Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Vacancies”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 541 records · Page 30

Active and passive defects in tetragonal tungsten bronze relaxor ferroelectrics

Tetragonal tungsten bronze (TTB) based oxides constitute a large family of dielectric materials which are known to exhibit complex distortions producing incommensurately modulated superstructures as well as significant local deviations from their average symmetry. The local deviations produce diffuse scattering in diffraction experiments. The structure as well as the charge dynamics of these materials are anticipated to be sensitive to defects, such as cation or oxygen vacancies. In this work, in an effort to understand how the structural and charge dynamical properties respond to these two types of vacancy defects, we have performed measurements of dielectric susceptibilities and single crystal diffraction experiments of two types of TTB materials with both ‘filled’ (Ba 2 NdFeNb 4 O 15 and Ba 2 PrFeNb 4 O 15 ) and ‘unfilled’ (Sr 0.5 Ba 0.5 Nb 2 O 6 ) cation sublattices. We also perform these measurements before and after oxygen annealing, which alters the oxygen vacancy concentrations. Surprisingly, we find that many of the diffuse scattering features that are present in the unfilled structure are also present in the filled structure, suggesting that the random fields and disorder that are characteristic of the unfilled structure are not responsible for many of the local structural features that are reflected in the diffuse scattering. Furthermore, oxygen annealing clearly affected both color and dielectric properties, consistent with a diminishment of the oxygen vacancy concentration, but had little effect on observed diffuse patterns.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Phase transition in bilayer MoS 2 under tensile loading: a molecular dynamics study

Abstract Molybdenum disulfide (MoS 2 ), especially single-layer MoS 2 , has been experimentally and computationally discovered to exist in several different polymorphs exhibiting various electronic and mechanical properties. The morphology of MoS 2 can be tuned through strain engineering. Molecular dynamics simulations are conducted to systematically study the phase transition of single-layer MoS 2 and bilayer MoS 2 under the uniaxial tensile condition at room temperature. The roles of edge and S-line vacancy are investigated. Phase transitions are always triggered near the edge and vacancy sites. The initiation of the metastable T″ phase can release the tensile stress in the lattice, followed by I4/mmm phase initiation, regardless of the edge conditions. The growth of the I4/mmm phase can cause the local buckling of the MoS 2 plane. With a tilted S-line vacancy, I4/mmm phase is first initiated to reduce the local shear stress accumulated near the vacancy line. Overall, the phase transition mechanism of single layer and bilayer MoS 2 under the uniaxial tensile loading is provided, which guides the future strain engineering of MoS 2 in nanoelectronics applications.

Materials Science↗

Mitigation of the internal p-n junction in CoS 2 -contacted FeS 2 single crystals: Accessing bulk semiconducting transport

Pyrite FeS 2 is an outstanding candidate for a low-cost, nontoxic, sustainable photovoltaic material, but efficient pyrite-based solar cells are yet to materialize. Recent studies of single crystals have shed much light on this by uncovering a p-type surface inversion layer on n-type (S-vacancy doped) crystals, and the resulting internal p-n junction. This leaky internal junction likely plays a key role in limiting efficiency in pyrite-based photovoltaic devices, also obscuring the true bulk semiconducting transport properties of pyrite crystals. Here, we demonstrate complete mitigation of the internal p-n junction in FeS 2 crystals by fabricating metallic CoS 2 contacts via a process that simultaneously diffuses Co (a shallow donor) into the crystal, the resulting heavy n doping yielding direct Ohmic contact to the interior. Low-temperature bulk transport studies of controllably Co- and S-vacancy doped semiconducting crystals then enable a host of previously inaccessible observations and measurements, including determination of donor activation energies (which are as low as 5 meV for Co), observation of an unexpected second activated transport regime, realization of electron mobility up to 2100 cm 2 V –1 s –1 , elucidation of very different mobilities in Co- and S-vacancy-doped cases, and observation of an abrupt temperaturedependent crossover to bulk Efros-Shklovskii variable-range hopping, accompanied by an unusual form of nonlinear Hall effect. Aspects of the results are interpreted with the aid of first-principles electronic structure calculations on both Co- and S-vacancy-doped FeS 2 . Furthermore, this work thus demonstrates unequivocal mitigation of the internal p-n junction in pyrite single crystals, with important implications for both future fundamental studies and photovoltaic devices

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Cation and anion topotactic transformations in cobaltite thin films leading to Ruddlesden-Popper phases.

