Advanced Membranes for Key Energy-Intensive Separations and Carbon Capture
Environmental Science Research Seminars (ESRS), University of Reading, December 2, 2021.
Yi, Shouliang↗
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Results for “membrane separation”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Developing a Carbon Negative Biorefinery for Organic Waste Valorization
Production of bio-based chemicals have become increasingly attractive as efforts to meet carbon neutrality goals expand. Diverse organic waste feedstocks can be valorized via arrested anaerobic digestion and chain elongation to produce important key intermediates, such as medium chain carboxylic acids. Our work aims to develop a carbon negative biorefinery that funnels multiple organic waste feedstocks into a chemically consistent stream of carboxylic acids that are then upgraded to exemplary carbon negative products. The pairing of a hydrolysis reactor with a chain elongation reactor will allow each biological step to be optimized to improve the ability to valorize a variety of organic waste streams. Specifically, this work has so far been aimed at screening for potential chain elongating organisms to produce VFAs and MCCAs of interest. Four chain elongating organisms were tested for their chain elongation potential with diverse single and mixed substrates. So far, Megasphaera elsdenii and Actinobacillus succinogenes have been tested to determine potential differences in titer as well as product speciation due to variations in pH. To do this, each organism was tested under 3 different substrate combinations with pH maintained at either 5.5, 6, or 7. With better understanding of their metabolic needs and optimal operating conditions, these chain elongating organisms could provide a valuable option to facilitate the chain elongation necessary to produce precursor molecules. In addition to optimizing the bioconversion steps, downstream processing of carboxylic acids is also a key component for the overall feasibility of the process. Our group previously developed a downstream in-situ product recovery (ISPR) process for continuously recovering bio-based carboxylic acids from fermentation broth. The ISPR includes: (i) a solid-liquid separation as a cell retention device, (ii) a liquid-liquid extraction (LLE) to selectively extract the desired bio-based acids, and (iii) a distillation to obtain the neat product. The integrated process was demonstrated at bench-scale and is now scaled up for pilot-scale operations. A more cost-efficient membrane-based emulsion separation is introduced for LLE in downstream separation process with greatly promoted mass transfer, leading to -2800 times smaller needed membrane area than membrane contactors to achieve the same butyric acid extraction rate.
BIOMASS FUELS↗
Trends and future outlooks in circularity of desalination membrane materials
Reverse osmosis desalination is one of the most important and increasingly popular technologies to augment available water resources. Central to the technology is a thin-film-composite polyamide membrane capable of separating pure water from seawater or brine. Since its conception and initiation, the membrane industry has followed a linear life-cycle scheme. However, increasing production costs of fossil-based materials and more stringent environmental regulations drive the initiatives to adapt to a circular economy of membrane materials. In this perspective, we briefly summarize the pressing issues in the state-of-the-art membrane industry, then discuss the opportunities in future technology innovations with a focus on sustainable membrane manufacturing and recycling, and lastly provided an outlook for future membrane design and fabrication towards a circular economy.
29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗
Fabrication of High-quality NaA Zeolite Membranes with a Novel Plate & Frame Configuration for Molecular-scale Mixture Separations
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
09 BIOMASS FUELS↗
Solar-thermal membrane for dewatering aqueous organic-acid solutions
A thermally conductive porous membrane has been developed to directly absorb solar energy and conduct heat that can effectively evaporate liquid water at the interface between the membrane and the bulk feed solution. Here, black, porous, thermally conductive graphite foam support is employed as an effective photothermal-energy absorber and heat conductor that heats up an aqueous feed solution to produce vapor. Graphite nanoparticle-slurry coating is applied onto the foam surface to reduce the pore size and generate a microporous membrane. Then, application of a dense graphene oxide membrane coating as an active separation layer on the microporous nanoparticle surface of internal foam channels allows vapor permeation of volatile molecules. Acetic acid/water solution was studied as a model feed system to experimentally demonstrate effective separation. This model vapor permeation system demonstrates excellent acetic acid separation, with a separation factor of 8.3, under simulated 0.7 sun irradiation. The membrane hydrophobicity and nanostructure, including pore size and surface chemistry, played a significant role in enabling high permselectivity of water vapor over acetic acid molecules, as well as liquid solution. Pore size reduction from open pores to a nonporous dense layer in the membrane enables effective separation of water vapor from the organic vapor, while it reduces the permeation flux. Also, the hydrophilicity of the membrane surface shows ~3 times higher permeation flux with higher permselectivity, compared with the hydrophobic membrane surface. This work introduces a process of directly using renewable energy instead of conventional heating to drive selective separation of water from organic acids.
