Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Cu”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 577 records · Page 32

Reductive Elimination From Tetra‐Alkyl Cuprates [Me n Cu(CF 3 ) 4− n ] − ( n =0–4): Beyond Simple Oxidation States

Abstract In recent years, the electronic structures of organocuprates in general and the complex [Cu(CF 3 ) 4 ] − in particular have attracted significant interest. A possible key indicator in this context is the reactivity of these species. Nonetheless, this aspect has received only limited attention. Here, we systematically study the series of tetra‐alkyl cuprates [Me n Cu(CF 3 ) 4− n ] − and their unimolecular reactivity in the gas phase, which includes concerted formal reductive eliminations as well as radical losses. Through computational studies, we characterize the electronic structures of the complexes and show how these are connected to their reactivity. We find that all [Me n Cu(CF 3 ) 4− n ] − ions feature inverted ligand fields and that the distinct reactivity patterns of the individual complexes arise from the interplay of different effects.

Zimmer, Bastian↗

A thermodynamic evaluation of metal halides for the recrystallization of Cu(In,Ga)Se 2

CdTe films are deposited at low temperatures and recrystallized to photovoltaic device quality using CdCl 2 treatments, leading to competitive manufacturing costs. Cu(In,Ga)Se 2 (CIGS) typically requires high-temperature, low-rate depositions to produce high-efficiency devices, resulting in higher costs. A similar metal halide treatment of CIGS has been demonstrated by us previously for some metal halide sources. To understand and optimize the process, a thermodynamic evaluation of candidate metal halides for such treatments is presented as a guide for their selection. By comparing bond dissociation energies, mono- and di-halide compounds are proposed to be ideal compounds to act as transport agents. Known recrystallization and temperature reduction benefits by Ag alloying suggests that Ag-halides should be used to aid transport of all species. The high vapor pressure and mobility of Ga compounds still poses a problem for metal halide treatment resulting in Ga etching and removal of intentional Ga gradients. Less severe but similar issues with In compounds may occur. As a result, Cu compounds have low vapor pressures which may limit transport, however, Cu is highly mobile in CIGS and recrystallization still occurs.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

Exploring the Photogenerated Charge Transfer Mechanism in Cu 2 O@MoS 2 Heterojunction Photocatalyst Using Transient Absorption Spectroscopy

Both heterojunction and core–shell photocatalysts have demonstrated promising performance in photocatalytic CO 2 conversions to fuels. However, fundamental knowledge of heterojunctions in core–shell structures is highly desired to facilitate the design of future photocatalysts. By combining advanced experimental characterizations and density functional theory (DFT) calculations, the role of the Cu 2 O@MoS 2 heterojunction in photocatalytic CO 2 conversions to fuels was investigated. We discovered that the charge dynamics and electron transfer properties of Cu2O@MoS 2 photocatalysts are altered by the heterojunction and Cu 2 O underlayer due to the electron transfer from Cu 2 O to MoS 2 and the change in CO 2 adsorption strength on the hybrid catalyst surface. Consequently, more electrons can travel to the surrounding liquid environment to be consumed by CO 2 reduction. This study provides experimental and theoretical investigations of the fundamental mechanisms of heterojunction core–shell photocatalysts.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Boosting Electrochemical Catalysis and Nonenzymatic Sensing Toward Glucose by Single‐Atom Pt Supported on Cu@CuO Core–Shell Nanowires

Abstract It is critical to develop high‐performance electrocatalyst for electrochemical nonenzymatic glucose sensing. In this work, a single‐atom Pt supported on Cu@CuO core–shell nanowires (Pt 1 /Cu@CuO NWs) for electrochemical nonenzymatic glucose sensor is designed. Pt 1 /Cu@CuO NWs exhibit excellent electrocatalytic oxidation toward glucose with 70 mV lower onset potential (0.131 V) and 2.4 times higher response current than Cu NWs. Sensors fabricated using Pt 1 /Cu@CuO NWs also show high sensitivity (852.163 µA mM −1 cm −2 ), low detection limit (3.6 µM), wide linear range (0.01–5.18 µM), excellent selectivity, and great long‐term stability. The outstanding sensing performance of Pt 1 /Cu@CuO NWs, investigated by experiments and density functional theory (DFT) calculations, is attributed to the synergistic effect between Pt single atoms and Cu@CuO core–shell nanowires that generates strong binding energy of glucose on the nanowires. The work provides a new pathway for exploring highly active SACs for electrochemical nonenzymatic glucose sensor.