Topotactic transformations involve structural changes between related crystal structures due to a loss or gain of material while retaining a crystallographic relationship. The perovskite oxide La0.7Sr0.3CoO3 (LSCO) is an ideal system for investigating phase transformations due to its high oxygen vacancy conductivity, relatively low oxygen vacancy formation energy, and strong coupling of the magnetic and electronic properties to the oxygen stoichiometry. While the transition between cobaltite perovskite and brownmillerite (BM) phases has been widely reported, further reduction beyond the BM phase lacks systematic studies. In this paper, we study the evolution of the physical properties of LSCO thin films upon exposure to highly reducing environments. We observe the rarely reported crystalline Ruddlesden-Popper phase, which involves the loss of both oxygen anions and cobalt cations upon annealing where the cobalt is found as isolated Co ions or Co nanoparticles. First-principles calculations confirm that the concurrent loss of oxygen and cobalt ions is thermodynamically possible through an intermediary BM phase. The strong correlation of the magnetic and electronic properties to the crystal structure highlights the potential of utilizing ion migration as a basis for emerging applications such as neuromorphic computing.

Chiu, I-Ting↗

Prediction of defect properties in concentrated solid solutions using a Langmuir-like model

The alleged existence of sluggish diffusion in high-entropy alloys has drawn controversy. In high-entropy alloys and, in general, in all solids, transport properties are controlled by point defect concentration, which must be known before performing atomistic simulations to compute transport coefficients. In this work, we present a general Langmuir-like model for defect concentration in an arbitrarily complex solid solution and apply this model to generate expressions for concentrations of vacancies and small interstitial atoms. We then calculate the vacancy concentration as a function of temperature in the equiatomic CoNiCrFeMn and FeAl alloys with modified embedded-atom-method potentials for various chemical orderings, showing there is no clear correlation between vacancy thermodynamics and chemical ordering in the CoNiCrFeMn alloy, but clear systematic patterns for FeAl. We believe this is due to the high stability of disordered, random, and ordered intermetallic phases, respectively, in the CoNiCrFeMn and FeAl systems. Finally, this work provides future avenues to the prediction of thermal interstitials and vacancies in solid solutions, which is necessary for models of nonequilibrium behavior of solid solutions.

composition↗

Overcoming photobleaching in imaging of single barium atoms in a solid xenon matrix

Neutrinoless double beta decay is one of the most sensitive probes for new physics beyond the Standard Model of particle physics. One of the isotopes under investigation is 136 Xe, which would double beta decay into 136 Ba. Detecting the single 136 Ba daughter provides a sort of ultimate tool in the discrimination against backgrounds. Previous work demonstrated the ability to perform single atom imaging of Ba atoms in a single-vacancy site of a solid xenon matrix. In this paper, the effort to identify signal from individual barium atoms is extended to Ba atoms in a hexa-vacancy site in the matrix and is achieved despite increased photobleaching in this site. Abrupt fluorescence turn-off of a single Ba atom is also observed. Significant recovery of fluorescence signal lost through photobleaching is demonstrated upon annealing of Ba deposits in the Xe ice. Following annealing, it is observed that Ba atoms in the hexa-vacancy site exhibit antibleaching while Ba atoms in the tetra-vacancy site exhibit bleaching. This may be evidence for a matrix site transfer upon laser excitation. Our findings offer a path of continued research toward tagging of Ba daughters in all significant sites in solid xenon.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Persistent optical phenomena in oxide semiconductors

