Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “structural materials”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 541 records · Page 30

On the origin of internal obstacles to dislocation glide in single-phase NiFe random alloys

Over the past decade, a new class of unconventional alloys, where several constitutive elements are presented in close to equal concentrations, is considered as promising structural materials in many applications. Properties and behavior of many concentrated solid solution alloys (CSSAs) under different conditions, including mechanical loading, differs from that of conventional alloys and has been the subject of intensive studies by different techniques. A key feature of these materials is that there is no clear distinction between solute and solvent species of atoms, which is the conventional approach to considering dislocation motion in alloys. To understand this regime, we have recently reported on the glide of a screw dislocation glide in a simple equiatomic NiFe alloy and reported the two-mode character. At low applied stress, the dislocation motion is similar to a glide through a field of obstacles. In this work, we report the results of a detailed study on the nature of these internal obstacles. We demonstrate that these are not conventional localized “obstacles” but is the result of significantly different energies of instantaneous dislocation configurations over the alloy bulk. The strong pinning positions are associated with composition changes in the partial dislocation cores, while observing no significant composition changes along the stacking faults. Local energies can vary significantly, as demonstrated using simulations of short-periodicity dislocation lines. Therefore, the critical stress to move a dislocation under such conditions is not a constant Peierls stress but represents a wide spectrum of barriers between different non-straight valleys that the dislocation line accommodates in the bulk at particular stress/strain conditions.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

High-throughput exploration of the WMoVTaNbAl refractory multi-principal-element alloys under multiple-property constraints

Development of next-generation gas turbines requires the design and fabrication of novel high-temperature structural materials capable of operating beyond 1300°C. Here, we propose a high-throughput alloy design framework under multiple-property constraints to discover new refractory multi-principal element alloys (MPEAs) for high-temperature applications. The framework treats the development of MPEAs as a composition-agnostic constraint satisfaction problem, i.e., no prescriptions are made concerning the design space before performing investigatory calculations. We target alloys in the WMoVTaNbAl chemistry space that are predicted to meet constraints on the following properties simultaneously: single-phase stability, density, solidus temperature, yield strength at 1300°C, and ductile-to-brittle-transition temperature. These properties are relevant to both applications in gas turbines and manufacturability. A set of 214 MoNbV-rich alloys meet these relevant constraints. These feasible alloys are investigated with density functional theory (DFT) to provide a fundamental electronic basis for their superior properties. Three compositionally representative alloys from the feasible design space (Mo 45 Nb 35 Ta 5 V 15 , Mo 25 Nb 50 V 20 W 5 , and Mo 30 Nb 35 Ta 5 V 25 W 5 ) are selected with a k-medoids-based design scheme for detailed DFT analysis and experimental characterization. The DFT analysis predicted a single-phase BCC at high temperatures with a high yield strength for all three MPEAs, in agreement with CALPHAD (CALculation of PHAse Diagrams) and experiments, respectively. These three alloys are benchmarked against a public database of 1546 MPEAs. Concerning the aforementioned constraints, the Mo 30 Nb 35 Ta 5 V 25 W 5 alloy outperforms these 1546 MPEAs. The present work demonstrates the ability of the proposed design methodology to identify candidate alloys for a given application under multiple property constraints in a combinatorically vast design space.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Mechanical properties of an Al 10 Nb 20 Ta 15 Ti 30 V 5 Zr 20 A2/B2 refractory superalloy and its constituent phases

Refractory superalloys (RSAs) are a new class of high-temperature structural materials consisting of a nanometer-sized mixture of two coherent A2 (disordered BCC) and B2 (ordered) phases. While these RSAs typically exhibit superior mechanical properties at elevated temperatures, they suffer from limited plasticity at lower temperatures, often attributed to the continuous ordered B2 matrix in these two-phase alloys. To knowledgably control the microstructure and mechanical properties of these alloys, the properties of the constitutive phases in RSAs should be known. Currently this information is absent. Here, in the present work, the microstructure and mechanical properties (at 20–1200 °C) of a candidate Al 0.5 NbTa 0.8 Ti 1.5 V 0.2 Zr RSA and two single-phase alloys, which compositions correspond to the compositions of the A2 and B2 phases in the selected RSA, are reported. Interestingly, and quite unexpectedly, the intrinsic mechanical behavior of the constituent A2 and B2 phases, deciphered for the first time in the present study, revealed that they are softer and substantially more ductile than the parent two-phase RSA. Furthermore, the ordered B2 phase exhibits a deformation twinning mechanism leading to twinning induced plasticity (TWIP) coupled with a low APB energy and activity of 1/2<111> dislocations. These mechanisms are thought to be responsible for the high plasticity of the ordered B2 phase. The results presented here question the current assumption that the ordered B2 phase in these RSAs has limited plasticity and strongly indicate that the nature of the B2/A2 interface boundaries and coherency strengthening play an important role in controlling the mechanical properties of the two-phase RSA.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