Chemistry↗

Effect of sink strength on coherency loss of precipitates in dilute Cu-base alloys during in situ ion irradiation

In situ irradiations with 1 MeV Kr ions at 50~613 K up to a fluence of 6.25 × 10 14 ions/cm 2 (~1.25 displacements per atom, dpa) have been performed on pre-aged dilute Cu-0.9%Co, Cu-0.9%Fe and Cu-0.8%Cr alloys containing uniform matrix dispersions of coherent precipitates in order to study the effects of initial precipitate sink strength, damage dose and irradiation temperature on radiation-induced coherency loss of precipitates. Coherent precipitates with different point defect sink strengths (2πNd, where N and d are the precipitate density and diameter) were used in this work to examine potential differences in atomic relaxation during absorption of point defects. In all cases, irradiation to low doses (<~1 dpa) was very effective at inducing loss of precipitate coherency. At low sink strengths (~10 13 m -2 ), loss of precipitate coherency could be induced for doses ~0.01 dpa. This suggests there might be an efficient preferential medium-range strain-induced bias for absorption of interstitial defects due to tensile strains emanating from the undersized precipitates, which induces relatively rapid loss of coherency at low precipitate sink strengths. High precipitate sink strength (~10 14 m -2 ) conditions were relatively resistant to the radiation-induced loss of coherency (requiring higher doses approaching ~1 dpa) and this might be due to nearly equal numbers of interstitial and vacancy defects arriving at the precipitate interface for such high sink strength conditions. The precipitate coherency loss was observed to have a weak dependence on irradiation temperature. Molecular dynamics simulations confirm a strong effect of precipitate sink strength on the probability of interstitial absorption at precipitates.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Additively-manufactured Al-0.3Zr-0.2Ce-0.2Cu alloy with high creep resistance and electrical conductivity

Here, a new, solute-lean Al-0.3Zr-0.2Ce-0.2Cu (wt.%) alloy is developed for additive manufacturing that overcomes the classical tradeoff between conductivity and creep resistance. The rapid-cooling-enabled supersaturation of Zr, and its uniform distribution in α-Al matrix, along with formation of submicron (Ce,Cu)-rich intermetallic particles on solidification lead to unusually high creep resistance at 200 °C. Near-zero secondary creep rates are achieved up to the alloy yield stress (YS) of 65 MPa at 200 °C in as-fabricated state. The Zr-solute-induced dislocation-climb suppression mechanism underlying this improvement also restricts dynamic recovery above YS, as noted from appreciable primary creep and its transitioning to near-zero secondary creep rates. A combination of relatively coarse, epitaxially-grown α-Al grains, low Zr concentration in α-Al, and the impurity-scavenging effect of Ce to purify α-Al matrix produces high electrical conductivity of ∼48 %IACS. Aging precipitation of L1 2 -Al 3 Zr nanoprecipitates doubles the YS (to ∼150 MPa) at room temperature and increases alloy conductivity to ∼58 %IACS, but loss of solid-solution Zr out of α-Al matrix leads to activation of dislocation climb, degrading the creep properties as compared to the supersaturated Al-Zr solid solution in the as-fabricated state. Compared to L1 2 -Al 3 Zr nanoprecipitates, submicron (Ce,Cu)-rich particles formed on solidification are more effective at impeding dislocation climb, producing a threshold stress for dislocation creep of ∼ 50 MPa at 200 °C. The new alloy design concepts, especially solute-induced dislocation-climb suppression for creep resistance, explored here may pave way for the design of new metallic alloys for thermal/electrical conductors and other high-temperature applications.