The interaction of transparent oxide semiconductors with light is critically important for a range of applications. Persistent effects could be exploited for holographic memory or optically defined circuits. Conversely, they may also be detrimental to device operation. Large, room-temperature persistent photoconductivity (PPC) was discovered in strontium titanate (SrTiO 3 , STO) after annealing in a hydrogen-containing atmosphere. Barium titanate (BaTiO 3 , BTO), a ferroelectric material, was recently found to also exhibit PPC. Room-temperature photodarkening was observed in Cu-doped gallium oxide (β-Ga 2 O 3 ) after exposure to sub-bandgap light. Hydrogen is believed to play a central role in these persistent phenomena. In the proposed model, a photon excites substitutional hydrogen (a proton inside an oxygen vacancy), making the defect unstable. The proton leaves and binds to a host oxygen atom, forming an O-H bond that is observed with infrared spectroscopy. Here, an oxygen vacancy is left behind. Because oxygen vacancies in STO and BTO are shallow donors, this process results in PPC. In β-Ga 2 O 3 :Cu, however, the oxygen vacancy neighbors a Cu acceptor. In that case, photoexcitation results in the rare Cu 3+ state, which absorbs visible light. The effect can be “erased” by annealing at 300-400°C.

Annealing↗

First Principles Modeling of Tritium Trapping in γ-LiAlO 2 Nanovoids

Experimental STEM and APT investigations both indicate the presence of nanovoids in γ-LiAlO 2 pellets. While those nanovoids can affect the diffusion of tritium in pellets, first principles simulations have been conducted to evaluate the potential for tritium trapping by single and double cation and anion vacancies. It was found that tritium trapping allows to recover a significant amount of the formation energy cost of cation vacancy, while the trapping of tritium by anion vacancies further increase the energy cost of forming a vacancy. The simulations also indicated the potential for tritium to be trapped in various forms by forming bonds such as Al—T, O—T or T 2 . These results raise further questions regarding the speciation and dynamics of tritium trapped in nanovoids.

38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗

Development of bubble evolution model for new mechanistic transient fission gas release capability in BISON

This report summarizes efforts within NEAMS to investigate the mechanisms that govern fission gas behavior in UO 2 . In particular, the focus is on understanding how fission gas behavior causes transient fission gas release and fragmentation/pulverization of high burnup structure (HBS) in UO 2 . HBS forms in the periphery of the pellet where temperatures are relatively low. Previously, MD simulations were performed to determine the reaction energies for various Xe and U defects with bubbles, as a function of Xe to vacancy ratio or, equivalently, pressure. As had been shown in FY22, it was found that the unmodified version of the Simple Integrated Fission Gas Release and Swelling (SIFGRS) model within BISON greatly over-predicted the number gas atoms per vacancy in the bubbles in the outer rim of the pellet (a ratio of > 1 million). This was due to slow grain boundary vacancy diffusivity and not accounting for the pressure-dependent reaction energy for Xe interstitials with bubbles. The application of the pressure dependent reaction energies was able to restrict Xe to vacancy ratios to 2:1, which is far more realistic than those originally obtained from SIFGRS.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Effect of Carbon on Void Nucleation in Iron

The study reports the significance of carbon presence in affecting void nucleation in Fe. Without carbon, void nucleation rates decrease gradually at high temperatures but remain significantly high and almost saturated at low temperatures. With carbon present, even at 1 atomic parts per million, void nucleation rates show a low-temperature cutoff. With higher carbon levels, the nucleation temperature window becomes narrower, the maximum nucleation rate becomes lower, and the temperature of maximum void nucleation shifts to a higher temperature. Fundamentally, this is caused by the change in effective vacancy diffusivity due to the formation of carbon-vacancy complexes. The high sensitivity of void nucleation to carbon comes from the high sensitivity of void nucleation to the vacancy arrival rate in a void. The void nucleation is calculated by first obtaining the effective vacancy diffusivity considering the carbon effect, then calculating the defect concentration and defect flux change considering both carbon effects and pre-existing dislocations, and finally calculating the void nucleation rate based on the recently corrected homogeneous void nucleation theory. The study is important not only in the fundamental understanding of impurity effects in ion/neutron irradiation but also in alloy engineering for judiciously introducing impurities to increase swelling resistance, as well as in the development of simulation and modeling methodologies applicable to other metals.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Effects of Minor Alloying Elements and Impurities on Long-Range Ordering in Ni-Cr-Based Alloys