14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
Hydrogen isotope fractionation using graphene and related 2-D materials. Final report
This report provides a final technical report and listing of products from the research on a research project from Clemson university, focused on use of two-dimensional materials within membranes to accomplish hydrogen ion separations. The project used CVD graphene and related 2D materials to accomplish hydrogen / deuterium / tritium (H/D/T) separation during water electrolysis in proton-exchange-membrane (PEM)-style cells. 2D materials were incorporated into PEM cells at varying places with the aim of accomplishing isotopic sieving through 2D materials by selective hydron transport at high rates and with high selectivity. The project work scope included studies on H/D separation with small-scale cells at Clemson, collaborative work between Clemson and SRNL on computational modeling and tritium separations, and issues associated with scaleup.
07 ISOTOPE AND RADIATION SOURCES↗
High-Temperature Ceramic-Carbonate Dual-Phase Membrane Reactor for Pre-combustion Carbon Dioxide Capture (Final Scientific/Technical Report)
Arizona State University, in collaboration with University of South Carolina, worked on a project aimed at development of a new high temperature, high pressure CO 2 perm-selective membrane reactor for water-gas-shift reaction (WGS) with simulated gasifier syngas to produce a high concentration H 2 stream with CO 2 capture. The membrane reactor is made of a CO 2 semi-permeable ceramic-carbonate dual-phase (CCDP) membrane with high CO 2 perm-selectivity/permeance and thermal/mechanical stability for application in WGS reaction. The objectives of this project were to (1) synthesize the chemically/thermally stable tubular CCDP membranes with CO 2 permeance and selectivity (with respect to H 2 , CO or H 2 O) larger than 6.5×10-7 mol/m2·s·Pa and 500, respectively; (2) establish CCDP membrane reactor setup and study high pressure CO 2 permeation and WGS reaction with CO 2 capture using the setup; and (3) identify conditions for WGS in the CCDP membrane reactor that produce CO 2 and H 2 streams with purity of >99% and >90% respectively at CO conversion >95% and overall carbon capture >90%. The work in this project included both membrane development and membrane reactor process study. The membrane development efforts were focused on investigating a H 2 S resistant and highly oxygen-ionic conducting metal oxide material and membrane for CO 2 separation, fabrication of tubular samaria-doped-ceria/molten-carbonate CCDP membrane with high mechanical strength, and experimental and modeling study of high-pressure CO 2 permeation of the CCDP membranes. Mathematical models were developed to describe WGS in the CCDP membrane reactor without a catalyst or packed with a commercial high temperature WGS catalyst. Experiments on WGS in the CCDP membrane reactor with the commercial WGS catalyst, guided by the model analysis, were performed to identify optimum conditions for achieving the CO conversion, carbon capture, and the purity of the H 2 and CO 2 streams mentioned above. At 30 atm feed pressure, 750°C operation temperature, space velocity of 250 h-1, and with steam sweep, a single-stage CCDP membrane reactor with average CO 2 permeation flux of 0.5 cm3(STP)/min.cm2 can achieve CO 2 conversion of 95% and overall carbon capture of 94%, and produce CO 2 and H 2 streams with dry-based purity of >99% and 92% respectively. The project also included process design and techno-economic analysis (TEA) for a CCDP membrane reactor process for WGS reaction with CO 2 capture for a 550 MW coal-fired IGCC power plant, and its comparison with the conventional fixed-bed reactor system for WGS with follow-up CO 2 capture by an amine absorption process. The target performance for the reactor for WGS with CO 2 capture includes CO conversion >95%, hydrogen stream purity >90%, CO 2 stream purity >95%, and total carbon capture >90%. The CCDP membrane developed in this project can achieve the performance target, without subsequent CO 2 capture process at the optimum conditions identified in this project. The outcome of the process design and TEA analysis shows that the membrane reactor for WGS with in-situ CO 2 capture has an operating cost about 40% lower than that for the conventional fixed-bed reactor with a separate amine absorption process for CO 2 capture. However, the capital cost of the membrane reactor process is about twice that of the conventional process because of the higher cost of the CCDP membrane. Modeling analysis shows that a membrane reactor using a CCDP membrane with higher CO 2 permeance (about three times the current value) can deliver the targeted performance for WGS reaction with CO 2 capture at a much higher space velocity and lower membrane surface area to catalyst volume ratio, leading to a smaller catalyst amount and/or membrane area and hence significantly reduced membrane reactor capital costs.