First-principles and cluster expansion study of the effect of magnetism on short-range order in Fe–Ni–Cr austenitic stainless steels

Short-range order (SRO), the regular and predictable arrangement of atoms over short distances, alters the mechanical properties of technologically relevant structural materials such as medium/high entropy alloys and austenitic stainless steels. In this study, we present a generalized spin cluster expansion (CE) model and show that magnetism is a primary factor influencing the level of SRO present in austenitic Fe-Ni-Cr alloys. The spin CE consists of a chemical cluster expansion combined with an Ising model for Fe-Ni-Cr austenitic alloys. It explicitly accounts for local magnetic exchange interactions, thereby capturing the effects of finite temperature magnetism on SRO. Model parameters are obtained by fitting to a first-principles data set comprising both chemically and magnetically diverse FCC configurations. The magnitude of the magnetic exchange interactions are found to be comparable to the chemical interactions. Compared to a conventional implicit magnetism CE built from only magnetic ground state configurations, the spin CE shows improved performance on several experimental benchmarks over a broad spectrum of compositions, particularly at higher temperatures due to the explicit treatment of magnetic disorder. We find that SRO is strongly influenced by alloy Cr content, since Cr atoms prefer to align antiferromagnetically with nearest neighbors but become magnetically frustrated with increasing Cr concentration. Using the spin CE, we predict that increasing the Cr concentration in typical austenitic stainless steels promotes the formation of SRO and increases order-disorder transition temperatures. Furthermore, this study underscores the significance of considering magnetic interactions explicitly when exploring the thermodynamic properties of complex transition metal alloys. It also highlights guidelines for customizing SRO through adjustments of alloy composition.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

In-situ ETEM study of plasma-facing tungsten nanofuzz oxidation at atmospheric pressure: Microstructure evolution and substrate-free oxidation kinetics

To enable sustainable carbon-free fusion energy, managing reactor structural material degradation during normal operation as well as accident scenarios is vital. Tungsten (W) plasma-facing materials (PFMs) are susceptible to aggressive high-temperature oxidation during air-ingress fusion reactor accidents, yet there's a lack of oxidation kinetic data for irradiated tungsten. Here, in this study, we utilize atmospheric environmental transmission electron microscopy (ETEM) to present the first kinetic data for substrate-free W nanofuzz oxidation at 400 ºC and 500 ºC in 1 bar dry air. Comparison with pristine bulk W during the early parabolic stage suggests an irradiationdecelerated oxidation for W nanofuzz. Our time-resolved in-situ characterization reveals a durable amorphous surface oxide, likely promoted by high-flux He + irradiation-induced surface defects, serving as an effective passivating layer that impedes nanofuzz oxidation onset. This surface oxide layer also interfaces well with newly formed orthorhombic WO 3 , facilitated by stress relief through He bubble shrinkage, providing lasting passivating protection throughout the nanofuzz parabolic oxidation. This new finding challenges conventional notions of irradiation's negative impact on metal oxidation, and calls for advanced characterization to enhance our understanding of fusion energy materials degradation, informed by further accident modeling.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Thermal Stability and Ion Irradiation Response of Refined Grained V – 4Cr – 4Ti