Additive Manufacturing↗

Mechanistic insights into N 2 O formation as a side product in NH 3 -SCR over small pore Cu-zeolites

Here, the present contribution provides clarity to N 2 O formation mechanisms and key influencing factors during low temperature NH 3 -SCR, with the goal of enabling the rational design of advanced SCR catalysts with low greenhouse gas impact. By studying more than 50 small pore Cu-exchanged zeolite SCR catalyst samples, including model catalysts synthesized in our laboratories and state-of-the-art industrial catalysts, we explored a wide range of factors affecting N 2 O formation. These factors included Cu loading, support Si/Al ratio, support topology, catalyst aging, reaction temperature and reactant feed composition effects. We probed N 2 O formation under both steady-state SCR, and during NH 4 NO 3 decomposition via temperature programmed desorption (TPD). Finally, we used DFT to probe energetics of possible N 2 O formation pathways. Based on these studies, we confirm that low temperature N 2 O formation occurs via multiple reaction pathways that all involve NH 4 NO 3 and are supported by Cu moieties that facilitate in-situ NO oxidation to NO 2 .

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Thermal stability and protective properties of phenylphosphonic acid on Cu(111)

Phenylphosphonic acid (PPA) adsorbed on Cu(111) has been studied by synchrotron radiation-based techniques in combination with density functional theory calculations. Here, the dehydrogenated phenylphosphonic acid molecule (PP) strongly bound in a tridentate geometry through oxygen atoms to Cu(111) is shown to be the dominant surface species in the temperature range 150–300 °C. The stable PP adlayer substantially protects the Cu(111) surface from oxidation during exposure to ambient conditions. Thermal treatment of the PPA adlayer at 375 °C initiates molecular decomposition through several channels: P–O bond scission forming C 6 H 5 PO 2 ; C–P bond scission forming phenyl and PO 3 ; and C–H bond scission forming C 6 H 4 PO 3 . All three reaction steps have activation barriers of 1.7–1.8 eV. Small products such as O, H, and phenyl can immediately react further and desorb, while the remaining phosphonate species undergo condensation. After annealing at a higher temperature, the phosphonate group is further reduced from oxygen-rich to phosphorus-rich species, which form the majority of remaining adsorbates after 500 °C treatment.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Effect of operating parameters on H 2 /CO 2 conversion to methanol over Cu-Zn oxide supported on ZrO 2 polymorph catalysts: Characterization and kinetics

Kinetic aspects of the operating parameters for the catalytic conversion of H 2 /CO 2 to methanol over two novel catalysts were evaluated to understand the effect of the polymorphic ZrO 2 phase composed of Cu 0/+ -ZnO sites at the atomic level and its impact on the reaction mechanism. The catalysts were characterized by in situ and ex-situ XRD, N 2 adsorption/desorption isotherms, FRX, TPR, TPD-N 2 O, in situ XANES, TPD-CO 2 , and in situ DRIFTS techniques. The influence of different reaction variables such as the GHSV, temperature, pressure, and H 2 /CO 2 ratio were studied using a fixed bed continuous plug flow reactor. The Cu-ZnO catalyst supported on the tetragonal zirconia polymorph exhibited the highest methanol yield due to the lower activation energy when compared to the catalyst with a greater amount of the monoclinic phase. In addition, the catalysts were reused for 8 cycles of 6 hours to evaluate their stability, which can translate into lower costs for large-scale methanol production. As a result, the estimation of the kinetic parameters over Cu-Zn oxide supported on ZrO 2 polymorphs was significant for understanding the reaction mechanism, as well as to provide a pathway for scaling-up of the process.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Deterioration mechanism of alkali-activated materials in sulfuric acid and the influence of Cu: A micro-to-nano structural, elemental and stable isotopic multi-proxy study

