Mechanistic Insights into Co and Fe Quaterpyridine-Based CO 2 Reduction Catalysts: Metal–Ligand Orbital Interaction as the Key Driving Force for Distinct Pathways
Both [Co II (qpy)(H 2 O) 2 ] 2+ and [Fe II (qpy)(H 2 O) 2 ] 2+ (with qpy = 2,2':6',2'':6'',2'''-quaterpyridine) are efficient homogeneous electrocatalysts and photoelectrocatalysts for the reduction of CO 2 to CO. The Co catalyst is more efficient in the electrochemical reduction, while the Fe catalyst is an excellent photoelectrocatalyst. This work uses density functional theory to shed light on the contrasting catalytic pathways. While both catalysts experience primarily ligand-based reductions, the second reduction in the Co catalyst is delocalized onto the metal via a metal-ligand bonding interaction, causing a spin transition and a distorted ligand framework. This orbital interaction explains the experimentally observed mild reduction potential and slow kinetics of the second reduction. The decreased hardness and doubly occupied d z 2 -orbital facilitate a σ-bond with the CO 2 -π* in an η 1 - κC binding mode. CO 2 binding is only possible after two reductions resulting in an EEC mechanism (E = electron transfer, C = chemical reaction), and the second protonation is rate-limiting. In contrast, the Fe catalyst maintains a Lewis acidic metal center throughout the reduction process because the metal orbitals do not strongly mix with the qpy-π* orbitals. Further, this allows binding of the activated CO 2 in an η 2 -binding mode. This interaction stabilizes the activated CO 2 via a π-type interaction of a Fe-t 2g orbital and the CO 2 -π* and a dative bond of the oxygen lone pair. This facilitates CO 2 binding to a singly reduced catalyst resulting in an ECE mechanism. The barrier for CO 2 addition and the second protonation are higher than those for the Co catalyst and rate-limiting.