Since the 1960’s, there has been interest in V-4Cr-4Ti and similar alloys as candidates for low activation structural materials for advanced nuclear reactors. V-4Cr-4Ti was produced using arc melting and subsequently subjected to large strain extrusion machining to produce a multimodal microstructure largely composed of nanocrystalline and ultrafine grain sizes. In-situ thermal stability of the multimodal V-4Cr-4Ti to 800 °C shows the formation of vanadium carbides with negligible grain growth. In-situ dual-beam 16 KeV He+ and 1 MeV Kr2+ ion irradiation performed at 700 °C to a final dose of ~5 displacements per atom show the formation of small He cavities well distributed throughout the system, with preferential clustering at grain boundaries. This work provides insight into how the increased fraction of grain boundaries affect the simultaneous dual beam ion irradiation response of multimodal V – 4 wt.% Cr – 4 wt.% Ti at elevated temperatures. Analysis of the cavities reveal an areal density of 0.024±0.007 cavities/nm2 and swelling of 0.236% after the dual-beam ion irradiation. Nanoindentation shows a ~50% increase in hardening after the ion irradiation at 700 °C.

TEM↗

Which nuclear data can be validated with LLNL pulsed-sphere experiments?

It is shown here that 14-MeV D+T LLNL pulsed-sphere experiments bring complementary information into the process of validating nuclear data compared to experiments that are traditionally used for this purpose—such as critical assemblies. To be more specific, the 14-MeV D+T LLNL pulsed-sphere neutron-leakage spectra enable to validate scattering and fission nuclear data up to 15 MeV (compared to approximately up to 5 MeV when using criticality experiments) and employ to this end simple compound targets containing only few isotopes. In this work, sensitivity profiles of the spectra to nuclear data are calculated in order to understand in detail which isotopes, observables, and energy ranges of nuclear data contribute significantly to their simulation. These profiles are presented for a few selected spheres containing 16 O, 12 C, 56 Fe, and 239 Pu. It is shown that the neutron-leakage spectra of spheres containing light elements are mostly sensitive to elastic- and inelastic-scattering cross sections on discrete levels and corresponding angular distributions. Spheres of structural materials are sensitive to elastic- and inelastic-scattering cross sections, including scattering on discrete levels and the continuum, and double-differential cross sections. Actinide spheres are also strongly sensitive to the fission observables, in particular to the total-fission neutron spectrum. Thin spheres (in which neutrons experience on average less than one scatter) are mostly sensitive to data near the elastic peak, in the energy range from 12–15 MeV, while thicker ones can be sensitive to data at lower incident-neutron energies due to multiple-scattering effects. This information is brought together with simulations of 71 pulsed-sphere neutron-leakage spectra using the ENDF/B-VII.1 and ENDF/B-VIII.0 nuclear-data libraries. This analysis highlights ENDF/B-VIII.0 data that could be further investigated for potential shortcomings ( 6 Li, 12 C, 16 O, 24-26 Mg, 27 Al, 48 Ti, 56 Fe, and 208 Pb) or are likely reliable ( 1,2 H, 7 Li, 9 Be, 14 N, 235,238 U, and 239 Pu) as indicated by validating with LLNL pulsed-sphere experiments.

14-MeV D+T LLNL pulsed-sphere neutron-leakage spec↗

Simulation-based methodology to assess the lattice defects creation as energy storing process

In nuclear industry, damages caused to in-core structural materials by high-energy neutrons have been studied for years. Recently, the possibility of storing energy through the creation of defects in crystalline materials via heavy particle bombardment was investigated. To evaluate the potential of the Wigner effect as energy-storing process, a graphite-moderated Molten Salt Reactor was adopted as a test case. Neutronics simulations performed with OpenMC Monte Carlo code allowed estimating the amount of energy released during fission events, the fraction that is deposited in graphite, and the fraction that has the potential to cause radiation damages. Additionally, molecular dynamics simulations were then performed to study the evolution of cascades triggered by high-energy neutrons. As a major outcome, a more accurate estimate of the radiation damage with respect to the traditional approaches was obtained, and the fraction of the deposited neutron energy that can be stored through long-lived defects was quantified.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Development of ultralow-background cryogenic calorimeters for the measurement of surface α contamination

