Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “sinter”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 559 records · Page 31
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2023

Enhancement in Mechanical Properties of Bulk Nanocrystalline Aluminum by Grain Boundary Strengthening Mechanism

In the present work, commercially pure aluminum (Al) powders were milled at cryogenic temperatures (a) without magnesium (Mg) and (b) with 5 wt.% Mg powders for different durations. The cryomilled powders were analyzed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and x-ray diffraction (XRD) to determine the changes in particle morphology, elemental composition, and crystallite size. The results showed a reduction in crystallite size with the increase in cryomilling duration. Thereafter, the spark plasma sintering (SPS) process was carried out to manufacture bulk samples. The mechanical properties of the bulk SPS samples were assessed by conducting microhardness, tensile, and fatigue tests. The Vickers microhardness tests showed improved hardness for the Al-Mg bulk samples as compared to pure Al. The Al-Mg samples also showed an increase in tensile strength with increasing cryomilling time. Fatigue test results showed an improvement in Al-Mg components' high-cycle fatigue response. Furthermore, the mechanism for the enhancement in mechanical properties as a result of crystallite size reduction and grain boundary strengthening by the addition of Mg dopant is also discussed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Overcoming mechanical fragility in Sm-Co permanent magnet materials

Samarium-cobalt alloys are used in some of the strongest permanent magnets, particularly for applications between about 200 and 550°C, but the utilization of these materials is restricted by their brittleness. Improving their mechanical resilience would allow them to be used more widely and, in some cases, substitute for neodymium-based magnet alloys which are subject to supply-chain risks. In this work, we have engineered a series of novel microstructures with bi-modal grain size distributions to achieve unprecedented combinations of mechanical and magnetic properties. Improvements up to 73% are obtained in the flexural strength of Sm 2 (CoFeCuZr) 17 sintered magnets, with negligible impact on the magnetic properties. Our mechanically-robust, high-performance Sm-Co magnets are made without changing the chemical compositions of the materials or their heat treatment procedures, making them highly compatible with existing manufacturing processes.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

3D-printed electrically conductive silicon carbide

The development of electrically conductive ceramics could achieve robust mechanical strength as well as practically high conductivity, offering applications in structural electrodes, conductors, catalyst supports, etc. However, its operating temperature is limited due to the intrinsic dense structures inevitably hindering the thermal management capability, thus resulting in a temperature-dependent electrical behavior in high-temperature environments. In this work, we report an additive manufacturing protocol through vat photopolymerization 3D printing to fabricate the architectured conductive silicon carbide (SiC) ceramics that simultaneously possess high electrical conductivity as well as low thermal conductivity, and demonstrate electric reliability under high-temperature environments above 600°C. The percolation of graphene into the ceramic scaffold establishes a uniform conductive network, exhibiting its electrical conductivity up to 1000 S m –1 . The bulk density of the 3D-printed ceramic is measured from 0.366 g cm –3 to 0.897 g cm –3 , with thermal conductivity ranging from 62 mW m –1 K –1 to 88 mW m –1 K –1 . Furthermore, the mechanical performance of conductive ceramic can be effectively reinforced by densifying the microstructures via spark plasma sintering treatment. The proposed additive manufacturing strategy widens the potential of ceramics as a structural and functional material, offering a promising pathway toward high-temperature electronics applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Enhanced flexibility and thermal conductivity of HfC decorated carbon nanofiber mats