20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗
Polystyrene sulfonate (PSS) stabilized polyethylenimine (PEI) membranes fabricated by spray coating for highly effective CO 2 /N 2 separation
Greenhouse effect, largely caused by CO 2 emission, has become a major concern for global climate change. Post-combustion CO 2 capture is one of the critical strategies to mitigate this issue. Membrane technology for carbon capture has drawn significant attention because of the cost and energy efficiency and scalability. Many membranes for CO 2 capture are limited by the trade-off between CO 2 permeability and CO 2 /N 2 selectivity and the long-term stability under practical operating conditions. Facilitated transport membranes with efficient CO 2 carriers have demonstrated potential to surpass the permeability-selectivity trade-off, but these carriers are often lost under operational conditions. In this work, we designed and fabricated a polystyrene sulfonate (PSS) stabilized polyethylenimine (PEI) membrane by a facile and scalable spray-coating method. The deposited defect-free selective layer, in which the amine carriers in PEI can be stabilized electrostatically by PSS, exhibited superior CO 2 separation performance with good long-term stability under practical operating conditions. The separation performance was optimized by spray-coating cycles, CNT network loading, and PSS loading. Our membrane showed CO 2 permeance ranging from 820 to 1,770 GPU and CO 2 /N 2 selectivity varying from 395 to 460 under vacuum operation mode in the temperature range between 80 and 90 °C. Furthermore, the membrane was successfully scaled up to 200 cm 2 with good uniformity. These results might suggest a novel membrane structure and a scalable approach for fabrication of highly efficient CO 2 separation membranes.
37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
Vacuum-assisted carbon molecular sieve membrane reactor for non-oxidative ethane dehydrogenation
Non-oxidative ethane dehydrogenation (EDH) is equilibrium-limited and endothermic. Selective hydrogen removal using a gas-permeable membrane within the EDH reaction zone can overcome the thermodynamic equilibrium, enabling higher ethane conversions. Employing vacuum as the permeation driving force, rather than a sweep gas, enhances the industrial viability of membrane reactors by eliminating additional post-reaction separation units. This study presents a membrane reactor that integrates H 2 -permeable carbon molecular sieve (CMS) hollow fiber membranes embedded in a fixed bed of cobalt in a dealuminated beta zeolite (Co@DeAl-BEA) catalyst, utilizing a vacuum to remove hydrogen efficiently. The CMS membrane exhibits high hydrogen permeance and an excellent H 2 /C 2 H 6 separation factor. The membrane reactor significantly enhanced the ethane conversion under reaction conditions comparable to those reported in the literature. A Langmuir-Hinshelwood kinetic rate expression was developed and incorporated into a one-dimensional steady-state reactor model. The experimentally validated model indicates that increasing the number of hollow fibers improves ethane conversion, although ethane loss to the permeate limits the benefit. The contact area between the catalyst and the membrane limits the reactor performance more than the catalytic throughput. Furthermore, we find that the location of the catalyst packing relative to the hollow fiber membranes influences ethane loss and conversion. Higher reactor pressures and inlet ethane flow rates improve space-time yield at the expense of lower ethane conversion. Increasing reactor temperature or packing length promotes both performance metrics. The EDH membrane reactor demonstrated durability over 200 h of continuous operation, maintaining record-low deactivation rates and high ethylene selectivity. Protocols for catalyst regeneration were developed.