In this study, a multi-proxy approach combining {sup 29}Si, {sup 27}Al and {sup 1}H MAS-NMR, FEG-EPMA, XANES at the Cu K-edge and XRD analytics with hydrochemical tools such as ICP-OES analyses, oxygen-isotope signatures, and thermodynamic modelling was applied to K-silicate-activated metakaolin specimens - with and without CuSO{sub 4}·5H{sub 2}O addition - exposed to sulfuric acid at pH = 2 for 35 days. The results revealed a multistage deterioration mechanism governed by (i) acid diffusion, (ii) leaching of K-A-S-H, (iii) microstructural damage related to precipitation of expansive (K,Ca,Al)-sulfate-hydrate phases (iv) complete dissolution of the K-A-S-H framework, (v) and formation of silica gel in the outermost corroded regions. Copper ions were mainly located in layered spertiniite-chrysocolla-like phases in the as-cured materials. The results demonstrate an overall negative effect of Cu addition on chemical material durability, implying that the reported higher durability of Cu-doped AAM in biocorrosion environments can be best explained by bacteriostatic effects.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Photooxidative decomposition and defluorination of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) using an innovative technology of UV–vis/Zn x Cu 1-x Fe 2 O 4 /oxalic acid

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are a large group of perfluorinated organic molecules that have been in use since the 1940s for industrial, commercial, and consumer applications. PFAS are a growing concern because some of them have shown persistent, bioaccumulative and toxic effects. In this work, we demonstrate an innovative technology of UV–vis/Zn x Cu 1-x Fe 2 O 4 /oxalic acid for the degradation of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) in water. The magnetically retrievable nanocrystalline heterogeneous ferrite catalysts, Zn x Cu 1-x Fe 2 O 4 were synthesized using a sol-gel auto-combustion process followed by calcination at 400 °C. The combination of Zn x Cu 1-x Fe 2 O 4 and oxalic acid generate reactive species under UV light irradiation. These reactive species are then shown to be capable of the photodegradation of PFOA. The degree of degradation is tracked by identifying transformation products using liquid chromatography coupled with quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectroscopy (LC-QTOF-MS).

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Combined density functional theory/kinetic Monte Carlo investigation of surface morphology during cycling of Li-Cu electrodes

In this work, we employed a combined density functional theory and kinetic Monte Carlo approach in order to investigate the nanoscale behavior of lithium stripping and plating on lithium-copper nanoalloys. Density functional theory calculations were used to develop an atom-by-atom understanding of the nucleation behavior of lithium on copper surfaces with different surface morphologies. We found that nanometric pits resulted in significantly more favorable lithium deposition when compared to pristine or lightly-defective Cu surfaces, which is in agreement with previous experimental studies. We then used density functional theory and constrained ab initio molecular dynamics to develop interaction and reaction parameters for a larger-scale kinetic Monte Carlo model in order to provide insight into the stripping and plating behavior of nanostructured Li-Cu nanoalloy anodes. Substantial losses in capacity and strong indications of morphological change were observed for a wide range of Cu:Li ratios over 100 cycles. We observed a complex relationship between the nanoparticle composition and the properties of the formed solid-electrolyte interphase.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Mineralogical transformations in polymetallic nodules and the change of Ni, Cu and Co crystal-chemistry upon burial in sediments

Polymetallic nodules from the Clarion and Clipperton Zone of the equatorial Pacific Ocean were studied using X-ray diffraction, X-ray absorption, Fourier-transformed infrared spectroscopy and transmission electron microscopy. Here, this study includes nodules found at the sediment surface as well as subsurface (14–16 cm sediment depth) and deeply buried (530–985 cm sediment depth) nodules. The surface and subsurface nodules are currently under oxic conditions whereas the deeply buried nodules are under suboxic conditions. Surface nodules consist mainly of turbostratic phyllomanganates (7 Å and 10 Å vernadite and Fe-vernadite); todorokite is a minor phase, if present at all. In contrast, subsurface and especially deeply buried nodules predominantly consist of todorokite, which increases in abundance with depth in the sediment. Thus, upon burial of nodules within the shallow sediment, phyllomanganates transform to todorokite, probably through the combined action of time and change in the ambient chemical conditions. Nodules from deeper sediment depth (>500 cm) consist primarily of todorokite and additionally show signs of dissolution. The transformation of phyllomanganates to todorokite and their further dissolution upon nodule burial under suboxic conditions induces modifications in the crystal-chemistry of Ni, Co, and Cu. In surface nodules, Ni and Co are incorporated in the octahedral sheets of phyllomanganates, whereas Cu mainly is located at the edges of those phyllomanganate sheets. In buried nodules Cu and to a lesser extent Ni are incorporated in todorokite by forming outer-sphere complexes within the tunnels. However, Ni is predominantly incorporated within the octahedra of the newly formed todorokite structure. Co is also enriched in the octahedra of todorokite as a result of dissolution of hydrogenetic vernadite and re-incorporation in the more stable Mn-phase formed during the diagenetic transformation. Co enrichment under suboxic conditions after burial within the sediments is noteworthy since Co in surface nodules is characteristic for oxic conditions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