Next-generation experiments searching for rare events must satisfy increasingly stringent requirements on the bulk and surface radioactive contamination of their active and structural materials. The measurement of surface contamination is particularly challenging, as no existing technology is capable of separately measuring parts of the 232 Th and 238 U decay chains that are commonly found to be out of secular equilibrium. We will present the results obtained with a detector prototype consisting of 8 silicon wafers of 150mm diameter instrumented as bolometers and operated in a low-background dilution refrigerator at the Gran Sasso Underground Laboratory of INFN, Italy. Furthermore, the prototype was characterized by a baseline energy resolution of few keV and a background <100nBq/cm 2 in the full range of α energies, obtained with simple procedures for cleaning of all employed materials and no specific measures to prevent recontamination. Such performance, together with the modularity of the detector design, demonstrate the possibility to realize an alpha detector capable of separately measuring all alpha emitters of the 232 Th and 238 U chains, possibly reaching a sensitivity of few nBq/cm 2 .

07 ISOTOPE AND RADIATION SOURCES↗

Metal-organic-framework and walnut shell biochar composites for lead and hexavalent chromium removal from aqueous environments

Extensive research in recent years has explored the realm of porous carbon composites for various applications, including electrochemistry, structural materials, environmental remediation, and more. In particular, the fabrication of porous carbon composites using a metal-organic framework (MOF) and biochar (BC) for aqueous remediation is a fairly new avenue of research. In this study, a MOF-BC composite was synthesized with unmodified and chemically modified BCs using solvothermal synthesis. The composites were used as adsorbents to remediate heavy metals, such as lead (II) and chromium (VI), from aqueous environments. Here, it was verified that the MOF was homogeneously deposited onto the BC's surface using various material characterization techniques. Lead and chromium adsorption studies revealed a high adsorption capacity with greater than 99% removal for lead and ∼65% for chromium, respectively. Impressively, for lead, the highest observed experimental adsorption capacity of the MOF-chemically modified BC composite was 535 mg/g, compared to 240 mg/g for pristine BC. Meanwhile, the adsorption capacity of the same MOF-BC composite for chromium ions was low at 18 mg/g, compared to 80 mg/g for the chemically modified BC. The MOF-BC had a rapid adsorption rate, achieving equilibrium at only 150 min of reaction time for lead ions. MOF-BCs have higher adsorption for cationic lead through physisorption and ion-exchange mechanisms, whereas, for anionic chromium, removal is dominated only by physisorption mechanisms. The outcomes and methodological developments attained in this study offer a novel and compelling approach for synthesizing MOF-BC composites for aqueous remediation applications.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

An error-in-constitutive equations strategy for topology optimization for frequency-domain dynamics

This paper presents a topology optimization formulation for frequency-domain dynamics to reduce solution dependence upon initial guess and considered loading conditions. Due to resonance phenomena in undamped steady-state dynamics, objectives measuring dynamic response possess many local minima that may represent poor solutions to a design problem, an issue exacerbated for design with respect to multiple frequencies. In this work, we propose an extension of the modified error-in-constitutive-equations (MECE) method, used previously in material identification inverse problems, as a new approach for frequency-domain dynamics topology optimization to mitigate these issues. The main idea of the proposed framework is to incorporate an additional penalty-like term in the objective function that measures the discrepancy in the constitutive relations between stresses and strains and between inertial forces and displacements. Then, the design problem is cast within a PDE-constrained optimization formulation in which we seek displacements, stresses, inertial forces, and a density-field solution that minimize our new objective subject to conservation of linear momentum plus some additional constraints. We show that this approach yields superior designs to conventional gradient-based optimization approaches that solely use a functional of displacements as the objective, while strictly enforcing the constitutive equations. The MECE strategy integrates into a density-based topology optimization scheme for void–solid or two-phase material structural design. We highlight the merits of our approach in a variety of scenarios for direct frequency response design, considering multiple frequency load cases and structural objectives.