Future-generation spacecraft components allude discovery of novel materials that can withstand extreme environments (>2000 °C). The combined effect of ultra-high temperature ceramics (UHTCs) and carbon fibers (C f ) can satisfy the demanding requirements of aerospace applications. A novel, hybrid, and flexible hafnium carbide (HfC)-decorated carbon nanofiber (C nf ) mat was fabricated via electrospinning. Enhanced thermal stability of the flexible HfC decorated C nf over C nf can be elucidated from the 20-fold increment in thermal conductivity and the onset of degradation at higher temperatures (840 °C). Successful integration of multi-layered sandwich lattice using in-housed fabricated HfC decorated C nf showed retention of the fibrous structure even after extreme spark plasma sintering (SPS) process at 1850 °C. Fabricating a similar multi-layered structure using procured C f was unsuccessful due to bundled agglomeration and micron-sized fibers. High-load indentation suggests that HfC decorated C nf interlayer is stronger (~2.3 times) than the parent UHTC with no cracking at the interface. Compared with the HfC matrix, the indentation-damaged area at the interface reduced up to ~56% due to toughening mechanisms such as C nf , fiber pull-out and bridging. The synthesized HfC decorated Cnf mat is proposed as an ultra-thin filler material for joining similar or dissimilar UHTCs while maintaining similar chemistry and better mechanical integrity at the interface. Furthermore, the findings insinuate a new paradigm in designing hybrid and flexible ceramic-containing materials for thermal protection systems (TPS) of future-generation spacecraft components that can mitigate failure in extreme environments (>2000 °C).

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Combining direct ink writing with reactive melt infiltration to create architectured thermoelectric legs

Here, we present a new additive-reactive synthesis method where inks – cast into molds or 3D-additively extruded into architectured shapes – are reacted into intermetallic thermoelectric compounds. The new method, as demonstrated for equiatomic TiNiSn, combines: (i) extrusion printing (or casting) of inks containing Ni and Ti powders, (ii) debinding and reactive sintering to form a porous NiTi network, (iii) network infiltration with liquid Sn and subsequent reaction to synthesize the TiNiSn phase. Thin plates, created through this method, show high phase purity and low residual porosity. A thermoelectric figure of merit zT = 0.47 ± 0.05 is achieved at 800 K, within the broad range of values (zT= 0.3–1.0) reported for TiNiSn created via traditional powder hot-pressing methods. Layered TiNiSn microlattices – after 3D ink-extrusion printing and infiltration – exhibit high relative densities and minimal undesirable secondary phase content, with a Seebeck coefficient on par with the ink-cast TiNiSn plates, demonstrating that thermoelectric legs with far-ranging architectural freedom can be created additively with this novel reactive manufacturing method. Numerous other thermoelectric (and other) compounds, currently limited to basic geometries due to brittleness, are amenable to this new method based on a sequence of reactive sintering/infiltration of cast or ink-extruded precursors.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Cr-doped U 3 Si 2 composite fuels under steam corrosion

Dense Cr-doped U 3 Si 2 composite fuels were manufactured by spark plasma sintering, and the effects of Cr addition on mechanical properties and oxidation resistance were investigated. Furthermore, dynamic oxidation testing by thermogravimetric analysis revealed significantly improved oxidation resistance of U 3 Si 2 with minimal doping of 3 wt% Cr. The onset oxidation temperature increased to above 550 °C in air and ~520 °C in steam conditions for the 5 wt% and 10 wt% Cr-doped composites. Steam corrosion testing under 360 °C for 24 hours indicated well-maintained pellet integrity without pulverization for the 10 wt% Cr-doped U 3 Si 2 pellet which only showed minor surface oxidation. The first promising results open up the possibility of designing and manufacturing metal additive-doped U 3 Si 2 composite fuels with significantly-improved corrosion resistance as a potential candidate for accident tolerant fuels.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2022

Chrome-free qandilite (Mg 2 TiO 4 ) refractory aggregates: Role of titania source and evaluation of thermal expansion coefficient

As used chrome-based refractories may contain toxic Cr 6+ , the chrome-free Mg 2 TiO 4 phase is being considered which is known to improve hot strength and resistance to thermal shock and slag corrosion. As in situ Mg 2 TiO 4 formation generates porosity, preformed aggregates are desirable. Dilatometric studies revealed that when dead burned magnesia is combined with industrial anatase instead of rutile, it expanded less (1% versus 7.2%) and the reaction occurred earlier (965°C compared to 1120°C). After sintering at 1,600°C, rutile produced an aggregate with 3.8% open porosity, whereas anatase led to 0 % porosity and a bulk density of 3.24g/cm 3 with a thermal expansion coefficient (70–1,600°C) of 13.5×10 -6 K -1 . Moreover, replacing rutile by anatase eliminates the undesirable MgTiO 3 phase. The anatase-based aggregate consisted of a Mg 2 TiO 4 matrix with residual unreacted MgO and an intergranular, refractory CaTiO 3 phase. In conclusion, the rutile-based aggregate was deemed unsuitable due to a low-melting microstructure of forsterite contiguous with CaTiO 3 .

