent capacity and sorbate desorption. Overall, this testing indicates that tritium and iodine abatement from an ATPTOG stream by solid sorbents is currently at a low stage of technological development and that deployment of such an abatement system would require substantial additional research and development.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Performance of Silver-Exchanged Mordenite and Silver-Functionalized Silica-Aerogel Under Vessel Off-gas Conditions

US regulations 40 CFR 61, 40 CFR 190, and 10 CFR 20 govern release limits for volatile radionuclides contained in the gaseous effluents of used nuclear fuel (UNF) reprocessing facilities. Of the four volatile radionuclides that are restricted by the release limits ( 3 H, 14 C, 85 Kr, and 129 I) 129 I will require the greatest degree of abatement. Previous studies have shown that overall plant decontamination factor (DF) for 129 I must, at minimum, exceed 1,000 to meet regulatory requirements. Iodine-containing off-gas will be present in the dissolver off-gas, the cell off-gas, the vessel off-gas (VOG), the waste off-gas, and the shear off-gas. The VOG will most likely contain 1%–5% of the total iodine at part per billion (ppb) concentrations. A number of studies have examined iodine abatement from the dissolver off-gas, which contains greater than 95% of the iodine inventory of the plant, but very few have examined the recovery of iodine from the VOG stream. Reduced silver-exchanged mordenite (Ag 0 Z) has been considered a promising iodine sorbent for use in UNF reprocessing plants, but recent efforts have identified silver-functionalized silica-aerogel (AgAerogel) as a potential alternative. The testing reported here reflects a substantial increase in the body of work available on iodine adsorption by both silver sorbents under prototypical VOG conditions. Both I2 and methyl iodide (CH 3 I) adsorption tests have been conducted with Ag 0 Z and AgAerogel at a range of concentrations up to 1,000 ppb. These experiments were performed with two specific aims: (1) to assess the effect of iodine concentration on its adsorption by the sorbent and (2) to compare the performance of Ag 0 Z and AgAerogel in the removal of iodine from a prototypical VOG stream.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Joint Test Plan for the Evaluation of Iodine Retention for Long-Chain Organic Iodides

A number of reports have identified four volatile radionuclides that arise from the reprocessing of nuclear fuel ( 3 H, 14 C, 85 Kr, and 129 I) that require controls limiting their environmental release from reprocessing facilities in order to meet US regulatory requirements. Of these, 129 I has the longest half-life and highest potential biological impact.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Testing of an Integrated Iodine Scrubber and Polishing Bed System

In 2016 an initial engineering evaluation and design of the off-gas abatement systems required for a hypothetical 1000 t/yr used nuclear fuel (UNF) reprocessing facility treating 5 yr–cooled, 60 GWd/tIHM UNF was completed. In this study two types of silver-based iodine sorbents were considered. The first was a silver-exchanged mordenite (AgZ), and the second was a silver-functionalized silica aerogel. In the initial design of the dissolver off-gas (DOG) iodine capture beds, the sorbent capacity was assumed to be 40 mg I/g sorbent. The total iodine released from the fuel, used as input for the design of the DOG system, was 1.635 kg/day. Tramp halogens increased this to ~5.1 kg/day on an iodine equivalent basis. The daily consumption of iodine sorbent was ~166 kg (including the mass transfer zones that have lower iodine loading). The iodine capture system was designed to utilize five beds in parallel. In this design each bed was ~1 m in diameter and 1.5 m long. This design allowed the beds to remain on line for 20 days, but at that point all five beds would need to be replaced, resulting in considerable material handling. It was proposed that the bed life could be extended and the number of parallel beds reduced if an aqueous iodine scrubber preceded the solid sorbent iodine capture beds. The testing described in this report was intended to provide an evaluation of an integrated system in which bulk iodine would first be removed by an aqueous NaOH scrubber with a target iodine decontamination factor (DF) of 10 to 50. This would reduce the sorbent usage by 90 to 95% and significantly reduce the associated frequent remote handling of the iodine filter beds. The effluent from the scrubber would then be passed through an AgZ sorbent bed to remove residual iodine. The integration of these unit operations was intended to demonstrate an iodine DF of >1000, which would facilitate regulatory compliance with regards to total volatile radionuclide emission from a reprocessing facility. Initial baseline performance testing of the scrubber system includes the characterization of CO 2 removal by the aqueous NaOH scrubber as a function of temperature, caustic concentration, packing length, liquid-to-gas mass ratio, and liquid flow rate. It was found that when the column was well wetted, very high CO 2 DFs were achieved (>650 and potentially as high as 15,000), preventing the ability to elucidate the effects of each specific variable tested. The L/G ratio in this system was not representative of typical L/G ratios found in industrial-scale scrubber systems. By significantly lowering the liquid recirculation rate to the point that column wetting was marginal, some significant variations in the CO 2 DF or CO 2 effluent concentrations could be observed. The additional tests conducted under these more adverse conditions still showed CO 2 DFs >100. The only operational parameter with significant effects was determined to be column length, with increased column length resulting in higher CO 2 DFs. Following these CO 2 tests, a single iodine scrubber test was performed deliberately at a condition indicated by the CO 2 demonstration to result in poor column performance. This was intended to establish a lower performance bound for iodine removal by the aqueous scrubber. The result showed that even under the adverse operating conditions, an iodine DF of >100 could be achieved. Finally, the aqueous scrubber and a AgZ polishing bed were integrated. This simple caustic scrubber system achieved an iodine DF of >12,000 for just the scrubber portion. Using this iodine DF, the iodine loading on the polishing bed was reduced by 99.993%. The performance of that integrated system was compared to a system including only a AgZ sorbent bed. The system without the scrubber also showed iodine DFs >3000 until breakthrough was observed. The loading on the saturated portion of the bed averaged 87.2 mg I 2 /gm AgZ. Comparing the penetration of iodine into the sorbent beds for these two systems showed a marked difference; the penetration with the scrubber was only 0.65 cm at a maximum loading of 0.11 mg I 2 /gm AgZ, whereas for the case without the caustic scrubber, the bed was saturated for the first 7 cm and breakthrough of the 13.3 cm bed occurred.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Mu*STAR ADSR Fuel Conversion Facility Evaluation and Cost Analysis