42 ENGINEERING↗

3D simulations of spinlike flames in Co/Al multilayers with enhanced conduction losses

Reactive Co/Al multilayers are uniformly structured materials that may be ignited to produce rapid and localized heating. Prior studies varying the bilayer thickness (i.e., sum of two individual layers of Co and Al) have revealed different types of flame morphologies, including: (a) steady/planar, (b) wavy/periodic, and (c) transverse bands, originating in the flame front. These instabilities resemble the “spin waves” first observed in the early studies of solid combustion (i.e., Ti cylinder in a N 2 atmosphere), and are likewise thought to be due to the balance of heat released by reaction and heat conduction forward into the unreacted multilayer. However, the multilayer geometry and three-dimensional (3D) edge effects are relatively unexplored. In this work, a new diffusion-limited reaction model for Co/Al multilayers was implemented in large, novel 3D finite element analysis (FEA) simulations, in order to study the origins of these spinlike flames. This reaction model builds upon previous work by introducing three new phase-dependent property models for: (1) the diffusion coefficient, (2) anisotropic thermal conductivity tensor, and (3) bulk heat capacity, as well as one additional model for the bilayer-dependent heat of reaction. These novel 3D simulations are the first to predict both steady and unsteady flames in Co/Al multilayers. Moreover, two unsteady modes of flame propagation are identified, which depend on the enhanced conduction losses with slower flames, as well as flame propagation around notched edges. Finally, future work will consider the generality of the current modeling approach and also seek to define a more generalized set of stability criteria for additional multilayer systems.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Quantifying the effects of artificial aging on the ignition and self-propagating reactions of Ni(V)/Al multilayers

Bimetallic, reactive multilayers are uniformly structured materials composed of alternating nanoscale layers that may be ignited to produce self-propagating intermetallic-formation reactions. When reactive multilayers age, there is a change in local composition and loss of stored chemical energy due to mass transport and rearrangement at the interfaces. Here, to quantify the long-term reliability of commercial Ni(V)/Al multilayers, the effects of accelerated aging on both ignition sensitivity and self-propagating reactions have been examined. Thermally aged samples were characterized using transmission electron microscopy, differential scanning calorimetry, and laser ignition combined with high-speed videography. The analytically quantifiable nature of both continuous wave laser ignition and reactive wave propagation enabled calculations of Arrhenius rate constants for as-received and various heat-treated multilayers. With heat treatment, there is a change in the intermixed thickness and interfacial chemistry that decreases the activation energy for point ignition but increases it for self-propagating reactions. This finding implies that with increased thermal aging, the reaction becomes easier to facilitate in the solid state but harder in the liquid phase.

Energetic material↗

Bayesian discovery of optimal reduced order models from mechanistic and experimental data: A case study of Pd penetration in TRISO fuels using BISON

TRistructural ISOtropic (TRISO) particles rely on a silicon carbide (SiC) layer as the primary structural material and barrier to metallic fission products (FPs) release. Accurate prediction of palladium (Pd) transport and penetration is therefore critical for qualifying TRISO fuels for advanced reactors. The empirical correlation for Pd penetration in BISON is derived from historical particle-fuel data, but cannot explain the large scatter in the experimental data that arises from varying experimental conditions. To aid fuel qualification, we previously developed a mechanistic reduced order model (ROM) using BISON that resolves these dependencies. Here, in this work we build on that mechanistic ROM and perform validation and quantify its uncertainty using Bayesian uncertainty quantification (UQ). calibration against a suite of in-pile and out-of-pile experiments spanning particle compositions, geometries, and operating conditions, and we benchmark it against the empirical correlation. Bayesian UQ identifies influential parameters, calibrates them to data, and yields predictive intervals. Results show that while the empirical correlation can be tuned to fit a single experiment type, it transfers poorly; the mechanistic ROM sustains accuracy with credible uncertainty across disparate conditions. This demonstrates a practical path—via Bayesian UQ applied to mechanistic ROMs—to leverage single-effect experiments for inferring in-reactor behavior and supporting TRISO fuel qualification.

11 - NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Substitution of virgin carbon fiber with low-cost recycled fiber in automotive grade injection molding polyamide 66 for equivalent composite mechanical performance with improved sustainability

Recycled carbon fiber has historically proven challenging to integrate into composite manufacturing due in no small part to the low-density, randomly oriented, discontinuous fiber format that results from typical recycling. Discontinuous fiber requires the use of alternative technologies than those traditionally applied to continuous fiber (e.g., hand lay-up, winding). Extrusion compounding is one such applicable technology, but material transfer into the system requires alternative feeding equipment or the use of an altered procedure as trialed in this research. In this study, an injection molding compound for automotive applications was prepared with recycled carbon fiber and compared against an existing commercial compound. Input fibers and molded compound were evaluated for mechanical performance, while relevant variables such as compounded fiber alignment and aspect ratio were compared to the existing baseline material to confirm a like-for-like composite material structure. Overall, analysis indicates that recycled fiber performs similarly to virgin fiber reinforcement, demonstrating that recycled fiber may be a viable drop-in replacement for short-fiber discontinuous applications.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Economic competitiveness of pultruded fiber composites for wind turbine applications