There is growing concern about long-range ordered Ni2Cr phase forming during thermal aging of Ni-Cr-based alloys (e.g., 690, 625), which leads to lattice contraction, hardening, and embrittlement, possibly limiting the service life of light water reactor components. The timespan when this phase transformation occurs can vary in orders of magnitude between model and commercial alloys and is likely related to the presence of major (e.g., Fe, Mo) and minor alloying elements (e.g., Ti, Si, Nb). These minor alloying elements have been hypothesized to bind with vacancies and therefore limit diffusion. Contrarily, impurities (e.g., P, S) are believed to enhance vacancy diffusion and accelerate the Ni2Cr phase transformation because of a vacancy drag mechanism. This study implements experimental isothermal aging of model Ni-Cr binary and Ni-Cr-X ternary alloys, where X is Ti, Si, Nb, and P to help understand how each minor alloying element affects the Ni2Cr phase transformation timeline. Synchrotron-based X-ray diffraction and hardness measurements are used to quantify the evolution of the Ni2Cr phase transformation through a variety of short aging times to identify the onset of long-range order. These experimental results are compared to first principles simulations from literature to understand the mechanism by which each element impacts vacancy diffusion and the formation of the long-range ordered phase, Ni2Cr.

36 - MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Evolution of dislocation loops in irradiated α-Uranium: An atomistically-informed cluster dynamics investigation

An atomistically-informed mean field cluster dynamics model has been developed to investigate the nucleation and growth of prismatic loops in irradiated a-Uranium. TEM analysis of neutron irradiated a-Uranium shows the evolution of self-interstitial atom and vacancy loops on (010) and (100) crystallographic planes, respectively, resulting in an anisotropic lattice swelling of its face-centered orthorhombic crystal. To provide model parameters, the crystallography of loops and the binding energy of point defects to these loops were studied using an angular dependent EAM potential and classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Furthermore, using the bond-boost hyperdynamics method, the anisotropic diffusion of interstitials and vacancies in a-Uranium was investigated. Here, the mechanisms of point defect diffusion and the associated migration energies were reported and compared with previous DFT studies. The energetics and kinetic quantities mentioned above were used in the cluster dynamics model to predict the cluster density as a function of dose rate, dose and temperature and the results were compared to the reported neutron irradiation experiments. The model predictions reveal an accumulation of small sized vacancy loops along with a population of large and growing self-interstitial loops, which closely corresponds to the TEM observations.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Defect–Concentration–Mediated T–Nb 2 O 5 Anodes for Durable and Fast–Charging Li–Ion Batteries

Metastable orthorhombic niobium pentoxide (T-Nb 2 O 5 ) is a promising anode to fulfill the requirements for high-rate Li-ion batteries (LIBs). Stoichiometric T-Nb 2 O 5 is plagued by low electric conductivity and particle pulverization after repeated charge/discharge processes. In this work, oxygen vacancies are implanted into T-Nb 2 O 5 particles via acid immersion of Nb 2 O 5 ·nH 2 O with the formation of Lewis acid sites. The multiple characterizations and simulations reveal the lengthening of Nb–O bonds, and the transformation from NbO 7 pentagonal bipyramids and NbO 6 tetragonal bipyramids in T-Nb 2 O 5–x . The enrichment of oxygen vacancies endows T-Nb 2 O 5–x with higher electric conductivity, better electrochemical kinetics, larger pseudocapacitive contribution. O-doped graphitic C 3 N 4 is creatively proposed as a trace oxygen pump to repair excessive oxygen vacancies, and it also serves as a sacrifice template for Nb 2 O 5–x growth to construct a porous and monolithic electrode network. Defect-modulated Nb 2 O 5–x displays extraordinary cycling stability (164 mAh g –1 at 5 C after 1100 cycles), high capacity retention (104 mAh g –1 ) at an ultrahigh rate (25 C), and large areal capacity (0.74 mAh cm –2 ) under high mass loading (4 mg cm –2 ). The practical prospect is proved by Nb 2 O 5–x /LiNi 0.8 Co 0.1 Mn 0.1 O 2 full cells with high average platform (2.12 V) and high specific capacity (229 mAh g –1 ). Finally, the oxygen-defect modulation strategy on oxide anodes provides an alternative solution to fast-charging and durable LIBs.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Effects of Aluminum and Molybdenum on the Phase Stability of Iron-Chromium Alloys: A First-Principles Study