The purpose of the reported effort is the development of a conceptual process for conversion of used nuclear fuel (UNF) from light water reactors (LWRs) to a fluoride salt form to facilitate its use for power generation in a Mu*STAR Accelerator-driven Subcritical Reactor (ADSR). This document evaluates potential processes for converting UNF into a fluoride salt, evaluates the costs/benefits of using enriched lithium in the carrier salt, and analyzes comparable costs of similar facilities to make a rough order of magnitude estimate for the cost to design, construct, and commission a Mu*STAR ADSR fuel conversion facility. This document also makes a high-level comparison of the Mu*STAR ADSR fuel cycle with other important fuel cycles. The results of the cost analysis show that the Mu*STAR ADSR fuel conversion facility will cost more than $100M, possibly up to around $1B, to design and construct. The cost will depend on the size of the hot cell required, which will depend on the processing options chosen for converting the UNF to a molten salt. Operations and maintenance of the facility will be on the order of $10M per year. The design, fabrication, and installation of the remote process equipment to support the fuel conversion will be an additional cost of more than $50M. Cost surveys of Department of Energy hot cell designs and previous Department of Energy hot cell construction suggest that the cost variance may be large, and the risk of escalating costs may be high in the regulation-mandated atmosphere of nuclear facility design and construction. The molten salt for the Mu*STAR ADSR contains all of the nonvolatile isotopes in the UNF, and there is never a separation of the plutonium from the fission products. This makes this conversion process much more proliferation resistant than the reprocessing options used for other closed fuel cycles. When normalized to the amount of electricity produced, the Mu*STAR ADSR fuel cycle’s expected cost might be less than any reprocessing fuel cycle and possibly less than the once-through cycle now used. Simulations show that once the conversion to fluoride is made, that up to seven times as much energy can be extracted from the UNF than was produced by the LWR while making it [Bowman, 2010]. Using once-only, on-site conversion to fluoride means no mining, no enrichment, no manufacturing of fuel rods, and no transportation costs. Typically, the UNF was produced over a 40-year period in an LWR; it can potentially be used for 280 years in Mu*STAR, producing the same power as the LWR did, ultimately requiring disposal of approximately the same volume of material as the LWR generated. Mu*STAR burns most of the higher actinides, which could reduce both the cost of disposal and significantly reduce the longevity of its radiotoxicity. Mu*STAR ADSR’s ability to demonstrate unique and valuable peripheral benefits are additional arguments for this technology, including (1) turning UNF into a valuable commodity (thus, its disposal will not be such an immediate problem, so continued operation of existing LWRs will be more acceptable); (2) burning fissile or fertile fuel including excess weapons-grade plutonium in subcritical mode; and (3) providing high-temperature process heat to convert natural gas to synthetic diesel fuel, water to hydrogen, or for other process-heat applications.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