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2026

From high-entropy ceramics to compositionally complex ceramics and beyond

Over the past decade, the field of high-entropy ceramics (HECs) has expanded rapidly to encompass a broad range of oxides, borides, silicides, and other ceramic solid solutions. In 2020, we proposed extending HECs to compositionally complex ceramics (CCCs), where non-equimolar compositions and the presence of long- or short-range order, although reducing configurational entropy, create new opportunities to tailor and enhance properties, often surpassing those of higher-entropy counterparts. Along these lines, several fundamental scientific questions arise. Is the entropy in HECs truly high? Is maximizing entropy always desirable? In this perspective article, I revisit key concepts and terminologies and highlight emerging directions, including dual-phase CCCs, ultrahigh-entropy phases, and novel processing routes such as ultrafast reactive sintering. I propose that exploring compositional complexity across vast non-equimolar spaces, together with exploiting correlated disorder (coupled chemical and structural short-range order), represents a transformative strategy for designing ceramics with superior performance.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Grain growth kinetics of the gamma phase metallic uranium

We report metallic uranium is a leading fuel form for sodium cooled fast reactors as an enabling technology of future nuclear energy systems. Mechanistic understanding of fuel behaviors and kinetics under thermodynamic equilibrium and highly non-equilibrium conditions are essential for evaluating fuel performance. It is important to understand and predict the grain and pore evolutions of metallic fuels under thermal and irradiation conditions. However, very limited data are available on the grain growth kinetics and mechanisms of pure gamma phase uranium. In this paper, the pure gamma uranium pellets with different grain structures were fabricated by combining high-energy ball milling and spark plasma sintering. Isothermal annealing tests were performed to investigate the grain growth behavior of the pure gamma phase uranium with different initial grain sizes. A parabolic relationship in grain growth with time was identified for the submicron-sized (374 nm) sample. In contrast, for the nano-sized (137 nm) sample, the grain growth shows a linear relationship with time. The activation energies of grain growth were determined as 199.5 KJ/mol and 80.6 KJ/mol for nano-sized and submicron-sized grain structures, respectively. For the nano-sized sample, the rate-control step of grain growth is dominated by the triple-junction migration, in which the grain boundary triple junction drags the grain growth, leading to a higher activation energy than the bulk diffusion. The dominating mechanism for the submicron-sized sample is grain boundary diffusion. The mechanistic understanding and critical data obtained on the kinetics of pure uranium phases will be useful to evaluate fuel behavior under thermodynamic equilibrium conditions and develop a high fidelity model to predict fuel performance.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2023

Simulation of two nanoparticle melting to understand the conductivity drop of 3D-printed silver nanowires

The future flexible sensor technology will require low-temperature, fast processing 3D printing techniques that will rely heavily on the quality of nanoparticle (NP) Ink. Electrical conductivity has been found to decrease in majority of the 3D printed electronic wires. Herein we report a fundamental understanding in drop of electrical conductivity in processed silver (Ag) line wire, generally found in Ag-nanoparticle Ink, using large-scale atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of sintering of five different sizes of Ag NPs. To preserve the high conductivity of pure silver wires, the integrity of the pristine face-centered cubic (FCC) crystalline structure must be retained in the processed line wires. Simulations show that the pristine Ag FCC structures of the nanoparticles are not recovered after melting and resolidification, instead, the resolidified material is paracrystaline. The breakdown of pristine FCC structures might be the cause of the drop in conductivity of processed Ag wires. Simulation results suggest that the intermediate size nanoparticles retain highest percentage of the pristine silver face-centered cubic (FCC) structure after pulse treatments. Our results show that the most promising Ag-Ink should contain smaller to medium size silver NPs that can retain FCC structure after 3D printing of the Ag-Ink.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2025