32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗
Freestanding self-assembled sulfonated pentablock terpolymer membranes for high flux pervaporation desalination
Pervaporation desalination has several advantages over competing desalination technologies, most notably an ability to select for or against volatile organic compounds and the ability to process high salinity feeds at a low transmembrane pressure. Pervaporation has not been commercialized for desalination applications because of its energy intensity. However, emerging processes such as hydraulic fracturing produce high total dissolved solids (>30-45 g/L) byproduct streams that exceed the operational limits of traditional reverse osmosis and could be treated by pervaporation. Here, we demonstrate free-standing pervaporation membranes with excellent permeance and high salt removal based on a partially sulfonated pentablock terpolymer with the tradename Nexar™. Pervaporation membranes were easily cast from this material with desalination performances comparable or superior to commercially available membranes. We found that the polymer degree of sulfonation and casting solvent polarity had a significant impact on the membranes’ water uptake but only a modest impact on the pervaporation desalination performance. Membranes with a degree of sulfonation of 52% (2.0 meq g –1 IEC) and a casting solution composed of 50 wt% n-propanol and 50 wt% toluene achieved a water flux of 3.32 kg m -2 h -1 (permeance 135 kg m -2 h -1 bar -1 ) with 99.5% salt removal in pervaporation from a 32 g/L –1 sodium chloride feed solution at room temperature. We demonstrated that dense, non-porous NexarTM pervaporation membrane permeance and salt separation performance were superior to commercial pervaporation membranes and equivalent to commercial membrane distillation membranes, which have much larger pores. Here, this study demonstrates that commercially available sulfonated pentablock terpolymers are excellent membranes for pervaporation desalination because of their ease of casting and excellent performance.
42 ENGINEERING↗
Separation characteristics of cations and natural organic matter in electrodialysis
Natural organic matter (NOM) in water can cause the formation of disinfection byproducts (DBPs) when NOM reacts with a disinfectant such as chlorine. Nanofiltration (NF) and reverse osmosis (RO) are effective treatment methods to remove NOM. However, the simultaneous presence of both NOM and divalent cations such as Ca 2+ can enhance fouling in NF and RO. Therefore, an appropriate pretreatment to remove such cations before NF or RO would delay fouling and perhaps improve water recovery and NOM removal efficiency. Electrodialysis (ED) is potentially an excellent pretreatment method because it separates inorganic ions well using ion exchange membranes (IEMs) but does not separate NOM well because of its size and consequent low diffusivity. This research focused on ion and NOM separation with ED using three different types of commercially available IEM pairs, two different commercially available NOM sources, and six different influents at 500 mg/L total dissolved solids in the presence or absence of both hardness (Ca 2+ and Mg 2+ ) and NOM. The target waters of interest in this research were drinking water supplies that require little or no desalination but substantial removal of NOM; after NOM separation in NF or RO, some or all of the ED concentrate can be added to the NF/RO permeate to create the finished water prior to disinfection. The results indicate that ED can effectively separate alkaline earth metal ions without separation of NOM. Cation exchange membranes with high exchange capacity, high selectivity for divalent cations are desirable, and both anion and cation exchange membranes should have low affinity for organic adsorption. As a result, the process would work particularly well for NOM with relatively low hydrophobicity, since NOM adsorption to most surfaces increases with hydrophobicity.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Ammonia separation from N 2 and H 2 over LTA zeolitic imidazolate framework membranes
LTA type zeolitic imidazolate framework membranes denoted as ZIF-21 were synthesized and evaluated for the separation of a commodity chemical, ammonia, from nitrogen and hydrogen. Membranes were grown using secondary seeded growth. Ammonia permeances were as high as 1727 GPU, with NH 3 /N 2 , and NH 3 /H 2 ideal selectivities of 35, and 12 respectively. ZIF-21 membranes were also evaluated for gas mixtures composed of 13.8:86.2 NH 3 /N 2 and NH 3 /H 2 , with mixture separation selectivities as high as 7.6 for NH 3 /N 2 . Differences in adsorption, and diffusivities were identified as the key separation mechanisms. Specifically, for both gas pairs the polar-polar interaction between ammonia and the linker polar channels, led to the preferential adsorption of ammonia, and therefore favored thermodynamically the separation of ammonia from nitrogen and hydrogen. In addition, for NH 3 /N 2 gas pair, differences in diffusivities was a contributing separation mechanism. For NH 3 /H 2 gas pair, due to the faster hydrogen diffusivity, the kinetic contribution was a strong competing separation mechanism.