Pultrusion manufacturing of fiber reinforced polymers has been shown to yield some of the highest mechanical properties for unidirectional composites, having a high degree of fiber alignment with consistent performance. Pultrusions offer a low-cost manufacturing approach for producing unidirectional composites with a constant cross-section and are used in many applications, including spar caps of wind turbine blades. However, as an intermediate processing step for wind blades, the additional cost of manufacturing pultrusions must be accompanied by sufficient increases in mechanical performance and system benefits. Wind turbine blades are manufactured using vacuum-assisted resin transfer molding with infused unidirectional fiberglass or carbon pultrusions for the spar cap. Infused fiberglass composites are among the most cost-effective structural materials available and replacing this material in the cost-driven wind industry has proven challenging, where infused fiberglass spar caps are still the predominant material system in use. To evaluate alternative material systems in a pultruded composite form, it is necessary to understand the costs for this additional manufacturing step which are shown to add 33%–55% on top of the material costs. A pultrusion cost model has been developed and used to quantify cost sensitivities to various processing parameters. The mechanical performance for pultruded composites is improved versus resin-infusion manufacturing with a 17% increase in design strength at a constant fiber volume fraction, but also enables higher achievable fiber volume fractions. The cost-specific mechanical performance is compared as a function of processing parameters for pultruded composites to identify the opportunities for alternative material and manufacturing approaches for wind turbine spar caps. Finally, four materials are compared in a representative wind turbine blade model to assess the performance of pultruded carbon fiber systems and pultruded fiberglass relative to infused fiberglass, where the pultruded systems produce lower weight blades with various cost distinctions.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Effect of pressure on high-temperature oxidation of Ni alloys in supercritical CO 2 containing impurities

Direct supercritical CO 2 (sCO 2 ) power cycles require structural materials compatible with hot sCO 2 containing high levels of water and oxygen impurities. Chromia-forming Ni-based superalloys, which are leading candidates at temperatures > 600 °C, have shown good compatibility in pure sCO 2 , however potential impurity effects are not well understood. In this report we exposed several commercial Ni-based alloys to 95%CO 2 -4%H 2 O-(1-3)%O 2 at 750 °C and 0.1 or 20 MPa for 2500 h. Protective chromia scales formed in all cases. Nevertheless, water vapor-assisted oxide volatilization clearly occurred at high pressure. The volatilization rates decreased with time, but still represent a potentially serious compatibility issue in real, high-velocity, sCO 2 systems.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Historic and modern nuclear graphite impurities: Pathways to improved waste strategies

Graphite has been used in large volumes as a structural material and neutron moderator since the earliest days of nuclear fission. However, no international consensus exists on the disposal of irradiated graphite, leaving much of the historic radioactive graphite inventory in interim vault or silo storage. With several new graphite-moderated reactors planned or under construction, the issue of graphite waste management is becoming increasingly urgent. This paper reviews and quantifies impurities in both historic and modern nuclear graphite, with emphasis on nitrogen—responsible for much of the 14 C inventory—and chlorine, which plays a critical role in repository performance and design. Modern graphites, benefitting from stringent quality-control measures developed for non-nuclear industries, meet or exceed the ASTM Ultra-High Purity nuclear standards, even without halide purification. Both chlorine and nitrogen concentrations have declined over time. For chlorine, identified as a key impurity influencing U.S. waste repository design, we propose a target of 0.1 appm in as-fabricated billets as a reasonable benchmark. Nitrogen sources are traced throughout the graphite production process, with surface and bulk concentrations characterized for all materials studied. Modern graphites commonly exhibit nitrogen levels below 5 appm, with values approaching 1 appm achievable. Using such reduced-nitrogen grades is critical to keeping graphite-induced radioactivity below the greater-than-Class-C waste threshold, thereby avoiding disposal cost penalties of nearly an order of magnitude.

Chlorine↗