W-ZrC composites prepared by reactive melt infiltration of Zr 2 Cu alloy into binder jet 3D printed WC preforms

W-ZrC composites were successfully prepared by reactive melt infiltration (RMI) of stoichiometric and excess amounts of Zr 2 Cu into sintered and un-sintered WC preforms made from binder jet 3D printing. The focus of this work was to study the conversion of reactant powders and liquid infiltrant with varying preform density and infiltrant amount by controlling the processing time to reach high conversion yield while understanding the phase composition, microstructure, and hardness. To investigate the effect of time, the reactive melt infiltration was conducted at 1400 °C for 2, 4 and 8 h in a furnace with 96% Ar - 4% H2 gas atmosphere. The increase in reaction time from 2 to 8 h increased the W and W 2 C phase contents and decreased the ZrC phase content when using sintered WC preforms. Samples prepared from un-sintered WC preforms exhibited improved reactive melt infiltration compared to sintered samples, and there was no detectable W 2 C phase and nearly full consumption of WC. Similar to sintered WC samples, the content of W and ZrC phases increased with the increase in time from 2 to 8 h. The interfaces and phases at reaction interfaces were investigated using electron diffraction analysis and S/TEM-EDS to understand material stability; the phases were identified and consistent with XRD analysis. Additionally, there was no Cu present at the interfaces. Increasing the amount of infiltrant led to better reactive melt infiltration. In general, the hardness increased with reaction time and the highest Vickers hardness was found in the W-ZrC sample formed from sintered WC reacted with excess Zr 2 Cu. Finally, this research addresses the critical comparison of sintering and RMI time and shows that by using un-sintered samples for 8 h we are able to achieve W-ZrC composites with fewer undesired phases.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

The role of Si in determining the stability of the θ; precipitate in Al-Cu-Mn-Zr alloys

Precipitate-strengthened Al-Cu-Mn-Zr (ACMZ) alloys demonstrate improved microstructural stability compared to conventional Al-Cu alloys. Si is typically considered an impurity in these alloys, but a systematic analysis of ACMZ alloys with a range of Si levels revealed that there is a Si content range (~0.05 wt. % < Si < ~0.10 wt. %) for achieving optimal high temperature microstructural stability. A combination of hardness testing, scanning electron microscopy, and atom probe tomography has been used to understand the relationship between Si content, aging response, and thermal stability in ACMZ alloys. It is shown that the optimum Si content range corresponds to a reduced as-aged hardness, but a greater hardness value retained by the alloy after thermal exposure to 350 °C for 200 hours. A mechanism is proposed in which optimum Si levels reduce the number density of nucleation sites for θ' precipitates, resulting in larger precipitates that, on average, provide a reduced as-aged strength but are more coarsening resistant. This inherent θ' coarsening resistance allows more time for slow-diffusing Mn and Zr to reach the θ' interface and further stabilize the precipitates. Designing the optimal as-aged microstructure for improved thermal stability of the alloy by controlling impurity levels is a concept that has implications beyond the investigated Al-Cu alloy system.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Thermoelectric performance in disordered Cu 2 ZnSnSe 4 nanostructures driven by ultra-low thermal conductivity