Establishing a process-structure-property-performance framework for SLS additive manufacturing through integrated multiscale modeling

This study presents a comprehensive suite of high-fidelity computational models that integrate multiscale and multiphysics simulations to capture the full Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) additive manufacturing process—from initial melting and solidification to mechanical response under external loads. Process simulations are linked with mechanical analysis through Representative Volume Elements (RVEs), establishing a process-structure–property-performance framework. The interaction between laser light and polyamide 12 (PA12) powder is modeled, accounting for laser characteristics and the optical, thermal, and geometrical properties of the powder. The heat source is incorporated into a heat transfer model, coupled with crystallization kinetics and densification models to predict material density and crystallinity. The porosity distribution from the densification model and crystallinity interpolated from experimental data are used to construct the RVEs. A multi-mechanism constitutive model is then calibrated using mechanical tests to predict the stress–strain response. Simulation results show good agreement with experimental data in terms of porosity, crystallinity, and mechanical performance when sufficient laser power (62 W or higher) is used. This research supports the inverse design of 3D-printed structures by introducing a high-fidelity framework that combines multiscale and multiphysics modeling with experimental calibration for predictive and performance-driven additive manufacturing.

SLS↗
DOE OSTI2024

Electric field enhanced diffusion welding of alloy 617: Microstructural characteristics and mechanical properties

This study investigated the microstructural characteristics and mechanical behavior of diffusion welded nickel-based Alloy 617 obtained by electric field-assisted sintering (EFAS) using various parameters. The interfacial microstructure exhibited different characteristics including good grain boundary (GB) migration across the interface in the samples diffusion-welded at 1100 °C and a flat interface in the samples joined at 1000 °C and 1050 °C. The interface consisted of fine Al 2 O 3 oxides, while precipitation of interfacial M 23 C 6 carbides was not observed. Grain boundaries migrated across the Al 2 O 3 oxides, leaving these oxides within the grains. Graded grain size was observed, with grain coarsening being more significant near the sample surface due to the temperature gradient induced by EFAS. Tensile testing revealed that the specimens fractured in the matrix away from the interface, indicting strong diffusion-welded joints. Further, the peak tensile strength of 807 MPa was obtained in the samples welded at 1000 °C due to minimal grain growth. The materials obtained at 1100 °C exhibited reduced tensile strength but improved ductility. Strain maps revealed by digital image correlation showed alternating high and low strain segments in the samples produced at 1000 °C and 1050 °C, indicating that the flat interfaces with no GB migration were less ductile compared to the matrix. A greater strain uniformity was observed along the bond interfaces with improved GB migration. The hardness reduced near the sample surfaces due to enlarged grains induced by temperature gradient. This study demonstrates that GB migration and enhanced mechanical strength can be achieved in diffusion-welded Alloy 617.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Rational synthesis of high-performance Ni-rich layered oxide cathode enabled via probing solid-state lithiation evolution

Lithium (Li)-ion batteries using nickel (Ni)-rich layered oxide cathode have been pursued with interest due to high practical energy density. A fundamental understanding of the reaction pathways and structural evolution of the solid-phase synthesis of these materials is crucial for their rational design and process development for mass production. In this work, structural evolution during solid-state synthesis was traced via in situ technique, with a particular emphasis on the lithiation reaction and migration of transition metal (TM) ions. The sintering process is governed by the competitive relationship of decomposition and lithiation reactions, which can be regulated through temperature windows. Controlling the melting point of the Li sources, as well as their affinity to cathode precursors, is highly desired to maintain the layered ordering of TM ions throughout the whole synthesis process, which simplifies the manufacturing process and improves the quality of the manufactured cathode material.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Development of Ti 3 SiC 2 MAX phase tubular structures for solar receiver applications