The interaction between solute atoms is critical to the thermodynamic behavior of Fe-Cr alloys, but the effects of non-dilute Al and Mo on the Fe-Cr phase stability and vacancy formation energy are not clearly understood. In this study, density functional theory, cluster expansion, and Monte Carlo simulation are used to predict the effects of ternary solute elements on the thermodynamic properties in multicomponent Fe-Cr alloys. The machine learning regression approach is applied to train and construct energy models that accurately describe the complex chemical interactions. The computational outcomes include the prediction of the partial ternary phase diagram, mixing enthalpy, and vacancy formation energy for different compositions. The phase boundary calculation predicts a pronounced change of Cr solubility in bcc Fe by the addition of Al and the rejection of Al atoms from a’ precipitates. The mixing enthalpy calculation shows that Mo may also reduce the Cr solubility in bcc Fe. Additionally, the simulations show that non-dilute Cr decreases the vacancy formation energy in bcc Fe, while adding Al results in a less significant effect. Finally, the results demonstrate important applications of using machine learning energy models to study model or commercial alloys with multicomponent solute species and point defects.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Realization of Electron Antidoping by Modulating the Breathing Distortion in BaBiO 3

The recent proposal of antidoping scheme breaks new ground in conceiving conversely functional materials and devices; yet, the few available examples belong to the correlated electron systems. Here, we demonstrate both theoretically and experimentally that the main group oxide BaBiO 3 is a model system for antidoping using oxygen vacancies. The first-principles calculations show that the band gap systematically increases due to the strongly enhanced Bi-O breathing distortions away from the vacancies and the annihilation of Bi 6 s /O 2 p hybridized conduction bands near the vacancies. Our further spectroscopic experiments confirm that the band gap increases systematically with electron doping, with a maximal gap enhancement of ~75% when the film's stoichiometry is reduced to BaBiO 2.75 . These results unambiguously demonstrate the remarkable antidoping effect in a material without strong electron correlations and underscores the importance of bond disproportionation in realizing such an effect.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

Significant Role of Oxygen Dopants in Photocatalytic PFCA Degradation over h-BN

The activation of the C(sp 3 )–F bond is extremely difficult due to its unreactive nature. The importance of this bond activation is recently highlighted because extensive distribution of perfluorocarboxylic acids (PFCAs) (C n F 2n+1 COOH) has emerged as a challenging environmental issue. Photocatalytic degradation of PFCAs over a few semiconducting light absorbers is known to remove these water and soil resilient contaminants but with limited efficiency. This work reports density functional theory calculations, through which we present a detailed mechanistic study of photocatalytic degradation of CF 3 COOH (the shortest member of the PFCA family) over hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN). Here, our results clearly demonstrate that the existence of point defects is necessary to activate the h-BN plane for photocatalytic dissociation of the C–F bond. Specifically, we show that vacancies create strong Lewis acid or base sites (B or N vacancy, respectively) that facilitate the activation of the C(sp 3 )–F bond considerably. Furthermore, this study presents vivid theoretical evidence for the significant role of oxygen dopants, which mitigate the strength of the active sites and promote PFCA degradation over h-BN. Our calculations suggest that while the very stable intermediates generated during the reaction, in the case of h-BN with B or N vacancies, practically poison the catalyst, oxygen dopants make the degradation much more plausible and controllable. This work thus provides both an explanation for recently observed photocatalytic activity of h-BN to decompose PFCAs and valuable insights for exploring defected two-dimensional materials for activating and removing the fluorine-containing contaminants from water and soil.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Study of CO 2 Adsorption Properties on the SrTiO 3 (001) Surface with Ambient Pressure XPS