Here, high-energy reactive mechanical alloying (ball milling) was used to synthesize tetragonal and cubic polymorphs of Cu 2 ZnSnSe 4 . The ordered tetragonal (I-4) polymorph undergoes a phase transition above 400 K into a Cu-Zn disordered tetragonal (I-42 m) polymorph, while the cubic (F-43 m) polymorph with full cation disorder is stabilized at room temperature. Both polymorphs show ultra-low thermal conductivities, 0.42 W m -1 K -1 at 722 K and 0.21 W m -1 K -1 at 523 K for the disordered tetragonal and cubic phases respectively. The cubic polymorph has a higher zT in the low-temperature range, peaking at 0.26 (523 K), while the disordered tetragonal has a maximum zT of 0.46 at 712 K. The latter is the highest reported zT for stoichiometric Cu 2 ZnSnSe 4 , comparable to the best-performing doped materials in the literature. A combination of experimental results and ab-initio calculations point to a coupling between structural disorder and microstructure as the mechanism behind the reported performance.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Unimolecular and bimolecular formic acid decomposition routes on dispersed Cu nanoparticles

The elementary steps and site requirements in formic acid (HCOOH) dehydrogenation on Cu surfaces remain of keen interest because formate species act as intermediates or spectators in methanol synthesis and water–gas shift reactions. Steady-state and transient kinetic data, isotopic effects, infrared spectra during catalytic and stoichiometric reactions, and theoretical treatments based on density functional theory (DFT) provide evidence for bimolecular reactions, in which saturated bidentate formate (*HCOO*) adlayers, present at 0.25 ML (0.25 *HCOO* per surface Cu atom), react with undissociated species (HCOOH$^\square$) bound at interstices within formate adlayers ($^\square$) to form H-bonded bimolecular HCOOH$^\square$-*HCOO* adducts. The co-existence of vicinal HCOOH$^\square$ and *HCOO* moieties is evident from antisymmetric infrared bands for *HCOO* that become stronger as a result of their H-bonding that perturbs the induced dipole moment of *HCOO* upon vibration, consistent with DFT-derived vibrational frequencies and intensities for such perturbed species. The *HCOO* moiety in this complex undergoes C-H activation via a transition state that is preferentially stabilized through H-bonding with the vicinal HCOOH$^\square$ relative to its *HCOO* precursor. DFT-derived HCOOH dehydrogenation activation barriers and those determined from the evolution of CO 2 from pre-adsorbed *HCOO* species are about 10 kJ mol -1 smaller in the presence of gaseous HCOOH reactants (because of HCOOH$^\square$-*HCOO* interactions) than those for the unimolecular decomposition of bound *HCOO* species. Such bimolecular routes are consistent with measured effects of HCOOH, H 2 , and CO pressures and of H/D isotopic substitution on dehydrogenation turnover rates and represent the predominant channel for the formation of CO 2 and H 2 during catalytic HCOOH dehydrogenation on Cu nanoparticles. A saturated *HCOO* adlayer that retains binding interstices and the presence of HCOOH(g) enable a sequence of elementary steps unavailable for *HCOO* species, thus circumventing unassisted unimolecular routes that exhibit higher activation barriers.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

63,65 Cu NMR study of the magnetically ordered state of the multiferroic CuFeO 2

In this work, field-swept 63,65 Cu NMR spectra under magnetic fields up to 8.3 T at a constant NMR frequency and temperatures T < 12 K on a single crystalline sample of multiferroic CuFeO 2 were measured and analyzed. When the magnetic field is applied along the c axis, a nearly zero internal magnetic field at the Cu site in magnetic ordered state was observed. This is explained by the perfect cancellation of the internal fields produced by the 6 nearest neighbor Fe 3+ ( S = 5/2) ions, revealing the magnetic structure to be a collinear four-sublattice structure. On the other hand, when the magnetic field is applied along the ab plane, we observed a finite internal field at the Cu sites, which is due to the canting of the Fe moments. Strong change in the NMR signal intensity is observed around 7–8 T, corresponding to the magnetic phase transition from the collinear magnetic to ferroelectric incommensurate states. The ratio of the two magnetic phases significantly depends on the history of the change in the external magnetic field and the temperature of the sample. The details of history dependence of the ratio were discussed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