Solar receiver tubes are key components of concentrating solar-thermal power (CSP) systems that harvest solar energy. For better efficiency, the Gen3 CSP receivers, which collect heat into a heat transfer fluid, require a temperature exceeding 700 °C during operation and need to perform under extreme conditions of high temperature and high thermal stress. Operators are seeking CSP designs using new high-temperature structural materials with high thermal conductivity and high creep resistance to achieve a design life of 30 years and thus help recover the plant capital cost sooner. MAX phase materials, which consist of an early transition metal element, an A-group element, and carbon or nitrogen, are expected to exhibit high creep resistance as well as high fracture toughness. Here, in this paper, we describe fabricating both (1) dense Ti 3 SiC 2 MAX phase disks and (2) short-length tubes using field-assisted sintering technology (FAST). First, the disk samples that we fabricated are fully dense and contain ≈90 % Ti 3 SiC 2 MAX phase materials and ≈10 % TiC phase materials. We determined a flexure strength of 519 ± 32 MPa by conducting a four-point bending test at room temperature with rectangular bar samples of ≈100 % density. The thermal conductivity of the Ti 3 SiC 2 MAX phase samples, measured by light flashing analysis, decreases linearly from a value of 41 W . m -1 . K -1 at room temperature to a value of 36 W . m -1 . K -1 at 650 °C. A solar reflectance measurement of the Ti 3 SiC 2 MAX phase revealed that, temperature increases from 400 to 1400 °C, thermal emittance increases from 0.39 to 0.49, while selectivity decreases from 1.8 to 1.4, respectively. Whereas the surface oxidized MAX phase samples after 100 h exposure to air at 1000 °C exhibit that of SiC. Next, we discuss fabrication of the crack-free Ti 3 SiC 2 MAX phase tubular structures accomplished by using FAST processing in graphite bedding. A Ti 3 SiC 2 MAX phase content of > 95 % with traceable ≈3% remaining TiC phase and ≈15 % porosity were demonstrated after high-temperature annealing. An average fracture strength of ≈250 MPa was determined with Ti 3 SiC 2 MAX phase tubes of ≈85 % density by diametral compression testing at room temperature. Our work demonstrated that using FAST processing to produce Ti 3 SiC 2 MAX phase tubular structures for CSP receiver applications is a viable approach.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2023

Screen printable copper pastes for silicon solar cells

The current work demonstrates the successful metallization of a PERC silicon solar cell with screen-printable copper (Cu) paste that is sintered at elevated temperature in air atmosphere. The existing state of the art in Silicon (Si) solar cell metallization is silver (Ag) paste; Cu cost is 1/100th the cost of Ag and has a comparable conductivity. However, Cu undergoes rapid oxidation at elevated temperatures and the high diffusion of Cu into Si restricts its usage in the metallization of silicon solar cells. In this paper, a Cu paste containing a proprietary mixture of antioxidant additives and diffusion inhibitors was used to make front gridlines on PERC cells. The Cu-printed cells were fired in an IR belt furnace with a peak temperature of 576°C in air atmosphere. The solar cells discussed here reached an efficiency of 19%, which is 88% of the efficiency measured for a commercial Ag-printed cell. The working devices were further characterized using STEM, EDX, ToF-SIMS and long-term suns-V oc studies demonstrating an absence of Cu diffusion. Furthermore, thermally stressing the Cu-printed solar cells yielded a reduction of less than 1.9% of the initial pseudo fill factor (pFF) after 1000 hours at 200°C. Here, the shunt resistance of cells monitored over 3 years remained within 2.5% of its initial value, which demonstrates the effectiveness of the Cu diffusion barrier.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2025

Irreversible Multielement Diffusion and the Resulting Compositional and Processing Flexibility in the Synthesis and Densification of Lithium Aluminum Lanthanum Zirconium Oxide