The adsorption properties of CO 2 on the SrTiO 3 (001) surface were investigated using ambient pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy under elevated pressure and temperature conditions. On the Nb-doped TiO 2 -enriched (1 × 1) SrTiO 3 surface, CO 2 adsorption, i.e., the formation of CO 3 surface species, occurs first at the oxygen lattice site under 10 –6 mbar CO 2 at room temperature. The interaction of CO 2 molecules with oxygen vacancies begins when the CO 2 pressure increases to 0.25 mbar. The adsorbed CO 3 species on the Nb-doped SrTiO 3 surface increases continuously as the pressure increases but starts to leave the surface as the surface temperature increases, which occurs at approximately 373 K on the defect-free surface. On the undoped TiO 2 -enriched (1 × 1) SrTiO 3 surface, CO 2 adsorption also occurs first at the lattice oxygen sites. Both the doped and undoped SrTiO 3 surfaces exhibit an enhancement of the CO 3 species with the presence of oxygen vacancies, thus indicating the important role of oxygen vacancies in CO 2 dissociation. When OH species are removed from the undoped SrTiO 3 surface, the CO 3 species begin to form under 10 –6 mbar at 573 K, thus indicating the critical role of OH in preventing CO 2 adsorption. The observed CO 2 adsorption properties of the various SrTiO 3 surfaces provide valuable information for designing SrTiO 3 -based CO 2 catalysts.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Understanding the Mechanism of Light and Elevated Temperature Induced Degradation of p-type Silicon Solar Cells (Final Report)

Light- and elevated-temperature-induced degradation (LeTID) was first discovered in multicrystalline Si (mc-Si) solar cells and was initially attributed to metal impurities. Later, LeTID was reported in Czochralski (Cz) and float-zone (FZ) Si, and is considered as an important efficiency loss mechanism in p-type passivated emitter rear contact (p-PERC) Cz Si solar cells. LeTID causes ~10% relative and permeant efficiency losses in these cells in warmer climate regions where the module temperature is > 50 °C. Unlike light-induced degradation (LID), which is also observed in p-PERC cells, LeTID is slower and takes weeks to months in the field to saturate. Another difference compared to LID is that regeneration in LeTID proceeds very slowly, and field regeneration could take > 25 years — essentially the life of the module. Unlike B-O defects that are responsible for LID, neither B nor O impurities are directly involved in LeTID. LeTID appears to be unique to p-type Si, and is also observed in Ga-doped Si. Currently, most experimental evidence relates LeTID to the injection of hydrogen present in the dielectric surface passivation layers, such as SiN x and Al 2 O 3 , into the monocrystalline Si (c-Si) bulk during the fast-firing step. The involvement of hydrogen is further strengthened by controlled studies that show that increasing the amount of hydrogen in the dielectric during fast-firing increases the degree of LeTID. Similar to LID, a regeneration process has been discovered for LeTID. Regeneration of LeTID defects occurs when samples are exposed to 2–4 Suns illumination at elevated temperatures of 140–220 °C for 2–15 hr. Given the slower kinetics of LeTID and sample regeneration compared to LID, this poses a challenge for the manufacturing and field reliability of p-PERC cells, which will be the leading photovoltaic technologies over the next decade. Therefore, there is a need to understand LeTID and develop strategies to mitigate this effect. The defect responsible for LeTID has been extensively studied with over 100 publications, but direct spectroscopic evidence of this defect’s structure is lacking. Without an atomistic understanding of the LeTID defect, it is difficult to assess the long-term efficacy of the current industrial mitigation strategies. This, in turn, has implications on energy production for tens of gigawatts of these cells that will be deployed yearly worldwide. Using electron paramagnetic resonance, we identified a defect associated with LeTID with a g-value of 2.006, which we attribute to an Si dangling bond in an extended defect such as a vacancy agglomerate with H possibly within or in close vicinity. These vacancy agglomerates are likely created during the firing process, during which time H atoms are also injected into the bulk from the hydrogenated SiN x dielectric layer. Our atomistic-level insight shows that the LeTID defect can be mitigated by targeted intrinsic defect engineering of the c-Si material through a slower pull rate of the Cz ingot or 1000 °C oxygen ambient processing of the Si wafer to reduce the vacancy concentration. This project was a collaborative effort between the Colorado School of Mines and the National Renewable Energy Laboratory.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