37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
Separations Consortium: Lignin Rich Stream Fractionation and Purification
In support of the Bioenergy Technologies Office in converting lignin to fuels and chemicals, this project develops scalable separations based on membranes and Electordeionization (EDI) to recover low molecular weight (LMW) compounds from lignin rich streams. The project addresses three technology barriers in developing the bioeconomy; (1) Cost of production (2) Selective separation of organic acid species, and (3) Advanced bioprocess development. Specifically, membrane cascades using Tangential Flow Filtration (TFF) are investigated for the recovery of LMW lignin compounds from lignin rich streams such as Alkaline Pretreatment Liquor (APL), Reductive Catalytic Fractionation (RCF) oil, and Catalytic Oxidation oil. Process concepts, including dynamic filtration, are investigated to meet specific performance targets indicated by the consortium's Industrial Advisory Board for the membrane filtration including maintaining permeance > 1 LMH/bar and an overall cost target of < $1/kg of LMW lignin. EDI is investigated as an integral part of the membrane cascade to recover LMW aromatic acids and as an alternative to nanofiltration. Economic analysis of the processes is presented with a focus on minimizing energy consumption and capital expenditure. Furthermore, a sensitivity analysis is presented to identify key cost drivers and optimize holistic process operating conditions.
29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗
Toward Lithium Recovery Using Modular (and Membraneless) Phase Separation and Extraction (MPSE) Technology with Ionic Liquid (IL) Solvents: Effect of Coatings
In this work, a single-channel slope-plate Modular and Membrane-less Phase Separation and Extraction (MPSE) device was fabricated using 3D printing. The slope-plate was designed with an insertable glass slide to enable surface modification with coatings. Self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) and perfluoropolyether (Zdol) coatings were applied to tailor surface wettability and enhance phase separation. Using a model biphasic system of water and hexadecane, both coatings significantly improved the separation efficiency compared to the uncoated device by promoting selective wetting. Building on these results, lithium extraction from a simulated saline solution was investigated using 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide ([EMIM][NTf₂]) as the ionic liquid (IL) extractant. The IL effectively extracted Li⁺ from the aqueous phase in bulk extraction, demonstrating its potential for lithium recovery. However, the low interfacial tension between the IL and aqueous phases posed challenges for phase separation. The application of SAM and Zdol coatings effectively mitigated this issue. Overall, integrating tailored surface chemistry with the slope-plate MPSE design shows great promise as an efficient and scalable platform for studying liquid–liquid separation and optimizing ionic liquid–based extraction processes for lithium recovery from saline sources.
3D printing↗
Adsorptive behavior of poly (vinylidene fluoride) membranes for the recovery of lignin-derived hydrophobic deep eutectic solvents
Abstract Recently, membrane technology has gained significant traction as an energy-efficient alternative to traditional thermal processes for solvent recovery. Deep eutectic solvents (DESs) have emerged as sustainable alternatives to conventional organic solvents, yet a systematic methodology for selecting compatible membrane materials for their recovery remains underdeveloped. This study established a predictive framework for membrane material selection in hydrophobic DES applications using Hansen Solubility Parameters (HSP) with inverted criteria targeting materials with relative energy difference (RED) values greater than 1.0. Flat sheet membranes were fabricated via the non-solvent induced phase separation (NIPS) technique. Four NIPS fabricated polymer membranes were evaluated: polysulfone, cellulose acetate, polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) fabricated with polyethylene glycol (PEG) as a pore-forming agent, and polybenzimidazole (PBI). The HSP approach successfully predicted membrane-solvent compatibility, with polysulfone (RED = 0.6) and cellulose acetate (RED = 0.9) dissolving completely within 24 h, while PVDF (RED = 1.9) and PBI (RED = 1.1) maintained structural integrity throughout a 7-day exposure period. Furthermore, PVDF demonstrated superior performance with minimal weight gain (3.0%), hydrophobic surface characteristics (122° water contact angle), and enhanced mechanical properties following DES exposure. Comprehensive chemical and morphological characterization confirmed PVDF’s chemical stability and revealed a surface-selective interaction mechanism involving simultaneous PEG (pore-forming agent) extraction and DES component adsorption. Adsorption kinetics followed pseudo-first-order behavior with reversible characteristics, best described by the Temkin isotherm model (R² = 0.9987). PVDF membranes-maintained separation functionality with average lignin rejection (75.2 ± 7.69%) and demonstrated filtration permeability of 2.0 ± 0.34 LMH/bar. This methodology provides a rational approach for membrane selection in emerging solvent systems, contributing to the advancement of sustainable separation technologies for DES-based biomass processing applications.