Despite the broad interest in Al-doped lithium lanthanum zirconium oxide (LLZO), the wide range of reported ionic conductivities suggests that the effect of processing parameters on the resulting phase purity and bulk conductivity is not well-understood. Here, in this work, we synthesized six separate series of LLZO with variations in Al concentration, Li excess, Li addition order, Li source, densification method, and mother powder to determine the effect on the composition, phase purity, density, and bulk conductivity. We found that a wider range of compositions (6.08–7.61 mol of Li and 0.06–0.23 mol of Al) than previously reported can result in cubic phase stability and that nearly all elements (Li, Al, Zr, and La) are lost to the MgO crucible during calcination and sintering. The manner in which different elements are lost is affected by the processing parameters. We observed that Al-doped LLZO shows great compositional flexibility in stabilizing the cubic phase, offering an explanation for the range of electrochemical performance metrics reported in the literature.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Structural Evolution and Stability of Rh/TiO 2 Catalysts under CO 2 Hydrogenation Conditions: Influence of the Initial Rh Structure

Characterizing catalyst stability by identifying the predominant mechanisms, timescales and driving forces of catalyst reconstruction under relevant reaction conditions is necessary for the design and commercialization of new catalysts. Here, in this paper, we study Rh/TiO 2 catalysts under CO 2 hydrogenation conditions (773 K, 75% H 2 , 25% CO 2 ) at high conversion and utilize reactivity studies along with ex-situ and in-situ spectroscopy and microscopy to characterize changes in catalyst activity and structure as a function of time on stream and the initial catalyst structure. This is a prototypical catalyst for CO 2 hydrogenation where Rh structure and Rh-TiO 2 interactions have been proposed to explain reactivity, selectivity (between CO and CH 4 formation) and catalyst stability. The influence of the initial Rh structure (varying from Rh single atoms to Rh nanoparticles), support stability, regeneration and pretreatment(s), and the chemical potential(s) of the reaction environment on reaction selectivity and catalyst stability were explored. The product selectivity between CO and CH 4 was determined to be dependent on the relative fraction of Rh single atoms and Rh nanoparticle-TiO 2 interfacial sites under reaction conditions, each exhibiting distinct stability under prolonged time on stream. Surprisingly, Rh single atoms exhibited stability for the duration of 90 h reactivity measurements, even at high Rh density (≥ 1.8 Rh atoms/nm 2 ) on the support, while Rh nanoparticles sintered under reaction conditions. As a result, all catalysts exhibited increasing selectivity to CO with increasing time on stream (> 10 h). We conclude the distribution of Rh structures evolved over time under reaction conditions through three distinct reconstruction mechanisms (Rh particle fragmentation, Ostwald ripening, and particle migration and coalescence) that occurred on varying timescales. Catalyst stability on the ~90 h time scale was ultimately controlled by the initial Rh structure.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Bi aliovalent substitution in Li 7 La 3 Zr 2 O 12 garnets: Structural and ionic conductivity effects

We report on the synthesis of cubic-phase garnet-type solid-state electrolytes based on Bi-doped Li 7 La 3 Zr 2 O 12 (LLZO). Bi aliovalent substitution of Zr in LLZO utilizing the Pechini processing method is employed to synthesize Li 7-x La 3 Zr 2-x Bi x O 12 compounds. A strong dependence of the ionic conductivity on Bi content is observed, and under our synthesis and sintering conditions, a >100-fold increase over the un-doped sample is observed for x=0.75. Cubic-phase Li 6 La 3 Zr 1 BiO 12 compounds are generated upon annealing in air in the temperature range 650 °C-900 °C. In contrast, in the absence of Bi, the cubic garnet phase of Li 7 La 3 Zr 2 O 12 is not formed below 700 °C and a transformation to the tetragonal phase is observed at similar to 900 °C for this un-doped compound. The role of Bi in lowering the formation temperature of the garnet cubic phase and in the ionic conductivity improvements is investigated in this work. We ascribe the effect of Bi-doping on ionic conductivity increments to changes in Li + -site occupancy and lattice parameters and the reduction in the formation temperature for the cubic-phase formation to rate enhancements of the solid-state reaction. To identify the site occupancy of Bi in the garnet structure, we employ synchrotron extended x-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy. Our results indicate that Bi additions occupy the Zr-type sites exclusively, to within the accuracy of the measurements.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