Science & Technology - Other Topics↗
Bipolar Membrane Capacitive Deionization for pH-Assisted Ionic Separations
Selective ionic separations represent an increasingly important technical area for the strategic interests of the U.S. economy–for example, securing critical minerals and materials and circular economy aspirations that include recovering organic acids from processed biomass. This work disseminates bipolar membrane (BPM) capacitive deionization for selective ionic separations from multicomponent, ionic species mixtures. The selective separations are guided by the Pourbaix diagram and acid–base equilibria principles. BPM capacitive deionization was demonstrated to generate alkaline or acidic process streams depending upon the location of the BPM in the electrochemical cell. The role of system operating parameters, such as the cell voltage, residence time, and feed concentration on effluent stream pH was studied. It was observed that the pH adjustment in BPM-CDI/MCDI (MCDI, membrane capacitive deionization) was more sensitive to the cell voltage when compared to the process stream residence time and salt feed concentration. The BPM-MCDI gave over 6 times higher percentage of copper(II) removal when compared to sodium ion removal from brine mixtures. Lastly, BPM-MCDI demonstrated over 40% greater removal for copper ions from brine mixtures and fivefold higher removal for itaconic acid from brine mixtures when benchmarked against a traditional flow-by-MCDI setup.
37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
Extraction of oxygen from the Mars atmosphere using glow-discharge and permeation techniques
Oxygen can be extracted from carbon dioxide via thermal dissociation at elevated temperatures. However, temperatures in excess of 1000 K are needed to effect significant levels of dissociation. The experiments reported here have examined the feasibility of using a glow-discharge in low-pressure carbon dioxide to produce increased atomic oxygen yields at lower temperatures (on the order of 800 K). The experiments have shown that when silver membranes are used simultaneously as anodes for the glow discharge and as permeable membranes for oxygen separation, oxygen yields which are comparable to the permeation rates for pure oxygen, can be produced. Since the silver membrane can be employed as the electrode interface between Mars atmosphere and a stabilized-zirconia electrochemical pump, glow-discharge enhancement can be considered as a complementary technology which can be used with the zirconia-based oxygen extraction systems described previously by others. Not only can glow-discharge be used to increase oxygen yields at lowered temperatures, but it can also be considered as a possible way to avoid filtration and compression of Mars atmosphere, since the glow-discharge can be sustained in Mars ambient pressures.
Wu, Dongchuan↗
Thin-sheet zeolite membrane and methods for making the same
Zeolite membrane sheets for separation of mixtures containing water are provided, as well as methods for making the same. Thin, but robust, zeolite membrane sheets having an inter-grown zeolite crystal film directly on a thin, less than 200 micron thick, porous support sheet free of any surface pores with a size above 10 microns. The zeolite membrane film thickness is less than about 10 microns above the support surface and less than about 5 microns below the support surface. Methods of preparing the membrane are disclosed which include coating of the support sheet surface with a seed coating solution containing the parent zeolite crystals with mean particle sizes from about 0.5 to 2.0 microns at loading of 0.05-0.5 mg/cm2 and subsequent growth of the seeded sheet in a growth reactor loaded with a growth solution over a temperature range of about 45° C. to about 120° C.
Liu, Wei↗